Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NO. 148247
G.R.
CORPORATION,
DECISION
Petitioner,
Present:
AUSTRIA-MARTINEZ, J.:
For being allegedly contrary to the
foregoing rule, the Resolutions dated January 11,
PANGANIBAN, C.J.
(Chairperson)
YNARES-SANTIAGO,
- versus AUSTRIA-MARTINEZ,
CHICO-NAZARIO, JJ.
ENRICO E. ZAMORA,
Promulgated:
Respondent.
August
7, 2006
x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -------------x
2
1
held:
SO ORDERED.7[7]
WHEREFORE,
judgment
is
hereby
rendered
finding
respondent liable for illegal
dismissal and ordering the
respondent to:
1.
dismissal. [5]
APC
denied
that
it
dismissed
2.
3.
4
5
6
4.
Reinstate
complainant
to
his
position
as
B-737
Captain without loss of
seniority
right
immediately
upon
receipt thereof (sic);
Pay complainant his
full backwages from May
15, 1997 up to the
promulgation of this
decision on (sic) the
amount of P1,732,500
(sic);
Pay complainant the
amount of TWO MILLION
PESOS (P2,000,000.00)
in the concept of moral
damages
and
ONE
MILLION
PESOS
(P1,000,000.00)
as
exemplary damages;
Pay attorneys fees
equivalent
to
TEN
PERCENT (10%) of the
total award. (Emphasis
supplied)
7
8
9
for
manner:
However,
upon
Motion
WHEREFORE,
the
instant
Motion
for
Reconsideration
filed
by
complainant is DENIED for lack
of merit and the appealed
decision AFFIRMED, while the
instant petition for injunction
filed by respondent is GRANTED.
However, respondent Air
Philippines
Corporation
is
ordered to pay complainant his
unpaid salaries and allowances
in the total amount of
P198,502.30 within fifteen (15)
days from receipt of this
resolution.12[12]
(Emphasis
supplied)
Resolution
of
the
NLRC
enjoining
10
11
13
15
12
14
16
dismissal
stands.19[19]
(Emphasis supplied)
Petitioner
filed
Motion
for
filed
and set aside the January 11, 2001 and May 23,
an
Opposition
to
Motion
for
18
Reconsideration. [18]
Up for consideration is
petitioners
motion
for
reconsideration (pages 64-71 of
the Rollo) of this Courts
resolution of dismissal (page 54,
id.), which was promulgated on
January 11, 2001. Considering
private respondents undisputed
comment on said motion (pages
159-161. id.), the same is hereby
DENIED. The resolution of
B.
The Honorable
Court of Appeals did not rule in
accordance with prevailing laws
and jurisprudence when it denied
petitioner APCs motion for
reconsideration in spite of the
fact
that
petitioner
APC
submitted copies of all pleadings
17
18
19
20
21
petitioner
insists,
for
the
deficiency
was
SECTION.
certiorari.
latter
at
fault
for
The
petition
shall
be
accompanied by a certified true
copy of the judgment, order or
resolution
subject
thereof,
copies of all pleadings and
documents
relevant
and
pertinent thereto x x x.
Petition
xxxx
having
1.
for
abandonment of employment.22[22]
xxxx
[The petition] shall be x x x
accompanied by a clearly legible
duplicate original or certified true
copy of the judgment, order,
resolution, or ruling subject
thereof, such material portions of
the record as are referred to
therein, and other documents
relevant or pertinent thereto x x
x.
xxxx
The failure of the petitioner to
comply with any of the foregoing
requirements shall be sufficient
ground for the dismissal of the
petition.
24
[31]
25
25
26
31
27
29
32
28
30
33
documents.
the
issue
raised
in
the
motion
for
to expedite matters.35[35]
34
35
Commission, we held:
comply
with
this
writ
of
execution,
its
xxxx
SO ORDERED
Case Digest
FACTS
38
cEnamoriZwspeylfAPh.CgtdckHraoimpneslfctdwuhrqaingpom.Afet,urdbshinPCoacte,udgmhivsnflckw.r
Isue
Second,vifaumsrtlphen,dobaiftswchernoludamtycheopnius.T,farlgt emnizdoqusgjt,wclhafyerdopugmjsntci3h1].[
1.W/napcshouldteifLg
HefildacomnphtwLbrA endoiglfhspmtuacrv.APC,ondesithamplrogwfk,ntbecaushdi ojrvlcmpany,GdA.
2h.W/neawtrdofupislyc
TheLaborAuitnldfmvZ.Op,NRCheatwsrnodilcuv beamZhrsiolfwunytdpebrogiwfkanyjthcmpeGdA.Hvr,uoMnfiRsaltmbyZheNLCrdcionuAPpatyZmhserldwncoiaut9fP8,5021D.esplhcmdionACgatrsehfinuo3l][1btNLRCdmesa.IinoOcfr1,20thNLRCjudeawpislnmr:
dHel
1.Asagenlru,ptiockfdsanrhecomybi.[28]Tu,wlsvnretpdfAhxacoiglsrtefdwhmuacopnysitfe,drhlapocumnteisyfrpladghocum2ent9.[]T,wvrispolf
h2emp.Tsroidfawunlyt hesvraofNLRCdcintbA,herasmodinwhleuytbjcfasroxpidg.Alhetncmywsirofuxa,gendtblhsoripfengal.
InRoquserpPhvilAc.40,1SC2(3)twadehnislvormbcRutefCapdlionysrmtefcuahbjvoLCdntemHc.,ifhorsalbAtevdnp,igoahrymeftlnsdpwgohiemuytrdfaplnsvhbgeicot.Orad,fmplyhsbnieugtrodacmnseivhwftly,porqudmbisewhavtlycforndu,mesihaltvcgrpod.
heTgrantofsildwcmp heronfisatcwxuypvdgelosfrntqiham,ueAc23loLfbrnCdth.Iysaw,mpiculogrkhfedtsnivpyalcoheftLbrAdingsmcaplteohfirwsgydmeplont
*
CaewsvldtonA.RIuiJry1,20heCfpsmaldtoinurexchpsfalding(uomt,werp)ahilnsofcdwupertaghi