You are on page 1of 149

1

Lean Manufacturing
(Mapua)

Version 2016

Presented by: Kaizen Management Systems, Inc.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN
Total System Approach to Improvement

Total System Approach to Improvement


Total System Approach to Improvement

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAI = Change

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


ZEN = Good (For the Better)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN = Continual Improvement

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAI = Change

ZEN = Good (For the Better)

KAIZEN = Continual Improvement

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Products

Processes

People

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


What is the Goal of a Company?
According to Eliyahu Goldratt, the goal of
a company is to make as much money
(profit) as much as it can in the present
and in the future. And this can be best
accomplished by increasing the T or
Throughput

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Throughput (T)*
defined as the rate at which the system generates money
(profit) though sales.
Operationally, maximizing throughput means ensuring the
market, not the company, is the constraint of additional
sales.
Technically,
Throughput Value = Selling Price Unit Variable Cost

*All the money generated by the system.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN Purpose
The underlying premise for an
organization is to enable work to
occur that satisfies the customer.

Kaizen is the process that enables all


aspects of an organization to
continually improve work to satisfy
the customer.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


11

Principles of Kaizen

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN
Super-Ordinate Principles
Process and results
vs. Results only
Total systems focus
vs. Functional focus
Non-blaming/Non-judgmental
vs. Critical and blaming

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN
Mental Framework I

Process & Results


Improvements in results are carried out in
the process.

If your results are bad what do you do?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Process-Oriented Thinking

Self-Discipline
Time Management
Skill Management
Participation and
involvement
Morale
Communication Process-oriented is people-oriented.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


15

Results-Oriented Thinking

I dont care
how you get it
done, just
give me the
results!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


16

Process P & Results R


Ignoring the process reduces chances
for improved results
Ignoring results risks unclear long-term
strategy and missing new ideas or
innovations
JIT is flow process improvement
TPM is facilities process improvement
TQC is support system process improvement

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


17

Process Thinking
New Old (Results Only)
Understanding how things work Demanding outcomes without
Control of process with people concern for how
Controls as tools for Control of people for outcomes
improvement Controls as means of inspection
Real time awareness of After the fact, tangible results
operation awareness
Based more on sensing, Based on numbers,
listening, looking goals,abstractions

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN
Mental Framework III

Total Systems Focus


Real improvements must find their way to the
bottom lines (profit & customer satisfaction)

Will the total system be better off as a result of efforts?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


19

Total Systems Focus


Traditionally functionally focused
Stresses integration of total system
Appreciates all critical factors

Vs.

Turbulent Flow Smooth Flow

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


20

Work System Model


6. Culture
(Informal way we operate)
3. Work Station 2. Core Process

4. Supply Base 1. Customer

Q Q
C C
D D
Customer Requirements
Expectations
Man
Machine

Material Methods
5. Support
Systems

Measurement Mother Nature

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


21

System
Interdependencies
Added Value

Supplier Customer
interior or Work interior or
exterior station exterior

Flow
What happens to the flow when a breakdown in quality occurs?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Non-System View
Confusion of direction
Misalignment of
resources
Excess of conflict
De-energizing of people
Passing problems around

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


KAIZEN
Mental Framework II

Non-blaming/Non-judgmental
Bring out the real issues and address them
instead of blaming one another

Do you eliminate fear and encourage problem solving?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


YES DOES THE DUMB NO
THING WORK?

DONT DID YOU


MESS YES FOOL NO
WITH IT WITH IT?

DOES YOU
NO
ANYONE DUMB
KNOW JERK
ARE YOU
YES YES
IN BIG
HIDE IT TROUBLE?
YOU POOR
NO
SLOB!

THROW IT
NO CAN YOU BLAME IN THE CAN
SOMEONE ELSE?
YES

NO PROBLEM
KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.
25

Traditional
Inspector View
After-the-fact critical judgment
Who is wrong overrides
What is wrong
Drives people into defensive
posture
Issues submerged for years
Creates crisis orientation

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


26

Problem in Japanese is Kiki


KI-KI
Kiken (Threat)

Kikay (Opportunity)

Problems are opportunities in disguise!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Welcoming Problems
Problems are a mountain of
treasures
Lower the water level
Abnormality management
Breakdown departmental barriers
Organize CFT

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


28

People & Problems

People are not the problem!


Blaming people does not solve your
problem
The answer is to make people
problem-solvers!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


29

Where to look for


Opportunities?

Source Countermeasures Location


My workplace
I can take
Myself
initiative Others
workplace

My workplace
I cannot take
The Other Guy
initiative Others
workplace

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


30

KAIZEN Concepts

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


31

KAIZEN Concepts
SDCA - PDCA Speak with data
Next process is Variability control
the customer and recurrence
Quality first prevention (Ask
Upstream Why 5 times)
management Market - in

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


32

S D C A CYCLE

Standardize
Act
the Process
A S

C D
Check Do

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


33

A P
C D

A S
A P
C D
C D

A S
C D

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


34

Process Standards
Best, easiest, cheapest, fastest, safest way
you know today; should only have one
standard at a time
Documentation of know-how
Objective, simple, conspicuous
Consistent with quality, cost, and delivery
requirements
Show relationship between cause & effect

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


35

Process Standard Benefits


Focuses management
(maintenance & improvement)
Basis for training
Basis for audit and diagnosis
Controls variability

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


36

PDCA Cycle
Act Plan
A P

C D

Check Do

The Improvement Cycle

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


37

PLAN
Policy & Goals
Act Working Plan

Checkpoints
What
Who
When
Where
Why Check Do
How

5 Ws & 1 H:

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


38

The Working Plan


Target:
No. Action Steps Resp Gantt (Weeks) Output Res. Rqmt Remarks

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


The Working Plan
Target: New end to end production standards and Yield >70% by March 20xx
No. Activity Resp. Time Frame w1 w2 w3 w4 w5 w6 w7 w8 w9 w10 OUTPUT/DELIVERABLES
1 Kick-Off JCN Jan. 12 Start the Project

2 Process Review & Experiment on Quick Feedback System DBA Jan. 14-17 Establish the variables of Quick Feedback System

RDC/DB
3 Det. new Standards that support the Quick Feedback Sys Jan 18-28 Spinning to GM Process Standards for QFS
A

4 Design & Install Material Prep Process RRA Material Preparation Process Installed

5 Run New Feedback System ATC Kaizen of Measurement


Jan 29-Feb 9
6 Adjust End to End Process Standards DBA Straighten the shape of the logger profile

7 Eval. of Adjusted Machine Settings Vis-a-vis Logger Data RDC Feb 10-23 New standards supporting straight logger profile

8 Implementation of Refined Standards (Spinning to GM) DBA Feb 24 - Mar 5 > 70% Yield at straight logger profile

9 Maintenance of Hitting Ratio & Problem Solving RDC Problems with new settings & stds Identified and Solved

10 Confirmation of All Machine Settings & New Process Stds DBA Mar 6-Mar 28 Practice of New Standards by Operators Assured

11 Closure & End of Intervention JCN 31-Mar Project Ends


Meetings: Every Wednesday 1:30 PM to 5:00 PM

Lege
nd:
1 Visit 2 consultants
1 Visit 1 consultant

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


40

Reflection
Standardization
Act Plan
Recurrence Prevention
Find Root Causes
Check Do Training
First Aid

Confirm Results Execution

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


41

I
m
Innovation + KAIZEN
p
+ Maintenance
r
o
v
e
m
e
n
t Innovation Oriented

Time
What would JIT-style KAIZEN efforts look like without examining
the work process and standardizing improvements?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


42

The Next Process is the


Customer
Types
Ultimate Customer
Immediate or Intermediate customer

Each process has its own supplier & customer. JIT


links customers and suppliers.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


43

Isolated Islands (Separate Work Stations)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


44

Connect, integrate with the next processes


and with the total system

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


45

Never Pass Problems on to the


Next Process
(Dont get it, Dont make it, Dont send it.)

Two Types of Quality Assurance


Inspection by third party
Do your own inspection
- QA process sheet
- Design review
- Information accuracy review
- Time line review

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


46

What is your organizations


definition of quality?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Customer Requirement: 200 units of product X @P100 each at 5:00 PM on
Wednesday next week

Supplier Order

A 100

B 100

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Come Wednesday both suppliers delivered almost at the same time beating the
5:00 oclock deadline

Supplier Order Delivery

A 100 ok

B 100 ok

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Now Test Your Definitions
Supplier Order Delivery Inside Info

A 100 ok 100

B 100 ok 120*
*10% defectives rate
+10% JIC

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


Who is a more profitable supplier?
Supplier Order Delivery Inside Info Profitable

A 100 ok 100

B 100 ok 120* X
*10% defectives rate
+10% JIC

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


51

Definitions of Quality

Quality R - What you can see


& measure

Quality P - What you can


improve by
eliminating waste
& variability
KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.
52

Quality First
Q C

C D Q D

KAIZEN Paradigm: Old Paradigm:


Process Improvement Cost Reduction

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


53

Definitions of Quality

Quality R - What you can see


& measure

Quality P - What you can


improve by
eliminating waste
& variability
KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.
54

Why Do We Say
Quality First?
Hint:
Why are most cost and delivery
problems actually quality problems?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


55

Quality Not First (1)

If we are not the lowest cost


provider, we will not survive.
Result: Cost cutting, compromising quality,
customer is not satisfied.

Quality option: Reduce waste activity and cost in the process.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


56

Quality Not First (2)


Meet the schedule first, even if
quality is not quite right

Result: Customer receives defective product on time.

Quality option: Improve process to reduce total cycle time

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


57

Quality Not First (3)


Lets postpone preventive maintenance
for one month, we need run time.

Result: Equipment breaks down unexpectedly,


or product too variable.

Quality option: Reduce PM process time

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


58

Upstream Management
Q Switch

Good to Customer
Find the
1. Bad
Problems
Work Flow Stream
Rework/Reject

Q Switch

2. to Customer
Solve the
Problems
Rework/Reject Rework/Reject

Q Switch
Avoid /
3. Design /
Development to Customer Prevent the
Problems

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


59

Upstream Management & Cost


Implications
COST
1

Planning Design Production Sales

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


60

What Do You Recommend?


# Defects

A B C D E
Operator

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


61

Decision Making -Traditional


Sixth Sense
Past Experiences
Gut Feeling

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


62

Speak With Data


Reduce issues to data (Check Gemba/Gembutsu)
Solve problems with data (Get & Analyze Data)
Make decisions with data (Take actions Based on
Data)
When you see data, doubt it (Ishikawa)
Data is not just numbers (It is what you see on the
shop floor)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


63

Variability Control & Recurrence


Prevention
Why does that happen?
Why does that happen?
Why does that happen?
Why does that happen?
Why does that happen?
The Five Whys

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


64

Market-In vs. Product Out


Product Out
I know what my customer wants
We are the experts in this industry
Our customers do not know any better
We will produce to schedules
convenient to us, let our customers wait
This is what we make, this is our price,
take it or leave it

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


65

Market-In vs. Product Out


Market-In
Factually understanding customer needs/wants
Translating understanding into activities to achieve
customer needs in Quality
Cost
Delivery
Detecting trends ahead of competition
Customer-driven scheduling (JIT)
By far superior
By far the best

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


66

Lean Manufacturing

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


67

Lean Manufacturing is a Total


Systems Approach in Production that
allows you to:

Continuously improve your production


system
Satisfy the customers QCD
Be profitable

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


68

Lean Manufacturing does this


through:
Continuous application of the Market-in
concept
Continuous identification and solution
of problems
Continuous elimination of non-value
adding activities and processes
Continuous waste elimination in
production and support processes

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


69

Lean Manufacturing is a
Profitable Business
Focus your efforts on customer requirements & avoid the
temptation of doing other things
Your processes must be able to create the values required
by the customers
Your organization structure must be supportive
Your people (and culture) must be supportive
Your policies and standards must be supportive
Your equipment and facilities must be supportive
Your factory layout must support a smooth and wasteless
production

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


70

Indicators of a Successful
Lean Manufacturing
Market $hare
Good quality product
Profit$
Fast cycle time Satisfied Customers
Low product cost
Just-In-Time Delivery Clean and orderly factory
Minimal inventory
Disciplined People Smooth & uniform product flow

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


71

TAKT Time
German word which means beat
Simply means rate of customer demand
(time/unit product)
It is an expression of customers demand
It is the customers capacity to absorb
products from its suppliers
It is not internal to the producers plant
It is the Manufacturing Systems External
Constraint

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


72

Formula for TAKT Time Calculation

Based on give us today our daily bread which simply


means satisfying our customers daily:
TAKT Time = Total working time per day *
Total units ordered for the day
Note: TAKT Time is expressed in seconds per unit

*The number of seconds per day scheduled for the product . Time spent on Machine Set-up,
Changeover, Unplanned Maintenance are not deductible.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


73

Goal of the Manufacturing System...

Maximize Profit

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


74

By delivering all the...

Quantity
that the consumers can absorb. But ...

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


75

Strategy of the Manufacturing System...

...you want to do it in such a way that the consumers


are satisfied, i.e. they want to do business with
nobody else but you because your...

price is lowest,
quality is best, and
delivery is timely!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


76

How to keep your price lowest, quality


best, and delivery timely?

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


77

Make only what you will deliver; buy only what


you will make; do only what is necessary; and
deliver on time

Thus: Do not make a work-in-process that you cannot deliver. Make a


complete product and deliver it in no time at all!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


78

Objective of Production

Produce the
required product
in the required quantity
at the required production rate

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


79

P Q C D S

Delivery Safety
Cost
Quality
Productivity

Other references - PQCDSME

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


80

Cycle Time

The amount of time to make one unit

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


81

Factors of Production Process


Amount Customer
Activity IE Symbol
Time willing to pay?
Operation Second Yes
P (Processing/Work)
R
O
D Transportation Minute No
U
C
T Inspection Second/Min No
I
O
N Storage Hour/Day/ No
(Waiting/Stop) Month

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


82

The 3 Mu
Muda
(Waste)

Mura
(Unevenness)

Muri
(Strain)

Mus are indicators of system inefficiency!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


83
Start
Example of a Simple Process Flow Map
Batching
Cutting Forklift Wait
100 units t=
t= t = 30 sec. t = 1 hr
t=

Batching
Drill Cart Wait
t= 24 units
t= t= t = 70 sec. t = 1 hr

Batching
Milling 12 units Manual
t= Assy
t= t= t = 20 sec. t=

t= Packing End-to-End Process Time = _____


t= Total Cycle Time = _____
End

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


84
Example of a Simple Process Flow Map Over Factory Layout
Drill
Cutting Packing

Foot Prints of Machines

Milling

Assy

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


85

Types of Muda
Muda of Over-production
Muda of Inventory
Muda of Transportation
Muda of Motion
Muda of Waiting
Muda of Overprocessing
Muda of Producing failures

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


86

When the Inventory is Full...


Hidden Obstacles
& Defects

Water level

Amount of
INVENTORY Machine Breakdown

Poor scheduling
High Defect Rate
Long changeover
Delay in delivery Abnormal operation

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


87

False Efficiency & Real Efficiency


200 units by 10 persons We need 250 units by 10 persons = Muda of 50 units
250 units by 10 persons 200 units 200 units by 8 persons = KAIZEN

False Efficiency
Real Efficiency

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


88

Individual Efficiency & Overall Productivity

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


89

Exploitation of Labor vs. Better Utilization of


Labor
Waste
Exploitation Waste
&
Work &
Varia- Work Varia-
bility
bility
Work Work

Waste
&
Work Varia- Work
bility

Waste &
Better Utilization Variability
Work
Work
Step 1: Identify muda
Waste & Waste &
Step 2: Eliminate muda
Variability Variability
Step 3: Add value

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


90

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time Chart

45
40
S 35
E 30
Takt Time
C 25
O 20
N 15
D 10
S 5
0

A B C D E F Cycle Time
OPERATOR OR PROCESSES
If there are 3 stations/machines working in parallel and making the same product, those three
machines will share the demand. E.g. if TAKT time = 30 sec. each machine can operate at a cycle
time of 90 sec. and still be able to deliver the customer requirement.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


91

Component Tasks Analysis


Time Observation Form
Observation Date: Name of Operator: Product name & No.
Process Name: Yrs. Operator worked process Name of Observer
Remarks on Waste
Component Tasks: Results of Time Observation Results of Calculation Abnormal Values &
Variability*
No. From To 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Min Ave. Max. Range
0 46 31 16 6 47 33 20 8 53
1 Stand up from chair
- 7 8 7 9 6 7 7 8 8
6 7.4 9 3
10 57 41 27 16 59 44 31 18 4
2 Walk up blackboard
10 11 10 11 10 12 11 11 10 11
10 10.7 12 2
13 59 44 30 18 2 46 34 20 7
3 Pick up chalk 2 2.7 3 1
03 2 3 3 2 3 2 3 2 3
23 8 54 41 27 M 56 44 29 18
4 Write Letters 10 9 10 11 9 M 10 10 9 11
9 9.9 11 2
26 11 58 44 30 M 60 47 32 22
5 Put down chalk
03 3 4 3 3 M 4 3 3 4
3 3.3 5 2
36 20 7 54 39 23 10 57 43 31
6 Walk back to chair 10 9 9 10 9 9 10 10 11 9 9 9.6 11 2
39 23 9 57 41 26 13 60 45 33
7 Sit down in chair 03 3 2 3 2 3 3 3 2 2 2 2.6 3 1
8
9
10
Total 45 46 48 44 M 47 47 45 48 41 44.2 54 13
* Circle abnormal values arising in time observation and clearly explain reasons for these

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


92

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time


Step 1: Determine Takt Time and operator cycle times
Step 2: Calculate target number of operators
45
40
S 35 Takt Time = 30 seconds
E 30
C 25
O 20
N 15 Cycle Time (Time
D 10 for operators to do
S 5 their job)
0

A B C D E F
PROCESS/OPERATOR Total Process Time = 150 Seconds
Takt Time = 30 Seconds
150/30 = 5 people
Target = 5 people

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


93

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time


Step 3: Identify waste (muda) & strain
45
40
S 35 Takt Time = 30 seconds
E 30
C 25
O 20
N 15 Waste (muda)
D 10
S 5
0

A B C D E F
PROCESS/OPERATOR
= Muda

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


94

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time


Step 4: Eliminate waste (muda) & strain
45
40
S 35 Takt Time = 30 seconds
E 30
C 25
O 20
N 15
D 10
S 5
0

A B C D E F
PROCESS/OPERATOR

Total Process Time = 87 seconds

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


95

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time


Step 5: Redistribute workload and eliminate strain
45
40
S 35 Takt Time = 30 seconds
E 30
C 25
O 20
N 15
D 10
S 5
0

A B C D E F
PROCESS/OPERATOR

Total Process Time = 87 seconds

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


96

Takt Time vs. Cycle Time


Step 5: Redistribute workload ... continued
45
40
S 35 Takt Time = 30 seconds
E 30
C 25
O 20
N 15
D 10
S 5
0

A B C D E F
PROCESS/OPERATOR

Total Process Time = 87 seconds

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


97

Conventional IE Type KAIZEN JIT Type KAIZEN


Current status analysis Search for ideal system
(Inductive type) (Deductive type)

Analyze the current practice for Draw an ideal image of a JIT


KAIZEN, finding any muda or production and make the current
problem. practice closer to the ideal.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


98

Example of Kanban
CURRENT
Process Prior Process PROCESS

Plating Plating
(PT-47) (PA-13)

Work 51341-16260-00
Name Tail Lamp Rim

No. Cards
Management No. L-2 Contained 20 Issued 6/10

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


99

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


100

Traditional JIT
Lean System GM TOYOTA
Results Framingham
Assembly
Takaoka
Assembly
Plant (1986) Plant (1986)

Gross assembly hours per car 40.7 18.0


Adjusted assembly hours per car 31.0 16.0
Assembly defects per 100 cars 130 45
Assembly space per car 8.1 4.8
Inventories of parts (average) 2 weeks 2 hours

Source: The Machine That Changed The World, Jas Womack, Daniel Jones, Daniel Ross

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


101
Optional

Autonomation

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


102

Autonomation
Automatic machines need to be attended by humans
because they can malfunction and make a lot of rejects.
If a human guard must attend the machine to ensure its
operation, why was the machine made automatic in the
first place?
Autonomation is an effort to equip the machine with
gadgets that allows itself to recognize abnormal situations
and automatically stop operation.
Autonomation is essential in a JIT production system.

Note: The principle behind autonomation (or jidohka) is to stop the


operation as soon a defect or malfunction occurs.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


103

10 Steps of Autonomation
1. The operation itself - The machining or process can be
done without human attendance
2. Holding - Install a jig that holds a work piece or
introduce automatic clamping
3. Forwarding - Give the machine an automatic forwarding
or feeding function
4. Stopping - The machine automatically stops if work is
finished or a malfunction occurs
5. Returning - The tool or table returns automatically to
starting position on completion of the work

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


104

10 Steps of Autonomation (2)


6. Take out - The work piece will be automatically taken out
of the machine on completion of the work
7. Quality confirmation - The quality of the process (or the
work piece) is automatically checked
8. Mounting - The work piece will be mounted automatically
9. Start-up - The machine starts automatically as soon as
the machine is set-up
10. Forwarding to the next process - the finished work piece
is automatically forwarded to the next process.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


105

Changeover and Setup


Reduction

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


106

Changeover and Setup


A multiple variety of small lot production has weak
points:
The first stages of production usually have
higher defects rates
The rate of machine efficiency or operation goes
down with many changes
This leads to the need to accomplish these
changeovers in less than 10 minutes or even the
One Touch

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


107

Quick Changeover Process


is Characterized in Stages
1. Intermingled Stage
2. Separated Stage
3. Converted Stage
4. Advanced Stage

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


108

Definitions

Work done External to the changeover are activities


that can be carried out even while the machine is
running or On Stream

Work done Internal to the changeover are activities


that can only be carried out while the machine
have already been shut down or Off Stream

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


109

Stage #1 - Intermingled Stage


Internal and External work is done together with no clear cut
separation between the two types of operations
Examples:
Mold is not maintained adequately
There are not enough bolts
Bolts do not fit in holes
The fixtures do not fit
The mold is found after the machine has been shut down
The tool setter is missing a tool

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


110

Stage #2 - Separated Stage


There is a clear distinction between Internal and External work; so
External work is carried on while the machine is running
Examples:
All necessary preparations are completed while the machine is in
motion
A checklist is available for carrying out External work
Maintenance, inspection of mold or cutting tools are thoroughly
carried out
Jigs and fixtures are checked to see if they work properly
Team work exists to make sure the work gets done properly

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


111

Stage #3 - Converted Stage


In this stage Internal and External processes are
thoroughly separated, but management is trying to
transfer a portion of the Internal work to External
Examples:
Standardize the die or tool height
Remove adjustment work from the machine stroke
Uniform bolt heads are adapted
Wrenches are standardized
Intermediate jigs are standardized

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


112

Stage #4 - Advanced Stage


In this stage both Internal and External work has been improved
upon and yet even more work is being carried out to further
shorten the setup time through more innovative means.
Examples:
Go from bolts to hydraulic fasteners
The height and width of jigs are standardized
Fastening and adjustment work are simplified and, if possible,
eliminated
The handling of molds, tools, and fixtures are standardized
The entire work setup is cassettized

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


113

Quick Changeover Improvement Flow


Chart
External Setup
Change Implement Jigs
from
Internal to Eliminate Adjustment
Separate
out External
Clearly Standardization

Improve Parallel Operations


Internal
Internal Setup Setup Mechanical
Improvements

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


114

Changeover Reduction
Technique

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


115

Setup Reduction Time Observation Form


No. Steps of setup process Amount Internal/ Preparation Replacing Positioning Adjusting Remarks
of time External & Centering of trial (Muda or problems)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


116

XYZ Machine Changeover


Team
Rico Edward
Julius Larry
Jose Obet
Bruja Frenchen

Team Leader - Bruno

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


117

Target Sheet
Wt. # Current Target Accomplished Completion
Date

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


118

5S Activity
# Red Tape Floor space freed-up
# White Tags # Removed
# Yellow Tags # Removed
# Standards made-up

General comments:

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


119

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


120

Layout of Area

Before After

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


121

Dance Chart(s)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


122

Changeover Reduction Time Observation Form

No. Changeover Step Amount Internal/ Preparation Replacing Positioning Adjusting Remarks
of time External & Centering of trial (Muda or problems)

Tool box unorganized & should


1. Getting tool box 532 int be done extremely

2. Bring die to work 1015 int Fork lift driver should pre
stage externally

Gauges are too far from


22. Check with plug gauge at QC 524 int workstation

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


123

KAIZEN Proposals
No. Problem & Muda Solution Who When Progress Impact
1 Batch Production Layout change for one piece flow VMI Done Much better flow

Precision study of new


2 Imbalance of Workload VMI 15-Jul
standard work
Welding machines too
3 Layout change SRL 15-Jul
far from process
Operator B motion not
4 Change layout & work procedure VMI Done
smooth Still needs work
Too much adjustment
5 Develop Standard Worksheet SRL 10-Jul
in process #1
Air wrench & torque Change to impact wrench
6 NMM 01-Aug
wrench used (testing on line 4)
Operator B has too
7 Train operator B JRL 01-Sept
much variability

8 Too much WIP Inventory Operate a one piece flow SRL 10-Jul

9 Lack of balance between Make layout change & VMI Still needs SMED
Done
operator A B & C reallocate work for A
Changeover & set up too
10 long - process 1 & 2 SMED KAIZEN VMI 01-Aug

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


124

Standard Worksheet for Changeover Reduction


Part Name Date of Issue

Part Number Issued By

TOOL TOOL NAME


MACHINE LAYOUT

STEP NO. ACTION TOOLS # OPERATORS

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


125

Instruction
Standard Worksheet for Changeover Reduction
Part Name Use common name Date of issue

Part Number Part going out to part going in Issued by Area supervisor

Machine Layout Tool Tool name


Tool # assigned
Name of tool

Step No. Action Tools # Operators

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


126

Sample
Standard Worksheet for Changeover Reduction
Date of
Part Name Cagdab Widget July 15, 1992
issue
Part Issued
Number 16-59F426 to 16-59F447 by Ron Smith
Machine Layout Tool Tool name
1 Forklift
2 Ratchet
3 T-slot Cleaner
4 Go/No-Go Rod
5 Setup Garage

Step No. Action Tools # Operators


Press y:
1 Move blanks to blank storage 1
2 Move conveyor A to east side of press 1
Press x:
3
Lower ram using two yellow bottoms. Do not strap on
4 1
bottom. Use press indicator to step at 175 or 185
5 Move run buttons to plug side of press
6 Loosen upper and lower die bolts 2 1
7 Place bolts and holders in the bolt box 1
8 Place safety block in center rear rail T-slot 2 1
Raise ram to top of stroke - stop at 0 as shown on
9 press indicator. Use 2 yellow buttons
10 Remove die from 1 press 1
11 Operator cleans press of slugs and debris 3 1
12 Install die at feed side of press 1
13 Operator guides die placement from unload side 1
Lower ram using tow yellow bottoms. Do not strap
14 on bottom. Use press indicator to step at 175 or 185 1
15 Remove bolts and holders from boltbox 1
16 Install and tighten die bolts 1 2

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


127

Changeover reduction measurement chart Date ____ Machine # ____

50 48

40 35

30
20
M 20
I
N
U 10
T
E
S
Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3 Trial 4 Trial 5 Trial 6 Trial 7 Trial 8 Trial 9 Trial 10 Trial 11 Trial 12 Trial 13 Trial 14 Trial 15

Team determines scale for each machine. Separate preparation, replacing,


positioning & Centering, and adjusting & trial from each other on bar graph

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


128

KAIZEN Proposals
No. Problem & Muda Solution Who When Progress Impact

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


129

KAIZEN Proposals
No. Problem & Muda Solution Who When Progress Impact
1 Batch Production Layout change for one piece flow VMI Done Much better flow

Precision study of new


2 Imbalance of Workload VMI 15-Jul
standard work
Welding machines too
3 Layout change SRL 15-Jul
far from process
Operator B motion not
4 Change layout & work procedure VMI Done
smooth Still needs work
Too much adjustment
5 Develop Standard Worksheet SRL 10-Jul
in process #1
Air wrench & torque Change to impact wrench
6 NMM 01-Aug
wrench used (testing on line 4)
Operator B has too
7 Train operator B JRL 01-Sept
much variability

8 Too much WIP Inventory Operate a one piece flow SRL 10-Jul

9 Lack of balance between Make layout change & VMI Still needs SMED
Done
operator A B & C reallocate work for A
Changeover & set up too
10 long - process 1 & 2 SMED KAIZEN VMI 01-Aug

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


130

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#1 Separation of External From Internal
Tool setting (changeover and setup) requires two general steps:
1. Preparations which must be made while the machine is stopped
(Internal), examples:
Attaching a mold or cutting tool to the machine
Removing a mold or cutting tool from the machine
2. Preparation which can be made while the machine is in motion or
adding value (External), examples:
Preparations of jigs and tools
Preparation of fixtures
Transportation of the mold or cutting tools

In this first approach, it is important to collect data and decide which is external and
which is internal

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


131

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#2 Conversion From Internal to External
In this approach operations which are regarded as Internal will be
converted to external; the current tool setting work needs to be
thoroughly reviewed.
Examples:
Adjust and coordinate the dimensions of molds
Adjust machine strokes
Standardize setting work
Abolish trial runs
One of the ways to do this is to have specific marks made either on the tool holder
or the tool itself as to how it should be positioned to reduce the need for trial runs
and adjustments

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


132

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#3 Adopting Functional Standards

The standardization of functional standards can greatly


reduce the changeover and setup time; in this approach,
standardization of molds, jigs, tools, and fixtures are
adopted.

Examples:
Standardize the height of molds
Standardize male and female jigs

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


133

Visual Examples (1)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


134

Visual Examples (2)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


135

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#4 Use of Functional Fixtures and Jigs
In this approach, the way jigs and fixtures are fastened
should be looked at; they should be changed to something
that is more efficient. We like to think that there is muda in rotating
a bolt several times before it is actually tight (the last 1/4 turn is all that
adds value). Examples:
Thread screw
Wedge
Cam
T-slots
Square slots

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


136

Visual Examples (3)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


137

Visual Examples (4)

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


138

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#5 Application of Preset Fixtures and Jigs

Prior to the time when a mold or cutting tool is affixed to


the machine, jigs and fixtures are preset and affixed to an
intermediate jig, externally

When the machine is powered down, the whole


intermediate set is attached quickly

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


139

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#6 Working in Parallel

When there is a large mold or tool set to be replaced, it is more


effective to have more than one worker involved
Examples:
One worker at front end and another at the back
On a very large machine, several workers work
collaboratively on various sections of the machines
In very large machines there can be considerable improvement
in the transportation and storage of molds or dies

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


140

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#7 Elimination of Adjustments
Adjustment usually accounts for about 50% of the time used for tool
setting; further, the time required for adjustment varies greatly
depending on the particular workers skills, working conditions, and
attitudes. This in turn can greatly disrupt the pace of production
downstream
Examples:
Functional standardization
Use preset mediated jigs
Employ stoppers and gauges

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


141

Quick Changeover Improvement Approach


#8 Adopting Mechanical Improvements
This approach should only be done after the other steps
are in place; it is necessary before automated tool
setting in introduced
The main idea is to make mechanical improvements
Examples:
Use of pneumatic and hydraulic methods
Cassettization
One-touch operations

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


142

Hints for Quick Changeover Improvement application

Color Coding Standardization


- Nuts & Bolts - Size and shape
- Tools and jigs - Bolts and nuts
- Hoses and handles - Tools and jigs
- Dies and processes - Hoses and handles
- Air hookup and wiring - Dies and processes
Number Coding - Height and stroke
- Tools and jigs - Die height
- Dies and processes - Machine stroke height
Pre-Work - Handling and storage
- Pre-setting level
- Pre-cutting - Die pressure
- Pre-adjusting
- Pre-heating

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


143

Value Stream Map

VALUE STREAM MAP (or Value Chain Map) A


visual picture of how material and information
flows from suppliers, through manufacturing, to
the customer. It includes calculations of total cycle
time and value-added time. Typically written for
the current state of the value chain and the future,
to indicate where the business is going.

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


144

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


145

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


146

Material Flow Icons

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


147

Information Flow Icons

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


148

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.


149

The amount of time a new unit of raw


material will show up as a complete product
will be 23.6 days + 188 sec!

KAIZEN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, INC.

You might also like