Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AreThereLimitstoTrumpsPower?TheNewYorkTimes
AreThereLimitstoTrumpsPower?
ByERICPOSNER
NOV.10,2016
DonaldJ.TrumpDamonWinter/TheNewYorkTimes
WhenDonaldJ.TrumptakesofficeonJan.20,hewillhaveimmensebut
notunlimitedpowerathisdisposal.BackinJune,Iwrotethathecould
evenwithoutcongressionalconsentexecutemuchofhisvision.Hecould,
forexample,shiftenforcementprioritiesagainstunauthorizedimmigrants,
probablybarMuslimsfromenteringthecountry,raisetariffs,withdraw
forcesfromtheMiddleEast,andtearuptradetreatiesandmilitary
alliances.
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/10/opinion/aretherelimitstotrumpspower.html?partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
1/4
11/11/2016
AreThereLimitstoTrumpsPower?TheNewYorkTimes
Buttherewerelimits:Hecouldnotbuildaborderwallwithouta
congressionalappropriation,imposethedeathpenaltyonkillersofpolice
officers,orstrengthenlibellawssothathecouldsuenewspapersthat
criticizedhim.
Thatwasthen.BecauseMr.TrumpenjoysRepublicanmajoritiesinboth
housesofCongress,hispowerisevengreater.IfhecangetRepublican
membersofCongresstogoalongwithhim,hecandoprettymuchanything
notbannedbytheConstitution.HecanrepealObamacare,cuttaxesand
buildhisborderwall.Butlimitsremain.
OnebarrieristhefilibusterintheSenate.Sincetheycomposenearlya
majorityoftheSenate,Democratscanusethefilibustertoblocklegislation
theyoppose.UnfortunatelyforDemocrats,however,thefilibusterisnotas
powerfulasitoncewas.In2013,SenateDemocratseliminatedthefilibuster
forfederalappointmentsexceptSupremeCourtjusticesinaneffortto
stopwhattheysawasobstructionismbytheRepublicanminority,who
repeatedlyblockedPresidentObamasnominations.
Youllregretthis,theSenateRepublicanleaderMitchMcConnellwarned
theDemocrats.Hewasright.DemocratsnowcantstopTrumpfrom
appointinganyoneacceptabletoRepublicansenators.Andcitingthis
precedent,RepublicansenatorsmayeliminatethefilibusterforSupreme
Courtjusticesaswell,givingMr.Trumpanearlyfreehandtoappoint
whomhewants.
Anotherbarrieristhecourts.PresidentObamahasappointedhundredsof
federaljudgesoverhistwoterms,andhundredsofothersincluding
Republicanappointeeswillviewwithskepticismsometypesofunilateral
executiveactionthatMr.Trumphaspromised.Itwouldnotbesurprisingif
judgesblockedoratleastslowedanaggressiveroundupofunauthorized
immigrants(thoughtheydidnotstopPresidentGeorgeW.Bushsroundup
ofMuslimsandArabsafterSept.11).WhilethelawgivesMr.Trumppower
towithdrawregulationsandrefusetoenforcethem,courtsthatdistrusthis
methodsormotivesmaycreateproceduralstumblingblocks,justasthey
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/10/opinion/aretherelimitstotrumpspower.html?partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
2/4
11/11/2016
AreThereLimitstoTrumpsPower?TheNewYorkTimes
didtoPresidentObamasplantograntworkpermitsandotherprivilegesto
agroupofunauthorizedimmigrants.
Butthecourts,too,possessonlylimited
SignupforfreeNYT
Newsletters
powers.Theytypicallyrefrainfrom
engagesinmilitaryoperationsand
interferingwiththepresidentwhenhe
MorningBriefing
Newstostartyourday,weekdays
diplomacy.Itishardtoimaginethem
OpinionToday
standinginthewayifhetearsuptreaties
Thoughtprovokingcommentary,weekdays
ortransfersmilitaryforceshitherand
Cooking
Deliciousrecipesandmore,5timesaweek
yon.Withthepassageoftime,President
Race/Related
Aprovocativeexplorationofrace,biweekly
Enteryouremailaddress
SignUp
Receiveoccasionalupdatesandspecialoffersfor
TheNewYorkTimes'sproductsandservices.
Trumpwillbeabletoplacehispeoplein
thejudiciary,andTrumpianjudgeswill
seethingshisway.Historyshowsthata
presidentcanusuallydependonhis
SupremeCourtappointee(orappointees)
tosupporthimifheischallenged.
ThegreatestconstraintonMr.Trump
maybethefederalbureaucracy.Ifhe
PRIVACYPOLICY
directstheF.B.I.,I.R.S.orDepartmentof
HomelandSecuritytoharasshispolitical
opponents,civilservantswillprobablynotcooperateindeed,theymay
blowthewhistle.PresidentBushfacedthreatsofresignationbyJustice
Departmentofficialsoverhissurveillanceprogramandleaksabouthis
policyofcoerciveinterrogation.Mr.Obamahadtoputupwithdamaging
leaksfromfederalemployeesandcontractorswhoopposedhissurveillance
programs.
Butmanyinthebureaucracyinthemilitaryandatimmigrationagencies
inparticularsupportMr.Trumpandmayfollowhispolicies
enthusiastically.Andbecausehisagendaismostlyderegulatory,he
possessesmostofthecards.Hecandelayorblocknewfinancial,
environmentalandworkplacesafetyregulationswithoutthecooperationof
agencyofficialshecanprobablyblockenforcementofthemaslongasheis
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/10/opinion/aretherelimitstotrumpspower.html?partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
3/4
11/11/2016
AreThereLimitstoTrumpsPower?TheNewYorkTimes
abletoappointloyaliststoleadershippositions.
ThenewsmediawillalsoplayaroleinconstrainingMr.Trump.Histhreats
tostrengthenlibellawsareidle.TheFirstAmendmentprotectsthemedia,
andtodayunlikeinthepastthatamendmentisadarlingofRepublican
jurists.ButthemediacanconstrainMr.Trumponlytotheextentthatitcan
rousepublicopinionagainsthimandhispolicies.Thismayinvolveshowing
sensitivitytoMiddleAmericansensibilitiesthatithasnotalways
demonstrated.
Intheend,thesuccessofMr.TrumpsadministrationdependsonMr.
Trumphimself.Ifheshowsselfdiscipline,whichwasconspicuouslylacking
duringthecampaign,andhewstorelativelymoderatecenterrightpolicies,
hemaybeabletoaccomplishagreatdeal(forgoodorill).Ifheinsultslarge
groupsofAmericans,useshispowerstounleashvendettasagainsthis
opponents,placespoliticalhacksinthebureaucracy,andbetraysallies,he
willfail.Itshischoice.
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/10/opinion/aretherelimitstotrumpspower.html?partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
4/4