Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The optical stimulation of solids by means of strong low-energy electronic description of fullerides based on
light pulses has opened new routes for the investigation the Jahn-Teller induced inversion of the effective Hunds
of collective phenomena in quantum materials [1]. A fas- coupling [12], which provides one of the most successful
cinating one consists in inducing superconductivity (SC) description of the unconventional superconducting prop-
beyond the limits where it can be stabilized at equilib- erties of these materials [13], these authors demonstrated
rium, which are set e.g. by temperature, external pres- that a specific orbital-dependent perturbation of the on-
sure or doping concentration. A series of experiments site repulsive interactions does enhance SC at equilib-
in different compounds revealed light-induced modifica- rium. Such a perturbation was motivated by the pos-
tions of the electronic properties suggestive of the forma- sible modulations of the electronic interactions that re-
tion of a transient superconducting state extending above sult from the excitation of a local phononic mode, as
the equilibrium critical temperature Tc [26]. Recently, already demonstrated for other correlated organic com-
the remarkable observation of a superconducting-like re- pounds [17, 18]. Furthermore, a first principle calcula-
sponse above Tc in the molecular compound K3 C60 [6] en- tion [16] for K3 C60 revealed that the favorable perturba-
larged this experimental panorama and raised new ques- tion is indeed induced, under the assumption that light
tions about the possible mechanisms leading to transient excites the T1u mode [6], as a result of the structural and
SC above Tc . electronic changes associated with this excitation.
From the theoretical point of view, various mechanisms This proposal relies entirely on equilibrium considera-
have been investigated, such as the non-linear excitations tions however, and this raises the outstanding question of
of phononic modes [5, 7] and their coupling to the elec- the relevance of this mechanism to the non-equilibrium
tronic density [8] or the effective slowing-down of the elec- response of the system and to the transient light-induced
tronic motion [9, 10]. While all these mechanisms lead SC. In this work we address this question. We investigate
to an increase of the superconducting coupling which is the non-equilibrium dynamics induced by the time- and
expected to provide a source of transient SC in a broad orbital- dependent modulation of the electron-electron
class of superconductors, K3 C60 appears as a peculiar repulsion. We show that this results in a transient super-
case. Indeed, the absence of any enhancement or even conducting state, which can be induced when the system
the suppression of SC below Tc reported in Ref. [6], to- is initially well above its equilibrium critical temperature.
gether with the appearance of a transient response above The properties of this transient state dramatically de-
Tc is not fully understood within an effective SC cou- pend on the frequency of the modulation. In particular,
pling enhancement. Furthermore, SC in alkali-doped ful- we uncover a regime of frequency in which the modula-
lerides is strongly affected by the non-trivial interplay tion leads to the reduction of SC below Tc and to the
between pairing, electronic correlations and orbital de- creation of SC above Tc , capturing an important aspect
grees of freedom [1115], requiring the investigation of of the aforementioned experimental observations.
the mechanisms for transient SC within a proper theo- The minimal description of strongly correlated super-
retical framework taking this interplay into account. conductivity in alkali-doped fullerenes is given by the fol-
A first step in this direction has been recently taken lowing three-bands model [12] arising from the t1u LUMO
by Kim et al. [16]. Working in the framework of the states of the C60 molecule half-filled with electrons do-
2
Psc
The local Hamiltonian Hloc (i) is of the Kanamori
type [19] and takes into account intra- and inter- or-
0.03 0.01
bital electron electron repulsion, spin-flip and pair hop-
ping terms, with a negative (inverted) Hunds cou-
(a) (b)
pling JH resulting from the competition between the 0.000.0 1.0 2.0 3.00.000.0 1.0 2.0 3.0
Hunds coupling and the Jahn-Teller intramolecular in-
teractions [12]. time [ps] time [ps]
We assume that, because the local electronic config-
urations couple to the square of the excited phonon 0.06
with frequency [17, 18], it leads to an oscillation of 0.04 Psc0.04
the electronic interactions at a frequency 2 around a 0.02
value renormalized with respect to the equilibrium one P sc
0.00
U (t) = U + U (1 cos 2t). First principle calcula- 0.02 0.0 0.4 0.8
U [eV]
1.2
tions [16] showed that in case of the excitation of the
T1u mode such renormalization is orbitally asymmetric
(c)
leading to the same value of U on two orbitals (x, y) and 0.000 40 80
an higher value on the third one (z). We include this per-
turbation in the model Hamiltonian Eq. (1) considering T [K]
the following time- and orbital- dependent interaction
Figure 1. Panels (a)-(b): Dynamics of the global order
U parameter for two driving frequencies = 0.1875 eV (blue
Ux,y (t) = U r(t) (1 cos 2t) ; Uz (t) = U, (2)
2 lines) and = 0.15 eV (red lines) at zero temperature (a)
where r(t) is a smooth ramping function defined as r(t) = and T = 58 K > Tc ' 42 K (b). Panel (c): Transient or-
der parameter as a function of temperature. Color code as
1/2 3/4 cos t/ + 1/4 cos3 t/ for t < and r(t) = 1 in panel (a). Shaded area highlights the regime for which
for t , being the ramping time during which the SC is suppressed below Tc and created above. For T < Tc
modulation of the U is switched on. (diamonds) where an almost steady value is reached during
We implemented and use the time-dependent the dynamics we extract this value taking a time average.
Gutzwiller approximation (tdGA) [20, 21] extended For T > Tc (circles) we take the value of the switched order
to the multiband superconducting case [2224]. The parameter at t = 3 ps. Dashed lines are guides to the eye.
method is based on the variational ansatz for the time Inset: Zero-temperature order parameter as a function of U .
The star indicates the values of parameters considered in this
evolved state work.
Y
|(t)i ' Pi (t) |0 (t)i , (3)
i
corresponding to a complete set of uncorrelated states
where |0 (t)i is an uncorrelated wavefunction describing |n (t)i and a distribution pn . The dynamical equa-
the coherent quasiparticle dynamics and P(t) is a pro- tions for (4) are obtained by applying the finite tem-
jector onto the local Hilbert spaces giving the weights of perature generalization of the Dirac-Frenkel variational
the local atomic multiplets. The dynamics of both quan- principle [29]. They are solved numerically, with an ini-
tities are determined
R via the time-dependent variational tial condition corresponding to the equilibrium thermal
principle h(t)|it H|(t)i = 0. At equilibrium the state. In the following we will consider a semicircular
variational ansatz Eq. (3) is equivalent to the rotation- density of states with a bandwidth W = 0.5 eV and
ally invariant slave bosons technique [25] which has been take U = 0.5 eV and JH = 0.02 eV. In the inset of
already successfully used to describe equilibrium strongly Fig. 1(c) we show that at equilibrium this corresponds to
correlated SC in the present model [26]. a superconductor on the weak correlation side of the su-
The method is extended to the finite-temperature case perconducting dome determined by the electron-electron
by the introduction of a time dependent variational den- repulsion U in the model Eq. (1). This is consistent with
sity matrix [27, 28] e.g. the pressure dependence of Tc observed experimen-
(t) = P(t) (t)P(t) (4) tally for K3 C60 [30]. We take the modulation frequency
as an adjustable parameter in a range reasonably in-
where the projector
P P(t) has the same definition as in (3) cluding the typical frequencies of T1u modes and we fix
and (t) = n pn |n (t)i hn (t)| is the density matrix U/U = 0.1. We choose a ramping time = 0.9 ps.
3
odic modulation of the local interaction energies. This tive U and Transient Superconductivity. ArXiv e-prints
perturbation may result from the light-induced excita- 1609.03802, September 2016.
tion of a local vibrational mode and is known to enhance [9] M. A. Sentef, A. F. Kemper, A. Georges, and C. Kollath.
SC at equilibrium [16]. We showed that this leads to Theory of light-enhanced phonon-mediated superconduc-
tivity. Phys. Rev. B, 93:144506, Apr 2016.
the dynamical formation of a superconducting state ex- [10] J. Coulthard, S. R. Clark, S. Al-Assam, A. Cavalleri, and
tending beyond the equilibrium critical temperature Tc . D. Jaksch. Enhancement of super-exchange pairing in
Due to the correlated nature of such systems we showed the periodically-driven Hubbard model. ArXiv e-prints
that the transient state, while extending SC beyond Tc , 1608.03964, August 2016.
may show no significant enhancement of the supercon- [11] M. Capone, M. Fabrizio, C. Castellani, and E. Tosatti.
ducting properties below Tc where a SC suppression can Strongly correlated superconductivity. Science,
even occour. This captures a non-trivial observation in 296(5577):23642366, 2002.
[12] Massimo Capone, Michele Fabrizio, Claudio Castellani,
the light-induced response of K3 C60 which validates the and Erio Tosatti. Colloquium : Modeling the uncon-
mechanism as a possible source of light-induced SC in ventional superconducting properties of expanded A3 C60
these systems. fullerides. Rev. Mod. Phys., 81:943958, Jun 2009.
Acknowledgments. We thank Minjae Kim, A. Caval- [13] Yusuke Nomura, Shiro Sakai, Massimo Capone, and Ry-
otaro Arita. Unified understanding of superconductivity
leri, M. Fabrizio, M. Capone and H. Strand for insightful
and Mott transition in alkali-doped fullerides from first
discussions. This work was support by the European Re- principles. Science Advances, 1(7), 2015.
search Council (ERC-319286 QMAC). [14] J. E. Han, O. Gunnarsson, and V. H. Crespi. Strong
superconductivity with local Jahn-Teller phonons in C60
solids. Phys. Rev. Lett., 90:167006, Apr 2003.
[15] O. Gunnarsson. Superconductivity in fullerides. Rev.
Mod. Phys., 69:575606, Apr 1997.
giacomo.mazza@polytechnique.edu [16] Minjae Kim, Yusuke Nomura, Michel Ferrero, Priyanka
[1] Claudio Giannetti, Massimo Capone, Daniele Fausti, Seth, Olivier Parcollet, and Antoine Georges. Enhanc-
Michele Fabrizio, Fulvio Parmigiani, and Dragan Mi- ing superconductivity in A3 C60 fullerides. Phys. Rev. B,
hailovic. Ultrafast optical spectroscopy of strongly cor- 94:155152, Oct 2016.
related materials and high-temperature superconduc- [17] S. Kaiser, S. R. Clark, D. Nicoletti, G. Cotugno, R. I.
tors: a non-equilibrium approach. Advances in Physics, Tobey, N. Dean, S. Lupi, H. Okamoto, T. Hasegawa,
65(2):58238, 2016. D. Jaksch, and A. Cavalleri. Optical properties of a vibra-
[2] D. Fausti, R. I. Tobey, N. Dean, S. Kaiser, A. Dienst, tionally modulated solid state mott insulator. Scientific
M. C. Hoffmann, S. Pyon, T. Takayama, H. Takagi, and Reports, 4:3823 EP , Jan 2014. Article.
A. Cavalleri. Light-induced superconductivity in a stripe- [18] R. Singla, G. Cotugno, S. Kaiser, M. F orst, M. Mi-
ordered cuprate. Science, 331(6014):189191, 2011. trano, H. Y. Liu, A. Cartella, C. Manzoni, H. Okamoto,
[3] S. Kaiser, C. R. Hunt, D. Nicoletti, W. Hu, I. Gierz, T. Hasegawa, S. R. Clark, D. Jaksch, and A. Cavalleri.
H. Y. Liu, M. Le Tacon, T. Loew, D. Haug, B. Keimer, Thz-frequency modulation of the Hubbard U in an or-
and A. Cavalleri. Optically induced coherent transport ganic mott insulator. Phys. Rev. Lett., 115:187401, Oct
far above Tc in underdoped YBa2 Cu3 O6+ . Phys. Rev. 2015.
B, 89:184516, May 2014. [19] Junjiro Kanamori. Electron correlation and ferromag-
[4] W. Hu, S. Kaiser, D. Nicoletti, C. R. Hunt, I. Gierz, netism of transition metals. Progress of Theoretical
M. C. Hoffmann, M. Le Tacon, T. Loew, B. Keimer, Physics, 30(3):275, 1963.
and A. Cavalleri. Optically enhanced coherent transport [20] Marco Schir o and Michele Fabrizio. Time-Dependent
in YBa2 Cu3 O6.5 by ultrafast redistribution of interlayer Mean Field Theory for Quench Dynamics in Correlated
coupling. Nat Mater, 13(7):705711, Jul 2014. Article. Electron Systems. Phys. Rev. Lett., 105:076401, Aug
[5] R. Mankowsky, A. Subedi, M. Forst, S. O. Mariager, 2010.
M. Chollet, H. T. Lemke, J. S. Robinson, J. M. Glow- [21] Michele Fabrizio. The Out-of-Equilibrium Time-
nia, M. P. Minitti, A. Frano, M. Fechner, N. A. Spaldin, Dependent Gutzwiller Approximation. In Veljko Zlatic
T. Loew, B. Keimer, A. Georges, and A. Cavalleri. Non- and Alex Hewson, editors, New Materials for Ther-
linear lattice dynamics as a basis for enhanced supercon- moelectric Applications: Theory and Experiment, pages
ductivity in YBa2 Cu3 O6.5 . Nature, 516(7529):7173, Dec 247273. Springer Netherlands, 2013.
2014. Letter. [22] Nicola Lanat` a, Hugo U. R. Strand, Xi Dai, and Bo Hells-
[6] M. Mitrano, A. Cantaluppi, D. Nicoletti, S. Kaiser, ing. Efficient implementation of the Gutzwiller varia-
A. Perucchi, S. Lupi, P. Di Pietro, D. Pontiroli, M. Ricc`
o, tional method. Phys. Rev. B, 85:035133, Jan 2012.
S. R. Clark, D. Jaksch, and A. Cavalleri. Possible light- [23] Malte Behrmann and Frank Lechermann. Large-
induced superconductivity in K3 C60 at high temperature. amplitude spin oscillations triggered by nonequilib-
Nature, 530(7591):461464, Feb 2016. Letter. rium strongly correlated t2g electrons. Phys. Rev. B,
[7] Michael Knap, Mehrtash Babadi, Gil Refael, Ivar Mar- 91:075110, Feb 2015.
tin, and Eugene Demler. Dynamical cooper pairing in [24] Giacomo Mazza and Michele Fabrizio. Dynamical quan-
nonequilibrium electron-phonon systems. Phys. Rev. B, tum phase transitions and broken-symmetry edges in
94:214504, Dec 2016. the many-body eigenvalue spectrum. Phys. Rev. B,
[8] D. M. Kennes, E. Y. Wilner, D. R. Reichman, and A. J. 86:184303, Nov 2012.
Millis. Electronic Squeezing of Pumped Phonons: Nega-
6
[25] Frank Lechermann, Antoine Georges, Gabriel Kotliar, thermal equilibrium. Phys. Rev. C, 43:27472752, Jun
and Olivier Parcollet. Rotationally invariant slave-boson 1991.
formalism and momentum dependence of the quasiparti- [30] Ruth H. Zadik, Yasuhiro Takabayashi, Gy ongyi Klupp,
cle weight. Phys. Rev. B, 76:155102, Oct 2007. Ross H. Colman, Alexey Y. Ganin, Anton Potocnik, Pe-
[26] A. Isidori and M. Capone. Rotationally invariant slave ter Jeglic, Denis Arcon, Peter Matus, Katalin Kamar
as,
bosons for strongly correlated superconductors. Phys. Yuichi Kasahara, Yoshihiro Iwasa, Andrew N. Fitch, Ya-
Rev. B, 80:115120, Sep 2009. suo Ohishi, Gaston Garbarino, Kenichi Kato, Matthew J.
[27] Matteo Sandri, Massimo Capone, and Michele Fab- Rosseinsky, and Kosmas Prassides. Optimized uncon-
rizio. Finite-temperature gutzwiller approximation and ventional superconductivity in a molecular Jahn-Teller
the phase diagram of a toy model for V2 O3 . Phys. Rev. metal. Science Advances, 1(3), 2015.
B, 87:205108, May 2013. [31] Malte Behrmann, Michele Fabrizio, and Frank Lecher-
[28] Nicola Lanat`a, Xiaoyu Deng, and Gabriel Kotliar. Finite- mann. Extended dynamic mott transition in the two-
temperature gutzwiller approximation from the time- band Hubbard model out of equilibrium. Phys. Rev. B,
dependent variational principle. Phys. Rev. B, 92:081108, 88:035116, Jul 2013.
Aug 2015.
[29] A. R. DeAngelis and G. Gatoff. Generalization of the
Frenkel-Dirac variational principle for systems outside