You are on page 1of 20

:

, 33, 2000, .
379-402.

Ian Morris Death ritual and


social structure in classical antiquity 1
,

,
. ,

.
,
, ,
,
(. 1).

.
,
,
.

,
.
.


.

.
tour de force:


.
Morris :
.


(. 120),

(. 123)
. , , ,
(. 116)
(. 129).
:

. ,
1

Ian Morris, , .
. , , 1997.
2

,
,
. ,
.

.
,
.

.
.
,
, ,

.
.
,
. 2
,
, .


,


.
,
, .
, , Michael
Rostovtzeff,

. 3 ,
Moses Finley, 4

,
,

.
,
.
(1200 700
..). ,

.

, ,
2

. M. Shanks, Classical Archaeology of Greece: Experiences of the discipline, ,


1996.
3
M. Rostovtzeff, The social and economic history of the Roman Empire, , 1957.
4
. M. I. Finley, The ancient economy, , 1985.
3

,
. Anthony
Snodgrass . Snodgrass
,
,

. 5
, Ian Morris,

. 6 , Snodgrass
,
, . 7
, ,

, (
).

. 8

9 :
, ,

.
, ,
:
.
.
,
, ,
, .
.
,
, .

, , , ,
...,

5

A. Snodgrass, Archaic Greece, , 1980.


. J. Whitley, Style and society in Dark Age Greece, , 1991, R.
Osborne, (1200 479 . .), , 2000.
7
A. Snodgrass, An archaeology of Greece: The present state and future scope of a discipline,
, 1987, . 93-131.
8
N. Coldstream: ( )
,
. Jeffery
.

, , . . , , 1997, . 25.
9
. M. I. Finley, Early Greece.The Bronze and Archaic ages, , 1970, O.
Murray, Early Greece, , 1981.
6

, (. 13-15
).
Montaillou, 10 .

.


. 11

16 .
(
: )
. 12 ;


.

,
. 13 , .


. :

,
,
. 14
, ,
.

, .. .
.
.
10

E. Le Roy Ladurie, Montaillou, village occitan de 1294 a 1324, , 1982.



. Finley
,


.
12
. Morris The Athenian
economy twenty years after the Ancient Economy, Classical Philology, 89, 1994, . 351366.
13
Keith Hopkins:
,
,
;. . P. Garnsey- C.R. Whittaker, , Trade and famine in
classical antiquity, , 1983, . 104.
, . R. Osborne,
Pots, trade and the archaic Greek economy, Antiquity, 70, 1996, . 31-44.
14
. R. Osborne, Classical landscape with figures, , 1987, S. Alcock, Graecia
Capta. The landscapes of Roman Greece, , 1993.
11

, ,
;

.
,
,
. 15
, ,

,
... 16
,
.

.
,
. 17
,
.

. ,
. 18
,
, Morris.
,
,
,
( ,
,

. 1).
. ,
,
. 19
15


. R. Parker, Miasma. Pollution and purification in early Greek
religion, , 1983, . 66-73.
I. Morris, Attitudes towards death in archaic Greece, Classical
Antiquity, 8, 1989, . 296-320.
16
. A. Snodgrass, The economics of dedication at Greek sanctuaries, Scienze dell
Antichitta, 3-4, 1989/90, . 287-294. ,
8 7
. . A. Snodgrass, Archaic
Greece, .. , . 51-65.
17
, . A.
Snodgrass, An archaeology of Greece, .., . 36-66.
18
. D. B. Small, , Methods in the
Mediterranean. Historical and archaeological views on texts and archaeology, ,
1994.
19
, . .
13 . .
6


. 20

.
.

, ,

. ..
,
.
, ,

.

.
.
. , (
),

, . 21
, ,
.
,
, ,
, ,
(. 16-18).
.
: ,
( )
( ),
(
).
. ,

.
.


.
,

(. 100-105).
,
20

, .
56 ..
21

. . R. Garland, The well-ordered corpse: an investigation
into the motives behind Greek funerary legislation, Bulletin of the Institute of Classical
Studies, 36, 1989, . 1-15.
7


(. 135-136, 138-140).
Morris
. , ,

.

8

. 22

.

.

. 23
6
. ,
(, , , ,
) ,
, 6
(. 190). 24

5
7,
,


. 25


.
,

. Morris
22

. I. Morris, Burial and ancient society: The rise of the Greek city state, ,
1987, . 189-194, F. de Polignac, Cults, territory and the origins of Greek city states,
, 1995.
23
Morris . C. Sourvinou Inwood, Early sanctuaries, the
eighth century and ritual space: fragments of a discourse N. Marinatos - R.Hgg,
, Greek sanctuaries. New approaches, , 1993, . 1-17.
24

.
6 ,
. ,
.
25
. Debating Dark Ages, Caeculus, III, 1996/7 M. Prent, The 6th century BC in
Crete: the best candidate for being a dark age? . 35-46. . I. Morris, Archaeology
and archaic Greek history N. Fisher H. van Wees, , Archaic Greece, ,
1998, . 59-68.
8

8 , Snodgrass, ,
7 . 26
, ,
.
, 8 7
,
.
8
,
:
( )
.
,
8 ,
. 27
, Morris
.
Morris


. , ,

, Morris
.
,

.

,
, , .


.
;
.
(
)
,
,
. 28 Finley,


,
. , ,
26

Morris, Burial, ..
, .
27
Morris (. 155). .
Snodgrass 16.
28
. G. Glotz, , . . , , 1978, .
110-117.
9



. 29 , ,
,

. 30
1970 Snodgrass
. Snodgrass

, ,
, , ... 31
,
,

. 32

(multiplier
effect) C. Renfrew, 33 , ,
Snodgrass.
,
,
Snodgrass ,

. 34
,
.
Morris
, , , . ,
1987, 35 .
,
(1200 700 ..) (700 500 ..)

. Morris
.
,

.


29

. A. Andrewes, , . . , ,
1982.
30
. I. Morris, Burial, .., . 196-205, K. A. Raaflaub, Soldiers, citizens and the
evolution of the early Greek polis L. G. Mitchell P. J. Rhodes, , The
development of the polis in Archaic Greece, , 1997, . 49-59.
31
A. Snodgrass, Archaeology and the rise of the Greek city state, , 1977.
32
A. Snodgrass, Archaic Greece, .., . 52-65.
33
C. Renfrew, The emergence of civilization, , 1972.
34
. A. Snodgrass, The rise of the polis. The archaeological evidence M. H. Hansen,
, The ancient Greek city state, , 1993, . 30-40.
35
. I. Morris, Burial, ..
10

. Morris 8

.
(
) ,

. 36
,
,
(.188-191).
, Morris
5 . 37

,
.
,
;
Morris
.
6 5,

.
,

. 500 .. 425
..
(. 175-176).
,
(.
171-176). 38
Morris
. ,
.
500 ..
:

. , 400 ..
(. 183-184).
,
,
.
36

Finley de Ste Croix. . M. I. Finley,


, , . , , 1991,
G. E. M. de Ste Croix, , . ,
, 1997.
37
. I. Morris, The strong principle of equality and the archaic origins of Greek
democracy J. Ober - C. W. Hedrick, , Demokratia. A conversation on
democracies, ancient and modern, , 1996, . 19-48.
38
. I. Morris, Everyman s grave A. Boegehold A. Scafuro, , Athenian
identity and civic ideology, , 1994, .67-101.
11


. 39
. Morris
(, , , )
5 (. 150-157)
(. 191-193). 40


. ,


(. 195).

;

. Morris
.
Aubrey Cannon 41
,
, , , ,

(. 185).


. Colin Renfrew 42


, (. 188).
Morris


. 43
Morris

( Cannon).
Morris, Cannon
,

39

. I. Morris, Law, culture and funerary art in Athens, 600300 BC, Hephaistos, 1112, 1992/3, . 35-51.
40
I. Morris, Beyond
democracy and empire: Athenian art in context D. Boedeker K. Raaflaub, ,
Democracy, empire and the arts in fifth century Athens, , ., 1997, . 59-86.
41
. A. Cannon, The historical dimension in mortuary expressions of status and sentiment,
Current Anthropology, 30, 1989, . 437-458.
42
. C. Renfrew, Beyond a subsistence economy, C. B. Moore, ,
Reconstructing complex societies, , 1974, . 69-95.
43
. Morris An archaeology of equalities? The Greek
city states D. L. Nichols T. H. Charlton, , The archaeology of city states.
Cross- cultural approaches, , 1997, . 91-105.
12

(
: ;
,
; . 187). Morris

(. 188195). Morris
420,
480,
(.187).
Morris .
.
. Morris
500 ..


.
.
: Renfrew
,

,
44 . :
,
,
. ,

. 45 .

.
,
.

, .

7 .
, Opferrinnen,
, . 7

. 46 560 ..
,
44

, ,
, ,
.
45


. . C. Antonaccio, An archaeology of ancestors:
tomb cult and hero cult in early Greece, , 1995.
46
. S. Houby Nielsen, Interaction between chieftains and citizens? Seventh century burial
customs in Athens, Acta Hyperborea, 4, 1992, . 343-374.
13

. 47
, 7
.

. 48 430 ..
;
, 49
560-300 ..,
.

500 ..
Morris
,
(standing monuments cemeteries).
,
.
,

. 50
,
.

, 317/6 .. .

. 51

500 .. . Small


52 . ,

.
(
,
47

. .. . 362 S. Houby Nielsen, The archaeology of ideology in the Kerameikos:


New interpretations of the Opferrinnen, R. Hgg, , The role of religion in the
early Greek polis, , 1996, . 41-54.
. M. Shanks, Art and the Greek city state. An
interpretative archaeology, , 1999.
48
. A. M. DOnofrio, Aspetti e problemi del monumento funerario attico arcaico, AION,
10, 1988, . 83-96.
49
. S. Houby Nielsen, Burial language in Archaic and classical Kerameikos,
Proceedings of the Danish Institute at Athens, 1, 1995, . 129-191.
50

Cannon.
51
. D. B. Small, Monuments, laws and analysis: combining archaeology and texts in
ancient Athens D. B. Small, Methods, .., . 143-174. Morris
,
. . I. Morris, Law, .., . 44-46.
52

( .. . 162). . .
14

, ).
.
, ,
,
. Morris

(. 171),

, .

Small. 53
(. 168-171)
Small, ,
Morris.
.

,
.
.
/
.

,
. ,
, .
.
, ,
54
(.. ).
,
. 55

, .
;


. 56 ,

53


. ,
,
500 ..
54
Morris (. 221-251).
. R. Hgg, Some aspects of the
burial customs of the Argolid in the Dark Ages, , 13,
1980, . 119-126.
55
. I. Morris, Burial, .., . 72-96.
56
. Houby Nielsen, Burial language, .., . 143-144. Nielsen

.
15

.
. Nielsen
,
.
.

.
, .

.


,
...

.
,

.


.
,

. ,
.

; ;

;
; 57

. Morris
. 1050
750 .. 700 500 ..
.
8
-
.

,
500 ..
. 58
Morris .
.

57

. R. Garland, A first catalogue of Attic peribolos tombs,


Annual of the British School at Athens, 77, 1982, . 125-176.
58
. Morris, Burial, .., . 57-62, 93-96.
16

.
.
,
,
. 59 Houby Nielsen

451/0 .. 60
,
, 61 .
.
,
,

.
,
. Houby Nielsen

,
30 %.
5 .

. 1:1,3 500-475 ..
1:7,3 (. 178).


, ;

. ,
,
.
: Morris


.
. 62

59

. .
Burial and ancient society B. DAgostino A. M. DOnofrio
Gnomon, 65:1, 1993, . 48.
60

. . S. Houby Nielsen, Burial language, .., . 150-152.
61

. R. Osborne, Law, the democratic citizen and
the representation of women in Classical Athens, Past and Present, 155, 1997, . 3-33.
62
,
. J. P. Crielaard, Cult and death in early 7th century Euboea: the aristocracy and the polis
S. Marchegay M. T. Le Dinahet J. F. Salles, Necropoles et pouvoir: Ideologies,
pratiques et interpretations, , 1998, . 43-58.
17

. 63


. 64

(. 195).

.
Morris. , Morris

.

,

. ,
.
,
, ,
. :

, (. 189).

600 300 ..,

;
Morris
. M. Vickers D. Gill

. 65 ,

, .

.
(.150-151).
,
,
.
(. 152-154). Vickers Gill

.
( ..
)
63


. L. Mitchell, Greeks bearing gifts. The public use of
private relations in the Greek world, , 1997.
64
. E. Meyer, Epitaphs and citizenship in classical Athens, Journal of Hellenic Studies,
103, 1993, . 99-121.
65
M. Vickers D. Gill, Artful crafts. Ancient Greek silverware and pottery, , 1994,
. 33-55.
18

. 66
.


. Miller

. 67
6 .
; ,
,
.

.
.
Morris
, ,
.

.

.
. .
8 ,
(
, )
, 68 .
69 ,
12
70 , ,
, 71 72 .

. 73
,
,
66

. H. Hoffmann, In the wake of Beazley: Prolegomena to an anthropological


study of Greek vase painting, Hephaestos, 1, 1979, . 61-70.
67
M. Miller, Athens and Persia in the fifth century BC. A study in cultural receptivity,
, 1997.
68
. C. Baurain - C. Bonnet V. Krings, , Phoinikeia grammata:
Lire et ecrire en Mediterranee, , 1991.
69
. W. Ward M. Joukowsky, , The crisis years: The twelfth century BC from
beyond the Danube to the Tigris, , 1992.
70
: R. V. d A. Desborough, , . , ,
1995, . 121. : M. Iacovou, The topography of eleventh century BC Cyprus V.
Karaghiorgis, , Cyprus in the eleventh century BC, , 1994, . 149-164.
71
. Houby Nielsen, Chieftains to citizens, .., 46, . 353-354.
72
. J. K. Papadopoulos, Phantom Euboians, Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology, 10:2,
1997, . 191-219.
73
,
Sarah Morris Daedalos and the origins of Greek art, ,
1992.
19

.
.

.

,
. ,

. Morris,
, .

,
. 74

. 75

,


.
,
.

.

Morris,
.

74
75

I. Morris, Archaic history, .., 25, . 74-79.


. M. van de Mieroop, The ancient Mesopotamian city, , 1997.
20

You might also like