You are on page 1of 8

Chapter 25

Exergy in Policy Development


and Education
Chapter Outline
25.1 Introduction 499 25.4 The Role and Place for Exergy in Education Policies 502
25.2 Exergy Methods for Analysis and Design 500 25.4.1 Education about Exergy 503
25.3 The Role and Place for Exergy in Energy-Related 25.4.2 The Need for Exergy Literacy in Scientists and
Education and Awareness Policies 501 Engineers 503
25.3.1 Public Understanding and Awareness of Energy 501 25.4.3 Understanding the Second Law through Exergy 503
25.3.2 Public Understanding and Awareness of Exergy 501 25.4.4 Exergys Place in a Curriculum 504
25.3.3 Extending the Publics Need to Understand and 25.5 Closing Remarks 505
Be Aware of Exergy to Government and the Problems 506
Media 502

It is easier for the public to be educated about and aware


ABSTRACT
In this chapter, we describe the role of exergy in policy devel-
of exergy if students are adequately educated about exergy
opment and education. We examine education and awareness of in appropriate venues (university and college thermody-
exergy, by focusing first on the public and the media, and then on namics courses, primary and secondary schools, etc.).
the education of thermodynamicists, as well as other technical Consequently, this chapter deals with education and
people. Also, it is demonstrated that exergy has a place in policy awareness of exergy, first by focusing on the public and then
development regarding energy-related education and awareness. It by dwelling on the education of thermodynamicists as well
is demonstrated that the public is often confused when it discusses as other technical people. The objective is to demonstrate
energy, needs to be better educated about exergy if energy issues that exergy has a place and role to play in policy develop-
and problems are to be addressed appropriately, and that a basic ment regarding energy-related education and awareness.
level of exergy literacy is needed among engineers and scien- Exergy can play a key role in developing appropriate
tistsdparticularly those involved in decision making.
and beneficial energy-related policies relating to education
KEYWORDS and awareness. Two main areas where exergy can have an
Exergy; Education; Policy; Design; Government; Media; Public. impact on policies are discussed in this chapter: (1) public
education and awareness and (2) student education. The
former is more general, but is supported by the latter.
25.1 INTRODUCTION Regarding public education and awareness about exergy, it
It is important for the public to have a basic under- appears that the public is often confused when it discusses
standing, appreciation, and awareness of many technical energy, and needs to be better educated about exergy if
issues. Such understanding and awareness fosters healthy energy issues and problems are to be addressed appro-
public debate about problems and possible solutions, often priately. Regarding the education of students about exergy,
helps guide how public funds are spent, and facilitates it appears that the coverage of exergy in thermodynamics
policy development. education is often insufficient and inappropriate. Better
Energy issues are no exception. Yet, the publics coverage of exergy is needed to improve thermodynamics
understanding of energy issues is often confused. In large education and to make it more interesting to students, and
part, this situation is attributable to the public having next a basic level of exergy literacy is needed among engi-
to no understanding of exergy. In this chapter, we explain neers and scientistsdparticularly those involved in deci-
why such an understanding is necessary. sion making.

Exergy. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-097089-9.00025-5
2013 Ibrahim Dincer and Marc A. Rosen. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved 499
500 Exergy

25.2 EXERGY METHODS FOR ANALYSIS deposit) while the exergy content increases if its
AND DESIGN concentration is enriched. A poorer mineral deposit
contains less exergy than a concentrated one.
Some features of exergy that are particularly pertinent to Conversely, when a concentrated mineral is dispersed in
this chapter include: the environment, its exergy content decreases.
l When energy quality decreases, exergy is destroyed. As pointed out throughout this book, exergy analysis,
Exergy is the part of energy that is useful to society, a methodology for the analysis, design, and improvement
has economic value, and is thus worth managing of energy and other systems, is useful for improving the
carefully. efficiency of energy-resource use.
l A system has no exergy when it is in complete equi- Exergy has many other implications on, and links with,
librium with its environment. Then, no differences other disciplines, as discussed in detail in previous chapters.
appear between the system and the environment in A link exists between exergy and environmental impact and
temperature, pressure, or constituent concentrations. sustainability. Energy production, transformation, transport,
l The exergy of a system increases as the deviation of its and use all impact on earths environment. The exergy of
state from that of the environment increases. For a quantity of energy or a substance can be viewed as
instance, hot water has a higher exergy content in winter a measure of its usefulness, quality, or potential to cause
than on a hot summer day, while a block of ice contains change. Exergy appears to be an effective measure of the
little exergy in winter but a significant quantity in potential of a substance to impact the environment. This link
summer. between exergy and environmental impact is particularly
Two simple examples well illustrate the attributes of significant since energy and environment policies are likely
exergy: to play an increasingly prominent role in the future in a broad
range of local, regional, and global environmental concerns.
l Consider an adiabatic system containing fuel and air at The tie between exergy and the environment has implica-
ambient conditions. The fuel and air react to form tions regarding environmental impact and has been inves-
a mixture of hot combustion gases. During the tigated previously by several researchers, including the
combustion process, the energy in the system remains authors.
fixed because it is adiabatic. But the exergy content Exergy is a useful concept in economics. In macro-
declines as combustion proceeds due to the irrevers- economics, exergy offers a way to reduce resource deple-
ibilities associated with the conversion of the high- tion and environmental destruction by exergy taxes or
quality energy of fuel to the lower quality energy of rebates. In microeconomics, exergy has been combined
combustion gases. The different behaviors of energy and beneficially with cost-benefit analysis to improve designs.
exergy during this process are illustrated qualitatively in By minimizing life cycle cost, we find the best system
Figure 25.1. given prevailing economic conditions and, by minimizing
l A mineral deposit contrasts with the environment of exergy losses, we also minimize environmental effects.
the earth, and is thus a carrier of exergy. This contrast Finally, exergy has been proposed as an important
increases with the concentration of the mineral, as consideration in policy making related to energy. This
shown in Figure 25.2. When the mineral is mined, its chapter expands this area by focusing specifically on
exergy content is low or zero (depending on the education and awareness.
concentration of the mineral in the environmental

FIGURE 25.1 Qualitative comparison


of energy and exergy during combustion. Exergy Energy
Energy or exergy (relative

100
80
units)

60
40
20
0
Fuel and air before Fuel and hot gases after Hot gases after complete
combustion partial adiabatic adiabatic combustion
combustion
Chapter | 25 Exergy in Policy Development and Education 501

Exergy (relative units)

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1


Concentration of mineral (%)
FIGURE 25.2 Qualitative variation of the exergy of a mineral with concentration.

25.3 THE ROLE AND PLACE FOR EXERGY IN 25.3.2 Public Understanding and Awareness
ENERGY-RELATED EDUCATION AND of Exergy
AWARENESS POLICIES An understanding of exergy, similar to that which exists for
Before considering understanding and awareness of exergy energy, is almost entirely nonexistent in lay members of the
by the public, and its role and place in energy-related public. This lack of understanding exists despite the fact
education and awareness policies, it is informative to that exergy overcomes many of the deficiencies of energy
consider the publics understanding and awareness of the methods described previously.
more conventional quantity energy. Worse still, the public is often confused when it refers
to energy. To those who deal with exergy, it often seems
that members of the public actually mean exergy when
25.3.1 Public Understanding and Awareness they say energy. For example, two respected exergy
researchers, Wepfer and Gaggioli (1980), begin an article
of Energy
with Exergy . is synonymous with what the layman calls
The typical layperson hears of energy and energy issues energy. It is exergy, not energy, that is the resource of
daily, and is generally comfortable with receiving that value, and it is this commodity, that fuels processes, which
energy-related information and feels he or she follows it. the layman is willing to pay for.
He or she even understands it, or at least thinks he/she does. These points illustrate why it is essential that the public
This sense of comfort and understanding exists despite developdor be helped to developda basic understanding
all of the problems associated with energy. For instance, of exergy. The level of understanding needed by the public
consider the following: about exergy should at least be comparable to that for
energy.
l Efficiencies based on energy can often be non-mean-
To help illustrate these contentions, some examples of
ingful or even misleading, because energy efficiency is
the problems associated with a lack of knowledge of exergy
not a consistent measure of how nearly a process
by the public are outlined in the following:
approaches ideality. For instance, the energy efficiency
of electric space heating is high (nearly 100%) even l One example of the confusion exhibited by the public
though the process is far from ideal. The fact that the when speaking of energy is the well-used term energy
same space heat can be delivered by an electric heat conservation. When members of the public say energy
pump using much less electricity than the electric space conservation, they are usually referring to an objective
heater corroborates this observation. of efforts to solve energy problems. Yet the term energy
l Losses of energy can be large in quantity when they are, conservation is meaningless in that regard, in that it
in fact, not that significant thermodynamically due to simply states the First Law of Thermodynamics.
the low quality or usefulness of the energy that is lost. Exergy, however, is not conserved and it appears that
For example, the waste heat exiting a power plant via what the public is really interested in conserving is
cooling water has a lot of energy, but little exergy exergy, the potential to drive processes and systems that
(because its state is near to that of the environment). deliver services or products.
502 Exergy

l Another example of confusion in the public surrounds 25.3.3 Extending the Publics Need to
the drive for increased energy efficiency. Energy effi- Understand and Be Aware of Exergy to
ciencies do not necessarily provide a measure of how
Government and the Media
nearly a process approaches ideality, yet that is what
the public means by energy efficiency. Exergy effi- By extension of the previous arguments, government offi-
ciencies do provide measures of approach to ideality, cials require a rudimentary understanding of exergy to
and so it appears that the public means increased improvedor at least complementdtheir understanding of
exergy efficiency when discussing increased energy energy issues. This understanding can help guide the
efficiency. development of rational energy policies. Government,
l A third example of the problems that can develop being another type of reflection of the public, will be far
when the public does not have knowledge of exergy, less prone to use exergy methods, even when they can be
but retains only a confused understanding of energy, beneficial, if it feels that the public does not understand
relates to the energy crisis. For instance, during the exergy even in the simplest way and therefore will not
energy crisis of the 1970s, oil scarcities existed due to appreciate government efforts.
reductions in oil production. Most of the energy that The importance of such government involvement
was available to the public before the crisis was should not be understated and has been investigated by
available during it. For instance, huge amounts of researchers. For example, Wall (1993) alluded to the
solar energy continued to stream into the earth every importance of exergy in relation to democracy in an article
day. Waste thermal energy was continually emitted that dealt with the dilemmas of modern society. There have
from facilities and buildings. The commodity for also been some successes in incorporating exergy into
which there was a crisis, therefore, appeared to be government policies. For instance, Favrat et al. (2008)
exergy, not energy. That is, energy forms capable of reported on the introduction of an exergy indicator in
delivering a wide range of energy services (like oil), a local law on energy in Switzerlands Canton of Geneva.
which have high exergies, were in short supply. Of Through that law, which governs the attribution of building
course, there were also other issues related to the permits for new or retrofitted city areas, the application
energy crisis, particularly the shortage of reasonably procedure requires the calculation of an exergy indicator
inexpensive and widely available resources. But, the for large projects.
key point here is that the crisis was about exergy, not Similarly, members of the mediadincluding the press,
energy, yet the public referred to the situation as an television, and radiodneed to be informed, at least at
energy crisis. a basic level, about exergy and its roles. In a sense, the
media are a reflection of the public. If the media have an
l A fourth example of public confusion about energy
appreciation of exergy, they can help ensure that the public
relates to the oft-pronounced need for energy security. If
has an understanding about exergy. Educating via televi-
it were simply energy for which we desire a secure
sion, in particular, can be an especially powerful method for
supply, there would be no real problem. We have energy
increasing public awareness about exergy.
in abundance available in our environment and even
However, for the press and media to run exergy-related
when we use energy we still have equivalent quantities
articles, it requires that the public has a rudimentary
of energy left over because our use is really only energy
understanding of, and interest in, exergy matters. Other-
conversion or transformation. However, we are not
wise, the press and media tend to neglect exergy-related
concerned about ensuring secure supplies of energy;
topics for fear of boring or confusing the public. A first step
instead we are concerned about only those resources
to resolving the reluctance of the press to write about
that are useful to us, that can be used to provide a wide
exergy is education.
range of energy services, and that can satisfy all our
The next section of this article focuses on educating
energy-related needs and desires. That is, we are con-
students about exergy, which is one manner of directly and
cerned with having secure supplies of exergy, or what
indirectly educating the public, in the long run, about exergy.
might be called exergy security.
The lack of clarity regarding the points raised in these
four examples has been discussed in more detail previ- 25.4 THE ROLE AND PLACE FOR EXERGY IN
ously, focusing on scientists, engineers, and other tech-
EDUCATION POLICIES
nical readers. This discussion, however, is intended to
raise these points in a different context, and emphasize Thermodynamics education is often thought of as a mature
that this lack of clarity extends to the public, where the discipline, yet it remains the subject of continual debate.
problems caused are different, but perhaps are just as, or The emergence of exergy methods as important elements
more, important. and tools of thermodynamics has provided additional
Chapter | 25 Exergy in Policy Development and Education 503

subject matter for dialog, especially regarding the role and general, room exists for improvement in the area of exergy
place for exergy in curricula. coverage in thermodynamics education, and efforts should
be made to achieve these improvements. Three points
related to improving thermodynamics education through
25.4.1 Education about Exergy better coverage of exergy are addressed in the following
The impact of exergy on the teaching of thermodynamics three subsections.
has been and continues to be significant. Developments in
this area abound. For instance, Bejan (2001) noted in an
editorial in the inaugural issue of Exergy, An International 25.4.2 The Need for Exergy Literacy in
Journal, As the new century begins, we are witnessing Scientists and Engineers
revolutionary changes in the way thermodynamics is
We need to ensure that our education systems provide all
taught. Further on, he observed that the methods of
students who study thermodynamics with a good grounding
exergy analysis . are the most visible and established
in exergy. For exergy methods to become more widely used
forms of this change.
and beneficially exploited, those who study and work in
One point of contention is whether present coverage of
technical fieldsdparticularly where thermodynamics is
exergy in thermodynamics education is sufficient and
applieddshould have a basic understanding of exergy. In
appropriate. Views on this issue are often not in agreement.
addition, technical managers and decision makers require
Exergy, where it forms part of the curriculum, is nor-
at least an appreciation of what exergy is and how it is used,
mally taught at the college and university levels. However,
if they are to make proper decisions on matters where
many feel that it should be covered in primary and/or
exergy is, or should be, considered.
secondary education levels. That point is also disputed.
Some may suggest that we do not, for practical purposes,
Most of the remainder of this section focuses on college and
need such an understanding of exergy among technical
university levels, since exergy is normally taught at the
personnel. Some examples help refute such suggestions:
post-secondary level.
In some ways and at some schools, present coverage of l Research proposals have at times not been funded, in
exergy is sufficient. Some evidence to support this claim large part because exergy methods formed part of the
includes the following: approach. On reading the comments of reviewers of
such proposals, it is sometimes evident that the
l Several articles have appeared in the engineering and
reviewers have read energy in place of exergy
education literature on teaching exergy analysis. For
throughout the proposalsdrendering them utterly
instance, Cengel (1996) proposed a physical or
meaningless. This result can occur despite the fact that
intuitive approach . as an alternative to the current
great pains are often taken within proposals to empha-
formula based approach to learning thermodynamics
size the need to use exergy methods. What perhaps
and incorporated exergy into the approach. Dunbar and
remains most disconcerting is that, in many of these
Lior (1992) recommended an exergy-based approach to
instances, the reviewers have technical backgrounds.
teaching energy systems. They noted that the approach
l Government officials or company managers have
highlights important conclusions from exergy analysis,
admitted to exergy researchers and practitioners that, in
not obtainable from the conventional energy analysis.
many instances, they chose not to use exergy on
In addition, they felt that the approach evoked the
a project or activity, not because an exergy approach was
intellectual curiosity of students and increased their
unsuitable, but because they did not understand it or had
interest in the course.
never heard of it. This situation is problematic because
l Most texts on thermodynamics have, over the last few
decision making, when it is based on avoiding topics
decades, incorporated sections or chapters on exergy
about which one is ignorant, cannot be productive.
methods. Even in 1988, while commenting on the
increased attention being paid to exergy analysis, Bejan We consequently feel in general that a strong need exists
(1988) pointed out that, every new undergraduate to improve the exergy literacy of engineers and scientists.
engineering thermodynamics textbook has at least one
chapter on the subject.
l Several excellent texts devoted to exergy analysis have 25.4.3 Understanding the Second Law
been published, including particularly useful ones, such through Exergy
as by Kotas (1995), Edgerton (1992), and Szargut et al.
The Second Law of Thermodynamics (SLT) often makes
(1988).
students of thermodynamics fearful. Introducing the concept
Such materials have made it easier to expand the of entropy usually only increases their trepidation. Even
coverage of exergy in thermodynamics courses. Yet, in students who pass courses on thermodynamics and ultimately
504 Exergy

graduate often retain fears of the SLT and entropy and feel graduate level. In the latter case, the rationale often
they do not really understand these topics. Ahrendts (1980), provided is that students need a firm grounding in tradi-
for example, begins one of his articles on exergy methods with tional thermodynamics before they deal with exergy. Those
Thermodynamics is not a very popular science, because the who support including exergy as a part of the undergraduate
concepts in thermodynamics do not conform to the unso- curriculum, on the other hand, claim this approach is
phisticated human experience. Focusing on the SLT he necessary because exergy forms a critical and important
continues Traditional formulations of the Second Law part of basic thermodynamics. Further support for this
prevent a simple understanding of energy conversions, argument is added by earlier statements in this article about
because the application of the entropy concept to those exergy providing a preferable approach to dealing with and
processes is often looked upon as a miracle. teaching the SLT.
Others also have agreed with these concerns and devel- Although there is likely some merit in each of the
oped different approaches to teaching the SLT. One example rationales for different placements of exergy in curricula,
is a thermodynamics text by Dixon (1975), the preface of this author nevertheless believes that some coverage of
which states entropy is [not] the most significant or useful exergy should be required in all undergraduate courses in
aspect of the Second Law and the Second Law has to do engineering thermodynamics. Beyond such a core of
with the concept of degradation of energy; that is, with loss exergy material, however, there are multiple ways in which
of useful work potential. Dixon introduces the SLT through additional exergy material can be incorporated into engi-
the concept of degradation of energy, claiming degradation neering curricula at undergraduate or graduate levels.
. because it is a work term, is an easily grasped concept. Exergy methods can also be incorporated into courses
By focusing on degradation of energy rather than the abstract that apply to thermodynamics. In Thermal Design and
property entropy, Dixon feels his book results in a clearer Optimization, for instance, Bejan et al. (1996) feature
physical meaning for entropy. a substantial amount of material on exergy and related
This approach, although instructive for some, is still methods. They explain in the preface that they include
somewhat abstract and vague. The approach comes close to exergy in the text because an increasing number of engi-
teaching the SLT through exergy, and would likely be neers and engineering managers worldwide agree that it has
clearer if it did so. Exergy provides a perspective of the SLT considerable merit and are advocating its use. They state
and entropy that is much more intuitively understandable to further that their aim in featuring exergy and related
students. The definition of exergy, which states that exergy methods is to contribute to the education of the next
is the maximum work that can be obtained from a system or generation of thermal system designers and to the back-
flow within a reference environment, is usually much more ground of currently active designers who feel the need for
straightforward than the definition of entropy. Also, char- more effective design methods. These authors clearly
acteristics of exergydsuch as it being a nonconserved regard exergy as a critical component in thermal design
quantitydare normally easier for students to grasp than the education, whose importance will only increase in the
concepts surrounding entropy and its characteristics. future.
Thus, we feel that exergy should generally form a central Much room for debate exists about the place for exergy
component of thermodynamics courses. More specifically, in a curriculum. Perhaps no single answer exists, and each
exergy should play a significant role in dealing with and approach will retain its proponents. Some engineering
teaching the SLT. Such an approach would likely make the thermodynamics curricula, to their detriment, do not cover
SLT more understandable and practical and less fear exergy at all, but these are likely in the minority. The range
inspiring. Some readers will point out correctly that there of views on how exergy can and should be incorporated into
exist some additional complexities when dealing with exergy a thermodynamics curriculum is sufficiently diverse that
rather than entropy (e.g., a reference environment must be a consensus on the best approach is almost certainly not
introduced and defined). Nevertheless, we believe that the possible in the near term. It is even questionable whether
overall benefits of approaching the SLT through exergy a consensus can be reached in the long term, after exergy
outweigh the difficulties. methods mature. Two points help illustrate this view:

l A panel session on The Second Law in Engineering


25.4.4 Exergys Place in a Curriculum Education was held within the Symposium on Thermo-
A challenging issue is where exergy should be covered in dynamics and the Design, Analysis, and Improvement
a curriculum. In engineering programs, for example, exergy of Energy Systems, at the 1996 International Mechanical
is sometimes covered lightly in thermodynamics courses at Engineering Congress and Exposition of the American
the undergraduate level. Sometimes exergy is covered Society of Mechanical Engineers (El-Sayed et al.,
separately, as either a core or an elective undergraduate 1997). Among the topics covered were whether or not
course, while in some schools exergy is only covered at the undergraduate engineers need to be educated in the SLT
Chapter | 25 Exergy in Policy Development and Education 505

and how much depth is required in this area. The panelists technical persons such as engineers and scientists are shown
included representatives of academia and industry, as to be different from those that are appropriate for nontech-
well as respected thermodynamicists and exergy propo- nical persons such as members of the public, government, or
nents. Although several opinions were expressed on the media. But, in a general sense, the factors involved in raising
need to include exergy methods in the teaching of the awareness and understanding are similar conceptually, and
SLT, the views expressed varied greatlydemphasizing differ mainly in depth and rigor of treatment.
the difficulties in reaching a consensus on the best The arguments presented in this chapter demonstrate
approach for incorporating exergy into a thermody- that the public is often confused when discussing energy
namics curriculum. and a need exists to improve public understanding and
l Consideration of the nomenclature and terminology of awareness of exergy. Such understanding and awareness is
exergy analysis reveals that a diversity of names and essential if we are to better address the energy issues and
symbols presently exist for the same quantities in problems of today and tomorrow. Thus, exergy can play
exergy analysis. This situation persists despite efforts to a key role in developing appropriate and beneficial energy-
reach a common nomenclature and terminology. This related policies, but exploiting the potential of exergy
weakness demonstrates how difficult it is to reach requires appropriate support for public education and
a consensus just on the relatively narrow topic of awareness about exergy.
nomenclature and terminology, not to mention reaching In support of the need for public understanding and
a consensus on the broader topic of incorporating awareness of exergy, it should take on a prominent place in
exergy into a thermodynamics curriculum. thermodynamics courses. Beyond elucidating the concepts
of the SLT and entropy, such an approach can help ensure
a rudimentary understanding of exergy in all technical
personnel. An approach based on exergy could make the
25.5 CLOSING REMARKS SLT more interesting, appealing, and practical, as well as
The key elements of this chapter are awareness, under- less daunting and confusing. Then, it may be easier to
standing, and education as they relate to exergy and its role in improve general understanding of exergy in the scientific
policy making. The relation between these key elements is and engineering communities, as well as the general public,
illustrated in Figure 25.3. There, it is shown that an under- by ensuring that a basic level of exergy literacy exists
standing and awareness of exergy requires, for all people, among engineers and scientistsdparticularly those involved
education. The types of education that are appropriate for in decision making. Education policies that support

Awareness and
understanding of
exergy

Education

Technical Non-technical

Other
Scientists Engineers technical Public Government Media
workers

FIGURE 25.3 Illustration of the importance of education in building awareness and understanding of exergy among different categories of people.
506 Exergy

inclusion of exergy in relevant curricula, at all appropriate 25.3 Do you favor changing the way thermodynamics is
education levels, should be considered. taught by adopting an exergy-based approach? Why?
25.4 Explain how a better understanding of exergy by
engineering students can help improve public
PROBLEMS awareness of exergy.
25.5 Explain how exergy is a useful tool in policy making
25.1 Conduct research to determine if thermodynamics related to energy. Provide examples.
textbooks written several decades ago cover exergy 25.6 Is it realistic to expect that the level of understanding
and to what extent. of the public about exergy should be comparable to
25.2 Almost all present undergraduate thermodynamics that for energy? Explain.
textbooks have at least one chapter devoted to exergy. 25.7 Explain how a better understanding and appreciation
If you were the instructor of a single thermodynamics of exergy by the public and by policy makers can help
course and you could only cover some of the chap- foster more efficient use of energy sources and
ters, would you cover exergy? Provide reasons for minimize their effects on environment.
your answer.

You might also like