You are on page 1of 14

Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No.

2, October-December 2010

CFD ANALYSIS OF A ROCKET NOZZLE WITH TWO


INLETS AT MACH 2.1

K. M. Pandey*1 and S. K. Yadav2

1. Department of Mechanical Engineering, N.I.T Silchar, Assam (INDIA)


2. Department of Mechanical Engineering, Gurgaon College of Engineering, Gurgaon
(INDIA)

Received July 5, 2010 Accepted September 06, 2013

ABSTRACT
In this paper CFD analysis of pressure and temperature for a rocket nozzle with two inlets at
Mach 2.1 is analyzed with the help of fluent software. When the fuel and air enter in the
combustion chamber according to the x and y plot, it is burning due to high velocity and
temperature and then temperature increases rapidly in combustion chamber and convergent
part of the nozzle and after that temperature decreases in the exit part of the nozzle. It is
concluded in this paper that two inlet rocket nozzle is having better performance than single
inlet.
Key Words : Rocket nozzle, Total temperature, Static temperature, Mach number, Total
pressure, Throat

INTRODUCTION transport, momentum transport and energy


transport respectively. Boris M. Kiforenko,
The world today relies heavily on
Zoya V. Pasechnik and IgorYu. Vasilev1
combustion of fossil fuels for its energy
worked on Comparison of the rocket
needs, as the major portion of energy used
engines efficiency in the case of low thrust
worldwide is contributed by combustion.
orbit-to-orbit transfers and their findings are
Hence the scope of the combustion is very
the following: The main task of this paper is
wide. Even in day to day life, we use
to compare two types of low thrust rocket
combustion appliances directly or indirectly.
engines: constant thrust vs. variable-thrust
The processes involved in combustion are
engines. They are concerned with efficiency,
governed by several different phenomena.
where efficiency is evaluated in the case of
This includes transport of mass, momentum
the orbit-to-orbit transfer with maximum
and energy. We know that the driving forces
payload mass in the central Newtonian
such as concentration, pressure and
gravity field. The launch mass of the space
temperature gradient can cause species
vehicle is supposed to be fixed. The
* Author for correspondence traditional solution is the decomposition of
308
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

the problem into parametric and dynamical condition of the ground-testing bed properly
parts. The corresponding variation problems and quantitatively. At last, the application of
differ for two rocket thruster types under the health evaluation system in fault
consideration. They proposed change of detection and health evaluation of the
variables, which makes it possible to reduce ground-testing bed are discussed.
averaged equations of optimal motion of a
Vadim Zakirov and Vladimir Pavshook3
spacecraft with the mentioned engines to the
unified form. Using this unified form worked on Russian Nuclear Rocket Engine
comparison of the performance of constant- Design for Mars Exploration and their
and variable-thrust engines is conducted. findings are described here. This paper is to
promote investigation into the nuclear rocket
Zhigang Feng and QiWang2 worked on
engine (NRE) propulsion option that is
Research on health evaluation system of
considered as a key technology for manned
liquid-propellant rocket engine ground-
testing bed based on fuzzy theory and their Mars exploration. Russian NRE developed
findings are the following: In this paper, the since the 1950s in the former Soviet Union to
theory based on multi-sensor information a full-scale prototype by the 1990s is viewed
fusion is studied, which is used to evaluate as advantageous and the most suitable
the health condition of liquid-propellant starting point concept for manned Mars
rocket engine ground-testing bed. The mission application study. The main features
concept of health degree is defined. It is used of Russian heterogeneous core NRE design
as a quantitative index for evaluating the are described and the most valuable
health condition of the ground-testing bed. In experimental performance results are
order to evaluate the health condition of the summarized. These results have
ground-testing bed on different levels, health demonstrated the significant specific impulse
degrees of a single parameter, of a sub- performance advantage of the NRE over
system and of a system are defined. They conventional liquid rocket engine (LRE)
accordingly measure the health conditions of propulsion technologies. Based on past
single parameter, sub-system and system of experience, the recent developments in the
the ground-testing bed. The method of fuzzy field of high-temperature nuclear fuels, and
data fusion is used to calculate the health the latest conceptual studies, the developed
degree. In this method the weight of each NRE concept is suggested to be upgraded to
monitoring sensor is calculated by analytic the nuclear power and propulsion system
hierarchy process (AHP), then, the multi- (NPPS), more suitable for future manned
sensor data are fused by the fuzzy Mars missions. Although the NRE still needs
comprehensive evaluation method, next, the development for space application, the
sequence data are fused by two-grade index problems are solvable with additional effort
evaluation method, finally, the health degree and funding.
is calculated by defuzzification method. Johannes Lux, Dmitry Suslov and Oskar
Based on these, the health condition Haidn4 worked on porous liquid propellant
evaluation system of ground-testing bed is rocket engine injectors and their findings
set up, which can evaluate the health are as followings. A novel injection concept
309
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

for cryogenic liquid propellant rocket a numerical study of a strong ignition


engines has been tested and verified sequence observed in a laboratory-scale
successfully using an optically accessible single-injector rocket chamber ignited by a
combustion chamber. The injector consists of laser and fueled with gaseous oxygen and
a porous faceplate made from sinter metal hydrogen. OH-emission images, Schlieren
and five LOX posts arranged in a classical pictures, and pressure measurements make it
parallel showerhead configuration. While possible to follow the flame propagation
liquid oxygen is injected at similar velocities experimentally. The present large eddy
known from typical coaxial injector simulation (LES) approach includes shock
elements, the fuel enters the combustion treatment, a six speciesseven reaction
chamber at much lower velocities. The flame chemical scheme for H2O2, and a model for
stabilization for both LOX/H2 and LOX/CH4 the energy deposition by a laser.
propellant combination has been investigated Flame/turbulence interaction is modeled with
at sub, near, and supercritical pressures. the thickened flame concept. LES is used to
Alexander Potapov, YuriyShtefan and Elena compute both the filling phase (during which
Lichman5 worked on Research of material the gaseous hydrogen and oxygen mix) and
for un cooled nozzle extensions of liquid the ignition phase. The flame location and
rocket engines and their findings are the structure, as well as the temporal evolution
following. One of the ways to increase the of the chamber pressure obtained
performance of liquid rocket engines (LRE) numerically, are in good agreement with the
is to use nozzle extensions (NE) made of experiment. The use of complex chemistry in
carboncarbon composites (CCC). The the computation also allows the comparison
following works were performed during of LES data with experimental OH-images
development of the NE: a fabrication method and shows that the sensitivity of the CCD
was verified, physio mechanical properties of camera used to record the spontaneous
the material were defined, effects of high emission of the OH radical is not high
temperature on a CCC oxidizing resistance enough to properly locate the flame front in
were studied, a method to protect CCC rich regions. The combined experimental and
against oxidation was developed. Prototype numerical results lead to a more detailed
NE were manufactured and tested in a LRE analysis of the ignition processes and its
test chamber. The test firings demonstrated coupling with flow rate oscillations in the H2
good performance characteristics of CCC. and O2 feeding lines. ValeriyI.
. Lacaze, B. Cuenot, T. Poinsot and M. Timoshenkoa,, IgorS. Belotserkovetsa and
Oschwald5 worked on Large eddy VjacheslavP.Gusininb7 worked on Problems
simulation of laser ignition and compressible of providing completeness of the methane-
reacting flow in a rocket-like configuration containing block-jet combustion in a rocket-
and their findings are described here. The ramjet engines combustion chamber and
control of ignition in a rocket engine is a their findings are the following. Some
critical problem for combustion chamber problems of methane - containing
design. Delayed ignition may lead to high- hydrocarbon fuel combustion are discussed.
amplitude pressure fluctuations that can It seems that reduction of methane burnout
damage the burner (strong ignition), whereas zone length is one from main problems of
early ignition may fail. This paper describes designing new type engine. It is very

310
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

important at the creation of combustion predicting with some accuracy hybrid rocket
chambers of a rocket-ramjet engine for engine fuel regression rates under standard
prospective space shuttle launch vehicles. M. flow conditions. A convective heat feedback
Masquelet, S. Menona and Y. Jinb, R. modeling approach is applied in tying the
Friedrich8 worked on Simulation of mass-flux-dependent heat flux directed into
unsteady combustion in a LOX-GH2 fueled the regressing fuel surface, to the subsequent
rocket engine and their findings are the solid fuel grain regression rate. Factors such
following. This paper presents results from as transpiration, hydraulic port diameter, and
an investigation of unsteady combustion effective fuel surface roughness are
inside a small-scale, multi injector liquid incorporated into the phenomenological
rocket engine. A time-accurate approach in surface regression rate model. A number of
an ax symmetric geometry is employed to comparisons between the models predicted
capture the unsteady flow features, as well as results and corresponding experimental data
the unsteady heat transfer to the walls of the are made, in illustrating the efficacy of the
combustion chamber. Both thermally perfect present approach for a classical head-end-
gas (TPG) and real gas (RG) formulations injection engine. Where substantial
are evaluated for this LOX-GH2 system. The differences between theory and experiment
PengRobinson cubic equation of state (EoS) exist, this might be due to one of several
is used to account for real gas effects identifiable factors related to non-standard
associated with the injection of oxygen. flow, such as the presence of radiant heating,
Realistic transport properties are computed swirl or flow impingement in or at the
but simplified chemistry is used in order to boundaries of the experimental core flow.
achieve a reasonable turnaround time.
Results show the importance of the unsteady Basic of combustion : various combustion
dynamics of the flow, especially the modes
In combustion processes, fuel and oxidizer
interaction between the different injectors.
are main ingredients which are mixed and
The RG EoS, despite a limited zone of
burnt while to produce heat energy.
influence, is shown to govern the overall
Combustion can occur either in flame or non
chamber behavior.
flame (smouldering / flameless) mode.
The sensitivity of the results to changes in Cigarette burning and charcoal burning are
the system parameters is studied and some two common examples of smouldering/
general trends are discussed. Although flameless burning of fuels. But in most of the
several features of the simulations agree well practical combustion system, flames are
with past experimental observations, formed during the combustion process.
prediction of heat flux using a simplified flux Hence, flame is often considered as the
boundary condition is not completely genesis of combustion process. It can be
satisfactory. Reasons for this discrepancy are defined as a spatial domain in which
discussed in the context of the current ax chemical reactions take place often emitting
symmetric approach. light. Based on the mixing modes of the fuel
David R. Greatrix9 worked on Regression and oxidizers, a flame can be classified in
rate estimation for standard-flow hybrid two categories, namely: (1) Premixed flame
rocket engines and their main results are and (2) Diffusion flame. In case of premixed
cited here. The present effort is towards flame both fuel and oxidizer are mixed
311
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

before actual combustion takes place. combustion. When chemical reaction occurs
Bunsen burner and LPG cooking stove flame in liquid or solid phase or both phase, then it
are some of the familiar examples of is labeled as heterogeneous combustion.
premixed flame. In contrast, the fuel and When combustion front moves with subsonic
oxidizer are mixed in the region where speed, it is known as deflagration. However,
chemical reaction take place in case of non- if the combustion wave propagates at
premixed (diffusion) flame. Candle flame, supersonic speed, it is termed as detonation.10
wick flame, etc are some of the example of
non-premixed flames. The flame can be OBJECTIVES
stationary as in Bunsen burner or it can be The objective of the present work is to
propagating as in SI (spark ignition) engine. simulate supersonic flow through rocket
We can again classify combustion process on nozzle with combustion chamber to precisely
the basis of character of fluid motion into understand the flow dynamics and variation of
laminar and turbulent. In laminar flow, flow properties in combustion chamber with
molecular diffusion plays an important role the nozzle. This simulation is carried out using
in mixing and transport processes. it is also fluent and gambit software. Gambit is used for
generating the required mesh and simulation
known as streamlined flow, which usually
done using fluent.
occur at low Reynolds number. In contrast
mixing and transport are mainly dominated MATERIAL AND METHODS
by microscopic relative motion of eddies or
Numerical methodology
lumps of fluid in turbulent flow. Generally
turbulent combustion more likely to occur in A numerical method adopted to approximate
practical combustion devices such as internal the governing equations, along with the
combustion engine, gas turbine engine, relevant boundary conditions, by a system of
rocket engine, etc. Based on the time linear algebraic equations is known as a
variation of the flame structure, combustion discretization method. Thus, a problem
can further divided in to two categories, involving calculus is transformed into an
namely: (1) steady and (2) unsteady. algebraic problem which can then be solved
Depending on the physical state of fuel and on a computer by using a solution
oxidizer, combustion process can be again methodology. A discretization technique and
classified into (1) single phase (2) two phase a solution methodology constitute the
(3) three phase. For examples, in Bunsen numerical methodology used to solve a heat
burner single droplets, wick flames are some transfer and fluid flow problem.
of the example of two phase combustion. Computational model parameter
During combustion processes in solid In order to arrive the precise solution, we
propellant rocket engine, three phases such need to describe the inputs that are to be fed
as solid, liquid and gas are likely to be to the simulation. Our descriptive study is for
present simultaneously. Even if fuel and the De Laval nozzles of Mach numbers 2.1,
oxidizer occur in different phase during for which it is important to know the
combustion, chemical reaction can occur dimensions of the respective set ups which
mainly in gaseous phase. Such kind of invariably includes the convergent-divergent
process is known as homogeneous nozzle and a combustion chamber.
312
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

The remaining factors such as turbulent Geometry and grid arrangement


parameters and pressure ratio are to be fed A 2D axis- symmetric computational domain
for initiating the flow within the created was considered, the initial design parameters
geometry.
for De Laval nozzle with combustion
With these parameters established we can
chamber for Mach number 2.1 with
proceed towards building a geometry using
the Gambit Software. combustion chamber.

Fig. 1 : Grid arrangement for axis-symmetric Rocket nozzle with combustion chamber

Problem description Boundary conditions


The liquid fuel combustion system Three types of boundary conditions were
considered here is depicted in Fig 1. A liquid used to describe flow field within the
spray of pentane fuel enters a 2D combustion computational domain.
chamber in which air is flowing at 650 K and Velocity inlet boundary condition
100 m/s. The combustion chamber walls are
Velocity inlet boundary condition is used to
held at a constant temperature of 1200 K.
define the flow velocity, along with all
The Reynolds number, based on inlet
conditions, is roughly 100,000 and the flow relevant scalar properties of the flow, at the
is turbulent. As the pentane Evaporates, it flow inlets. The total properties of the flow
enters the gas phase and reacts. The are not fixed, so they will rise to whatever
combustion is modelled using the mixture- value is necessary to provide the prescribed
fraction approach, with the equilibrium velocity distribution. This boundary
mixture consisting of 11 chemical species condition is intended for in compressible
(C5H12, CH4,CO, CO2, H2, H2O(g), H2O(l), O2, flows, and it use incompressible flow will
OH, C(s) and N2).The spray is assumed to lead to a nonphysical result because it allows
consist of 100-micron diameter liquid
stagnation condition to float to any level.
droplets injected at 300 K over a filled spray
half-angle of 30 degrees on the duct Velocity should not too close to a solid
centreline. The mass flow rate of liquid fuel obstruction, since this could cause the inflow
is 0.004 kg/s, corresponding to very fuel-lean stagnation properties to become highly non-
conditions in the flow. uniform. The flow of liquid fuel droplets is
313
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

defined by the initial conditions that describe subsonic. Should the flow become locally
the droplets as they enter the air stream. supersonic, the specified pressure will no
longer be used, and pressure will be
Table 1 : Initial condition under point extrapolated from the flow in the interior. All
Properties for injection other flow quantities are extrapolated from
First point Last point the interior. A set of back flow condition is
also specified should the flow reverse
X-Position direction at the pressure out let boundary
0.001 0.001
(m) during the solution process. Convergence
Y-Position difficulties will be minimized if you
0.001 0.001
(m) specified realistic values for the back flow
X-Velocity quantities. All other conditions associated
100 100 with velocities at the pressure outlet
(m/s)
boundaries were extrapolated from the
Y-Velocity interior of the computational domain.
0 57.5
(m/s)
Density 620 kg/m3
Temperature
303 303 Cp 2300 J/kg-K
(K)
Flow Rate Thermal Conductivity 0.136 W/m-K
2.0E-4 2.0E-4
(kg/s) Latent Heat 3.63E5 J/kg
Vaporization Temperature 303 K
These initial conditions define the spray of Boiling Point 306 K
liquid fuel droplets with a uniform diameter Volatile Component Fraction(%) 100
of 100 microns. The filled spray cone of 30 Binary Diffusivity 6.1E-6 m2/s
degree half-angle is defined by the range of
Saturation Vapour Pressure 8.2E4 Pa
Y-Velocity from 0 to 57.7 m/s. The total
mass flow rate is 10 4.0E-4 = 0.004 kg/s. Heat of Paralysis 0 J/kg
This corresponds to the mass flow rate of Thermal Conductivity 0.025
liquid fuel in the half of the symmetric duct Viscosity 2.0e-5
considered here. Set the following constant
property values for the n-pentane-liquid Wall boundary condition
material. The default property value settings
Wall boundary conditions are used to bound
for n-pentane-liquid, from the fluent
database, are similar to the values below and fluid and solid regions. In viscous flow, the
could be used to represent the fuel. Here, you no-slip boundary condition is enforced at
will exercise the capability to modify the walls by default, but you can specified a
database properties. tangential velocity component in terms of the
Pressure outlet boundary condition translational or rotational motion of the wall
boundary, or model a slip wall by specifying
Pressure outlet boundary conditions require
the specification of a static pressure at the shear. (You can also model a slip wall with
outlet boundary. The value of specified static zero shear using symmetry boundary type,
pressure is used only while the flow is but sing symmetry boundary will apply
314
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

symmetry condition for all question. The X- Momentum (2)


shear stress and heat transfer between the
fluid and wall are computed based on the U ( UU) (VU) P 1 2U 2U
n
flow details in the local flow field. X Y X Re X 2 Y 2
Computational methodology Y-momentum - (3)
To start with fluent, it is necessary to know if
the meshed geometry is correct, so is V ( UV) (VV) P 1 2V 2V
n
checked. To ensue with, we are to define the X Y Y Re X 2 Y 2
model, material, operating condition and
boundary condition. Models are to be set in With
order to define if any energy equation is dealt
with our study, if the flow is viscous etc. We u v tu x y p
U ,V , , X , Y , Pn 2
have chosen coupled solver, 3d implicit, u u D D D u
absolute velocity formulation, cell based
gradient option, superficial velocity porous Where u is the constant inlet velocity Note
formulation. As our flow is dealt with energy that all velocities are non-dimensionalised by
equation so is necessary to check them up. u and v , respectively.
The material is selected as air and the density
as ideal gas to make the solution simpler. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Under the solve command the control is For Mach number 2.1 and for two fuel
selected for limiting the pressure to a inlet
maximum of 5e+7 and minimum of 1e+4. The
initialization of value is computed from the Total pressure
inlet. It is also necessary to select the The maximum total pressure in the
appropriate approximation required in the combustion chamber is 1.09e+05, and the
residual command under monitors and check average total pressure in the combustion
in plot to visualize the progress of iteration. chamber is 1.5e+05, the total pressure in the
Once every parameter is described the conversion portion of the nozzle is
iteration is performed till the value gets 9.50e+05,while the average total pressure in
converged to required approximation.
combustion chamber ,pressure increase in
Governing equation combustion chamber and after that pressure
The unsteady, conservative and dimen- goes on decrease in the convergent portion
sionless form of the Navier-Stokes equations and at the throat total pressure is cover the
in two dimensions for the incompressible 6.77e+04 value, due to supersonic nozzle
flow of a constant viscosity fluid is as total pressure in the convergent part is less
follows: and velocity increoase in this portion. You
Continuity (1) can easily visualize the Fig.1 that. There is
decrease in stagnation pressure near the
U V
0 nozzle wall due to viscous effect.
X Y

315
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

Static temperature decrease in divergent part of the nozzle


Static temperature increase when we use two corresponding to decrease in static pressure.
fuel inlet comparison to one fuel inlet, here There is formation of shock, the static
the maximum temperature is 3.70e+03 and temperature increase due to decrease Mach
average temperature is1.90e+03,As we have number across the shock.
assumed the combustion property of fuel, the The static temperature is higher in the
static temperature is directly proportional to combustion chamber comp aired to the
static pressure, the static temperature convergent part of the nozzle.

Fig. 2 : Total Pressure


316
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

Fig. 3 : Static temperature


317
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

Total temperature When the fuel and air is enter in the


combustion chamber according to the x and y
The average temperature in combustion
plot, its burn due to high velocity and
chamber is 2.84e+03, and maximum temperature and then temperature increase
temperature is 3.70e+03, the total rapidly in combustion chamber and
temperature decrease in the divergent part of convergent part of the nozzle and after that
the nozzle compared the combustion temperature decrease in the exit part of the
chamber and convergent part of the nozzle. nozzle.

Fig. 4 : Total Temperatures

318
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

Turbulence intensity exit. Further downstream as flow gets


The nozzle is designed for stream line flow stabilizes, the turbulence intensity also
and hence the intensity has high of reduces.
turbulence is less inside the combustion Turbulence intensity at the fuel inlet is
chamber compared to divergent part of the 1.47e+04. A maximum of 1.62e+04(%) is
nozzle. The turbulence intensity has high attained and beyond which the turbulent
value about 1.62e+04 at fuel inlet and nozzle intensity steadily decreases.

Fig. 5 : Turbulence intensity


319
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

Fig. 6 : Specific Heat

Specific heat convergent part is less and velocity increases


The contours are shown in Fig. 6 the specific in this portion.
heat is largest where the pentane is There is a decrease in stagnation pressure
concentrated, near the fuel inlet and the near the nozzle wall due to viscous effect.
where the temperature and combustion Static temperature increases when two fuel
product concentration are large. Due to the inlet is used if compared to one fuel inlet,
two fuel inlet heat capacity increase. Relative here the maximum temperature is 3.70e+03
to the constant value used before, and average temperature is1.90e+03, The
substantially lowers the peak flame. static temperature is directly proportional to
static pressure, the static temperature
CONCLUSION decreases in divergent part of the nozzle
In this paper CFD analysis of pressure and corresponding to decrease in static pressure.
temperature for a rocket nozzle with two There is formation of shock, the static
inlets at Mach 2.1 is analyzed with the help temperature increases due to decrease in
of fluent software. The maximum total Mach number across the shock. The static
pressure in the combustion chamber is temperature is higher in the combustion
1.09e+05, and the average total pressure in chamber compared to the convergent part of
the combustion chamber is 1.05e+05, the nozzle. The average temperature in
Pressure increases in combustion chamber combustion chamber is 2.84e+03, and
and after that pressure goes on decreasing in maximum temperature is 3.70e+03, the total
the convergent portion and at the throat total temperature decreases in the divergent part
pressure is 6.77e+04 in value as analyzed of the nozzle compared the combustion
from the Fluent software due to supersonic chamber and convergent part of the nozzle.
nozzle design, total pressure in the When the fuel and air enter in the

320
Journal of Environmental Research And Development Vol. 5 No. 2, October-December 2010

combustion chamber according to the x and y 4. Johannes L., Dmitry S. and Oskar H.,
plot, it is burning due to high velocity and porous liquid propellant rocket engine
temperature and then temperature increases injectors, Aer. Sc. Tech., 12(2), 469-477,
rapidly in combustion chamber and (2007).
convergent part of the nozzle and after that 5. Alexander P., YuriyShtefan and Elena
temperature decreases in the exit part of the L., Research of material for un cooled
nozzle. It is concluded from the above nozzle extensions of liquid rocket
analysis that the performance of the nozzle is engines, Acta Astrona., 64(1), 22-27,
better for two inlets, if compared with single (2008).
inlet.
6. Lacaze G., Cuenot B., Poinsot T. and
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Oschwald M., Large eddy simulation of
The authors acknowledge the valuable laser ignition and compressible reacting
suggestions from Prof. E. Rathakrishnan, flow in a rocket-like configuration,
Professor, Department of Aerospace Combustion and Flame, 156(1), 1166-
engineering, IIT Kanpur , India. The authors 1180, (2009).
acknowledge the financial help provided by 7. Valeriy I., Timoshenkoa, Igor S. B. and
AICTE from the project AICTE: Vjacheslav P. G., Problems of providing
8023/RID/BOIII/NCP(21) 2007-2008 .The completeness of the methane-containing
Project id at IIT Guwahati is ME/P/USD/4. block-jet combustion in a rocket-ramjet
REFERENCES engines combustion chamber, Acta
Astrona., 65(2), 231-1237, (2009).
1. Boris M. K., Zoya V. P. and Igor Yu. V.,
Comparison of the rocket engines 8. Masquelet M., Menona S., Jinb Y. and
efficiency in the case of low thrust orbit- Friedrich R., Simulation of unsteady
to-orbit transfers, Acta Astrona, 60(1), combustion in a LOX-GH2 fueled rocket
801-809, (2007). engine, Aero. Sc. Tech., 13(1), 466-474,
2. Zhigang F. and Qi Wangk, Research on (2009).
health evaluation system of liquid- 9. David R. G., Regression rate estimation
propellant rocket engine ground-testing for standard-flow hybrid rocket engines,
bed based on fuzzy theory, Acta
Aero. Sc. Tech., 13(1), 358-363, (2009).
Astrona., 61(2), 840-853, (2007).
10. Christophe R., The propulsion system for
3. Vadim Z. and Vladimir P. , Russian
nuclear rocket engine design for Mars the Ludion one-man hopper : An Anglo-
exploration., Tsi. Sc. Tech., 12(1), 256- French rocket engine cooperation 40
260, (2007). years ago, Acta Astrona, 67(2), 264-278,
(2009).


321

You might also like