Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi: 10.1111/jpr.12126
Abstract: This study analyzed the structural relationships between school-related psychological variables (teacher support, learning ow, friendship) and the happiness of
Korean youths, and compared structural equation models for middle and high
schools. Questionnaire data were collected from students in middle and high schools
in 10 cities and provinces of Korea. The nal data set from 870 students was analyzed with Amos 20.0. Goodness of t indices for the hypothetical model were good,
and all paths were signicant. That is, a model incorporating indirect and direct
impact of school-related psychological environment variables, such as teacher support, learning ow, and friendship, on the happiness of Korean youths is valid. Second, structural equation models for middle and high schools demonstrated
signicant differences. Therefore, different types of assistance are needed to
increase the happiness of students in middle schools and high schools.
Key words: Korean youths, school-related psychological environmental characteristics, happiness, structural equation model.
*Correspondence concerning this article should be sent to: Ji-Hye Lee, Department of Education, Seowon
University, Cheongju-si, Chungcheongbuk-do 28674, Korea. (E-mail: wisdom56@hanmail.net)
2016 Japanese Psychological Association. Published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.
311
312
J.-H. Lee
Methods
Participants
This research was conducted on students of
20 middle and high schools in 10 different
areas in Korea. The surveys were distributed
via mail, and 870 out of 1,000 survey responses
were used for the nal analysis, after excluding
130 incomplete surveys. Of the 870 respondents, 421 (47.0%) were middle-school students, while 449 (53.0%) were high-school
students.
Assessments
Teacher support. To measure the various
types of teacher support that students receive,
we used the Social Support Appraisal Scale
(Dubow & Ullman, 1989). This scale is composed of 15 items in four subdomains of support: Emotional, Informational, Evaluational,
and Materialistic. Each question is answered
using a 5-point Likert scale, whereby higher
scores denote greater teacher support. Cronbachs in this study was .92 for the entire
313
314
J.-H. Lee
Inf.
Eva.
Mat.
Cog.
Aff.
Rec.
Con.
Dis.
Hel.
Fel.
Com.
Conf.
Cont.
Pos.
Emo.
Inf.
Eva.
Mat.
Cog.
Aff.
Rec.
Con.
Dis.
Hel.
.936**
.898**
.904**
.202**
.337**
.147**
.060**
.043**
.119**
.109**
.108**
.466**
.465**
.455**
.908**
.899**
.187**
.325**
.149**
.100**
.106**
.171**
.181**
.188**
.441**
.445**
.443**
.867**
.208**
.316**
.100**
.058**
.012**
.071**
.113**
.079**
.443**
.431**
.486**
.146**
.287**
.173**
.062**
.106**
.132**
.132**
.119**
.395**
.392**
.401**
.721**
.028**
.151**
.171**
.203**
.028
.239**
.215**
.233**
.254**
.103**
.161**
.181**
.233**
.032
.239**
.326**
.388**
.350**
.509**
.486**
.466**
.382**
.430**
.109**
.110*
.121**
.537**
.509**
.257**
.576**
.002**
.064**
.055**
.828**
.318**
.823**
.192**
.235**
.230**
.332**
.807**
.280**
.326**
.321**
Fel.
.342**
.091** .273**
.051** .293** .917**
.050** .290** .910 .897**
Note. Emo. = emotional support; Inf. = informational support; Eva. = evaluational support; Mat. = material
support; Cog. = cognitive ow; Aff. = affective ow; Rec. = recognition and interest; Con. = conict resolution; Dis. = conicts and mistrust; Hel. = help and guidance; Fel. = relationships and entertainment; Com. =
intimate/personal communication; Conf. = condence; Cont. = self-control; Pos. = positive attitude.
*p < .05, **p < .01.
Results
Correlations Among Variables
Table 1 shows that most variables were signicantly related to each other.
Research Model Verication
Table 2 conrms the model of the relationships among variables that affect the happiness
of Korean youths. All indices denoted good t
according to the criteria. Therefore, this early
hypothetical model was conrmed as the nal
model.
As shown in Figure 2, specic paths showed
that teacher support had a signicant impact
on learning ow ( = .337, p < .001), friendship ( = .135, p < .01), and happiness
( = .382, p < .001). Additionally, learning
ow and friendship both signicantly inuenced happiness ( = .217, p < .001 and
= .203, p < .001, respectively). Teacher support had the greatest direct impact on the happiness of the participants ( = .382, p < .001).
Learning ow and friendship acted as mediators between teacher support and happiness
(p < .05). Specically, the path teacher support
! learning ow ! happiness ( = .073) had a
315
Table 2 Goodness of t of the SEM and invariance conrmation of nal structural equation
model groups
2
Fit index
Criterion
>.05
SEM
Middle school
High school
Measurement invariance limit
435.015 (df
217.290 (df
220.665 (df
431.095 (df
=
=
=
=
86, p
86, p
86, p
86, p
< .001)
< .001)
< .001)
< .001)
RMSEA
GFI
TLI
CFI
NFI
.05.08
>.9
>.9
>.9
>.9
.073
.070
.069
.055
.920
.901
.910
.908
.932
.946
.950
.952
.933
.955
.959
.959
.945
.929
.935
.933
Note. RMSEA = root mean squared error of approximation; GFI = goodness of t index; TLI = TuckerLewis
index; CFI = comparative t index; NFI = normed t index.
Figure 2 Structural equation model. M = SEM of middle schools; H = SEM of high schools. **p < .01, ***p < .001.
Japanese Psychological Association 2016.
316
J.-H. Lee
Middle school
High school
Non-standardized
CR
Non-standardized
CR
.207
.097
.223
.208
.174
5.127***
2.034*
5.759***
3.644***
3.386***
.217
.089
.219
.191
.168
5.630***
1.942
5.770***
3.457***
3.377***
Table 4
317
d2 (dfd)
434.373 (170)
434.415 (171)
434.388 (171)
434.377 (171)
434.411 (171)
430.380 (171)
.042 (1)
.015 (1)
.004 (1)
.038 (1)
.007 (1)
<.001
<.001
<.001
<.001
<.001
Hierarchical model
Unconstrained model
Teacher support ! learning ow
Teacher support ! friendship
Teacher support ! happiness
Learning ow ! happiness
Friendship ! happiness
demonstrates that the structural equation models of middle school and high school were
different.
Discussion
This research considered the happiness of
Korean youths, and examined the relationship
between happiness and school-related psychological environment variables. We conrmed
the validity of a model predicting happiness
from measures of teacher support, with learning ow and friendship as mediators. In particular, we examined the differences between the
middle-school and high-school models. The
salient points based on the results are as
follows.
First, the goodness of t of the structural
equation model with teacher support as the
exogenous variable, learning ow and friendship as the endogenous variables, and happiness as the dependent variable, was
satisfactory. Such a result is consistent with
previous studies (Kim, 2005; Kim et al., 2009;
Lee & Lee, 2014; Oh, 2010; Yune et al., 2013),
particularly the nding that the happiness of
Korean youths was most inuenced by direct
teacher support. Learning ow and friendship
did not affect the happiness of youths to the
same extent as teacher support. Additionally,
learning ow as a mediator between teacher
support and happiness had a greater effect
than friendship as a mediator. This shows that
increasing learning ow based on teacher support was a more effective way to increase the
happiness of Korean youths than encouraging
friendship. However, since all direct and indirect paths were signicant, an integrated view
of fostering happiness is advised; instead of
focusing on individual variables, such as
teacher support, learning ow, and friendship,
separately, one should consider all schoolrelated psychological environmental characteristics from multiple perspectives.
Second, the structural equation models of
middle schools and high schools were analyzed
separately, and both provided satisfactory t.
That is, the nal middle-school and highschool models were both appropriate. However, the two models were signicantly different. The middle-school model exhibited
signicant parameters for all paths, whereas in
the high-school model, teacher support did not
inuence friendship. This nding is consistent
with studies of both Park et al. (2000), who
reported that teacher support affects friendship between high-school students less than
middle-school students, and An (2009), who
reported that high-school students display
more interest in learning and take more proactive approaches in relationships with teachers.
Such results are presumed to derive from the
college-admission-focused learning environment of high schools. Further, Korean highschool students are reported to have a more
positive development of subjective selfcondence regarding their future and sense of
purpose than middle-school students (Park,
1996); therefore, college-bound Korean highschool students can be understood as pursuing
their happiness by focusing their energy on
teacher support and learning ow to achieve
Japanese Psychological Association 2016.
318
J.-H. Lee
References
Ahn, D. H. (2008). The happiness of children of
health and psychological aspects. Paper presented at the Korean Association of Child Studies Conference (Seoul, South Korea), 2335.
An, E. M. (2009). The relationship among physical
change in adolescence, psycho-social characteristics, and school adaptation (Unpublished masters thesis). Kwangwoon University, Seoul.
Argyle, M., Martin, M., & Crossland, J. (1989). Happiness as a function of personality and social
encounters. In J. P. Forgas & J. M. Innes
(Eds.), Recent advances in social psychology:
An international perspective (pp. 189203).
Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Bak, G. S., Lee, G. A., Lee, D. Y., Kim, S. H., &
Kim, D. S. (2013). International comparison
study on school curriculum organization and
instruction time. Sejong: Ministry of Education.
Brewster, A. B., & Bowen, G. L. (2004). Teacher
support and the school engagement of Latino
middle and high school students at risk of
school failure. Child and Adolescent Social
Work Journal, 21, 4267.
Cho, S. Y., Shi, H. Y., Choi, M. S., & Choi, H. Y.
(2008). Survey released: Are children in Korea
happy? Targeting elementary school 2, 4, 6 graders nationwide. Paper presented at the Korean
Association of Child Studies Conference (Seoul,
South Korea), 6981.
Choi, I. J., Kim, J. G., Lim, H. J., & Kang, H. C.
(2011). 2010 international survey youths values.
Sejong: National Youth Policy Institute.
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1975). Beyond boredom and
anxiety. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Dubow, E., & Ullman, D. (1989). Assessing social
support in elementary school children: The
319