Professional Documents
Culture Documents
P A C H U T A
Reproduced from astern and Western Approad1es to Healing: Ancient Wisdom and
Modern Knowledge, (ed), Anees A. Sheikh and Katharina S. Sheikh, John Wiley and
Sons.
42 I India International Centre QuaJterfy
emotions fit into the Five Elements. The second major cycle, the K'o
cycle, provides a unique view of the relationships of emotions and
the idea of emotional antidotes, which can be helpful in our daily
lives as well as in psychotherapy. Finally we will investigate the
diagnostic and therapeutic systems of ancient Chinese medicine.
spirit. Thus, the patient has a primary responsibility, and the health
care practitioner can only assist him or her in becoming well. The
basic energy is treated; all else flows from it. In the Eastern systems,
centeredness and wholeness of the practitioner are crucial, and love
is essential to the cure.
In contrast, the Western healingsystemsare linear and emphasize
d ifferences. We have great difficulty in tolerating paradox. We stress
the division of the person into body and mind, and the spirit is
generally irrelevant to person into body and mind, and the spirit is
generally irrelevant to Western scientific medicine. The practice of
medicine consists of the treatment of symptoms rather than of the
whole person. To most physicians, only external sources of disease
matt~~r, and they pay little or no attention to the internal sources of
illness. Therefore, the patient has little or no responsibility, and the
practitioner is put on a pedestal. The state o f being of such a
practitioner is not relevant; for, it is the external medicine or the
external technique that effects the cure. A pill exists or must be found
for every ill. Love is completely ignored.
Ancient Chinese medicine was always a system of preventive
medicine. In con trast, Western medicine, until very recently, had
focused on the treatment of illness and paid li ttle attention to
prevention.
Finally, the Eastern systems of healing differ radically from the
Western ones in their regard for their healing heritage. The Eastern
systems display a deep reverence for their heritage. For the most
part, we have lost that reverence in the \Ves t. Healing professionals
must realize that every time they pick up a prescription pad or an
acupuncture needle, they touch thousands of years of traditions and
somehow share in the divine. We wou ld do well to remember the
words of Albert Einstein:
The Ch'i Energy, the one universal energy, the cosmic life force,
is the most fundamental concept of the entire Chinese system of
medicine. It is the vital life force, the flux, the flow. It is the energy of
the heavens and the earth, the energy within and without. It is the
vital life force that flows through us, and it does so in a very orderly
and logical fashion on pathways called meridians.
Ironically, Western medicine, which so values order, generally
denies the existence of an orderly flow of energy through us. But
perhaps the greatest Western scientist, Albert Einstein, held the idea
of a universal energy. He said that the different energies held by
physicists were not separate but part of one single energy. Finally, in
the last several years, all notions of separate energies have crumbled,
and his idea has been accepted.
The Ch'i flows in an orderly way. Balance and harmony of this
energy means health. Imbalance or disharmony of the flow of Ch'i
results in illness. This idea illustrates a fundamental Eastern notion:
namely, that it is not possible to be sick in body wi thout being sick in
mind, emotion, and spirit. You cannot possibly have a sickness of the
body, or the mind, or the emotions, or the spirit only; illness resides
46 I India International Centre Quarterly
Fig. 1: Yin/Yang
DONALD M. PACHUTA I 47
on. Yet it is also our unity, our integration of all these things into a
whole; it is a circle never ending and complete.
To the Western mind, things are black and white or black or white.
But in the Eastern way, things are black/white. ln theJudeo-Christian
tradition, all opposites are warring forct'S. The chief battle is good
against evil. One must triumph, and we must be sure that it is good.
In the Eastern way, the inseparable Yin and Yang gently wrestle with
each other. Nothing in the universe is one or the other. Everything
contains Yin/Yang. They are part of the same reality. They are
merely opposite polarities of the same magnet, and it is impossible
to have one w ithout the other.
Westerners havegreatdifficulty with this concept. We hold that
light battles with darkness, life with death, good with evil, positive
with negative. As Alan Watts said (1975, p. 20):
Thus, the ideal to cultivate the former and be rid of the latter flourishes
throughout much of the world. To the traditional way of Chinese
thinking, this is as incomprehensible as electric currents without both
positive and negative poles. For polarity is the principle that plus/
minus, north/south (and indeed all parts of opposites) are different
aspects of the same system. The disappearance of either one of them
wou ld be the disappearance of the entire system.
Under heaven all can see beauty as beauty only because there is
11gli11ess.
All can know gooii as good only because f/i,~e is evil.
Therefore having and not having arise together.
Difficult and easy complement each otlrer.
Long and slrort contrast eac/1 other;
High and low rest upon each oflier;
Voice and sound harmonize eacli other;
Front and back follow one anot/1er.'
(Feng & English, 1972, p. 2)
C!.11 ~l'lt.t ff l'AIK lifA S t: AHIH Gllt A IES-1 " " '
universe and the eternal Tao. Many concepts, especially the elements
and officials that are all encompassing, frequently raise disbelief in
the student from the West. It is useful to willingly suspend our
disbelief in approaching this system.
fortifies muscles. Its sense organ is the mouth, and its secretion is
saliva. The time of the Stomach is from 7 to 9 a.m., and the time of the
Spleen / Pancreas is from 9 to 11.a.m. Earth encompasses the emotion
empathy, the singing voice, a fragrant odor, an d a sweet taste. Its
power is to decrease. Westerners have been trained to usually view
decrease negatively; yet, decrease is a part of balance. If the fires and
expansion of summer did not decrease, the planet would bum up.
The life aspect of Earth incorporates ideas and opinions. Beyond all
this, Earth is the Divine Mother.
includes the Father, the Creator, the Heavens, and the Air.
Water. Water is associated with the color blue, winter, cold,
north, the Bladder, and the Kidneys. It fortifies bones. Its sense
organs are the ears, and its secretion is spittle. The time of the Bladder
is from to 3 to 5 p.m., and the time of the Kidneys is from 5 to 7 p.m.
Water includes the emotion fear, the sound of a groaning voice, a
putrid odor, and a salty taste. Its power emphasizes, and its life
aspect is will power. Beyond this, Water has many spiritual points on
its meridians. It contains the primordial stuff of the universe, its very
essence; and hence it represents utmost power. The ancient Chinese
placed the nervous system in the sea of bone marrow, under the
control of Water. Also they put blood in the sea of bone marrow (they
knew that marrow made blood) under the control of the Kidneys.
Only centuries later was it "proven" that the Kidneys control the
bones and secrete a hormone that controls the making o f red blood
cells.
Wood. Wood is associated with the color green, spring, wind,
east, the Gallbladder, and the Liver. It fortifies ligaments and tendons.
It is our eyes and our tears. The time of day of the Gallbladder is from
11 p.m. to 1 a.m., and the time of the Liver is from 1 to 3 a.m. Anger,
a shouting voice, a rancid odor, and a sour taste are associated with
Wood. Its power is birth, and its life aspect is spiritual faculties.
Wood encompasses creativity and spiritual vision.
We have a hard time accepting the organs as mother of each
other. How can the Liver or Gallbladder be the mother of the Heart
(see Table3)? Western "scientific" research maintains that there is no
relationship behveen gallbladder disease and heart disease. Yet, I
saw three young women die of heart attacks after having had their
gallbladders removed, although they had no known underlying
disease. It encourages me to know that others know this connection.
An acquaintance who had had two previous heart attacks was
hospitalized with a gallbladder attack. Both the surgeon and the
cardiologist told her that they would not touch her gallbladder until
she had resolved the anger at her husband (perhaps the cause of the
attack). Whenever I see a patient who needs gallbladder surgery, I
always assist them in dealing with their anger prior to the surgery.
Times of Day. Table 2 shows the times of d ay. This is the
circadian and biological rhythm that indicates when the energy of a
DONA.LO M. PACHUTA / 57
have to worry about it. I just blow my top and it's gone." Blowing
your top is pathological. You should not have to blow your top. You
should not suppress the anger until it reaches boiling point and leads
to an explosion.
angry, sad when you feel sad, afraid when you feel afraid, and so on.
Mastery is being how you are.
Empathy/Fear. The K'o Cycle is written in our hearts . We all
know it at some level, but many of us do not function by it. Mastery
of the emotions involves knowing the K'o Cycle of control. The
controlling emotion is the antidote of the emotion it controls. Fear is
controlled by empathy, not by love or joy as is often thought. You can
tell someone who is afraid that you love him or her, and it does
absolu tely no good. But if you tell the person that you understand,
the fear lessens. If you tell a child who just fell down, "Mommy loves
you," it does not help. But ii you look the child in the eye and say,
"Hey, that must really hurt," he or she stops cold, looks up at you,
and said, "Yes, it does hurt." The child experiences that you know the
feeling. I treated a man who was beaten and robbed. He had received
a lot of!ove from others, but he still had numerous symptoms. When
I empathized with this fear, he fully recovered. Empathy is the
antidote.
Joy/Sorrow. We often use empathy as the antidote for sadness
with very disappointing results. When we say to a friend whose
mother has just died, "I know how you feel," the reaction is, "You
can't possibly know how I feel. This is my experience, not yours." Yet
if we put our hand on the friend'sshoulder and tell him that we care,
the grief starts to subside. The antidote for grief is love and joy. Joy
is a major preventer and cure of depression.
Anger/Sympathy. Anger is the antidote for sympathy. There
are people who are grand victims, and they carry a sign that says,
"Give me sympathy." On their back, they have another sign that
says, "I am a doormat, s tep on me." These people are sympathy
sponges that will soak up every ounce of your energy and still not be
satisfied. They usually evoke an angry reaction.
I saw a woman in the emergency room who was receiving
intravenous medication to treat her asthma. She was not responding
to any of the drugs, because she was wailing on and on about how
nobody understood her. I walked in on this scene and I said, "Stop
it, enough. Shut up." The residents thought my bedside manner left
something to be desired. I said to her, "Your job is to stop wheezing.
It is not to lie here and moan. Your problems will not be solved in this
emergency room. The only thing that will be decided here is whether
DONALD M. PACHUTA I 63
we take you out of here in a box or vve move you up to a bed. Your
job is to stop wheezing, and we are giving you the best medicines to
help you do the job." Even as I said this, you could hear the wheezing
subside. This patient never had another emergency room visit. When
she began to wheeze, she would call me, and I helped her get in touch
with her own anger; the wheezing always stopped.
The best way to obtain sympathy is to ask for it. Simply say to
a friend, "Jean, I need some sympathy. How about it?" If she agrees,
you have your sympathy. Or she may say, 'Tm tired; I can't give you
any right now, wait until later. Let's have a drink first and relax." All
sympathy needs can be met this way.
Grief/Anger. Some say sadness is a quiet anger. That is an
interesting observation because grief is the antidote for and controller
of anger. If you react to anger with sadness, it helps to express it: "It
makes me sad seeing you angry." Very often this response will
dissipate the anger. When I was a junior medical student, I was asked
to draw blood from a man who had just beaten up six police officers.
As J entered the room, he screamed at me, "What d o you wan t?" He
was a giant of a man, and I trembled as I explained. He became even
angrier and refused to cooperate. I looked up at him and said, "You
know, it really makes me sad to see you like this." Immediately he
went from violent to peaceful, and I had no problem carrying out my
assignment. The expression of grief did it. Of course, it cannot be
phony. Often we use sympathy to try to deal with anger, but
generally it does not work.
indicate balance. Those who say, "I can't stand summer," "I despise
blue," "I detest red," "I can't live without eating liver several times
a week," are manifesting excesses and show a lack of balance or
harmony in an element.
In the diagnostic system, the law of mother I child must be borne
in mind. According to it, if the mother becomes sick, she cannot
nurture the child, and it, in turn, becomes ill. Thus, an imbalance in
a particular element may be d ue to the imbalance in the mother of
that element.
An imbalance in the flow of Ch'i that controls \-\1ood may result
in d isease in the liver or gallbladder, in a craving or avoidance of sour
tastes, in abnormal anger and resentment, and in acu te and chronic
back piiin. However, the imbalance also may cause the child-Fire--
to scream, so that the person may have symptoms in the heart,
circulation, sexual organs, endocrine system, and so on.
Imbalance in the flow of Ch'i energy that controls Water may
show up as kidney d isease; a craving for salt or avoid ance of it; excess
fear; lack of willpower, drive, or resolve; sexual inadequacy; and
problems with cold. A person can even have pain radiating on a
merid ian pathway tha t makes no sense to Western doctors. Such
pain is then diagnosed as psychosomatic. But the problem is readily
made clear by a practitioner skilled in Chinese medicine. (See also
Pachuta, Branson, & Measures, 1973)
Color. A person in a state of disharmony is. predominantly
colored with one or more of the following five colors, regard less of
skin color. Green is the color of anger (Wood). Weare all famil iar wi th
the expression, "Green wi th envy." Envy is an intellectualisation of
anger. In England they say, "You look livery." The liver and
gallbladder are on the green circle and are associated with anger. We
say, "He has a lot of gall." That comes from a place of anger. Red is
the color of joy (Fire); yellow is the color of empathy (Earth); white is
the color of grief (Metal); blue is the color of fear (Water). With
training and by letting go of your barriers, it is not hard to see these
colors. The color, of course, is associated with all the other
correspondences of that element.
Sound. The sound of anger is shouting. Some people's voices
grate your eardrums even when they are speaking softly; others
seem to be yelling all the time. The sound of joy is laughing. A
laughing voice generally indicates an imbalance in the Fire element.
OONAWM. PACHUTA ! 65
Notes
References
Bean, W.B. (Ed.) (1950), Sir William Osler, aphorism from his bedside teachings and
writings. New York: Henry Schuman.
Easwaran, E. <Trans.) (1985). BIU1gavad Gita. Petaluma, CA: Nilgini Press.
Connelly, D.M. (1979). Traditional acupuncture: The law of tlte five ,e/emelfls. Columbia,
MD: The Centre for Traditional Acupuncture.
Feng, G.F., & English, J. <Trans.) (1972). l.ao Tsu: Tao Te Ching. New York: Vintage
Books.
Larre, C., Schatz, J., & de la Vallee, E.R. (1979). Survey of traditional Oiinese medicine,
Sarah Elizabeth Stang (Trans.). Columbia, MD: Traditional Acupuncture
Foundation.
Pachuta, D.M. (1981). The integration of east and west. /O'rmra/ of Traditio11al
Acupuncture, 7:1, 29-34.
Pachuta, D.M. (1987). The life you save may be, your own. Baltimore: Institute for
Learning Mastery Press.
Pachuta, D.M., Branson, B.M., & Measures, }. (1983). Acupuncture and other adjunct
therapy in the treatment of acquireii immunodeficiency syndrome. Journal of
Traditio1U1I Acupuncture, 7:2, pp. 27-30.
Porker!, M.(1974). The.iretical foundations ofChines<! medicine: Sy~tl?ms ofcorrespo11drnce.
Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Reps, P. (1957). Zen Flesh, Zen Bones. Rutland, VT: Tuttle.
68 I India International Centre Quarterly
Veith, I., (Trans.) (1972). Nei Ching: The Yellow Emperor's Classic of Internal Medicine.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Watts, A. 0975). Tao, the watercourse way. New York: Pantheon Books.
Worsley, j.R. (1973). ls acupuncture for you? New York: Harper & Row.
Worsley, J.R. 0982). Traditional Chinese acupuncture. vol. 1. Meridian and poi11ts.
Tisbury, Wiltshire, England: Element Books.