Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COSTA STOYANOVITCH
1Q1Q
,1
PRIMER]
Rue
RAJ HIQUE
Saint-Gil
ECONOMIC PROBLEMS
of
SERBIA
by
COSTA STOYANOVITCH
BIBLIOTEKA
HKONOMSKCG INSTITUTA
1919
I.MPRIMKRIK --(iHAI'llI^X
i.^. Rue Sainl-( lilies, i5
I
'A
HIS
i;
Introduction.
2052238
INTRODUCTION,
BIBLl
KONOM.
INJ fill
independence
still
lived in
some
Ottoman Empire,
and yet even later, we see in all the regions inhabited by our race, continuous struggles and insurrections, it is true without any permanent
littoral,
till
it
organisation.
At the beginning of the i()th century, there were
two organised insurrections in Serbia, which ga\c
birth to the new State, a Stale which has realised,
include
the
all
conditions necessary
economic and
numbering
of
for
a
the
nation
political independence
If one considers, at
i4 million souls.
our
superhuman
effort*.
6
justice, the principle of nationalities, as \\ell as the
is filled
with Serbia's
economic as
struggles against Austria-llungarv
'<
well as in political questions.
\ustria-IIungary
.
method, known
in
history,
all
After the
fall
of
after
The
completely neglecting the principle
Balkanic
nations
Balkans for the
Europe always interested herself in the Balkans.
is
For the last fifty years Austria-Hungary and Germany have practically monopolised the Balkans.
Commerce, industry, credit, communications byland and by sea, tariffs, all were controlled by those
two States. The same States controlled the development of all interior important questions with the
help of the
German
life
ations.
create
till
now
all
at
1
;
guaranteed to us by the intensified work of ^ ougoslavia in connection with all our Allies,
\ougopossesses the conditions which will allo\\
her to suffer on her territorx all the traffic which
slavia
up
till
humanity's progress.
also the limits of those problems, taking into connew frontiers of the State of the
sideration the
The tables
Serbians, Croatians and Slovenes.
are also important, which we are publishing, in
order to acquaint the reader with the necessities
and with the nature of the products
same way Ave have treated
communications necessary
for the junction between the Balkan States as Avell
of our State
In the
of our country.
also the question of the
as the
new
in Europe.
May
1919.
C. STOYANOVITGH.
Serbia
\ustria
is
110
and
flusiria-Huogary.
The
more.
which caused
State,
in
of
sequence
efforts
was
terminated,
but
the
monarchy
and economic
conflicts
ex-
in the
I
common.
New
on the principle of
interests
mutual
h\
insuring
renewing all
ancient programs, which had their source in the
megalomania ideas of racial domination and pre!\
the
Political
and
Economical Intercourse
Poliiical
&
Economical Intercourse
i.
1804-1878
Since the insurrection oi' iHo'i and until 1876.
Serbia \vent througli yarious reyolutionary phases
to obtain firstly a half-soy ereignty and then her
complete liberation.
under the su/.erainty
guaranteed
!>\
As
half-soy ereign
Stale
Turkish Kmpire.
commercial and
of
in the
subjects
of Turkex,
Serbia,
ical situation
of European
political lights
in case of the liquidation
Balkans,
llungary
had,
by
common
Hns>ia
action,
and
lii'st
Vuslriaagainst,
Balkans their
The awakening
of national
conscience
in
the
win frequent
fluctuations
in
And
exterior
that
politics
The Occidental
States, especially
England and
On
the
trouble
other
amongst the
hand Germany
ments of gratitude of the racial and religious relationship, and the necessity of a union of the Balkan
States, which was in favour of their interests, Germany on the contrary established at the basis of
her action, real bonds with the courts of the BalkanStales and brought in thai way her allies to the
present conflict.
Germany forced humiliated, weakened, isolated
Austria-Hungary, to conclude an
xego viua.
But Ihe interior problem of tlie dual Monarchy,
so difficult to resohe, did not give Austria the
This Monarchy
possibility to execute her plans.
needed, to maintain herself, \arious abilities in
all branches of political, customs, administrative,
legislalne, commercial, juridical, military, nniversitary life and external economy
Considering the
1
wanted
to
in
the general
economical
politics.
and
Hungarians
i8
Slavs
commercial
treaties
industry. The safeguard of the Hungarian agriculture had to enter for a great part into the protection-
ism
of
Austro-Hungarian
treaties.
Over
these
to
Hungarian
II.
1878-1903
After 1878, after the Serbo-Turkish war and the
formation of Bulgaria, Serbia wanted to manifest
her independence by the conclusion of commercial
treaties with one of the European States.
For that
she
chose
Great
at once
Britain.
Austria
purpose,
led
to
the
for Foreign
Affairs
made with
the neighbouring Monarchy a secret convention according to which Serbia could not con-
19
But on
only through her commercial treaty with AustriaHungary. All the treaties were drafted on that one
of
nationality,
also
of
articles
the
vinces,
such
as
Bosnia-Herzegovina, Dalmatia,
She could not any more
communicate directly with Europe, for the transCroatia or Bohemia.
SlMlos either
intensive
commerce.
20
municalion
Vustria
in the
\\as
regard to the
creased.
v\ith
The junction
Constantinople by way of Sopha.
of Serbia with Salonica was accomplished much
later.
To
increase
Hungarian harbour,
the
of
importance
obstacles
were
Finnic.
constantly
exchanges, connection of the harbour to the railroad, etc... The construction of a transversal railroad, which could have given Serbia an outlet on
On the
the Adriatic sea, has never been allowed.
coast of that sea
all
from the economical point of view. Our agricultural, industrial and fiscal resources brought hardly
80 million dinars to the State budget. Our exportations did not reach 70 millions and importations
varied from 60 to 65 million dinars.
Serbia, after
her loans for the liquidation of the w ars of 18761878 and of 1 885, and after the construction of the
railroad Belgrade-Vrany and Belgrade-Pirot could
not for at least 20 years contract a loan
r
at
rates of
interest
yo to
'to
o/o
in
Vienna and
Berlin.
little
to deliver her
them were
indifferent
and designs
liberation,
their
who
dependance
following
The
German hegemony.
these Austro-Hungariaii
III.
1903-1912
The
alliance of
Italy
was
of Italy and Austria-Hungary in the Adriatic contributed to make the former of these powers
encourage
ation of
all
Roumania and
Serbia.
ing
all
new
current for
The
Germany developed.
policy of
Edward Ml was crowned at the eve of the European
war by an understanding between England and
France. By this fact the Russo-French alliance was
reinforced. The isolation of Germany then showed
the isolation of
denounce
a preliminary
23
treaty for customs with Bulgaria in order to enable
herseli to start at once negotiations of a treaty with
her. After the change of a cabinet and the refusal
months
member
To
The
new
situation.
found access
and Xorwa\
\ieima.
Up
Fondova
in everything
one of 96 million,
million dinars, and finally a loan
millions contracted by the
Ouprava
the other of
of
ij)ir>
in Paris
f)o
(TTypothecarv Bank).
The
and finan-
State budgets balanced i>\ surin thai \\a\ that at the e\e of the
\nd it is
pluses.
\>ar against Turkey in 1912 Serbia had cash in hand
The exportto the amount of \o million dinars.
The.
ations amounted to more than 200 millions.
new
are
annexation
of
regard to
all
subdued to
a control as before.
It is
formed
in Serbia,
During
Italy
and other
before.
The intercourse
of Serbia
States concerning commercial traffic, the communications and credit were also completely altered.
The
Independent economical
committees formed hehveen Serbia and the above
mentioned States precede political understandings
which prepare the Balkanic alliance under the protectorate of our present Allies.
After the annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina the
question of the construction of the \driatic Railroad presents itself again and the question of the
creation of a Serbian maritime navigation with the
help of the legislation of one of the Allied States
for us.
26
IV.
1912-1914
Apart from the evident enterprises of AustriaJJungary against Serbia and her economical independence, and apart from the expectation in view
of conquering her politically, new events occurred
Alliance
of
1912.
In
the
Kingdoms of the
Balkanic Peninsula entered the war against Turkey,
while Germany and Austria-Hungary were not
prepared to rise against this conflict. The victory
and the nearly complete disparition of
European Turke\ let Germany feel the urgent
necessity of an European war.
Already at the beginning of the Balkan war
Austria, which expected a defeat of Serbia, was
surprised at our successes and tried at various
occasions to find an excuse for an intervention
of the Allies
firstly
at
the
at
the
27
politics,
different
Russians.
Two months
Bucarest,
the
Government withdrew
When
conflict.
the
according to the sense of this convention, everything Greece had reserved for Serbia.
Naturally,
following the order of things, the exigences of
\ustiia were illusory, for the principle itself of the
said convention on veterinary regulations concerned
the importation
products b>
and
Saloiiica,
commerce
to
June
declare
war on Serbia,
28
haa
after
lie
Germans
tho
equally hastened to enter the war.
death of the Archduke Ferdinand, Austrian Cn;v\nbecair:"
most precious
On one
assistants for her territorial conquests.
side the isolation of Germany, on the other hand
fortifying the idea of an
alliance in the small nations, the armaments of th^
the democratic
awakening
deferred
Allies,
we
went,
Serbia,
this
devote
all
regulations
of
the
The
could
first
riot
be executed in
its
debts,
w ere intended
r
One
real estate,
included.
real plans of studies for the development of railloads in old and liberated Serbia were elaborated.
II
course of these
enter-
9 5
1
of the
Serbia's
Commercial Movement
Serbia's Commercial
Movement
1804-1814
The period
of Serbia's resurrection
which began
Turkish reoccupation in
i8i3.
Serbia never had the time, during the unceasing \\ars against the Turks, in the above period
to consolidate her economical and commercial life
After the second revolution
\\itli her neighbours.
of 18];"), commercial relations in Serbia we e
legulaled on tariffs based upon commercial treaties
bet \\een \nstria and Turke\ provided in PojarevaU
These tariffs taxed mer(Passaro\ilx) in 1718.
chendise with 3 o/o (id valorem augmented l>\
o/o
of additional tariffs.
Uler the Peace of Adrianople
in 180/1 \vas (UK led b\ the
\>.
in
\\here b\ a
i8y.i)
nomy
Tnrk<\\
\vas
's
recognised
Serbia's auto-
Ilatlisheriff
ii8.'Jo,
.Inly
i/jtlu,
Serbia,
com-
lic^r
IT).
.">
.">
>
Serbia, which remained with the rate of 5 o/o towards Austria-Hungary. The treaty of Paris in 1866
which warranted as a principle to the Danubian
principalities the economical autonomy, had not
commerce
as a sovereign State
was
The
the
article
treaty
of
to
regulate her economical relations like the independent European States, by which Serbia came out of
the regime of capitulations in force for Turkey.
II.
1881-1906
In 1879 Serbia had concluded with Great Britain
a provisional agreement on the principle of the most
first
commercial
which the
October
Austrian exigencies.
The
that
capital articles of that convention were
Serbia did not have the right to conclude any treaty
of commerce without the assent of Austria-Hungary.
:
first
treaties
36
Hungary and
Serbia under
Austria-
Empire to have
an
idea
domination,
exposed in the
In the
da\s
which
followed
the
Berlin
first
treaty.
frontier traffic asserted to Serbia in those two
treaties, the rights of other foreign countries which
had commercial relations with Serbia on the basis
of the most favoured nation, were actually baffled...
the other States w hose treaties were not tariff
treaties and which should benefit by the advantages
of low custom rates for Austrian importation did not
benefit on account of two reasons
the reason of
and
reason
of
the
proximity
privileges in the frontrealize the idea of that
tier
ier-traffic
between
taxes.
of live cattle
and
fruit,
cereals.
-3 7
from
pletely
all
Europe.
ing fluvial navigation, successions, recourses in juridical matters and extraditions of criminals.
Ill
1906-1912
hen the delay of the second treaty of commerce
expired, it was prolonged until the end of KJOO.
\\ hen the
negotiations were started for the con\\
clusion of the
new
treaty,
he
\ustrian exigencies
with
Sofia in 1908.
pretexting motives of the Bulgaro-Serbian convention asking her to withdraw them so as to continue the negotiations with Austria-Hungary.
38
treaty, into a
the (iclinilixc
until the
\<
treaty.
Vustria
commercial
wanted
treat
to secure, by according a
to Serbia, for ever special politic**!
adxantagvs. particularly the guarantee of the principle that for Government supplies Austrian products
on
egality of prices
September 1908, the frontiers of AustriaHungary were closed for the greater part of our
The cattle, poultry and
exportation and transit.
animal products were prohibited during that
In this period our efforts for our economperiod.
were crowned with success.
ical emancipation
to
Serbia, obliged
go to new and ancient markets
with her products by new ways underwent the
productive transformation in quantity and quality
and confirmed the vitality of the Serbian nation i.i
the exterior world and proved that she could do
without the markets of Austria-Hungary.
In this interval Serbia had improved her treaties
of commerce almost with all the European States
except with Austria-Hungary.
The negotiations with Austria-Hungarx vseiv
started, several times from 1906 to 1908 and they
were much improved in the beginning of 1908. In
ist
of
convention does
no more export-
3g
On
account of the annexation of BosniaHerzegovina the concluded treaty was in force only
by trimestrial prolongations on decrees instead of
being approved by the Austro-Hungarian parliaments to whom it \\as submitted.
products.
commerce submitted
to
to her parliaments
new
and
treaty.
tried
Serbia
frontier
COMPARATIVE TABLES
of the exterior
i
in
commerce
million francs
1864-1880
YEARS
of Serbia
1881 -1905
YEARS
1906-1911
YE \KS
43
1881
YK
I'.S
1893
44
1906
YEARS
1912
- 4 5COMPARATIVE TABLE
of exported goods
from
Average of exportation
ioods
in
884
to 1 91
million francs.
first
when
fruit 17,7
lowest
the
frontier
and
factories
zone
to
supply
the
Austrian
Exportation of
Period
of the second
treaty of
live cattle
into
tlio
Austria-Hungary
47
Custom-war.
48
ned
cattle
on various occasions.
canery was
often repeated, several times for diseases and other times because the provenience of Ser-
On
bian swine was supposed to he Roumanian.
the 24th of May 189/1 cattle exportation was temporarily prohibited until the i/Uh of October 1898
August 1896.
In
1898,
1901,
1902,
cattle
was hindered
cattle.
The definitive
on account of
wealth m
commercial
results of Serbia's
the
abnormal
49
flie
nufactured exportation
articles.
am!
aggression of
Uistri;i-Hungar\
to,
912
190619071908
Exportation
in
million francs.
Cattle
is, 3
Cereals
22,0
31
Fruit
lo,l
22
]">
Animal products
1->,0
10
10
1906
Annual average
in
1
:>7,7
1912
0/
on
Cattle
total exportation.
8,.">
Cereals
33,0
14,0
Fruits
Animal products
3,0
13,1
10
39,7
/,
17,77"
v
l-
>,5/
DO
COMPARATIVE TABLE
of the commercial
movement
by countries of
provenience and of destination during 1911.
(in
Country.
million francs).
5i
First
Category.
Products.
Products of agriculture.
91 1
Products.
Denomination.
53
Denomination.
Q
c.
c2
CO
o
o
o
73
Cti
CO
0)
s*
1
|!
.
s--
CO
_CD
J2
cd
*j
CD
>
I
BJ
Q.
E
o
56
of exportation are
cereals,
fruit,
fresh
or
dealt
with
herewith
newly
The importation
regions of Serbia.
liberated
for the
new
Serbia in
her- frontiers
before
i<)i:^
far
from the
whose
into Bosnia-HerSerbian
purely
country, succeeded in
awav
he
of
life
Serbian Stale by difthe
washing
ferent methods she used against Serbia.
The conditions for the Serbian economical development and
first
/<>go\ina.
step
external
after the
58
good
he,
\\
truth,
spirits \\ith us
\\ere concentrated
on the
sea,
had conquered
and our
upon
Owe
preventions upon Dalmatia and the other Serhian, (Iroatian and Sknene countries ai e justified
not onl\ b\ national motives but also by reasons of
%
nomical independence.
The Economical
Serbia with
relations
the
of
Allied
War.
6i
IN
When
on the
()th
TRODUCTION.
my
January 1918
published
relations
ol
Thanks
to the
worth.
lost its
Toe
Economical
relations
of
Seroia
WITH THE
Countries
Hilled
and
liefore
after
INTRODUCTION
me War,
(I).
I.
In these
war when,
nations,
all
fields to
the
barbarism, notwithstanding the condition,
confidence that victory is ours, Humanity feels the
necessity of beginning- to reflect on the hasis ol' he
peace, its future duration and the new conditions
I
of
life
a lot of
problems
in
and
rents
prevailed on
other'
ii
An extract of this work has been the object of my Conference, held the nth January IUK>, at the Hotel des SocieU'-s.
Savantes, in Paris, under the Presidency of Dr. Chervin.
64
fire
out
oi'
which
tliis
con-
no resources, had
the
The amelioration of
workmen's situation was great, enormous, although far from being perfect, but the labour questaken the place of revolution.
the
tion preoccupied the intellectuals as well as the salaried persons, and the legislative bodies of all States
contributed with
to
th-j
same time
as these tendencies,
and thus the
A
of the last century was prolonged.
campaign
campaign which had begun and had been crowned
by success in Italy and in Germany. Besides these
two currents the iriveterated ambitions of an ancient
past were dragging along, The Middle Age covet
ousness for supremacy, imperialistic wishes and
violent domination were the unique aim of certain
nations and certain States. One was only awaiting
the favourable
moment
with unheard of
anarchy of Russian
Bolsheviks. The true Barbarians who unite themselves with brutes in order to vanquish moral right
and justice those that have neither pity nor soul,
that were massacring women, children and old
men, that were drowning- innocents and taking men
away like the Satrapes of Assyria and Babylonia
Axero clasping the principles of equality between
men in order to be able, disguised thus, to avoid
social
One
one is bound
have actually
if,
solution could perhaps augment the means of sanction within the power of such an Institution as the
Society of Nations will be. If we succeed to have in
the East of Europe, homogeneous, solid and strong,
States among w hom a natural federation could be
r
66
intuit
1
,
onh
that
peace against
The
all
those
latest
The
self-determination of these nations.
national autonomies in Austria-Hungar\ are absurd
free
generation
with
nearh
irreparable
evils
and
sufferings.
II.
their liberation
from
68
Scarcely ten months passed between the end of
the Balkanic wars and the commencement of the
World war.
During
this
interval Austria-Hung-
The interference
of
all
political
Customs
little.
foreign
this period,
end of
importation and
attained, at the
\o millions of francs,
traffic
greatest part.
After the above mentioned period comes the
epoch of the economical emancipation and of arm-
ament.
done
7O
view of her
Till
political
of Serbia
independence
in
the
The exportation
of the articles belonging to the international traffic \vas being made on the coast of
Venice, Geneva,
at that
commerce
dominated
European
Byzantium
Turkish
invasion.
Till
Serbia
the
even
after
epoch,
became
at
the
independent
again
beginning of the
i()th century, the importance of Ragusa and the
other Dalmatian towns was very great for the traffic
which was operated between the Serbian provinces
under the Turkish domination and the other
subjected countries Byzantium, Roumania. Hung:
ary, etc....
much
All
and in place
which one desired to have these new free States.
The disaggregation of the Ottoman Empire, the
iw\\ route to India, the new Danubian States exposed to external currents and to internal movements which were gravitating towards national
alread\ notched since several centuries
of
States.
first
Serbia.
At the Con-
gress of Berlin she had taken possession of BosniaHerzegovina and had seized this occasion to establish herself in Serbia like in one of her colonies.
She controlled,
ian awakening.
72
of
Commerce with
the
neighbouring
to Serbia
from
The successes
England, Belgium and Holland.
arrived at by our sacrifices and our efforts put up
the question of our issue to the sea. The
principal
- 73lever of
political
independence,
the annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina which followed the second year of our customs war with
Austria
more
our
is
of the
vitalit)
hegemony.
They
felt
bound
to risk anything in
74
of Serbia
Till
\\illi
to 1905.
Montenegro declared
relations.
Bosnia-Herzegovina, Montenegro,
Macedonia, Bulgaria and the other regions of the
ical
producing thanks to
its
natural richness
more than
was prevailing
at that
epoch.
affairs, in
the affairs
ical \assal.
70
selves for the historical missions
During
this period of
independent State, was trading with foreign countries, thanks to commercial treaties based on autonomous tariffs and on the clauses of the most favoured nation. In order to consecrate her right which
made any
real Treaties
Austria-Hungary.
with Tariffs
The other
States
except
with
with
which
clause
Treaties of
of
the
to
Serbia.
very
much
different
from the
first.
bia
Before 1880 the commercial movement of Serwith Austria-Hungary was the following.
Austria-Hungary and Serbia with Bosnia and
IKr>;>
1870
1875
1879
...
.
Import.
Export.
36.4
32.4
29.8
4H.4
22
33.2
24
38
!8<i;>
1870
1875
187!)
...
.
17-7
15.4
30.5
20.02
36.8
27.9
21.2
l.l.'i
period
merce
our com-
I.
Import.
1888
1893
1898
1903
1905
....
....
....
....
.
127
Export.
Transit.
II.
thousands of francs.
Import.
1888
1893
Kxport.
Transit.
V.
....
....
....
....
....
....
1884
188!>
!8!)4
18!)!)
l!)04
i!)or,
thousands of francs.
Import.
Kxport.
338
4!)2
Transit.
IK;
:;!>.<;
240
Mi
:i!)
:i<;
1!)0
38
i;i7
VI.
and Montenegro.
In
thousands of francs.
Import.
1888
1898
I!
HIM
i!o:;
Kxport.
Transit.
....
....
8:i
43
3.-)
VII.
thousands of francs.
Import.
1881
1880
I8JI1
18!)(i
I'.ioi
l!)03
30.018
Kxport.
Transit.
80
thousands of francs.
81
r~
.5
'/i
03
CQ
(0
*ft
o
z
_
S
oc
b.
ed
(A
The commercial
of Serbia
relations
ean war.
The second period, which is characteristic, is the
period of our attempt in view of our economical
Period 1881-1905.
In
From
thousands of francs.
Serbia.
Import.
1881.
I88r>.
1890.
189?).
I9o:i.
1905.
43.173
Export.
83
thousands of francs.
In
From Austria-Hungary.
...
30.000
20.700
22.800
16.60(1
33. 400
33.300
(14.700
In
From
Kxport.
24.000
30.700
35.400
38.700
50.300
188-1.
1885.
1890.
1805.
1903.
1905.
Import.
thousands of francs
other countries.
1881.
1885.
1800.
1895.
1903.
1905.
Import.
Kxport.
JO.
13.000
11.000
000
7.000
-16.000
(i.OOO
12.000
5.000
9.000
7.200
More than 80
23.000
22.000
and
9ll(i
1907
1908
thousands of francs.
Import.
Export.
44 328
607
81.997
77. 754
70.583
70.000
Total.
Transit.
1 15
932
152.580
.
147. 75
48 645
.
55.903
tiU in
force.
84
In thousands of francs.
Difference
....
....
....
....
America
Austria-Hungary
Belgium
Bosnia
Bulgaria
Greece
England
Italy.
Germany-.
Norway"
Roumania.
....
Russia
.'"..
....
Holland
Switzerland
Montenegro
...
...
0.012
31.272
(i.2
0.00
in
1906
1906
3.0!>4
0.420'
0.005
0.572
19. 03:*
0.040
2.334
0.131
0.087
0.024
0.008
71:599
1906
0.012
64.71233.139
0.323
0.157
1.220
+
-
3.!l3(i
O.O'.Mi
2.474
0.420
O.OG5
-f
0.372
2.11(1 - Hi. 937
+
+
+
+
O.oir,
0.03(5
0.003
0.002
0.087
0.021
O.ooii
1.097
0.03(1
2. 237
1
71 .09(5
.703
0.396.435
Germany
thousands of francs.
............
............
.........
.............
........
Turkey
Russia ...... ......
France ............
England ............
............
Roumania ...........
Egypt .............
Switzerland ..........
Norway ............
Sweden ............
Bosnia ............
Greece ............
Denmark ...........
America ............
Montenegro ...... ....
Other
..........
Belgium
Austria-Hungary
Italy
Bulgaria
States
32.842
13.010
12.939
3.443
4.418
3.113
2.698
2.337
1.994
1 87
1.037
310
233
204
103
59
5
1
1
10
81.997
85
Exportation in 1908
In
thousands of francs.
Austria-Hungary
Belgium.
Bosnia-Herzegovina
1(1.075
05
Bulgaria.
.!2I
3.UH)
Italy
7<>o
Egypt
Germany
14.018
Roumania
Turkey
3.00.")
I0.!>(7
3.04;>
France
America
Other States
1.985
1.073
77.754
The
with the
has
European
become more intense, with which \ve only had relations by the medium of Austria-Hungary. Because
of the length of the routes a transformation had been
made with the articles of commerce. The rawproducts had been replaced by semi-manufactured
exportation of our goods.
traffic
States
cattle
1)\
independence.
86
during the
economical war with Austria-Hungary.
In
thousands
of francs.
Allied States
Belgium .........
..........
Russia .........
France ........
England .........
Roumania ........
Egypt ..........
-l.'
o.UM
Italy
3.1
2.WN
'2.331
1
187
o:n
28.823
Enemy States
Germany
........
Austria-Hungary ......
Turkey .........
Bulgaria .........
3'2.
842
\2.U32
4.418
1
991
1.187
1.988
Neutral States.
Total.
81.991
Germany was
the
new
Europe and the transit through AustriaHungary. The percentage is in favour of our Allies;
before the Customs War it amounted only to
of central
o/o
fallen
since
it
was
raised to 33 o/o.
Austria has
from 80
to 16 o/o.
annual average of the Serbian
The
movement
in this period,
\\ithout treaties of
Hungary 1800 to 1879
I.
was
commercial
commerce with
Austria-
-87
In millions of francs
Importation
29.6
II. -
With
Hungary
Hungary
Total
Transit.
29.9
Bg./i
l5.20
treaties of
since 1881-1906
46.2
III.
Exportation
commerce with
Austria-
100.2
54-
67.
89.
181.
92.
97.
symptom
forces
may be
of
all
productive
prepared to accomplish her histormission, began during the war with Turkey
that she
ical
of the expansion
in 1912.
88
The economic
with the
total
The greatest
population represents only 17 o/o.
of
the
land
is
of
small
part
composed
properties
89 o/o between 5 and 20 ha., and among the rest,
the properties between 100 and 3oo ha. are very
:
rare.
is
the following
in
Millions
of kilos of francs.
Cereals
Indian corn
Fresh fruit
124
21
IIS
14,">
14
Prunes
33
2
Hi..-;
0,22
2.1
!)
i.li
89
II
In millions
of franls.
Breeding products
Oxen
Pigs
Poultry
Meat, lard
17.788 heads
4,8
0,6
3,5
7.707
....
Eggs
Grease
1.108.000 kilogs
000
055 000
Hi. 7011.
1
Skins
11,7
3
.287.000
.7
3.3
-1.361.706
etc.).
2.0
Ill
\Vheatilour.
Copper
All other products
1.813.260
503.940
1.175.000
9.000.000
7.128.717
1.275.000
11.611.000
6.826.502
Sugar
Bran
Totals.
francs
ki logs
Other products
82.000.000
20. ooo heads
66.000 me.
437.873.081 kgs
10.283
heads
5.488.000
The importation
of 1912
amounted
be exposed
to 8/1.222.000
later.
-icith
the
of
third Treaty
I.
Balkanic Countries
In millions of francs.
IMPORTAT.ON
H)I(>
KM
EXPORTATION
1<H<)
I'Jl
Bosnia-Herzegovina.
0.21
0.2
0.11
Bulgaria
0.4
0.<5
4.1
0.12
2.80
Roumania
Turkey
1.2
!.">
(i.l
(5.00
6.0
3.8
23.:;
12. 00
0,3
O 04
0,4
0.07
8.13
H.o"
Greece
Montenegro
Total
II.
France
Allied Countries
0,1
0.002
0.03
33.912
21..").")
-- Central
Empires
Til.
19IO
1910
K>I
22
17.8
....:; 1.2
78.7
39.8
3,1
2.1
2.8
84.7
115,4
98.4
Austria-Hungary
Other countries
Totals.
will
EXPORTATION
31.3
47.4
IMPORTATION
35
16.2
Germany
Total
millions of francs
In
'.
191
29
48.2
118
movement with
the different countries, in categories and showing the special commerce of Serbia
with France during the year 1911, under the re-
gime of the last Treaty of Commerce between Serbia and Austria-Hungary, in the period immediately after the Customs War.
Table of the Commercial Movement with the
different countries for 1911.
In francs.
IMPORTATION EXPORTATION
....
....
America
Austria-Hungary
Belgium
Bosnia
Carried forward.
Norway
Portugal
Roumania
Russia
....
....
.
Carried forward.
93
84.221.000
10(1.986.000
niture
Paper
Books and pictures.
Works
000
9.000
19.000
lid.
of stone, asphalt
and cement
Works
of terracotta ..
Glass and works of glass
43.000
109.000
843.000
I9.ilil.ooo
9.037.000
1.801.000
489.000
1.138.000
28.000
116.916.000
nical articles
313.0011
1.303.000
1.520.000
and
ol
plants
mPORTA^oNExPORTAT ON
commercial
.......
80.000
......
.
338.000
119.000
6.000
cocoons)
Forest products
Products of agricultural
.
industries, flowermills
........
Products ol alimentation
Mineral raw materials.
Wax
........
Chemical products
Textile
Leather and
furs.
and
material
their products.
363.000
71.000
14.000
32.000
1.007.000
954.000
497.000
.......
To be carried forward.
16.000
3
59 000
.
338 000
.
94
Carried forward.
338.noo
3.139.000
Manufactures plaited
with vegetable mat2.000
ters
Brushes
Matters to be cut
Paper
3. (MM)
21.000
15.000
Works
54. (MM)
of stone, plaster
2.000
11.000
and cement
Works
Glass
of terracotta
and \vorks
of
29.000
glass
Precious metals.
Ordinary metals and
their products.
Machines, electro-technical articles and
vehicles
Objects of art and
.
(i.OOO
1.987.000
35N.OOO
47
science
l.:i!MJ.OOO
:i.
>0
7 ir..
OIMI
000
ooo
.934. ooo
<p
(in
OIK)
francs)
Balhanic
War after
every advantage to the commerce of the neighbouring monarchy which is, of all European States, the
nearest to Serbia.
means of transport,
depending on the Austrian
Insufficient
commerce
Serbia with
for 1912
IMPORTATION
EXPORTATION
Germany
32.659.000
31.117.000
36.076.000
18.279.000
Total
63.776.000
54.355.000
Austria-Hugary
55
65
II
IMPORTATION
EXPORTATION
3.631,000
3.713.000
3.783.000
2.978.000
8.511.
(ion
2.01)0.0011
8.765.000
Italy
France
Great Britain
Total
13
10
III
Other countries.
37.329.000
Total
21.102.000
o/
39
J
/O
23
''
/O
117.903.000
84.222.000
'
provinces,
all
was behind-hand.
The
feodal system
in
forces.
The
the ancient
takes into
consideration the
(railway,
roads, etc.) of establishments of credit (banks, cor-
new
primitive,
and
efforts
and
state
which we
standards be-
Serbia as
francs,
The
economical value of Greater Serbia would therefore amount to 9 to 10.000 millions whose agricultural production amounted to 1:8 -- 2.000 millions
on the eve of the world's war.
The importation, which we have spoken of
alreach, was smaller than the exportation for about
i/3 and was unequally divided among the different
phases of our economic life.
millions
The administration
etc.)
to
260-260
millions
of
We
IOO
Importations
In millions of francs.
Cereals
1.7
Fruits
0.0
Rice
Flour
Beer
4.0
1.4
0.51
Wine
o.os
Victuals
Sugar
1.20
4.03
Coffee
1.14
Salt.
1.15
0.80
Alcool
Oil
0.30
1.25
Petrol
Tobacco
Wool, cotton
Tissues
Shoemaking
Material of buildings
Writing paper
Glass
Chemical products
Drugs
Metals
Ironmongery
Tools.
Divers
..;...,
Total
2.20
1.90
2.63
12.73
2.00
0.84
0.04
0.85
2.12
0.25
5.58
0.03
0.51
3.09
51.377
1/4 of the importation comes from AustriaHungary, 1/5 from Germany. After these two States
we have Turkey, Italy, Serbia, Russia, Roumania
:
IOI
Export at ions
In millions of francs.
Cereals
1.350
Fruits
3..').')<
Rice
Flour
0.<;i(;
Victuals
0.2S:]
Wine
0.03G
0.378
Cattle
1.703
Tobacco
."i.7oG
Opium
7.179
Cocoons
3.00(1
Leather
2.4(('
Wool
0.348
O.o.Vi
Shoemaking
Bowels
0.070
Cloth, stockings
0.171)
Metals
Divers
0.02:i
O.oOO
Total
27.:i<>2
European War.
The consolidation
to have
IO2
trials.
first to
receive
the blow from the north, as she was the first, in the
Middle Age, before Byzantium, Bulgaria and Roum-
where future
States are
will
our country.
because we are
of
its
am
is
starting
from
supposition,
war and
which
are
between
two
currents
liquidation
at the eve of the
end of
this
definite peace.
io3
moment with
war
is
else
provoked
culprits and to leave the same intolerable situation
between the nations, the same as it was before the
war.
104
1
3 to
4 million inhabitants.
If
appreciation of the economical value of these provinces, the standard by which Austria-Hungary s
The resources
for
roads,
numerous
in
ing that nobody will consider this absurdity of leaving the robbed nations and devastated countries
without indemnities we may say that, within the
frontiers of the future Serbo-Croato-Slovene State
it will be possible to find all the
necessary means,
on the base of the credit which our Allies could
for creating all that
and
facilitates
the
relations
us
and
counbetween
the
augments
us
grant
our friends.
do not see any reason
tries of
We
tries
ated
the
means which
war.
why
mon
enemy,
100
countries, with Albania and Serbia, after the disappearance of Turkey from the Balkans and dis-
memberment
of 600.000 sq.
would amount to
be raised,
European
sions.
developments which exclude every exploitation to the detriment of any member of this new
federation.
The sale of the goods and of the raw
itated
markets which
will
interests
of
these
three
The
necessity of the industrial developof these three countries is more than evident
nations.
ment
enough
r
,
firstly in
consequence
agricultural works
which must pass from the extensive to the intensive
io8
would represent
in future a
new power
in
Europe
to saveguard peace and a powerful lever for the expansion of the forces useful for the European civilisation.
forever.
way the
now
and eco-
show
off their
rights of
penetrating
in
the
Balkans.
shows
certainly four times smaller than that of the prosperous countries in Europe and this is explained by
the history of
all
these nations.
IO
---
the
francs even
losses
if
we had
amounts
to
we do
in
deported
The
different
Red
whom
of
some
The example of
cruelty was given by German troops which passed
through Serbian in 1910. The Germans have taken
away the enormous booty of the gigantic Serbian
extracts of this report.
The German troops sustained themselves for nothing during several months. After the Germans,
Austrians and Bulgarians came to conclude the
ruin of the Serbian country. They deprived of food
those families which they were spoiling of their
formal, effective
and
is
impossible
without
independence.
Serbia has
In
are quite out of proportion to the necessities.
two years one has sent a 100 million. The authorities
am
everything, in the literal sense of the word is exported from the country. Great and rapid help is
necessary, in
condemn
money and
in food,
a people, possessing-
in the
if
most atrocious
conditions.
The
suppressed.
One
kills
llungary
's
Ml that
tration
is
criminal policx.
said for
\ustro-llungarian adminisas
exact
for that of the Bulgarians
just
is
not
know any
course of justice.
Nobody escapes
francs.
this
would amount
to nearly
200 millions of francs. If .one evaluates the production only at the half of this sum because of the
scarcity of the labour and other elements necessary
for the production and if one understands well that
the enemy has stolen half of our real production the
enemy has robbed us of material worth i.5oo millions of francs.
The other damages can be estimated at 3.000 i. e. the total damages would amount
to more than o.ooo millions of francs.
5.
II
work
years.
The
of reconstitution,
first
may
*\
*
'
sary credit, the necessary means of transport, without able administrative and technical men, one
would never be able to execute the above mentioned
work even if one obtains the indemnities which one
is
country.
If we consider
all
damages
inflicted to the
are necessary for bringing their economical standard to the height of the least prosperous
tries
which
Ill
When
their national
all
the other
of the
will
war debts
will
amount
Allies.
to nearly 4 milliards
Our
and the
>\ar situation,
ho
sive in their
The
men
credit, transports,
works
(roads,
railways,
port*,
In order to prevent
on the part
all
of our enemies
possible exploitation
to base
we would have
lines
Italy,
in
ID
>\ ill
hy giving
its
seal to all
The Mittel-Europa.
In order to vanquish Germany on the battle-fields
one must prolong the war till the Central Empires
Once Germany
are quite exhausted economically.
beaten we must find in the new frontiers of future
Europe
Allies
war were
indifferent to
all
those
who
before the
all
The
situation created
after
many
1870
and
status
re-establish
again.
If
this foolish
idea
to
re-
117
a splendid confirmation of the German victory. The
States which, like the Germans, have saved their
isolated
surrounded by
still
W lien we
ation.
after the
of our allies,
the Balkans
5oo.ooo sq. km.
The population would only amount to 26.000.000
without ain mutual intensive relations, instead of
38.ooo.ooo belonging to a compact block. The
sq.
without
am
union on
a surface of
to
The wealth
The development
only 8 instead of 16 milliards.
would be twice or thrice smaller in these artificial
limits than it would be in its natural limits.
Mittel-Europa existed before the war, in view of
the Balkanic States and of Russia which were more
or less tributary to Germany and to her ally AustriaHungary. All these countries, excepting Greece,
could communicate with our Allies only through
Central Europe.
and
directly
credit,
italists,
nical
men.
All these
means
of exploitation of the
Balkanic countries kept back and delayed the development of all these little States and made illusory
every trial to transform their ra\\ products as they
war more
in
become prosperous,
and
independent
be
able
slavia,
will
German
race in
Empires
has
120
The Commercial
Routes of the Balkans.
T&e
Commercial
Routes
of
me
Balkans.
German
of
German
line.
1o
Ibis
line b>
Greece was not connected with the line ParisConstantinople nor with the line Belgrade-Salonicu.
Sea).
development of the
independent Balkanic
Roumania and Greece,
had augmented the local lines but never succeeded
terior
countries
Serbia, Bulgaria,
which had
to
augment
Hungary prevented
works
1907, was
till
And
Austria-
union of
this port
and
ex-
Roummeans
the
port of
steam-ship
Consequently
120
we have
Balkan
traffic,
several thousands
routes,
kanic commerce were gravitating were concentrated in the towns of Central Europe. The Balkanic
countries and Russia were gravitating towards Aus-
tria-Hungary and Germany that is towards MittelEuropa, which existed long before one spoke of
her.
II
If
126
all
which
lines
have to join
Roman
roads
show
us the
communication.
line
Danube
Plains.
This
is
one can
Roman
grade.
The
markets of
tinental route of Constantinople, ha> already foreseen Belgrade's dominant position as knot of rail-
way
lines.
Belgrade,
All* -sio
hy Monastii-
London-Paris-Milan-Lahaich, arri\e in
houi-s instead of f\'\ hours and a ha!!'
.'^)
Belgrade
which i< the actual time for the journex from
Lon<lon to Belgrade via Paris and \ienne.
in
\\onH
be
and afterwards by
Suez.
Many
of the routes
we
12 9
For the
as those which have to he constructed.
Indian mail, for the direct communication of Italy
with the Balkanic States, the utilisation of the Mediterranean routes, the benefit of the producers and
of goods, one must make every effort in
order to annihilate these ancient methods.
Having these now communications the products
and the men will choose the best and shortest markets and routes to arrive at their aims.
The ques-
consumers
the obstacles
made by
HI
still
line evsi
have to
in
jc
;>!
least, partially,
le
fragments)
dishte-Sarayevo and
secondly, Oujitze-Var-
thirdly, Nish-Prokouplye-Mit-
1.1O
rovitza-Prizrend-Alessio
fourthly,
Antivari),
(or
Skoplye by Ohrid)
of Greece sixthly, Sarayevo-Spalato and Sarayevo;
The ports
of the Adriatic of
which we have
al-
The economical
situation
of Serbia
at the eve of I9I2-I9I3.
33
me
eve
of
\m-\m
agriculture.
The culture
of the land
is still
in the extensive
tions for
products.
The
total
amount of
family
Bank (Ooprava
The State
Hypothecarj
Fondova) and private credit institutions back the
peasants mostly for the purchase of land whose
price has augmented to 5 or 6.000 francs a hectare
more on psychological then on economical reasons.
Of
till
municipalities.
According to the statistics of 1906 the arable iand
is divided up in the following way
:
cereals.
Vegetables
Vineyards
Fruit-gardens
Meadows
Pastures
Woods
Forests
Uncultivated land
Various other land.
Total
1.020.000 hectares
20.800
33.ooo
i36.ooo
322.000
90.700
i36.4oo
166.600
oo.ooo
60.000
2.o45.ooo
35
etables
ares.
on American roots.
Amongst fruit exportations the plums take the
in 1908 plum gardens covered a space of
lead
1/17.000 hectares and the export of the same year
amounted to ^90.000 Cwts. of plums corresponding
cultivated
Cwts.
of
According to the
cattle in Serbia
was
Oxen
968.000 heads
908.000
8.160.000
5 1 o.ooo
Pigs
Sheep
Goats
Total
5.
we
obtained every year a better quality of cattle, which represents a higher value.
In 1906 the exportation of cattle reached the
figure of 3o.ooo.ooo francs of which 12.000.000
for oxen,
i5.ooo.ooo for pigs, i.ooo.ooo for
for poultry.
The export of
and
2.000.000
sheep,
meat and its products reached a value of 7.000.000
foreign breeds
francs.
i3b
The
The
are
forests
divided
follows
as
II
We
This
1909).
amount
number
of mills completed by
the
consump-
We
is
still
The
is
production
nearly
small quantities are exported into Bulgaria and Turkey.
We have further two sugar-factories producing
1 20.000 Cwt. a year.
The capital engaged in those
two factories is of 12.000.000 francs. The other
two hemp-factories producing
manufacturies are
12.000 Cwt. a year, which are entirely exported
country
two
cloth-factories,
two
founcleries,
two shoe-
There are
manufacturies, two glass-factories.
besides in Serbia various other small factories whose
capitals vary
millions
augmented
38
to 20.000.000 in i<)iy.
Coal,
industry.
Most of the metals extracted
of
Serbia, especially copper, are exported to the exAs to the coal there is plenty of it, but the
terior.
Ill
our fatherland.
We
and exportation
Products of agriculture
Live cattle
and
animal
.
........
......
products
Forest products
Products of agricultural industries
.........
Alimentary products
43
6(1.202
10.44.-i
38.130
2.2(52
8-">8
-IS.
-1
4. 37'i
544
....
To be carried forward
(i.936
718
39.705
104.494
Carried forward
Articles
Wax
39. "Oo
lOi.iDI
879
IS
7.o"3
288
31.320
2.U3
4.140
43o
37
\vith
prepared
grease, oil or
ves
Skins, raw and
tured, furriery
manufac-
79
materials
Brush-making,
and
sieves
brooms
84
07
2.210
302
GO
9
19
cement
Baked-clay-works
Glass and glass-works.
Precious metals and jewel-
31?)
43
1.303
109
I.o2()
843
"
lery
401
9. Ho"
11.801
28
11).
Works
and science
Watches weapons and toys
of art
Total.
489
338
2o.42i
119.910
140
The
and up
to the
catastrophe of 1915.
in
finish-
army of 200.000
combatants in the proper sense of the word, and
with 35o.ooo non-combatants (auxiliary services
etc.)- So 600.000 men had been mobilised which
caused a double prejudice to the economy of the
country.
The expenses
combatants
time of peace.
expenses of
to
what
strictly financial
we
meiitionned
36o.ooo.ooo francs.
The second prejudice caused to the economy of
the country w as the loss of national handicraft mobilised by the war.
By the mobilisation of 600.000
r
men belonging
dustry, to
to agriculture, to
workmanship,
commerce,
the production
to in-
of the
country had diminished by two fifths. The grossproduction of Serbia, at the eve of the wars of
1912-1913, has been estimated to about one milliard francs
first
wars
it
has.
With
this pro-
at the front
and
the auxiliary services in the rear, which was success fully done with the loans and supplies from the
exterior,
which were
of loans immediately
\
partially liquidated
after the war.
by means
stands
war,
The revenues
of the railways
and other economical enterprises cease in the same
way. Only one half of our budget, which was of
The
deficit in
the
economy
of the country
was
comes
to a
war
country back to
its
was
The
loss
was consequently
of
5oo
million of francs.
The same
deficit
consequence of
for our restoration w as to enlarge our national territory and
to obtain an access to the Aegean or Adriatic seas
and consequently to free ourselves of an oppressing
atmosphere and of the pression of Austria-Hungary
which hindered the national life of Serbia.
the wars.
as a
onl\
iliarv services.
The
railway**,
the
exportatioris.
the harvests,
men
of the
new
M4
91 5.
national
francs.
products at very
high prices in the country and not abroad. Leaving
out the losses at the front, whose number was
ize
its
July
and
number
of
inhabitants through the epidemics which annihilated Soo.ooo lives. The stillness of the Serbian front
up
to the
victories of 191 4
and reigned
attacked
men and
Our
in the national
effort
had reached
its
sudden
Wars
of Serbia
I9I2-I9I3.
I.
of Serbia's
wars
I.
of 1912-13.
- - Serbia's surface
was of 48.ooo
population amounted to
before 1912
its
a hectare,
the hectare,
worth 700
to
146
ory whose
surface
estimated 600
is
the incomes as value of day work, capitals in agricultural instruments, in cattle and seeds, all this
representing a gross-income of !\ 20 million francs.
According to the above statement the gross -income of the arable land of both categories amounts
to 700 million francs a year.
II. -
its
of Serbia's economical
importance
is
the breeding
of cattle.
of
million yearly.
2.
a) Of 700.000 tax-payers in Serbia, the greater part who occupied themselves with the culture
of the soil and breeding, were small land-owners
.
counting
The income
to 3 individuals for
of
workmanship,
each
tax-payer,
children of less then eight years excepted, is of
1.800.000 workers. The gross-profit of land and
cattle
147
amounts
Taking
a worker.
is of Aoo francs for
These gross-revenues disappear or hide in the feed-
The arable
territories
and the
cattle represent a
The collaboration
whom we
a)
all
production was
realized
more thanks
to tboir
43
and
intellectual capacities
--
instalments.
francs.
3.
men
c)
are
In
ileged banks
annually.
The export
the import 80
M9
The gross-income
of
all
the
about 60 million
commerce and
of
rents, instalments
and
to oo million francs.
real-estate
One can
which are
of \n
according to
considered only comsee,
Ave shall
contem-
plate later.
4.
The value
of private real-estates.
amongst the
If
we
one of the
real -estates.
The bulk
of
is
all
of AOO.OOO
inhabitants,
whose
possesses
population
about 80.000 homes. Taking as an average prict<
of each apartment the sum of 3.ooo francs, their
The surface
total value is of 2/40 million francs.
affected to these real-estates with their court-yaras,
covers 10.000 to 20.000 hectares.
Estimating a
hectare 5.ooo francs, the value of grounds occupied
In buildings in the towns represents a value of 100
millions francs. Taking movable property at i.ooo
home, the
total value of
The value
francs
IDI
The
million francs.
--Of
48.ooo square kilometers, Serbia's surface, there remain 2.800.000 hectares of territory.
i.Boo.ooo hectares of this territory are occupied by
5.
The
railroads,
with
all
their constructions,
represent a value of 200 million francs. The established roads of a length of 10.000 kilometers are
all its
As we
represents
their
annual
7.
collective property of the urban and rural municipalities and their revenues serve to cover the budgets
102
institutions of the
war-materials, food-reserves, strategical roads, fortresses, etc... reached at the eve of the catastrophe
of 1916 the figure of 600 million francs.
in
Arable land
Workmanships
....
in
Income
millions
10
250
Industry
Commerce and
credit
establishments
Furniture and real estate
.
r>
Gross
2.000
400
2 Cattle
3
4
5
Capital
millions
2.">0
100
2.000
400
208
500
50
100
JO
400
(JO
(1)
100
navigation,
roads
9 Fallow land, pastures
10 State and economic
.
institutions
means
of national defence.
If
we add
above
53
capital,
is
of
The administration of the State and of the autonomic municipalities cost i5o million francs,
which means 10 o/o of the total production of the
The exportation of the country, whose
country.
is
i3o millions, was also 10 o/o of the
of
figure
international exchange was of
g-ross-productiori
i3o million francs of exportation and 80 million^
of importation, which is equal to 210 millions, and
means 1/6 of the total production.
Admitting that Serbia's handicraft was of
;
all
the land.
The
capital
is
of 2.3oo francs
head,
which
As our system of repartition of taxes was absolutely irrational and irregular the charges were supported mostly by the liberal professions and much
less l)v the rural classes.
II
The
surface of the
of 3. 200
square kilometers with i.Soo.ooo inhabitants. Thopopulation of the towns compared to the one of tho
-country was relatively stronger than in old Serhia.
Arable lands belonged to spahis (great proprietors)
it was only in the
arid to the inhabitants of towns
;
mountaiious
voted
districts,
where the
population
de-
was of 5o
Taking
to 60 o/o.
into consideration
the institutions
left
be
in the new-
millions of francs.
Until the eve of the wars of 19 12-1 91 3, Serbia' *
debts amounted to about 700 million francs. As a
1
to a distant 'future.
Ill
56
Nevertheless this
major part
in
to
that
we have
still
lost
60 million francs.
The repurchase of the above mentionned production can be effectuated with 120 millions of AustroBulgarian paper money. Stating that the purchases.
-a
The Economic
at the
58
situation of Serbia
Damages caused
bombardment
of the
capital
urban centres.
Stating- that the total \alue of the
towns
in the
war-zone was of 700 to 800 million irancs, the damages caused by the bombardments reach until our
retreat a sum of 4oo millions of francs at least.
During- the retreat
all
w ere
r
be valued to at least 10 million francs. Our navigation on the Sava and on the Danube was completely destroyed already at the beginning of the
Avar operations.
Its
value
was
of 6 million francs.
Clothing and supply-deposits, all the war materials bought in the exterior or made in the country
fell into the hands of the invader
a value of 700
:
million francs.
The
losses in
weapons and
other-
IOC)
it
Serbia in
v\e
can
November
191/4, in
deficit
of
the
of
-.
are
the factories of he
completely annihilated, so
He...
matches.
the manufacMonopoly (tobacco,
I
160
Stating
that
movables,
those
of
the
capital
Danube
and
towns
on
the
the
in
the
Sava,
excepted,
the Driiia, and the instruments of workmanship
worth
we
deterioration
or
destruction
II
The
refuges
army
and
population,
number
160.000 deads.
Deported population or the one
used on roads or in the war zone is of 600.000
:
161
to
according*
Austro-Hungariaii
there
statistics,
of 6
o/o
interest the
will
for
all
ii
!!*ds
If
of francs.
the formula
without indemnities
were to-be
Serbia, humil-
iated, unhappy and poor, leaving out moral consequences, would fall back on her devastated, delivered and dishonoured territory with a deficit of
This would equal
/I. ooo i.o o.ooo millions of francs.
a reduction to a half of the economical value she
were to be
a period
left
of thirty years to
162
attain the
To
a
new
better conditions
of francs.
If
amount
at 3
o/o
and amortisation, she would need 260 millions a year for the payment of debts only. Yet our
budget was, at the eve of the war, of 280 million
interest
One can
francs.
invalid pensions. If we further take into consideration the high value money will have after the war
when
we
is
63
not
money nor
quantity
Note
to Serbia's wealth,
al
industry
cattle,
offered.
tain for a
The dearness
Principle of indemnity.
i6 7
Principle
of
indemnity.
(WAR EXPENSES)
Gentlemen,
The discussions
indemnity.
The theory of the Americans in the question of
reparations is that the damages are not more than
the losses sustained in consequence of illegal acts
committed by the enemy, while the English,
together with nearly all the other representatives,
consider that our right to reparation is the consequence of our enemies' acts of aggression, illegal
and
illicit
acts,
168
sibility
11
if not identical
establish in the world a new order
which
before the
similar
to
the
one
existed
very
war.
It is
moral.
The
first
are reparable,
material and
either
ory
- -
all
we
on the
principles of justice
damages of the first categ-
losses.
If
we were
not
we
who have
vanquished, and
to whom Germany has already caused so many
damages and losses, and save Germany and her
allies who, by their barbarous and savage acts, have
indeed not deserved to be treated with more consideration. Having neither the wish nor the will to
search for the means to apply to our enemies, means
which would be based on reciprocity, and wishing
to avoid anything Avhich could give a semblance
of a punishment in our solutions, I will try to find
damages
to those people
the solutions justified from the economic and financial point of view, solutions which could give us an
answer to the question concerning an integral restoration,
that this
German adherence to
November 1918 is only
place
etc...,
if
we want
to solve the
of reparations.
prohlem
Concerning the principal question,
((
What
is difficult
Long
practice.
possible, while long discussions are necessar\ conSo that after all, the
cerning their realisation.
it
is
possible to accom-
plish...
and
clusion of
war expenses
Mr. \\ilson
's
is
restoration of the
lishment of
ical, to
damaged
a state of
of this problem
is
The only
solution
the ex-
all
It
is
in-
idea
ity,
to a reparation implying all war expenses, would be an unstable basis which could lead us to
is,
war even
many
if
:)
it is
remember
all
German
their declaration of
acts
wilfullv
committed,
of enriching
- In the war.
themselves -- directly* or indirectly the proceedings applied by the Germans and which
aimed at completely destroying the vitality of their
competitors in the future. The laws do not create
the events they do riot precede them
they follow
them. Had one been able to imagine and to believe,
relying on the technique, the sciences and the ex:
periences of
many
centuries of civilisation
that the
way and
is
now
to find an equitable
who
tranquillity.
IV
170
exterior loans
r
men
(800.000 com-
damages
at
Conference 26
of
the Peace
May
1919.
Speed! made
in tiie
fig
Plr.
Costa sioganovitcii
May
1Q19.
Kingdom
and Slovenes.
war Serbia and Belgium have been
During the
known
allied
of the
war our
Allies
and
i/a milliards
which represent
178
as a total a value of about 10 milliards.
Immediatly
1918 and
Germany nor
in the
was
in the
same
situation as Serbia.
mean
Perhaps
we shall obtain more of Hungary and Bulgaria.
But we do not know this. It would be right to
should this
mean
it is
intended to
that
179
to
invitation, a
memorandum
which we hand
enemy
Notwithstandyou
our
to
submit
observations
of
us
ask
to-day
ing you
the
in
as
far
as
concern
they
treaty with Auso:i!y
tria, a treaty which has been communicated to us
two hours ago. \\e are not in a position to dhide
our claims and I take the liberty to submit them lo
you pointing out that they concern the three enemy-
Stales
States in
\\ e
to
to-day.
common.
demand
to you.
2)
in
the
sub-commission
for
monetary
(juestions.
4)
fleet
Kingdom
which
the property of
of the Serbians, (iroatis
i8o
ians
common
pool
but should be
my
her to deliver
all
her vessels
nage.
the enemy having destroyed our entire fluvial fleet,
Austria is treated sparingly without any consideration for our most urgent necessities, although
80 o/o of her
fleet
are
for
until
on
their teritories.
Our Allies say that Austria is economically weakened but one must take into consideration the state
in which our new provinces are. They have to take
over about 3 milliards of the Austro-Hungarian prewar debt. By the force of circumstances they have
to
about 10 milliards of the Austroaccept
r
war
memor-
invalids of these
about 6 milliards.
to-day we
submit also a project of the text for the treaties
we hand you
them
We
request
To
the
Commission
ration
of
for repa-
damages
at
the
To
die
85
me
of
damages
Claims of the Kingdom of the Serbians, Croatfans and Slovenes in connection with the
Treaties of Peace to be concliid ed with Austria
Hungary and Bulgaria.
>
our enemies
writing.
Recoveries.
The
although
cattle in
it is
towards Germany has not been mentioned, by omisThe same has hapsion, in the Armistice treaty.
pened in the Armistice treaties concluded with Germany 's allies. As a consequence of the steps we
have undertaken at the Supreme Command of the
Allied Armies we were informed that our just
claims would be included in the Peace treaties. Yet,
notwithstanding these assurances, we have remained without any right towards Germany. We consider that our right of recuperation on all objects
which have been taken away from Serbia and which
can be identified is based on the principles of justice
and equity as well as on positive Law, and that it
must be secured to us in the Peace treaties to be
concluded with Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria.
6) Restitutions.
1 1
th
November 1918,
series of objects
that Treaty.
common
Annex
Austria
Milch cows
2.000
Bulls
50
Young cows
Young oxen
i.OOO
Draught oxen
Mares
Draught horses
i.OOO
>
...
Ewes
Automobiles
Lorries
....
000
5.000
10.000
1
.000
50
50
300
50
250
88
20.000 sets
1
Annex
Hungary
Milch cows
JO.
Bulls
Young cows
Young oxen
Draught oxen
Mares
Draught horses.
Ewes and sheep
'.
Ewes
....
....
000
200
20.000
20.000
50.000
23.000
40.000
100.000
2.000
50
300
50
250
Lorries
cupboard and
dresser).
Ploughs
Oxen-carts
Carts and carriages
....
big
dredging
machines.
eleva-
barges for
swimming
tors
24
towing
boats.
wooden
15.000
25.000
3.000
destroyed
houses
'
thetransportofsand
and wood.
\vithoutthismateriaL
89
Annex
Bulgaria
......
Milch cows.
Bulls.
3.000
(iO
Young cows
40.000
50.000
100.000
20.000
Young oxen
Draught oxen
Ewes
Mares
JO. 000
Draught horses
Sheep for breeding purposes
cupboard and
Ploughs
1
carts
wooden
consisting of
Oxen
20.000
500
300.000
10.000
dresser).
35.000
35.000
7.000
.......
....
I!
We
ments with
his paper
to be the legal
money on
the base of
war
its
nominal
this value
was
KjO
Exchanges.
ever
it
To-day
this
The enemy
it had not been imposed upon them.
could never have been considered as having paid.
This paper money is nothing else bnt requisition
receipts which the enemy has to pay just as well as
any other promise of payment.
The Serbian nation possesses actually about
liard
mil-
of
money
If
the
demands
Hungary
made
jointly
191
--
Id
ReiinburseTnent of
tlie
\\
~ur
expenses
also obliged to
reimburse jointly Serbia's expenses of war for the
Austria,
following reasons
The \\ar with Austria and
:
accept
them
way
page 6).
Bulgaria on her side,
attacked Serbia with premeditation,
XXith a peren
scene
fidious -iiiise
(see the same Report, page
Responsibilities,
10).
It
is
war
192
economic position.
Since the end of 1916 Serbia has been deprived
of all her fiscal revenues, which had passed into
the hands of her enemies. On the other hand, the
expenses of her administration had not diminished
ional
was obliged
as she
who
had
left
o/o of her expenses with loans conThese loans were also spent, for the
The national economy has
greater part, abroad.
not profited by them. According to the words of
Monsieur Klotz, the French Minister of Finance, 5o
milliards of the French war expenses have found
their w a\ into the pockets of French tax-payers.
Serbia on the countrary, is the only country in
to cover 90
tracted abroad.
occupation
him
of his
Contrary to the law of the moratorium, the Austrians have obliged our merchants to
immediately pay all their debts in Austria and Germany thus, the merchant was deprived of his ready
money like the peasant of his cattle. Lastly, even
during the retreat, the Germans have destroyed
our railways and left Serbia without any means of
communications. To-day, Serbia is an economical
organism without any circulation, and it is no
wonder that her economical renewal is so very hard.
less brutality.
i3
life
in Serbia.
They concern the reparations which must be realized immediately after the signing of the peace, independently of the Commission for Reparations it is
only a payment on account, without w hich Serbia
would fall in a state of misery and debility without
example in history. Serbia will be able to await
;
honoured.
IV
Hungarian Monarchy.
The Austro-Hungarian bank-notes which had
remained on these territories amount to 8 milliards
of Kronen. These bank-notes represent a State debt
of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy, which our new
Kingdom will have to take over if an indemnity is
not guaranteed to us.
Besides, these territories are bound to take over
a part of the Austro-Hungarian pre-war debt, whose
These
territories
up
charge of
i
!\
milliards of
Kronen and
8 milliards of francs.
Therefore
we
That these
territories
That the pre-war debts of the Austro-HungMonarchy be divided among her ancient provinces, according to the key of investments. It is not
just that the repartition of this debt be made withII.
arian
the property of the new States without any indemnity, as these domains have to serve as guarantee
sustained.
citizens of our
into
the
thro\vn
common
be
not
pool
Kingdom
but be restored to their owners. The reason of this
claim lies in the fact that all Dalmatia draws her
V.
new
liber-
ated from every participation, even in the pre- waxdebt of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy, and from
- -
for the
unde r
have
remained under the Sultan's sovereignty up to the
annexation of 1908, proclaimed by Austria-Hungary
in open violation of an international act.
The
events which followed this attempt against the
authority of international treaties, and which very
nearly provoked a general conflagration, are so
recent that it is not necessary to recall them. Since
the new state of affairs was created in the occupied
provinces, their juridical condition, from the point
of view of internal Public Law, has not changed.
'97
important matters continued to be voted by legislatures, foreign to the country, without those concerning
whom
this legislation
From
had,
provinces
budget, maintained
by the
local
budget.
Without insisting on the well-known patrioticattitude of the population living in these two provinces, which have been treated during the war as
keeping
strictly to
we
will
with Hungary
The provinces
pectively the
all
198
name
with Germany).
eable goods
which are
many.).
In case the obligation to contribute to the
payment of the reparations of the war damages, for
III.
Germany.
201
Observations on
me
Germany
all
quesincurred
damages
This commission has received the task to
by war.
to fix the
as
have to pay.
In one word the proposed commission whose
competence is illimited has not been subjected to a
discussion in the commission for reparation and
sub-commission, whose decisions are executory has been created by the Council of War.
It has been proposed that all great Powers be
Great Britain,
represented in this commission
France, Italy and the United States of the small
Powers only Belgium. These five members have
the right to vote and without their unanimous
consent no decisions whatever can be brought on
capital questions, and no other question can be
decided without a resolution of the majority.
this
c<)2
We
demand
Because Serbia was attacked by AustriaHungary in the very beginning and remained at wai
i).
to the
end
Because her territory was completely occupied by the Germans and their Allies from October
1916 to October 1918 and exploited, if riot more, at
- -
2).
much
least as
3).
as
Belgium
Because
Serbia
entered
the
war with
<;hevism.
the
mid
enemy
mentioned
w hich
r
rations.
You have
20d
as a hase.
Serbia reserves her right to put forward
her opinion in order to secure those rights which
are not sufficiently guaranteed in the treaty to he
concluded with Germany, always under the condition that she has the right to he indemnified, like
the other States, in the first place, out of Germain 's
debts.
on
She
Thanks
her by her allies, Amerher.
allies.
amount
amount
annuities
will
Germany
all
difficult.
204
We also think that the treaty of Peace -with Germany ought to comprise stipulations concerning resin natura
that Germany will he bound
titutions
to restitute to Serbia all articles which she has taken
away from our country without awaiting the deci,
permanent commission on
condition having been foreseen
sions of the
this
this question
for
certain
cattle,
agricultural
Commission and to the second subcommission for the reparation of damages. In consequence of this we have lost the harvest of 1919,
to the Versailles
and,
if
In concluding
sailles
we beg
to
demand
on the
means
the country
our Government kiiow s best what
articles are needed most inasmuch as among these
r
means
the
away.
in
natura
specially
the
Commission
for
Reparation of Damages.
Extract
Submitted to
me
o!
Reports
The extract which accompanies our claims annexed to this letter - - claims I have the honour to
submit to you in view of the drafting of the Peace
Treaties with Hungary arid Bulgaria - - will easily
the
them
manent Commission
great part of
to declare that
will be repaired
of Reparation, we
able
if
stipulate an
difficulties
show you
the considerable
which
consequence
decisions brought by the Conference, which concern the solution of certain questions interesting
our liberated regions; viz: the question of the War
208
2O9
Belgium.
The Peace-Treaty with Germany contains in
g* -a-
towards the
allied
a parti-
work
will be ef-
commission
after
The questions
of priority, repartition
etc., are also transmitted to the said commission.
The Treaty of Peace with Austria-Hungary and
other
allies,
of peace with
general cases
Germany
tries of
tries of
our Kingdom.
In the armistice of 1918, with Germany, AustriaHungary and Bulgaria the recovery for Serbia has
On
our request
the
second
we
memorandum,
submitted
list
of
all
the
stolen
things,
life.
ticles of
Belgium are stated in special enclosures, as a complement of the deliveries made by Germany in the
period between the armistice and the signature of
Peace.
also losses
WAR DAMAGES
of the
Kingdom
and Slovenes.
I.
to
Serbia
2l5
1.
in Serbia
IN
ANNUITIES
MILLION FRANCS
MINIMUM
SERBIA
MAXIMUM
b]
c]
II.
68,4
85,
1 36,8
170
228
456,25
38 1, 4
MONTENEGRO
Total
4
8
12
...
12
18
at
Total
The
5%
the rate of
millions
and,
amounts
to,
minimum,
216
.OVKMA
*-*
^
?
5^
s/-
""*
**,*
VOr
^ 3
s
s
<y
*-
3
=:
^ 5
"^
S
^
^
x,
-^
*.
<3
to
^:
^-^
i
5
Q O
<:
~^
in the countries
COUNTRIES
i)
Conclusion.
221
COINOUUSIOIN
war amounted
appears that
apart from debts contracted during the w ar and the
securities of the annuities and of the pensions to
the invalids, the damages directly caused by the
war amount to about 7 milliards. The wealth of
the liberated countries amounted to about 20 milliards before the war, it has been diminished by
6 milliards through the damages of war. It follows
that the total national wealth of our State is, after
the war, not 3i to 35 milliards but between
the
to
1 1
milliards
it
8 and 22 milliards.
It is
that war-debts have to be added, the latter amounting to 3 milliards for Serbia and to the same amount
for the liberated regions in as far as they are heirs
of the pre-war debts of the Austro-IIungarian
monarchy.
The annuities
of pensions
and upkeep
itself,
that there
would
we do
not obtain
sufficient indemnities, only the elements which we
hold from nature itself.
As to the population it has been decimated by
the scourge of the war epidemics, death, exhausThe deficit represents about 3 million
tion, etc.
as national wealth,
if
lives.
To
first
be achieved when the balance between our production and our international exchange will be restored
The
we
shall
damages and reparations in rather a hypothetway, during the war itself, according to the
figures which were at my disposal.
To-day, at the
the
ical
extracts
of
the
22r>
in
some
some damages
hut, on the other
damages which
in
a complete reparation.
One
cannot object anything against the lack of reparation if it is contrary to nature itself, but one can
stand up against measures depending of human
decisions
if.
22 4
of Liquidation
not
last long.
territorial
although one
22i)
if
we
prejudice,
able in certain States are
compensated by the
losses
or
other States, belligerent
neutral. The problem of the war damages is therefore reduced to quite another question if it is exam-
and the
profit
of
ined as a whole or
especially
if
if
is
it,
II
We
will
commence by giving
common example
in order to
which have
to be
damages.
Which was the state of a country at the beginning of the war ? One must first of all consider the
wealth of the country as it is determined by moveable capitals then the wealth represented by the
;
number
of the
men and
the wealth represented by their work, by the production, i. e. by the relations between these and the
capital as well as the technical and economical
tools of the country perhaps also the work determ;
226
Yet, the work produced by a given
on the capitals which this society
depending
society
which human work is leaning,
and
on
of
disposes
it is better to consider the work from two points
of view one of which would represent the potential
energy and the other the cinetic energy of the resIn this way wealth as well as
pective society.
would
be the determined functions
only
damages
of the work and of capitals.
In order to better examine the problem of dam-
disappeared.
us to express
ities
is
others.
The conditions from which each of these quantdepend may be numerous one could there-
ities
knowing
of
the
valuations
and,
observe them.
The production
sumption augmented.
is
In the worst
case
if
one
damages.
The
The
difficulties of
reflected in the
which provoke
rise
by
fiscal
war
ili
to
do
Is this really a
debt
228
the
war wliich
war debt
of only 68 milliards.
one considers that this debt has been contracted
a real
If
w ould
maintenance of the
is
reserve
of
her population.
Germany has not been invaded and her capitals
may be considered intact. The percentage of the
births after the war will be diminished and this will
he a new loss to be added to the loss of manual
If Germany had riot been defeated and
labour.
obliged to pay indemnities she would have of all
the belligerant States the best situation for a rapid
rising which would have allowed her to reconquer
quickly the world's market in the atmosphere of
the frantic demand which will follow the war.
fn face of
Germany we
which
The example
of Serbia
try
is
a typical one.
first,
This coun-
Serbia's economical
life
aged
all
of the war.
this
at first sight.
Our
foreign
230
IV
that
all
war amounts
to io-i5 millions.
2, Boo a
head
or,
20
If
Taking into consideration the probable disappearance of the different war budgets as well as the
reparation which the enemy will have to pay it will
not be difficult to cover these annuities of 12 milliards.
If
Allies
war
1/2 or 7 milliards.
Bulgaria, Turkey,
Hungary
charge of 10 1/2 to
milliards.
Germany
202
--
There
is
the
of
life
as well as
duction.
ical state.
nomical situation
may be
it
will
always tend to
which the
233
results of all causes creating disorder will be equal
and where the effects of the destructive
to zero
We
which
the
economical
The
elements.
an administrative measure
which
facilitates
the
liquidation of different encumbrances and accelerates the return of the prices and of the social situation to the normal base.
As soon as this will have
been done, as soon as the exchanges and the proportion of wealth and production will have returned
to their primitive state, the financial transactions
will again regulate the question of exchange and
the international money relations.
as a
ages divided among a very great number of indivand requires less time for the reparations
than if it were considered in its details. I had here
the intention only to show the principal lines of
iduals
this
in
means
of reparation.
The actual moments and
the future are the tw o principal elements which
the
must be considered
in
view of
rompletp liquida-
tion.
B1BLIOTEK A
'
COINTBINTS.
Introduction
...................
...........
........
Serbia's commercial movement ...........
9
i3
3i
.....
in
5()
view of
70
the
...........
..................
war
....................
........
.........
Serbia
and
Balkanic
the
countries
after
...............
88
96
98
101
106
no
..............
116
.......
121
The
82
the
European war
Economical union between the Balkanic countries
Period of restitution and regeneration of the
Balkanic States damaged by the war .....
The Mittel-Europa
74
.............
catastrophe.
war and
Damages caused
the occupation
directly
........
140
145
by the
:
08
Principle of indemnity
made by
Speech
Mr
Commission for
Costa
Sloyanovitch
in
i65
the
reparation of damages at
..
i83
199
2o5
Reparation of damages
Indemnities due to Serbia, Montenegro
War damages of the S. C. S. Kingdom
176
etc.,
209
210
Conclusion
219
The
224
movimcnto commercial
".
La
dal Corriere
della
Economico
>>,
Serbia, 1918.
Estratto
Roma.
Bologne, 1918.
La qitestione maccdone.
della
Estratto
Nuova
Antolog-ia
>>,
1916.
La
Serbie economiqnc a
la veille
de la catastrophe, Paris,
1919.
La
Serbie
et la liquidation
de
la
a Historical
Rome.
de Geneve, 1919.
Deux discours
Dommages,
Memoires sur
les
la
Commission des
Reparations
rAllemagne
des
et
I'Autriche.
(i
AMBER,
7,
h<>JL\, Belgrade.
rue
obtained
Dan ton,
Paris,
in
the Librairie
and
at
CiEZA
iiciiiiiiii
I
nun
E R E
".KAPHIOL'E
.M
15,
}'
AI
Rue Saint-Gilles, 15
PARIS
i : 1 1
in ii
(.>'
1 1 1
arr)
in ig
is
Nu PHUNh
K ENEWALS
STA<