Professional Documents
Culture Documents
11 (2012)
Research India Publications;
http://www.ripublication.com/ijaer.htm
Abstract:
Tax evasion occurs when individuals deliberately fail to
comply with their tax obligation. The resulting tax revenue
loss may cause serious damage to the proper functioning of
the public sector, threatening its capacity to finance its basic
expenses. This study investigated the overview of the opinion
of tax professionals regarding the tax evasion in India,
delineating the number of factors responsive for tax evasion
and examining the possible remedies to reduce the problem of
tax evasion.
Key Words: Evasion, Compliance, Discriminatory,
Assesses, Bilateral Agreement, Errant
INTRODUCTION
In India, most of the persons do not pay their taxes. They try
to avoid this by some illegal means or by taking the benefit of
some loopholes in the Indian tax system. Tax evasion is the
term for the efforts by individuals, corporate, trusts and other
entities to evade taxes by illegal means. It is the deliberate,
misrepresentation or concealment of the true state of their
affairs to the tax authorities to reduce their tax liability or to
avoid the tax liability by declaring less incomes, profits or
gains than actually what they earned or overstating their
expenses. Thus the amount which would have been used for
economic and social development is used for anti social
activities. All this creates black money and social evils in the
society. Thus tax evasion is not a problem in development of
country but also harmful for the country. The level of Evasion
Tax also depends on the chartered accountants and tax lawyers
who help companies, firms, and individuals evade paying
taxes. Tax Evasion is a crime in all major countries and the
guilty parties are subjected to imprisonment and fines.
Although, only 1.3 per cent of all tax-payers earn more than
20 lakhs in India, they account for a whooping 63 per cent of
all the taxes collected by Indian Government. So 4.6 lakh
Indians pay a total of 93,229 crore rupees of tax. That comes
to an average of roughly 23 lakh per person. This all shows
that huge amount of tax is evaded by the citizens of India.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE:
Indian Taxation Enquiry Committee (1924) under the
chairman Charles Todhunter examine the burden of taxation
on different classes of people, equity of taxation and to
suggest alternative sources of taxation under the chairmanship
of. The committee recommended some suggestions to evade
tax evasion as Loss sustained in one year should be allowed to
carry forward and set-off in the subsequent year, in case
private companies are formed just for tax avoidance by with
holding dividends, then such companies should be treated as
firm., the officer should be authorized to compute liabilities of
unregistered firm as if it had been registered in some particular
cases if he thinks it reasonable. Direct Taxes Enquiry
Committee (1971) was appointed by government of India
International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, ISSN 0973-4562 Vol.7 No.11 (2012)
Research India Publications;
http://www.ripublication.com/ijaer.htm
under the chairmanship of Justice K.N. Wanchoo to
recommend measures for unearthing black money, checking
tax evasion and reducing tax arrears. The committee estimated
that unreported income during 1968-69 was Rs. 1400 crore
which resulted in tax evasion amounting to Rs. 470 crore. The
committee was of the opinion that high tax rates, controls and
licenses in the economy, donations to political parties,
ineffective enforcement of laws and deterioration in moral
standards were the main causes responsible for tax evasion.
The measures suggested were reduction in tax rates with
maximum marginal rate of 75 percent, regulation of donations
to political parties, imposition of penalty with reference to tax
sought to be evaded instead of income concealed. Direct Tax
Laws Committee (1978) was appointed by the Government
of India on June 25, 1977 under the chairmanship of N.A.
Palkhiwala. Later on C.C. Choksi took over the Chairmanship
as Palkhiwala had to leave. The committee (also known as
Choksi Committee) was directed to recommend measures for
simplifying and rationalizing the direct tax laws and
improvement in administration. Committee observed that
frequent amendments in tax laws led to uncertainty and
confusion among tax payers and tax collectors. The committee
made some suggestion in its final report as a uniform central
law governing registration of trust, regulating their fund
raising activities, maintenance of accounts, application of
income and investment of trust funds should be enacted.
Murti (1982) studied different aspect of income tax
administration in India viz. origin and development of income
tax in India, the structure and organization of income tax
administration, public relations, recruitment and training of
personnel as well as morale of income tax personnel. The
study reflected both strengths and weaknesses of Indian
Income Tax administration based on its historical evolution
since the colonial period. It highlighted that income tax
officials were overburdened with work. The service conditions
in the department were not healthy for accomplishment of
goals. The reforms in administrative machinery were very
slow. In the end, the researcher stressed upon reviewing the
income tax administration as a part of the larger Indian
bureaucracy. Das, Gupta and Mookherjee (1998) studied the
role of incentives and institutional reform in tax enforcement
in India and compared it with other countries like Mexico,
Spain, Singapore, Philippines and Indonesia. The study
revealed that income tax compliance in India deteriorated
during 1965-66 to 1994-95. The authors opined that income
tax revenue in relation to GDP was low not because of tax
rates, exemptions, amnesty schemes and non taxation of
agricultural income but only due to poor enforcement. The
researchers suggested for amending the provisions regarding
appeals, penalties and prosecution which were exploited by
large scale tax evaders. Jha (1999) examined the reasons for
tax evasion, black money and implications of offering
amnesties to tax evaders in India. She opined that most
important reason for tax evasion was that it provided
economic benefits to tax evaders. She further opined that
besides tax evasion, black income was also generated from
illegal activities like smuggling, trafficking in illicit drugs and
gambling etc. She recommended reduction in marginal income
tax rates for individuals, firms and corporations, which could
help in widening the tax base. Sreekantaradhya (2000) tried
International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, ISSN 0973-4562 Vol.7 No.11 (2012)
Research India Publications;
http://www.ripublication.com/ijaer.htm
and establishment of good relationship with taxpayers .Arora
R.S. and Rani Vanita (2010) Studied the causes and
Remedies for Tax evasion & corruption in the Indian Income
tax system . They investigated the opinions of tax
professionals from the different districts of Punjab regarding
tax evasion and corruption in Indian Tax system . They
pointed out the high tax rates ,corruption ,social acceptance of
tax evasion, low probability of detection and low tax morality
are the main causes of tax evasion. Further they opined that
excessive discretionary powers available with income tax
authorities, harassment to tax payers, lack of integrity on the
part of income tax officials, lack of processes are the factors
which lead to corruption. They suggested the rationalization of
tax rates, simplification of tax laws, extensive use of TDS
system and proper processing of information available under
the Annual Information Return for increasing tax compliance.
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:
This study is carried out with the following objectives:
1) To find out the causes of income tax evasion.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:
To collect the information regarding tax evasion in India a
well designed questionnaire with five point likert scale has
been used. To achieve the specific objectives of the study, the
data is collected from tax professionals such as chartered
accountants, company secretaries and ICWAs from the state
of Haryana. A sample of 150 respondents has been taken by
selecting 30 respondents from Faridabad, Gurgoan, Murthal,
Panipat and Sonipat respectively. The data is also collected
through secondary sources also such as Internet, websites,
professional magazines, referred journals, news papers and
conference books. In addition books on income tax and reports
published by ICAI, ICSI and ICWA etc.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION OPINION BY RESPONDENTS FOR INCOME TAX EVASION IN INDIA
Hypothesis
:
:
Significant difference among the respondents from various locations regards to tax evasion in India.
is not true.
Response/Area
Strongly agree
Agree
Neither agree nor
disagree
Disagree
Strongly disagree
Total (N)
Chi-Square
Df
Asymp. Sig.
Hypothesis
1(3)
0(0)
0(0)
0(0)
0(0)
0(0)
30(100)
30(100)
30(100)
38.533
4.800
15.200
3
1
2
.000
.028
.001
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Null
Null
Null
Source: Calculated by author.
Total
105(70)
26(17.34)
17(11.33)
1(3)
0(0)
30(100)
23.067
3
.000
Accepted
Null
Causes/Area
High Tax Rates
Complex
tax
system
2(1.33)
0(0)
150(100)
-
Total
83(63)
63(48)
International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, ISSN 0973-4562 Vol.7 No.11 (2012)
Research India Publications;
http://www.ripublication.com/ijaer.htm
Inefficient
tax
authorities
Ineffective
enforcement
of
law
Generation
of
black money in
public sector
Low tax morality
Multiple taxes
Total (N)
14(51)
10(41)
19(63)
9(38)
11(42)
63(48)
8(30)
17(71)
9(30)
10(42)
13(50)
57(44)
16(59)
18(75)
16(53)
19(79)
9(34)
78(60)
15(56)
20(74)
27
10(42)
16(67)
24
13(50)
16(62)
26
60(46)
77(59)
131
10(33)
12(50)
12(40)
13(54)
30
24
Source: Field survey
The Table 4 depicts the causes for Income tax evasion in India given by the tax professionals. Majority of the respondents
identified that high tax rates (63%), corruption in public sector unit (60), multiple taxes and inefficient tax authorities are the
main reason of tax evasion in India. Beside this complex tax system and low tax morality are the other source of tax evasion.
IMPACT OF INCOME TAX EVASION
Table 5: Impact of Income tax evasion in India listed by respondent
Impact/Area
Faridabad Gurgoan Panipat Murthal
Reduction in Countrys economy growth 19(70)
15(62.5) 12(40)
18(75)
Increase in inflation
15(56)
16(67)
14(47)
16(67)
Impact on moral
8(30)
10(42)
17(57)
19(79)
Increase in corruption
21(78)
20(83)
14(47)
19(79)
Increase in prices of land and houses
10(37)
12(50)
13(43)
14(58)
Decrease in countrys reputation
5(18)
17(71)
10(33)
13(54)
Total (N)
27
24
30
24
Source: Authors Calculation.
The Table 5, shows the impact of Income tax evasion in India
given by the tax professionals. Tax evasion and thereby
establishment of parallel economy has been creating the
following serious impacts on the social and economic system
of the country. Most of the respondent are agreed on the
opinion that tax evasion has been causing reduction in
countrys economic growth as an enormous volume of
income is diverted to this unaccounted sector resulting in
Sonipat
20(77)
18(69)
14(54)
23(88)
12(46)
8(31)
26
Total
84(64)
79(60)
68(52)
97(74)
61(47)
53(40)
131
Suggestions/Area
Reduction in tax rate
Strong surveillance
system
Simplified tax law
Strong
corruption
law
Remove
tax
loopholes in tax
subsidy and Grants
Annual Information
Return
Severe punishment
to errant tax officials
Bilateral agreement
with foreign Govt.
Total (N)
Total
92(61)
73(49)
10(33)
10(33)
18(60)
12(40)
20(67)
14(47)
16(53)
12(40)
10(33)
17(57)
74(49)
65(43)
15(50)
18(60)
14(47)
10(33)
24(80)
81(54)
8(27)
16(53)
10(33)
15(50)
20(67)
69(46)
8(27)
7(23)
14(47)
15(50)
18(60)
52(35)
15(50)
16(53)
9(30)
4(13)
8(27)
52(35)
30
30
30
30
30
150
International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, ISSN 0973-4562 Vol.7 No.11 (2012)
Research India Publications;
http://www.ripublication.com/ijaer.htm
Source: Authors Calculation.
The study reveled that most of the respondents are in opinion
of reduction in tax rates to reduce tax evasion in India.
Further, tax evasion can be reduce with the help of removing
loopholes in tax system, by utilising information from annual
information return.
[10]
[11]
[12]
CONCLUSION:
This study has surveyed the opinion of income tax
professionals regarding tax evasion in India. As per their
opinion income tax evasion is prevalent in India. They
opinioned that high tax rates, corruption in public sector units,
multiple tax rates and inefficient tax authorities are the main
causes of tax evasion. They suggested that reduction in tax
rates, simplifications of tax laws, remove loopholes in the tax
system and some extent proper processing of information
available the under the annual information return can be best
tool for improving Indian tax compliance. Therefore there is a
need for creating transparent, friendlier and less
discriminatory administrative system. Further there is also a
need to educate the people about Indian Tax law and create
such an environment in which they pay their due taxes, do not
evade the tax and feel proud in discharging their duty to pay
the taxes.
REFERENCES:
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]