You are on page 1of 8

November 2015

ArisaigPartnersisanindependentinvestmentmanagementcompanyfoundedin1996.Ourfocusisondominantconsumersector
businessesinemergingmarkets.WerunanAsiaConsumerFund,anAfricaConsumerFund,aLatinAmericaConsumerFundanda
Global Emerging Markets Consumer Fund. In addition to our head office in Singapore, we have research offices in Hong Kong,
Mumbai,CapeTown,RiodeJaneiroandtheUK.

Performanceto30November2015(%)
NAV Size 15yr 10yr 5yr 3yr 2yr 1yr 6mth 3mth 1mth YTD Since Annualised
(USD) (USDm) Launch Return
1
ArisaigAsiaConsumerFund 63.85 2,884.2 +861.6 +239.4 +71.5 +23.5 +20.7 +7.6 (4.1) +4.3 +0.6 +5.7 +852.0 +12.6
ArisaigAfricaConsumerFund 13.78 374.3 (2.8) (25.1) (38.4) (24.0) (12.3) (7.2) (4.3) (24.9) +23.8 +2.4
ArisaigLatamConsumerFund 20.43 266.3 (28.3) (24.6) (19.3) (9.4) +0.5 (2.8) (14.8) (10.7) (2.3)
ArisaigGlobalEmergingMarkets
2,4 10.23 857.4 (2.4) (5.2) +3.1 (1.6) (0.4) +2.7 +1.4
ConsumerFund(BVI)
(EUR/GBP) (EURm)
ArisaigGlobalEmergingMarkets
2,3 100.7
ConsumerFund(UCITS)
4
EURshareclass 12.43 +13.0 (1.3) +8.8 +2.8 +12.2 +29.6 +14.5
4
GBPshareclass 11.14 +0.0 (4.4) +5.0 +0.9 +1.6 +11.4 +5.8

1ReflectstheperformanceofArisaigAsianSmallCompaniesFundfrom31stDecember1996to21stJanuary2000,ArisaigAsiaFundfrom22ndJanuary2000to31stMarch2010andthereaftertheperformanceof
ArisaigAsiaConsumerFund.
2 th th
TheoffshoreversionoftheFundwaslaunchedtothirdpartyinvestorson16 September2013andtheUCITS(EUR)versionon4 November2013.TheadditionalGBPshareclassfortheUCITSFundwaslaunched
on16thDecember2013.
3
TheEURAUMoftheAGEMCFUCITSreflectsboththeEURandGBPshareclassesoftheFund.
4Performanceismeasuredfromaneffectivelaunchdateof1stJanuary2014forAGEMCFBVI,UCITS(EUR)andUCITS(GBP)forconsistency.

NovemberDiaryHighlights
PerformancewasmixedinNovemberwiththeAsiaFund(up0.6%)andGlobalUCITSFund(up2.8%)stayinginpositiveterritory,whilst
GlobalBVI(down1.6%),Latam(down2.8%)andAfrica(down4.3%)allregistereddeclines.
ThismonthwehostedourthirdbiennialConsumerSymposiuminCapeTownprecededbyatriptoLagos.Almost50investorswerein
attendancetohearpresentationsfromsevenholdings,otherAfricanconsumernames,macroeconomicexperts,aswellasourown
analysts.TheGlobal,AfricaandESGdiariessharesomeofthekeytakeawaysforthosewhowereunabletoattend.
Speakers described the huge longterm opportunities in a continent still at the bottom of the Scurve but making rapid strides in
development.Asthecurrentdownturnconfirms,progresswillnotbeinastraightline,butweownsomeexceptionallyhighquality
businessesinAfricawhicharestillinvestingconfidentlyforthefuture.Manyareevenburgeoningmultinationals;andthevastpotential
isabundantlycleartomoreestablishedMNCssuchasNestl,UnileverandIndiasGodrejConsumer.
InAsiaweintroducetwonewinvestments,bothfoodcompanies:OlympicinBangladeshandDaliinChina.MakingwayisChinese
hypermarketgroup,SunArt,which,despitebeingwellmanaged,isnotimmunetothestructuralchallengesfacingbigboxretailers.
The Latam section discusses InRetails promising move into the discount segment, a sounder strategy for conquering informal
competitorsthanitsexistingmainstreamsupermarkets.WealsohailtheadditionofArgentinatothegrowinglistofLatinAmerican
countriestohaverenouncedpopulistleftwingregimes,whichhavebeenpartandparceloftheregionsselfdefeatingpoliticsinthe
earlypartofthiscentury.

Whatwelookforinourstocks Whatourinvestorscanexpectfromus

Marketleadershipdominantcompaniestendtodobetter; Alignmentofinterestscappedfunds,nosegregated
Scalabilitylargetargetmarkets; portfolios,coinvestment;
Strongmoatsbrands,distribution,innovation; Transparencyholdingsbooklets,monthlyportfolio
LowcapitalintensityhighROCE; summaries,examplesofresearchreports;
Predictabilitycompoundinggrowth; Coverage26analysts;fiveresearchoffices;190target
Accessmanagementwhowelcomeourinvolvement. stocks;
Minimaltradingactivemanagementdestroysvalue;
Focusconsumercompaniestendtooutperform,sowe
wontbedoinganythingelse.

1/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

FundDetails

GeographicAllocation(%)
AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF
BVI*
India 47.8 Nigeria 20.1 Mexico 37.6 Indiansubcontinent 23.0
China/HongKong 19.6 Morocco 13.8 Brazil 25.0 ASEAN 10.7
Philippines 14.2 SouthAfrica 12.6 Peru 23.0 China 10.5
SouthKorea 4.8 Ghana 11.2 CentralAmerica 7.7 MiddleEastandCentralAsia 9.1
Pakistan 4.4 Egypt 7.2 Chile 4.1 OtherLatam 7.1
Vietnam 3.8 Turkey 6.7 Ecuador 1.9 ContinentalEurope 6.3
Indonesia 3.1 Kenya 6.6 SubSaharanAfrica 6.3
Bangladesh 1.4 Tunisia 6.5 SouthAfrica 4.7
Rwanda 6.4 USA 4.6
Tanzania 5.4 Brazil 4.4
IvoryCoast 1.0 Russia&EasternEurope 4.3
Others 3.9
Netcash 0.4 Netcash 0.8 Netcash 0.6 Mexico 2.9
Othernetassets/(liab)

0.5

Othernetassets/(liab)

1.7 Othernetassets/(liab) 0.1 UK

2.3

100 100 100 100


*IndividualcompanyFY14revenuesplitandweightedonAGEMCFBVIcomposition

SectorAllocation(%) Valuations(FY2015)
AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF
BVI BVI
Food&Beverage 53.7 62.0 59.1 50.8 EV/Sales(x) 2.8 2.0 1.4 2.9
FMCG 21.8 15.2 9.3 31.3 PER(x)* 37.6 30.3 19.6 30.3
Retail 12.5 13.4 30.9 10.3 PERrolling12m(x)** 34.3 27.1 17.4 27.7
FastFood 11.1 6.9 5.7 Yield(%) 1.2 2.1 3.0 1.6

*usingaggregateforecastearningsofallportfoliocompaniesfortheircurrentfinancialyears
**usingaggregate12monthforwardforecastearningsofallportfoliocompaniesirrespectiveof
financialyearend
Valuationmetrics(exceptyield)arecalculatedonthebasisofaweightedharmonicmean

PortfolioConcentration PerformanceMetrics(FY2015)
AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF
BVI BVI
No.ofholdings 28 23 17 33* ROCE(%) 41 30 23 32
Top10holdings(%) 57.0 64.5 72.0 46.4 Netmargin(%) 11 9 10 11
Top20holdings(%) 88.5 95.0 99.3 74.4 EPSgrowth(%) 15 14 12 10
Av.marketcap(USDm) 5,373 1,512 10,158 30,480 EPSgrowthrolling12m(%)* 13 14 14 12

*HoldingsforAGEMCFcountlistedsubsidiarieswithinonebusiness *Reflectsblendedforward12monthEPSgrowth

CompoundAnnualReturns(%)to30November2015 The Arisaig family of Funds are openended investment companies domiciled in the
BVI, Mauritius or Ireland and their daily valued NAVs are published in the Financial
AACF AFCF ALCF AGEMCF Times and on Bloomberg. The Asia Consumer Fund is listed on the Irish Stock
BVI Exchange.ThisDiaryisintendedtobefortheinformationofholdersofoneormore
15years 16.3 ofArisaigsFunds.Itisnotintendedtoconstituteinvestmentadviceandshouldnot
berelieduponassuch.Investorsshouldbeawarethat,astheFundsarealsoinvested
10years 13.0
in the securities of certain smaller companies as well as those listed in emerging
5years 11.4 (0.6) markets,sharepricescanbemorevolatileandtradingliquiditymuchlower.
3years 7.3 (9.2) (10.5)
Sinceinception 12.6 2.4 (2.3) 1.4

ArisaigPartners(Asia)PteLtd ArisaigPartners(India)PrivateLimited ArisaigPartners(Mauritius)Ltd
69CircularRoad,#0201,Singapore049423 VillarVille,FirstFloor,16P.J.RamchandaniMarg, IFSCourt,TwentyEight,
Tel(65)65323378Fax(65)65326618 Colaba,Mumbai400001,India Cybercity,Ebene,
Tel(91)2222875031Fax(91)2222875030 Mauritius

ArisaigPartnersResearchServices(CapeTown) ArisaigPartners(HK)Limited ArisaigPartnersServiosLtda
26KildareRoad,Newlands Suite4701,47thFloor,TheCenter AvBorgesdeMedeiros633sala206
CapeTown,7700,SouthAfrica 99QueensRoadCentral,HongKong Leblon,RiodeJaneiroRJ,Brazil22430041
Tel(27)216716680Fax(27)216716679 Tel(852)28506335Fax(852)28506355 Tel(55)2135917076Fax(55)2135910018

Forallenquiriespleasecontactinvestorrelations@arisaig.com.sgorcall(65)65323378.Websitewww.arisaigpartners.com.ArtworkcourtesyofthelateSophieMacpherson.

2/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

ArisaigGlobalEmergingMarketsConsumerFund

Performance UnileverInvestorDays
The BVI Global Fund ended November down 1.6% for the This month Hugo and Steven attended the Unilever investor
month,whiletheUCITSvehiclerose2.8%.Thisbringsyearto daysinManilaandSingapore,wheretheyjoinedfieldtripsto
datereturnstominus0.4%andplus12.2%respectively. consumers homes and to various sales channels. They also
had the opportunity to meet senior management. The
Themajorityofourstocksfell,butweweremosthurtbyour overarching impression was of the quality of Unilevers
largest holding, Britannia, which dropped 11.1% on no people, and the strength and coherence of the corporate
particularnews.Meanwhile,Orionbouncedback17.1%after culture. This is perhaps the prime example of how putting
a resurgence in China results in Q3 (see Asia section). This sustainability at the heart of a business model can create
stockhashadarockyyear,butisnowup6.4%yeartodate. competitive advantage by energising the organisation with a
sense of shared purpose, as well as driving valueadding
TheGlobalFundbecameacornerstoneinvestorattheIPOof productdevelopmentandbrandpositioning(seeESGsection).
DaliFoodsinNovember.Thisisdiscussedinmoredetailinthe
Asiasectionofthediary. SouthEast Asia is one of Unilevers strongest markets, the
companyholdingnumberonepositionsin85%ofitsbusiness
ArisaigSymposiumRisingMultinationals here. The region is at the forefront of business model
In November we hosted our third Symposium, this event innovationsthatarebeingrolledoutglobally,illustratinghow
taking place in Africa, split over two legs in Lagos and Cape emerging markets are increasingly influential within
Town.Wewerejoinedbysevenofourholdingstogetherwith multinational groups. ZeroBased Budgeting (ZBB) was
almost50ofourinvestorsrepresenting40%ofourtotalfirm originallyintroducedinThailandasanexpediencyinresponse
AUM. 16 of our analysts also gave presentations. One of the to recent political unrest in the country, but proved so
key themes of the Symposium was the rise of EM regional successful that it is now being adopted more widely.
champions such as lker, Godrej and Edita, all MNCs ofthe Combinedwithsomeothereffortsoncosts,ZBBcouldcreate
Future in the Global Fund. Such businesses are the core of savingsofEUR1bnayearfrom2018.
theFund,accountingforaroundhalfofourportfolio.
A second innovation we were shown in the Philippines was
Thesestilladolescentcompaniesareallimmenselyambitious. Unilevers new sales management system Leveredge, a
Theiruniquelyemergingmarketskillsets,suchasdistribution tabletbasedplatformwhichgivesmanagementgranulardata
ininformalretail,canbecarriedintoneighbouringdeveloping on distributors and the sales force. This is being rolled out
markets as each looks to internationalise its operations. globally and should prove a powerful tool in serving the
Anotherstrongmessagewasthattheinnovationcycleofthe complextraditionalretailchannel.
MNCs of the Future is speeding up. They are beginning to
compete at the premium end of the market, defying the old ChiefMarketingandCommunicationsOfficerKeithWeedgave
paradigmofbeingsimplylowcostproducers. a fascinating presentation containing a digital advert that
couldhave100,000differentpermutationsdependingonthe
These companies are typically more nimble than their larger observerscharacteristics.Healsonotedthat,usingbigdata
multinationalcounterparts,meaningtheirspeedtomarketon Unilever could correctly predict 97% of new hair trends. In a
newlaunches(aswellaspricing,brandcommunicationetc.)is personal care industry where ecommerce and social media
usuallysuperiortothatoftheirdevelopedworldrivals. have opened the doors to niche new entrants, this better
understandingofconsumersisarguablyonemeansbywhich
All that being said, Nestl Nigeria provided a pertinent majorbrandownerscansustainstrongmoats.
reminder of the formidable strengths of the established
MNCs. Whilst these may be more ponderous organisations, Beiersdorf
often slowed by bureaucracy and process, they benefit from Beiersdorf posted an uptick in sales growth in Q3, coupled
huge global research and development spending; a host of withimprovingmargins.However,thisresulthidadivergence
strong brands; and great corporate culture. We have often between the better performing consumer business and the
heard that Unilever is consistently one of the preferred more cyclical Tesa industrial adhesives segment (which
graduate employers in emerging market countries, giving it accounts for around 20% of operating profit). Still, the
recurrent access to a great pool of human capital. Some EM strength of the core Nivea brand, from which about 60% of
operations, such as China and India, have even become for thecompanyssalesarederived,providesaplatformforvery
Unilevernetexportersoftalent. promisinglongtermgrowth.

3/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

ArisaigAsiaConsumerFund
Performance ThisisaroundathirdofneighbouringIndiaandafractionof
NovemberwasarelativelycalmmonthfortheAsiaFundwith the world average of USD13. With the biscuit market still
theNAVclosingup0.6%.Thisbringstheyeartodatereturns largely informal and highly fragmented, Olympic is perfectly
to 5.7%. The positive performance during the month was placed to expedite the transition towards greater branded
driven by strong contributions from Future Retail (up 38.4%) consumptionitalreadyhasaleadingmarketshareof22%.
andOrion(up17.1%)onstrongresultsinChinaseebelow.
China:OneInOneOut
India November saw both the Asia and Global Funds become
TherulingBJPssecondconsecutivelossinstateelections,this cornerstoneinvestorsintheIPOofDaliFoods,aleadingfood
timeinBihar,sapsfurthermomentumfromtheModiwave and beverage player in China. Prior to taking up the offer,
ahead of the winter session of parliament. However, while membersoftheAsiaandGlobalteammetwithmanagement
political intransigence will likely disrupt progress on GST and andtouredthefacilitiesonfiveseparateoccasions.
land rights, there have been important developments taking
placeawayfromtheheadlines.Theseincludeacrackdownon Foundedin1993andbasedinFujianprovince,Dalihasgrown
corruption, improved fiscal discipline, infrastructure projects rapidlytobecomeasizeablenationalplayer(revenueinFY14
andemploymentgrowth. was USD2.3bn). Crucial to its success has been a superior
understandingoflocalconsumertastes.Indeed,innovationis
Thatsaid,itincreasinglylookslikeModiwillneedtosecurea atthecoreofDalisalesofproductslaunchedwithinthelast
second term to see through the more significant structural twoyearsare18%ofthegrouptotal.
reforms.Apossibleenablerhereisthetransformationofthe
public subsidy mechanism from a cash system (pilfered by Going forward we expect beverages (currently 43% of sales)
corrupt middlemen) to a direct bank transfer. This could be to be the major growth driver courtesy of Dalis exposure to
Modissilverbulletinthebuilduptothenextelection. the fastgrowing subcategories of energy drinks and plant
basedbeverages.Thisshouldensurethetoplinecontinuesto
Our Indian holdings continue to report good quarterly growaheadofthemarket.
numbers. Britannia was once again the star with second
quarter sales and net profit increasing by 12% and 49% Heading the other way is Sun Art, the leading hypermarket
respectively.RetailersTrentandFutureRetailalsosawsame operator in China. As highlighted during our Africa
storesalesadvancestronglyduringthequarter. Symposium, we have become wary of mainstream big box
groceryretailers.Theyareincreasinglybeingoutcompetedin
MeanwhileresultsatMaricoandNestlIndiaweremixed:the terms of price (by discounters), convenience (small format),
former saw top line growth slow due to deflationary pricing assortment(online)andquality(premium/organic).
(although still able to grow profit by 27%), while the latter
continuedtoexperiencethefalloutfromtheMagginoodle SunArthasnotbeenimmunetothis,inparticularduetothe
recall. With the ban now overturned and products returning unprecedented rise of ecommerce in China. Although it is
toshelves(andsellingfast)theworstshouldbebehindus. making strides towards creating its own online business, we
believeitisstillmanyyearsawayfromdeliveringanyreturns
AnOlympicsizedOpportunityinBangladesh here. Importantly, it has failed to integrate this with the
Over the last few months, the Asia Fund has accumulated a offline business to create an omnichannel proposition a
position in Bangladeshs number one biscuit player, Olympic criticalsuccessfactorhighlightedinourrecentcasestudy.
Industries. We are particularly encouraged by the deep
thinkingculturewithinthecompanyithasstudiedindetail OrionResults
the success of overseas peers such as Britannia, Orion and Orionsrecentresultsgavemoretocheer,withlocalcurrency
URC as well as its metricsdriven approach to capital salesinitscoreChinamarketreboundingafteratoughsecond
allocation. It is still a relatively modestsized business at quartertoriseby13%annually.Thiswassupportedbygreater
USD103m in revenue, but is growing fast with sales A&Pinvestment,apositivesignalofintentfrommanagement.
compoundingat30%overthelastfiveyears. Inordertocapitaliseontheincreasinglyaspirationaltastesof
Chinese consumers, the company plans to launch its
Thereisavastrunwayforfurthergrowthahead.Bangladesh successful premium confectionery ranges from Korea in the
sitsrightatthebottomofthebiscuitsSCurveconsumption first half of 2016. This should provide further support for
percapitaisjustUSD1peryear. revenuegrowthaswellasenhancingmargins.

4/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

ArisaigAfricaConsumerFund
Performance
Against the backdrop of our Symposium and its message of Importantly, as Francis and Desmond highlighted in their
long term optimism, November proved another unrewarding presentation on Why Eat, Drink, Wear, Wash, Shop? And is
monthfortheFundwiththeNAVpersharedecliningby4.3%. thistherightstrategyforAfrica?,theevidencesuggeststhat
Thistakesouryeartodateperformancetominus25.0%. aconsumerorientedstrategylooksjustasappropriateforthis
region as it does for Asia and Latam. Over the last ten years
Currenciesonceagainplayedasignificantrole.TheCFAFranc dominantconsumerbusinesseshavedeliveredconsistentEPS
(minus 5.0%), South African Rand (minus 4.6%) and Tunisian growthunderpinnedbystrongreturnsoncapital.
Dinar (minus 4.0%) all lost further ground to the Dollar. The
Rand,whichisnowdown20.3%yeartodate,hasreactedto Therecanhoweverbelittledoubtthatglobalenthusiasmfor
deteriorating economic conditions in South Africa and the the Africa Rising narrative has placed too many shortterm
potentialprospectofaratingsdowngrade. expectationsonaregionthatremainsfragileindevelopment
terms. As we heard from our guest speakers, current
From a share price perspective the largest detractors were economic conditions are being further exacerbated by social
Heineken subsidiaries Bralirwa (down 24.7% on tiny volume) andreligioustensionsinthenorthofthecontinent.
and Nigerian Breweries (down 11.5%). The former has had a
dire year primarily due to weak results which included an LagosLeg
accidental overstatement of inventories. The latter has, like Preceding the main event in Cape Town, a smaller group of
most Nigerian stocks, not escaped the current economic ourinvestorsaccompaniedTorquil,FrancisandAlaninLagos
downturn. to hear presentations from a wide range of industry
professionalsfromtheconsumersector,aswellastheprivate
CapeTownSymposium equity,agricultural,andinfrastructuralspheres.
InCapeTownwewerejoinedbyseniorrepresentativesfrom
five of our Africa Fund holdings: BM Birleik, East African The mood on the ground in Nigeria remains cautiously
Breweries, Edita, Nestl Nigeria and lker Biskvi. We also positive,despitethefactthattheeconomyisclearlystruggling
heard from the South African Dominos Pizza and Starbucks andmayeventipintorecession.Afurtherdevaluationofthe
masterfranchisee,TasteHoldings;GrantPattison,theformer Nairaisalsoalmostcertainlyonthecards.Wewouldwelcome
CEO of Massmart; Unilever Africa; and Godrej Consumers thisasitshouldbreakthepresentcapitalflowparalysis.
Africansubsidiary,DarlingHairCare,whichwediscussinthe
ESGsection. Supporting the optimism is a change of leadership that is
spearheadingabadlyneededanticorruptiondrive;concerted
We also hosted a morning session on the topic of Africa military engagement against Boko Haram; and a complete
RisinginwhichwewereledbytheexCentralBankGovernor shakeout of the ineffective ministries that have been
ofNigeriaandcurrentEmirofKano,LamidoSanusi;aswellas hampering the country both bureaucratically and financially.
Xan Smiley, editoratlarge and former Africa Editor of The In the last week we have seen President Buhari present to
Economist. globalleadersattheenergysummitonthedesperateneedto
rejuvenatethedesertifiedLakeChad,atopicaboutwhichwe
The message from our attending holdings was broadly have written before and which has caused significant
consistent with what we have been communicating in our socioeconomicdamagetothenorthernpopulationofNigeria.
Diaries over the past 18 months. Although current operating
conditionsareverytough,ourcompaniesareinvestingforthe ChangingoftheGuard
futureandremainfirmlyfocusedonthecompellinglongterm KevinHedderwick,CEOofourSouthAfricanfastfoodholding,
opportunity. FamousBrands,hasannouncedthathewillbesteppingback
inthenewyear,tobereplacedbythewellregardedcurrent
InthisregionconsumersremainatthebottomoftheScurve Chief Executive of Food Services, Darren Hele. This was an
across virtually all categories and are especially sensitive to expectedmove.
small changes in disposable income. Perhaps the best
illustration of this was East African Breweries reminder of OverhisimpressivetenureKevinhasoverseenanincreasein
how Kenyan consumers reacted to the implementation of market capitalisation from R105m to the current R14bn.
excisetaxontheSenatorKegvaluebeerbrandvolumesin Darren is a highly competent operator who is familiar to us
thissegmentfellby90%. havingbeenwiththebusinesssince2003.

5/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

ArisaigLatinAmericaConsumerFund
Performance Encouragingly, the company has now launched a compact
TheLatamFundwasdown2.8%inNovember,takingyearto discountformat(Mass)modelledonourAfricaholdingBM
date performance to minus 14.8%. Once again USD strength Birleik. Unlike InRetails existing supermarkets, Mass will be
was a major headwind, with all Latam currencies in the red. abletodefeatmomandpopstoresonprice.Itsreducedunit
Forus was the only stock to post a significant local currency sizeallowsittoadapttosmallerinnercitylocations(inwhich
sharepricedecline(minus10.0%)asitsufferedslowingsales Inkafarmaalreadyholdsconsiderableexpertise),importantin
acrossitsAndeanmarkets. a market facing severe constraints on real estate and where
themajorityofconsumersdonothaveacar.
PriceSmart was a key positive contributor this month, rising
8.4% after reporting good October sales and announcing the These developments are as yet unnoticed by the market,
openingofits38thstore.InRetailgained11.2%havingposted despitetheopeningof20Massstoresthisyearandplansfor
healthythirdquarterresults. 50 more (as well as a dedicated DC) in 2016. Importantly,
InRetail has stolen a march on competitors Cencosud,
9M15ResultsSummary constrained by its stretched balance sheet; and Falabella,
Allofourholdingshavenowpublishedthirdquarternumbers. whichisinsteadtriallingamuchlargersoftdiscountformat.
At the threequarter mark for the year, our portfolio has
achieved weighted average sales growth of 11% and EBITDA ArgentinaANewCycleBeginsinLatam
growthof16%.EPSgrowthiscurrentlyrunningat9%. The Argentinian elections ended this month with a win for
centreright candidate Mauricio Macri, extending the wider
Performance from the two thirds of the portfolio in Mexico regional shift away from the populist presidents who have
andBrazilremainsstrong.Ourholdingsinthesetwomarkets dominated Latin American politics over the last decade.
achievedearningsgrowthof18%.NumbersfromtheAndean Mexico elected a centreright president in 2012, Peru will
regionwereweakerinfact,ifweexcludeonlyAlicorpfrom followsuitnextyearandBrazilshouldjointhepartyby2018.
our portfolio calculations, EPS growth climbs to 13%. As we
mentioned last month, we expect deleveraging and an easy ArgentinaiscryingoutforchangeandMacrihaspromisedto
comparisonbasefromthisyeartodriverapidearningsgrowth end unsustainable energy subsidies; remove investment
forourPeruvianstocksin2016.Ourthreeholdingsheretrade stifling export taxes and currency controls; and renegotiate
atanaverageEV/EBITDA(16)ofjust8.5xandPERof16.1x. with holdout creditors. Simply adopting orthodox and
transparent economic metrics will help restore credibility
InRetail giventhefarcicaldatareleasedunderthecurrentregime.
LikeitscompatriotAlicorp,InRetailhasbeenheavilyaffected
by nonoperating losses in recent quarters but is now There is, however, reason to be cautious in the shortterm.
beginning to generate healthy net income and cash flows to Macris narrow victory margin and his lack of support in
accompanyitsconsistentgrowthinoperatingprofit. Congress suggest that reforms may only materialise after
much wrangling and compromise. Fiscal adjustments and a
InRetailisathreepartretailconglomerate.Arguablythejewel sharpcurrencydevaluationarelikelytoprovokeasignificant
in its crown is its pharmacy chain Inkafarma totally spikeininflationfollowedbyrisingrealinterestrates.
dominant with its lowprice approach; and exceptionally
profitable thanks to its cheap, flexible store layouts, efficient Our portfolio has limited indirect exposure to Argentina and
distributionandstrongprivatelabel.Weareleastenthusiastic weexpectdevaluationtoreduceitsrevenuecontributionnext
about the shopping malls division, which has delivered rapid year.Wearehopeful,however,thatfrom2017onwardsthis
EBITDAgrowthbutholdsaheftyassetbase,depressingROCE. largemarketcanturnfromheadacheintoopportunity.

Until now, our assessment of the supermarkets business has We are evaluating two additional investments which have
beensomewhereinbetween.Theopportunitytoconsolidate greaterArgentinanexposure.Thereislittleinthewayoflisted
thePeruviangroceryretailmarket,stillatleast70%informal, domestic consumer plays, but in the new businessfriendly
is perhaps the most attractive in Latin America. But despite environment, indigenous companies may begin to look more
InRetailsoutperformancewithinthemodernretailsector,we favourably on using the stock market to finance new
have remained unconvinced by the use of mainstream investment.Therearesomestrongconsumernames,suchas
supermarkets with a highlow pricing model as the vehicle theconfectionerygroupArcor,whichwouldfitthebillforour
withwhichtotakedemandawayfrominformalplayers. Fundshouldtheydecidetogopublic.

6/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

Environmental,SocialandGovernanceIssues
MakingSustainableLivingCommonplace Given that Unilevers fragmented agricultural supplier base
It felt entirely appropriate that we welcomed James Todd, comprises 750,000 small holders, there has been a strong
CFO of Unilever Africa, to our Symposium to discuss the focusonidentifyingtherightpartners.Atagovernmentlevel,
companys approach to sustainability on the continent. Unilever has signed publicprivate partnership agreements in
BeyondJamessregionalexpertiseandthefactthatwethink Tanzania,aswellasinVietnamandYunnanprovinceinChina.
UnileversSustainableLivingPlan(SLP)istheleadingstrategy Meanwhile nongovernment agencies have been critical in
of its kind, Unilever was actually Rebeccas first port of call developingreputableandindependentcertificationprocesses
whenwekickedoffourESGresearchsomefiveyearsago. toclassifywhatissustainable.

Jamess presentation brought to life the benefits of aligning Darling
Unilevers sustainability objectives to its core business Rebecca followed James Todd with a presentation which
strategy. This comes as second nature to Unilever, which stressed the growing impact of millennials, an increasingly
developeditsfirstbrandedproductcalledSunlightSoapto important consumer class that is twice as likely to check on
rid Victorian England of cholera by making cleanliness sustainability credentials before making a purchase. We
commonplace. expect this group of consumers, the youngest of whom are
justleavingschool,tomakesustainabilitymoreofabusiness
In Africa, a continent where Unilever built its first factory in imperative than ever before. Rebecca also turned her
1911,itistheLifebuoysoapbrandthatistargetingdiarrheal attentiontohowourMNCsoftheFuturearedrawingfrom
disease which, according to the World Health Organisation, years of communitybased work and multigenerational
can be halved by proper handwashing. Promotional dollars thinkingtocreatemoreformalsustainabilitystrategies.
usually focused only on driving revenue growth can also
deliver significant social benefits if channelled into school LikeUnilever,GodrejConsumerhasidentifiedthreekeygoals
basedhandwashingcampaigns. todeliveronby2020.TwoofthesearesimilartoUnileverin
being focused on environmental and product innovation
By looking at its business through the lens of sustainability, objectivesbut Godrejs Good & Green strategy reflects the
Unilever continues to scale up its social impact and reap importanceofemploymentasanissueinIndia.
businessbenefits.InGhanaacostefficient,multibrandchild
health and wellness programme has brought Lifebuoy Pointingtothefactthatonly13%ofIndias600millionpeople
alongsidePepsodent(oralhealth)andfortifiedBlueBand under25areemployable,Godrejhassetthegoaloftraining
(micronutrients)intoalocalinitiativecalledGrowFMthat one million rural and urban youth in skilled employment. In
aims to improve health and hygiene habits in one million India, Saloni, an initiative with a local beauty salon chain,
children. will train 50,000 beauticians over the next three years with
businessbenefitseasytoidentifygivenGodrejsstableofHPC
SustainablegrowthhasalwaysbeenthegoalforPaulPolman products.
(CEO)andheusedUnileversFY14resultsbriefingearlierthis
yeartostressthatsustainablebrandsgrewtwiceasquicklyas Following his insightful multimedia presentation, Aaron
otherbrandsovertheprevious12months.Musictoourears. Radomsky (MD) took us to visit hair salons in Cape Towns
Langa Township to see how Godrejs Darling hair extensions
FancyaCuppa? business is leveraging the entrepreneurial spirit of women
To mitigate the impact of selling more, Unilever has had to salonownerstoimprovetheirdistributionreach.Inthesame
makeasignificantcommitmenttothesustainablesourcingof way that Hindustan Unilever has used a micro
itsrawmaterialsandthroughitssizeandscaleitisstartingto entrepreneurship model to empower a network of 70,000
changewholeindustries. ShaktiAmmastodistributeitsproductsinIndia,Godrejhas
aFidelityprogrammethatisworkingdirectlywithsalons.
JameshasseenthisfirsthandontheteafarmsofKenyaand
Tanzania, which supply 10% of the tea used in its Lipton, Itfundssomeoftheinitialsetupcostsforsalonsinreturnfor
PG Tips and Brooke Bond brands. Back in 2007, Unilever instorebrandingandwordofmouthadvertising,whilstlocal
becamethefirstmajorteacompanytocommittosustainably academies provide training and support for young people
sourcing tea on a large scale and has since made the wantingtogetintotheindustry.Proofagain,ifweneededit,
commitmentthat100% of its tea will be sustainably sourced that doing good and good business are one and the same
by2020. thing,ifyougetyourstrategyrightattheoutset.

7/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

November 2015

MarketandCurrencyPerformance
KeyMarketsLocalCurrencyPerformance(%) KeyCurrenciesPerformancevsUSD(%)
Nov YTD 12mth Nov YTD 12mth
Asia
HongKong (2.7) (3.7) (5.2) HongKong 0.0 0.0 0.0
China 1.9 8.2 30.5 China (1.3) (3.0) (4.0)
Taiwan (2.7) (7.1) (5.9) Taiwan (0.3) (3.2) (5.3)
SouthKorea (1.8) 4.1 2.0 SouthKorea (1.5) (5.8) (4.3)
Indonesia (0.1) (13.4) (12.0) Indonesia (1.2) (10.5) (11.9)
Philippines (2.9) (2.5) (3.3) Philippines (0.8) (5.3) (4.9)
Malaysia 0.5 (2.5) (5.3) Malaysia 1.0 (17.9) (20.6)
Singapore (4.7) (12.4) (11.9) Singapore (0.7) (6.1) (7.5)
Thailand (2.4) (6.6) (12.2) Thailand (0.5) (8.1) (8.3)
Vietnam (5.6) 8.8 5.3 Vietnam (0.7) (4.9) (4.9)
India (1.9) (3.6) (7.6) India (2.1) (5.4) (7.0)
Bangladesh 0.4 (5.8) (4.0) Bangladesh (2.1) (1.9) (2.4)
Pakistan (4.9) 1.6 5.0 Pakistan 0.0 (4.7) (3.4)
SriLanka (1.6) (3.1) (1.0) SriLanka (1.5) (8.4) (8.5)

Africa
Egypt (14.5) (31.0) (35.0) Egypt 2.5 (8.6) (8.7)
Ghana (1.9) (12.1) (12.3) Ghana (1.0) (15.6) (16.0)
Kenya 3.8 (18.0) (18.6) Kenya (0.2) (11.4) (11.9)
Morocco 1.9 (2.2) (5.3) Morocco (2.3) (9.9) (12.1)
Nigeria (6.0) (17.7) (17.4) Nigeria 0.0 (7.8) (10.2)
Rwanda N/A N/A N/A Rwanda (2.2) (9.1) (8.4)
SouthAfrica (3.9) 7.1 6.9 SouthAfrica (4.6) (20.3) (23.7)
Tanzania (0.8) (3.7) (6.4) Tanzania 0.2 (20.0) (19.6)
Tunisia (3.2) (0.9) 1.4 Tunisia (4.0) (10.0) (11.0)
Turkey (4.5) (8.5) (8.6) Turkey 0.0 (19.8) (23.8)
FrancophoneWestAfrica 0.7 21.1 28.1 FrancophoneWestAfrica (5.0) (14.2) (16.5)

LatinAmerica
Argentina 4.1 51.2 32.3 Argentina (1.8) (12.6) (12.0)
Brazil (1.6) (9.8) (17.5) Brazil (0.3) (31.3) (33.7)
Chile (4.5) (5.1) (8.4) Chile (2.8) (14.7) (14.5)
Colombia (8.5) (24.1) (24.6) Colombia (7.9) (24.5) (29.5)
Ecuador (1.9) (9.3) (8.8) Ecuador N/A N/A N/A
Mexico (2.3) 2.5 0.1 Mexico (0.6) (11.1) (16.1)
Peru (3.0) (30.9) (32.3) Peru (2.6) (11.7) (13.4)

Global
Brazil (1.6) (9.8) (17.5) Brazil (0.3) (31.3) (33.7)
China 1.9 8.2 30.5 China (1.3) (3.0) (4.0)
Egypt (14.5) (31.0) (35.0) Egypt 2.5 (8.6) (8.7)
Euro 2.7 14.9 11.4 Euro (4.1) (12.8) (15.2)
HongKong (2.7) (3.7) (5.2) HongKong 0.0 0.0 0.0
India (1.9) (3.6) (7.6) India (2.1) (5.4) (7.0)
Indonesia (0.1) (13.4) (12.0) Indonesia (1.2) (10.5) (11.9)
Mexico (2.3) 2.5 0.1 Mexico (0.6) (11.1) (16.1)
Nigeria (6.0) (17.7) (17.4) Nigeria 0.0 (7.8) (10.2)
Peru (3.0) (30.9) (32.3) Peru (2.6) (11.7) (13.4)
Philippines (2.9) (2.5) (3.3) Philippines (0.8) (5.3) (4.9)
Russia 3.5 32.2 21.7 Russia (3.7) (8.5) (25.5)
SouthAfrica (3.9) 7.1 6.9 SouthAfrica (4.6) (20.3) (23.7)
SouthKorea (1.8) 4.1 2.0 SouthKorea (1.5) (5.8) (4.3)
Switzerland 0.6 3.2 1.3 Switzerland (3.9) (3.3) (6.1)
Turkey (4.5) (8.5) (8.6) Turkey 0.0 (19.8) (23.8)
UnitedKingdom 0.3 0.3 (1.9) UnitedKingdom (2.6) (3.5) (4.0)

8/8 Arisaig Diary We are a CarbonNeutral organisation and a signatory of the UNs Principles of Responsible Investment.

You might also like