09 - Archaeology - May June 2012

Donner Party: The Native American Perspective
A publication of the Archaeological Institute of America
www.archaeology.org
Mapping
Titanic
The New Frontier
of Underwater
Archaeology
Galilees
Cultural
Crossroads
Bronze Age
Social Network
Ancient Mexican
Board Games
vk.
com/
engl
i
s
hl
i
br
ar
y
PLUS:
Dogtooth Handbag, German
Ax Hoard, First Zodiac,
Greengrocer Curse Tablet
July/August
May/June2009
2012
vk.com/englishlibrary
MAY/JUNE 2012
VOLUME 65, NUMBER 3
CONTENTS
features
24 Excavating Tel Kedesh
More than a decade after they began
working at an enormous mound in
Israels Upper Galilee region, two
archaeologists reflect on their work
BY ANDREA BERLIN AND SHARON HERBERT
30 Ancient Germanys
Metal Traders
A post-Cold War construction boom

is exposing evidence of a powerful
Bronze Age culture
BY ANDREW CURRY
34 Archaeology of Titanic
One hundred years after it sank, the
wreck of Titanic has finally become
what it was always meant to be: an
archaeological site
BY JAMES P. DELGADO
42 Rethinking the
Thundering Hordes
How pastoralist nomads carried

civilization across Central Asia more
than 4,000 years ago
BY ANDREW LAWLER
48 Games Ancient
People Played
An intriguing discovery in a
Mexican swamp provides evidence
of the earliest form of amusement
in the Americas
BY BARBARA VOORHIES
Cover: A map of the bow of Titanic made

using multi-beam and side-scan sonar
AP PHOTO/RMS TITANIC INC.
42 Archaeologists are searching

Central Asias vast landscape
for evidence of ancient nomadic
trade networks.
12
14
departments
18
4 Editors Letter
6 From the President
8 Letters
The number of deaths on the Trail of Tears, why
on the web
www.archaeology.org
700-year-old artifacts persist on New Mexicos surface,
More from this Issue To read our
and how tall is the Lion Man?
previous coverage on Titanic, go to

www.archaeology.org/titanic
9 From the Trenches

The Resurrection Ossuary and the risks of interpretation,
the worlds oldest handbag, CT scans uncover artifacts
within artifacts, the disease that killed two ancient
Albanians, and did drought doom Angkor Wat?
22 World Roundup
Excavating a Mormon tabernacle, cursing the
local greengrocer, the worlds earliest popcorn,
and did Bantu-speaking farmers reshape central
Africas landscape?
53
Letter from California
discoveries at the Minoan site of Zominthos in

central Crete; at Johnsons Island, a Civil War
site in Ohio; and at El Carrizal; in Veracruz.
Archaeological News from around

the worldupdated by 1 p.m. ET every
weekday. And sign up for our e-Update so you
dont miss a thing.
Stay in Touch Visit Facebook to like

ARCHAEOLOGY or follow us on Twitter at
@archaeologymag
A new look at the notorious Donner Party
68
Interactive Digs Read about the latest
Artifact
A Roman gurine is the rst depiction in bronze of an
African child charioteer ever found
Clear your mind in Texas. To plan your own Texas

adventure or to order your FREE Texas State
Travel Guide, Accommodations Guide and Texas
Map, visit Travel Tex.com.
j2IFHRIWKH*RYHUQRU(FRQRPLF'HYHORSPHQWDQG7RXULVP
EDITORS LETTER
A Lifes Work
Editor in Chief
Claudia Valentino
Executive Editor
Deputy Editor
Jarrett A. Lobell
Samir S. Patel
Senior Editors
Nikhil Swaminathan
Zach Zorich
hat sometimes gets overlooked in our coverage of archaeology is the nature of

the connection that archaeologists can have to their areas of study, especially as
that relationship evolves over the years they devote to particular sites.
In Archaeology of Titanic (page 34), underwater archaeologist James P. Delgado,
who first dived the wreck and subsequently wrote about it for us more than a dozen
years ago, speaks of revisiting the ship as part of a new expedition in 2010, and details
the considerable changes, since then, in underwater archaeology. He also shares his
view that Titanic, at last, can become an archaeological site in the truest sense.
In Excavating Tel Kedesh (page 24), archaeologists Andrea Berlin and Sharon
Herbert
Herber recount their more than 10 years of work at a tell in the
rural
rura interior of Israels Upper Galilee region. This site, which
lies
lie along the Israeli-Lebanese border, yielded a richer story
than
th they ever could have imagined.
Julie M. Schablitsky, in Letter from California: A New
Look
L
at the Donner Party (page 53), reveals the ways in
which
w
archaeology is allowing a clearer interpretation of
the
t situation that these doomed migrants faced. She also
refl
re ects on the ways in which it brought her own practice of
archaeology
into sharper focus.
ar
Also in this issue you will find the latest analysis of Central
Asias
Asi more than 4,000-year-old nomadic culture. Rethinking
The Thundering Hordes (page 42), by contributing editor
Andrew Lawler, challenges the long-held view that the peoples who
lived in the areas covered by modern countries including Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and
Kazakhstan were destroyers of civilization. Rather, they may have helped to advance it.
Contributing editor Andrew Curry, in Ancient Germanys Metal Traders (page 30),
writes of an astonishing find made during the course of building a highway on-ramp
in Dermsdorf, Germany: a jar filled with 100 bronze ax heads. This hoard, and the
remains of Bronze Age structures, settlements, and burial sites discovered in the area,
add up to significant evidence of a culture that maintained trade networks with places
as far-flung as Denmark, Poland, and Scotland some 3,000 years ago.
Of course, even millennia ago, people knew that all work and no play was no way to live.
In Games Ancient People Played (page 48), Barbara Voorhies examines the discovery
of circular patterns of holes in a clay floor in Mexico, and how archaeology may have
determined that they are some of the earliest evidence of game-playing in the Americas.
And dont miss From the Trenches, World Roundup, and Artifact, where youll
find our very own blend of everything that archaeological discovery has to oer.
Editorial Assistant
Intern
Malin Grunberg Banyasz
Aldo Foe
Creative Director
Richard Bleiweiss
Contributing Editors
Roger Atwood, Paul Bahn, Bob Brier,

Andrew Curry, Blake Edgar, Brian Fagan,
David Freidel, Tom Gidwitz, Andrew Lawler
Stephen H. Lekson, Jerald T. Milanich,
Jennifer Pinkowski, Heather Pringle,
Angela M. H. Schuster, Neil Asher Silberman
Correspondents
Athens: Yannis N. Stavrakakis

Bangkok: Karen Coates
Islamabad: Massoud Ansari
Israel: Mati Milstein
Naples: Marco Merola
Paris: Bernadette Arnaud
Rome: Roberto Bartoloni,
Giovanni Lattanzi
Washington, D.C.: Sandra Scham
Publisher
Peter Herdrich
Associate Publisher
Kevin Quinlan
Director of Circulation and Fulllment
Kevin Mullen
Vice President of Sales and Marketing
Meegan Daly
Director of Integrated Sales
Gerry Moss
Inside Sales Representative
Karina Casines
West Coast Account Manager
Cynthia Lapporte
Oak Media Group
cynthia@oakmediagroup.com
323-493-2754
Circulation Consultant
Greg Wolfe, Circulation Specialists, Inc.

Newsstand Consultant
T.J. Montilli,
Publishers Newstand Outsource, LLC
Ofce Manager
Malin Grunberg Banyasz

For production questions,
contact production@archaeology.org
Editorial Advisory Board
James P. Delgado, Ellen Herscher,

Ronald Hicks, Jean-Jacques Hublin,
Mark Lehner, Roderick J. McIntosh,
Susan Pollock, Jeremy A. Sablo,
Kenneth B. Tankersley
ARCHAEOLOGY MAGAZINE
36-36 33rd Street, Long Island City, NY 11106
tel 718-472-3050 fax 718-472-3051
Claudia Valentino
Editor in Chief
Subscription questions and address

changes should be sent to Archaeology,
Subscription Services,
P.O. Box 433091 Palm Coast, FL 32164
toll free (877) ARKY-SUB (275-9782),
or subscriptions@archaeology.org
ARCHAEOLOGY May/June 2012
Presenting the
VV 7>i
V i
" Liiv}
>i V i
When we introduced the original Acoustic Wave music

system, Sound & Vision said it delivered possibly the bestreproduced sound many people have ever heard. And the
Oregonian reported it had changed the way many Americans
listen to music.
Today, the improved Acoustic Wave music system II
builds on our more than 40 years of industry-leading
innovation to deliver even better sound. This is the bestperforming all-in-one music system weve ever made, with
sound that rivals large and complicated stereos. Theres
no stack of equipment. No tangle of wires. Just all-in-one
convenience and lifelike sound.
Even better sound than its award-winning predecessor.
With recently developed Bose technologies, our engineers
were able to make the acclaimed sound even more natural.
We believe youll appreciate the quality even at volume
levels approaching that of a live performance.
1i ii i
This small system fits almost
anywhere. You can move it
from room to room, or take
it outside. It has what you
need to enjoy your music,
including a built-in CD player
and digital FM/AM tuner.
You also can easily connect
additional sources like your
iPod, iPad or TV.
i> iv vii v `> Use our 30-day,

risk-free trial to try it in your home. When you call, ask about
adding the optional 5-CD Changer to play your music for
hours the same slim remote operates both system and changer.
Also, ask about using your own major credit card to make
i>>i] with no interest charges from Bose.* Order
now and save $100 on the Acoustic Wave music system II.
Compare the performance with large, multi-component stereos
costing much more.
And discover why Bose
SAVE $100 i`i
is the most respected

iVV7>e V
name in sound.
iL>]12.
/`ii>i\
n{x] i{
iV7-
Name________________________________________________________
Address______________________________________________________
City_________________________________State_____Zip____________
Phone_________________ E-mail (Optional)_________________________
Mail to: SST, Bose Corporation, P.O. Box 9168, Framingham, MA 01701-9168
Shown in Graphite Gray

with optional 5-CD Changer.
/ " U , " 1
/ " U 7 9 , " "
*Bose payment plan available on orders of $299-$1500 paid by major credit card. Separate financing offers may be available for select products. See website for details. Down payment is 1/12 the product price plus applicable tax and shipping charges,
charged when your order is shipped. Then, your credit card will be billed for 11 equal monthly installments beginning approximately one month from the date your order is shipped, with 0% APR and no interest charges from Bose. Credit card rules and
interest may apply. U.S. residents only. Limit one active financing program per customer. 2012 Bose Corporation. The distinctive design of the Acoustic Wave music system II is a registered trademark of Bose Corporation. Financing and savings offers not
to be combined with other offers or applied to previous purchases, and subject to change without notice. Offers are limited to purchases made from Bose and participating authorized dealers. Offers valid 4/1/12-5/31/12. Risk-free refers to 30-day trial only,
requires product purchase and does not include return shipping. Delivery is subject to product availability. iPad and iPod are registered trademarks of Apple Inc. Quotes reprinted with permission: Sound & Vision, 3/85; Wayne Thompson, Oregonian, 9/10/96.
FROM THE PRESIDENT
Archaeological
Institute of America
Located at Boston University
Open Access
OFFICERS
President
everal bills currently making their way through

Congress are causing considerable concern in the
archaeological and broader scientific community. The
Federal Research Public Access Act of 2012 was introduced in
both houses of Congress on February 9 of this year.
The legislation would require that publishers of academic
and scholarly journals provide the government with final peerreviewed and edited manuscripts, and, six months after their
publication, those manuscripts would be made available to the
public, on the Internet, for no charge. The House bill states,
The Federal Government funds basic and applied research with
the expectation that new ideas and discoveries that result from the research, if shared and
effectively disseminated, will advance science and improve the lives and welfare of people
of the United States and around the world.
We at the Archaeological Institute of America (AIA), along with our colleagues at the
American Anthropological Association and other learned societies, have taken a stand
against open access. Here at the AIA, we particularly object to having such a scheme
imposed on us from the outside when, in fact, during the AIAs more than 130-year
history, we have energetically supported the broad dissemination of knowledge, and do so
through our extensive program of events and lectures for the general public and through our
publications. Our mission statement explicitly says, Believing that greater understanding
of the past enhances our shared sense of humanity and enriches our existence, the AIA
seeks to educate people of all ages about the significance of archaeological discovery. We
have long practiced open access.
While it may be true that the government finances research, it does not fund the
arduous peer-review process that lies at the heart of journal and scholarly publication, nor
the considerable effort beyond that step that goes into preparing articles for publication.
Those efforts are not without cost. When an archaeologist publishes his or her work,
the final product has typically been significantly improved by the contributions of other
professionals such as peer reviewers, editors, copywriters, photo editors, and designers.
This is the context in which the work should appear. (Almost all scholarly books and many
articles lead off with a lengthy list that acknowledges these individuals.)
We fear that this legislation would prove damaging to the traditional venues in which
scientific information is presented by offering, for no cost, something that has considerable
costs associated with producing it. It would undermine, and ultimately dismantle, by
offering for no charge, what subscribers actually support financiallya rigorous publication
process that does serve the public, because it results in superior work.
Elizabeth Bartman
First Vice President
Andrew Moore
Vice President for Outreach and Education
Pamela Russell
Vice President for Professional Responsibilities
Laetitia LaFollette
Vice President for Publications
John Younger
Vice President for Societies
Thomas Morton
Treasurer
Brian J. Heidtke
Chief Executive Officer
Peter Herdrich
Chief Operating Officer
Kevin Quinlan
GOVERNING BOARD
Susan Alcock
Michael Ambler
Carla Antonaccio
Cathleen Asch
Barbara Barletta
David Boochever
Julie Herzig Desnick
Michael Galaty
Greg Goggin
Ronald Greenberg
Michael Hoff
Jeffrey Lamia
Lynne Lancaster
Deborah Lehr
Robert Littman
Elizabeth Macaulay-Lewis
Heather McKillop
Shilpi Mehta
Naomi Norman, ex officio
Maria Papaioannou
Eleanor Powers
Paul Rissman
Glenn Schwartz
David Seigle
Chen Shen
Charles Steinmetz
Douglas Tilden
Claudia Valentino, ex officio
Shelley Wachsmann
Ashley White
John J. Yarmick
Past President
C. Brian Rose
Trustees Emeriti
Norma Kershaw
Charles S. LaFollette
Legal Counsel
Elizabeth Bartman
Mitchell Eitel, Esq.

Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP
President, Archaeological Institute of America

Archaeological Institute of America
656 Beacon Street Boston, MA 02215-2006
www.archaeological.org
Finally, a cell phone

thats a phone
e
ic ed
Pr uc 8
d 4
Re y $
B
o act
N tr
n
o
C
with rates as low as $3.75 per week!

Well, I nally did it. I nally decided to enter the digital age
and get a cell phone. My kids have been bugging me, my book
group made fun of me, and the last straw was when my car broke
down, and I was stuck by the highway for an hour before
someone stopped to help. But when I went to the cell
phone store, I almost changed my mind. The phones are
so small I cant see the numbers, much less push the
right one. They all have cameras, computers and a
global-positioning something or other thats
supposed to spot me from space. Goodness, all I want
to do is to be able to talk to my grandkids! The
people at the store werent much help. They couldnt
understand why someone wouldnt want a phone the
size of a postage stamp. And the rate plans! They were
complicated, confusing, and expensiveand the
contract lasted for two years! Id almost given up until
a friend told me about her new Jitterbug phone.
Now, I have the convenience and safety of being
able to stay in touchwith a phone I can actually
use.
Sometimes I think the people who designed this
phone and the rate plans had me in mind. The
phone ts easily into my pocket, and ips
open to reach from my mouth to my ear.
The display is large and backlit, so I can
actually see who is calling. With a push
of a button I can amplify the volume,
and if I dont know a number, I can
simply push 0 for a friendly, helpful
operator that will look it up and even
dial it for me. The Jitterbug also reduces
background noise, making the sound
loud and clear. Theres even a dial tone,
so I know the phone is ready to use.
Aordable plans that I can understand and no contract to

sign! Unlike other cell phones, Jitterbug has plans that make sense.
Why should I pay for minutes Im never going to use? And if I do
talk more than I plan, I wont nd myself with no minutes
like my friend who has a prepaid phone. Best of all, there
is no contract to sign so Im not locked in for years at
Monthly Minutes
Monthly Rate
Operator Assistance
911 Access
Long Distance Calls
Voice Dial
Nationwide Coverage
Friendly Return Policy1
50
100
$14.99
24/7
FREE
No addl charge
FREE
Yes
30 days
$19.99
24/7
FREE
No addl charge
FREE
Yes
30 days
More minute plans available. Ask your Jitterbug expert for details.
a time or subject to termination fees. The

U.S. Based customer service is second
to none, and the phone gets service
virtually anywhere in the country.
Call now and get a FREE gift
when you order. Try Jitterbug
for 30 days and if you don't love
it, just return it1. Why wait, the
Jitterbug comes ready to use right
out of the box. If you arent
as happy with it as I am, you can
return it for a refund of the
purchase price. Call now, the
Jitterbug product experts are ready
to answer your questions.
Available in
Graphite and Red.
Jitterbug Cell Phone

Call now and receive a FREE gift
just for ordering. Hurrythis is a
limited time offer. Call now!
Call today to get your own Jitterbug phone.

Please mention promotional code 44484.
1-888-862-0337
www.jitterbugdirect.com
47526
We proudly accept the following credit cards.
IMPORTANT CONSUMER INFORMATION: Jitterbug is owned by GreatCall, Inc.Your invoices will come from GreatCall. All rate plans and services require the purchase of a Jitterbug phone and a one-time set up fee of $35. Coverage and service is not available everywhere. Other charges
and restrictions may apply. Screen images simulated. There are no additional fees to call Jitterbugs 24-hour U.S. Based Customer Service. However, for calls to an Operator in which a service is completed, minutes will be deducted from your monthly balance equal to the length of the call
and any call connected by the Operator, plus an additional 5 minutes. Monthly rate plans do not include government taxes or assessment surcharges. Prices and fees subject to change. 1We will refund the full price of the Jitterbug phone if it is returned within 30 days of purchase in
like-new condition. We will also refund your first monthly service charge if you have less than 30 minutes of usage. If you have more than 30 minutes of usage, a per minute charge of 35 cents will apply for each minute over 30 minutes. The activation fee and shipping charges are not
refundable. Jitterbug is a registered trademark of GreatCall, Inc. Samsung is a registered trademark of Samsung Electronics America, Inc. and/or its related entities. Copyright 2012 GreatCall, Inc. Copyright 2012 by firstSTREET for Boomers and Beyond, Inc. All rights reserved.
ARCHAEOLOGY
LETTERS
Research Program
Why Are Coronados Artifacts

Still on the Surface?
I dont understand the logic in Coronados Deadly Siege (March/April 2012).
The pueblo is buried such that archaeologists cant dig to its foundations or even to
the top of the ruined structures, yet the
artifacts are at ground level? Logically,
shouldnt those artifacts be at the same
level as the pueblo foundations?
Excavate alongside professional

archaeologists and
study artifacts in the lab.
Sessions in
June, July, August, & October, 2012
ROW CANYON
CARCHAEOLOGICAL
CENTER
Discover the Past, Share the Adventure
800.422.8975
www.crowcanyon.org/travel
Make Room for the Memories.

An adventure of historic proportion is waiting for
youat two living-history museums that explore
Americas beginnings. Board replicas of colonial
ships. Grind corn in a Powhatan Indian village. Try
on English armor inside a palisaded fort. Then, join
Continental Army soldiers at their encampment
for a rsthand look at the Revolutions end. Dont
forget your camera. Because the history here is
life size. And your memories will be even bigger!
Save 20% on a combination ticket

to both museums.
8
CST 2059347-50
Flo Samuels
Hayward, CA
Archaeologist Matt Schmader

responds:
The buried wall outlines were detected by
instruments at a depth of 18 inches, but are
even shallower (and sometimes even visible at
the surface). The average depth of the sixteenthcentury metal is two to four inches. It is common
to find artifacts even thousands of years old
lying on the surface in New Mexico. Essentially,
Piedras Marcadas is at a zero point where there
is little deposition or erosion, but more like a balance between the two. Thats why 500,000
pieces of pottery dating 400 to 700 years ago
are right there, lying on the surface.
Full Scope of the Trail of Tears
The Trail of Tears involved not only the
Cherokee, but over 40 other groups
and tribes. Your story (Return to the
Trail of Tears, March/April 2012) contains several historical inaccuracies. For
example, the Cherokee moved themselves
in 13 separate contingents. Further, while
many of the Cherokee were interned at
the beginning of Removal, they were on
their own on the trail. Troops did not
accompany the Indians, prodding them
on their way. Also, the figure of 4,000
deaths is considered by most scholars to
be on the high side.
James W. Parins
University of Arkansas at Little Rock
Little Rock, AR
ARCHAEOLOGY welcomes mail from

readers. Please address your comments
to ARCHAEOLOGY, 36-36 33rd Street,
Long Island City, NY 11106, fax 718-4723051, or e-mail letters@archaeology.org.
The editors reserve the right to edit
submitted material. Volume precludes
our acknowledging individual letters.
Author Marion Blackburn responds:

For this feature we focused tightly on the
events associated with Fort Armistead,
which is believed to be one of the bestpreserved forts within the former Cherokee
Nation associated with Removal. Its story
is indeed part of a much larger event. When
describing deaths along the Trail of Tears,
the number cited most often is 4,000,
though there are estimates as high as
6,000. The deaths before, during, and after
the forced emigration, as well as the deaths
of children and the elderly, loss of fertility
and miscarriages, combined with the ongoing increased mortality, would support the
4,000 number.
Lion Man Lament
I am dismayed at the stubborn insistence that the intended sex of this
magnificent ivory carving (New Life
for the Lion Man, March/April 2012)
is indeterminate. It is clear that there
is a pubic triangle between the legs of
this image, a familiar feminine symbol
found in many painted caves. For all
known primary hunting cultures living
in and dependent upon the world of
nature, the pubic triangle is a powerful
symbol of that unseen energy which
gives birth to and nurtures all forms, and
so is, properly and universally, depicted
as female. The lion would not become
symbolic of masculine royal authority
for another 30,000 years.
T.D. Austin
Palm Springs, CA
Maybe I missed something, but it does

not appear that anywhere in your article
do you give the size of the statue/figure.
Frank Simon
Greenacres, FL
Executive Editor Jarrett A. Lobell

responds:
The Lion Man, as currently composed, is
roughly a foot tall, though archaeologists
expect it to gain an inch or two when the
fragments of the neck are added to the figure.
As for the figurines gender, thats been hotly
debated for many years. The new pieces,
however, could eventually put that argument to rest.
LATE-BREAKING NEWS AND NOTES FROM THE WORLD OF ARCHAEOLOGY
The Perils of Interpretation
cholars often arrive at difHe and Tabor wanted to know if

ferent interpretations of
there was a relationship between
the same evidence. But few
the two tombs that would lend
archaeological artifacts in recent
credence to their theory that
memory have produced interprethis section of Jerusalem, known
tations as radically divergent as
as Talpiyot, contains a cemetery
those advanced in connection with
filled with the burials of Jesus, his
two first-century A.D. ossuaries
family, and his followers.
(boxes containing skeletal remains)
When Jacobovici, Tabor, and
in Jerusalem. Their discovery was
project archaeologist Rami Arav
announced in February, and when
of the University of Nebraska at
filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici
Omaha looked closely at one of
and James Tabor, professor of
the ossuaries, they immediately
religious studies at the University
interpreted the image on it as a
of North Carolina at Charlotte,
fish spitting out a manreprereleased their book The Jesus Dissented by a stick figureand
covery that same day, it ignited
therefore concluded that it was
a heated debate in the fields of
a depiction of the story of Jonah
archaeology, theology, linguistics,
and the whale. On a second
and biblical scholarship.
ossuary in the tomb, they read a
The ossuaries are unremarkable.
dual-language Greek and Hebrew
More than 2,000 of similar date
inscription in several ways, includand appearance have been found in
ing O Divine Jehovah, raise up,
Israel. Although the tomb in which
raise up. Taking the image on
they and five others were found
one ossuary and the inscription
was originally explored in 1981, it
on the other, they developed an
was not until Jacobovici and Tabor
interpretation of what the collecreturned in 2010 that the ossuartion of ossuaries represents.
ies could be photographed on all
According to Jacobovici and
sides inside the tomb.
Tabor, the Jonah ossuary bears
In 1981, Orthodox religious
the earliest Christian symbols
leaders had chased away archaeever discovered, the first Chrisologists trying to excavate the A camera on a robotic arm took this picture of
tian symbol found in Jerusalem,
tomb, saying that they were dis- an inscribed image on one of two ossuaries.
and the earliest representation
turbing the dead. Jacobovici and Interpretation of the image has sparked controversy
in Jewish art of a Biblical tale.
in the scholarly community.
Tabor negotiated with the leaders
Furthermore, they believe that
and the owners of the apartment
the other ossuarys inscription is
that sits on top of the tomb, and received permission to
the earliest record of a teaching or saying of Jesusperhaps
bore a hole through the tombs roof and excavate it with
recorded by someone who heard him say it.
a robotic arm that held a camera. Jacobovici and Tabor had
Immediately following the annoucement, scholars began
chosen the tomb because of its proximity to what Jacobovici
presenting different interpretations, as well as harsh critihad identified four years earlier as The Jesus Family Tomb
cism of Jacobovici and Tabors claims. The critics pointed
200 feet away (Hype in the Holy Land, May/June 2007).
out possible errors in the transcription and its translation.
www.archaeology.org
FROM THE TRENCHES

They also questioned the similarity of
what Jacobovici and Tabor had identified as a fish to both depictions, and
actual remains, of a funerary marker
called a nephesh. Others referred to the
images strong resemblance to etched
glass amphorae and ointment jars, both
of which were commonly buried with
the dead. A harsher reaction came from
those who condemned not only Jacobovici and Tabors interpretations, but
also their motives. Chief among them
was Eric Meyers, professor of religion at
Duke University, who decried Jacobovici
and Tabors interpretation as much

ado about nothing and a sensationalist
In the winter of 18971898, word

spread like wildfire that gold had
been discovered along the
Klondike River in Canadas Yukon
Territory. Men and women from all
over the world converged on the
area, and two small settlements,
Skagway and Dyea (both in
Alaska), became competing
boomtowns, each claiming it had
with goods, the bones of pack

animals, and other detritus.
Though today Skagway is a historic
town of about 800, Dyea is a ghost
town. Karl Gurcke, historian and
archaeologist of the Klondike Gold
Rush National Historical Park, and
his colleague Theresa Thibault say
that Dyea is a major archaeological
resource and the Chilkoot Trail
constitutes one
of the worlds
longest
museums.
The inscription on one of the ossuaries
The site
Originally
occupied by
Tlingit natives,
Dyea was home
to approximately
5,000 to 8,000
people at its
peak. The historic
the easier path to the gold fields.

The route of choice for many
stampeders was the 33-milelong Chilkoot Trail that began at
Dyea and bypassedso its
boosters claimedthe crime of
Skagway and the gridlock of its
White Pass Trail. Some 25,000 to
30,000 people passed through
Dyea and traveled the Chilkoot,
portions of which were so narrow
that sleds and pack animals were
almost useless. The worst part of
the trail was known as the
Golden Stairs1,500 steep
steps carved out of ice and snow
(right). The trail became littered
10
ttownsite
it is
i just
j t over
e a mile
ile and
dah
half
lf
long and a little less than a half-mile
wide, and boasted a post ofce, a
hospital, a school, a church, 49 hotels,
47 restaurants, 39 saloons, and four
cemeteries. Today one can see ruins
presentation of data that are familiar to

anyone with knowledge of first-century
Jerusalem. Meyers went on to say, We
may regard this book as yet another in
a long list of presentations that misuse
not only the Bible, but also archaeology. Interpretation in archaeology
is about finding meaning in the past.
And especially when archaeology and
the worlds of religion and the Bible
intersect, one thing is certainthe
meanings scholars find in the artifacts
will rarely, if ever, be the same.
JARRETT A. LOBELL
and artifacts all over the site and

up and down the trail, including the
remains of buildings, aerial tramway
towers, telephone lines, wharf
pilings, and boilers that powered
tramways (left). Archaeologists
from the National Park Service and
Parks Canada have spent 30 years
documenting features and artifacts.
The trail now attracts thousands
each year to experience the scenery
and history. Some items have been
taken over the years, but much
remains and can be seen right on
the surface in Dyea and along the
trail. Care must be taken when
viewing the fragile artifacts.
While youre there
Whereas Dyea is a ghost town,
Skagway is very much alive. Its
historic downtown has a visitor
center for the Klondike Gold Rush
National Historical Park, where
one can arrange tours
o
of Dyea by foot,
o
bicycle, or horse,
b
or backcountry
o
excursions along the
e
Chilkoot Trail. The
C
downtown area has
d
many restaurants,
hotels, and museums,
including the Skagway
Museum in City Hall,
with many gold rush
artifacts on display.
The White Pass
Route Railroad offers
and Yukon Rou
beautiful sightseeing trips as well,
following the path that many hopeful
prospectors once toiled along
though you can do it in total comfort.
MALIN GRUNBERG BANYASZ
SPECIAL MARKET OPPORTUNITY

Your Expert Guide to the Worlds Finest Coins
Nicholas J. Bruyer, Chairman & Founder, First Federal Coin
ANA Life Member Since 1974
$5,340 for an Ounce of

Silver Bullion? Impossible!
10 years ago Id have called you crazy to make such a prediction.
Yet today its a fact. Now our deal with a $4 billion precious metals wholesaler
nets you a great deal for Americas hottest ounce of silver!
It wasnt more than ten years ago that we met with former U.S. Mint
Director Donna Pope. She spoke with pride about what she considered
to be her greatest achievement as Director under President Reagan:
Creation of the American Eagle silver and gold bullion coin programs,
the first of their kind in our nations history.
The purpose of these coins was to give people the opportunity to own
physical silver and gold in a form certified for weight and purity by
the U.S. Mint. While the bullion coin program was a signal success,
nobody took into account the profound effect it would have on the
collector market.
Silver Eagles = Todays Morgan Dollars
In the 1800s and early 1900s, the U.S. Morgan Silver Dollar was
struck year upon year at various mints and circulated at face value.
Their core value was in their precious metal content. However, in
top grades, Morgan Silver Dollars can sell today for tens and even
hundreds of thousands of dollars each!
For the same reason, many collectors today see the Silver Eagle series
as a literal ground floor opportunity to acquire the top-grade coins
as they are released. They started submitting Silver Eagles to the
leading independent coin grading services, such as Numismatic
Guaranty Corporation (NGC), praying that the coins would come
back with the highest possible grade: MS70 (all Uncirculated coins
are graded on a point system from a low of 60 to a high of 70, with 70
representing flawless perfection). Of all the Silver Eagles produced by
the U.S. Mint in 2011, less than one out of every 788 earned the NGC
MS70 grade!
MS70 = $$$$$!
In the rarified atmosphere of MS70, Silver Eagles have soared to
market prices that I can only characterize as surreal. Consider this:
MS70 Silver Eagles have been selling for truly stratospheric prices.
Here are just a few eye-popping examples:
1996 MS70 Silver Eagle
$5,340
$2,660
$3,910
$1,660
top two firms for grading coins. But

better yet, because we received the
very first coins released from the
mint, they all have the valueenhancing First Releases
designation.
What Does First
Releases Mean?
NGC designates
only those coins it
certifies as having
been released
during the first
30 days of issue
as First Releases.
Collectors place a
premium on these
coins because they are
struck from freshly made
dies, which is thought to
impart superior quality. Only a
miniscule number of the mintage
gets the First Releases pedigree - so it can
turbo charge the value of an already valuable MS70 coin.
Actual size
is 40.6 mm
BUY RISK FREEAND SAVE $30 OVER LAST YEARS COIN

Because of our industry-leading status, you can take advantage of
our bolt of lightning deal on these Perfect Gem MS70 2012 Silver
Eagles at an incredible price $30 lower than the 2011s: just $99 each
(plus s&h)
To avoid disappointment I urge you to call immediately.
Hurry! This is a first-come-first-served offer. Call 1-888-201-7057
to find our how to qualify for free shipping.
Mention offer code: SEM157
Call First Federal Toll-FREE today
It Just Keeps Getting Better

I was thrilled to lock up a guaranteed supply of Perfect Gem MS70 2012
Silver Eagles from a primary distributor who gets them directly from the
U.S. Mint. (This is a coin you cannot buy directly from the U.S. Mint).
Moreover, every coin is certified and encapsulated by NGC, one of the
1-888-201-7057
to Reserve Your 2012 Silver Eagle MS70 First Release!
Offer Code SEM157
Please mention this code when you call.
Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Prices subject to change without notice. Note: First Federal Coin is a private distributor of government and private coin and medallic issues and is
not affiliated with the United States government. Facts and figures were deemed accurate as of January 2012. First Federal Coin, 2012.
American Numismatic Association

Nicholas Bruyer
Life Member 4489
1-888-201-7057
14101 Southcross Drive W., Burnsville, Minnesota 55337
FROM THE TRENCHES
Nothing New
Under the Sun
Dogtooth Is the
New Black
fter three years of cleaning and

reassembling ceramic drinking
vessels from a 2,000-year-old
Illyrian-Hellenistic sanctuary deep in
a Croatian cave, archaeologist Stao
Forenbaher turned his attention to
the 30 ivory fragments he also found
there. When I started putting the
fragments together, he says, I soon
realized that I was looking at signs of
the zodiac. Forenba-her consulted with
experts in ancient
Greek astrology, who
were stunned. When
n
arranged in a circle, thee
ivory fragments commpose what may be the
he
worlds oldest astrologers
rs
board. Although some of
the inscribed signs (highghlighted at right) are too
fragmentary to name, the
Cancer, Pisces, and Gemini segments
(top to bottom) are clearly identifiable.
The tiles would have originally been
fixed to a flat surface. The fragments
were found with the drinking vessels in
front of a large stalagmite, which was
clearly a focus of worship. It is impossible to tell if the board was an oering
itself, or if it had been used there to
provide horoscopes to visitors.
JARRETT A. LOBELL
erman researchers have uncovered what may be the remains

of the worlds oldest handbag,
according to Sachsen-Anhalt State
Archaeology and Preservation Oce
archaeologist Susanne Friederich.
Though the bag itself, probably made
of leather or linen, rotted away long ago,
the form of the bags outer flapmade
of more than 100 dog teeth, all sharp
canineswas preserved. The remains
were discovered in a surface coal mine
not far from Leipzig, next to the body
of a woman buried at the end of the
Stone Age, between 4,200 and 4,500
years ago. Dog teeth are often found
in graves from the period, usually as
necklaces or hair ornaments. But every
woman would argue that a handbag
should count as jewelry too, says Friederich. Further analysis may reveal more
about the dozens of dogs whose teeth
decorated the bag.
ANDREW CURRY
The Neolithic Grind
sing a technique for analyzing

friction in industrial equipment,
a group of French and Turkish
scientists have unraveled the process
that was used approximately 10,000
years ago to make a highly polished
obsidian bracelet. The team examined a
bracelet fragment from Akl Hyk in
Turkey at dierent levels of magnifica-
12
tion and saw evidence of three stages

of productionpecking, grinding, and
polishing. Striations on the bracelet
indicate that a mechanical device may
have been used to achieve its regularized
shape and glossy finish. It is the earliest
evidence of such a sophisticated stoneworking technique.
ZACH ZORICH
Scientically Engineered to Defy Gravity
Defy Pain, Defy Aging, Defy Fatigue

This is my story
I used to be more active. I used to run, play
basketball, tennis, football I was more than
a weekend warrior. I woke up every day lled
with life! But now, in my late 30s, I spend most
of my day in the ofce or sacked out in front of
the TV. I rarely get to the gym not that I dont
like working out, its the nagging pain in my
knees and ankles. Low energy and laziness has
got me down.
My energy has
Customer Satisfaction
zzled and Im
Speaks for Itself!
4 out of 5 customers purchase a
embarrassed to
2nd pair within 3 months.
admit that Ive
grown a spare
tire (Im sure its hurting my love life). Nowadays
I rarely walk. For some reason its just harder
now. Gravity has done a job on me.
Excitement swept through my

body like a drug
I received my package from GravityDefyer.
com and rushed to tear it open like a kid at
Christmas. Inside I found the most amazing
shoes I had ever seen different than most
running shoes. Sturdy construction. Cool
colors. Nice lines I was holding a miracle
of technology. This was the real thing.
GDefy Benets
s Relieve pain
s Ease joint & spinal pressure
s Reduce fatigue & tiredness
s Be more active
s Have more energy
s Appear taller
s Jump higher, walk and
run faster
s Have instant comfort
s Cool your feet &
reduce foot odor
s Elevate your
performance
Wear them and

youll know
Thats what my doctor
recommended. He said, Gravity
Defyer shoes are pain-relieving
shoes. He promised they would
change my lifelike they were a
fountain of youth. They ease the
force of gravity, relieving stress
on your heels, ankles, knees and
back. They boost your energy by
propelling you forward.
The longer he talked, the
more sense it made. He
was even wearing a pair
himself!
I put them on and all I could say was,

WOW! In minutes I was out the door.
I was invincible; tireless in my new Gravity
Defyer shoes. It was as if my legs had been
replaced with super-powered bionics. What
the doctor promised was all correct. No more
knee pain. I started
to lose weight.
At last, I was pain
free and lled with
energy!
I was back in the
game. Gravity had no
ABSORB SHOCK
power over me!
Nothing to lose:
30 Day
Free Trial*
Eliminate pain from every step.
So, my friend, get back

on your feet like I did.
Try Gravity Defyer for
yourself. You have
REBOUND PROPELS
nothing to lose but
YOU FORWARD
Reduce fatigue. Be more active
your pain.
Tell us your story!
Login at Gravitydefyer.com
and share your experience.
Resilient High Grade

Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate
(EVA) Midsole
Rocker construction protects

metatarsal bones and aids fluid
stepping motions
Semi-Rigid
Heel Stabilizing
Cage
Removable
Comfort-Fit
Insole
Accommodates
most orthotics
Rugged Polymer Sole

VersoShock Trampoline
Shock-Absorbing Membrane Heel
Twin Stabilizers
Smart Memory Master Spring
Propels you forward and reduces fatigue
AVS3 Ventilation Port

Cools & Reduces Microbial Growth
EXCLUSIVE ONLINE OFFER
$129.95
Ankle &
foot pain
gone
Most
5
4 out ofse comfortable
a
er
h
Exerciseer purcother shoeneved
g
n
w
n
a
o
lo
%
20 o
pair
w/ n
in 3
fatigue witnhth
mo s.
Gravity Defyer
Customer Survey Results
MEN (Shown above)

TB902MBL
sizes 7 - 13
Med/Wide and
ExtraWide/XXWide Widths
WOMEN (Black on Black)
TB902FBL
sizes 5 - 11
Med/Wide and
ExtraWide/XXWide Widths
TRY THEM FREE* PAY IN 30 DAYS
Take advantage of this exclusive offer at

www.GravityDefyer.com/MQ8EDC3
or by phone, dial (800) 429-0039 and
mention the promotional code below.
Promotional Code: M Q 8 E D C 3
*Offer not available in stores. Shipping & Handling not included.
A+
FROM THE TRENCHES
Israels Garden Spot
cientists have re-created an ancient royal garden

on a hilltop between Jerusalem and Bethlehem, at
a site known as Ramat Rahel. Using archaeological evidence and intact pollen grains discovered in the
plaster lining of the 2,500-year-old gardens sophisticated irrigation system, researchers from Tel Aviv University reconstituted both the gardens layout and its unique
collection of both local and imported vegetation, including willow, poplar, birch, myrtle, water lilies, grape vines,
figs, olives, Lebanese cedars, Persian walnutsand citron, which first appeared in the Middle East at this site.
The whole garden is an enigmano one really knows
who built it, project leader Yuval Gadot says. He adds
that this Iron Age palace, which perhaps represented
the Assyrian, Babylonian, and Persian imperial presence
in Jerusalem, is the only such structure uncovered in Judea, and that, so far, the Ramat Rahel site is the only
garden to have been excavated in the Levant.
MATI MILSTEIN
Seeing Inside
-rays and computed tomography (CT ) scans of

artifacts and mummies have been conducted
for years now, but the unusual insights from
these techniques keep coming.
SAMIR S. PATEL
Curators from Amsterdams Rijkmuseum transported their

twelfth-century South Indian sculpture of Shiva (above) to
the most powerful X-ray tunnel at the Rotterdam customs
authority. They found, as they had suspected, that it was
cast in solid bronze.
CT imaging was used to

look inside a mummified
ibis (above) from ancient
Egypt (300 B.C.A.D. 30),
and showed that the bird
had been packed with
food, such as snails, for
the afterlife.
14
German and Italian scientists used

CT technology, with 3-D software, to
study heads that were mummified in
the nineteenth century for use as
anatomical specimens (right). This
image reveals remains of brain
tissue and a braided cord that had
been inserted to deposit toxic
preservatives inside the skull.
off
RD
ER BY J U
LY
What Is the Real Story behind

Christianitys Formative Years?
Explore the surprising development of early Christianity as it
transformed from the religion of Jesus to a religion about Jesus. From
Jesus to Constantine: A History of Early Christianity shows you
how the form of Christianity we know today emerged only after
many years of transition and conict. In 24 engaging lectures that will
increase your understanding of Christianity, you discover how a single
group from among many lost Christianities won the struggle for
dominance, established its beliefs as central to the faith, rewrote the
history of Christianitys internal conicts, and produced a canon of
sacred textsthe New Testamentto support its own views.
Bestselling author and award-winning Professor Bart D. Ehrman, Chair
of the Department of Religion at The University of North Carolina,
Chapel Hill, offers you a scholars perspective on the origins of what he
calls the most important institution in Western civilization.
Offer expires 07/09/12
1-800-832-2412
www.thegreatcourses.com/4ar
Taught by Bart D. Ehrman

the university of north carolina
at chapel hill
lecture titles
70%
LIM
IM
ED T E OF
IT
FE
From Jesus to
Constantine:
A History of Early
Christianity
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
The Birth of Christianity

The Religious World of Early Christianity
The Historical Jesus
Oral and Written Traditions about Jesus
The Apostle Paul
The Beginning of Jewish-Christian Relations
The Anti-Jewish Use of the Old Testament
The Rise of Christian Anti-Judaism
The Early Christian Mission
The Christianization of the Roman Empire
The Early Persecutions of the State
The Causes of Christian Persecution
Christian Reactions to Persecution
The Early Christian Apologists
The Diversity of Early
Christian Communities
16. Christianities of the Second Century
17. The Role of Pseudepigrapha
18. The Victory of the Proto-Orthodox
19. The New Testament Canon
20. The Development of Church Offices
21. The Rise of Christian Liturgy
22. The Beginnings of Normative Theology
23. The Doctrine of the Trinity
24. Christianity and the Conquest of Empire
From Jesus to Constantine:

A History of Early Christianity
Course no. 6577 | 24 lectures (30 minutes/lecture)
SAVE UP TO $185
DVD $254.95NOW $69.95
CD $179.95NOW $49.95
+$10 Shipping & Handling
Priority Code: 65888
Designed to meet the demand for lifelong

learning, The Great Courses is a highly
popular series of audio and video lectures led
by top professors and experts. Each of our
more than 350 courses is an intellectually
engaging experience that will change how
you think about the world. Since 1990,
over 10 million courses have been sold.
BORA ZKK / Cultural Folk Tours 34th year
TURKEY
PLUS CENTRAL ASIA / SILK ROAD TOURS

Offering quality tours with great food, photo
opps., the best guides, excellent hotels, buses
and many people-to-people events.
Our focus is on culture, history, music,
folklore, architecture and archaeology.
FROM THE TRENCHES
The
Persistence of
Brucellosis
A most unique, luxurious

boutique hotel in Turkey!
info@cappadociacavesuites.com
T
We will visit the Worlds oldest city and Worlds oldest temple on our Turkey tours.
ALLTOURS WILL STAYAT BORAS CAPPADOCIA CAVE SUITES!
WWW.CAPPADOCIACAVESUITES.COM
CA Reg # 2011417-40
For a free brochure & DVD CALL:
Website: www.culturalfolktours.com E-mail: tourinfo@boraozkok.com
1-800-935-8875
16
he skeletal remains of two

adolescent males found at
Butrint, a Roman colony in
Albania, indicate that both suered
from fatal cases of brucellosis. The
chronic respiratory disease, which is
typically contracted from contaminated meat or dairy products, today
aects roughly 500,000 people per
year worldwide.
Initi
Initially researchers believed that the teens died
of tub
tuberculosis (TB). Peasized holes found on
their 800-year-old spinal columns are indicativ
tive of an infection
se
secondary to the resspiratory illness and
sseemed to confirm
tthat view. However,
DNA samples held
D
no genetic markers
n
of TB. Brucellosis can
ca
cause similar bone
d
degradation, and a
se
search for genes associa
ciated with brucellosis
came up positive.
If you look at the World Health
Organization data, Albania has one of
the higher brucellosis rates in the world
today, says David Foran, a forensic
scientist at Michigan State. Its there
now and it was obviously there many
hundreds of years agoand most likely
throughout the centuries.
NIKHIL SWAMINATHAN
Technology Simplified
WOWA Computer Designed For YOU,

Not Your Grandchildren!
NEW
Just plug it in!!!
Its easy to read. Its easy to see. Its even easier to understand and use!
NEW
Touch
Screen
Technology
designed for SENIORS
Big Bright Screen

One-touch zoom magnification
No bulky tower
Have you ever said to yourself Id love to Then youll see the screen. This is
get a computer, if only I could figure out how a completely new operating system,
to use it. Well, youre not alone. Computers without the cluttered look of the normal
were supposed to make our lives simpler, but computer screen. The buttons on the screen
theyve gotten so complicated that they are not are easy to see and easy to understand. All
worth the trouble. With all of the pointing you do is touch one of them, from the Web,
and clicking and dragging and dropping E-mail, Calendar to Games you name it
youre lucky if you can figure out where and a new screen opens up. Its so easy to
use you wont have to
you are. Plus, you are constantly
worrying about viruses, spam I just wanted to tell firstSTREET ask your children or
and freeze-ups. If this sounds that I am having a great time on grandchildren for help.
familiar, we have great news for my WOW computer. I am learning
Until now the very
you. There is finally a computer something new everyday. I am 79 people who could
years old and cannot believe that I
thats designed for simplicity am typing and sending e-mails to all benefit most from
and ease of use. Its the WOW my friends now. My daughter and E-mail,
and
the
Computer, and it was designed granddaughter are so excited now Internet are the ones
that I have a computer. They use that have had the
with you in mind.
This computer is easy-to-use, computers on their jobs everyday, hardest time accessing
worry-free and literally puts the but they cannot believe what it. Now, thanks to
you can do on this computer. It is
world at your fingertips. From
the WOW Computer,
wonderful... Thanks.
the moment you open the box,
Johnnie E., Ellijay, Ga countless older Ameryoull realize how different the
icans are discovering
WOW Computer is. The components are all the wonderful world of the Internet every
connected; all you do is plug it into an outlet day. Isnt it time you took part? Call now,
and your high-speed Internet connection. and a patient, knowledgeable product expert
surf the internet

Get current weather & news.
will tell you how you can try it in your home

for 30 days. If you are not totally satisfied,
simply return it within 30 days for a refund
of the product purchase price. Call today.
Call now for our special

introductory price!
Please mention promotional code 44483.
send and receive emails, and video chat

Keep up with family and friends.
1-877-718-2607
play games online

hundreds to choose from!
80332 Copyright 2012 by firstSTREET for Boomers and Beyond, Inc. All rights reserved.
Simple
navigation,
so you never
get lost!
New from
Thames & Hudson
FROM THE TRENCHES
Hunley Revealed
Sam Moorhead & David Stuttard

$34.95 | 288 pages | 73 illus.
he famed Confederate submarine H.L. Hunley, the first submarine ever to sink an enemy
ship, has finally been unveiled in its
entirety. Discovered in 1995 and raised
in 2000, the 40-foot-long wreck had
been supported by a steel framework
while archaeologists and conservators
studied and stabilized it. The sub was
finally rotated so the structure was no
Bill Manley
$16.95 paper | 160 pages | 47 illus.
Neanderthals in Color
I
Andrew Robinson
$17.95 paper | 168 pages | 40+ illus.
thamesandhudsonusa.com
Available wherever books are sold
18
longer needed to support it. This is the

first time it has been seen by anyone,
complete and unobstructed, since it
mysteriously went down with its eightman crew in 1864, just minutes after
sinking the USS Housatonic in Charleston Bay. The next step is a special bath
that will remove the salts and concretions that still cover the vessel.
SAMIR S. PATEL
n 1981, when Wil Roebroeks of

Leiden University was beginning
his archaeological career, he ran
across some red stains in the grayish
sediments on the floodplain of the Maas
River where his team was excavating.
The site, called Maastricht-Belvdre,
in The Netherlands, was occupied by
00,000
Neanderthals at least 200,000
years ago. Roebroekss
collected and stored
samples of the red
stains, and 30 years
later he received funding
ng
to analyze them. It became
came
apparent that he and his team
had discovered the earliest
rliest evidence of hominins usingg the mineral
iron oxide, also known as ocher. Until

now, the use of ocheras a red pigment
in rock paintings, an ingredient in glue,
and for tanning hides, among other
thingswas thought to be a hallmark
of modern human behavior. While
the manner in which the mineral was
used at Maastricht-Belvdre is something of a mystery,
m
the find has had an
impac
impact on the question of whether
och
ocher use represents modern
be
behavior. This whole debate
is now to some degree a
n
non-debate, Roebroeks says,
b
because Neanderthals were
al
already doing this 200,000
yyears ago.
ZACH ZORICH
ARC
Drought
Doomed
Angkor?
the region being more weathered during Angkorian times due to people using the land for intensive agriculture,
says Mary-Beth Day of Cambridge University, lead author of the study.
It is believed that Angkor, already
suering from deforestation and conflict with other kingdoms, overtaxed its
hydraulic system, which increased the

eects of the drought and precipitated
the citys decline. The study concludes
that the Khmer water management
system is an example of a sophisticated
technology that failed in the face of extreme environmental conditions.
ALDO FOE
JOURney into the heart of History

F E AT U R E D J O U R N E Y S
with
PRO FES SO R BO B BR IER
ngkor Wat, the seat of the

powerful Khmer Empire from
the ninth to fifteenth centuries, is famous for its haunting ruins
situated in Cambodias dense jungle.
The enigmatic nature of the empires
collapse has inspired researchers to dig
deep into Angkors remains for new
insights. In its heyday, Angkor relied
on an intricate engineered system of
canals, moats, embankments, and reservoirs. The largest reservoir, the West
Baray (below, at left), has recently pro-
EGYPT and Rome

in ENGLAND
June 15 - 24, 2012
OASES OF EGYPT
November 1 - 17, 2012
GREECE
With Professor Jennifer Tobin

May 12 - 27, 2012
CYPRUS & MALTA
With Professor Brett Whalen

June 3 - 15, 2012
BOLIVIA
With Professor John Janusek

June 5 - 20, 2012
PERU
Caral, Chanquillo, ChanChan

With Dr. Bill Sapp
June 23 - July 8, 2012
CHINAS SILK ROAD
With Professor Dru Gladney

August 18 - September 3, 2012
vided a clearer understanding of the decline of the city. According to a study

in Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences, a sediment core taken from
the West Baray reveals evidence of an
extended drought in the fourteenth
and fifteenth centuries.
We see that water levels from the
Baray dropped. We also see sediments in
www.archaeology.org
Since 1983, Far Horizons

has been designing unique
itineraries led by renowned
scholars for small groups of
sophisticated travelers who
desire a deeper knowledge of
both past and living cultures.
HIKE THE
INKA TRAIL
With Professor Anita Cook

August 10 - 22, 2012
EASTERN TURKEY
With Professor John France

September 8 - 23, 2012
TURKISH
TREASURES
With Professor Garrett Fagan

September 15 - 30, 2012
PUB CRAWL OF
GREAT BRITIAN
With Dr. James Bruhn

September 16 - 28, 2012
and much more!

India Cambodia & Laos Bali Scotland Myanmar Mongolia Ethiopia
Maya World Sri Lanka American Southwest Central Asia Easter Island
1-800-552-4575 www.farhorizons.com
19
FROM THE TRENCHES
An Elite Viking
Community
Written on Agate
rchaeologists have uncovered a Viking cemetery dating to the turn of the eleventh century
A.D. near the central Polish town of Bodzia. The
graveyard holds close to 50 peoplewarriors and their
familiesand consists of neatly arranged plots enclosed
by wooden fences, each containing up to three burials in
wooden caskets with iron fixtures.
Men were buried with weapons, including Viking langsax

(single-edged swords). Womens graves contained jewelry
made from glass, gold foil,
precious stones, and silver.
Other finds included silver
kaptogora (amulet containers,
left), glass ornaments, coins
throughout
Europe,
and the remains of silk
ffrom th
h t Western
W t
E
from the Far East.
We suppose the individuals buried in Bodzia belonged
to a small but high-status community, says project leader
Andrzej Buko, director of the Polish Academy of Sciences
Institute of Archaeology and Ethnology. In addition, he
says, Many of them probably came from abroad.
Evidence suggests the warriors emigrated from a nearby state in what is now Ukraine, though Buko concludes
from the quality of the weaponry and other characteristics
of the burials that the deceased had been absorbed into
the elite of the early Piast Dynasty. The Piasts ruled in
Poland from the ninth to the fourteenth centuries.
The finds support chronicles by Gallus Anonymous, Polands first historian, who described a military stronghold near
Bodzia with elite foreign warriorsperhaps these Vikings.
NOAH WEINER
20
talian archaeologists working at the sanctuary of TasSilg on Malta have discovered an agate fragment with
a Middle Babylonian cuneiform inscription dating to
the thirteenth or fourteenth century B.C. Found more than
1,500 miles from Mesopotamia, where cuneiform was u
used, it is the westernmost
example o
of the script ever found.
T
The fragment, which was
o
originally part of a crescentsh
shaped votive object mounted on a pole or hung on a rope,
mention
mentions the religious center of
Nippur, tthe moon god Sin, and
of at least five people. Acthe names o
project director Alberto Cacording to pro
dicult to know how and when
zzella, its dicu
the artifact arrive
arrived in Malta. He believes it
was probably plundered during a war, taken to Greece, and
then perhaps traded between the Mycenaean Greeks and the
Cypriot world, which at the time included Malta.
JARRETT A. LOBELL
Huts for Hunters
he transition from hunting and gathering in the Paleolithic period to sedentary agricultural lifestyles
in the Neolithic may have been a long process,
according to a research team working at Kharaneh IV, a
20,000-year-old site in Jordan. There, archaeologists uncovered the remains of two huts and plant and animal remains that show the site was occupied continually across a
thousand-year time spanbut only for several months at a
time. The landscape
is arid today, but back
then it was grassland
that provided stable
food sources, including herds of gazelle,
wild cereal grains and
other plants, and small
stands of trees that
provided more food
and hut-building materials. The study builds on evidence from
other sites in Jordan and Israel. We can actually say now, with
evidence, that there was a widespread pattern of people staying put in larger groups, and starting to build the environment
around them, says Lisa Maher of the University of California,
Berkeley, one of the lead archaeologists on the project.
ZACH ZORICH
Own a piece of the Wild West

An exclus
exclusive,
sive heirloom-quality
heirloom quality ring featuring
a genuine U.S. Indian Head Nickel
ACT
SUPP
NOW
LIES
ARE
LIMI
TED.
CRAFTED WITH
24K GOLD
PLATING AND
TURQUOISE
ENAMELING
CENTERPIECE IS A GENUINE
U.S. INDIAN HEAD NICKEL
OUR
COIN RING IS A STRICT LIMITED EDITION

DUE TO THE SCARCITY OF INDIAN HEAD NICKELS
Sides feature a
dramatic buffalo
portrait recalling the
Indian Head Nickels
reverse design
A BRADFORD EXCHANGE MINT EXCLUSIVE

NOT AVAILABLE ANYWHERE ELSE ... AND ONLY
FOR A LIMITED TIME!
Honor the spirit of Americas West
Comes
ome
m s in a handsome
han
ands
dsom
ds
om
presentation case
RESERVATION
NO MONEY NOW
PRIORITYAPPLICATION
RESERVATION SEND
CERTIFICATE
Long a collectors favorite, the classic LIMITED TIME OFFER

obverse design of the Indian Head Nickel was
th e
chosen to honor the proud Native American

heritage and spirit of Americas West.
M i nt
Expertly crafted with 24K gold plating and
9345 Milwaukee Avenue Niles, IL 60714-1393
turquoise enameling, the Indian Head Nickel
9 3 0 7 M Please
i l w a u kreserve
e e A v the
e n uXXX
e PRODUCT
N i l e s , I L NAME
6 0 7 1 4XXX
- 1 3 for
93
Ring features a genuineand increasingly
YES.
me as described in this announcement.
scarceU.S. Indian Head Nickel as its
Limit: one
per reserve
order. the Indian HeadPlease
YES.
Please
NickelRespond
Ring for Promptly
me as
centerpiece. Because each coin has its own
described in this announcement.
unique characteristics, each ring is a true oneLimit: one per order.
Please Respond Promptly
of-a-kind! Engraved inside is the inscription:
Indian Head Nickel: Honoring the American
Signature
West.
Mrs.
A hand-crafted jewelry exclusive ...
Mrs.
Mr.Mr.
Ms.Ms.
Name (Please Print Clearly)
Name (Please Print Clearly)
Actual Size
and a superb value
Your
Complete
Satisfaction
Address
Act now, and this genuine piece of American
Address
Guaranteed
history can be yours for just $129, payable
in three convenient installments of $43 To assure a proper t, a ring sizer CityCity
will be sent to you after your
each. To reserve your ring, backed by our
State
State
ZipZip
unconditional, 120-day guarantee, send reservation has been accepted.
01-00000-001-00000
no money now. Just return the Reservation
17-00176-001-E98091
$4.99and
shipping
and
service.
Limited-edition
restricted
to 95for
ring
days.
Certificate. But hurrythis is a limited www.bradfordexchange.com/ihr $9.00*Plus
shipping
service
per
item. Please
allow 4-6presentation
weeks after initial
payment
shipment.
Please
allow
4-8 weeks
after initial
for shipment. Sales subject to product avail 2011 Licensor Copyright here
Sales
subject
to product
availability
andpayment
order acceptance.
timewww.bradfordexchange.com
offer!
ability and order acceptance.
2011
BGE BGE
17-00176-001-BIBM
2011
01-00000-001-BI
CHOOSE LONG OR SQUARE COUPON FROM LAYERS

AND DELETE YELLOW BOX
WORLD ROUNDUP
UTAH: The
2010 blaze that
gutted the Provo
Tabernacle, a
meeting place
for members
of the Mormon
Church, created
an opportunity
to excavate the remains of the
citys first such building. The
old meetinghouse, which was
torn down on the site in 1919,
would have been the center of
religious and cultural life for the
pioneers who founded the city.
Finds include parts of the stone
foundation and stone frames that
held stained glass above the door.
MEXICO: Today we expect

labels on containers to
tell us what is inside.
Perhaps the ancient Maya
did as well. In a two-inchtall, 1,300-year-old flask
decorated with glyphs
reading the home of his/
her/its tobacco, chemical
analysis identified residue
from the breakdown of
nicotine. It is the first
physical evidence of Maya
tobacco, and the second
known example of Maya
truth-in-packaging,
after a cacao vessel that
underwent the same
analysis.
22
SCOTLAND: A project led by the

Royal Commission on the Ancient
and Historical Monuments of
Scotland asked residents of the
Outer Hebrides to report previously
unidentified archaeological remains
resulting in the possible discoveries
of a medieval village, a complex of
fish traps, and Neolithic pottery.
An aerial survey team currently is
following up on the reports, relying
on the low winter sun to highlight
remote archaeological features.
PERU: At two
tw mounds dating to
between 4,000 a
and 6,500 years ago,
dete
archaeologists have determined
how ancient
Peruvians liked their cornpopped and ground into
flour. Among the finds were starch grains, husks,
kernels, stalks, tassels, and cobs of species that leant
themselves to either popping or grinding. Before this
find, li
little if anything was
kn
known about how
c
corn was used in
tthese early years of
its cultivation.
DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO:

About 3,000 years ago, much of central
Africa changed from rain forest to
savanna, and its long been thought that
natural climate change was the cause.
Marine sediment cores from the mouth of
the Congo River suggest, however, that
forest clearance, intensive land use, and
increased soil erosion occurred at the
same timeimplicating Bantu-speaking
farmers, who began to spread across the
region at this time. Their forest clearing
for agriculture and iron smelting might
have contributed to the widespread shift
in central Africas environment.
T
TURKEY:
Getting a
b
bad piece of fruit is
ffrustratingits not like
y
you can return itbut few
w
would hire a magician to
c
curse the man who sold
it to you. In a well in the ancient
city of Antioch was a lead tablet
inscribed with a curse directed
at a greengrocer named Babylas,
according to the first published
translation. The curse, which may
actually have been authored by a
business rival almost 2,000 years
ago, insults his mothers polluted
womb and calls for the gods to
drown and chill his soul.
By Samir S. Patel
EGYPT: At the necropolis

of Qubbet el-Hawa in
Aswan, archaeologists
have uncovered hundreds
of mummies and a tomb
dating to the 12th Dynasty,
around 1830 B.C. Many of the
mummies and coffins come
from later reoccupations of
the older tomb, including
this delicately featured
and wonderfully preserved
wooden sarcophagus,
thought to contain someone
of high rank from the 18th
Dynasty (ca. 15501292 B.C.).
FROM THE CLASSICAL

CIVILIZATIONS OF
RUSSIA: A genetic study of the native

people of the Altai region of Siberiawhere
Kazakhstan, China, and Mongolia meet
shows an affinity between the people of the
region and Native
Americans, who
crossed from Asia
to North America
via land bridge as
early as 16,000
years ago. Study
of Y chromosomes suggest that Altaians and
Native Americans share a common ancestor
from not long before that time.
EUROPE...
TO THE MYSTERIES
OF THE
PA
PAPUA
NEW GUINEA:
A mysterious two-inchlo
long tool had scientists
b
baffled.
The 3,300-yearo gouge, made of a
old
r
rare
form of jade called
ja
jadeite,
was found on
E
Emirau Island. Its jadeite
is different from any
geologists had ever seen, with the
closest match being from distant
Mexico. A possible solution came
from an unpublished manuscript
by a German scientist who found
some strange rocks on the Irian
Jaya mainland (the Indonesian half
of New Guinea) 100 years ago.
Analysis is ongoing, but the finds
appear to be a close match.
ORIENT
Unique itineraries
start from $3,795 include:
SHORE EXCURSIONS
PRE/POST-CRUISE 4 & 5 STAR HOTEL STAYS
LAND EXTENSIONS IN ASIA
WINE WITH DINNER ON BOARD
EXPERT LECTURE PROGRAM
ON BOARD GRATUITIES
LOW COST ROUNDTRIP AIR & TRANSFERS
SPECIAL SINGLE PRICING
FOR BROCHURE & RESERVATIONS CALL
1-877-398-1460
CRUISES TO
CLASSICAL
CIVILIZATIONS
2012
D I S C OV E R T H E H I S T O RY,
A RT A N D C U LT U R E S O F
T H E A N C I E N T WO R L D
0758/05.11
WINTER 2012- 2013

INDIA &
SOUTHEAST ASIA
CRUISES TO
THE ORIENT
WINTER 201 2/13
VOYAGES TO ANTIQUITY
SPRING - FALL 2012

MEDITERRANEAN,
AEGEAN, ADRIATIC
& BLACK SEAS
AUSTRALIA: Marine archaeologists have

discovered the wreck of Royal Charlotte, a convict
and troop ship that wrecked on a reef in 1825. The
75 soldiers aboard, along with officers and family,
built up and huddled on a sandy cay for six weeks
while waiting for rescue. Researchers expect the
teak timbers, anchor, cannon, and other goods
found will help them better understand trade
between New South Wales, where the ship had
departed, and India, where it was headed before
returning to England.
www.archaeology.org
#


BOOK
EARLY &
SAVE
Visit www.voyagestoantiquity.com
Or contact your travel professional
Price is per person, double occupancy, cat N for Mediterranean. Low Cost round-trip
air (and transfers) applicable with cruise-tour purchase only and includes all
government taxes, fees and airline fuel surcharges, which may change at any time.
Special single pricing applicable to select categories and not available on all sailings.
All offers are subject to availability, capacity controlled and may be withdrawn at any time.
Ships Registry: Malta.
23
An aerial view shows the immense administrative building constructed around 500 B.C. and used until
the 2nd century A.D. as it appeared after more than 10 years of excavation. Early 2nd-century redslipped dishes, part of a set found in the buildings courtyard, were imported from coastal Syria.
24
The story of a site and a project
Excavating
Tel Kedesh
by Andrea Berlin and Sharon Herbert
In 1997, archaeologists Sharon Herbert and Andrea
Berlin began an excavation project at Tel Kedesh, an
enormous mound located in the rural interior of Israels
Upper Galilee region. More than a decade later, they
have completed the first phase of their work and reflect
on how the site brought them a story far dierent from
the one they had gone looking for.
ORTHERN ISRAEL, a region with multiple

border zones, has seen its share of modern
conflict. But a picture of what life was like
on this border in antiquity, especially during the period from Alexander the Great
through the revolt against Rome (ca.
330 B.C.A.D. 70), also years of political and religious unrest,
remained undrawn. In the mid-1990s, as we were each finishing long-term projects in Israel, we realized that Tel Kedesh
was the perfect place to investigate this question. Ancient
sources repeatedly describe it as a border sitebetween
Canaanites and Israelites in biblical times and between Phoenicians and Jews in the classical period. Today it lies along the
Israeli-Lebanese border, a location that saw several dramatic
battles during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.
Tel Kedesh is enormousmore than half a mile north to
south. It is a double mound, with an upper tell occupied since
the Early Bronze Age (3150
((31502300
2
B.C.) and a plateau-like
lower tell likely constructed in the Middle
Bronze Age ((23001550 B.C.). Since our
research interests
inte
focused on a relatively
short period
perio in the sites long history, we
hoped to devise
d
a strategy that would
allow us to
t reach those levels rapidly.
In 1997, we began by surveying the
entirety o
of the lower tell along two
broad nort
north-south and east-west transects. N
Next we excavated two small
test trenches to discover the
www.archaeology.org
eology.org
25
A magnetometric map (below)

completed in 1998 showed the
buildings outline and helped determine
where to dig the following year. A
panoramic view of the tell in 2010
(right) shows the completely excavated
complex. Artifacts including juglets
and loom weights (bottom) were found
on the floor of one of the main rooms
during the excavations first season.
sites uppermost geological profile, as well as the depth and

preservation of Hellenistic remains. The nature of what we
foundwhich we expected to be largely soil or a random array
of rockswould help determine which type of remote sensing
technique would be most eective.
To our surprise, less than three feet below the surface, we
found ourselves in a room with more than 20 intact vessels
and household objects scattered on the floor. The pots dated
to the second century B.C., the heart of the Hellenistic period.
There must have been a particular reason why so many complete items had been abandoned, but based on the evidence
available at the time, the remains in the room could not be
related to a specific historical event.
The test trenches also revealed intact limestone walls of
exactly the type that would show up best in a magnetometric
survey, which we carried out on the lower tell in February
1998. The resulting map showed something wholly unexpectedan approximately 20,000-square-foot outline at
the tells southeastern corner,
er, just to the east of the room
wed uncovered the year before.
fore. A single structure of
this size ought to be palatiall or administrative, but no
ancient historical source mentions
ntions Kedesh as a place
of such importance.
room next to the northwestern corner had a plastered floor,

several wine jars from the Greek island of Rhodes, and 14 huge
jars, almost five feet tall each, leaning against the walls. With
permission from the Israel Antiquities Authority, we took
the broken bottoms of two jars back to the United States for
residue analysis and discovered phytolithsmineral secretions
left by plants after they decayof Triticum aestivum (bread
wheat). It was clear that this building had been a storeroom
for wine and grainlots of grain. Each jar held almost 25 gallons, which, once ground into flour, would produce about 150
loaves of bread.
Additional surprises came to light around the corner where
we found more than 40 amphoriskoi (small, two-handled flasks)
and about 1,500 tiny stamped clay lumps, or bullae. The bullae
carry images including those of Greek deities, Seleucid kings,
and animals and symbols. They have string holes through the
sides and the neat linear impressions of papyrus on the back,
both indications that they originally sealed rolled-up papyrus
documents. The quantity of bullae in the room indicated that
it once housed a sizeable archive. While none of the documents survive, the bullae themselves
them
provide clues about
who sent the texts and who ocially approved them.
I
26
rchaeologists joke that the most

rchaeologi
1999, KNOWING THAT

T we needed
to explore that huge outline
line and
determine if it were one building
or groups of smaller structures,
es, we
began our first full excavation
ation
season. Digging in the opposing
sing
southeastern and northwestern
tern
corners revealed that it wass
one enormous complex. The
important di
discoveries occur on the
last days of aan excavation season, and
what happened: We found
thats exactly w
with less than a week to
the bullae w
go in 1999. There was no
time to clean them all or fintim
ish excavating the room in
is
which theyd been found, so
w
these were the top priorith

ARCH
ties when we returned the next summer. By the end of the

season, the total number of excavated bullae was more than
2,000. We christened this the Hellenistic Administrative
Building, on the basis of the granary and the archive, both
administrative features.
HE HUNDREDS OF useful objects that were left behind

in the building, including more than 20 Rhodian wine
jars, continued to confirm our first impression, from
1997, that it had been abandoned very quickly. The wine
vessels have handles stamped with the names of ocials,
each of whose tenures can be dated with greatt
accuracy. The latest jars date to 144 or 143 B.C.
According to 1 Maccabees 11:6373, at that time
there was a battle in the valley below the Kedesh
plateau between the Hasmonean leader Jonathan
(the Hasmoneans were a family of high priests and
kings who ruled the Jewish state of Judea between
167 and 37 B.C.) and the Seleucid king Demetrius.
Jonathans forces pursued the Seleucids to Kedesh,
h,
re
killed many, and camped there for several days before
ly
leaving for Jerusalem. It appears that the hastily
abandoned remains found throughout the building are a result

of that battle.
HE SECOND INTIFADA, a period of intensified Palestin-
ian-Israeli violence that began in September 2000 and

ended in 2005, derailed excavation plans for 2001. In
fact, we were unable to return to the site for five years. Beginning again in 2006, we had four productive excavation seasons
that produced many incredible finds and advanced our understa
standing of the building. In 1999 and 2000, we had found
bro
broken column shafts from an earlier structure incorporated
in
into the walls of the Hellenistic building. Further excavation
almost 10 years later in the structures eastern half uncovered tw
two long foundations with circles lightly incised on
th
the stones. These were, in eect,setting marks for
placing
p
the columns, allowing us to reconstruct a
colonnaded
c
entry court that belonged to that earlier
li building phase. Associated pottery and small
finds date to the Achaemenid Persian period (ca.
540332
5
B.C.). Thus we renamed the structure
th Persian-Hellenistic Administrative Building
the
an dated its initial construction to 500 B.C., when
and
the Persian king Cyrus permitted exiled
xiled
Jud
Judeans in Babylon to return to Jerusasalem
lem, as told in Ezra 1.
Se
Several special finds reflect the
character
chara
of the culture that inhabited
the region
re
at the time. These include
a beautifully
beau
carved green jasper scarab
with a helmeted oriental head (right); two
small conical glass stamp seals, both likely worn
n
Student Scott Thompson (left) excavates in a storeroom
containing huge grain jars. In the adjacent room, dozens of
small two-handled flasks (above) and about 1,500 stamped clay
lumps, or bullae (below), used to seal documents, were found.
Artifacts of Administration
2,000 bullae found in the

archive room at Tel Kedesh, there were many identifiable imprinted seals, both ocial and personal. These
include seals belonging to kings Antiochus III (324261 B.C.)
and Antiochus IV (ca. 215164 B.C.), who ruled a vast empire
founded by Seleucus I, one of Alexander the Greats generals, that stretched from Anatolia (modern Turkey) to central
MONG THE MORE THAN
www.archaeology.org
Asia. Seals of the city council of Tyre, a Phoenician city on

the southwestern coast of modern Lebanon, as well as several
seals belonging to both male and female private citizens and
possibly the Phoenician governor of the region, were among
the finds. A seal belonging to the city of Kedesh itself, with an
image of a cluster of grapes and a shaft of wheat and the citys
Greek name, Kudissos, was excavated as well.
27
archive complex. South of the courtyard are

utility and cooking areas. Several rooms here
contain plastered bins of various shapes and
sizes, perhaps for collecting and measuring
agricultural products. East and north of the
courtyard, three rooms form an impressive
reception and dining area. Two of these have
monochromatic mosaic floors, the earliest
firmly dated mosaic floors yet found in Israel.
A blue glass stamp seal, left to right: seen from the side; the stamp itself; the
stamps impression in plasticine; an artists rendering of the stamps image.
The floor of the third and largest room was
removed in antiquity, but we think it, too,
was probably mosaic. The rooms walls have carefully molded
as amulets, each with a version of the Master of Animals motif
and brightly colored painted plaster. We also found sets of
long popular in the Near East; and, finally, a clay bulla that had
red- and black-slipped dishes that petrographic and chemical
been stamped by a seal whose Neo-Babylonian style and design
analyses indicate were imports from the area around Antioch,
appear on many seals in a late fifth-century B.C. commercial
archive discovered in the Mesopotamian city of Nippur in
the Seleucid capital far to the north.
1893. Our current hypothesis is that the Persian-period buildWhen taken all together, the archive where the bullae were
ing belonged to well-connected ocials from Tyre and that it
found, the granary, and the collection bins all suggest the presfunctioned as both an agricultural depot and an impressive
ence of imperial ocials with administrative responsibilities,
marker of territory. The discovery of a substantial Phoenician
such as tax collecting. Taxation was an ever-present fact of
life under the Hellenistic monarchies, but its rare to find
foothold in inland Upper Galilee provides a rare opportunity
the actual location where the ocials worked and collection
to consider native life under imperial Persian rule. It also has
occurred. The buildings trac patterns, which we have been
implications for understanding the biblical authors of this era,
able to reconstruct, show limited access between working areas
especially the work of the Chronicler, a writer who lived in the
and the reception rooms. In the former we found mostly plain
fifth century B.C. In his retelling of the history of the Jewish
pottery for cooking, food preparation, and storage, while in
people, the Chronicler also frequently reframed relationships,
the latter we uncovered beautiful dishes and decorated lamps
especially those between the kings of Judah and the kings of
to adorn dining tables. Visiting ocials may have carried docuPhoenicia, always to the advantage of Judah. He may have
ments to Kedesh and then enjoyed a fine meal before going
been trying to imagine away the presence of this enormous,
Phoenician-administered building deep within territory that
on their way.
earlier biblical texts identify as Israelite.
FTER SIX YEARS OF excavation, we thought we knew
HE PERSIAN-HELLENISTIC Administrative Building
the site completely, and yet, the last day of our last field
seems to have been briefly abandoned in the late
season still had one incredible surprise in store. While
fourth century B.C., when Alexander the Great began
we were preparing for aerial photography, a student spotted a
his march down the Phoenician coast. But after a short period
large, perfectly round disk in some soil that had accumulated
of time, perhaps no more than 10 or 15 years, it was reoccuon the eastern wall of the granary. Although the disk was covpied by ocials of the newly empowered empire of Ptolemaic
ered in dirt, a bright glint along one of its edges caught his eye.
Egypt. From this point on, By the end of 2010, the team was able to identify the activities that
Upon picking up the artifact,
from approximately 300 took place in each of the buildings sectors.
he knew immediately from
its heft that he was holdB.C. until the battle between
ing a solid gold coin. When
Jonathan and Demetrius in
he brought the coin to our
144 or 143 B.C., the building
was continuously occupied
attention, we were able to
and often remodeled to suit
identify it as a mnaieion (a
its various inhabitants. By
one-mina coin, equivalent
the end of our 2010 seato 100 silver drachmas, or a
son, about 75 percent of
mina of silver) of the Egypthese Hellenistic levels had
tian ruler Ptolemy V, struck
been excavated and we were
in the year 191190 B.C. at
able to identify what went
the imperial mint of Kition
on in the buildings various
on Cyprus. The mnaieion
sectors. A large open-air
is the largest gold coin ever
courtyard dominates the
found in Israel and only the
western half. To the north
second example of this issue
and west lie the granary and
found anywhere.
28
This room (left, top) contained large bins

for collecting and measuring agricultural
products. An official reception space (left,
below), featured walls covered in painted
plaster (inset). A gold coin (left, bottom)
was found near the wall of one of the grain
storage rooms.
sim
simply
too large in value.
It might have belonged
tto a high-ranking Ptoleemaic official, who
would have traveled to
wo
Kedesh to meet with one
Ked
of his Seleucid counterparts
and br
brought the coin as a
diplomatic gift. The findspot
diplomat
within a w
wall of the granary suggests that it had been stolen and
hidden, likely by somebody who
worked in this part of the complex.
Tel
Kedesh to investigate life on
the border more than 2,000
years ago. No ancient author recorded
an ocial presence here and it occupied
an area and a time outside the pages of
history. Tel Kedesh, until 1997, remained
unexcavated and the surrounding region
largely unexplored. Our curiosity about
this border area led to the discovery of a
building of enormous size and complexity, and its expensive decoration and the
vari
variety and quantity of artifacts uncovered have revealed a
do
dominating administrative presence in the Kedesh valley
aand the Upper Galilee lasting nearly 350 years. Now that
tthe excavation phase of the project is at an end and we
work through the thousands of objects we discovered, we
w
aare asking questions that only archaeological evidence can
aanswer: How did provincial elites and the workers who
catered to them live? What was the relationship between
ca
thi
this ocial collection complex and nearby settlements? Did
status items and the cosmopolitan culture they represent
stat
trickle out, or did local ocials live in a kind of elite bubble,
tric
with their own supplies of specialty goods? And perhaps
most interesting, how do the social, economic, and cultural
conditions reflected in the architecture and artifacts relate
to periods of political calm and turmoil? As we turn from the
excitement of excavation to the necessity of final report writing, we must now shift our focus from looking for artifacts
to looking for answers.
E ORIGINALLY
ORIGI
CAME TO
The appearance of this coin at Kedesh is a reflection of the

periods power politics. By the time of its issue, the Seleucid
kings controlled this portion of the southern Levant, having won it after a series of wars against the Ptolemies, the
Macedonian kings of Egypt who ruled from 305 to 30 B.C.
Nonetheless, for approximately the first 20 years of their rule,
the Seleucids maintained the region as a Ptolemaic monetary
zone, probably as a kind of diplomatic courtesy. Their actions
may also have been intended to maintain market confidence,
communicating that despite the change in ruling regimes,
the older currency would still be honored. The gold mnaieion
was certainly not a coin used as regular currencyit was
www.archaeology.org
Andrea Berlin is a professor of archaeology at Boston University;

at the time of the Tel Kedesh field seasons she was at the University
of Minnesota. Sharon Herbert is a professor of archaeology at the
University of Michigan.
29
Ancient
Germanys
Metal Traders
A postCold War construction
boom is exposing evidence of a
powerful Bronze Age culture
by Andrew Curry
Weapon hoards dating to

around 3,000 years ago, such as
these bronze ax heads uncovered
by a bulldozer near the German town of
Dermsdorf, have been discovered throughout
Central Europe. The hoards indicate that the
metal trade was a major source of wealth and
power in the area during the Bronze Age.
May 11, 2011, Mario

Kssner looked on as a bulldozer shaved a
layer of soil a few inches deep from a roadside field near the eastern German village
of Dermsdorf. Kssner, a sta archaeologist
for the state of Thuringia, was brought in
before the scheduled construction of a highway on-ramp would
begin. He knew that his team of archaeologists was working atop
a medieval site, but the bulldozer uncovered something even
more surprisinga handful of dull green ax heads lying in the
soil. For the rest of that day, the bulldozer was banished as the
archaeologists meticulously dug the site by hand. Their careful
work revealed a clay jar standing a foot-and-a-half tall packed
with 100 bronze ax heads dating to the Bronze Agemore
than 3,000 years ago. The ax heads would have represented a
tremendous amount of wealth at a time when bronze was in high
N THE MORNING OF
30
demand for weapons and tools. What they were doing buried
outside of Dermsdorf became the question.
We had had signs of a settlement from the Middle Ages,
but we had no clue there were Bronze Age finds, says Kssner.
Before uncovering the ax heads, the only things the team had
turned up were post moldsdark stains in the soil that show
where wooden posts had once been planted as a frame for a
house. With the discovery of the axes, Kssner and his team
began taking a harder look at the surrounding area. Soon they
found more post molds, dozens of them, enough to trace where
the walls of a structure 35 feet wide and nearly 150 feet long
had been. Based on the width of the walls and the spacing of
the posts, Kssner estimates that the roofs peak would have
been nearly 30 feet above the ground. Inside the walls, a double
row of posts ran the length of the building, creating a central
chamber. Altogether, the structure covered 5,000 square feet,
making it the biggest Bronze Age structure discovered north

of the Alps. The ax heads were buried at the southern end of
the house, where the front door might once have been.
The Dermsdorf house is similar to another building that was
discovered about 60 miles away in 1996 by Saxon Archaeological Heritage Oce researcher Harald Steuble. That site, in
Zwenkau, near Leipzig, contained the remains of more than 40
houses between 60 and 90 feet longand one massive building
rivaling the Dermsdorf house in length, if not width. Steuble
says the appearance of a second structure of that size shows that
huge houses of this sort may have been an important feature
in Bronze Age villages across the region. Theyre very rare.
Surely they were functionally dierent from the other, smaller
structures, but its hard to know exactly how, Steuble says.
As the summer wore on, the team found evidence that the
Dermsdorf house was the center of a settlement that stretched
www.archaeology.org
for miles. A few hundred yards away was a cemetery with dozens of burials. At least two other Bronze Age villages were also
found within a mile of Dermsdorf as part of the rescue excavations for the highway construction. The villages and burial
sites all date to within a century of each other and are part of
what has proven to be a densely settled Bronze Age landscape.
Y THE LATTER HALF of the twentieth century, historical circumstances had brought research on Germanys
prehistory to a halt. In the 1930s, some impressive finds
at sites dating to the Bronze Age and earlier became part of
the Nazi propaganda narrative. The Nazis claimed that the
archaeological sites were proof of a prehistoric German nation
stretching across most of Europe. The Nazis tried to prove all
culture was from Germany, which was a joke, Kssner says.
Researchers of the time went so far as to measure the skel-
31
This collection of bronze artifacts found in Germany in 1904

includes neck rings and weapons that are typical of the
netice
culture.
etons found in Bronze Age graves to show that the people had
been Nordic, in an eort to prove an ancestral link to modern
Germans. Nazi propaganda claimed European culture originated in Germany, then spread south, Kssner says. German
archaeology is for meindigenous, blood-bound Germanic and
Indo-Germanic prehistory, wrote Hans Reinerth, the Reich
Deputy of German Prehistory. Our spadework has the preeminent goalof illuminating our hitherto neglected indigenous
prehistory, he continued. After the war, German archaeologists
stayed away from studying sites in their own nation in order to
avoid being associated with the Nazis and their dubious science.
They ruined it for another 50 years, Kssner adds.
After the Berlin Wall was torn down in 1989, infrastructure
investment poured into the former East Germany. Since then,
construction of new highways, train tracks, gas pipelines, and
power lines has been preceded by archaeological surveys and
digs intended to recover parts of the past before construction
erases them forever. The study of the German Bronze Age has
boomed once again, thanks in part to rescue excavations like
the one at Dermsdorf.
Carbon dating, ceramics analysis, and burial practices
suggest that the Dermsdorf sites belonged to the ntice
culture, which dated from 2300 to about 1600 B.C. As soon
as the Dermsdorf graves were opened Kssner could see the
people had been buried in the ntice style. Theyre buried
in a fetal position, always lying on their right sides with their
32
heads pointed south, Kssner says. That way theyre looking toward the rising sun. ntice-style ceramic vessels with
concave sides were also found at the site.
The ntice culture was first identified at a site near Prague
in the 1870s. Since then, ntice artifacts have turned up
at sites in the Czech Republic, Germany, and Poland. The
ntice people were adept metal workers, producing distinctive styles of ax heads, daggers, and a type of spearhead called
a halberd, which could be used for both stabbing and slashing.
The ntice people controlled the area around the only known
source of tin on the continent. Tin is an important ingredient
in manufacturing bronze, which put the ntice people in a
good position to control a large part of the European metal
trade. ntice dominates the routes from north to south,
says Harald Meller, head of the State Museum of Prehistory
in the nearby town of Halle. In the Bronze Age, you needed
copper and tin, the same way you need lithium for the battery
of your iPhone.
Grave goods recovered from ntice sites show the extent
of their trade networks. Amber, finely worked flint knives, and
reindeer antler connect archaeological sites in the region to
Denmark, northern Poland, and Sweden. Metal axes similar
to those found in what is now Hungary and Romania are also
found in ntice graves. Broad-bladed bronze axes, shaped in
a style best known from Scotland and Ireland, have also turned
up. All of the trade moving through their territory made the
ntice people wealthy, especially their rulers.
WO MILES FROM the Dermsdorf house and cemetery is
a saddle-shaped burial mound first excavated in 1877.

Named for the nearby town of Leubingen, the 30-foottall mound, perched on a windy hill, was the final resting place
of a wealthy chieftain. Tree ring analysis puts the date of the
burial at 1942 B.C.
The chieftain was one of the Bronze Age super-rich. A trove
of gold artifacts and bronze axes and swords surrounded his
body. One of the gold arm rings found in the grave weighed
One of the wealthiest netice

culture graves was a 30
foot-tall burial mound excavated in 1877 near Leubingen,
Germany, which held the remains of a chieftain.
more than a pound. The Leubingen chieftain and the people who built the Dermsdorf house all lived within a few generations
of each other. Kssner says the men and
women buried in the Dermsdorf cemetery
could have been the grandparents or parents
of the people who erected the Leubingen
burial mound.
There are only a handful of similar grave
mounds in the area, suggesting that the
ntice culture had a definite hierarchy.
We know it was a stratified society, Kssner says. People with political or religious
power had a better life. In contrast to the
occupant of the burial mound, the people
buried at the Dermsdorf cemetery had
much simpler graves than the chieftains.
They were buried with some ceramic
pots, shell beads, maybe some small bronze
piecesa pin, a ring, Kssner says. But
nothing like the immense riches we found
in the house or in the grave mound.
mendous amount of metal, especially in an

age when just one bronze tool was a rarity.
Bronze was still new and very valuable in
these societies, says Steuble.
Kssner believes that the hoard was left
where it was on purpose, not hidden for
w
safekeeping and then forgotten. The pot
was buried where the lack of post molds
w
suggests an opening in the houses wall or a
doorway. The vessels central location means
everyone who went through the door had to
pass over it. The hatchets might have been
p
buried ceremonially or perhaps covered up
b
and then revealed on ceremonial occasions.
Meller thinks they might have been a sacriM
fice. Some archaeologists speculate that the
abundance and uniformity of the hundreds
of early Bronze Age hoards spread throughERMANYS BEST KNOWN
out central Europeall axes in some places,
Bronze Age artifact
all daggers in otherspoint to deliberate
might have been made by
ritual. Tilmann Vachta, an expert in Bronze
the grandchildren of the people
Age
A hoards at the German Archaeological
who built the Dermsdorf house.
Institute, says, If you placed a dot for each
Barely a foot across, the Nebra
hoard
on the map of this region, it would be
N A BRIGHTLY LIT LAB on the first floor
h
sky disc was discovered in 2000.
black
with
them. Meller observes, Theyre
of the Thuringian State Preservation The five-pound disc bears images
b
not
building
temples, theyre not building
Oce in Weimar, Kssner arranges
of the sun, moon, and 32 stars, all
holy
places.
Instead
theyre sacrificing masdrawer after drawer of the ax heads from
h
embossed in gold leaf. A cluster of
sive
amounts
of
metal
to the gods.
Dermsdorf on a table. Before removing
seven starsrepresenting the PleBurying
the
axes
in
such a heavily trafthe axes from the clay pot, authorities had
iades constellation, which appears
the pot scanned at a lab in Berlin using
ficked area probably held some significance
in the sky in the Northern Hemicomputed tomography. The scan produced
for the people of Dermsdorf. Everyone
sphere around the autumnal
a three-dimensional image of the contents
would
w
have known the bronze was there,
equinox and signals the arrival
exact placement inside the vessel.
Kssner says. The question is: why was it
of harvest seasonis the oldest
On a nearby screen, Kssner calls up an
l
left?
Because the pot was buried essentially
astronomical representation ever
image of the scan (below). Outlined in green
u
under
the houses front doorstep, Kssner
discovered.
and black are the 100 bronze ax heads, neatargues that the house may have been some
The disc, which is displayed in
sort of ritual center for the surrounding
a dedicated hall in Halles State
settlements. The number of axes may have
Museum of Prehistory, was uncovheld
ered by treasure hunters near the
h some kind of meaning, he says, but so
far it is unclear what that meaning might
eastern German town of Nebra
have
been.
and put up for sale on the black
h
Kssner hopes to continue working
market. To get it back, Swiss
at Dermsdorf. He wants to scan the soil
police set up an elaborate sting
around Dermsdorf to find the outlines of
operation together with local
the settlement and, based on those results,
archaeologist Harald Meller. Its
p
perhaps
dig some test trenches. A fragment
the first realistic depiction of the
of antler found at the Dermsdorf house is
heavens ever, Meller says, and
b
being
carbon-dated to establish the buildsuch a thing isnt seen again till
ings age as closely as possible. For now,
the days of Kepler and Galileo.
there are no further excavations planned
ly arranged with smaller pieces toward the bottom and larger
though new results could change that, Kssner says. In the
ones on top. The ax headsmost palm-sized and designed to
meantime, construction work continues. One way or another,
fit through a hole drilled in a piece of wood or antlerwere
the house will soon disappear beneath asphalt, and cars may
the all-purpose weapons and tools of the day. You could fell
be driving over the site by the summer of 2013.
a tree with one of these, and just as easily crack a skull, he
says, hefting one. Each weighs about half a pound. It is a treAndrew Curry is a contributing editor at Archaeology.
The Nebra
Sky Disc
Under Bronze
Age Heavens
www.archaeology.org
33
Inside a laboratory
of the oceanographic
vessel Jean Charcot,
an array of screens
display sonar images
of the wreck of
Titanic, part of the
effort to create the
first comprehensive
archaeological
map of the site.
Archaeology
of Titanic
It has been 100 years since it sank, and 27
years since it was rediscovered. Now the wreck
of Titanic has nally become what it was
always meant to be: an archaeological site.
by James P. Delgado
T THE BOTTOM OF THE
ocean, centuries pass

with little occurring
in the way of incident.
But on April 15, 1912,
deep in the Atlantic,
375 miles southeast of Halifax, Nova
Scotia, that changed. A massive steel
structure, after falling for more than
two miles, hit the silt and drove into
thick clay beneath. Silt bloomed as
the sound of the impact reverberated
in the darkness. Other pieces of the
worlds largest passenger steamship followed like a heavy rain. The bow came
in fast, nose first, plowing a deep furrow into the clay. Over the next several
hours, fragments of the hull, dishes,
machinery, and linoleum tilesand the
remains of peoplesettled across miles
of seabed. What had once been a floating city was fragmented and scattered
two and a half miles down. More than
1,500 people lost their lives.
Slowly but inexorably, the processes
of the deep sea went to work. Marine
organisms and acidic clay consumed
wood and other organic material, including human remains. Bacteria colonized
and began to eat away at the steel, leaving behind tendrils and puddles of red,
orange, and yellow byproducts. The

ships crisp angles blurred and the proud
name on the bow, Titanic, dissolved. Silt
slowly accumulated on intact paneling,
doors still on their hinges, and a metal
bed frame with a nightgown draped over
it. In 1912, Thomas Hardy imagined,
in a poem lamenting Titanic, Over the
mirrors meant/To glass the opulent/The
sea-worm crawlsgrotesque, slimed,
dumb, indierent. Intact compartments and cabins that had once been
filled with air, light, and passengers
were full of water pressurized to 6,000
pounds per square inch and seemingly alien life. Over decades, the wreck
became a haven for deep-sea creatures
such as ghost crabs, crinoids, and
wormsa series of reefs in what had
once been a deep-sea desert.
Seventy-three years after the sinking,
in the early morning of September 1,
1985, Argo, an unmanned deep-sea vehicle, disturbed the darkness for the first
time. Argo, carrying video cameras and
sonar, was towed at the end of miles of
coaxial cable by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) ship
Knorr. Argo sent back to the ship grainy,
real-time images from the deepthe
first the world had seen of Titanic since
35
Titani departs Southampton, England, on

Titanic
April 10, 1912, five days before the ship struck
an iceberg
ic
and sank in the North Atlantic.
black-andwhite photographs depicted it departing the Irish coast in 1912. Humans first visited the wreck
the following year in the research submersible Alvin, peering
out of small portholes. In 1987, another submersible, Nautile,
glided over the site, and with a robotic arm carefully picked
up the first of 1,800 artifacts it would recover from the mud
during that expedition.
Since then, a new era has dawned in our quest to study the
past that lies at the bottom of the ocean. In 2010 two highly
sophisticated robotic vehicles systematically crisscrossed the
seabed on their own, with high-resolution sonar and camera
systems, creating the first comprehensive map of the Titanic
site. Another robot, at the end of a fiber-optic cable, sent to
the surface live, full-color, 3-D images, allowing scientists to
virtually walk the decks of the ship. This latest research eort,
of which I was a part, represents a paradigm shift in underwater archaeology. For the first time, Titanic can be treated and
explored like any other underwater siteeven extreme depth
is no longer an obstacle to archaeology. Thanks to rapid technological advances and interdisciplinary work, archaeologists
have a whole new perspective on sites such as Titanic, and new
questions to ask, questions we never could have dreamed of
when underwater archaeology began just 50 years ago.
ROUND THE TIME THAT deep-sea technology was first
developing, so was underwater archaeology. Its specific techniques and methods began to emerge in the
late 1950s, through pioneers such as Jacques Yves Cousteau,
Frederic Dumas, Peter Throckmorton, Honor Frost, and
George Bass. Their work culminated in Bass first complete
underwater excavation of a shipwrecka Bronze Age vessel
at Cape Gelidonya, Turkeyin 1960. When asked by col-
36
leag
leagues
whether proper archaeology could
be done
d
underwater, Bass said that archaeology was archaeology, regardless of where it
was performed. Since then, thousands of
wa
underwater archaeological sites, from shipun
wrecks to prehistoric sites to submerged
wr
cities, have been located, documented, and
cit
excavated. And advanced diving, especially
ex
mixed-gas technology, has allowed divers
m
to go deeper and stay longer, without the
muddling eects of pressurized air on the
m
brain. However, deep sites still lay beyond
b
tthe reach of divers.
Ironically, the first steps in expanding
underwater
archaeology to the depths
u
were propelled by the Titanic disaster
itself, as the first sonar systems were
developed and tested after the sinking to
locate and avoid iceb
icebergs. This technology improved through
the two world wars an
and into the Cold War, moving into deeper
waters, until its most dramatic discovery to dateTitanic. But
even in 1985, the idea that Titanic could be explored, photographed, and mapped like an archaeological site seemed like
the stu of science fiction.
The introduction of the global positioning system (GPS)
was the next big step, providing a platform on which to integrate sonar data with increasingly sophisticated maps and
satellite imagery. Better robotic systems also evolved, as well
as manned submersibles that could travel even deeper than
Titanic. But the submersibles are hardly the same as diving
on a site. They are built on Cold War technology, with tiny
crew compartments surrounded by life support, thrusters,
batteries, lights, cameras, and sonar systems. Lying face down,
neck craned upward in the cold, dark capsules, scientists peer
through small portholes and rely on deployed instruments and
mechanical arms to interact with the environment outside.
My first submersible dive was in 2000, in a Russian Mirclass sub, to assess the wreck and cultural tourism at the
Titanic site. I was struck by both the extreme conditions and
the incredible skill that these unsung pilots need to safely
launch, dive, navigate, and ascend. As submersible pilot PaulHenry Nargeloet of the salvage and exhibition company RMS
Titanic Inc. noted, those missions to Titanic were merely
glimpses through a keyhole. I spent my submersible dive
with my forehead pressed for hours against the cold steel of
a Mir hull to stare through four-inch-thick PlexiglasI know
exactly what he means. Each of those dives added incrementally to our knowledge of Titanic, but the ability to do a basic
detailed survey, map with accuracy, and measurelet alone
impose the archaeological discipline of a grid and units, as
one would on a divable underwater siteremained elusive.
After my 2000 visit to Titanic, I wrote in ARCHAEOLOGY

magazine:
We see scoop marks that show where selected pieces have
been plucked from clusters of artifactsno grids, no scientific
samplingsimply for their display or monetary value. What is
happening here, two-and-one-half miles down and out of sight of
much of the world, is not archaeology. . . . In short, other than the
well-known intact bow section and the stern and the sub pilots
recollections, no detailed road map, let alone a highly detailed
archaeological site plan, exists.
Photos of Titanic had been taken and artifacts collected, but
none of these activities reflected the process by which we apply
scientific methods to the study of the past. To actually study
the wreck, and the lives of the people on the ship, we would
need a detailed site map that we could visit again and again,
with ever-more sophisticated questions. Could such a map be
created not only for the largest featuresthe bow and stern
sectionsbut also for artifacts ranging from boilers and hull
sections, down to a teacup, bottle, or button? Could we catalog
the sites smallest constituents in a nondestructive way? Could
we discern the site formation processdetermine exactly how
the pieces of the ship and its contents came to their resting
places? And did the salvage of artifacts from the site compromise its archaeological integrity and render archaeological
technique and method moot? The 2010 Titanic expedition,
led by David Gallo of WHOI, set out to answer these questions and establish that archaeological science beyond mere
observation could be conducted at crushing depths.
OLLOWING THE DISCOVERY OF the wreck in 1985,

there were opposing views on what should be done
with it. In the United States, Congress passed the RMS
Titanic Memorial Act at the urging of oceanographer Robert
Ballard, who led the expedition that discovered the wreck.
It recommended that the site be left untouched as a memorial. But because Titanic rests in international waters, it was
under no nations jurisdictionunder admiralty law, Titanic
was open to anyone with the right equipment and technical
expertise to reach it. The act also gave the National Oceanic
and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), working with the
Department of State, the task of negotiating an international
agreement on Titanic and developing guidelines for appropriate
activities on the site, a process that took a decade and a half.
As this discussion was taking place, beginning in 1987, a
private American company formed by investors and known
as Titanic Ventures Limited Partnership (now Premier Exhibitions, with the Titanic artifacts handled by subsidiary RMS
Titanic Inc.), began diving to the wreck with codiscoverers
IFREMER, Frances deep-sea agency, to recover artifacts and
photograph the ship. Working from submersibles, over seven
expeditions between 1987 and 2004, RMS Titanic Inc. ultimately raised some 5,000 artifacts, with the aim of displaying
them for profit. Their activities were controversial. In 1987,
the London Daily Express called the recovery dives Vandalism
for Profit. A 1988 editorial in Discover magazine was titled,
We All Loot in a Yellow Submarine. Guest columnists
www.archaeology.org
squared o in the pages of USA Today: Salvaging Artifacts Is

an Insult to the Dead versus Salvaging Artifacts Brings the
Legend to Life. Public opinion remains divided. While newspaper columnists, cartoonists, and archaeologists decried the
practice, countless people have lined up to visit RMS Titanic
Inc.s touring artifact exhibitions.
The furor over the recovery of artifacts from Titanic is
understandable. The greater concerns for archaeology, however, are how and why the artifacts were removed, and what
would become of them. Were they being appropriately conserved, cataloged, and researched? Would they ultimately go
under the hammer at auction, artifact by artifact? The legal
history of Titanic and RMS Titanic Inc. is long and complex.
The U.S. District Court in Norfolk, Virginia, which for two
decades has overseen the salvage companys activities under
admiralty law, decided a number of these questions. Rulings by
the court have limited recovery to artifacts scattered outside
the intact bow and stern sections. At one stage, RMS Titanic
Inc. sued the Departments of State and Commerce unsuccessfully to stop publication of the International Agreement
on Titanic guidelines. Most recently the court awarded RMS
Titanic Inc. title to the 5,000 artifacts, with the stipulation
that the company follow international standards for conservation, treatment, and display of the collection. Furthermore, any
sale of the artifacts would be subject to review by the court,
and allowed only if the collection stays together and is maintained for public display and study. (As ARCHAEOLOGY went
to press, the results of a sealed-bid auction were scheduled to
be announced on April 11, 2012, days before the 100th anniversary of the sinking.)
Amid the years of legal battles and publicity, in 1997 I
participated in an independent review of the work that had
been done on the Titanic site for the International Congress
of Maritime Museums. The review was prompted by concerns
of the international museum and archaeological communities
over the impending display of recovered Titanic artifacts at
the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich, England. Larry
Murphy of the National Park Service, Roger Knight of the
National Maritime Museum, and I were surprised to learn that
though RMS Titanic Inc.s artifact recoveries had been selectivefor iconic, intact, and, at times, random artifactsthey
had been conducted with great skill. The recoveries had been
documented by video, and additional data existed, we were
told, to create a map of where the artifacts had come from.
RMS Titanic Inc. had also conducted studies in 1996 of
the wreck and its environment, such as a sonar survey through
the mud to assess now-buried damage to the hull that may be
from the iceberg impact, and an ongoing assessment of the
biological corrosion by microbiologist Roy Cullimore and his
colleagues to determine how long Titanic would remain intact.
Ballard and NOAA also jointly examined the site and the
remains of the bow and stern, and film director James Cameron
explored the interior, revealing much about the ship and what
happened inside it the evening that it sank.
Much data had been gathered since Titanics rediscovery,
but the scope of the entire site remained largely unknownwe
37
had no detailed knowledge of the whole, and didnt even know

how large it was. The keyhole views of the wreck had not
described or defined the scattered field of artifacts, for example. Understanding Titanic from these eorts was like driving
through a city at night, in a rainstorm, peering through a portion of the windshield, and trying to piece together in your
minds eye what the headlights revealed around each corner.
But by 2010, with the latest technology and the right team, a
comprehensive, finely detailed site map was finally in reach. A
decade after my first visit to Titanic in 2000, I returned with
the best-equipped and most experienced group of scientists
and technicians ever assembled for such a project.
The result was a multiagency expedition, including
WHOI, the Waitt Institute, Phoenix International, NOAA,
and the National Park Service, that would develop a detailed
archaeological site plan and report. The new eort also
includes a Titanic Advisory Council to review proposals to
work on the site in accordance with UNESCO and U.S. historic preservation law and practice. Other recommendations
include a voluntary exclusion zone around the wreck site
where ships would not discharge waste of any sort (modern
garbage is indeed present on the site) and designated areas
where submersibles visiting the wreck would enter and exit
the archaeological area. This last point is important25 years
of dives have littered the wreck site with the dive weights
each sub drops to ascend to the surface.
RMS Titanic Inc. paid for the expedition, which included
many staunch critics (some directly involved in the litigation)
of the prior handling of the Titanic wreckmyself among
them. Such a collaboration was simply unimaginable to many
people right up until the missions launch in the research ship
Jean Charcot from St. Johns, Newfoundland, in August 2010.
at Titanic as if through a rainsplattered windshield at night, we now have an elevated

view of the city, with the clarity and detail of a slow,
low-altitude flight at noon. This is possible because of the latest robotic technology, deployed in the 2010 expeditiontwo
autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs) and a remotely operated vehicle (ROV). The AUV team, including Mike Dessner
and Andy Sherrell of the Waitt Institute, and Greg Packard,
Mike Purcell, and Jim Partan of WHOI, operated and maintained the AUVs. At 12.5 feet long and 28 inches in diameter,
they look like fat, yellow torpedoes. Weighing one ton and
costing nearly three million dollars each, they can dive to
almost 20,000 feet and run for up to 22 hours autonomously
at depth, following preprogrammed courses at speeds of up
to five knots. They carry a variety of instruments, including
high-resolution multi-beam profiling sonar; dual-frequency
side-scan sonar; sub-bottom profiling sonar; an automatic digital camera with strobe; conductivity, depth, and temperature
sensors; and collision avoidance software. One of the scientists
on the expedition joked that if you are not there to pick the
AUVs up when they surface, they have the ability to call your
cellphone to ask for a ride. Once retrieved, they provide terabytes of data from the ocean floor. (After our expedition, they
ATHER THAN PEERING
38
were deployed on another mission, classified at the time: the

successful location of the wreckage of Air France flight 447
in the South Atlantic.)
The other robot was an ROV, Remora, a refrigerator-sized
frame covered with crush-proof foam, cables, thrusters, deepsea lights, and high-definition cameras from WHOIs Advanced
Imaging and Visualization Laboratory (AIVL). Rated to dive to
20,000 feet, Remora, operated by Tim Weller and Bradley Gillis of Phoenix International, was tethered to the ship by more
than 12,400 feet of fiber-optic cable and driven by joystick.
Two levels above the main deck of Jean Charcot, in a darkened
compartment of the ships laboratory, the AIVL team conducted
systematic sonar and digital imaging of the bow, stern, and other
major sections of Titanic. Wearing bulky black plastic glasses,
we watched large screens and saw Titanic, brightly lit and in
3-D, and relayed directions to the ROVs pilotstop, a little
to port, turn 10 degreesfor hours. I was struck by how much
more insightdigitally documented in high definition, with
remarkable precision and claritywe were gaining compared
with being down there in a manned submersible. The lights,
literally and figuratively, were on for the first time. Previously, the
results of work on the wreck had to be carefully pieced together,
at times by hand, to provide glimpses of certain artifacts and
features. Now, the entire wreck site became accessible, down to
a teacup or wine bottle or crabs crawling along the hull.
Our data acquisition complete, the processing of this
information is ongoing. AIVLs William Lange (a member of
the original Titanic discovery team) and his visualization team,
including 3-D specialist Evan Kovacs, are merging all this optical and sonar data together into a detailed, comprehensive
baseline map of the wreck, built on a GIS database developed
by the National Park Services David Conlin, co-principal
archaeologist on the expedition (with me). Science begins
with measurement. Understanding the relationships between
features and objects on the seafloor is key to deciphering how
the site was created on April 15, 1912.
With the new site map, we are able to virtually fly in on
the wreck, dropping into the water anywhere in a roughly
three-by-five-mile area that encompasses the full extent of
the wreck, and get a view of anything, from the large intact
portions of the ship down to the most current-scattered
pieces of coal, dishes, and deck tiles. Digitally, we can move
in closer to any portion of Titanicnow sectioned into grid
units like a proper archaeological siteincluding a small area
that holds the greatest concentration of features. There, close
to the intact but mangled stern, is a collection of pieces of
hull, machinery, superstructure, and other artifacts known for
decades as the debris field. We have now started referring to
it as the artifact fieldmore than 60 major features and tens
of thousands of artifacts in a non-random patternwhere we
are both plotting relationships between objects and studying
the features on a pair of shoes.
We have begun the task of identifying features, artifacts,
and their contexts, especially with the help of Titanic expert
Bill Sauder. I have known of Sauders scholarship for years,
so I was not surprised by the depth of his knowledge. But
A portion of the first-ever comprehensive map of the Titanic

wreck site (above), created with automated underwater
vehicles (left), shows the ships mangled stern and the
artifact field, including portions of the hull, boilers, and
machinery. This sonar map was only the first step toward a
finely detailed archaeological site map.
I was amazed all the same when he meticulously explained

how a battered feature on the seabed was one of the revolving doors from Titanics first-class smoking room, and as he
identified the half-intact oval domed skylight from one of
the ships two grand staircases.
Returning virtually to the wreck again and again like this is
critical to any scientific approach. Rather than seeing Titanic
through a keyhole, we can interrogate the entire thing and
ask fresh questions of it.
The archaeological methods now being applied to Titanic
have given us clear insights into the site formation process,
specifically how Titanic broke apart and fell, and how the bow
plowed into the mud at an angle. We can see how the stern sank,
along with broken sections of the hull, including a cluster of
www.archaeology.org
boilers. We can delineate where heavier objects landed and blew

away silt, and at the bow we can see how the hull dug in, flexed,
and sprang back, leaving a knife-sharp edge in the mud even
a century later. We have also plotted pairs of shoes, laced and
tied, next to disturbed mudplaces where victims came to rest.
Some of the site formation processes were known or surmised before. As early as 1986, Lange, with Ballard and Al
Uchupi of WHOI, worked with images from Argo to begin to
map around Titanics stern and hypothesize about patterns of
the fallen artifacts. Others, including a 2005 television documentary crew working with experts, developed new theories
on how Titanic came apart. And Camerons expeditions sent
small robots deep into the bow that yielded detailed information on the sinking and the exceptional levels of preservation
inside the wreck. A variety of further expeditions, including
two by NOAA in 20032004, had surveyed, generated partial
photomosaics, and continued to assess the bacteriological
consumption of Titanics steel.
The 2010 expedition brought these eorts together with
a new base of solid data, a grid, assigned units, and feature
numbers, providing a new perspective on how Titanic went
from ship to shipwreck, and how it continues to change over
39
HERE IS EVERYTHING ELSE? Still

inside. Camerons explorations of
the bow interior revealed cabins
complete with furniture, cupboards stacked
with dishes, painted wooden paneling, and
hanging light fixtures. Cargo and luggage,
including the packed bags of passengers, remain
in the hold, and the mailroom, visible through a
hole that opened in the hull when it flexed and
broke on impact with the seabed, has stacks of
mailbags. We believe that, while badly mangled,
the stern also retains intact cabins. Titanic was
a floating microcosm of society, a city shortlived and dramatically terminated that carried
both the rich traveling for pleasure and immigrants seeking new lives in the United States or
Canada. Each cabin, trunk, suitcase, valise, grip,
and mailbag is itself both archive and memorial.
RMS Titanic Inc. recovered a few scattered
bags from the ship, and the clothing, correspondence, and personal eects inside them demonstrated exceptional levels of preservation. These
bags speak evocatively about the people who
packed them, many of whom are known only
as initials and a last name on a manifest. By the
time this story hits newsstands and mailboxes,
the bags, the rest of RMS Titanic Inc.s collection, and the companys documentation on the
site will have, pending court approval, a new
steward. Hopefully further study of this collecA suitcase from one of Titanics passengers (top), portholes from near the stern tion will continue to tell the story of what we
now know to be one of the great human migraof Titanic (above), and the ships iconic bow (opposite). Images like these are
being integrated into the comprehensive map.
tions, the nineteenth- and twentieth-century
maritime trail from Europe to America.
time. The new map revealed to us that the scattered features
It is clear that Titanic, though well-studied, has so much
and artifacts do not represent everything that once lay inside
more to teach us. We have yet to conduct detailed oceanoor on the ship. Rather than streaming like comet tails from
graphic studies to assess the wrecks eects on the surrounding
the bow and stern as the ship sank, most contents of the artideep-sea environment, and what currents, oxygen levels, temfact field come from the full disintegration of a section of the
perature, and marine organisms are precisely doing to Titanic.
shipsome 70 feet of Titanics 882-foot length that branched
Those processes are as important to the future of Titanic as is
up and out between two of the deck funnels. Broken pieces
our dedication to preserving and learning from the site. Titanic
of the hull from that section were accompanied by two of the
still awaits a solid, comprehensive research and management
reciprocating engine cylinders, the five boilers from the numplan, as well as what I see as the most appropriate home for its
ber one boiler room, 51 tons of coal (of 1,000 or more tons on
salvaged artifacts, a public Titanic museum. There are no plans
board), and four tons of coke. This segment also included the
for such an initiative at the moment, but those artifacts are
contents of the Verandah Caf, the Palm Court, the aft end
as close as we will ever get to the people who were caught up
of the First Class Lounge, and a group of first-, second-, and
in that nights events a century ago. Ultimately, archaeologys
third-class cabins, as well as the galleys and pantries, sculleries,
role in Titanics story will be to move beyond April 15, 1912,
wine room, barber shop, smoking room, hospital, cold storage
and deeper into the society that produced Titanic, populated
rooms, silverware locker, and bakers shop. Among these items
its cabins, and looked to the ship as a voyage to the future.
on the seafloor are also pieces swept from the deck, such as the
Answers will be elusive, but were now better equipped than
funnels, the davits used to launch lifeboats, and the remains of
ever before to ask those questions.
the bridge. There is a lot of material down there and reflected
on the site map, but it represents just a tiny fraction of the
James P. Delgado is the Director of Maritime Heritage for the
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrations Office of
presumed millions of artifacts. The artifacts salvaged between
National Marine Sanctuaries.
1987 and 2004 do not represent even 1 percent of that total.
40
www.archaeology.org
41
AST STRETCHES OF CENTRAL ASIA feel eerily

uninhabited. Fly at 30,000 feet over the
southern part of the former Soviet Union
Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Kazakhstanand
there are long moments when no town or
road or field is visible from your window.
The landscape of stark desert, trackless steppe, and rugged
mountains seems to swallow up anything human. It is little
surprise, then, that this region remains largely terra incognita
to most archaeologists.
Wandering bands and tribes roamed this immense area
for 5,000 years, herding goat, sheep, cattle, and horses across
immense steppes, through narrow valleys, and over high
snowy passes. They left occasional tombs that survived the
ages, and on rare occasions settled down and built towns or
even cities. But for the most part, these peoples left behind
few physical traces of their origins, beliefs, or ways of life.
What we know of these nomadic pastoralists comes mainly

from their periodic forays into India, the Middle East, and
China, where they often wreaked havoc and earned a fearsome reputation as enemies of urban life.
As early as the fifth century B.C., the Greek historian
Herodotus warned of a barbaric and warlike pastoralist people
called the Scythians who lived north of the Caucuses and drank
human blood from skulls. The hardy Xiongnu from the Siberian steppes raided Chinese towns in the second century B.C.,
prompting construction of the Great Wall. And troops from
Mongolia led by Genghis Khans grandson Hulagu Khan laid
waste to the rich metropolis of Baghdad in A.D. 1258, ending
one of Islams most glorious periods.
In the past century, scholars have continued where the
ancient writers left o, criticizing these people as destructive,
dismissing them as marginal, or, at best, casting them as a
harsh tonic for restoring vigor to decaying and soft agricul-
RETHINKING
THE THUNDERING
How herding nomads created the network
that carried civilization across Central Asia
more than 4,000 years ago
by Andrew Lawler
tural societies from ancient Mesopotamia to Imperial Rome

to Han China. Nomadic people are generally the invincible
opponents of civilization, wrote sociologist Jerome Dowd
in 1907. A half-century later, British archaeologist Mortimer
Wheeler blamed the aggressive, chariot-driving Aryans who
swept in from the steppes for the demise of the peaceful
Indus River civilization after 1800 B.C., though later archaeologists dismissed that claim.
But Michael Frachetti, a young archaeologist at Washington
University in St. Louis, takes the radical view that Central
Asians were early midwives in the birth of civilization rather
than a destructive force bent on its extirpation. Frachetti
argues that ancient pastoralists living in the third millennium
B.C., at the time of the first great cities of Mesopotamia, Egypt,
and the Indus, created a network stretching across thousands
of miles that passed along goods, technologies, and ideas central to urban life. He believes they helped create civilization
rather than hindering it. This isnt the pastoralism of Genghis

Khan and his thundering hordes, says Frachetti, who is digging in both Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. These people arent
living on the fringe of society, he says, adding, They actually
are dictating the regions politics and the economy.
Most archaeological work in Central Asia during the past
century has focused on the open and rolling plains that stretch
from the Black Sea to Manchuria. These steppes only came
to life after 2000 B.C., when horse domestication and riding
suddenly turned a forbidding landscape for pedestrians into a
natural highway of grass. Drawing on linguistic research, textual evidence, and remains from steppe tombs, archaeologists
and historians have long argued that these peoples migrated en
masse from west to east, taking with them fast horses, chariots,
metal weapons, and a pantheon of sky gods.
By contrast, the areas to the south of the steppesa confused welter of mountain chains and harsh desertshave long
Archaeologists are
uncovering Bronze Age
settlements where modern
Uzbek and Tajik pastoralists
today drive their flocks
through the same landscape
as their ancient forebears.
HORDES
Covering nearly 500 square miles,

this region lies between the Tian
Shan and Altai mountain ranges, and
boasts sharp peaks topping 12,000
feet, as well as harsh desert. At a site
near a village called Begash, on a flat
terrace enclosed by steep canyon
walls alongside a small stream, the
team uncovered the foundations of
simple stone structures along with
an array of potsherds and bronze
and stone artifacts in stone-lined
oval and rectangular tombs. The
earliest layers at Begash date to at
least as early as 2500 B.C., based
on alpha magnetic spectrometry
dating of organic remains, says
Frachetti. One woman was laid
to rest with a bell-shaped hooked
bronze earring around 1700 B.C.,
according to electron spin resonance dating. Similar earrings are
only found several centuries later
some 600 miles to the north on
Ancient pastoralists built this dwelling at Begash in Kazakhstan in around 2500 B.C.
the Siberian steppes, hinting at
In a nearby grave, archaeologists found these tiny grains of millet and wheat, the oldest
styles that moved north over time.
domesticated grains yet found in Central Asia.
More surprisingly, the excavators found wheat, which was first
been dismissed as backwaters of history. In the past, these
domesticated in the Fertile Crescent of the Middle East, and
southern mountains and deserts were considered too remote,
broomcorn millet that was first widely grown in northern
rugged, and inhospitable to have played a role in early migraChina. The grains were used ritually in a burial, and radiotions or the emergence of urban life. The Karakum Desert,
carbon dating of the remains dates them to about 2200
B.C., making them the oldest known domesticated grains
where it might rain once in a decade, covers nearly two-thirds
in Central Asia. The people of Begash may not have grown
of todays Turkmenistan, while the perpetually snow-covered
either grainthere are no grinding stones, the telltale sign of
Tian Shan Mountains of western China and eastern Kyrgyzstan
grain preparationbut instead received it via trade networks
soar 24,000 feet into the thin air. It is there that Frachetti and
stretching from the Near East to China.
a new generation of archaeologists from the United States and
Dorian Fuller, a leading expert in ancient grains based
Central Asian nations are discovering evidence of a network
at University College London, calls the finds important
of pastoralists who thrived centuries before hooves resounded
and well dated. He adds that Chinese crops such as millet
on the steppes to the north. These forgotten peoples may have
began to appear in southwest Asia around 1900 B.C., a few
carried such markers of civilization as ceramics and grains
across thousands of miles, two millennia before the Silk Road
centuries after they reached Begash, which could mean the
linked the Roman Empire with Han China. Frachetti argues
passage through the mountain regions was a means of gradual
that the new data emerging from the region force archaeolotransmission from east to west. Frachetti speculates that the
gists to rethink their ideas about trade across Eurasia during
grains may have been acquired from other tribes and used
the Bronze Age, when the first civilizations were taking form
for ritual purposes, and then perhaps were passed on in turn
to the east, south, and west.
to other pastoral peoples.
What makes the Begash discoveries so important is that
RACHETTI,WHO HAS STUDIED modern-day pastoralists
previously this region was assumed to have been a land of
in such unforgiving landscapes as the Sahara and Scandiscattered foragers until steppe peoples trickled down into
navia, was drawn to the southern region of Central Asia
the areas valleys and mountain ranges after 2000 B.C. But
for its environmental diversity of desert, grassland, and alpine
it is becoming evident that the people of Begash were not
meadows. Instead of a wasteland, he saw an ideal landscape for
simple foragers, but sophisticated pastoralists who tended
enterprising herders who wanted to pasture their animals in all
their flocks, much as people in the area still do today. They
seasons. Together with his Kazakh colleagues, Frachetti began
built small encampments, favored sheep and goat over cattle,
digging a decade ago in the Dzhungar Mountains of Kazakhstan.
and ate few wild animals. The inhabitants did not begin to
F
44
use horses until well into the second millennium B.C., and
the varieties of sheep and goat found here today appear to be
related to the varieties first domesticated thousands of years
before in western Iran, near ancient Mesopotamia. This indicates that Begash was at the crossroads of extremely wide
networks among Eurasian communities by the third millennium B.C., asserts Frachetti. That doesnt mean that traders
traversed thousands of miles in this early period. Instead,
the archaeologist envisions pastoralists taking their flocks
to higher pastures in the summer, where they encountered
neighbors from other valleys doing the same. Thus, ideas
and technologies might have passed gradually through the
mountain corridors of southern Central Asia. This corridor,
Frachetti believes, may have been a key conduit for Bronze
Age developments farther into East Asia and Mongolia. Frachettis team is now busy analyzing both human and animal
EEKING MORE EVIDENCE, Frachetti and his colleagues

in recent years turned to an area 400 miles southwest
of Begash in todays Uzbekistan. Frachetti and Farhad
Maksudov of the Uzbek Archaeology Institute chose a region
north of Samarkand, the ancient Silk Road city, because of its
proximity to another, even more ancient, town called Sarazm
(Sogdian for where the land begins). Founded in the fourth
millennium B.C., Sarazmjust over the modern border in
Tajikistanflourished for a thousand years and is the oldest
large-scale settlement in Central Asia, what scholars call a
proto-urban center. It also marks, at least prior to the finds
at Begash, the northeastern frontier of the Fertile Crescents
reach. Sarazm, discovered accidentally by a villager in 1976 and
excavated in the 1980s by Soviet archaeologists, was once a prosperous center of trade for goods such as turquoise, agate, wool,
and leather. It was connected through trade networks to the
bone and tooth samples in order to garner isotopic, DNA,

and health data. This sort of digging requires stamina and
patience, as well as a sense of adventure. Its a lot of work
for a few artifacts in places that are hard to find, says David
Anthony, an archaeologist at Hartwick College and a longtime critic of Frachettis theory. He acknowledges, however,
the importance of the discovery. Begash is one candle shining in this vast dark region, he says. Anything dating to
2000 B.C. or earlier is incredibly important. However, he
adds that there is still not enough evidence that the people
of Begash were anything other than an anomaly.
Archaeologist Michael Frachetti is focusing his research on the

role of Bronze Age nomadic pastoralists in spreading civilization
across Central Asia and into China on several sites, including
Begash in Uzbekistan and sites near Sarazm in Kazakhstan.
www.archaeology.org
flourishing civilizations of Mesopotamia, Iran, and the Indus,

as well as with traders as far north as Siberia and as far east as
Afghanistans Hindu Kush Mountains. As with cities from the
Mediterranean Sea to the Indus River, Sarazms economy was
based on wheat, barley, sheep, and goats. The people produced
fine pottery and had a taste for luxury items imported from afar.
45
These hilly mountainsides in

northern Uzbekistan offered
plentiful protected grazing
land for the flocks of Bronze
Age pastoralists in winter. In
summer, they would take their
sheep and goats to the cooler
pastures at higher altitudes.
Frachetti and Maksudovs

goal was to understand how
pastoralists may have interacted with their neighbors, with
Sarazm, and with more distant
places during the third and
second millennia B.C. One of
the questions they asked was
whether the areas ancient pastoralists indeed guided their
herds as high up as alpine
meadows, as Frachetti speculated. If so, then they might
easily encounter pastoralists from other valleys who had made
the same trip. Such seasonal meetings might have forged
networks that explain the diusion of goods and technologies
without the need for mass migration. No evidence of such
interaction, however, had been found. But in June of 2011,
surveying a pasture more than 6,000 feet above sea level,
in an area of 3.5 acres, Frachetti and Maksudov uncovered
evidence of at least fifteen ancient dwellings on a mound, as
well as more than 1,000 pieces of ceramic. Though some are
from medieval times, others appear to be from the Bronze
Age. The team hopes to begin excavating the site this summer to gather more data.
Based on ethnographic research, knowledge of the local
geography, and a measure of intuition, Frachetti and Maksudov
also sought out likely Bronze Age settlement spots in the steep
valleys below the alpine meadows. At one site dubbed the

eagles nest after the resident bird of preys massive home,
they found pottery and charcoal amid the remains of a small
settlement. Preliminary radiocarbon dates place the site at
roughly 2000 B.C., in the middle of the Bronze Age, and long
before steppe pastoralists from the north might have migrated
here. Other sites, including one in a protected ravine, yielded
medieval Islamic pottery, Iron Age potsherds, and what appear
to be remains of Bronze Age pots, which are still under analysis. Even if the settlement only dates to 1200 B.C., it will add
3,000 years to the pastoral record of Uzbekistan, Frachetti
says. Though not permanent, these sites appear to have been
repeatedly used for millennia, and they appear to be scattered
over vast areas. If you consider there are thousands of valleys
in this region, and if there were five to 15 villages per valley,
then you have an incredible force for civilization, Frachetti says.
The combined finds in Uzbekistan and at
Begash suggest to Frachetti that the people
living in Central Asia around 2000 B.C. were
part of the rapidly urbanizing world, when
the great cities of Egypt, Mesopotamia, and
the Indus were at their first peak, and just as
Chinese urbanization was beginning. Though
these pastoralists may never have traveled
more than a few dozen miles from plain to
valley to alpine meadow, Frachetti maintains
they had access to the wider world. And, by
Working in the Uzbek hills north of
Samarkand, Farhad Maksudov (left) and
Frachetti (right) examine a trench for organic
material that will help them date the sparse
remains left by ancient pastoralists.
46
passing along important innovations such as grains and other

goods, they had a hand in connecting far-flung civilizations.
This movement from south to north took place centuries
before the horse-riding pastoralists moved across the Eurasian
steppes from west to east.
Some archaeologists champion that view as groundbreaking
research while others dismiss it as unconvincing theorizing.
Frachettis ideas will upset a few apple carts, but so be it, says
Dan Rogers, a Smithsonian Institution anthropologist who
works in Mongolia. Philip Kohl, an archaeologist at Wellesley
College who has dug extensively in Central Asia, finds Frachettis methods valuable and his thesis intriguing. He too prefers
the concept of chains of networks to mass migrations. There
just isnt evidence for waves of warriors running from one end
of the steppes to another, Kohl says. But he is taking a waitand-see approach until Frachetti can provide more data. I
wouldnt call it a robust body of evidence, he adds.
According to David Anthony, the dominant view is still that
pastoralists went from west to east, rather than north through
the southern Central Asian terrain. He believes that it is not
surprising that the Uzbek sites appear to have had contact with
Iran to the south, given their proximity to Sarazm. However,
hes skeptical that influence extended much beyond Begash,
or that it was strong. The idea that pastoralists from Iran
brought domesticated animals and plants as far as Begash is
interesting, says Anthony, but with just one site it is dicult
to interpret. He also questions the idea that millet might have
come from as far away as China, and suggests instead it might
have reached Europe via the steppes then circled back north.
Other scholars remain adamantly opposed to Frachettis
concept of pastoralist networks as a means of transmission of
ideas, technology, and raw materials. The idea that you could
get things from southwest Asia through those mountain passes

is not convincing, says Victor Mair of the University of Pennsylvania. He sees the debate as an old one, pitting those who
view the dominance of Mesopotamia and Iran to the south
against those who are focused on the steppe societies to the
west and north. Anthony suggests that in the end, researchers
may well discover that both sides are right, and that Central
Asian pastoralists had links with both western steppe peoples
as well as the civilizations to the south. But the key role that
Central Asian pastoralists played in the emergence of civilization across the vast continent may no longer be at issue.
For the moment, all agree that more fieldwork in places
long ignored is necessary. For example, one of Frachettis
students is now digging in the Altai, far to the north of
Begash, to explore possible southern connections through
the mountain corridor. Researchers also hope that genetic
and isotopic analysis of both human and animal bones may
help resolve the controversy. Analyses of modern sheep in
the area point to an Iranian origin, strengthening Frachettis
argument that Begash and other Central Asian sites were
connected with peoples to the south and west.
Whatever the outcome, the image of the nomad as solely
a bloodthirsty marauder may finally be laid to rest. Whether
through small networks, mass migrations, or some combination, pastoralists in fact served as the connective tissue as
civilization expanded across the Asian continent, funneling
goods, ideas, and innovative technologies. Frachetti is eager
to add to slowly mounting data that are certain to revamp our
ideas about their role. Were going to find many Begashes,
he predicts. We dont have to worrythey are out there.
Andrew Lawler is a contributing editor at Archaeology.
Frachetti and Maksudov plan to continue

their search for evidence of Bronze Age
pastoralists in the mountains of Uzbekistan
and beyond.
www.archaeology.org
47
Games Ancient
People Played
An intriguing discovery in a Mexican swamp provides evidence of the
earliest form of amusement in the Americas
by Barbara Voorhies
Professor Emerita Barbara Voorhies of the University of California,
Santa Barbara, has spent much of her career investigating Mesoamericas
Archaic period, the time when people were on the verge of practicing
agriculture and settling in permanent villages. Over a span of nearly 35
years, she has excavated on several occasions at the 5,000-year-old site
of Tlacuachero in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas.
TLACUACHERO in southern Mexico is an

island in a mangrove swamp made up almost entirely
of clamshells. Material recovered from the site shows
that it was a place where people harvested shellfish and fish
between 5,050 and 4,230 years agolong before the great
civilizations of Mesoamerica would build their city-states.
Over the years, the island grew as clams were harvested from
the swamp and the shells were discarded there. While the shell
HE SITE OF
48
mound was accumulating, the early people at Tlacuachero

built several superimposed clay floors at the island center to
create smooth surfaces that were easier to walk and work on.
Nothing resembling the remains of houses has been found at
the site, which probably indicates that the place was used only
for processing the food that people gathered from the swamp.
Excavations begun in 1973 revealed holes where sturdy
wooden posts had been driven into the floors. The pattern of
the postholes marks places where racks for drying fish may
Oval arrangements of small holes (above) found at the site
of Tlacuachero (right), may have been used to play an early
type of board game. Clay disks, with markings on one side
(inset), might have been thrown like dice but date to hundreds
of years later than the game boards.
have stood. Also on the floors were groups of tiny holes in oval
patterns. These oval features are clustered only in one area of
the floors, but why they were made has been a mystery ever
since the first one was found. Features like these are often
interpreted by archaeologists as being either purely utilitarian
or purely ritualistic, which leaves out a whole range of human
activities that has nothing to do with religion or making a living. But an answer to the question of what the oval features
were used for may have been provided by an unlikely sourcea
book titled Games of the North American Indians, published in
1907, by Stewart Culin. Were the oval features used to play a
game? Historical, ethnographic, and archaeological evidence
supports this idea.
Culins book pulled together ethnographic accounts showing that board games were played by societies across the area
that is now Canada, the United States, and Mexico. Nearly
all of the board games Culin compiled were variations on one
of two themes: wars and races. In war games, the object is to
capture your opponents pieces, as in checkers. In race games,
the winner is the first player to move his or her pieces to a
goalCandyland and Snakes and Ladders are modern versions
of race games. The boards themselves were usually impro-
vised arrangements of small stones. In places where stones

were not easily available, people made their game boards by
digging small holes. The Hualapai people of Arizona used a
type of game board closely resembling the oval features at
Tlacuachero.
In the Hualapai board game, an example of a race game,
the board is a circle of stones roughly four feet in diameter
with a gap in it where the players could sit. In place of dice,
the Hualapai used short pieces of wood that are flat on one
side and rounded on the other. The players would throw three
of these sticks onto a large striking stone in the center of
the circle and move their counters according to the number
of sticks that landed with the flat side facing up. The winner
was the first player to move his or her counter to a large stone
at the far side of the board.
Arizona is a long way from Tlacuachero. But people
throughout Mesoamerica had similar gaming traditions. Game
boards as old as 1,200 years have been found etched in stone
and scratched in stucco at ancient cities from Teotihuacn near
modern-day Mexico City to Copn in northern Honduras.
Some modern-day Maya still play a war dice game called
Bul to celebrate the beginning of the planting season. The
This 16th-century image shows Aztecs playing a game called patolli, next to Macuilxochitl, the god of games, whom gamblers
prayed to for luck. His name translates as Five Flower, shown here by the flower he holds and five circles.
50
game board is a line of 20 maize kernels.

A player or team of players starts at each
end. Each team gets five game pieces,
usually small twigs, leaf stems, or blades of
grass. For dice, they hollow out one side
of a flat maize kernel and blacken it with
charcoal. They throw four of these kernels, count the number that land with the
black side facing up, and move their pieces
accordingly. The object of the game is to
land your piece in the same space as your
opponents, thereby capturing it. Next you
have to move the captured piece back to
your end of the board and avoid having it
recaptured on the way.
Historical accounts written by Spanish friars in the sixteenth century provide
another line of evidence about the oval
features at Tlacuachero. Friar Diego
Durn described a game that was played
in Tenochtitln, the ancient Aztec capital.
The players used split reeds for dice, and a
game board pecked into a buildings floor:
Small cavities were carved out of a
stucco floor in the manner of a lottery
board. Facing each other, one (player) took
ten pebbles, and the other (also took) ten.
The first placed his pebbles on his side, and
the other on his. Then they cast split reeds
on the ground. These jumped, and thosee
that fell with the hollow side facing upward
d
indicated that a man could move his pebbless
that many squares.
Other historical accounts written by
Spanish friars describe Aztec versions of
me
bowling, checkers, and a second dice game
ed
called patolli. In place of dice, players used
large patol beans that were marked on one
side with a white dot or small hole. Fourr or
five of these beans were used for each throw,
row,
and their configuration determined the score
core
es as
of the throw. The players used pebbles
counters and moved them around a board that
h fform off an X
consisted of two long rows of squares in the
painted on a woven mat.
According to the friars accounts, Aztec games were often
played on feast days, when people from dierent territories
came together, allowing players to gamble for exotic goods.
In this way, playing games may have served an economic
purpose as a means of distributing wealth. According to the
Spanish accounts, there was often heavy betting by both
players and onlookers. The betting gave rise to a group of
itinerant professional gamblers, but the games also came
with serious costs for some. Consequences for not being
able to pay gambling debts were often dire and could include
death by hanging. Friar Bernardino Sahagn wrote about
www.archaeology.org
Archaeological evidence of
Archae
game playing is widespread in
Mesoamerica. A game board
Mesoa
carved into a stone (above)
carve
was ffound at Piedras Negras in
Guatemala. This statue of the
Guat
Aztec god Macuilxochitl
Azte
(left) dates to the 15th
(left
16th century.
or 16
a p
person who had what we
would consider a gambling
wo
addiction, but instead, he
ad
attributes the persons probat
lem to his having been born
le
on an inauspicious day:
o
He wagered everything
which was in his home.
w
He used up everything
H
in patolli and tlachtli [a
type of ballgame]. The friars
disapproved of the gambling
gamblin and that the gamblers
often
f
invoked
i
k d Macuilxochitl,
M il hi l the
h god of games, for luck.
Macuilxochitl also appears in documents from neighboring
societies, such as the Eastern Nahuas and Mixtecs, indicating that this gaming culture was widespread.
If the oval features at Tlacuachero are indeed game boards,
they are the earliest evidence of people playing games in Mesoamerica. Parts of more than 10 of these ovals have been found
at the site. One of the most telling details is that as the clay
floors were repaired and remade, so were the oval features. For
the fisherfolk of Tlacuachero, game playing had apparently
become one of the necessities of life.
Barbara Voorhies is a professor emerita of the University of
51
The invention of the year

is great news for your ears
NEW
Now w
power ith more
and cl
arity!
Perfect Choice HD is easy to use, hard

to see and costs far less than hearing aids
its like reading glasses for your ears!
New Personal Sound Amplification Product
is an affordable alternative
Reading glasses for your ears
thanks to the efforts of the doctor

who leads a renowned hearing
institute, there is Perfect Choice HD.
Its designed to accurately amplify
sounds and deliver them to your
ear. Because weve developed an
efficient production process, we
can make a great product at an
affordable price. The unit has
been designed to have an easily
accessible battery, but it is small
and lightweight enough to hide
behind your ear only youll know
you have it on. Its comfortable and
wont make you feel like you have
Perfect Choice HD is NOT a

hearing aid. Hearing aids can
only be sold by
an audiologist. In Perfect Choice HD vs Traditional Hearing Aids
Perfect Choice HD Traditional Hearing Aids
order to get a
Lightweight and
Some
YES
hearing aid, you Inconspicuous
Easy
Toggle
had to go to the
Few
YES
Switch Adjustment
doctors office for a Intelligent Setting
Few
YES
battery of tests and Memory
Tests and Fittings
Yes
NO
numerous fitting Required
a p p o i n t m e n t s . Affordable
as much as $5000
YES
Once they had you Friendly Return
rarely
YES
tested and fitted, Policy
you would have to pay as much as something stuck in your ear. It
$5000 for the product. Now, provides high quality audio so
sounds and conversations will be
Are you or
easier to hear and understand.
a loved one frustrated

in these situations?
Restaurants Dinner parties
Outdoor conversations
Lectures Sermons
Meetings
and other times where you
need to turn up the volume
Try it for yourself with our

exclusive home trial. Some people
need hearing aids but many just
need the extra boost in volume that
a PSAP gives them. We want you to
be happy with Perfect Choice HD,
so we are offering to let you try it
for yourself. If you are not totally
Affordable, Simple to use,

Virtually impossible to see
satisfied with this product, simply
return it within 60 days for a refund
of the full product purchase price.
Dont wait dont miss out on
another conversation call now!
Call now for

the lowest price ever.
Please mention promotional code
44485.
1-888-654-0584
Perfect Choice HD is not a hearing aid.
If you believe you need a hearing aid,
please consult a physician.
80326
Over the years, technology has

made the way we live easier,
safer and more convenient. In
many cases, its even made
many products more affordable
(remember how much the first
VCRs used to cost?). Unfortunately,
the cost of hearing aids never
seemed to come down. Now, a new
alternative has been invented its
called Perfect Choice HD.
LETTER FROM CALIFORNIA
A New Look at the Donner Party

The Native American perspective on a notorious chapter in American
history is being revealed by the excavation and study of a pioneer campsite
by Julie M. Schablitsky
n late October 1846, an early

snowstorm stranded 22 men,
women, and children in Alder
Creek meadow in Californias Sierra
Nevada. The squall came on so fiercely and suddenly that the pioneers had
just enough time to erect sleeping
tents and a small structure of pine
trees covered with branches, quilts,
and the rubber coats off their backs.
Living conditions were crowded, and
their wool and flannel clothes were
useless against leaks and the damp
ground. As time passed, seasoned
wood became so hard to find that
the stranded pioneers, known as the
Donner Party, were often without fire
for days. Huddled under makeshift
shelters, the migrants ate charred
bone and boiled hides until they
turned to more desperate measures
to survive. Today the people of the
www.archaeology.org
Donner Party are remembered for

cannibalizing their dead in a last-ditch
effort to survive.
Almost 10 years ago, I arrived at
Alder Creek meadow, a few miles outside of Truckee, California, with my
excavation codirector Kelly Dixon, of
the University of Montana, and
a team of colleagues to search
for archaeological evidence of
that miserable winter. The
story of the Donner Party is a
familiar tale, well known from
the accounts of survivors and
rescuers. But, as in many cases,
archaeology provided a different perspective and forced us to
reevaluate what we thought
we knew about this dark chapter in Western history.
The Donner Party was a wagon
gon
train of about 80 pioneers who set
out for California from Springfield,

Missouri, in 1846. Hoping to make
the Sacramento Valley by autumn,
they fell behind schedule after taking an untried shortcut through the
Great Salt Lake Desert. When an
October snowstorm hit, the party was
just 100 miles
m
from their destination.
Most of the migrants sought
Mo
shelter in cabins near Truckee
sh
Lake (now Donner Lake),
La
while the families of brothers
wh
George and Jacob Donner,
G
their teamsters, and trail
th
widow Doris Wolfinger made
w
IIn Alder Creek meadow
((top), archaeologists
e
excavated many bones,
such as this horse bone with
s
chop marks (left), that
ch
at
attest to the desperation of
tthe hungry pioneers.
53
George Donner Jr.

(far left), son of Jacob
Donner, survived the
winter of 184647, when
he was just 10 years old.
The Donners might have
fared better had they
accepted the help of the
Washoe tribe, pictured
here in 1866.
the decision to winter at Alder Creek

Creek.
By the time the pioneers were
found in late February 1847, half the
members of the Donner Party had
died. Both survivor and rescue party
accounts note human bodies disarticulated and butchered. Survivor Jean
Baptiste Trudeau, George Donners
hired hand, admitted to eating the
remains of his employers four-year-old
nephew. Even before the last survivor
made it out of the mountains, the California Star newspaper wrote, A woman
sat by the body of her husband, who
had just died, eating out his tongue;
the heart she had already taken out,
broiled, and eat [sic]! But as with
many tales of the Wild West, there are
deeper and more complex truths to
be found in the four months the Donners spent trapped. Our archaeological
investigations revealed the nuances
of daily life, the partys mounting desperation, and, surprisingly, that these
unfortunate migrants were not alone
in the mountains.
he approximate location of
the Donner Party encampment at Alder Creek has been
known since the late nineteenth century, but the precise camp spot had
never been pinpointed. Don Hardesty, an archaeologist and professor
emeritus at the University of Nevada,
Reno, searched for the site in the
54
1980s and early 1990s. Using metal

detectors, he found a mid-nineteenthcentury site there, but was cautious
about declaring it the Donner camp
in the absence of human bones or any
remains of a campfire. Building off
his work, my research focused on the
layout of the camp, close study of the
pioneers fragmented belongings, and
identifying evidence of cannibalism.
One can imagine the morbid appeal
of discovering human bones with
butchery marks among other, more
genteel artifacts such as floral decorated teacups, but I felt uncomfortable and even guilty about considering the grim possibilities.
Part of this anxiety comes from
being a Generation X archaeologist trained in the age of NAGPRA
(Native American Graves Protection
and Repatriation Act), a federal law
that protects Native American graves.
Both the government and my mentors taught me to avoid burial sites.
Though I understood the legal and
logistical reasons for this, only when
I began to work as a professional
archaeologist did I appreciate the
Native American perspective. My
work with Pacific Northwest tribes
taught me a respect for their culture
that changed my approach to human
remains, regardless of ancestry. So
before digging at Alder Creek, I
turned to the person who taught me
the most about Native American culture, Jeff Van Pelt, a member of the
Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla
Indian Reservation in Oregon.
Van Pelt knows the story of the
Donners, but he held a different viewpoint than I did. From my EuropeanAmerican perspective, the Donners
were an unfortunate, hard-luck chap-
ter in the otherwise heroic tale of pioneers who settled the American West.
I pictured hundreds of wagons, packed
full of provisions, with calico-clad
children bouncing along the Oregon
Trail to a better life. Not unexpectedly,
Van Pelt saw the story of the Donnersand all westward expansion, for
that matteras a self-serving expedition for land and wealth. To him, their
troubles were symptomatic of greed
rather than bad luck.
Van Pelt urged me to seek out the
wel mel ti, or the tribe now known as
the northern Washoe, to ask what
their oral history says of the Donners.
They were there, and probably saw
them, he said. Van Pelt also warned
me against the negative energy that
lingers in such places of suffering. He
removed from his neck an elaborately
carved shell pendant given to him by
a Florida shaman. On it, two animal
spirits, called splya (coyote in the
Sahaptin language), danced, actively
creating order from chaos. It would
protect me through the turmoil of
the Alder Creek dig, Van Pelt said.
onths before arriving in

California, I studied maps,
historical narratives, and
the notes from earlier archaeological
investigations. Hardesty had found
the eastern edge of the site, but not its
western extent, so we planned to move
from the known to the unknown. The
first shovelfuls of dry soil were sterile,
but inches below, we began to find
glass shards, once part of beverage and
sauce bottles, mixed with fragments of
decorated and blue shell-edge teaware.
We also discovered a particularly riveting artifacta small piece of writing
slate, possibly used by the Donner chilARCHAEOLOGY May/June 2012
25 to Lim
00 th it
re e f ed
sp ir
on st
de
nt
s
Spectacular
Treasure from
Mount St. Helens
The Beauty in
the Beast
F
or almost a hundred years it lay dormant. Silently

building strength. At 10,000 feet high, it was truly a
sleeping giant, a vision of peaceful power. Until everything changed in one cataclysmic moment. On May 18,
1980, the once-slumbering beast awoke with violent
force and revealed its greatest secret.
It was one of natures most impressive displays of
power. Mount St. Helens erupted, sending a column of
ash and smoke 80,000 feet into the atmosphere. From
that chaos, something beautiful emerged our spectacular Helenite Necklace. Produced from the heated volcanic rock dust of Mount St. Helens, this brilliant green
creation has captured the attention of jewelry designers
worldwide. Today you can wear this 6-carat stunner
for the exclusive price of only $129!
Your satisfaction is guaranteed. Our Helenite
Necklace puts the gorgeous green stone center stage,
with a faceted pear-cut set in gold-layered .925
sterling silver. The explosive origins of the stone are
echoed in the flashes of light that radiate as the piece
swings gracefully from its 18" gold-plated sterling silver
chain. Today the volcano sits quiet, but this unique
piece of natural history continues to erupt with gorgeous
green fire.
Add the 3-carat earrings!
Your satisfaction is guaranteed. Bring home the

Helenite Necklace and see for
yourself. If you are not completely blown away by the rare
beauty of this exceptional
stone, simply return the necklace within 30 days for a full
refund of your purchase price.
Helenite Necklace (6 ctw)$249 $129

Helenite Earrings (3 ctw)$249 $129
Helenite Set (necklace & earrings)$498 $199 Save $299
When it comes to color and

sparkle, this gorgeous green stone
gives the worlds finest emeralds
a run for their money!
Stauer has a
Better
Business
Bureau
Rating
of A+
James Fent
Certified Gem Guru
Call now to take advantage of this extremely limited offer.
1-800-859-1979
Promotional Code HEL141-01
JEWELRY SPECS:
- 6 ctw Helenite in gold over sterling silver setting
- 18" gold-fused chain
Stauer
14101 Southcross Drive W., Dept. HEL141-01,

Burnsville, Minnesota 55337 www.stauer.com
Smart LuxuriesSurprising Prices
UTE CULTURE &

BEADING WORKSHOP
With Rebecca Hammond
Create your own work of beaded art.

Learn how history has shaped Ute
artistic expression.
August 511, 2012
A THOUSAND YEARS
OF TAOS HISTORY
The archaeological team, co-led by the author (right), located the hearth the
Donners had used that notorious winter.
Discover the Past, Share the Adventure
800.422.8975
www.crowcanyon.org/travel
STOP!
We have had complaints from
subscribers who have received
fraudulent renewal notices, subscription offers, and invoices
from companies who are
NOT authorized agents or
representatives of ARCHAEOLOGY
magazine or the Archaeological
Institute of America.
Your renewals should only be
sent to our ofces in Palm Coast,
FL or Boston, MA. You can verify
your subscription status by calling
1-877-ARKY-SUB (1-877-275-9782)
or checking online at
www.archaeology.org/subscribe
The publishers of ARCHAEOLOGY
and many other popular magazines are working together to
stop our subscribers from being
harassed by these notices.
For updates please go to
www.archaeology.org/fraud
56
CST 2059347-50
Explore the archaeology, history,

and cultures of the northern Rio
Grande valley of New Mexico.
September 25
October 1, 2012
dren or adults in camp to make notes,

figure math problems, practice letters,
or just doodle. This nineteenth-century
notepad may have helped the children
pass the time, and perhaps even made
their situation feel a little more normal.
Deeper in the soil, just below these
more recently discarded objects, we
found Native American stone tools
large basalt flakes and bifaces that
reminded us who was there first.
The soil that held pioneer-era artifacts contained occasional pockets of
ash and charcoal that gave me hope
that an elusive Donner hearth might
be near. As our team pushed south
through the site, the soil became
more ashy, and larger pebbles and
pieces of lead shot appeared. My
trowel followed the edge of a dark
charcoal stain with a thin layer of
ash: the hearth. Shannon Novak of
Syracuse University, one of the teams
bioarchaeologists, knelt beside me
with a whisk broom, further delineating the feature. She exposed bone
fragments that appeared larger than
any we had seen before, and some
exhibited cut, saw, and chop marks.
As my trowel continued to scrape
the edge of the charcoal, I discovered a large ceramic plate sherd, face
down. Everyone gathered around as
I picked up the fragment from the
exact place it was broken by one of
the Donners. A hooray rang out as
I turned the artifact over to reveal a
scalloped edge rimmed with a vibrant
cobalt-blue glaze. The hearth feature,
approximately two by two-and-ahalf feet, anchored our collection of
artifacts that fanned out to the east.
In addition to delicate ceramics

seemingly out of place in the wilderness, but right in line with a Donner
campsitethe assemblage included
wagon hardware, even horseshoe nails
and oxen shoes, clear evidence that
the animals that pulled the pioneers
into the meadow never left it. At last,
we had found our long-term pioneer
campsite, but we were still looking for
evidence of starvation and desperation. So we turned to the most abundant artifact on the site, bone.
The dig crew picked out thousands
of tiny, calcined (burned) bone fragments from the site. Whenever we
found a big bonea piece at least
the size of a thumbnailI handed it
over to our faunal analyst, Guy Tasa of
the Washington State Department of
Archaeology and Historic Preservation. I waited for each of his verdicts
as he turned the bones around in his
hand a few times, but all he ever said
was, Medium to large mammal. This
frustratingly broad category includes
everything from goats to buffalo, but
in this region and context more likely
represents cow, horse, deer, elk, bear
and human. We know from survivor accounts that the Alder Creek
pioneers consumed the animals they
brought with them, including cattle,
horses, and perhaps even their faithful dog, Uno. When the last of the
meat was gone, they turned to boiling
animal hides and charring bone so
they could eat the pieces by crunching them between their teeth.
Back at the laboratory, with his
collection of comparative bone sam(continued on page 62)
Technology Breakthrough
Safe, comfortable bathing from Jacuzzi
Enjoy A Bath Again

Safely and Affordably
Five major considerations to

help make an informed decision
before buying a Walk-In Tub:
Quality - A walk-in tub is a
major investment. You want
to find a quality tub that will
last for decades. Look for
one thats 100% leakproof,
mold-resistant, full metal
frame construction and one
thats American made.
Low
Threshold
Step
Warranty - Ask for a lifetime

no leak guarantee The best
tubs offer a lifetime warranty
on both the tub and the
operating system.
Jacuzzi
PointProTM
Jet System
The Designed for SeniorsTM Walk-In tub

is luxurious, feature-packed and affordable
here is nothing like the simple
pleasure of taking a warm bath.
The cares of the day seem to fade
away, along with the aches and pains of
everyday life. Unfortunately for many aging
Americans with mobility issues, slipping
into a bath can result in slipping onto the
floor. The fear of falling has made the simple
act of bathing and its therapeutic benefits a
thing of the past until now. firstSTREET,
the leader in products Designed for Seniors
has partnered with Jacuzzi, the company
that perfected hydrotherapy. Together,
theyve created a walk-in tub that offers
more than just safe bathing, peace-of-mind
and independence, it can actually help you
feel better.
Unlike traditional bathtubs, our Designed
for Seniors Walk-In Tub features a leakproof
door that allows you to simply step into the
tub rather than stepping precariously over
the side. It features a state-of-the-art acrylic

surface, a raised seat, and the controls are
within easy reach. No other Walk-In Tub
features the patented Jacuzzi PointProTM jet
system. These high-volume, low-pressure
pumps feature a perfectly balanced water to
air ratio to massage thoroughly yet gently.
Some swirl, some spiral, some deliver large
volumes of water and others target specific
pressure points. They are all arranged in
precise locations designed to deliver a
therapeutic massage, yet they are fully
adjustable so that your bathing experience
can be completely unique.
Why spend another day wishing you could
enjoy the luxury and pain-relieving benefits
of a safe, comfortable bath. Call now and
youll get an unsurpassed limited lifetime
warranty. Knowledgeable product experts
are standing by to help you learn more about
this product. Call Today!
Pain Relieving Therapy - Find

a tub that has both water and
air jet therapy to soak away
your aches and pains preferably
with a perfectly balanced water
to air mix.
Comfort - Insist on ergonomic
design, easy-to-reach controls.
Endorsements - Only consider
tubs that are ETL or UL listed.
Also look for a tub tested to
IAPMO (Internatl Assoc. of
Plumbing and Mechanical
Officials) standards and thats
USPC (Universal Spa Plumbing
Code) Certified.
Designed For SeniorsTM

ew! Walk-In Tub
For information call:
1-877-516-6819
Call now Toll-Free and mention your
special promotion code 45020.
SEE THE JACUZZI DIFFERENCE

Laboratory tests clearly show how Jacuzzi
outperforms other manufacturers jet
systems, producing a deeper and wider
plume of revitalizing bubbles. Best of all,
it doesnt cost you a penny more!
Third-party financing available with approved credit.

Not Available in Hawaii and Alaska
80401
What To Look For

in a Walk-In Tub:
All rights reserved. 2011 firstSTREET, Inc. For Boomers and Beyond
CLASSIFIEDS
BOOKS
CUNEIFORM BY MAIL
RAVENS BLOOD. A supernatural,

archaeological thriller by Deborah
Cannon. He dreamed the dreams of his
ancestors. Now his next foray into the
realm of Raven may be his last. Read also:
THE RAVENS POOL, WHITE RAVEN,
RAVENSTONE. Available at amazon.com.
Also on Kindle.
Learn one of the worlds

oldest writing systems in the
newest correspondence
course offered by the
University of Chicagos
Oriental Institute.
Discover the New

Armenia
Small Groups
Personal Service
www.culturalcache.com
Call: (773) 799-0880
Register by May 14, 2012.

773.702.9507
oi-education@uchicago.edu
http://oi.uchicago.edu
We offer:
low prices and many options
production time of 20 days
low minimum of 100 books
assistance from start to finish
For a FREE Guide, call 800-650-7888, ext. ARC5
www.morrispublishing.com
FIELD SCHOOLS
Join our 2012 MAYA

excavation team!
Belize Spring
p g and Summer 2012
Call 817-831-9011 or visit
www.mayaresearchprogram.org
maya
SFTFBSDI!QSPHSBN
SFTFBSDI
QS
SPHSBN
OF INTEREST TO ALL
AN INCREDIBLY REFRESHING
CHANGE member of Science
Connection, the singles group for
science-philes. Join and see for yourself!
SciConnect.com
58
TRAVEL & TOURS
TM
We print all kinds of books!
Keel Billed
Toucans
are very
social
creatures
Costa Rica
10 DAYS $1095 + tax, fees
Rainforests, Beaches,Volcanoes
Caravan makes it easy to travel.
Free 24 page brochure.
&DUDYDQFRP&$5$9$1
Affordable Vacations
$995 - $1395 + tax & fees.
8 days U.S. National Parks
8 days Grand Canyon, Zion
8 days California & Yosemite
10 days Canada - Nova Scotia
9 days Canada - Rockies
10 days Guatemala
8 days Panama: Canal Cruise
Beaches, Panama City
Caravan
com
Guided Vacations for 60 Years!
AMAZING ARCHAEOLOGY, expert

guides, comfortable hotels, beautiful
scenery, relaxing, informative, wonderful
holidays: Orkney Islands, Scotland:
www.orkneyarchaeologytours.com;
info@orkneyarchaeologytours.com
ARCHAEOLOGICAL TOURS: Spring

2012: Yampa River Visit remote
archaeological sites on downriver
adventure. Northern Plains Explore
Double Ditch, Huff Indian Village, Fort
Union and more. Peru Visit Machu
Picchu, Moche tombs, Cuzco and more.
Fall 2012: French and Indian War Tour
Visit Ganondagan, Fort Ticonderoga and
more. Best of the Southwest Explore
Acoma, Canyon de Chelly, Mesa Verde
and more. Oaxaca Experience Day of
the Dead, visit Mitla, Motne Albn and
more. www.archaeologicalconservancy.
org Archaeological Conservancy,
Albuquerque, NM, (505) 266-1540,
tacmgt@nm.net
MACHU PICCHU & CUZCO: Explorations
since 1992! Inca archaeology, Spanish colonial
history, Quechua culture, Andean ecology.
Amazon, Nazca, Titikaka extensions.
(800)446-9660. www.GoExploring.com
Maya 2012: Examine the myths and truths
of the Mayan calendar with Prof. David
S. Anderson. Travel the Yucatan, study
astronomy, mathematics, creation myths
and Maya historical record.
Aug. 11-18; Mayan Cuisine: Yucatan/
Campeche, Discover Mayan flavors and
culinary traditions. Join this delicious trip
with cooking and tastings! Nov.28-Dec. 7
info@tiastephanietours.com 734-769-7839
UNBELIEVABLE ARCHAEOLOGICAL
TOURS - Custom Design, Hassle free,
Private tours - Leptis Magna, Cyrene,
ancient rock art. BEST SITES in North
Africa. Discover NEW LIBYA
www.libyatravelandtours.com/discover
discover@libyatravelandtours.com
Photo Credits
>i>`
i>
>V*VV
Vii>>}iv
>iV>V`}>v>i
>\nn
>>V
Classified Ad Rates
$5.75 per word.
$115, 20-word minimum.
Contact:
Karina Casines, Account Manager
karina@archaeology.org
(718) 472-3050 ext. 4905
Materials for the
July/August 2012 issue
are due May 8, 2012.
ARCHAEOLOGYS
SPECIAL COLLECTORS EDITION:
Th special newsstand only

This
collectors edition of ARCHAEOLOGY
co
m
magazine presents the magnicent
w
world of the Greeks and Romans.
S
Stunning photography and vivid
sstorytelling uncover life in these
g
great Mediterranean empires from
e
evidence of a Sicilian naval battle,
tto a Roman household only recently
uncovered, to Pompeii, then and now.
Dont miss it!
Order your copy now for just $5.00

plus $3.00 shipping and handling.
Visit www.archaeology.org/classicalworld
Or call 1-800-345-2785
17%
OFF
the newss
tand
price of
$5.99
**This collectors issue is not included as part of your regular subscription to ARCHAEOLOGY Magazine.
www.archaeology.org
COVERAP Photo/RMS Titanic Inc.; 1Courtesy

Michael Frachetti; 2Courtesy Stao Forenbaher,
Courtesy Tel Aviv University, Courtesy Friends of the
Hunley; 4 Courtesy Clara Amit, Israel Antiquities
Authority; 9Courtesy Associated Producers, Ltd.;
10Courtesy Associated Producers, Ltd., Wikimedia
Commons; Candy Waugaman Collection Klondike
Gold Rush National Historical Park Library SS-1268831; 12Courtesy Stao Forenbaher, Peter Endig/
DPA/Landov, Courtesy Obsidian Use Project; 14
Courtesy Tel Aviv University, Courtesy Rijksmuseum,
Courtesy Andrew Wade and the Peabody Museum
of Natural History, Yale University,Division of
Anthropology, ANT.006924.004., Courtesy Stephanie
Panzer,Trauma Center Murnau; 16G.L. Kohuth,
Michigan State University; 18Courtesy Friends of
the Hunley, Courtesy Wil Roebroeks; 19Wikimedia
Commons (2); 20Courtesy Institute of Archaeology
and Ethnology of the Polish Academy of Sciences (2),
Courtesy Alberto Cazzella, Courtesy EFAP Archive;
22(clockwise from top left):Courtesy Richard Talbot,
Office of Public Archaeology, Brigham Young University;
Courtesy Outer Hebrides Coastal Community Marine
Archaeology Pilot Project,J. Benjamin, WA Coastal &
Marine; Wikimedia Commons;Courtesy Alexander
Hollmann, University of Washington;Courtesy Tom
Dillehay, Vanderbilt University;Courtesy Jennifer
Loughmiller-Newman, University at AlbanySUNY;
23(clockwise from top left):Courtesy Alejandro
Jimnez Serrano, University of Jan; Wikimedia
Commons;Courtesy Glenn Summerhayes, University
of Otago, Photo: Les ONeill;Courtesy Kieran Hosty,
Australian National Maritime Museum, Photo:
Xanthe Rivett; 24-25Courtesy Pascal Partouche,
Skyview Photography, Ltd., Courtesy Zeev Radovan;
26Courtesy Lew Somers, GeoScan, Courtesy
Pascal Partouche, Skyview Photography, Ltd.,
Courtesy Sylvia Horowitz; 27Courtesy Andrea
Berlin, Courtesy Sharon Herbert, Courtesy Baruch
Bandl, Israel Antiquities Authority, Bullae Courtesy
Clara Amit, Israel Antiquities Authority; 28Glass
stamp seal Courtesy Baruch Bandl, Israel Antiquities
Authority, Plan Courtesy Lindy Lindorfer, Andrea
Berlin, Sharon Herbert; 29Courtesy Sharon
Herbert, Courtesy Susan Webb, Courtesy Sharon
Herbert, Courtesy Donald Ariel, Israel Antiquities
Authority; 30-31Courtesy Thuringian State Office
for Heritage Management and Archaeology (2);
32Courtesy State Office for Heritage Management
and Archaeology Saxony-Anhalt, photographer Juraj
Liptk (2); 33Nebra sky disk Courtesy State Office
for Heritage Management and Archaeology SaxonyAnhalt, photographer Juraj Liptk, Axes Courtesy
Thuringian State Office for Heritage Management
and Archaeology; 34-35Courtesy Waitt Institute/
Robert Sitrick; 36AP Photo; 39AP Photo/
RMS Titanic Inc.; Courtesy Waitt Institute/Robert
Sitrick; 40Courtesy Institute for Exploration/Center
for Ocean Exploration at the University of Rhode
Island/NOAA Office of Exploration and Research
(2); 41Courtesy NOAA and the Russian Academy
of Sciences; 42-43Courtesy Michael Frachetti;
44Courtesy Michael Frachetti (2); 46Courtesy
Michael Frachetti, Courtesy Mahan Kalpa Khalsa;
47Courtesy Michael Frachetti; 48-49Courtesy of
Barbara Voorhies (3); 50Scala / Art Resource, NY;
51Justin Kerr, Image copyright The Metropolitan
Museum of Art. Image source: Art Resource, NY; 53
Courtesy Julie Schablitsky, University of Oregon (2);
54Courtesy Julie Schablitsky, University of Oregon,
Legends of America Photo Prints; 56Courtesy Julie
Schablitsky, University of Oregon (2); 62Courtesy
Julie Schablitsky, University of Oregon; 68Courtesy
MNHA Luxembourg/T. Lucas
59
Free Information Service

Log on to www.archaeology.org and click on Free Info for products and services featured
by our advertisers. You can also get this information by filling out and mailing the attached card,
or by faxing the card to the number provided.
Tourist Boards
1. Cyprus Tourism Organization
10,000 years of History and
Civilization. The island is an open air
museum, visit Neolithic settlements,
Greek Temples, Crusader Castles,
Venetian Fortresses, Byzantine
Churches and more. Several of our
sites are on the UNESCO list.
www.visitcyprus.com Inside Front
Cover, Brochures, Free
2. The Great State of Texas Texas
vacations are filled with possibilities.
Explore them all with your FREE
Texas State Travel Guide.
www.TravelTex.com p.2, 3 & 16
6. Maya Research Program Excavate

Maya ruins in Blue Creek, Belize,
with a professional team that needs
volunteer help. No experience
necessary. Please include your email
address for more information. p.58,
Brochure, Free
7. Jamestown Yorktown Foundation
Jamestown Settlement and Yorktown
Victory Center. Explore Americas
colonial beginnings through museum
gallery exhibits and living history
depicting 17th- and 18th-century
Virginia. p.8, Brochures, Free
4. Caravan Tours Fully Escorted

Tours $995, Costa Rica, Mexico,
Guatemala, USA, and Canada. 60
years, since 1952. 800-Caravan,
www.CaravanTours.com p.58, 28Page Color Brochure, Free
5. Cultural Cache Tours Professional
academic guides lead archaeological
tours for small and private groups to
the Ancient Near East, including Turkey
and Armenia. www.culturalcache.com
p.58, Tour Itineraries, Exclusive Offers
9. Voyages to Antiquity Voyages

to Antiquity cruises to classical
civilizations INCLUDE shore
excursions, gratuities, pre- and/
or post-cruise hotel stays. Far East
journeys also include land extensions.
For information and reservations, call
877-398-1460. p.23, Brochures, Free
10. Wilderness Travel Wilderness
Travel offers extraordinary cultural,
wildlife, and archaeological
adventures throughout the world.
Request a free catalog or Maya
program brochure. p.59, Catalog and
Program Brochure, Free
11. World Heritage Tours Small group
journeys concentrating on culture,
history and World Heritage sites to
over 85 countries in Asia, Middle East,
ARCHAEOLOGY (ISSN 0003-8113) is published bimonthly for $23.95 by the

Archaeological Institute of America, 36-36 33rd Street, Long Island City, NY 11106.
Periodicals postage paid at Long Island City, NY, and additional mailing oces.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Archaeology, P.O. 433091, Palm Coast,
FL 32164.
Subscriptions should be addressed to Archaeology, Subscription Services, P.O.
433091, Palm Coast, FL 32164, toll-free (877) ARKY-SUB (275-9782), subscription@archaeology.org. $23.95 per volume. Single numbers, $4.99. Foreign and
60
Of Interest to All
12. Oriental Institute The Oriental
Institute is a research and museum
institution focusing on the history,
art, and archaeology of the ancient
Near and Middle East. oi.uchicago.edu
p.58, Membership, Events, Travel
Brochures, Gallery/Museum Materials
and Info, Free
Publishing
8. Tara Tours Inc. Since 1980 selling

quality tour programs to Central &
South America. p.59, Brochures, Free
Travel and Tours

3. AIA Tours Join distinguished
lecturers at the greatest archaeological
sites with the Archaeological Institute
of Americas Tour Program. Visit
www.archaeological.org for more
information. p.67
Eastern Europe & Africa. Offering

published and customised tours.
p.59, Tour Itineraries, Free
13. Morris Publishing Publish

your book! Our free guide to selfpublishing gives you all the features
and prices up-front. p.58, Guide to
Self-publishing, Free
Field School
14. Crow Canyon Archaeological
Center Looking for a learning vacation?
Crow Canyon offers archaeology,
cultural, and adventure travel programs
in the Southwest and beyond for adults,
teens, and families. p.8 & 56, Brochures,
Catalogs, Prospectuses, Free
AIA
15. Archaeological Institute of
America Join the oldest and largest
society devoted to the study and
preservation of the record of the
human past. www.archaeological.org
p.64
Canadian subscriptions, $38.95; includes all government taxes (130277692-RT).

Canadian Publication Agreement #1373161. Allow six weeks for processing new
subscriptions. Send manuscripts and books for review to 36-36 33rd Street, Long
Island City, NY 11106 or editorial@archaeology.org. All manuscripts are reviewed
by experts. Advertisements should be sent to the Advertising Director, 36-36 33rd
Street, Long Island City, NY 11106, (718) 472-3050, advertising@archaeology.org.
We are not responsible for unsolicited manuscripts and photographs. For subscription problems please call (877) 275-9782; AIA members with subscription problems
should call the membership oce at (617) 353-8706. All rights reserved. Printed in
USA. The views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reect the policy of the
AIA or Archaeology.
2012 The Archaeological Institute of America
Limited Mintage Striking...
WORLDS FIRST $100

SILVER PROOF
First-year
2012 date
Mirrored proof
background
Larger Franklin
portrait
Liberty Bell, quill pen

& July 4th date
New York Mint Announces the Limited Mintage

Striking of an Extraordinary Silver Proof
the New United States $100 Bill Struck in
Pure Silver Bullion. Discount Price $99
This extraordinary piece of pure
silver bullion has a surface area that exceeds 30 square inches...and it contains
one Troy ounce of pure silver bullion!
And now, during a limited strike
period, the very first Year 2012 $100
Silver Proof is available at a special
discount priceonly $99!
EXQUISITE DETAIL
The historic First Year 2012 $100
Silver Proof is an exquisite adaptation of the
United States Treasurys $100 Federal Reserve Noteonly
the second new $100 bill design in 70 years. It is a true
artistic masterpiece that will always be treasured.
.999 SILVER
Best of all, this stunning Silver Proof is even more
beautiful than the original, because its struck in precious
silver bullion!
It is a landmark in proof minting, combining unprecedented weight with extraordinary dimension. The specifications for this colossal medallic proof are unparalleled.
Each one:
Is Individually Struck from Pure .999 Silver Bullion.
Weighs one Troy ounce.
Has a Surface Area That Exceeds 30 Square Inches.
Contains 31.10 Grams (480 Grains) of Pure Silver.
Is Individually Registered and Comes With a
Numbered Certificate of Authenticity.
Is Fully Encapsulated to Protect Its Mirror-Finish.
Includes a Deluxe Presentation Case.
Minted in one Troy ounce

of pure silver bullion
Shown larger than

actual size of 6" x 212"
ADVANCE STRIKE DISCOUNT

The price for the 2012 One-Ounce Silver Proof will be set
at $129 per proof.
However, if you place your order now, you can
acquire this giant silver proof at the special advance strike
discount priceonly $99.
NOTE TO COLLECTORS: If you place your order for the
$100 silver proof within the next 10 days, it will be
processed immediately, and the earliest orders will
receive the lowest registration numbers.
ADDITIONAL DISCOUNTS
Substantial additional discounts are available for serious
collectors who wish to acquire more than one of these
exquisite silver proofs.
You can order:
ONE Year 2012 $100 Silver Proof for just $99 + s/h
FIVE Year 2012 $100 Silver Proofs for just $95 + s/h
TEN Year 2012 $100 Silver Proofs for just $89 + s/h
There is a limit of twenty $100 Silver Proofs per order,
and all orders are subject to acceptance by New York Mint.
ONLY 9999 AVAILABLE

New York Mint will strike only 9999 One-Ounce Silver
Proofs for the year 2012, so oversubscription is a virtual
certainty.
Telephone orders only will be accepted on a strict firstcome, first-served basis according to the time and date of
the order.
Call Today to Order Your $100 Silver Proof!
1-888-201-7060
Offer Code: NSP132
A major credit card is necessary to secure your reservation, and New York Mint guarantees satisfaction with a
money-back policy for a full 30 days.
New York Mint
Prices and availability subject to change without notice. Past performance is not a predictor of future performance. New York Mint is a private distributor of worldwide
government coin issues and is not affiliated with the United States government. Facts and figures were deemed accurate as of January 2012. 2012 New York Mint
Visit our web site at www.newyorkmint.com
(continued from page 56)

ples at hand, Tasa listed the cuisine on
the Donner Party desperation menu:
small rodent, rabbit-sized animal,
canine, cow, and deer. But no human.
Only a very small percentage of the
bone could be visually identified.
Out of 16,204 bone fragments (5.03
pounds), over 13,000 pieces remained
unidentified. Because I knew the
faunal analysis would be a challenge,
I sacrificed a few bone fragments to
a DNA laboratory in California, but
the results were inconclusive. The
bone had been cooked and boiled
before it spent over 150 years in acidic soil, degrading the DNA beyond
detection even by twenty-firstcentury forensic technology. Tasa had
another idea. Gwen Robbins Schug,
an anthropologist at Appalachian
State University, can identify animal
species by observing bone structure. It is not a common method for
archaeologists, but was worth a try.
Using an optical microscope to
observe osteons, or the fundamental
structural units of bone, Schug found
85 bone fragments that belonged to
cow, deer, horse, and dog. But again,
there were no human bones. This, of
course, does not mean that the Donners did not practice cannibalism.
Our excavations might have missed
the human remains, or if the Donners
ate only organs and flesh, leaving the
bone unprocessed and unburned, the
skeletons may have decomposed in
the acidic soil. A third possibility is
that the human bone simply remains
undetected in our collection. Although
the absence of identifiable human
bone was an interesting problem, I
was much more intrigued by what we
did find: None of the survivor accounts
from Alder Creek mention successfully hunting and killing rabbit or deer.
We also found lead shot and sprue
from lead casting, suggesting the pioneers had attempted to make ammunition for their guns. Perhaps one of the
Donner Party members or rescuers
had been successful at hunting wild
game. But if the Donners found themselves too weak to hunt in the deep
62
snow, or their aim was

as off,
how could they have
ended up eating
these animals?
fter the dig I

returned home
me
to Oregon, but
there was one thing left
to do. We still needed
ed to
check in with the wel
el mel ti,
the northern Washoe,
oe, to learn if
their ancestors passed
ed down stories
about the Donner Party.
arty The wel mel
ti are thought to have lived in that
region for centuries, and Alder Creek
was just miles from one of their villages. Although they usually wintered
in lower elevations, living off food
stores gathered throughout the year,
it would not have been unusual for a
wel mel ti to strap on a pair of round
snowshoes, or shumlli, and go ice
fishing or hunting on higher ground.
We asked ethnographer Penny Rucks,
who has more than twenty years of
experience with the local tribes, to
ask the wel mel ti if the pioneer tragedy had survived in their tribal narrative. Rucks reached out to Jo Ann
Nevers and Lana Hicks, who agreed
to share the wel mel ti story, with the
understanding that they did so to
honor their ancestors.
Until now the Native American
perspective has been left out of the
telling of the Donner tragedy, not
because the wel mel ti did not remember the pioneers, but because they
were never asked, or perhaps were
not ready to share. Their oral tradition recalls the starving strangers who
camped in an area that was unsuitable
for that time of year. Taking pity on
the pioneers, the northern Washoe
attempted to feed them, leaving rabbit meat and wild potatoes near the
camps. Another account states that
they tried to bring the Donner Party a
deer carcass, but were shot at as they
approached. Later, some wel mel ti
observed the migrants eating human
remains. Fearing for their lives, the
areas native inhabitants continued to
watch the strangers but avoided fur-
A fragment
frag
of a writing slate may
have been used by the children
hav
and adults of the Donner Party
for lessons, notes, and speaks,
perhaps, to their desire to
per
maintain a sense of normalcy.
ma
the contact. These stories, and

ther
the archaeological evidence that
th
appears to support them, certainap
ly complicated my interpretation
of the Donner Party event. The
o
migrants at Alder Creek were
m
not surviving in the mountains
alonethe northern Washoe were
alone
there, and they had tried to help.
Historical archaeologists combine
anthropology, history, and science to
reconcile the human experience with
archives, oral history, and physical evidence. More often than not, there are
contradictions in these data, reminding
us that we can never truly know the
past. But when the pieces fit together,
we are provided with possible scenarios of what may have taken place
hundreds of years ago. In this case, the
absence of cannibalized bone forced
us to give up trying to answer who
was butchered and how it was done.
Instead, we had to find answers to
questions about life in camp from the
crumbs of domestic debris and animal
bone. Our intense desire for information drove us to seek out cutting-edge
technology and reach out to a group
of people who I thought played only
a peripheral role in this pioneer tragedy. When I considered the subtle
archaeological findings within their
proper cultural landscape, an unexpected narrative was born. This new
perspective is one that I believe gives
us a better understanding of what the
Donners experienced and whom they
met in the mountains during that
notorious winter.
Julie M. Schablitsky is a senior research
archaeologist at the University of Oregon,
chief archaeologist at the Maryland
State Highway Administration, and an
editor and contributing author of An
Archaeology of Desperation: Exploring
the Donner Partys Alder Creek Camp
(University of Oklahoma Press, 2011).
BEST-SELLING PRODUCTS
f o r
S e n i o r s
Ten-ten AM,
Thursday,
April 12th,
2012
i n
2 0 1 2
The wristwatch you never

have to set or even see.
Thanks to its revolutionary design, the Talking Atomic Watch gives you accuracy to within
a billionth of a second. It gets its signal from the US Atomic Clock, the standard for time
keeping worldwide. Plus, all you have to do is push a button, and the watch will tell
you the time in a clear, easy-to-understand voice. It will even tell you the day and date.
Travelling? Touch a button to switch it to any time zone. Its lightweight and attractive
and its always accurate. The Talking Atomic Watch was . . . $89.95. Now $49.95 + S&H.
Call today. 1-888-420-8768. Please mention Promotional Code 44486.
Our Lighted Full-Page Magnifier

is hands-free and huge!
Our one-of-a-kind magnifying floor lamp combines powerful FULL-PAGE magnification with flexible
adjustability and clear, even Balanced Spectrum light. Twelve high-powered LEDs provide ample light
for close work and reading. The super-large lens provides 2.5X-plus variable magnification, to easily
cover an entire page without glare or hot spots. The ultra-flexible gooseneck positions the lens exactly
where you need it. And unlike that magnifier in the drawer, youll always know where this one is.
Magnifying lens dimensions are a whopping 7.375 x 10. AC operated. Lighted Full Page Magnifier
was . . . $99.95. Now $79.95 + S&H Call today. 1-877-731-2089. Please mention Promotional Code 44487.
A floor lamp that spreads

sunshine all over a room.
The Balanced Spectrums 27-watt compact bulb is brighter than a 100-watt ordinary light bulb. With
the lamps sharp visibility, you will see with more clarity and enjoyment in close tasks such as
reading, writing, sewing, and needlepoint. It is especially helpful for aging eyes.
Experience sunshine indoors at the touch of a switch. This amazing lamp is not only easy on the eyes,
it is easy on the hands as well, featuring a special soft-touch, flicker-free rocker switch that is easier
to use than traditional toggle or twist switches. And its flexible gooseneck design enables you to get
light exactly where you need it. The high-tech electronics, the user-friendly design, and a bulb that
lasts 10 times longer than an ordinary bulball these features make the Balanced Spectrum floor lamp
a must-have. Balanced Spectrum floor lamp Only $59.95 each + S&H or buy two lamps for $99 + S&H.
Call today. 1-877-721-9046. Please mention Promotional Code 44488.
Are you in love with your home,

but afraid of your staircase?
If you or someone you love lives in a home with more than one floor, the staircase can be more than
an inconvenience, it can be a health threat. Whether it's due to mobility issues or cardiac concerns,
why risk your life climbing stairs when an easy solution is only a phone call away? Youll be surprised
how easy, simple, and affordable the Easy Climber is. It features a reliable, aircraft-grade cable drive
thats been tested over 30,000 cycles. Its also designed for basements and outdoors. Its simple enough
for most people to install on either side of the stairs, a snap to use, and comes with an exclusive
lifetime warranty on the drive train. Call our toll-free number now, and a friendly, knowledgeable
product expert can answer all of your questions and help you get on the road to independence and
safety in the home. Call today. 1-888-691-7192. Please mention Promotional Code 44489.
TM
SITE PRESERVATION
t(SBOUT
t"EWPDBDZ
t0VUSFBDI
t4QSFBEJOH
CFTUQSBDUJDFT
t0OMJOFSFTPVSDFT
SAVE A SITE!
Donate at
WWW. ARCHAEOLOGICAL. ORG/ SITEPRESERVATION
The AIA Preservation Program safeguards the worlds archaeological heritage

for future generations through direct preservation, raising awarness of threats
to sites, education, outreadch, and by facilitating the spread of best practices.
The AIA currently supports projects on five continents. Your generous donation
will help preserve more archaeological sites in need.
Photos of 4 AIA Site Preservation Grant Funded Sites: Assos, Turkey: AIA/Assos Project; Kissonerga, Cyprus: AIA; Easter Island,
Chile: Charles Steinmetz; Umm el Jimal, Jordan: AIA/Open
Hand Studios and Umm el Jimal Project;
www.archaeological.org
EXCAVATE, EDUCATE, ADVOCATE
Site Preservation Grant awarded to Carr Plantation

Archaeology Project on Montserrat
he eruption of the
Soufrire Hills Volcano on
Montserrat covered the southern two-thirds of the Caribbean
island under pyroclastic ow and
volcanic ash. The eruption destroyed
Montserrats capital, Plymouth, and
a signicant portion of the islands
prehistoric and historic settlements.
The islands populace was forced to
relocate to the northern part of the
island and a new capital was established in the town of Little Bay.
Subsequent to the tragic destruction of most of the islands historical
sites, the Montserrat National Trust
(MNT) initiated a program to preserve and study the William Carr
Estate, one of the earliest and few
remaining European settlements
on Montserrat. Despite the histori-
cal importance of the site, the Carr

Estatelocated in the center of Little
Bayis under constant threat from
encroaching development and Montserrat is in danger of losing an important part of its early history.
The Carr Estate may have been
established as early as 1639. There are
a few early documentary mentions

of the site, and its location is noted
on a map of the settlement dating
to 1675. Apart from this, not much
was known about the plantation. The
Carr Estate is currently being studied
by Jessica Striebel MacLean of Boston University. MacLean, director of
the Carr Plantation Archaeology and
Heritage Project, is working in conjunction with the MNT to excavate,
interpret, and preserve the site.
Excavations at the Carr Estate
have uncovered artifacts connected
to the daily life of eighteenth-century
Montserratian planters and exposed
a previously unknown nineteenth- to
early-twentieth century component of
the site. The continuous occupation
of the plantation provides researchers with the unique opportunity to
understand the nature of European
occupation of Montserrat from initial
settlement to the present.
In 2012, the AIA awarded a Site
Preservation Grant to the Carr Plantation Archaeology and Heritage
Project. The grant will be used to
protect the site from urban development and increase local community
involvement in its protection and
preservation. MacLean will create an
archaeology-focused program at local
secondary schools in which students
will be trained in basic archaeological
eld and lab techniques, install interpretive signage around the site, develop a guided walking tour of the site
to be used in conjunction with the
interpretive signs, and erect protective
fencing with gate access around the
perimeter of the site.
65
Excavate, Educate, Advocate
Dispatches from the AIA
The work supported by the AIA

at the Carr Estate combines preservation eorts with public outreach
designed to raise local awareness of
the site. This holistic approach to site
preservation exemplies the AIA Site
Preservation Programs approach to

tackling the issue of protecting and
preserving our invaluable archaeological resources and reiterates the idea
that long-term preservation is possible only when local communities
are committed to protecting sites. To

learn more about the AIA Site Preservation Program and to read about
the other projects we support, please
visit www.archaeological.org/
sitepreservation
National Archaeology
Day, October 20, 2012
successful celebration of National

Archaeology Day was the cooperation
we received from other organizations
committed to archaeology. These
organizations hosted events and publicized National Archaeology Day to
their membership. We are currently
seeking organizations that are will-
ing to host events and/or promote

National Archaeology Day 2012 to
their membership. For information
on how your group can become a
Collaborating Organization and for
sponsorship details, please visit
www.archaeological.org/NAD/
CollaboratingOrganizationInfo
he Archaeological Institute
of America (AIA) is pleased to
announce that National Archaeology Day will be held on October
20, 2012. National Archaeology
Day is a celebration of archaeology
and an opportunity for the AIA and
other like-minded organizations
and individuals to raise awareness
of the discipline across the United
States, Canada, and abroad. In 2011,
National Archaeology Day was ocially recognized by Congress and
more than 14,000 people participated
in over 100 events held throughout
the month of October. To follow this
years program and to nd out about
events in your area, visit
www.nationalarchaeologyday.org. In
addition to events that you can attend,
the AIA will organize a series of online
opportunities that will allow you to
participate in the event from the comfort of your home. Last years virtual
participation opportunities included a
global scavenger hunt and the cooperative creation of a Google Earth layer
showing popular archaeological sites
across the United States and Canada.
An important part of last years
NATIONAL
ARCHAEOLOGY
DAY
O C TO B E R 2 0 , 2 0 1 2
www.nationalarchaeologyday.org
66
AIA Societies promote local community involvement
here are currently 108 AIA Local Societies actively involved in

promoting archaeological learning and raising awareness of archaeological issues in their local areas. Joining an AIA Local Society is a
great opportunity to get involved with archaeology enthusiasts in your
community.Societies provide people with chances to connect with both
professional archaeologists and fellow community members who simply
enjoy learning about the discipline.
Societies organize and host events
throughout the
year. An important
component of society programming
is the AIA Lecture
Program. Each
year, the AIA sends
world-renowned
archaeologists to our
Societies to share
their latest research
and discoveries.
Societies supplement these lectures with their own events, such as dinners
with archaeologists, study groups, eld trips, and more.
The AIA provides funding to Societies that organize archaeological outreach programs for their communities through the Society Outreach Grant
program. Recent Society Outreach Grant awardees have given presentations
at local schools, worked with museums to provide outreach components to
archaeologically themed traveling exhibits, organized archaeology fairs, and
even re-created a Roman spectacle!
Most Societies participate in National Archaeology Day celebrations
because it is a great opportunity for them to promote their programs and
activities on a national level.
Join a Local Society today and get involved! Visit www.archaeological.org/
membership/join. Cannot nd an AIA Society near you? Contact
societies@aia.bu.edu for more information on how you can start one.
Travel & Learn with the AIA
Fascinating Itineraries
Expert Lecturers
India China Greece Turkey Egypt Tunisia

Italy France Spain Georgia Armenia Scotland
Ireland Guatemala Mexico & more
call: 800-748-6262 web site: www.aiatours.org email: aia@studytours.org

ARTIFACT
hariot racing was ancient Romes favorite pastime. It attracted millions of

spectators to stadiums across the empire, inspired fierce fan loyalty,
DATE
and provided its stars a chance to earn spectacular sumsa successful

charioteers single-day winnings could equal a teachers annual salary. It is
perhaps surprising, then, to learn from epigraphic evidence that most charioteers were
slaves who began racing as children, and many were foreigners, who came to the sport
to earn fame and fortune. But until the discovery
very of this
figurine, according to archaeologists Sinclair Bell
and Franziska Dvener, no representation of an
African child charioteer had ever been found. Bronze
figurines of Roman charioteers are rarethere
re
WHAT IS IT?
Statuette of an auriga
(charioteer)
2nd century A.D.
MATERIAL
Bronze
DISCOVERED
2005, Altrier,
Luxembourg
Luxembou
SIZE
1.8 inches hhigh

CURRENTLY LOCATED
LO
Muse national
natio
dhistoire et dart
Luxembourg
Luxembou
are fewer than tenparticularly in comparison

n
to those depicting other entertainers, including
ng
gladiators and actors. Bell and Dvener are certain
rtain that
this statuette represents a charioteer on the basis of his
distinctive costumehis upper abdomen and
chest are corseted by three wide leather belts
called fasciae, part of a charioteers basic
uniform, worn to protect the chest. That
the figurine represents a child is clear from
his enlarged head, large eyes, fleshy cheeks, and
nd
youthful expression. The curly hair, flat nose,
thick lips, and bulging eyes are features typical
al
of Roman depictions of Africans. The archaeologists
ologists
are, however, less certain of the statuettes function.
nction.
It was found near what may have been a sanctuary
tuary
to mother goddesses, but it is impossible to say
ay
whether it was a votive oering or a toy.
68
Archaeological Tours
led by noted scholars
Invites You to Journey Back in Time

Peru (17 days)
Discover the intriguing empires of the Inca,
Lambayeque, Mochica, and Chim peoples
with Prof. Gregory Zaro, U. of Maine.
Touring includes visits to Limas museums,
the Moche tombs of Sipn, Trujillo, Tcume,
Chan Chan, the largest adobe city in the
world, as well as Cuzco and the sacred
Urubamba Valley. Tour highlights
include Cerro Sechn, renowned for
its unique stone carvings, the early
temple-fortress of Chankillo and amazing
Caral, the oldest city in the Americas,
plus two days at Machu Picchu.
Southern Spain (15 days)
Megaliths, Moors & Conquistadors

Spain evokes lovely white towns and the
scent of oranges, but it is also a treasury
of ancient remains including the cities left
by the Greeks, Romans and Arabs. As we
travel south from Madrid with Prof.
Ronald Messier, Middle Tennessee State
U., to historic Toledo, Roman Mrida and
into Andalucia, we explore historical
monuments, Moorish architecture,
Crdobas great cathedral, the splendor of
the Alcazar in Seville and end our tour in
Granada with the opulent Alhambra.
Ancient Cities of
Maritime Turkey (18 days)
with an optional 5-day Jordan

extension
Never far from the sea, Prof Robert Stieglitz,

Rutgers U., will guide us from Izmir and
Ephesus along the Mediterranean and
Aegean coasts to the ancient cities in Karia,
Lycia and Pamphylia. We will sail by private
gulet to Kekova and make day trips to the
Greek islands of Samos and Kos. We will
visit two of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient
World as well as Cnidus, renowned in
antiquity for its statue of Aphrodite. The tour
ends with the Hellenistic cities of Perge and
Aspendos and two days in Istanbul.
Discover Israels layers of ancient

history with archaeologist Dr. Mattanyah
Zohar. After six days in Jerusalem
and a reception at the W.F. Albright
Institute of Archaeological
Research, we visit the fortresses
built by King Herod at Herodion and
Masada. We continue to Qumran and
the sites around the Sea of Galilee
including the Roman/Byzantine city at
Bet Shean, Tel Dan and Solomonic
Hazor in the Golan and Megiddo, as
well as the great Roman/Crusader port at
Caesarea and vibrant Tel Aviv.
Ethiopia: Ancient Kingdoms and

Legends (18 days)
Israel (17 days)
Explore the historic sites associated with the

Kingdom of Axum, one of the oldest empires
of Africa with Dr. Jacke Phillips, U. of
London, SOAS. Beginning in Addis Ababa
we travel north to visit the churches of
Tigray, ancient Axum, medieval Gondar, the
origin of the Blue Nile in Bahir Dar and the
famous rock-cut churches of Lalibela. During
this wonderful adventure we will experience
Ethiopias intriguing pageantry and its
diversity of peoples and traditions.
2012 tours: Eastern Turkey Khmer Kingdoms Oman Sicily & So. Italy Morocco Egypt Viking Age Scandinavia
China: Silk Road Lebanon Ethiopia Chile & Easter Island Gujarat India Sri Lanka Caves & Castles...and more
Journey back in time with us. Weve been taking curious travelers on fascinating historical study tours for the
past 36 years. Each tour is led by a noted scholar whose knowledge and enthusiasm brings history to life and adds
a memorable perspective to your journey. Every one of our 37 tours features superb itineraries, unsurpassed service and
our time-tested commitment to excellence. No wonder so many of our clients choose to travel with us again and again.
For more information, please visit www.archaeologicaltrs.com, e-mail archtours@aol.com, call 212-986-3054,
toll-free 866-740-5130. Or write to Archaeological Tours, 271 Madison Avenue, Suite 904, New York, NY 10016.
And see history our way.
archaeological tours
LED BY NOTED SCHOLARS
superb itineraries, unsurpassed service
2012 United Air Lines, Inc. All rights reserved.
Wherever youre going...

were there.
Over 370 destinations
throughout the world.
And there. And there. And there. The truth is, with over 370 destinations throughout
the world, chances are good that no matter where youre headed, we can take you.
For information and reservations, go to united.com.
Includes destinations served by United Air Lines, Inc.

and United Express.

09 - Archaeology - May June 2012

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

09 - Archaeology - May June 2012

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Donner Party: The Native American Perspective

A publication of the Archaeological Institute of America

A post-Cold War construction boom

How pastoralist nomads carried

Cover: A map of the bow of Titanic made

42 Archaeologists are searching

700-year-old artifacts persist on New Mexicos surface,

More from this Issue To read our

and how tall is the Lion Man?

previous coverage on Titanic, go to

9 From the Trenches

Letter from California

discoveries at the Minoan site of Zominthos in

Archaeological News from around

Stay in Touch Visit Facebook to like

A new look at the notorious Donner Party

Interactive Digs Read about the latest

Clear your mind in Texas. To plan your own Texas

hat sometimes gets overlooked in our coverage of archaeology is the nature of

Malin Grunberg Banyasz

Roger Atwood, Paul Bahn, Bob Brier,

Athens: Yannis N. Stavrakakis

Greg Wolfe, Circulation Specialists, Inc.

Malin Grunberg Banyasz

James P. Delgado, Ellen Herscher,

Subscription questions and address

ARCHAEOLOGY May/June 2012

When we introduced the original Acoustic Wave music

i> iv vii v `> Use our 30-day,

is the most respected

Shown in Graphite Gray

/   "  U 7 9  , "   " 

FROM THE PRESIDENT

everal bills currently making their way through

Mitchell Eitel, Esq.

President, Archaeological Institute of America

ARCHAEOLOGY May/June 2012

Finally, a cell phone

with rates as low as $3.75 per week!

Aordable plans that I can understand and no contract to

a time or subject to termination fees. The

Jitterbug Cell Phone

Call today to get your own Jitterbug phone.

We proudly accept the following credit cards.

Why Are Coronados Artifacts

Excavate alongside professional

June, July, August, & October, 2012

Make Room for the Memories.

Save 20% on a combination ticket

Archaeologist Matt Schmader

ARCHAEOLOGY welcomes mail from

Author Marion Blackburn responds:

Maybe I missed something, but it does

Executive Editor Jarrett A. Lobell

ARCHAEOLOGY May/June 2012

LATE-BREAKING NEWS AND NOTES FROM THE WORLD OF ARCHAEOLOGY

The Perils of Interpretation

cholars often arrive at difHe and Tabor wanted to know if

FROM THE TRENCHES

and Tabors interpretation as much

In the winter of 18971898, word

with goods, the bones of pack

The inscription on one of the ossuaries

the easier path to the gold fields.

i> iv vii v `> Use our 30-day,

/ " U 7 9 , " "