Professional Documents
Culture Documents
40TH ANNIVERSARY
CELEBRATION GALA
HONORING WAYNE BARRETT AND HENRY GARRIDO
www.citylimits.org1
Forty.
Forward.
A message from
the editor
My fellow New Yorker:
Since its founding in 1976, City Limits
has published thousands of articles on
matters big and small, tragic and joyful,
from every corner of the city, chronicling
the famous and obscure, casting heroes and
villains and passersby.
Together, these stories tell the tale of four
remarkable decades in the life of the greatest
city in the world.
Its not the standard history of New
York that filled our magazines, faxes, email
bulletins and web stories. But it is the one
we know to be true: a tale of struggle by
people who wanted a better city. Some
sought momentous change. Others aimed
for more modest goals. Each in their way
fought for justice and dignity. The city we
love today was shaped by their failures,
successes, frustration and hope.
Our anniversary, first and foremost,
celebrates these neighbors of ours.
We single out for honor two among
them: DC37 leader Henry Garrido, who has
spent a career fighting for the people who
make New York work, and Wayne Barrett,
whose tireless pursuit of the truth and
devotion to the city has set the standard for
all journalists.
Hundreds of writers, photographers,
editors, designers, donors, advertisers,
funders, sources and readers made City
Jarrett Murphy
Executive editor and publisher
2
Robert Alexander
Esther Kaplan
Alyssa Katz
George Arzt
Jonathan Larsen
Jordan Barowitz
David Lebenstein
Neil Barsky
Jim Ledbetter
Bill Bastone
Nicholas Lembo
Jonathan Bowles
David Lewis
Joseph Calderone
Stuart Loeser
Jim Capalino
Shelly J.London
Mario Cilento
Richard Martin
Michele de la Uz
Kevin McCabe
David Dinkins
Janie Eisenberg
Mark Edmiston
Cheryl & Blair Effron
Richard Emery
Rachel Fee
Fernando Ferrer
Bart Friedman
Marilyn Gelber
Jerry Goldfeder
Mark Winston Griffith
LynNell Hancock
Alex Herzan
Anne Hess
David Cay Johnston
David Jones
Mary McCormick
Vinny McGee
Kim Nauer-Birbiglia
Nick Pileggi
Andy Reicher
Brooke Ritchie-Babbage
Tom Robbins
City Limits
Board of Trustees
Mark Edmiston, chairman
Dan Rubin, treasurer
Brent Phelps, secretary
Andrew Breslau
Bob Herbert
David Jones
Elizabeth Cooke Levy
Mark Lieberman
Jeff Maclin
Brent Phelps
Staff
Jarrett Murphy
Executive Editor & Publisher
Fran Reilly
Executive Director
Adina Berliant
Development Coordinator
Frederick Joseph
Marketing Director
Abigail Savitch-Lew
Staff Writer
Ben Reiter
Dan Rubin
William Traylor
Gene Russianoff
Doug Turetsky
Lee Saunders
Ronald Shiffman
Andrew White
Hildy Simmons
Ismene Speliotis
Ken Sunshine
Glenn Thrush
Michael Tomasky
Mark Willis
Kathryn Wylde
Sondra Youdelman
www.citylimits.org3
Thank You
CO-CHAIRS
Elizabeth Cooke Levy and Reynold Levy
Andy Breslau and Michele deMilly
JACOB RIIS LEVEL
Neil Barsky Bill Bastone Mark Edmiston Bart
Friedman Alex Herzan Vinny McGee Nick Pileggi
Andy Reicher Katrina vanden Heuvel Janice Savin
Williams & Christopher J Williams Community
Service Society Harper Collins Neighborhoods
First Fund
JOSEPH MITCHELL LEVEL
Robert Alexander Jordan Barowitz/Durst Organization Cheryl and Blair Effron Jon Larsen Mary
McCormick/Fund for the City of New York Ben
Reiter Dan Rubin William Traylor M&T Bank
Partnership for New York City
IDA WELLS LEVEL
Adam Blumenthal Assemblyman Jim Brennan
Joseph Calderone Jim Capalino Mario Cliento/
New York State AFL-CIO Michele de la Uz
Fernando Ferrer Jerry Goldfeder Anne Hess
Shelly J. London David Cay Johnston Alyssa Katz
David Lebenstein Jim Ledbetter Nick Lembo
David Lewis Richard Martin Kevin McCabe
Victor Navasky Kim Nauer-Birbiglia Lee Saunders Ismene Speliotis Ken Sunshine Mark
Anthony Thomas Michael Tomasky Mark Willis
The Downtown Lower Manhattan Association
Hotel, Restaurant & Club Employees and Bartenders
Union Local 6 New York Housing Conference
LINCOLN STEFFENS LEVEL
George Arzt Jim Buckley/UNHP Gail & Dan
Collins Maureen Connelly Harry DeRienzo/
Banana Kelly Community Improvement Association
Janie Eisenburg Audrey & Harvey Feuerstein Ruth
Ford Marilyn Gelber Jennifer Gootman Nicole
Gordon LynNell Hancock Ray Horton Marc Jahr
Sr. Paulette LoMonaco/Good Shepherd Services
Alice Martell Jim Mintz Martin Needelman
John Reilly Tom Robbins Ron Shiffman Claire
Silberman Hildy Simmons Brian Sullivan Glenn
4
The Urban
Journalist
Award
Chester Higgins Jr./The New York Times/Redux
www.citylimits.org
The Civic
Champion
Award
6
Forty. Forward.
A Developing Story
The conventional narrative of New York City after the
1970s fiscal crisis emphasizes what mayors, police
commissioners, developers and other powerful
people did. But thats not the story. Its just one story.
From its founding 40 years ago, City Limits has told
a different taleone that sometimes complemented
and other times contradicted the official version.
Thats because we talked about the New York seen by
tenants, single mothers, strikers, prisoners, advocates,
social workers, the homeless, the young and others
who, when they strolled the traditional corridors of
power, did so with a visitors pass.
As the excerpted stories that follow illustrate,
those New Yorkers had their own kind of power, and
the city has always been shaped by it.
And always will be. The storylines that dominate
our citys headlines todayincome inequality, racial
disparities, the housing crunchare the ones weve
been writing about since our founding. Thats why no
media outlet is better positioned than City Limits to
cover the next chapter in New Yorks story.
8
Corlandress Pittman
at the Willard J. Price
Houses in 1992.
(FM Kearney)
1976
A MESSAGE FROM THE
EDITORS
February
With this introductory issue of
City Limits, the Association is
responding to a need, expressed
at our retreat last September, for
more communication within and
among people and organizations
in the movement to save and
improve housing for low- and
moderate income residents of
New York City. We hope that our
members and affiliate groups as
well as others concerned with
our citys housing problems will
find this publication to be useful.
To insure that it will serve the
community housing movement
and to make future issues better
and more effective, we urge our
readers to keep in touch with
us. Please let us know what you
think of this issue; how should
it be improved; what do you
want to see included in future
issues; what should be left out?
1977
ORGANIZED COMMUNITY
GROUPS HELP WIN RENT
CONTROL EXTENSION
May
In a surprise move, the
Republican party members who
control the New York State
1978
UPHILL BATTLE TO BRAKE
THE SLIDE OF 590 PARKSIDE
By Bernard Cohen
June/July
Mabel Kelly, 59, covers her
white lamp shades with plastic
to protect them from the soot
that blows so thick into her
apartment that she sometimes
thinks her building is on fire.
Downstairs, the mustard-colored
wall of her son Jamess kitchen
looks two-toned from the neat
line marking the upper limits
www.citylimits.org9
1979
COUNCIL EYES RENEWED
J-51 PLAN FOR EVEN
BIGGER TAX GIVEAWAY
By Susan Baldwin
October
A city program that in 1979 will
reward owners who rehabilitate
buildings for multi-unit housing
with $74.8 million worth of
tax exemptions and abatements
could be a still bigger giveaway in
years to come, if City Hall has its
way. But, City Council insurgents
have mounted a challenge to
the
citys
business-as-usual
proposal to extend from 12 to 32
years owners exemption from
increased tax assessments and to
swell tax abatements from 90 to
100 per cent of owners costs.
1980
A DAY IN HOUSING COURT
By Susan Baldwin
November
Stories abound from Housing
Court, and terms like, Its a riot,
... a zoo, Its total chaos are
frequently used to describe it.
On the surface, every faction
tenants,
landlords,
judges,
attorneys,
community
and
tenant associationscomplain
about the court, but few have
suggestions for correcting it and
many argue, It might as well
stay the same because we have
learned to live with it and what
will replace it? Do we want to
take a chance on something else?
10
1981
THE DESCENDING
BUDGET AX
By Tom Robbins
April
Reagan and his staff have
zeroed in on the public-service
employment program because,
they say, CETA must be
returned to its original purposes
improving the employability
of low income people, something
they charge PSE largely fails
to do. Their stand is buttressed
by a widely held belief among
Congressional legislators that
the program remains wracked by
the abuses that plagued its earlier
years when municipalities used
the federal job lines as patronage
plums and supplemented the
federal salaries with large
chunks of local money for middle
income people. CETA advocates,
on the other hand, counter that
many of those early problems
in the program have been
eliminated both through national
legislation and local initiative.
The program, they say, is today
a well-functioning, meaningful
and socially useful experience for
participants and neighborhoods.
1982
NEW YORKS
ENERGY FUTURE
By Barry Commoner
April
1983
ORGANIZING THE
NORTHWEST BRONX
By Tim Ledwith
March
www.citylimits.org11
12
www.citylimits.org13
Brownsville, 1993.
(Suzanne Tobias)
1992
THE WELFARE REFORM
RUNAROUND
By Mary Keefe
June/July
On the wall outside Room 401 in
the South Bronx welfare office on
Rider Avenue is a large, framed
illustration of a Monopoly board
with a difference. The squares
on the board have names like
Education Avenue, Independence
Place and Employment Avenue.
And one corner of the board is
home to a large pair of smiling
red lips accompanied by a single,
tantalizing word: Paycheck. But
its very doubtful that the women
waiting on hard blue plastic
chairs inside the welfare office
will end up as smiling recipients
of a paycheck. Theyre part of a
14
1995
THE BIG SQUEEZE
By Andrew White
May
It all began in the early part of the
last decade when, after 20 years of
devastating owner-abandonment
and arson-for-profit, government
returned to neglected areas
with low-interest financing,
replacing windows and boilers,
eventually even financing the
rehabilitation of entire buildings.
Within five years, this public
investment helped put a stop to
the long decline, recalls former
city housing commissioner Felice
Michetti. But it also sparked
private investment, much of it
extremely reckless, as speculators
got caught up in the highs of a
co-op conversion frenzy they
thought would spread from
gentrifying middle class areas.
1996
FORTY DEUCE
By Kierna Mayor Dawsey
August/September
It will all be, at long last, sane
remarkably so. But using my
own Brooklyn sensibilities as the
barometer, I would venture to
say that the new 42nd Street will
also prove intimidating, albeit
intriguing, to thousands of young
people who will grow up here
in the Big Apple and perhaps
never leavethose city kids
who unabashedly wear the oftmisunderstood banner of Black
and Latino urban youth culture
everywhere they go. Im afraid
theyll be shut out. Hell, they
www.citylimits.org15
1998
7-AND-A-HALF DAYS
By Kevin Heldman
June/July
A nurse comes out into the foyer.
She asks me what the problem is. I
tell her Im depressed, I need some
help, I don t want to go on living
like this, Im thinking about killing
myself. You use cocaine, huh?
Smoke some crack tonight, huh?
She frames it as a statement, not
a question. I say no, I dont use
drugs, Im just worn out by life,
overwhelmed by poverty and
stress, sick of going on. Several
more times she conspiratorially
asks me about the heroin or crack
Ive used. I say no repeatedly. She
tells me to pull up my sleeves and
looks for track marks.
1999
THE HARLEM SHUFFLE
By Kemba Johnson
November
Three years ago, HUD banned forprofit investors from the program,
citing problems with profiteering
and corruption. Now, City Limits
has learned, for-profit interests
are once again profiting mightily
from the 203(k) program. The
result: overpriced properties in
poor neighborhoods, quick-flip
speculation, and, in Brooklyn, a
chain of expensive defaults. This
is so big and such a mess, itll
take [HUD] years to figure this
16
2003
MARKET BABIES
By Tracie McMillan
January
www.citylimits.org17
2004
WILL YOU ADOPT ME?
By Kendra Hurley
June
Twelve-year-old Marisol Torres,
a round-faced girl with a pink
headband, long black hair and
thick bangs, sits primly before a
room of nearly 50 people at an
orientation in Harlem for adults
who are thinking of becoming
adoptive parents. In a few minutes,
Marisol will be videotaped as she
tries to persuade this audience
that someone out there should
become her new mother or
father. At first Marisol deftly
whittles the complications of her
life to a few charming facts
Then everything goes wrong.
2005
THE PEOPLES MAYOR?
By Alyssa Katz
July/August
The new Battery Park City
deal is a side effect of the
administrations
West
Side
redevelopment mania. In March
2004, the mayor and governor
announced an agreement to
finance the expansion of the
Javits Center, a plan that counted
on using $350 million in Battery
Park City revenues. That use
of the funds was shot down by
State Assembly Speaker Sheldon
Silver, and the city never pursued
18
2007
PRISONERS DILEMMA
By Jarrett Murphy
Fall
In an era of falling felony crime
rates but rising arrest numbers,
New York Citys courts are
increasingly dealing with lowlevel misdemeanor offenses that
years ago might never have led
to arrest, arraignment and bail.
And at the same time, a growing
litany of life consequences
the loss of housing, ineligibility
for some jobs, disqualification
for government assistance
have been arrayed to target
people found guilty even of
petty crimes and non-criminal
violations
like
disorderly
conduct. People who get arrested
today are likely to be accused
of more minor crimes but face
penalties for a conviction that go
well beyond prison or probation.
Bail can hasten those convictions
regardless of guilt or innocence
2008
A SHOW OF HANDS
By Ali Winston
March
The concerns, however, arent
confined to privacy issues.
CityTime critics like State
Assemblyman
Alan
Maisel
www.citylimits.org19
A crowd in Brownsville
during campaign 2013
(Adi Talwar)
2011
EVEN ENTREPRENEURS
NEED FOOD STAMPS
By Neil deMause
July
2012
YEARS OF WARNINGS, THEN
A BOYS DEATH
By Jordan Moss
March
20
2013
CAMPAIGNS SKIP MOTT
HAVEN, DRUG CENTERS
AND SHELTERS DONT
By Joe Hirsch
March
People
come
to
hospital
emergency rooms to sleep, to
sober up, to get warm, to stay in
between other shelters. They come
if someone is violent at home, or
back on drugs, or if theyve lost
their job. As long as theyre not
disruptive, theres no reason to
think something else is going on,
says one hospital administrator,
who requested anonymity. There
are certain circumstances where
you do pay attention: Someone
comes in with a family, sits down
there for three or four hours.
Then, something needs to be done.
But for the most part, people use it
as a quick stay, to sober up, sleep
and then move on.
2014
FOR CLIENTS SICK OR NOT,
HOSPITALS SERVE AS SAFE
HAVENS
By Ruth Ford
March
2015
CLOSING RIKERS
By Ed Morales
November
Certainly there is plenty in the
air about criminal justice reform
not just in New York but all
around the country particularly
since the anguished summer of
civilian deaths at the hands of
police in Ferguson and Staten
Island last year, the emergence of
22
Weve
Accomplished
Absolutely
Nothing
Wayne Barretts tremendous
legacy includes dozens of interns
whove gone on to great careers
in journalism, public service and
other fields. We carry forever
the skills we learned during our
months as Waynes assistant,
memories of the calls to his home
so he might dictate endless to-do
lists of tedious if not impossible
reporting tasks, and scars from
the occasionalor not so occasionaleruption of the infamous
Barret temper. So basically,
he told one terrified aide upon
hearing a particular days report,
youve accomplished absolutely
nothing. Rarely has so fearsome
a boss been so beloved.
In honor of Waynes unique
and steadfast insistence that all
of ones work be done on pads
of yellow legal paperearlier
ones littered his office like
sun-bleached bonesa few of
Waynes protgs jotted down
some of the lessons, about life and
reporting, they learned from him.
Many thanks to Sara Dover,
Bryan Farrell, Adam Fifield,
Adam Fleming, Alex Gecan,
Douglas Gillison, Keach Hagey,
Jeff Herman, Luke Kummer,
Anna Lenzer, Tracie McMillan,
Matteen Mokalla , Puneet Parhar,
Solana Pyne, Robin Shulman, and
Jane Timmand to Vinny McGee
for generously sponsoring these
pages.
-Murphy
www.citylimits.org23
City Limits
Henry Garrido and Wayne Barrett
our allies in working toward
a more just New York.
NEIGHBORHOODSFIRSTFUND.NYC
Mark
Edmiston
welcomes you to
tonight's event
congratulates
the honorees
and invites you
to be part of
City Limits' future.
Acknowledges
City Limits'
contributions to New York City
and coverage of housing
policy
WAYNE BARRETT.
In any deck of journalists,
he will always be the Trump card.
Love,
Alex, Alvin, Caroline,
Christina, Debby, Doug,
Jamie, Janet, Jonathan,
Lynne, & Steve
New York is a
more honest city
thanks to Wayne
Barrett. Thank
you for your
contributions to
civic sanity, to
journalism and to
friendship, Wayne.
-Neil Barsky
Wayne Barrett
and
Henry Garrido
from
Wayne Barrett
and Henry Garrido
Salutes
CITY LIMITS
honoring
HENRY GARRIDOWAYNE BARRETT
OFFICERS
Arthur Cheliotes
PRESIDENT
Gina Strickland
FIRST VICE PRESIDENT
Gerald Brown
Gloria Middleton
SECRETARY-TREASURER
Lourdes Acevedo
RECORDING SECRETARY
MEMBERS-AT-LARGE
Robin Blair-Batte
Hilary Bloomfield
Charles Garcia
Denise Gilliam
Lisa Lloyd
Debra Paylor
Lenora Smith
Venus Williams
Hazel O. Worley
WAYNE BARRETT
AVAILABLE NOW
www.citylimits.org43
44
supports
City Limits
on the occasion its
40th Anniversary Celebration Gala
and congratulates 2016 Honorees:
Wayne Barrett
Journalism Award
Henry Garrido
Civic Champion Award
On Behalf of the Board of Directors,
Administration and Medical Staff
www.citylimits.org45
Congratulations
to City Limits
and your honorees
Wayne Barrett
and Henry Garrido.
pfnyc.org
is delighted to honor
Wayne Barrett
and
City Limits
for their valuable
contributions to
journalism.
www.citylimits.org47
48
www.citylimits.org49
50
Thanks to
City Limits
for 40 years
of shining light
on issues critical
to the well-being
of all New Yorkers.
-Mark A. Willis
www.citylimits.org51
CONGRATULATIONS TO
CITY LIMITS
ON 40 YEARS OF EXCELLENCE!
New Yorks Affordable Housing Advocate
www.thenyhc.org
52
Janie Eisenberg and Tom Robbins salute Wayne Barrett and City Limits
in the best tradition of muckraking.
"He not only got the news;
he cared about the news.
He hated passionately all
tyrannies, abuses, miseries,
and he fought them. He
was a 'terror' to the officials
and landlords responsible,
as he saw it, for the
desperate condition of the
tenements, where the poor
lived. He has 'exposed'
them in articles, books, and
public speeches, and with
results."
CONGRATULATIONS TO
A MENTOR,
ROLE MODEL,
AND FRIEND.
-from Michael Tomasky
www.citylimits.org53
Jerry H. Goldfeder
Special Counsel, Stroock & Stroock & Lavan LLP
congratulates
Wayne Barrett
winner of the Urban Journalism Award
Henry Garrido
Winner of the Civic Champion Award
&
City Limits
on 40 years of journalistic excellence.
54
Congratulations to the
honorees and best wishes
to City Limits.
-Fernando Ferrer
www.citylimits.org55
Thank you,
Wayne
Barrett!
- Barbara Turk
CONGRATULATES
CITY LIMITS
ON ITS
WAYNE BARRET
HENRY GARRIDO
RESTORATION ROCKS! MUSIC FESTIVAL OCTOBER 8, 2016
bedford stuyvesant 10k run & fun walk OCTOBER 9, 2016
OFFERINGS
Restoration Plaza | BROOKLYN BUSINESS CENTER | CENTER FOR ARTS & CULTURE
ECONOMIC SOLUTIONS CENTER | ENERGY CONSERVATION
CENTER FOR Healthy Neighborhoods | MIXED-INCOME HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
56
In
tribute
to
Wayne
Congratulations
to my old friend
and frequent
thorn in my side
on a lifetime well
spent.
Dan and
Gail Collins
--Glenn Thrush
former co-editor
www.citylimits.org57
Congratulations
on 40 years of
steadfast
commitment to
social justice.
Co
ongratulations to
Citty Limits on
o their
40
0th Anniveersary!
- Jennifer Gootman
UniversityNeighb
borhood
HousingProgram
m,Inc.
www.unhp.org @UNHP
2751GrandConccourse
Bronx,NY104
468
ForServicesandInfo
Call:(718)9332539
Best Wishes
City Limits!
Congratulations,
Wayne!
58
Keep
doing
good
right
here!
-Marilyn Gelber
Heartiest
congratulations
to the one and
only Wayne
Barrett, whose
deep research
has so greatly
informed New
York and beyond!
-from Nicole Gordon and
Roger Bernstein
www.citylimits.org59
Congratulations
to the Honorees
Wayne Barrett
and
Henry Garrido
60
Congratulations to
Henry Garrido
as 2016 City Limits
Civic Champion
Award Winner
From your friends at
Segal Rogerscasey
www.segalrc.com
Offices throughout the United States and Canada
make
news
news
news
JOIN TODAY.
citylimits.org