IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HINDS COUNTY, MISSISSIPPI IRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT STATE OF MISSISSIPPI v. CAUSE NO. 25CI1:16-cr-00110-WLK BENJAMIN W. ALLEN, IIT DEFENDANT. SENTENCING MEMO COMES NOW Benjamin W. Allen, III, pursuant to M,R.C.C.C.P, Rule 11.01, and files this Sentencing Memorandum and for good cause would request the Court fo enter a sentence and judgement of probation. INTRODUCTION 1. A description of the offense and the circumstances surrounding if, not limited to ispects developed for the record as part of the determination of guilt; Mr, Allen was indicted for eight (8) counts of embezzlement. ‘The indictment charged that Mr, Allen embezzled property belonging to Downtown Jackson Partners, Inc, He was also indioted for one (1) count of making a false statement to a government entity for a “fraudulent business incubator.” The tenth (10") count alleged Mr, Allen contributed in excess of $1,000.00 to a political campaign or party, The Jury found Mr, Allen not guilty of nine (9) counts and guilty of one (1) count (Count 4) involving his wife’s cell phone line, which the Board of Directors of Downtown Jackson Pariners, Ine, allowed on their cell phone plan, Mr. Allen had reimbursed Downtown Jackson Partners for all charges connected with his wife’s phone, but the jury nevertheless returned this guilty verdict. The Court is well acquainted with the facts and other issues in this case so they will not be recited.2. Any prior criminal convietions of the defendant, or juvenile adjudications of delinquency: Mr, Allen has no prior criminal record of any kind, 3. The defendant's financial condition; Mr, Allen received a salary from Downtown Jackson Partners, Inc., in approximately $150, 000.00 per year. He is not indigent, 4, The defendant’s educational background; 5, A description of the employment background of the offender, ineluding any military record and including present employment status and capabilities; 6 ‘The social history of the defendant, ineluding family relationships, marital status and residence history: Mr, Allen was born on Decomber 16, 1950 at the Vicksburg Hospital in Vicksburg Mississippi. His mother, Ann Lois (Menger) Allen, was a native of Vicksburg, Mississippi, and his father, Benjamin Wade Allen, Jr, was a native of Hamburg, Arkansas, moving to Vicksburg to begin employment with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers shortly after the end of World War II, where he served in the Army as a Captain stationed in the Philippine Islands. Mr, Alllen was the second of four (4) children, with an older sister Ginger (2 years), a younger brother Hogan (3 years) and a younger sister Kim (10 years). He attended public schools in Vicksburg his entire childhood and graduated from H.V Cooper High School in 1968. Mr. Allen was active in high school activities and enjoyed many extracurricular organizations, such as the Boy Scouts, where he attained the rank of Eagle Scout at age 14, and earned the "God and Country Award". During the time he lived in Vicksburg, Mr. Allen was involved in his church, First Baptist Church of Vicksburg, Mississippi, and was baptized, accepting Jesus Christ as his Lord and savior, at the age of nine. At First Baptist Church, Mr. Allen also participated in the church youth choir, and was a leader in the youth leadership group, Summers were filled withLittle League baseball, Boy Scouts, and church camps and ell things "normal" for a boy growing up in the late 1950's and early 1960's. In 1964, he attended the Boy Scout National Jamboree in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, Mr. Allen had a good home life, with some of his fondest memories of his childhood were learning to fly fish with his father, impromptu campouts, lnunting behind his home, and sports of all kinds. As he grew up in Vieksburg Mr. Allen attended Carr Junior High School, where he was active in many activities; he was the starting wide receiver in football and involved in student government, After graduation from junior high, he attended H.V, Cooper High School, involved in a host of activities ‘was captain of the track team, played varsity football, and was including a role in the senior play “Oliver”, the Fellowship of Christian Athletes, the Glee Club, and a long list of many others. Graduating in 1968, he attended Mississippi State University, where he graduated in 1973 with a double major in Business Marketing and Political Science. While a student at MSU, Mr. Allen was a member and leader of Pi Kappa Alpha fratemity, a varsity cheerleader, and worked summers as an inspector for the US Army Corps of Engineers, Mr. Allen met his current wife, Susie Moore of Starkville, in college and they have been married for 41 years. They have been blessed with two (2) dedicated sons, Matthew Wade Allen, a partner and attorney with the law firm Brunini, Grantham, Grower and Hewes (in their Jackson office), and Clayton Allen, a medical doetor at the Vanderbilt Medical Center, Matt and his wife Megan West Allen have a daughter, Hartley (17 months).Clayton, and his wife Christine, have a son Joseph (2 4). After he graduated from MSU in 1973, Mr, Allen was commissioned a Second Lieutenant in the US Army and was stationed at Aberdeen Proving Ground, Maryland. He was honorably discharged after his 8 years of service, either active or reserve, as a First Lieutenant.He then entered the employment world as a marketing specialist for Shell Oil Company in Birmingham, Alabama, Mr, Allen’s love for Jackson and Mississippi called him back home in 1975, He accepted a sales position with Campus Supply Company, a regional manufacturing representative company in its Jackson, Mississippi office. This company represented many school supply firms such as the L.G, Balfour Company, Taylor Publishing Company, RM Hendrick Graduate Supply Company, and others. In 1986, Ben was promoted as its sales manager. After the premature death of the owner at that time and some management changes, in 1988 Ben purchased these franchises. He worked hard creating a successful organization (Scholastic Products and Awards, Inc) with seven (7) sales representatives, 3 offices statewide (and in Memphis) and many support staff employees. Mr. Allen ultimately sold all his interests in his company to his employees. Today those employees have all been very suecessful and have carried on the tradition of hard work, premier quality, and first elass customer service in all that they or their employees do. After he sold the majority of his businesses in 1997, Ben ran successfully for the Ward 1 representative to the City Council of Jackson, and was overwhelming re-elected two more terms, He served as its City Council President in 2006-2007. In 2007, the Board of Directors for Downtown Jackson Partners (DIP) hired Mr. Allen to serve as its President, DIP is a 501(c)(4) (non-profit social welfare) Business Improvement District corporation focusing on the betterment of our capital city in general and the downtown in particular, DJP exists to make Jackson a better place to live, While Mr. Allen's children were growing up in Jackson, he was involved in the community, serving as a deacon at First Baptist Church, a member of the church choir, a seniorhigh Sunday school teacher, and for five (5) years was the Scoutmaster of Troop 8, which was the largest Boy Scout troop in the state, Troop 8 has over 150 scouts and is the longest continually chartered scout troop in the nation, Both of his sons attained the rank of Eagle Seout, and eamed the “God and Country” award while he served as their scoutmaster. He also coached their soccer and baseball teams continually during their childhood and adolescence and was a member of their high school Booster Club Board of Directors. Mr, Allen has been involved in scores of boards and commissions through the years. This included the Mississippi Symphony, The Central Mississippi Planning and Development District, pi Advisory Committee for the US Commission the Mississippi Municipal League, the Mis of Civil Rights, the Jackson State University Presidential Search Committee, The Rotary Club of Jackson (where he also served as its President), Hospice Ministries, the FBI Citizens Academy, and a long list of others. Mr, Allen is proud of the many accomplishments of DIP and its Board of Direetors, including the Block-by-Block Ambassador program, the Capitol Street Renaissance project, the $1 Billion in redevelopment and capital improvements downtown, ‘These are projects that DJP helped promote and facilitate, including King Edward, Standard Life, Federal Courthouse, Walthall, The Piaza, Tombigbee Lofts, 308 Electric Building, Gartin Supreme Court Building, the Muscum of Mississippi History, the National Civil Rights Museum of Mississippi, The South Warchouse, the Smith Park renovation, and more, Mr, Ben Allen and his wife Susie live in Jackson, Mississippi and reside at 2517 Meadowbrook Road. They are faithful members of Christ United Methodist Church, where Susie has been a long time academic tutor to inner city children and is co-chair of the community outreach “Meals on Wheels” efforts delivering hot food to the less fortunate weekly.7. Information about environments to which the offender might return or to which the offender could be sent should probation be granted; Mr. Allen has a strong family and community environment. Attached are copies of Seventy-Six (76) letters from friends, family members, and others in the community who support Mr, Allen, More letters may be offered later. With probation, Mr, Allen would continue 10 live his life and serve in his community. enters ‘Not applicable, since Mr. Allen has no drug or alcohol substance abuse problem. 9. A physical and mental examination of the defendant if the Court orders it, None ordered. CONCLUSION Mr, Allen’s attorneys believe there are errors, which will require this ease to be reversed for a new trial or, more likely, that Mr, Allen’s charges case will be “reversed and rendered”. ‘The appeal process may take two (2) years to complete. Mr, Allen is a proper candidate for probation. He has no prior criminal record, He has a diverse group of community supporters who do not believe incarceration is in the “best interests of justice.” Mr. Allen has been a valuable member of the Jackson Community for most of his life, and the offense amount is low. Therefore, counsel for Mr. Allen moves the Court not to impose any sentence of incarceration. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED, THIS the 1* day of March, 2017, BY: _/s/ Merrida “Buddy” Coxwell MERRIDA “BUDDY” COXWELLOF COUNSEL: MERRIDA “BUDDY” COXWELL (MBH 7782) CHARLES R, MULLINS (MB# 9821) COXWELL & ASSOCIATES, PLLC Post Office Box 1337 Jackson, MS 39215-1337 ‘Telephone: (601) 948-1600 Faosimile: (601) 948-7097 mertidac@coxwelllayy.com chuckm@coxwelllaw.com Attorneys for Defendant, Benjamin Wade Allen, IIT CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ‘This is to certify that 1, Mérida “Buddy” Coxwell, have this day filed the above and foregoing Sentencing Memo with the Clerk of Court via the MEC system, which sent notice of same to the following persons of interest: Robert Shuler Smith, Esquire Assistant Hinds County District Attorney Post Office Box 22747 Jackson, Mississippi 39225-2747 rator to Evelyn Hunter, Circuit Court Admini Judge Winston L. Kidd Post Office Box 327 Jackson, Mississippi 39205 THIS, the 1* day of March 2017, MERRIDA “BUDDY” COXWELLEXHIBIT “A” LETTERS RECEIVED IN SUPPORT OF BEN ALLEN: Michael Rejebian Tom Johnson Ed Blakeslee Jim Rosenblatt Wirt A. Yerger, Jr. Barney E. Eaton, II William M. Cooley Jonathan A. Kiser Laura P. Johns Primus Wheeler . Theresa G, Kennedy . Paul G. Moak, Jr. . H. Scott Ross . Joseph W. Moss . John Ditto Nick Walters . Pam Johnson . Emily Damiens . Robert Luckett . Joseph and Mary Rogoskey . William R. “Randy” James . Edward F. Kennedy . Joseph K, Sims . Anthony Warren . Charlie Chandler Matthew W. Allen . Logan B. Phillips, III . Mark and Kit Fields29. Christine Rogoskey Allen 30. John Gomez 31. John Clayton Allen, M.D. 32. Bob Wilson 33. Russell Morrison 34, Ronald W. Tew, Jr. 35. John W. McGowan 36. Wanda Collier-Wilson 37. Debra L. Griffin 38. Dana F. Robertson 39. Maury Breazeale 40. Andrew C. Walker 41. Thomas B. Shephard, III 42. Susie Allen 43, Sam Lane 44, Sister M. Dorothea Sondgeroth 45. Wayne Farrell, Jr. 46. Walter S. Weems 47. Tom Underwood 48. Delbert Hosemann 49. Hunter and Suzanne Cade 50. Reverend Jody Schmelzer 51. J. Peter Jernberg 52. Jeff Good 53. Hilda Stauss Owen 54. Jimmye Sweat 55. Sylvia Y. Stewart 56. Amy McMahn 57. Susan H. Lunardini 58. Sam Begley 59. Hogan E. Allen. Brad Chism . Duane A. O’Neill . Michael W. Boerner . Shirley R. Tucker . Harris H. Barnes, IIT . W. David Watkins . Leland Speed . Kane Ditto . Alan Lange . Steven G. Rogers . Rick Calhoon . Frankie Box . Sunny Desai . Nic Lott . Cynthia Buchanan . Foster Kennedy . Steve DavisMICHAEL REJEBIAN JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI PRESIDENT, DOWNTOWN JACKSON’S NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONFebruary 25, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd | am writing this letter on behalf of my friend and colleague Ben Allen, president of Downtown Jackson Partners and one of our community's true public servants. ‘As the longest tenured resident of Downtown Jackson and president of Jackson’s Downtown Neighborhood Association, | have had the opportunity and privilege of working clesely with Ben as we've striven to improve Jackson’s central business district forall of the citizens of our state, In that time, | have come to know Ben as a man of character, integrity and honesty. And | do not use these words lightly. | was raised to believe that a man’s true heart is found in the good works he leaves behind for others to follow and to use in their own quests for success. Ben's heart is found in each of the projects that he’s spearheaded to bring forth the renaissance that Downtown Jackson is now enjoying. From the rebirth of historic Smith Park to the two-way reconstruction of Capitol Street, Ben has served as a shepherd to see these endeavors to completion. Because of his efforts ~ and the dedication, honesty and character they demand I can say, without hesitation, that Ben is a man to be applauded rather than convicted of a charge to which even the most jaded among us can see he is not guilty. I hope you will take my heartfelt testament into consideration as Ben comes before the court for sentencing and restore this good man to our community where he’s needed most. Sincerely, Mech Kure Michaél Rejebian President, Downtown Jackson's Neighborhood Association2. TOM JOHNSON 121 Hickory Glen Madison, MS 39110 Immediate Past President Rotary Club of JacksonFebruary 25, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winton Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, This letter is in support of Ben Allen, President of Downtown Jackson Partners. | have known Ben for ten years and have always been impressed with his unwavering support and enthusiasm for the city of Jackson, In his role as city councilman, he was always a voice of reason, a person who could look at all sides of a problem and work with other councilmen for the betterment of the city. ‘As President of Downtown Jackson Partners, he worked tirelessly to promote our capital city and to reinvigorate it by bringing more businesses into our downtown. | have found him to be a forthright, honest and sincere individual who throws himself into whatever job or task he is involved. | do not, for one moment, believe that he could, or would, embezzle money from an organization that he was so proud of, These past many months have been a nightmare for Ben and his family as he hashad to endure charges that were subsequently proved to be groundless. The final charge is groundless as well. | would ask for you to review the entire case and hopefully you will come to see that he is, innocent of all charges. Thank you for your consideration. Tom Johnson Immediate Past President Rotary Club of Jackson 121 Hickory Glen Madison, MS 39110 601-954-21643. ED BLAKESLEE Gulfport, MS Ben Allen’s Brother-In-Law / Retired Vice President for Mississippi Power Company / Trustee on Board of Trustees of the Institutions of Higher LearningThe Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39201 | am Ben's brother in law, married to Susie's oldest sister. | am a retired vice president for Mississippi Power Company and recently completed eleven years as a trustee on the board of trustees of the Institutions of Higher Learning. | have been a witness in a Federal grand jury in Atlanta and so have some understanding of how the system works. Marilyn and | live in Gulfport and have been married for 64 years today as | sit here and tried to put my thoughts together. We knew Ben when he was dating Susie. We can't imagine what Ben, Susie, Matt, and Clayton have had to endure all these many years since there charges were brought. It breaks our hearts as we have observed the toll on each of them as they go through this travesty. It never should have happened. We know that Ben has documentation showing that Susie's cell phone expenses were fully reimbursed as they were incurred. We implore you to dismiss this one charge and bring this to a merciful end. Susie and Marilyn come from a very close knit family of six siblings, children of a dairy farmer in Starkville. It is family that frequently gets together to share life's experiences and a family that supports each other. Therefore, we have had many opportunities and occasions to witness the love Ben and Susie have for each other and for their two fine sons. We have enjoyed listening to Ben, Matt, and Clayton recount stories about scouting, school-especially sports, church, hunting and camping, family trips, and many other activities. We know that Ben was actively involved in these activities as a coach, scout leader and in other leadership roles. We know that Ben served three terms on the Jackson city council. | grew up in that environment as my father was the public works commissioner for the city of Gulfport for 24 years and therefore understand first-hand the pressure public life can put on a family. We have enjoyed listening to Ben tell us with pride and excitement the accomplishments of the Downtown Jackson Partners, We know he has worked extremely hard to keep downtown Jackson vibrant. | value Ben's judgement. | often sought his advice relative to higher education matters in the greater Jackson area Finally, we know the character of Ben Allen. We know that he is a Christian and a man of tremendous integrity and courage. We know he loves his family, and we know he loves Jackson. We have never doubted his innocence. We thank you for the opportunity to share with you our knowledge of Ben Allen. Respectfully submitted, Ed BlakesleeJIM ROSENBLATT Dean Emeritus and Professor of Law Mississippi College School of Law (MC Law)February 25,2017 ‘The Honraba Waston Kids teat Court Suse, Deitet3 {tr east Paseageua Steet ‘eso, MS 39205 Subject. CharctorRearnoo fr Be kn Dear Je Kit tutto share win your vew of Bn Aan who was ecnty beer your ur where ay found hn ot pay ofl cages save one. This ‘eforeoesofree my ines enpoey and rae Pte vows lnmy vw Bon Alen fan harrabie men, fed utile that he ‘al enberae any mney tom Be ogszaon for wich he serves the Prestent~Ceuntew fckson Paes. Tat panzaten has cone Imuch god or downto Jockon unde Ba eae. aga ea Hen hl tne onto aeon Cty Gouna where was ays ‘open, det. sd honest in cecssng sins bafor tho Cty Coun. am ‘Sea lntio etary Clio wih Bon whore hana el lacerehip potions Sd suposed re Cubn on enemy flan. Ins inaractons vith IMocher meters Ben's svayssbov beard oll, ad porsonabe It srg charge ct whit he wa found guty wists juss ‘sty, ecommond tat ny saree mit exceed probs. defer oan espect your il uma in ican, it wate 0 ‘hae ih ou my enprenion Bon eas caret shes, hn Arowelttt— Jin RosonlatWIRT A. YERGER, JR. 6 Laurel Cove Jackson, MS 39211 Ross & Yerger Insurance, Inc.Wirt A. Yerger, Jr. 6 Laurel Cove Jackson, MS 39211 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson MS 39205 Dear Winston: Tam pleased to tell you that Ben Allen is a fine young man and an asset to the City. It is terrible what he has been put through. His honesty and character are impeccable and I consider him an outstanding citizen of the City of Jackson, Sincerely, LlBARNEY E. EATON, III Retired U.S. Bankruptcy JudgeFebruary 27, 2017 The Honorable Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 38205 RE: Mr. Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd, Ben Allen is someone | have known for 30 years. He is a very honest and giving person. In fact, when Ben ran for City Council, | felt that the citizens of Jackson were gifted to have a man of Ben's character. He has given countless hours of his time to help make Jackson a better place for all. Having had children grow up with Ben guiding or coaching them in scouting or baseball, | always knew and trusted his judgement. Please consider this man’s contributions and ability to contribute in the future. Sincerely, Barney E. Eaton, Ill Retired U.S. Bankruptcy Judge7 WILLIAM M. COOLEY Chairman of the Board Social Entrepreneur & Professor Emeritus of Management, Jackson State UniversityAn Consultants PSUs VIA HAND DELIVERY February 23, 2017 The Honorable Winston Kidd Hinds County Circuit Court ~ District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Through my work as a business owner, social entrepreneur, college professor and community developer, | have been associated with Mr. Ben Allen for over twenty-five years. The Ben Allen I know is above reproach. The Ben Allen, | know has: * Worked with me in forming the Jackson Chamber of Commerce} © Served asa lecturer to the West Jackson Leadership Academy, a group I developed to grow young business and community leaders in West Jackson; © Physically supported the Penguin Restaurant and Koinonia Coffee Shop by patronizing both places and directing other patrons there; * Supported many of my social causes; and, © Helped me research the feasibility of securing an athletic arena for downtown Jackson. In short, I can think of no one who has been a greater cheerleader for Jackson and its diverse communities than Ben Allen. Judge Kidd, | understand that Mr. Allen isto be sentenced shortly. And, I have no first-hand knowledge of the events that precipitated the finding of guilt and his sentencing hearing. However, | am keenly aware of the value Ben has contributed to Jackson, specifically. Thus, | appeal to you to grant him the lowest possible sentence that the law allows. ‘Thank you for your time and considering my comments, Sincerely, bXNe\, WILLIAM M. COOLEY Chairman of the Board Social Entrepreneur & Professor Emeritus of Management, Jackson State University8. JONATHAN KISER Professional Traffic Engineer & Transportation Planner — Neel-Schaffer, Inc.NeNeel—ScHArFeR iacageeeis February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Cirouit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 30205 Re: Ben Allen - Downtown Jackson Partners Dear Judge Kidd: Since I moved back to Mississippi in 2010, after being born, raised and educated in Mississippi, I have had the opportunity to work with Ben Allen and Downtown Jackson Partners on many projects related to engineering and inftastructure in the downtown area. I have enjoyed getting to know Ben and have ‘worked closely with him on many projects in the downtown area. In my experience with Ben, he has demonstrated that he is a leader and a champion of the revitalization of downtown Jackson. My opi is that Ben is an honest person, with integrity and commitment to helping the community. Ben works elessly to promote and defend Jackson and to find ways to improve the community. Ihave watched him work with city council, public citizens and property owners to improve Jackson. Thate to see Ben have embezzlement charges against him for something that was proven not to be a crime, Ihope that you will see that Ben has not committed a erime, and let him go without punishment. We need people like Ben working in our community to make it a better place. I consider Ben a friend of imine and T believe that he is an honest person. Ifyou have any questions that I could answer directly, please call me at 601-948-3071. Sincerely, NEEL-SCHAFFER, INC. mon Hh Jonathan A. Kiser, ?.E., PTOE, PTP Professional Traffic Engineer & ‘Transportation PlannerLAURA JOIINS VP of Marketing — Fuse Former Executive Director of TeamJXNThe Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 Fast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 February 27, 2917 Judge Kidd: As a board member and the former executive director of TeamJXN, | am writing today to speak to the character of Ben Allen and the positive influence he has had on me personally, ‘as well as on the City of Jackson. TeamJXN is a 504(c)(3) organization that showcases growth and positive momentum rising up in Jackson. Mr. Allen, who spearheaded the organization from its early days and served as chairman of the board, saw the need for a passionate group of cheerleaders in Jackson ‘whose purpose was to support and lead efforts to ensure good things (events, programs, etc.) happen in the city. The organization encourages business owners, developers and entrepreneurs to work, play and live in Jackson. met Mr. Allen at a lunch meeting where he was enthusiastically explaining the need for the Team4JXN organization to have an executive director so it could grow. After eventually taking the position myself, | have had the privilege of seeing his leadership firsthand within the organization. From his dedication to leading the board and recruiting membership to his ability to “preach” an inspiring message of hope for our city in large group settings, Ihave learned so much from Mr. Allen about what it takes to motivate and inspire others. | have been involved in a number of leadership organizations in Jackson (Leadership Greater Jackson, Young Professionals of Jackson, Vision 2022, ete.). The difference in my involvement in TeamJXN is that we had a leader that TRULY cared about the orgarization and its growth. If | have learned anything from Ben Allen, its that a genuine hear, character and a burning passion for something (in his case, Jackson) can move mountains. | am proud to serve alongside him in this organization, Sincerely, Laura P. Johns. TeamJXN Board Teamsx 736 8. President Stree, Sule 10 ‘Jackson, MS 3920 wonnteamjen.cot10. PRIMUS WHEELER Executive Director Jackson Medical Mall FoundationMat towndation 350. Woakow ‘isn Drive ‘ite 107 Jackson, ssi own st Office Box vs Jeckson, Missi SDB SE cono.sisr |-S46MED MALUTeI Free 01.90.2168 Fs Website wonnjaesonmedicamalorg January 26, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: ‘The purpose of the letter is to provide support to Mr. Ben Allen. I have. known of Mr. Allen and his work and love for the City of Jackson, MS, I recently became involved with him on a startup initiative called, ‘Team Jackson. The primary purpose of this organization that he single handedly visioned and guided through the startup and successful operation to highlight the positive activities about our City. He outworks all of us to ensure that “Team Jackson is successful and sustained. Thave known Ben to be a devoted citizen of Jackson. You can’t speak to him ever without him passionately getting into a conversation about what we all ccan do to keep our City moving forward. His honesty and character are constantly on display in my dealings with him. When he tells you something ‘or makes @ commitment, you can 100% count on him to follow through, ‘As you consider his case that is before you, please accept my comments above as support for Mr. Allen. Respectfully submitted, Primus Wheeler Executive Director Jackson Medical Mall Foundation | | | |i. THERESA G, KENNEDY Post Office Box 391 Ridgeland, MS 39158 Team Jackson/Community StakeholderMists Kenedy P.O. Box 391 ° Ridgeland, MS 39158 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge Disirict 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205, Dear Judge Kidd: 11am writing this etter of support on behalf of Jacksonian, Ben Allen. | have known of Ben Allen and his ‘good works since moving here in 2005. In most recent years, | have grown fond of his devotion to bettering Jackson. Currently, he and both serve on the Steering Committee for Team Jackson, and he is. {ving of his time and talent in ensuring that Team Jackson promotes all that is good about lackson, | can attest to Ben's character and professionalism. Even before I knew hin personally, he was always cordial and professional. Since getting to know him, he will speak up for what's right and certainly unapologetic for calling out the wrong. And as a young professional | ook at not only the words but also the deeds of my elders to decide a person's character. Ben has shown himself to be inspirng, caring and selfless. Those are traits that any good leader would and should possess. Judge Kidd, | hope you will consider all the good that Ben has done for the good of Jackson and all of us impacted by his good works. He deserves a fair and just trial and decision. As | followed the trial, it was proven and obvious that the OJP investigation proved that he did Not embezzle ANYTHING from DIP. Please consider that the case be dismissed as factually wrong, Sincerely, Theresa G. Kennedy ‘Theresa G. Kennedy ‘Team Jackson/ Community Stakeholder12. PAUL G. MOAK, JR. President of Paul Moak located in Jackson, Mississippisi ost office 90x 1500 ‘al oO: Sackson is $9218 80 Tetons ear2.2700 ax ® 601.360.2129 February 27", 2017 isernst ‘wor paulmoak.com ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd nal Creu suige Distr Paulmarki@paulmoak-car 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 RE: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd, My relationship with Ben Allen began around 35 or more years ago when we lived close to one another in the Heatherwood area of Jackson and had children about the same age attending schoo! together. ‘Our paths crossed on many occasions. Ben was the Scoutmaster of Boy Scout Troop 8 at our church and ‘my son was a participant in that troop with one of Ben's son, ultimately receiving his Eagle rank. For a while Ben and his family also went to the same church as our family. Ben was the City Council representative for many years for the area where my family still ive in Jackson. | remember the difficulty of serving in that position at that time and how well he dealt with the serlous issues of that time. If he wanted to be corrupt, there was plenty of opportunity for that to ozeur asit did with some of his fellow council members during that time. Yet the FBI found him totally clean and above board, My path has continued to cross with Ben's as he has led the Downtown Jackson group now for a number of years. | have been in many meetings with him while serving on various committees for the Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership as he would represent the Downtown Jackson Partners. When we opened our location on Larson Street in 2008, | asked Ben to come and share his thoughts about Jackson to our guests and factory representatives. He did an excellent job of communicating and promoting our community. | mention all of these relationships over the years to give some evidence that | have known, observed and been around Ben Allen and his family in many different settings for over three decades. The actions and behavior of Ben Allen today is no different to me than it was when | first met him. Everything | have ‘observed is that he has lived a consistent life built along biblical values and that truth, honor, and doing the correct thing is real and important to him. He is someone that cares greatly about Jackson. He is, someone that cares greatly about our youth. He is someone whose word is his bond. It is extremely hard for me to raconelle how a jury could return a verdict on even one count against him over an integrity issue. That isnot the Ben Allen | know. May God grant you special wisdom as you make decisions related to this matter. Ne Ee Melo President oo13. Il. SCOTT ROSS Attorney — Ross & Kelley, PLLCROSS & KELLEY, PLLC Attorneys At Law H. Scott Ross J. Brian Kelley P.O, Box 332 639 Commerce Street West Point, MS_39773 Phone: (662) 494-2593 210 Highway 182 East Starkville, MS_39759 Phone: (662) 324-3476 Facsimile: (662) 796-3021 Facsimile: (662) 494-2562 February 27, 2017 Honorable Judge Winston Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Re: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd: Jam writing to express my fervent support of Ben Allen, Specifically, | request that you ‘grant him your maximum amount of leniency. Having had the privilege of knowing Ben for many years, | fee! fully able to share with you my thoughts, You are about to pass judgment on a fine anc! entirely honorable man. Thave had the honor of serving in several positions in public service over the years, and have had the pleasure of interacting with Ben. In every case, he has impressed me as a man of integrity and honesty. Never have I had any reason to doubt either. On another point, Lhave been lucky to know Ben's extended family. If that is ever indicative ofa person's character, then Ben has passed the test with aplomb. What an outstanding extension of himself he hast Your honor, | beseech you fo use your best instinets in passing judgment on Ben Allen. Having practiced law for over thirty years myself, { have the utmost respect for juries, but they are not infallible. Please take into account Ben's long and distinguished service to the eommunity’ and his lasting legacy through his friends and, especially, his outstanding family. ‘Thank you very much for your consideration of my thoughts. ihe {2 one | C0 HSR/gb14, JOSEPH W. MOSS Mid MS Division President — BancorpSouth 525 E. Capitol Street, Jackson, MS 39201Q BancorpSouth February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Judge Kidd, { would like to thank you for all that you do for the citizens of Jackson. | would also like to show my support for Ben Allen. | have had the opportunity to work with Ben on multiple occasions during my 25 year banking career. Ihave always found him to be a very hard working and honest gentleman to do and he always has the best interest of city in mind on each and every prospect. | support 1, thank you for all that you do. business Ben and agai (ne sph Wi Moss ld MS Division President BancorpSouth 2.0.x 1605 Jacson, MS 39215 | 525 Coptel St. Jackson, MS 39201 | P: (601) 3544500,15. JOHN DITTO Post Office Box 13925 Jackson, MS 39236-3925 President, State Street Group= Si StateStreetGroup February 28, 2017 Via Email and US MAIL Honorable Winston L. Kidd 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd | am writing today in support of Ben Allen, and ask that you grant unto Ben a senteace of probation, Since 2007 Ben has worked diligently to bring prosperity to downtown Jackson. Ben once {old me that he didn't really discover his professional passion until later in life. Onee he found this passion for urban economic development, he never slowed down. Ben has worked tirelessly to bring jobs and people to downtown Jackson. He has always approached his position in a positive manner, and has often served as the voice of | ‘optimism even when things were not going well for our City. I have always found Ben to be a man of ‘good character; he truly represents what is best about the City of Jackson. | don’t pretend to know all the facts in this ease, but I do feel confident that Ben never intentionally committed a erime. ‘The past year or so has been extremely taxing on Ben and his family. He has already suffered a great deal. Again, | would ask that you grant a sentence of probation. Thanks for your consideration, sincerely, IKDIN/da to2 Biches Packie Site A 9868 et 99197 0 fx 1985, cae, Nasi 3929860190 44H5 1 D191 599F-womaaeketyoup cm16. NICK WALTERS 1817 Crane Ridge Drive, Suite B-1 Jackson, MS 39216 Easy Grant$(c5 Cc] 1817 Crane Ridge Drive, Suite B-1 Jackson, Mississippi 39216 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Honorable Judge Kid: Ben Allen cares because he wants to ~ not because he has to, Most people who have lived in the city of Jackson over the past 40 years have moved away to Madison County or Rankin County. But not Ben Allen — because he eares what happens to Jackson. Many people who still live in northeast Jackson have all but abandoned gi complain or stay at home and try to build walls to bunker themselves in the ought to be. But not Ben Allen — because he eares what happens to Jackson, any concem about Jackson's future. They own fantasy definition of how the world Ben gives back when he doesn’t have to do it. After building a successful business in Jackson, Ben decided to give back serving on the city council. Ben’s fellow councilmen could see the tireless effort he put in to council business. No one would have guessed that an African-American majority of the Jackson City Council would elect « white, northeast Jacksonian as council president. But they did because Ben Allen showed he eared about what happens to Jackson. ‘One of the “charges” made against Ben centered on the Downtown Jackson Partners’ efforts to create an atmosphere of helping small business in the form of an incubator. I brought the idea of an incubator to Ben and he immediately jumped con the idea. After conferring with his board, Ben leapt at the chance to give budding entrepreneurs and small business ‘owners the skill sets they needed to sueceed. This was not a part of DJP’s original mission but when Ben saw how successful incubators had been across the country, he could immediately imagine how one could work for Jackson. Ben put countless hours into the formation of the community board (chaired by former US Secretary of Agriculture Mike Espy) and to help raise the funds necessary to get the incubator started. Why? Because Ben eares what happens to Jackson, ‘When Parkway Properties pulled out of Mississippi and out of downtown, the incubator lost is primary funder and our location and we had no cheice but to fold it. Attimes fundraising was very difficult and Ben wanted to be sure he did everything possible to see itsueceed, So much so, that he personally wrote a $13,000 check to pay bills. Why? Ben Alllen cares about Jackson. Ben understands public trust and public scrutiny and public accountability, He understands he is accountable to a board and what his role is: make downtown Jackson al it can be as Mississippi capital city, I've seen him do that in his role as President of Downtown Jackson Partners. Pye seen first-hand how Ben does his personal business and how he conducts the business of the Downtown Jackson Partners. It is done with keen attention to integrity and honesty. Ow apital city, our tri-county area — indeed our state — have benefitted from three simple words: Ben Allen cares. Sincerely, Nick Walters17. PAMELA A. JOHNSON 114 Bent Creek Drive Brandon, MS 39047 Owner/President at Ableson Enterprises, LLCPAMELA A. JOHNSON 114 BENT CREEK DRIVE, BRANDON, MS 39047 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: This letter is to ask you to consider an order of probation for Mr. Ben Allen who was recently found guilty of ‘embezzlement in your court. | have known Ben since approximately 1977 when he entered my classroom in Mount Olive as an enthusiastic, ‘earnest, and fresh-faced yearbook representative. Asa young man, Ben was memorable in that he was so intent on treating his clients with respect, and he recognized and accommodated the urgency that comes with that particular type of publishing. There was never a call or request that he didn’t personally attend to, We always cheered up when Ben visited; his infectious laugh and genuine likeability were truly encouraging to all he touched, And, | knew his word. was his bond. If he sald something would be handled, it was. | “kept up with hiny” over the years - running into him In Jackson, hearing mutual acquaintances mention in him conversation. When Ben was elected to the Jackson City Council, it was a delight to see him in action again, energetically attending to his constituents’ needs, articulating a particular “common sense” approach to his role in city government, always smiling and moving. | was just someone who “knew him when.” ‘That changed when we showed up at the same Leadership Jackson orientation in 1998, There he was again — happy, kind, a breath of wholesome fresh air. That program has a way of creating siblings of the classmates, and that’s ‘what happened to our class. We learned from and about each other. We learned to depend on each other, and, we learned a whole lot about life in Jackson. | believe it changed Ben's outlook on how he could be the best leader he could be. | saw him tenderly considering the sad circumstances that many brave, poverty-stricken Jacksonians were striving so hard to overcome. He was affected in ways that, | believe, ultimately informed his effort to revitalize our Capital City through Downtown Jackson Partners. The very idea that he would be accused of doing anything illegal at all is completely contrary to the Ben Allen have known for so many years. Some people just are not wired to scheme and commit a crime; | believe that Ben is ‘one of those people. I can't imagine his ever trying to figure out a way to obtain something that wasn't his. While | recognize that he was indeed accused and is, n fact, convicted ofa crime, itis my humble request that you strongly consider allowing Ben to continue his service to the people of Jackson as someone on probation, rather than behind bars. ‘Thank you for your kind consideration in allowing those of us who know Ben Allen to approach you about his sentence. Respectfully,18. EMILY DAMIENS Downtown Jackson PartnersFebruary 24, 2017 Honorable Winston L. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Honorable Winston L. Kidd, | have worked alongside Ben for nearing seven years, although | have known him since | was thirteen. Through those years, | have seen every side of him - the good, the bad and the ugly. Ben's worst day doesn’t hold a candle to most people's best days. There is not one ounce of Ben that doesn’t strive to give his all no matter what the situation or circumstance, He cares deeply, listens openly and works tirelessly for any and everyone he meets. Ben is an amazing boss, but an even better husband to his wife, father to his two children and grandfather to his two grandchildren. | can’t begin to count the many of times | have heard, “it must be amazing to work for a man like Ben Allen,” and itis. Ben lives and breathes Jackson, i. He doesn’t do anything for praises; he does everything because it's his passion. He is Jackson's very own Rudy. ‘Many people think that Ben was given a privileged life, but that couldn't be further from the truth, Ben has worked hard for everything he has in life - his businesses, family, reputation - and, he’s proud of it, One day he casually told me a story about growing up in Vicksburg. His parents took him to an event, and they were offering free Coca-Colas, a drink his family couldn't afford. Ben was so excited at this luxury that he drank so many he physically became ill. My point of. this story isn't to show a gluttonous moment in his life, but to shine a light on his humble upbringing. Bea grew up just like everyone else. Everything he has is because of the hard work and dedication he put into It. You can’t ask Ben anything without seeing his face light up about it. His enthusiasm for life is infectious. Everyday he pushes me to try harder, breath deeper and give more. Very few people in the world won't give up when faced with adversity; Ben Allen is one those few. His focus is, steadfast, his character is unwavered and his heart is modest. Ben is not a good man; he is an exceptional man. The world would be such a better place if it were filled with more Ben Allens and I'ma better person for knowing him. Sincerely, Emily =.19, ROBERT LUCKETT, PhD 1400 John R. Lynch Street Post Office Box 17008 Jackson, MS 39217 Jackson State University Director, Margaret Walker Center Associate Professor, History Dept.JACKSON a STATE UNIVERSITY® [MARGARET WALKER CENTER February 28, 2017 sssonsiaeinverty "The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Kicatinacsaimoron Circuit Judge District 3 wesaisnmess 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Thave had the good fortune to know of Ben Allen for most of my life. Asa native Jacksonian, I have been aware of his keen love for this city, especially through his years on the city council, and deep commitment to making ita better place for all of us to live and to work. In my professional life over the past eight years at Jackson State, I have gotten to know Ben Allen and have witnessed not just his passion for the city and its people, but I have seen the fruits of his labor both through Downtown Jackson Partners, Team Jackson, various boards, and commissions. As the Chair of the Board of Leadership Greater Jackson, I turned to Ben this year as we are preparing to become an independent non-profit, evolving from our 30 year partnership with the Greater Jackson Chamber. Ben was an immediate help and asset in helping us think about the ways Leadership Greater Jackson can evolve and best serve this city. Iam glad to know that we have a leader like Ben Allen living and working, in and for Jackson. I have the utmost confidence in him and in honesty and character, and I hope you will take all of these things into account as part of your deliberations. Please do not hesitate to contact me if I can provide any further information or support. Sincerely, Vad fe dest Robert Luckett, PhD 1400 John R Lyacht. | PO. Box 17008 | Jackson, MS 39217 | 601.979.3935 | 601.979.5929 fax | jsumsedu/margaretwalkercenter20. JOSEPH and MARY ALICE ROGOSKEY 115 Blacksmith Lane Madison, VA 22727 Joseph Rogoskey — Retired FBI Special Agent Mary Alice Rogosky — Retired Elementary School Teacher‘Mr. and Mrs. Joseph G. Rogoskey 4116 Blacksmith Lane Madison, VA 22727 February 26, 2017 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205, Dear Honorable Judge Kidd, ‘We are writing to you on behalf of Ben Allen. By way of introduction, we have been married for over 36 years and have two daughlers, Sarah and Christine. Also, we have three grandchildren, including our youngest ‘grandson, Joseph Benjamin Allen. Joseph Rogoskey is a retired FEI Special Agent and Mary Alice Rogoskey is ‘a retired elementary schoo! teacher from Fairfax County, Virginia, each of us with many years of service to our ‘country and our community. We are devoted to our faith, family and nation, and we can say unequivocally that Ben Allen is devotedito these very same ideals. ‘Our daughter, Christine Rogoskey Allen, is martied to Ben's son, Dr. John Clayton Allen, We couldn't be more proud of our son-in-law, who is a loving, caring and faithful husband to Christine as well as an altentive and ‘amazing father to his son, Joseph. Itis clear to us that Clayton had a wonderful role model in his father, Ben. ‘No doubt, Ben taught his sons to value and honor marriage and family. At the same time, he showed them the discipline and reward of hard work as Clayton has dedicated his professional life as an oncologist to the care of cancer patients. We first met Ben in 2013 at the wedding of Christine and Clayton, and we were immediately impressed with his {generous character and gracious spirit. He is so welcoming and inclusive to all those he meets, and his warmth ‘and gregarious nature help everyone to feel at ease. Ben and his lovely wife, Susie, are such admirable parents to their sons, and the most loving and dedicated {grandparents to both Joseph and their granddaughter, Hartley. Their example of family love and fidelity is an asset to the community and important for all to see. We are confident thet Ben's principled nature and ethical character are obvious to acknowledge. We know Ben Allen to be a good and righteous man who is innocent of any criminal behavior, and we ask that you act justly on his behatt. Sincerely, Joseph and Mary Alice Rogoskey.21. WILLIAM R. “RANDY” JAMES 217 West Capitol Street Jackson, MS 39201 Past Chairman of the Greater Jackson Chamber PartnershipWilliam R. “Randy” James “Tacnson, miesiesiee1 39201 February 27, 2017 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Your Honor, | am wrting on behalf of Ben Allen and with the understanding that he will have his “sentencing hearing" next Monday, March 6, 2017. | have known Ben and consider him to be a close friend, Not only do | have respect for him as a friend, but | have had @ number of dealings with him involving the leadership with various boards and boards involving our community and city Ben has given so much to our community including being a Boy Scout Leader, Youth Coach, served several terms on the City Council and also a member of the same church as Paula and | attend, Christ United Methodist Church. Ben has given so ‘much to so many organizations and | don’t know of anyone who has provided more for our community. In my opinion, his honor and character is outstanding and much of that goes beyond what we see involving the business with this community. 1 know his wife and children very well and have the utmost respect for all that he does each and every day. ‘The charge that | understand that is before him at this time, involved a cellphone and | have been told that the cost had been fully reimbursed eighteen months before the indictment was delivered. This is again, only what Ihave been told. attended several of his meetings with the Downtown Jackson Partners when | was serving as the Chairman of the Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership and can attest to the upfront and positive way that he led the Downtown Jackson Partners. Ben has been through enough with this trial and 1 hope that he can put this behind him and resume his duties of providing great leadership and guidance for our city. i ‘rely, William R. “péndy” James wedilg22. EDWARD F. KENNEDY 1530 East County Line Road Ridgeland, MS 39157 DVM — Northeast Animal Hospital2parpoit The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Your Honor, {lam writing this letter in an effort to support Ben Allen in his sentencing hearing. | have known Ben for thirty five years. Without doubt Ben is @ man of integrity, courage, spirituality, patriotism, and love , especially for the City of Jackson. | don't know of anyone who has been ‘a bigger cheerleader for the City of Jackson than Ben Allen. My thirty seven year old son was @ Boy Scout in Ben Allen’s troop at First Baptist Jackson. Ben hhurtured that group of young men and saw toit that they did not give up on achieving their Eagle Scout Badge, a huge accomplishment that to this day sets young men apart from alot of their peers The average Eagle Scout in Ben's troop worked for four years to reach Ben's goal for ther. Ben never gave Lp on any of them and that troop set unbelievable records of achievement. Ben's determination was the engine that drove that troop. Ben Allen has taken stands thet have not always been popular with his constituents but he has never wavered in his convictions to make Jackson the best it can be. Downtown Partners could not have a better person representing them, Ben Allen isa good person , a person that Is trustworthy, a person that is fair and a person that | Edward F. Kenedy DVM Since 1978 | award 1530 Bast County Line Road + Ridgeland, MS 39157 + Tel, 601.986.2932 + Pax 601,956,2933 Kennedy, DVM23. JOSEPH Kk. SIMS 5305 Reddoch Drive Jackson, MS 39211 Has known Ben Allen for 47 yearsJoseph K, Sims 5305 Reddoch Dr. Jackson, MS. 39211 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS. 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: 1am writing to provide you with some information on Ben Allen, whom I have known for approximately forty-seven years. Ben Allen is someone I have admired greatly as a husband, father, son, businessman and a public servant. He has been a good friend to my family and me and has lived his life and conducted himself in the business world with the utmost integrity. His character is beyond reproach. Tcan assure you that my wife and I have always aspired to raise our children like the Allens and we were certainly influenced by their example. He was always very active in the lives of his two boys and their friends, coaching youth sports and serving in leadership roles at their school and Church. ‘Throughout his long and successful career in business and community setivites, he has always been respected by his peers, ‘A number of years ago when Ben ran for the City Council in Jackson, his friends and admirers readily pitched in to help as we knew he would do a good job and keep the City of Jackson's interests paramount in his service. He served with distinction as a Councilman while at the same time continuing to be actively engaged in his business endeavors. He was a true public servant becatise he made sacrifices and worked hard for his Ward and the City in trying to make Jackson a better place. ‘Thank you very much for your consideration of this letter and please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions or need more information. TS Joseph’24, ANTHONY WARREN 206 Briarwood Drive Jackson, MS 39206 Senior Staff Writer, Northside Sun‘Anthony Warren 206 Briarwood Drive Jackson, MS 39206 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 E, Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Judge Kidd: My name is Anthony Warren and | am writing to ask for leniency in the case of Mr. Ben Allen. Ihave known Mr, Allen and his family for nearly 10 years, and can attest to his and his family’s character and. love for the capital city. ‘As president of Downtown Jackson Partners, Mr. Allen has been one of Jackson's greatest cheerleaders, He has stood up for the city numerous times, even with others have put it down. He has been at the forefront of bringing new development to Downtown Jackson, and has met with numerous developers interested in investing here, ‘Mr. Allen has also advocated for Jackson on the state level, working with legislators to pass bills that benefit Jackson. He has also helped raise awareness among state lawmakers regarding the city’s ‘crumbling infrastructure. Right now, a law that would give Jackson an additional $11 million to $22 million a year for roads, water and sewer is making its way through the Senate now. Ifit passes, Mr. Allen will be one of many individuals to thank. |n addition to his work with Downtown Jackson Partners, Mr. Allen has been involved in is church and ‘with the Boy Scouts of America. He also has served on numerous boards, including three terms as a member of the Jackson City Council. ‘Mr. Allen Is seeking leniency, and | am asking for this on his behalf as well, Please set aside the charges against Mr. Allen, and allow him to continue to serve the city and community he loves. e, AS firw) a ANex anthony Warren Senior Staff Writer, Northside Sun25. CHARLIE CHANDLER Vice President — Marketing BancorpSouth Insurance Services Gulfport, MississippiBancorpSouth* Insurance Services, Inc. February 27", 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Honorable Judge Kidd, ‘My name is Charlie Chandler and I'm a local business man with BancorpSouth Insurance Services in Hinds County. | have known Ben Allen since 1998 when his son and | were roommates incollege. Mr. Ben, 2 | call him, has been a great mentor and role model to me since | moved to Jackson over 13 years ‘ago. He helped me get involved in the Jackson business community and with groups like the Downtown Jackson Rotary Club. He isa big reason | have stayed In Jackson the 13 years have lived in Jackson and his positive outlook and leadership have given me hope for our City of Jackson. | have found Mr. Ben to be one of the mest Honest, Caring, Loyal, and Respected gentlemen | know. He is an asset to our city and state and we need more men like him in my opinion. | hope this letter finds you well and helps you see the kind of man he I. Kindest Regards, ane Charlie Chandler Vice President ~Marketing BancorpSouth Insurance Services . Stewart Sneed Hewes £2009 3th Street, 4th Floor + Gulfport, MS 90501 « Phone (228) 883-5362 » Toll Free (B00) 386-8083 + Fax (228 869-1957 + wavw.bxsl.com ‘ay St, Louis, MS + Bilow, MS + Guilpon,, MS + Hattiesburg, MS + Jackson, MS « Moss Point, MS + Pascagoula, MS * Tupelo, MS26. MATTHEW W. ALLEN Ben Allen’s son)? Marie We ALES The ant ing, Sa 100 Pot One Dawe 119 1D 190 Fast Capita Ste Sesto, isi 39208 {aut amalerainisom Jacke, Msg 39201 ATTORNEYS AT LAW Dist: 601 9T3ATIS Telephone: 601 918,310 Frese: 601.960.0502 February 27, 2017 Honorable Winston L.. Kidd Hinds County Circuit Court Judge 407 East Pascagoula Strect Jackson, MS. 39205 RE: State of Mississippi v. Benjamin I, Alten, 11 Dear Judge Kidd: I write this letter in support of Ben Allen as a fellow citizen, a lawyer for well over a decade, and his oldest son. It is difficult to know precisely where to begin. siate confidently at the outset that | believe him to have been an upstanding, contributing member of society and in a very meaningful sense, and that our community has been and is a better place for his having been in it, I'l further state confidently that I believe his actual innocence, which further underscores what would be the true tragedy and incre injustice of sentencing him to even a day in prison. I also believe that Miss. Code Ann. § 97-11 25 does not eves apply to him because Downtown Jackson Partners oversees private money, and therefore, any sentencing of time to prison for an alleged violation of an inapplicable statute would be unconstitutional. | say that respectfully, but that is what I believe to be the case. 1 will My father, who I will simply refer to as Ben for purposes of this letter, has been the type of loving, active, caring father that most children are not fortunate enough to have. I am very grateful for the role he has played in my life. He had a very busy professional life as my younger brother and [ grew up in Jackson, but somehow found the time to be aetive in our lives. He was a Sunday School teacher, He was a soccer coach, He ran the press: box for my high school baseball team, He was a Scoutmaster at Troop 8, First Baptist Chureh Jackson, where, with his guidance, both my brother and | eventually obtained the rank of Eagle Scout, In his capacity as Scoutmaster, he counseled countless youth from Jackson in helping them become productive members of society. I cannot think offhand of any of those young men who have not gone on to productive careers as doctors, lawyers, businessmen, and the like, and they number in the hundreds, He led weekend campouts in Mississippi once a month; hiking, trips at Philmont Ranch in New Mexico; scuba diving trips at Scout Sea Base in the Florida Keys; and canoeing in Minnesota, Outside of Seouts, he, along with « handful of other fathers, regularly took groups of our peers on outdoor trips for hunting, fishing, and hiking, always going out of his way to make those whose fathers could not attend feel weleome and comfortable: When time eame for our senior tip to Florida after graduation from high school, it was my fatherHonorable Winston L.. February 27, 2017 Page 2 answered and a friend’s father who answered the call to attend and oversee the trip. He always calls to duty like that, He still does. Ben stressed education for my brother and me. Clayton, my younger brother, attended Ole Miss and briefly thought of a legal career and attended Columbia Law School for a year before deciding to turn to medicine, Ben fully supported Clayton in that transition that was, at the time, a difficult move. Clayton went on to graduate medical school from UMMC, did hi residency in internal medicine at the University of Vinginia Medical Center, where he was the Chie Resident for a year, and this summer finishes his fellowship in hematology/oncology at Vanderbilt University’ Meclical Center. He has aeeepted a job in Mississippi, and will begin work in Hattiesburg teating patients with eaneer beginning this summer. It is impossible to predict how many countless lives in Mississippi Clayton will impact in his profession. Ben's fathering made that possible, He was there for me, too, supporting and encouraging me through Mississippi State University for undergraduate school, Millsaps College for a master of business administration, and ‘The University of Texas School of Law for my law degree, 1am now a partner at the Brunini Law Firm in Jackson, where I have been since 2005, and a resident of Jackson, As with Clayton, Ben's fathering made that possible Ben has been incredibly generous with his time and money in supporting others in the community in times of need. Incredibly generous, and in ways that you would not read about in the paper and would not eam Ben any titles or “points.” I'm talking about selfless generosity with no expectation of personal ret David school baseball team who came from from South Africa, Ben was a play baseball at Belhaven College ander and Reneir Stingley come to mind, Both exchange students on my high icult. backyrounds, from Sweden and Reneir st, finan or otherwise. David went on to ormed wy. He has since moved back home to Sweden where he isa businessman and father of seven wonderful children. Reneit went on to play baseball at Jackson State University, and he has remained in the Jackson ‘area where he manages a MeAllister’s restaurant. Derrick Greer also comes to mind, Derrick grew up outside of Lexington, Mississippi. He didn’t have much financially. He was very poor, in fact, His mother sometimes worked at our nearby deer camp. On numerous occasions Ben invited Derick to Jackson to stay at our house. He would take Derrick to our high school baseball games andl teach Derrick about how to run the press box. Derrick was a good, smart kid from a very rough background, and Ben was making & concerted effort ‘0 provide him some direction. That really stuck with me, He even attempted to have Dertick enroll in The Piney Woods School, but never could convince Derrick’s mother. “These are just some examples among many I have witnessed. You will hear from others about Ben’s role as city councilman and some of his more publicly known activities, but I wanted you to get a sense of some of the private things he has done along the way. These are not an exhaustive list by any means, but it will give you an idea, | believe they speak to the absence of'a need for Ben to serve time in prison, onssort7Honorable Winsion L.. Kidd February 27, 2017 Page 3 also believe the evidence produced at trial did not support a conviction on Count IV, the cell phone, and further militates against sentencing Ben to time in prison, Robert Gibbs’ testimony that Ben repaid Susie Allen’s portion of the cell phone bill was never contradicted swith evidence, Never, No one ~ no one except the prosecution with argument before the jury, not testimony ~ contradicted Gibbs. As we know, a lawyer's argument without the benefit of evidence to support it is not legally sufficient to prove an element ofa crime, nally, respectfully 1 believe an elephant in the room still stands, in that the question of Jaw of whether this is public money or private money has not been addressed by the Court, The jury implicitly ryjected the argument that the funds are public finds beeause it found Ben not ‘guilty on nine counts, and the prosceution argued that if the funds are public funds, he is guilty on all ten, But Count 4 remains, and the question of law still stands. | believe legal authority’ supports the argument that DP funds are private dollars, andl if that is so, then Seciion 97-11-25, the code seetion under whieh the jury, incorrectly I believe, found Ben guilty does aot apply. IFit does not apply, he cannot be convicted for an alleged crime under it, and it would be “unconstitutional for him (o serve time in prison for an alleged violation of And therein would lie the tavesty of travesties if he were sentenced to time in prison. enced when he did no wrong, and sentenced under a statute that does not apply. #1 When others ran, He Ben is a good man, He has been a loyal fan and supporter of Jacl crved any of this, and does not deserve time in prison. never des All of the above is submitied with the utmost respect for the Court, and 1 thank you for your time and consideration ofthis letter and matter sincerely, Matthew W. Allen MWAMlh eagsorst27. LOGAN BURCH PHILLIPS, II 4427 Deercreek Drive Jackson, MS 39211 Family Friend for Over 30 YearsLOGAN B. PHILLIPS III 4427 DEERCREEK DRIVE JACKSON, MS 39211 February 24, 2017 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Ihave known Mr. Allen and his family for over 30 years, I have literally grown up around his family as | was good friends with his son, Clayton Allen. | played sports and went through Boy Scouts with his boys. During this time Mr. Allen has been my scout master, mentor, and family friend, I have always known him to be of the highest character. What | have always admired about Mr. Allen is his enthusiasm. Whether it’s cheering on his Bulldogs, being a Boy Scout master, a city councilman, and now a grandfather, he’s comes at everything with a lot of energy and passion, He has always thrived in a leading role and will not back down froma challenge. This is the type of man we want leading our city and a role model to our kids. | can’t imagine what his family is going through but | can assure this is a good man with a big heart for this family and community. | hope that you will see it in your heart to drop all charges against Mr. Allen. Sincerely, Lage 8 ie ps5 Logan Burch Phillips III28. ROBERT MARKWOOD FIELDS KIT FIELDS 200 Agency Burn Ridgeland, MS 39157 President, Woodmark Investments, LLC Jackson, MississippiROBERT MARKWOOD FIELDS ‘The Hononble Judge Winston Kidd February 26,2017 Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 ‘Your honor: We ace weiting in support of Ben Allen. Kit has known Ben for 45 years, and Ben and I have ‘been fiends and acquaintances for over 25 years! Kit and Ben were cheerleaders together at Mississippi State. In hee words, “We could always count on Ben. He was hard working and loyal to both school and friends. Cectanly, there ‘were opportunites to take advantage of the privileges afforded us in our roles of responsibility at Mississippi State University: But, Ben always toed the line, and certainly never breached the teust or responsibilities vested in us. Not even a hint” have had the distinct honor of getting to know Ben well as we served (and continue to serve) ‘our community, state and the world through our membership and leadership in the Rotary Club of Jackson. Ben's participation and leadership in Rotary’s service projects and foundation giving earned him unparalleled respect from the 300+ member civic club - to the excent that hhe was elected and served as the club’s President and as Director. His leadership and service ‘were and continue to be admirable. have great respect for Ben's service as President of Downtown Jackson Partners (DJP). Ben's heat and soul ace devoted to betterment of the City of Jackson, stacting with the downtown, area, Tam cectain that Ben has business and carcer opportunities whose financial rewards far ‘exceed those of his position at DJP, but his devotion has been unswerving, Lastly, we know Ben to be a wonderfully loving and active family man with a 40+ year marriage to adelightful and supportive With all due esteem, we respectfully request and plead that any leniency allowed under the law be provided to this wonderful, exemplary citizen of our state, Ben Allen, lease feel free to contact us if we can provide additional information, Sincerely i ds Eile h/t Peds Mark and Kit Fields 200 Agency Burn, Ridgeland, Mississippi 39157 601-918-2704 / ‘ieldeS@pmailcom” President, Woodmark Investments, LLC ‘10 South President Street, 2nd Floor Jackson, Mississippi 29201 Scanned by CamScanner29. CHRISTINE ROGOSKEY ALLEN 204 Wauford Drive Nashville, TN 37211 Ben Allen’s Daughter-In-LawChristine Rogoskey Allen 204 Wauford Drive Nashville, TN 37211 February 25, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Circuit Judge District 3 407 Kast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd: Tam writing this letter in support of my father-in-law, Ben Allen. I have known Ben for six ‘years and have been lucky enough to be his daughter in law for almost four years, To be part of the Allen family is to be truly blessed, From the moment I met Ben, he has welcomed me with arms wide open. His warmth and kindness were apparent from the start and his happiness for his son, Clayton, and me was truly heart warming. In the six years that I have known Ben, it has become very obvious to me that this is a man who loves God, his family, and the state of Mississippi-particularly Jackson. Ben is an example of what it means to be a true Christian, He truly walks the walk, He is generous with both his time and his money. He has helped both friends and family in times of financial and emotional hardships, never looking for anything in return, Recently when my family and I were visiting Jackson, I learned that Ben was spending countless hours with a friend whose spouse was dying of cancer. He was late coming home from work and I assumed that he ‘was just staying late to get some work done but he was actually visiting his friend in the hospital to offer support during a time of great need. He took time out of his week every week to do just this, When my extended family has faced hard times, Ben always asks me how they are doing and if he can do anything to help. Through Clayton and Clayton's friends, I have heard numerous stories of Ben helping different people in the community. He does these things because he is a good man who has a true servant’s heart, Ben always says the blessing for our family before we eat a meal together, and I remember one time in particular him saying, “May all that we do bring praise and glory to your name.” This had an impact on me at the time and now I realize that this is exactly how Ben lives his life, Ben's love for his family is immeasurable. All you need to do is walk in his home to see this. It is filled with pictures of his children and grandchildren. His phone screen for as long as I can remember has been a funny picture of my son with a “boo boo” on his nose. His love for Susie and Matt and Clayton is beautiful to witness. He still refers to his wife of 41 years as “my bride” and his face literally lights up when telling old stories of going on camping trips and to baseballgames with his sons, My husband has countless stories of fun things that he did with his dad and his hope for doing those things with our son one day. Whenever I hear these stories, I can’t help but think what a wonderful childhood and life Ben has provided for his children. Now, he has extended that love to me and to my son, Joseph. I knew that he and Susie would love their grandchild, but I could never have imagined just how much, Ben beams with pride when talking about Joseph and he ean never say enough how much he has loved being a grandfather. He can’t ‘wait until my son is old enough to take him on fishing trips and Clayton and I can’t wait for them to experience that together. Ben and Susie have helped Clayton and me more times than I can remember at the drop of a hat, We truly know that we are never without help if needed as long as they are in our ives. Most recently when I thanked Ben for his help he simply said, “This is ‘what you do for your kids.” That's just the kind of man he is. He desires to help others without even thinking twice about it. Thave often told Susie that I am so thankful to her and Ben for raising my husband to be such a ‘good man. A man that loves God and his family, a man that is kind and does the right thing, a ‘man that ean be depended upon and a man who wants to be remembered for being a good person and for what he did for others. My husband is the man he is today in very large paut because of Ben Allen who is an example of so much of what it means fo be a good man, I am so thankful to have him in my life Ben also has a deep love for the state of Mississippi, He fondly remembers growing up in Vicksburg and his time at Mississippi State and he traly enjoys sharing his vast knowledge of the history of the stale, He has put this love into action as he has devoted so much of his time to making Jackson a better city. He frequently works long hours and receives cals late at night ‘when someone in the city needs help. I have never once heard him complain about this. Ben did not need to work at Downtown Jackson Partners, he wanted to. He wanted to use his time and his skills to make Jackson a better city for its residents. He desires to make things better for those around him, whether itis his family or a stranger on the street. ‘There is no doubt in my mind that Ben did not commit any crime while working as the President of DJP. Itis simply not in his nature to do the wrong thing, And so Task you to allow this good man to continue to be with the family that he adores. I ask you to do the right and just thing for a man that has lived his life doing what is right and just.Sincerely, Gatton, allen. Christine Rogoskey Allen30. JOHN GOMEZ Colleague — Downtown Jackson PartnersFebruary 27, 2017 Honorable Winston L. Kidd Cirouit Court Judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, Tam writing on behalf of my friend and colleague Ben Allen. I have worked with Ben for the last 10 years at Downtown Jackson Partners and have gotten to know him not only professionally but ‘more importantly on a personal level, Ben has helped guide me in my career and has been a role model in how to conduct myself as a good husband and father. Thave been made aware that Ben’s sentencing will be on March 6" | am well aware of the 10 counts Ben was charged with and the one count he was convicted of. I worked with Downtown Jackson Partners Board Attorney Robert Gibbs in reviewing any relevant documents related to the charges brought against Ben to determine if there was any truth to the indictment. I am thoroughly convinced Ben is innocent of all the charges. Working with Ben for so many years, Ihave seen how cating Ben is. On numerous oecasions, he has asked me how my wife and kids were doing. When I have boasted about my boys playing soccer, Ben has told me a number of times that this is one of the best times in my life. He recalled how he enjoyed watching his sons play little league baseball and ree soccer and seeing them grow from little boys to men is something he will always treasure, Ben is also an extremely thoughtful person, Tle made sure to know the names of all the regular guards in our building and revealed to me that Centry who had worked in private security for over 20 years was retiving earlier this year. Ben made it a point to focus on little things like that, Normally, I would be explaining to you that Ben regrets his actions, but in this case, [ cannot, As have said before, I believe Ben is innocent of all the charges he was indicted of. I believe the City of Jackson is worse off due to his conviction. Ben works tirelessly to improve Downtown and the city that he loves. The world would be better off if we had more caring, thoughtful and passionate people like Ben Allen, a Phe Gomez31. JOHN CLAYTON ALLEN, MD 204 Wauford Drive Nashville, TN 37211 Ben Allen’s SonJohn Clayton Allen, MD 204 Wauford Drive Nashville, TN 37211 February 24, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd: L write today in support of my dad, Ben Allen. For as long as I can remember, he has been the best man I have ever known, There is simply no way on earth that I can put into words what he means to me and to all of us blessed enough to have him in our lives, but I will do my best. ‘To start, he is such a kind, honest, and generous man. He has always helped out those in need, and when he does he never asks for anything in return nor does he ever publicize his generosity. In fact, I only know about most of his acts of kindness because some of those he has helped have Jet me know, I am certain there are many things he has done for others that I do not know about, but even still I could fill up pages with stories about the people he has helped with his generosity. I will give a few examples. At our high school there were two foreign exchange students, David from Sweden and Renicr from South Africa. They came to this country without any friends or family or really any money. My dad saw their struggles and immediately helped them. He invited them to our house for dinner, bought them clothes, bought them sporting equipment so they could play baseball, and ceven invited them fo come on family trips with us, He helped them both find colleges to attend, But even more than any of that, he gave them a sense of family away from home and a father figure they could depend on, Even after high school, he remained in their lives. I know my dad and David still keep in touch, and David is now in the ministry. Another example is my aunt who has long battled financial trouble and trouble in her personal life, She has never had to fight that battle alone as time and time again my father has done whatever necessary to ensure she has the help she needs. There was also a woman named Dorothy and her boy, Derrick, who we met where we used hunt in Lexington, MS. His family \vas crippled by poverty, so my dad helped raise money to build them a new house at no cost to them whatsoever.His generosity extends into his friendships. Recently I attended a cancer fundraiser where an old friend from high school came up to me and asked if I could speak with her. Her mother was slowly dying of brain cancer and was at home on hospice, her physical and mental abilities ‘fading, She told me how heartbreaking and earth shattering this was for her dad, then went on to tell me that she thanked God for my dad because of the kindness he had shown to her father. 1 found out that day that my dad had reserved one night weekly to wipe everything off his schedule and to go to their house and spend the evening with him, He would bring a couple of steaks to cook and more than that, he would just spend time with someone in need oF friendship and in need of someone to talk to, His kindness literally brought my friend to tears as she told ‘me. And he did all of this all of this while going through his own personal struggles with his, indictment and impending trial. I could continue on about his kindness and generosity, but I will not belabor the point, His involvement in the community is well known. He gave up a large portion of a very successful business to be on the city council because he desired to make Jackson a better place, He has stayed involved for that same reason. As thousands of people have left the city to move to mote affluent areas with less crime, he has declined. As thousands of people refuse to get involved but instead find comfort in their cozy lifestyles, he has insisted on involvement. He does this not because he needs to but because he loves Jackson and wants to make ita better place for all of its citizens, [ would also like to talk a moment about my dad as a husband of 41 years to my beautiful mother, In an age of broken up families and failed commitments, their love for and commitment to each other is rock solid. Their marriage is the foundation of this family, and after 41 years of navigating through the ups and downs of life together, their love for each other is stronger today than ever. They have lived honest and just lives, and they deserve to live the rest of their lives with each other, raising grandkids, continuing to teach me and Matt how to grow as people, and walking hand in hand until God calls them home. They deserve that. My dad deserves that, as all innocent and good men do, Allow me to finisk by telling you what he has done for me. He was always very involved in my childhood. Despite being incredibly busy while starting his own business, he always found time to spend with me and my brother Matt. He helped coach our soccer teams and was the troopmaster of our boy scout troop for years (meaning he would spend one weekend « month on ‘campouts with over 50 youths teaching us valuable skills about life and the importance of living with principles). And while 1 could write you a list of countless examples of his involvement, Ithink more important is what he means to me, because I think only that can truly give you a sense of who he is asa person. Tam certainly a flawed man, just as much as any, but whatever sense of goodness, justice, and godliness I have in me I have because of the grace of God, and because of my dad and mom. ‘And whatever success I have found in life would not have happened without my mom and dad. My dad has shown me what itis to be a loving husband, He has shown me what it isto be a Joving father. I have a lifetime of memories filled with his kindness, direction, and love. When my heart has beer. broken, he has hugged me. When I needed sternness, he has provided it, When. 1 have been lost, he has guided me back to the right path, Thave a wife that I treasure and we have a 2-year-old gon that means more to us then anything in the world. I feel about them the way my dad feels about me and my mom. Whatever positive traits I have as a husband and father come fiom parents, and how blessed I am for their example, ‘The thought of my son having to grow up without his granddad is a thought that is more than I can bear. On the night of February 7, 2017, my wife and I sat by the computer in anticipation of the verdict, and as we waited I broke down and cried like a have not eried in many years, overwhelmed at what this world can do to a good and innocent man, and terrified. Tervfied of life without him. Terrified my son would not get to really know my father, or that he would only know him as a maa in prison. Terrified my son would never learn the lessons from my dad that I have, And still today I have this fear, and the idea that this good man may go away and be taken from our family unjustly absolutely breaks my heart, ‘One day, when my son looks back on his life and reflects on me, | hope and pray Lam a good cnough man that he feels even half of the love and appreciation I have for my dad, Because even if he feels only half what I do, I would consider being even half of my dad the greatest of honors. {can only hope that my letter gives you some glimpse of the type of man he is. I know beyond all doubt that he is innocent of the erimes he was charged of and the crime he was convicted of, but he is much more than that. He isa truly good man with a good heart and a pure scul. I implore you to do what is right and just by him. Sincerely, poh Cbg lle 2/24 117 John Clayton Aller32. BOB WILSON Post Office Box 12367 Jackson, MS 39236 Executive Director — Associates General Contractors of MississippiFebruary 27, 2017 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Ihave known Ben Allen for over 40 years and he is as passionate, caring and supportive of his family, friends and business associates as he is of the city of Jackson and the state of Mississippi. Iirst met Ben at Mississippi State University. We were students and fraternity brothers together and | was always amazed at how energetic and positive Ben was. He was and ig a natural born leader. His feelings for those he was around and engaged with was genuine. Although | doubt that he realized it, everyone he met became long term fiends and relished the opportunity to be around him. He met the love of his life at Mississippi State and their life together defines what family is all about. His children embody the cheracteristics of Ben and Susie and what an unbelievable gift to them, their families and their communities. ‘After school, Ben built a terrific business by doing what he does best - genuinely caring about his clients. It was never about “sales, it was about creating friendships and providing what his "friends" wanted most. Ben was the perfect person to enter into ‘community service and he did it with the same amount of gusto, honesty and passion that he exhibited in his service to his family and his clients. This community and state has benefited greatly from the skills and talent that Ben brings to the table - every day, every hour and every minute. |, along with everyone in this community, should be grateful that people like Ben exist. ‘Watching Ben in the public eye was inspiring and I never thought | would have the opportunity to work hand and hand with my friend and hero. | worked with Mississippi Main Street fora good part of my professional career. | was working with Main Street when Ben joined Downtown Jackson Partners(DJP). Downtown Jackson Partners focused on revitalizing their downtown district. Mississippi Main Street did the same thing throughout the state as a program of the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Mississippi Development Authority, Main Street and DJP was in discussions about locating to a common location so we could take advantage of resources: and talents for the betterment of communities throughout our state when John Lawrence, Ben's predecessor, resigned to pursue an opportunity in Memphis. When the DUP Board offered that position to Ben, | truly thought it was divine intervention. Main Street and DUP shared office space for over 10 years in downtown Jackson. it was a joy to come to work each day. The city of Jackson along with the slate of Mississippi benefited greatly from the sharing and relationships generated in that office. My staff was very good and worked together so well. Once DJP joined that equation,my staff took ona new look and passion. | attribute that to Bon. Just his presence and commitment to people brought our staff and achievements to the next level. Every day | watched Ben deal with existing businesses in downtown Jackson, prospecting new ones, sharing information and expertise with owners and developers and trying to work with what seemed like a never ending dysfunctional city government. Although there were many who failed to take advantage of Ben's talent and passion, the city of Jackson and this state enjoyed his desire to do his best for his hometown and state everyday he came to work. | leamed so much watching Ben go through his day, leading his staff and dealing with the trials and tribulations of city government. | never finished my day without a true admiration for how Ben conducted his work life and his home life and my work life and home life benefited greatly from watching and working with Ben. This whole situation driven by a disgruntled employee and a misguided city servant has been a travesty. Not just for Ben and family, but for our entire community. It has to stop. It is my desire to see more talented and driven public servants prevail and right the wrong that has been committed against Ben, his family and the Board of Downtown Jackson Partners. The fate of this city hangs in the decisions that will be made in your court. Please do the right thing. Respectfully submitted, Bob Wilsof/Executive Director Associated General Contractors of Mississippi PO Box 12367 Jackson, MS 39236 601-842-007833. RUSSELL MORRISON 4125 Roxbury Road Jackson, MS 39211 Worked with Ben Allen at Team JXNRussell Morrison 4125 Roxbury Road Jackson, MS 3921: February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Jucge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 Cast Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Honorable Judge Kidd, ‘The intent of this letter is to describe my experience and relationship with Ben Allen. I met Ben when ‘working on a research project to determine the cost savings associated with moving the Department of Revenue into The Landmark building downtown. The first thing that stands out about Ben s his passion for Jackson, which was so contagious | sought him out to learn more about what was goingon ‘downtown and how | could help, Ben introduced me to Team JXN, a program he spearheaded to provide ‘people interested in supporting Jackson an opportunity to get involved. He encouraged me to join a committee at Team JXN. | did, and this was where | really got to know Ben. One of the things ladmire about Ben is his willingness to lead the charge, to take a others to work together to improve our State's Capital. It is an extremely dificult task which requires strong leadership to build momentum and get things accomplished. In the face of challenges, Ben never loses enthusiasm or optimism, which illustrates the size of his heart. From my experience working wit Ben and watching him put so much of himself into bettering our community, a feeling that always comes ‘over me is gratitude. | am personally thankful for Ben’s leadership and his efforts to make the place we all live better, He’sa man of good character willing to dedicate himself to the service of others, and | will always admire him for that. He is strong leader, a noble citizen, and a dear friend. Sincerely, Russell Morrison34. RONALD W. TEW, JR. 130 Riverview Drive, Suite E Flowood, MS 39232 CPA / Tew & CompanyTEW & COMPANY Aine ‘ean aed Pae Actas 10 Riesee ve Sue Fowl S32 Gnas a ness ald WTS ooh Bar Bala eae: erin Intieot Ciel aie estas Misi Sosa nts Pie ‘ronlas February 27, 2017 The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: 11am writing this letter to you in support of Ben Allen, lam a certified public accountant that has been working with small businesses in the Jackson area for over 35 years now. Ben has been a client of mine for about twenty years. I have prepared his personal income tax returns, and my firm has performed bookkeeping and accounting functions for his businesses as well In my years working with hundreds of small businesses, | have noticed distinct differences in attitude of clients regarding how | should go about my job of preparing their income tax returns, Some are quite timid to the point that | have to convince them to take perfectly legitimate deductions. Others want me to bend every rule and do everything possible to lower thelr taxes short of actual fraud. These two personalities are the extremes. The vast majority of people, Including Ben Allen, fall into the category of wanting me to prepare their returns as accurately as possible. They don’t want to take aggressive positions, yet want every legal deduction taken on their returns, | bring Up these personalities only to say that | believe people's attitude toward the IRS reflects on how they deal with all other areas of their lives. If someone is willing to cheat the IRS, | believe that same individual would be willing to cheat in general. In the twenty years | have spent working with Ben, I have never, ever, gotten the feeling that he wanted to be aggressive on his taxes, or on anything else, Over the years, | have watched him handle himself and his businesses in a professional forthright manner. | have never seen him do anything that might harm the fine reputation that he has worked so hard to attain,The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Page 2 One thing that has always impressed me about Ben Is his positive attitude and genuine concern for the City of Jackson, He lives in Jackson. As far as can remember, his businesses have always been located in the City of Jackson. He served on the City Council of Jackson. With my knowledge of his personal income, | can confidently say he didn’t serve on the City Council for the extra money. He did it to serve the City. | also never saw any evidence that he had any ulterior motives like so many of our politicians seem to today. Finally, | believe he took the job with Downtown Jackson Partners out of a real concern for the future of Jackson. Even though many people, including myself, moved their business from Jackson, Ben did not and | applaud him for that. thriving and healthy Jackson is good for everybody. As | stated above, Ihave extensive experience in working with small businesses. All small companies face common problems and issues. One of these inherent problems is the lack of resources to'spend on accounting, bookkeeping and recordkeeping. Large companies have the luxury of having full ime accountants on staff along with various internal control procedures in place, Small businesses Invariably have to rely on one or two people to run everything. They are also forced to rely on their independent accountant to clean things up at the end of the year. ‘Small companies are also plagued with having to account for expenses that inherently have business and personal components to them. Cell phones and vehicles are prime examples. Cell phone carriers give various incentives to having entire families’ cell phones on the same bill, Many times one phone ts business while the others may be personal. Business people commonly have to use their personal cars for business purposes. Company owned cars Invariably have at least some personal use involved. In an ideal world, the business owner would have two separate phone bills, even though that may very well be more expensive. In theory, company owned cars should only be driven after the driver has already driven to work in his or her own personal vehicle, Again, this is obviously more expensive to both the employee and company as well: In the real world, people are forced to do things that the accountants may not like, but are necessary to get things done. ‘At year end, the outside accountant for an organization will typically work on accounting for these items, He scans the company’s books. He also makes inquirles as to personal expenses paid out of the business as well as business expenses paid using personal funds. The accountant primarily does this to make sure the company’s income tax returns are prepared correctly. Many times, the small business client will have more than one owner. In that case,The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Page 3 the accountant may also be responsible for ensuring that all the owners know what is going on in the business regarding expenses that have personal as well as business aspects to them. How these items are accounted for affects the tax returns. The accountant will insist that the personal use items be either paid back to the company, or in some cases report the personal use as additional income to the employee. The typical small business comes to rely on the accountant to account for these relatively immaterial items because the company itself lacks the resources and/or ability to account for these items o own. Cell phones and automobiles are just two common examples. There are other examples. Many times an employee may need its employer's assistance in obtaining products and/cr services ‘that are personal ini nature with the understanding that they will reimburse the company. Having a spouse and/or children on an employee's health insurance policy is a common item. It ‘would obviously be less paper work for the company if it just forced its employee to go get a separate health insurance policy. Another example might be that an employee would like to purchase something in the company’s name because it would allow the employee to get a discount or other benefit not otherwise avallable, 1am aware that BKD, a national accounting firm with offices in Jackson established to attorney Robert Bibbs and Board of Directors for Downtown Jackson Partners (DIP) that Ben Allen reimbursed DIP for his wife’s phone charges, as was his habit and practice. As | stated earlier, having a personal cell phone line on the same phone bill as the business line is not unusual, | think under the circumstances, Ben acted appropriately. The Executive Committee for the Board of Directors was aware of the personal amounts on the cell phone bill. Ben did not appear to try to hide anything. | don’t see any intent to deceive or get way with something. Ben acted as any overworked professional would in a small office setting. With little to no bookkeeping resources to draw on, he did the best he could. Small business owners and directors of non-profit and/or quasi-governmental agencles regularly fall into the habit of relying on the outside accountant to remind them of the details‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Page 4 Looking at it from the big picture, Ben made complete reimbursement payments for his wife's cell phone. The accountants for DIP agreed that the bill was paid in full as of August 2014. The whole affair seems to me like normal activities for a small office or business. A small expense ‘was run through the business with everyone’s knowledge and the expectation that it would be ald back, The small monthly amount of the bill did not seem to necessitate a monthly reimbursement schedule. The intent and actual practice followed was to settle up at some point In the future. This Is not unusual and is not evidence of wrong doing. Ben Allen is not a criminal, | have worked with him for many years and have never suspected that Ben wanted to do anything other than what is right. | wish | could say that for all of my clients. He may or not have been the best bookkeeper, but his actions were not consistent with someone wanting to steal. Over the years, | and my co-workers have caught various individuals actually stealing money. In every case, active measures were taken in an attempt to hide or disguise their actions. Some were cleverer than others, However, each time, there was obvious intent to do something wrong, a conscious decision to do it, the actual theft, and a subsequent action consisting of some attempt to conceal It. | see none of thishere. There is definitely no obvious intent to embezzle; | don’t see a definite decision to commit malfeasance, I don’t see an actual theft, the money was paid back. Finally, | see no evidence whatsoever of an attempt to conceal anything. | just pray that the Court recognizes the difference in actual theft versus someone at worst having to be reminded to do something that he had done willingly of his own accord In the past. | conclude this letter with my assurances as a friend of Ben Allen and a fellow businessman that there is not a dishonest bone in the man’s body. As a certified public accountant, with extensive experience with this type of client, | state as clearly as I can that | see no evidence of wrongdoing. Furthermore, | would be happy to state as much under oath. Finally, lam at your disposal should any further explanations be helpful to the Court. You may reach me at my office number shown on my letterhead, or my cell phone at 601-832-3838,The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Page 5 ‘Thank you for your time in reading this lengthy letter. Yours truly, ‘Tew & Company, PA ‘Craw Fieieh Ronald W. Tew, Jr., CPA Cc: Ben Allen Merrida Coxwell35. JOHN W. MCGOWAN 1837 Crane Ridge Drive * Post Office Box 55609 Jackson, MS 39296-5809JOHN W. VICGOWAN Geologist 1897 CRANE RIDGE OFVE 1.0, 0 #5000 TELEPHONE Ac eonoaatae {IMCKSON,MISI8SPP 367002800 PACA eo1nae879 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Ihave known my friend, Ben Allen, for many years. He is a genuinely good and honest man, He loves Jackson and has worked tirelessly to make the city he loves even better. He could not possibly have violated the trust of his many friends in our community. | pray that you will agree that the evidence proves Ben to be innocent. Sincerely, Soke W WheAStruan John W McGowan JWMelapt Kidd 022736. WANDA COLLIER-WILSON 111 E. Capitol Street, Suite 102 Jackson, MS 39201 President/CEO of Visit JacksonVISIT February 27, 2017 LAG OK: ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Re: Sentencing hearing of Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd: | am writing to you today on behalf of Ben Allen, whom { have known for more than 25 years in my positions with the City of Jackson. I had the privilege to meet him when he served as a City Councilman and always appreciated his sincere interest and assistance in building the tourism product for Jackson. ‘As a Councilman, Ben was instrumental in the continuing authorization of my agency, the Jackson Convention & Visitors Bureau now known as Visit Jackson. His support of tourism development never wavered over the years, ‘even when he did not personally agree with decisions made by administrations, He understood the bigger picture of progress and working together to accomplish the goal of positioning Jackson as a tourist destination. Ben has always been a proponent for the betterment of Jackson and provided a sound, reliable voice of reasoning during intense discussion of items presented to the Council for passage. When Ben was hired as the head of the Downtown Jackson Partner’s organization, he bought his enthusiasm and love for the City of Jackson to the position. His positive energy was evident in every presentation and proposal that he made to potential investors, local businesses and the citizens of Jackson. Ben is the person to have on any Jackson project because he can get the job done using his contacts and relationships, Your Honor, | respectfully ask that you rule for probation on the charge against Ben. The City of Jackson will not benefit from Ben serving any time; however we would definitely loose a valuable member of our team. Respectfully Yours, OiGrcla Colle 3G. ‘Wanda Collier-Wilson President/CEO ! Mme Rite ones era37. DEBRA L. GRIFFIN 308 East Pearl Street, Suite 203 Jackson, MS 39201 e Small Business Owner in Downtown Jackson e Former Hospital Administrator and Mississippi State e Department of Health Board Member e Former Executive Committee Member of Downtown Jackson Partnerssackson, nis ~~ HoLLy sPRMcs, Hs “Te ee lng ITA Huy Sout 08 East Por Sect + Suite 203 eee Holy Springs 5 30635 dean 53920 PALLIATIVE & Basie (62) 5512118 Baines (0) 919.8500 rapedicenbessisnstast Fr (60) 551-2118, Fa (1) 96.388 February 28, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Iam Debra Griffin, former Hospital Administrator and Mississippi State Department of Health Board Member, currently small business owner located in Downtown Jackson. I was appointed to the Downtown Jackson Partners’ Board in the fall of 2010 by then Mayor Harvey Johnson; sometime thereafter I was voted onto it’s executive committee. The executive committee met monthly in between quarterly board meetings. I have watched in awe-Ben working like a force of nature on behalf of DJP to lift and re-invigorate our City’s Downtown. Ben has always gone beyond and above to bring some common synergy between the many people and entities needed to revive downtown. Ben has been a workhorse for The City of Jackson's Downtown, As a former executive committee member, who was at the table during most of the events cited, it troubles me to see him have to defend himself on actions with the DJP Board been fully involved. Because of witnessing all of Ben's effort to re-engage Jackson's Downtown principals, I kept my coffee shop opened over 8 years, never making a profit or even breaking even, hecause I believed that it complimented our downtown. I wanted to do my part, help where I knew how. I Pray God Speed and Favor in this Matter. Respectfully wiz ean Ox ih Iw 601 968 2468 Emaphyscinhocesolcm MS Lene 157 an 1838. DANA F. ROBERTSON 2470 Sand Ridge Drive Jackson, MS 39211From the Desk of Dana F, Robertson 2470 Sand Ridge Drive Jackson MS 39211 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Re: Sentencing Considerations for Ben Allen Dear Judge Kicd, Thope this letter finds you well. | am writing you today to speak on behalf of Ben Allen, and to respectfully ask you to consider my remarks when you make your determination of his, sentencing, First, Ben is my neighbor and a colleague in community improvement work. My husband and | live about a block away from Ben and his wife of 41 years, Susie Allen, Ben and Susie are well liked and very respected in our neighborhood and in the larger community. As the executive director of a community improvement organization for the last eight years, | have had a number of occasions to attend community gatherings and meetings where Ben has been called to contribute his opinion and to lend his leadership skills. As a former Jackson City Council member and as someone who has served so many civic organizations, Ben well known asa passionate community leader. Itis that zeal for improving our quality of life the Jackson area that made Ben the ideal candidate for his role as the executive director of Downtown jackson Partners. Second, Ben and Susie are long-time members of the same church that my family belongs to, where they been actively involved for many years. | know Ben to be a devoted husband, father and grandfather. He is always excited to babysit his grandchildren and takes great pride in his family, Part of the reason that Ben is so committed to improving the Jackson area is so that it will be a desirable place for his sons and their families to call home. Finally, [ would like to close by asking that you consider Ben's many contributions and service to our community, as well as his long-standing reputation as a man of integrity and honesty. As such, I humbly ask that you would please limit Ben Allen's sentence to the lowest of the sentencing guidelines range. Thank you for your time and consideration of my sentiments, Sincerely, Dana Dana F, Robertson39. MAURY BREAZEALE Jackson, Mississippi Business Owner / Friend of Ben AllenMaury Breazeale February 27,2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, 1am writing this letter in support of Ben Allen. He has been a good friend for almost 35 years. Ben's son, Clayton, has been my best friend since 1984. Ben and his wife, Susie, were good friends to my late parents for many years. For as long as | have known him, he has been a servant who has given his time to causes - and to people ~ that he loves. When we were children in Jackson, he coached us in soccer and baseball. Foryears, he served as my Scoutmaster in Troop 8 at First Baptist Church in Jackson, He took us to more high school and college football games than I can count. Now that | am a father, a husband, and a business owner, | know how rare and how precious free time is in this season oflife. And now I look back at that time in his life and realize that during some of the most difficult years of his life - as a young man, when he was building a business to support his family and helping his wife raise their two young sons - he gave most of his precious free time to others. ‘And he always did so with a great attitude and with all of his heart. When I look back on my life, I realize that | was fortunate to have a number of strong role models, And Ben Allen is among the finest of them, alongside my father and grandfather, Ben did not grow up in Jackson. He is from Vicksburg, But, as an adult, when it was time for him to choose a place to plant roots and raise a family, he chose Jackson. ‘And from the very beginning, he loved and served Jackson and its residents. He bought a house here. He raised his children here. He served on the City Council for three terms, He started and grew a business here. He started a radio show to promote all things Jackson, He gave thousands of hours of his free time to causes in Jackson that made the city a better place for all of its residents. Not in Ridgeland, or Madison, or Flowood, or Brandon, or Pearl. He did all of these things in Jackson. Later, when his children were grown and out of his house, and he had solé his business, he dedicated his life - and all of his free time - to revitalizing downtown Jackson by growing Downtown Jackson Partners from the ground up. He studied urban revitalization all over the country, and brought ideas and best practices from these cities to the table to help Jackson prosper and grow. He started ‘Team Jackson, a diverse collaboration of organizations and individuals from across the City of, Jackson, joined together for information sharing and cooperative team building, to assure our continued positive momentum. When so many in his generation left Jackson for the suburbs, Ben stayed and doubled down on his commitment toJackson and his service to its citizens by literally devoting his career to promoting and celebrating all of the great things about Jackson and by serving as its greatest cheerleader. Ona personal level, Ihave always known Ben to be kind, friendly, funny, passionate and honest. He is driven by principle. He is a man of great conviction and integrity. ‘And he shows great empathy. I lost my mother to breast cancer when I was 29 years old. I was devastated, In the weeks and months after her death, I received inundreds of letters from friends and family members who knew her and knew me. Allof the letters were kind and supportive. And of all of the letters, the one that he wrote to me stands out. It was the most honest and personal and empathetic letter that I have ever received, in which he shared with me his own experience of losing both of his parents at a young age. It blew me away, And it speaks to his character that he took the time to write me such a long, heartfelt letter at a time when I really needed it. Several years later, when I lost my father to cancer, Ben was there for me again, and this time he made me realize what a special person my father was, which ‘was an awesome tribute to his life. In summation, there are few people | have known in my 37 years in Jackson - and everywhere else in the world that I have traveled - who have invested as much time and energy in me, and who have made as much of an impact in my life as Ben has, And I think this is true of everyone that has gotten to know him and every organization that he has served. From the moment that these accusations were ‘made against him, I was confident that they were not true. The investigation by Downtown Jackson Partners proved this, as I was sure it would. [hope that when the sentencing hearing occurs, you will consider all that Ben has done for me and for s0 many others, and for all that he has done for the city of Jackson. | love Jackson. It ‘was a wonderful place to grow up, because of people like Ben Allen. Now,as an adult, itis a wonderful place to live and raise a family. And if there were more people like Ben Allen, who loved and served the city the way that he does every single day, it would be even finer. Sincerely, Maury Breazeale Jackson Resident40. ANDREW C. WALKER 108 Chantilly Drive Madison, MS 39110 Ben Allen’s Friend of 50 yearsPludhew C Wathen 108 Chantilly Drive Wadison, US BMO February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 E, Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, Ben Allen has been a very close friend of mine since the first time we met, 50 years ago, Ben is a wonderful father, husband and now Grandfather. have never in my life questioned his character or integrity, and we have participated in many mutual endeavors’ together. My wife Deb and | are deeply saddened that so many of our friends have had to feel so much pain from these charges. Our hearts ache. Knowing many of the Board members of Downtown Jackson Partners, I cannot understand how his actions, all board approved, could ever be questioned? If you have any questions or feel the need to speak with either of us personally, my cell phone number is 601-954-8890 and Deb's is 601-953-7711. Thank you for all consideration in the matter. Sincergly, peed eR flo — Andy Walker41. THOMAS B. SHEPHARD, IIT 4 Pierce Cove Jackson, MS 39211‘Thomas B, Shephard IIL 4 Pierce Cove Jackson, MS 39211 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 —— 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Re: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd, ‘This letter is written in support of my dear friend Ben Allen. Thave known Ben for the past ten years, primarily through the Rotary Club of Jackson. ‘Ben was the President of the club the year before I was President, In that capaoity and through other community sorvice, I have come to know and admire Ben and appreciate him for being the fpood person thet he is, He is truly my fiend. I have the highest confidence in him personally and professionally as an honest and forthright person, ‘There is no person who better fits the definition of a “community-minded” person and a cheerleader for Jackson, Ben has been tireless in his efforts to support and promote our capital city, in both official and volunteer capacities, He was always very responsive to my concerns ‘when he served on our city council Ben is one of the most honest persons I know. He is a strong Christian and is respectful and kind to all he meets. Ben is a strong family man, having been active in the Boy Scouts and having coached youth sports. He has raised his son Matt (also my friend) to be a good father too, 1 urge you to grant the greatest leniency to Ben in his sentencing, Jackson still needs Ben’s enthusiasm and leadership. ‘Thank you for considering my thoughts, Myghar ‘Thomas B, Shephord IIT Sincerely, (rans)42. SUSIE ALLEN Wife of Ben AllenDeen Honorable Quelag, Kid, G tase act Yee gaoct ervene, vo Ae raniad ne Bi Allee fort gins Bt Leaw pptat pv Onli, alutt Lrfte vy 8¥hurw- : WP haw Hein Zoruniers ate Teme Unity Acw Quorn Chualelrer dacll arherai Abtdawn “Hnaigbe Coaching, Bang Scand, Sekaol, duct seat ow Leen cha ; ) Werarigfe drnalediel duc. | Porenial hordahaps. Ne thaw deegopileO Vanony ChanLid dud oy ra | ee Aa alae) ol irre Ua ped rung tell PARL Ne ¥kers pevimberarel OTP Jp Luere, Contea | Lar Heastlraaluics, ¥0 yhe One $0 Auch a gassol os oe | geek poem ‘Dacha | who tard Commitid aboslEil, | eet Please cornet ww | Unguatn bey charrrunaing, He Counchine. | Aenerralay Hrcere Abbe,43. SAM LANE 2 Rivers Creek Drive Jackson, MS 39211 Personal Banker of Ben Allen for 20 YearsSam Lane 2 Rivers Greek Drive Jackson, Mississippi 3920 Dow dV 9se. Kae. 7" Ben AQ. Beg fran Ag personel frouQ oD LT se Quan Rr porsoned 28 FEAL ALY 2007CBIR Dare Gen cou 9D | ebay Ban AQQe. pO, Doan oy | ERD Kes a. oD. Dong br eo, B perm ote ely. ee OD yh Rh Dias cre boar Ua & Aemp. ! foPP HEBD, Bar 100, Go Gaiam, ~ On Lone44, SISTER M. DOROTHEA SONDGEROTH, O.P. 969 Lakeland Drive Jackson, MS 39216 Associate Executive Director / St. Dominic Health Services Foundation“i” St. Dominic’s February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Winston Kidd Circuit Fudge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, I am writing on behalf of Mr, Ben Allen, who has been and continues to be an active member of the Rotary Club of Jackson, the largest service Club in the State of Mississippi. 1 have known Ben for a number of years and we served together on the Executive Committee of this same Rotary Club. Following my term as President, Mr. Allen served effectively as President of this Club and I have always found him to be a man of integrity following good moral principles. Being an active Rotarian, Mr. Allen was involved in numerous community service projects sponsored by the Rotary International Organization. In working with Ben, I have known him to be a fine Christian businessman with respect for those with whom and for whom he worked and served, Mr, Allen served effectively as a member of the Jackson City Council for two terms and assisted many citizens while in this role. I have great respect for Mr. Ben Allen, and respectfully request your positive consideration on his behalf, If you need further information, please feel free to contact me, Sincerely, tell, Mh: aa ‘Sister M. Dorothea Sondgeroth, O.P. Associate Executive Director St. Dominic Health Services Foundation ‘St. Dominic Health Services Foundation 1969 Lakeland Drive ‘Jackson, MS 39216 '801.200'6910 office {601.200.6840 fax stdom.com Rear eee an reais45. WAYNE E. FERRELL, JR. 405 Tombigbee Street Jackson, MS 39201 Attorney — Law Offices of Wayne E. Ferrell, Jr., PLLCLAW OFFICES OF WAYNE E. FERRELL, JR., PLLC 405 Tombigbee Street (39201) Post Office Box 24448 Jackson, Mississippi 39225-4448 Telephone: 601.969.4700 Fax: 601.969.7514 WEB FAGE. MASTER OF LAWS, LL.M. EMAIL: wonwairlawonline.com AVIATION & SPACE LAW \werrell@airlawonline.com February 28, 2017 Honorable Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Re: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd: This letter is vaitten on behalf of Ben Allen, my long-time, good friend. Ihave known Ben for many years, since his oldest son and my son were best friends in high school and college. Thave known Ben through his coaching baseball, football, and basketball, and through his work in the Boy Scouts. Ben has a good heart. He is an exemplary human being; there is no question in my mind that he is an honest person with strong character and high morals. I know Ben Allen's wife and children. Ben is a family man, who spends the majority of his free time with his, family and grandchildren, am appalled that anyone would claim or accuse Ben Allen of embezzlement. 1 believe Ben's accusers have a vendetta against him. I am familiar with the charges that were brought against Ben, and I believe they were frivolous charges, including the 18 charges of which he was found innocent, and the one charge that the jury made against him, Ben Allen has spent hundreds of hours working to better the City of Jackson and the Downtown Partners Association, by his work on the City Council and as President of Downtown Jackson Partners. Ben and I worked on the proposed Downtown Arena that was to be built in downtown Jackson. Ben commissioned a group of Jackson citizens, who were dedicated to planning, building, and funding the Downtown Jackson Arena. | firmly believe that had the arena been left in Ben's capable hands, it would be a success story today. ‘The Downtown Jackson Arena would have brought citizens from the metropolitan area to downtown Jackson for events, which in tur would have brought much-needed money for downtown Jackson businesses, restaurants, and hotels, Should you have questions, I would request the opportunity to orally present this letter to Your Honor or answer questions about Ben Allen's integrity, his citizenship, and his contributions to the City of Jackson,February 28, 2017 Page 2 WEFjrede Sincerely, BEL ayne E, Ferrell, Jr.46. WALTER S. WEEMS Post Office Drawer 119 Jackson, MS 39205 Attorney — Brunini / Attorneys at Law190 East Cito Suet Jackson, Misisipp 39205 Exmal: wweems@brusnicom eckson, Missipph 39201 ATTORNEYS AT LAW Dive: 601 9606863 ‘Telephone: 601.948 3101 asin: 601,960 6902 February 28, 2017 ‘The Honorable Winston L. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 473 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Re: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kid I offer this letter in support of my good friend Ben Allen have known Ben for over 30 years in numerous capacities, including as his lawyer, as a father of sons of approximately the same age who attended the same school, as his constituent when he served on the City Counel, in connection with involvement in civic affairs, as members of a“supper club” who have been meeting every other month for over 20 years, and most importantly, as a friend, Ben’s life story has been that of a model citizen: a loyal and devoted hhusband; the father of two outstanding children (one of whom is my law partner); a successful businessman; a devoted church member; a Boy Scout leader; a public servant; a civic leader; and the list could go on and on. In my observation over the 30+ years that I have known Ben, he is a ‘man of the highest ethical standards and impeccable character. I do not know what the Distriet ‘Attomey's motives were in the attack that he has made against Ben over the last year or so, but based on what I know, I do not believe that it was the pursuit of justice. I would like to give you one anecdote about Ben’s advocacy for downtown Jackson. ‘About ten years ago, our firm was making a decision whether to remain in downtown Jackson and become an anchor tenant of The Pinnacle Building or whether to move to Ridgeland in the Renaissance development, We were being courted by developers of both projects, and we had attractive proposals from both locations, When Ben leamed that we had undertaken a process to make this decision, he put together a strong presentation by leaders of the City of Jackson as well as the City's business community in an effort to convince us that we should remain in downtown Jackson, We ultimately signed a 15 year lease to be an anchor tenant in The Pinnacle Building, witich enabled the Pinnacle to be constructed. Ben was then, and he remains, a tireless advocate for downtown Jackson, Our firm is here in no small part due to Ben's efforts, and I am sure our story is repeated in many of the other building projects that we have seen, onss34i7‘The Honorable Winston L. Kidd February 28, 2017 Page 2 It is my understanding that a sentencing hearing is scheduled before Your Honor's Court next week. I must admit that am not familiar with the procedures given the posture of the case, ‘but based on what I know I would hope that the Court would have the authority to render the equivalent of a NOV and clear Ben's name, Based on the testimony of Judge Gibbs and no evidence to the contrary, it is difficult for me (o understand how the jury could have convicted Ben on the cell phone charge, If dismissal of that charge is not possible at this stage, then I ‘would urge you to sentence Ben (o probation and allow him to appeal, if he and his legal team believe that to be appropriate, as a free man. ‘This process over the last year has taken an enormous toll on Ben and his family, and Ben has suffered cnowgh for having done nothing wrong other than being willing to serve in the public arena, I urge you, as I know you will, to consider Ben's life story and service to our community as you determine an appropriate ending to the proceedings in your Court. In my humble opinion, dismissal of the cell phone count is appropriate, but if that is not possible, then would hope that a sentence of some type of probation would be in order. ‘Thank you for your service to our system of justice, and thank you for considering the testimony of those of us who know and love Ben Allen, erely and respectfully, Auten Walter 8. Weems wsWivmp onss3747. TOM UNDERWOOD 3999 Dogwood Drive Jackson, MS 39211 Friend of Ben Allen for Over 35 Years‘Tom Underwood 3999 Dogwood Drive Jackson, MS 39211 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Tunderstand there is a sentencing hearing Monday the 6" of March, ia regards to Ben Allen’s case, Ben Allen has been a close and good friend for over 35 years. We met ‘while he was in private business in Jackson, I know personally Ben has been a ‘great community leader and volunteer and has a great reputation for his honesty ‘and personal character, He felt the calling to serve Jackson by running and being elected to three terms to the Jackson City Council and then on to being a tireless worker for downtown development as President of Downtown Jackson Partners, AL the heating I ask you to please consider probation. Sincerely, Toon Chr alors. ‘Tom Underwood48. C. DELBERT HOSEMANN, JR. 2219 Heritage Hill Drive Jackson, MS 39211 Secretary of State, State of Mississippi6. Delbert Kosemann, Je 229 Keritygo Kill rive Sachson, Mawieiypé 89217 February 28, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 3920S Dear Judge Kidé: thas been my privilege to know Ben Allen and his family for the last 40 years, My son was mentored by him to the rank of Eagle Scout in the Boy Scouts of America. He also coached both of my sons in various athletic endeavors, Ben has been the strongest advocate for the City of Jackson and has led s0 many of our residents in continuing to support our Cit cciucational system and its economic vitality, Inno instanee in the past 40 years, I have ever experienced any possible questions of Ben’s honesty, character, and integrity. On the contrary, Thave often witnessed him giving up his own time and his family time to benofit hundreds of the youth and the citizens of Jackson at no financial reward or even, in most eases, not even a thank you. He and Susie are personal friends of my wife Lynn and I and we will proudly continue to call them our friends, Please nccept this letter as my letter of support for Ben from one of his many friends. Sincerely, Put Moerman” Delbert Hosemann CDH,JR/me49, ILUNTER and SUZENNE CADE 4450 Old Canton Road, Suite 100 Jackson, MS 39211Hunter Cade 4450 Old Canton Road, Suite 100 Jackson, Mississippi 39211 Tho Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascazoula Stroct Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, We are writing in support of our long-time friend Ben Allen and his whole family. Wo have known Ben and Susie for many years and have always hold thom in the highest regard. We all movod to Jackson in the mid-seventies, made our livings, and raisod our chikiren here. Ben has bean a ‘woridertul role mode! to his children and a loving and supportive husband to Susie for aver forty yoars. His older son Matt is a successful attomoy, working and building a home for his family in Jackson. His youngor son Clayton is an oncologist soon moving to Hattiesburg. His sons and their families are living testaments to the overall good character and honesty of Ben and Susie. Ben has been awondertul citizen of Jackson, being Involved In his church, various youth sports programs, Boy Scouts, and, of course, he served the city as councilman for threo tors, He has, been a passionate supporier of Jackson for docades, Ho, whothor in a business or a social selting, is always a cheerleader for Jackson, dedicated to making it a belter placo to live and «work for all its citizens. His honesty, sincority, and integrity aro rollected in and integral to his lito. The cily of Jackson is fortunate to have someone of his character as its advocata, We rospecttully ask that you consider this leer of our unwavering support for Bon as you fonder your decision, Sincerely, Kila tee Hunter and Suzanne Cade50. JODY SCHMELZER 302 Enterprise Drive, Suite B Oxford, MS 38655 Campus Pastor (Oxford), PinelakeThe Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 This letter of support is written on behalf of Ben Allen. | have known Ben Allen as the father of one of my childhood friends for the past 30 years. | have always known Mr. Allen to be a man that loves his family well and truly enjoys serving his community. Although | have not interacted with Mr. Allen for the past several years, | have always looked up to him as a great leader in the community that has always done what he could to improve his surroundings. | hope this letter serves as a support for Mr. Allen. | believe that his heart for his family, friends, and his community is a great testimony of who this man truly is. JODY SCHMELZER Campus Pastor, Oxford51. J. PETER JERNBERG 4908 Ridgewood Road * Post Office Box 14978 Jackson, MS 39236-4978 Retired as Headmaster of Jackson AcademyJacxson AcapEMY é ee Post Office Box 14978 601.362.9676 | wwwjacksonacademy.org Jackson, MS 39236-4978 February 28, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Court District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kida, 1am pleased and honored to offer this letter to you and your court in support of my dear friend Ben Allen. Our professional and personal association began in the late 1970's when I was Principal at Indianola Academy and he represented The Balfour Company and Taylor Publishing Company. ‘This relationship continued when I was appointed in 1988 as Headmaster of Jackson Academy where I served until my retirement in 2014. During these forty plus years, I have admired and been personally influenced by his professional integrity, honesty and genuine respect for others, as well as always exemplifying a sincere sense of fairness to all. | also have closely observed his dedicated devotion as a husband to his wife Susie and asa father to his two sons Matthew and Clayton. Jackson Academy had the privilege of having his sons as students and now alumni, saw first hand Ben's supportive nature of his children but also his nurture and care for the well being of their classmates. Asacitizen and resident of Jackson, I have witnessed first hand Ben's passionate commitment to our city and its future. His service as a Jackson City Councilman was truly outstanding as demonstrated by his efforts to serve the interest ofall Jacksonians, 1am firmly convicted that we are most fortunate to have him continue to serve and provide both vision and progressive leadership as President of Downtown Jackson Partners. In closing, it should be further noted that Ben Allen’s life is one that is punctuated by serving and caring for others. ‘This is reflected not only in his various professional and formal roles of leadership, but on a day to day basis by his personal example ofhow he lives his daily life. He is a person whose moral values are rooted in his deep faith, which undergirds the integrity with which he serves. Please know Au For Onethe great respect and appreciation | have for my friend Ben Allen and his family. tt is my hope and prayer that my words will give you and the court an even deeper insight into Ben Allen, the man. JPJ:cs. Respectfully submitted, Gt J. Peter Jernberg President Emeritus Jackson Academy52. JEFF GOOD 3317 North State Street Jackson, MS 39216 President — Mangia Bene Restaurant Management GroupUT MANGIA. jw BENE ING, [RD Jeff Good %, os ats, MS 8218 Lelueetianae y cell 601.540.8111 USGS A ee email: jefg@bravobuzz.com February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Iam writing on behalf of Ben Allen, a tireless cheerleader for our embattled town, Jackson. Ben is genuine, transparent, effervescent and sincere. Each day he rises, he goes to work for our city, and each night, he goes to bed knowing he tried his best. While | am not privy to the details of the Downtown Jackson Partners bookkeeping practices and board - executive director relationships, | can say that | know the vast majority of individuals who have been involved on that board, and within that organization, and they all sing Ben's praises. Asdol. | find it incredulous that Ben is guilty of embezzlement. Lousy record keeping? Maybe. But stealing? Never. With all respect, | ask that you consider the goodness thats the core trait of Ben Allen. Ben has suffered mightily through this ordeal, and | pray that we can keep the spark of hope and enthusiasm alive within his heart. Ben is an incredible asset to our community and we need him now more than ever. You can contact me at 601-982-4443 ext. 11, if you wish to discuss my comments in mare deta ! remain sincere) ‘yours, caf Jet Good, President Mangia Bene Restaurant Management Group53. HILDA STAUSS OWEN 1920 Dunbarton drive Jackson, MS 39216 President - Communication ARTS Company28 February 2017, COMMUNICATIONARTS Honorable Winston L. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39201-4206 RE: Berjamin Wade Allen IIL Honorable Winston L. Kidd— ‘Thank you for calm leadership in our community as a member of the judiciary. Please accept this letter of character regarding Ben Allen, President of Downtown Jackson Partners. ‘Asa native Jacksonian with professional offices in downtown Jackson for nearly thirty years and aboard member of Downtown Jackson Partners (DJP) since its beginning, [have served all seven Chairman of the organization and worked closely with each of its four presidents, President Ben Allen has been our enthusiastic leader over the past decade, successfully championing projects that have brought energy and development to Downtown, diligently managing services that keep Downtown attractive to visitors and workforce, and. expertly shepherding DIP through two successful reauthorizations. An incredibly hard-working person of integrity, he cares deeply for our city and its people, As a member of the DJP Board of Directors, I have read the indictment against Ben Allen, authorized an investigation into the allegations, been satisfied by the evidence, and stated my belief in his innocence. I am grateful that the jury exonerated him on nine counts, yet mystified by the guilty verdict on one count, knowing that there is full documentation of his reimbursements for the phone charges in question. Tam not an attorney and bow to the advice of Board Attorney Robert Gibbs on legal ‘matters for DIP. Tdid not attend Ben’s trial and am not privy to the reasons why various pieces of evidence were or were not submitted. However, I did attend the closing remarks in the case on February 7,2017, and was dismayed by unrelated allegations, made against Mr. Allen, as well as Downtown Jackson Partners and its leadership, that strayed from the charges as I understood them and seemed to be solely targeted at damaging him and the organization as a whole. ‘These proceedings have weighed heavily upon all of us and in particularly upon Ben and his family. Even though there has been no wrong doing, we will all be working for a very long time to restore public confidence clestroyed by these false accusations. Please know that I am exceeding respectful of your authority and the jury's decision in Ben Allen's case, yet ask your patience and thoughtfulness on the remaining count to consider dismissal ora sentence of probation, so that Ren can continue the important work of caring, for the Downtown Business Improvement District “Thank you for: e Khe: Celebrating more than 40 years of work worth doing COMMUNICATIONARTSCOMPANY: 1920 DUNBARTON DRIVE: JACKSON: MISSISSIFPI:392 16:601.982.9820:FX601 982.9825: CONMARTS.NET54, JIMMYE SWEAT Jackson, Mississippi Editor / Northside Sun Newspaper & Northside Sun MagazineJudge Kidd, Never in my wildest dreams did | expect to find myself writing a letter to the courts on behalf of Ben Allen, There are many kind words | could write about Ben addressing his role as a husband, father, grandfather, friend. | could spend my time writing about his integrity. Also loyalty is another subject to address on his behalf. But I’m sure many letters have been written on those subjects. What | want to address is Jackson and what Ben means to the city my husband has lived in all his life, the city we raised our son in and now the hometown of our grandchildren. It’s perplexing to me the way many residents of the metro area and the state feel about Jackson. Some seem to want Jackson to fail. Others act as if the city is a place of lawlessness. I'm always amazed how these Mississippians don’t realize the importance of our state capitol. However Ben Allen does. All this is evident in what he has done for years. While on the city council, although I didn’t always agree with everything, he conducted himself in way that it was obvious he was willing to help make Jackson better. Then with the formation of the Downtown Partnership he again stepped up to the plate, The term cheerleader seems a trite adjective to tag him with, but a most appropriate one. | think he and his family could move to the suburbs, but instead they live in Jackson and all his actions for years are indications that he is trying to make the city a wonderful place for his grandchildren to continue to call home, | admire him for this and can say I’m a fan of his. | respect him and disappointed he has been put in this position. He is an asset to Jackson and Mississippi. It’s encouraging to know someone who is so philanthropic with their time and actions, | sincerely hope we will continue to have Ben Allen doing all that he does. My Regards Jimmye Sweat Jimmye Sweat Editor Northside Sun Newspaper Northside Sun Magazine 601-957-112355. SYLVIA Y. STEWART 607 Monroe Street Jackson, MS 39202 DVM / Monroe Street Animal Clinic Jackson, MississippiVv SYLVIA Y STEWART DVM. Febsuary 28, 2017 Honorable Winston 1. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Winston 1. Kid 1 have known Hien Allen since 1997 when he was elected as the Ward 1 representative to the City Council of Jackson, and T had the oppostunity to work closely with him on several projects concerning community and ‘economic development for the City of Jackson ducing his thece terms. Jn 2007, I was 1 member of the Boaed of Directors of Downtown Jackson Pattnets (DP) and had the honor to seave on the selection committee for the open position of President. I voted in the aifiemative to recommend Ben Allon (othe full Bosed to be hited asthe organization's President because of his charset, his ‘experience and his unigue and genuine passion for effecting positive change for the City of Jacksoa, In 2007, Ben wus hiced by the Boned of Directors for Downtown Jackton Partuers to serve as its President and I was lected to serve on the Executive Committe 2s Treasueee and served the organization in that positon until October 2016. DIP is 4 501-C-4 (non-profit social welfize) Business Impeovement District corporition focusing on stubiization and economic development of Downtown Jackson, Ben Allen has worked tirelessly lend, grow tnd strengthen the organization and because of Ben's lexdership DJP and its Board of Directors have long lst of significant developments. The Block by Block Ambassador program, the Capitol Steet Renaissance ect, King Edward, Standard Life, Federal Courthouse, Wall, The Plaza, Tombighee Lofts, 308 Pletic Baling. Gavia Building, the Museum of Missisippi Histoxy, the national Civil Rights ‘Museum of Mississippi, The South Warehouse, and most recent and implemented because of Ben Allen’ leadership. ith Park renovation have been initiated know Ben Allen to be an honest and honorable man. His actions as President of DJP since 2007 have been fully supported by the Boatd of Directoes and at no time was there ny concern on my part that he was making, lbssiness decisions that were merely in his interest only. Respectfully Subrni Cal Pleat Cs Mesa Conwell via email meusidac@coxwellasscom 607 MONROK STMT + JAESKON, MS + 3920256. AMY McMAHN Jackson, Mississippi Retired / The Learning Center — Jackson State’s Continuing Education Division‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39206 Dear Judge Ki id, It is my pleasure to write this letter in support of Ben Allen. When my family moved to Jackson from Dallas in the late 80's, Ben is one of the city leaders I met early on, Julie Mabus contacted me to see if I would help start a workforce educational program that was to be part of Jackson State's Continuing Edueation Division. The Learning Center was located on Highway 80 in the Enterprise Building, Having grown up in Greenville, graduating from Ole Miss in 1962, I realized that moving back to Mississippi I would help in any way possible to facilitate educational opportunities for our citizens. ‘The Learning Center is still a GED program in the area. For 17 years until retirement, it was my {job to solicit support with publicity, donations, grant writing, supplies, workbooks as well as searching for interested students, Ben was my Councilman and was nice enough to give me an appointment. We hit it off with our ideas and eagerness to educate as many people as we could, Ben visited our facility, met the staff, offered support from the city, let me speak before council meetings to inform the other Council members of our progress and acknowledged our efforts over the years with a lovely plaque which is still on the wall. Thave known Ben in other situations over the years, and have always known him to be of highest cthies, have a continuing desire to help Jackson be the best, be frugal with resources and is a constant energetic spokesman for the city. Ben and his lovely wife Suzie of 41 years sit behind me at Christ United Methodist and they came to the 50th wedding anniversary for my husband and me given by our three adult children a couple of years ago. I will always cherish the friendship with both of them. Ben is an asset in all endeavors and we are so lucky he is here in Jackson. Sincerely, ‘Amy McMahan57. SUSAN H. LUNARDINI 5740 County Cork Road Jackson, MS 39206 President, Southern Consultants, Inc. — Consulting EngineersConsulting Engineers SUSAN Hl LUNARDINI, AMES 8: STEWART, P. Ror ESIDENT ‘VICE PRESIDENT (TC, LUNARDINI, PE, SENIOR ENGINEER wormmscivilengineers.com SOUTHERN CONSULTANTS, INC. § February 26, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: ‘One of my best teachers of “all things Jackson” is Ben Allen. He has led several trips for many of us to view several mid-sized cities that have utilized various innovations to better their quality of life. | first met Ben as a City Councilman and found him enthusiastic and realistic regarding Jackson’s challenges and their possible solutions. These city visits were just what | needed to advocate for changes and to help me select where | could contribute. Ihave known Ben through business and Rotary. It is a rare Monday that he is not at Rotary and contributing to cur civic projects. In Rotary we make decisions by a four-way test, and | believe him to utilize these principles. Ben has a winning smile and speaks with good humor to encourage all to strive for a better Jackson. Judging others by race or economic status is not ‘obvious in any dealings or meeting that | have attended, and those meetings are well over two hundred in over 18 years. It is impossible for me to believe that Ben would ever seek to deceive on purpose. He would suffer from pangs of conscience and, in my opinion, try to offer amends should he hurt a fellow human, As a woman, | have never felt belittled or discounted by Ben. As a Curved Bar Girl Scout, | instinctively recognize in Ben the Eagle Scout who strives to act with honor. As a Christian, | have never seen Ben act without charity or reason. Sincerely yours, Southern Consultants, Inc. (Susan H. Lunardini, President 5740 COUNTY CORK ROAD, JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI 39206 PHONE (601)957-0999, FAX (601)957-9332 ‘A Woman's Business Enterprise *mscivilengineers.com58. SAM BEGLEY 854 North Jefferson Street Jackson, MS 39202 Attorney / Past Member of the Board of Directors for Downtown Jackson PartnersSam Begley 854 North Jefferson Street Jackson, MS 39202 (601) 969-5545 March 1, 2017 ‘The Honorable Winston Kidd Hinds County Circuit Judge 407 East Pascagoula St. Jackson, MS 39201 State of Mississippi v. Benjamin Wade Allen, II Cause No. 25CI1:16-CR-00110-WLK Dear Judge Kidd: Tam writing Your Honor regarding Mr. Ben Allen, I hope you will consider this leter as you decide the sentence to be provided as a result of the jury verdict returned in Mr. Allen’s case. Thave personally known Ben for 20 years, when he was elected to the Jackson City Council, in 1997. During that same time, I found myself at City Hall as well, as the Co-Chairman of the ‘Transition Committee for Mayor Harvey Johnson, Jr. During Mayor Johnson's first two terms in office, Iwas hired by the City to handle litigation and bond transactions, which caused ‘me as an attorney to deal with the members of the City Council frequently and intimately, From the beginning, I was impressed with Ben's quick mind and his seriousness as a public official, particularly when it came to insuring that public dollars were spent efficiently. He was courteous and attentive to the countless number of city employees, contractors, and citizens who came before the City Council each week. He worked to build consensus and civility in the often rough and tumble polities of City Hall. His leadership traits caused him to be elected by his colleagues as Council President, Ben always struck me as someone who took his oath of office seriously seeking to follow both the letter and spirit of the Mississippi Code and the City Ordinances, He ‘was not shy about secking the advice of the City Attorney or the opinion of the Mississippi Attorney General to insure that the City was acting well within the boundaries of the law. As a councilman, Ben quickly developed a reputation at City Hall for honesty and integrity. The citizens of Jackson greatly benefitted fiom Ben’s service on the City Council In 2009, Mayor Johnson recommended me to serve on the Board of Directors of Downtown Jackson Partners, where I served through October 2016, During my entive tenure on the Board, Ben served as President of the corporation, responsible for the day to day Page 1 of 3administration of the Business Improvement District. Ben has worked to insure that assessment funds for our organization were not spent wastefully but spent strategically to promote the economic growth of our Capital City through a flourishing downtown, Ben always took seriously the primary governance role of the board of directors, working closely with our Bosrd chairs and the Board’s executive committee, while relying upon guidance and assistance from our accounting firm and legal counsel. I am not aware of Ben making any decision, particularly involving the expenditure of corporate funds, that was not authorized by the Board and its officers. [ am not aware of any decision that he made as President that was not for the benefit of the various stakeholders of downtown Jackson, During my time on the Board, I felt that Ben kept me fully informed of the affairs of the corporation, and lhe earned my highest respect and confidence many times over. As President of Downtown Jackson Partners, Ben has been a passionate advocate for Downtown Jackson. People often refer to him as a “cheerleader for Jackson,” which he should ‘wear as a badge of honor, Ben is greatly respected by our Congressional delegation and at the State Capitol. Ben's leadership secured the funding from state and federal sources for the recent improvements to Capitol Street. Although we as a team came up short up in our effort, Ben and his boatd worked tirelessly to get the legislature to move the Mississippi Department of Revenue to the Landmark Center in Downtown Jackson. Last year, Ben lead the successful eifort to cause the legislature to provide more than $60 million in state historic credits for the renovation of historic buildings. This infusion of state money was recently applied to the Capitol Loft project across the street from the King Edward Hotel, ‘The developers for the old Deposit Guaranty Bank. Building and the old Federal Courthouse are using state historic credits in their finance plans to renovate these buildings for residential uses, The historic tax credit legislation would not have happened, in my opinion, without Ben’s leadership. All in all, the various stakeholders of downtown Jackson— the property owners, the various businesses, and the people who live and work there — have greatly benefitted from Ben’s ten years of hands on and thoughtful leadership as President of Downtown Jackson Partners. During the past 36 months, I have worked closely with Ben in organizing “Team Jackson,” a 501(0)(3) tax exempt organization, hutpAwww.teamjasn.com/, The organization showeases the growth and positive momentum taking place in the Capital City. Ben largely came ‘up with the idea for Team Jackson, after sceing similar organizations at work in other Southern cities that had experienced economic stressors similar to what has happened in Jackson. Ben took the ball and ran with it and assembled the moving parts to make it work. In short order, the organization is now funded with the membership dues of more than 200 organizations and individuals, and operates through « hands on board, an executive director and a steering committee divided into several task forces. Most of the committee members are under the age of 35. The organization holds quarterly luncheons featuring out of town speakers presenting ideas for urban “placemaking” while showcasing the creative and entrepeneurial talents of persons Page 2 of 3working inside the City. Ben continues to be a guiding force for this extremely successful organization, There would have been no Team Jackson without Ben, 1am respectfully requesting that you consider Ben’s exemplary character and many contributions to our community in your sentencing decision, With that in mind, I hope you will consider a sentence of probation, In my opinion, the community would be best served by having Ben in place so that he may continue with Respectfully, Sam Begley SAM BEGLEY, Page 3 of 359. HOGAN E. ALLEN 282 Maxey Drive * P.O. Box 150 Jackson, MS 39043 CPA — Barlow, Walker & Company, P.A. And Ben Allen’s BrotherBarlow, Walker & Company, P.A. Certified Public Accountants Charles S. Barlow, CPA Kenneth ©, Walker, CPA Keisti G."Mhompson, CPA Rose L. Willison, CPA Lauren M. LaPrade, CPA Hogan E. Alten, CPA Carley W. Moore, CPA, CFE, Jolley 8, Eildes, CPA Members of “American Institue of CPA's Mississippi Society of CPA's Mare 1, 2017 282 Maxey Drive P.O. Bos 150) Bacon, Mississippi 39043 (601) 825-1310 (601) 825-1326 Fax 113. Main 8 Quitman, Mississippi 39353, (601) 776.3361 nll: sandy @brandoncpas.com eng@brandonepas.com Wet: worw.bariowwalkerepa.cont ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: Lam writing on behalf of my brother, Ben Allen, who faces sentencing by your court resulting from a charge of embezzlement from Downtown Jackson Partners, Since Ben is my brether, I'll not address character and life issues because, understandably, my views are considered inherently prejudiced, ‘What | do want to address is that which 1 am professionally and experientially qualified to do: the conviction, Tam expressing my viows 2s a Certified Public Accountant, licensed by the State of Mississippi in 1980, that practiced: as a partner with Eubank & Betts, PLLC during the period 1983-2008; on my own 2008-2013; and, with Barlow, Walker & Company, P.A. since 2013. Over the course of this practice, I have served as an Expert Witness in two Federal Court actions, a Fact Witness for the FBI in another Federal Court sction, and in three State of Mississippi actions (all embezzlement, all on behalf of the plaintiff) I was contacted yesterday to assist attorney Kate Fiat in another matter involving disputed accountings. Using my expertise in evaluating evidence presented in court, I concluded that the prosecution provided no, zero, evidence supporting the charge of embezzlement: no smoking gun, not even a corroborating statement from an interested party. In fact, the prosecution's witness from an audit/accounting perspective openly stated that he found no evidence of embezzlement. Furthermore, I have personally examined the documentation establishing that the cellphone bills relating to Susie Allen’s persone cellphone were fully repaid a full 18 months prior to the indictment; documentation provided to, and ignored by, the office of the District Attorney. This documentation was testified to by defense witness, Judge Robert Gibbs. There was no testimony that the bills were not paid, nor that a request for repayment had been made, much less denied by the defendant. Period Because of what I personally heard in court, and what { have physically examined, I strongly request that this charge of embezzling money from Downtown Jackson Partners be dismissed as factually wrong.60. BRAD CHISM 2906 N. State Street Jackson, MS 39216 Owner / Chism StrategiesBrad Chism Chism Strategies 2906 N. State Street Jackson, MS 39216 3/1/2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd c/o Attorney Meitida Coxwell Dear Judge Kidd: Tam wtiting to express my opinion of Ben Allen. Tam not a property owner in downtown Jackson and have no business relationship with Mr. Allen or Downtown Jackson Partners. My great respect for Ben Allen began with our experiences in the Leadership Jackson progiam twenty years ago. I found Ben to be industrious, cordial and a good listener. He worked hard to learn the perspectives of different participants in the program. Iam a partisan Democrat. At the time Ben was a staunch Republican. We disagreed on many issues but always found common ground when it came to the future of our Capitol City. Thave witnessed Ben’s great love for Jackson and a deep devotion to his work as an elected representative of the city. I saw Ben work tirelessly behind the scenes as a City Councilman to find ‘common ground with his adversaries so that the logjams at City Hall could be overcome. Since that time T have watched Ben work with a wide array of elected officials and economic development professionals to advance Jackson. He combines a rate combination of boundless optimism and a studied practicality. Ben understands both the vision and the necessary, often rocky path to fulfill it, He has demonstrated both the courage and the drive accomplish great things for our city, 1 cannot speak to the charges against Ben Allen. But I know that Jackson is a better place because of him, "Thank you for your consideration. Bead Chism61. DUANE A. O’NEILL Post Office Box 22548 Jackson, MS 39225 President/CEO of Greater Jackson Chamber PartnershipGreater Jackson Chamber PARTNERSHIP MISSISSIPPI February 27, 2017 Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39201 Dear Judge Kidd, Please allow me to say a couple words on behalf of Ben Allen, | have heard that he has a sentencing hearing next week, In light of his charge of “embezzlement”, | feel compelled to offer a few of my comments before his “sentencing hearing”. have known Ben for more than twenty years. My position as the President/CEO of the Greater Jackson Chamber/Economic Development entity brought us together on many issues/opportunities while he was on the City Council and more recently leading Downtown Partners. People rallied behind Ben and his leadership style. On numerous occasions, | was Impressed by Ben’s energy and determination to make this a better community. His actions ‘were, and continue to be selfless and aimed at improving the quality of life for all Jacksonians, His vision for a better Jackson is neither centered just on downtown, nor Northeast Jackson. Other initiatives such as to help Jackson State connect to the business community and additionally help find funding for a new JSU stadium are important to Ben, In addition to our work relationship, Ben and I became very good friends. He and Susie also are fellow members of Christ United Methodist Church where we have shared in serving over the years. They have ralsed two wonderful sons. It is easy to see the positive influenceon these fine young men they have become today. Admittedly, | have had more of an opportunity to interface with his son Matt, and observe the close relationship he and his dad share. Matt, like his father, is not afraid to be a leader even though we all know strong leadership sometimes. comes at cost.Ben is good and honest person. He is also a positive voice for Jackson, Some, even me at times, may not have always agreed with Ben on every issue and initiative. However, he Is right more often than most of us. Additionally, | personally think this city needs Ben’s leadership, He has already suffered greatly from this entire process. | hope your decision is such that he can leave this behind him and be an effective civic leader we need, ‘Thanks for listening, Ciau kOMD Duane A. O'Neill President/CEO. Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership P.O. Box 22548, Jackson, MS 39225, P; (601) 948-4300/ C: (601) 668-527562. MICHAEL W. BOERNER 2727 Old Canton Road, Suite 200 Jackson, MS 39216 Principal Architect / Wier Boerner Allin ArchitectureMarch 1, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd ecu ge iste 3 407 East Pascagouls Street Jackson, Missssip) 39205 RE: Letter of Suzport for Ben Allen Dear Judge Winston Kidd - The intent of this letter is to share my high personal and professional opinion of Mr. Ben Allen. Ben is a ‘man of honesty, integrity and character. He is also a pillar of our Jackson community. His leadership for the City of Jackson has served as a catalyst for downtown Jackson development, during a time when ‘many businesses wanted to turn their backs on the city. The City of Jackson is a better place because of his efforts. My business partner and I approached Ben Allen with our plan to start Wier Boerner Architecture in the summer of 2009, which was considered an awful time to hang a shingle. Ben talked with Jamie Wier and me for about an hour, trying to help us game plan for a sustainable business during this rough economic period. Mr. Allen could have easily sent us away or discouraged us from making this move, but rather he ‘encouraged us to be hungry and out-work our competition in the industry. Since that meeting, every time that we see Ben, he tells us how proud he is and encourages us to continue doing great things. Our firm is now 17 architects and designers strong and we consider Ben to be an influential part of our success. Please consider these thoughts and as lenient of a sentence as possible for Mr. Allen. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely: Avib.L rea— Michael W. Boerner Principal Architoct ce: Mertida Conwell 2727 Old Canton Road, Suite 200, Jackson, MS 39216 | P.601.321.9107 | F:601.321 9108 | wunwwbzarchitecturecom63. SHIRLEY R. TUCKER Greater Jackson PartnershipFebruary 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: | personally write on behalf of Ben Allen whom I’ve worked with numerous years both professionally and personally and found him to have great integrity, pride and an incredible passion for our community. I've also had the great pleasure of knowing Ben's family through thelr affiliation in many events and programs. He and his son, Matt Allen, were both In the Chamber's Leadership Greater Jackson program where they have provided a host of resources since their completion of the program. Ben has even offered financial support to the Chamber's Youth Leadership Jackson program, in an effort to continue such program. Ben has always impressed me with his strong support for this community and his unwavering desire to stand up for great causes regardless of adverse consequences. I've not only observed him in public venues but personally as well. I've frequently utilized Ben's services to provide positive messages and encouragement to our audiences and he’s never refused the opportunity to do so. recall when one of my co-workers informed me of an incident where Ben stood up for the rights of all people in anon diverse audience. This story ! have never shared with hirm but have always admired him for taking on such stance. As the saying goes, “a man’s character is not determined by what he does when someone Is watching, but when they're not”. In closing, | want to say that I value you as an established leader and a professional ctizen of this community so that’s why | enjoy having you to speak to our leadership groups every year. | also place Mr. Ben Allen in the same category. Therefore, | trust that you will provide lentency on a man that | believe has given this community so much already as a public servant, business ‘owner, and a strong community act cerely, WS a7 Shirley R. Tucker64. HARRIS H. BARNES, III 5 River Bend Place, Suite A Flowood, MS 39232-7618 Attorney / Barnes Law Firm, P.A.Barnes Law Firm, P.A. Attorneys at Law H. Barney I, JD, LLM. 5 River Bend Place, Suite A Osford, MS Offe: 5S tiny JD: Flowood, Mississippi 39232-7618 405 ah Stes, Sat 106 ae Lalo} Tuatkare (O81) 9816896 “Osler, Missy’ 38655 James) jams Janoush, J.D., LL.M. Faceimile: (601) 981-7075 Telephone: (662) 236-6226 Dens A. Love, Enrolled Agent® Gulfport, ME Office: 2610 1th Stace, Suite 830 Website: www. Barneslavefiem.com Or Counsui Ronali A. Wecley,J.D, LLM! : February 28, 2017 “As Al aa” ‘Maan ain Southaven, Minos 38672 ‘Ante te Pato eS “Tuephen: (662) 890-6560 The Honorable Winston Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Steet Jackson, MS 39208 Re: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd: Tam writing you concerning a very important decision that you will soon have to make regarding my good friend Ben Allen. Just so you will know, I have known, and been friends with Ben since our days at Mississippi State University in the mid-1960s. In the 50 years that I have known Ben, he has been a man of principle, and integrity. T have observed him when he had his own business, when he served as a councilman for the City of Jackson, and as he has served the citizens of Jackson through his work with the Downtown Jackson Partners, In each of these Ben has thrown his entire body, soul and energies into making each of them a success. In faet, I watched Ben work so hard for the City of Jackson that it almost destroyed his health. ‘Through Ben’s love for the City of Jackson, and its citizens he came back to work with the Downtown Jackson Partners to assist in building up the City of Jackson in an effort to keep it a vibrant community, and to avoid what appears to be its downward slide over the past 20 years. Thave known Ben Allen as the Scout Master of Troop 8 at First Baptist Church where he guided young men throughout their lives, helping them to become Eagle Scouts. In addition to helping his two sons Matt and Clayton, he also helped my son Bryan also become an Eagle Scout, Throughout my 50 plus years of knowing him I have found him to be a man of Christian faith, high principles, supreme integrity, and having an acute love for his fellow man. Ben has always simply wanted what was best for the Jackson community. In my 44 years as a practicing attorney, and as a prosecutor intern on the Mississippi Gulf Coast, | have handled a large number of criminal cases for both the prosecution and defense, IHonorable Winston Kidd February 28, 2017 have never seen stich unwarranted, and uncalled for charges. It is obvious the jury reached a “compromise” verdict possibly leading to Ben’s conviction of a “nothing charge” through the use wife's cell phone, thus rewarding the prosecution for going to so much trouble, However, jon has placed my friend’ life and liberty in jeopardy. T would ask you, as the sentencing, judge, to take all of this into consideration, Ben has committed no crime, Quite frankly, you cannot order restitution sinee Ben paid the cell phone charges back to Downtown Jackson Partners as they occurred. I would ask you to require no sentence, probation or any other type of confinement for Ben Allen. L appreciate your consideration of this letter. With kindest regards, Iam Very truly yours, BARNES LAW FIRM, P.A. Harris H. Barnes, IIT HHB,[I:cas65. W. DAVID WATKINS 256 Eastbrooke Street Jackson, MS 39216 President and CEO / Watkins Development, LLCW. David Watkins 256 Etioche Stet Jucon, Misisipp sons February 28,2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 Fast Pascagoila Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 RE: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd, understand that you will be holding a sentencing hearing for Ben Allen on Monday, March 6, As part of your deliberations | would like to offer you my personal comments regarding the moral integrity and character of Ben, based upon my personal observations and experiences with Mr. Allen. | how known Ben Allen for over 30 years and have worked with him in various professional and personal endeavors. As legal counsel to the Jackson Public Schools, | dealt with Ben numerous times on school budgeting issues, bond issues, and challenges facing the school district. Ben was always eager to do everything in his rower to make JPS better. He never flinched or held back his support for a strong public school system and, as is typical for the Ben Allen most of us know and love, he was not afraid to vote his support of our school system to audiences that might not usually be predisposed to listen. Nevertheless, he continued to be a vocal supporter of our schools and to help fight the good fight. As | transitioned my career from legal to real estate and community development, Ben was the "go to” uy for helping me find my way. | soon realized that no matter who you were, if you had an idea to make Jackson a better place, then Ben was going to be there for you, whenever you needed him. Ben ‘was instrumental in helping me with legislation and with gaining the needed support of City leaders that made the successful redevelopment of the King Edward Hotel possible. It took seven hard years to secure the historic tax credit legislation, the environmental remediation measures, and the approval by ‘not less than 16 governmental entities necessary to restore the King Edward. Ben was with me EVERY step of the way, tirelessly make calls, having focus groups, meeting with bankers, legislators and other governmental officials to support our efforts, To be candid, without Ben's constant support and reassurance, | would have given up on the project. I realized that “but for Ben” is a commen expression for many downtown Jackson warriors. ‘More recently, my experience with Ben has been through my work on the Downtown Jackson Partners Board, including service on the Executive Committee and as past Chairman. Ben's energy, vitality and passion has served this community well. Ben was, and is, “alin” for this great city we call lackson, He has worked many long hours, made many personal sacrifices and bullt many bridges that have aided our community through some very dfficut times. He was always looking at innovative and creative ways to ‘make our City better, and he has never stopped being our City’s biggest cheerleader. Ben is not just a leader, but a man of great moral character and integrity. As Chairman of DIP, | always hhad great confidence that Ben was fighting the good fight for our City, butting heads with naysayers andPages legislators and others with prejudiced perceptions. Ben always took the high moral ground, however. I never, ever once had any question about his integrity or honesty. He has always been disarmingly candid, honest, and eager to serve, traits not found in many leaders of today. The allegations that became the basis of this indictment surfaced when | was Chalrman ofthe OJP Board. To protect the board, | personally conducted my own independent investigation and made sure ‘we had outside lawyers and auditors did the same, | can honestly say that | have absolutely no doubt that Ben Allen is innocent, did not embezzle ANY money from DIP and is in fact, a victim. There can be no question that this indictment arose out of complaints from former DIP employee, Linda Brune, as retaliation against Ben for changing her employment to part time. The truth is that |, and several other Executive Committee Members, encouraged Ben to terminate Ms. Brune, because of her racist comments and attitudes, and her inappropriate and insensitive demeanor. Ben’s falure here was ‘one of the heart. When he met with Ms. Brune, rather than terminating her position, he listened to her pleas for help and simply reduced the number of working hours. It was only later that we found out that. she had embezzled some $40,000 of DJP funds. It is an ironic twist that Ben's good hearted and kind gesture of sparing Ms. Brune her job, resulted in her bearing false witness and making false charges against him. Finally, | should acd that there is another side of Ben Allen that very few people have seen. Ben not only cares deeply for this community, but deeply for the people init, all of them. Only a handful of people know that Ben has time and again put himself at financial risk to help others in this community from financial ruin, for no reason other than Christian kindness. He has co-signed notes, has loaned money to thers, and has paid off tax liens for people and small businesses in this community, just to keep them from going under. 1am reminded of appropriate scripture here. “But you, when you pray, enter into your closet, and when you have shut your door, pray to your Father which Is i secret; and your Father which sees in secret shall reward you openly.” (American King James Version, Matt. 6.6) implore you to consider Ben's good deeds and acts, as the life of an exemplary Christian, when you consider the motions and proceedings before you. | know in my heart that Ben is innocent of any ‘wrong-doing, | also know In my heart, that Ben Allen is a good man, a good husband, a good father and a good friend, and deserves your merciful consideration. Respectfully submitted, a“ Loonl Willi! W. David Watkins, Sr66. LELAND SPEED Chairman Emeritus and Director of EastGroup Properties Jackson, MississippiEASTGROU February 23, 2017 The Honorable Winston Kidd Hinds County Circuit Court ~ District 3 307 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 RE: Ben Allen Dear Judge Kidd: | was involved in the creation of Downtown Jackson Partners (DIP) over twenty-five years ago, and served as its chairman for its first twelve years, and as a director ever since. Downtown Partners serves downtown, but it also serves as the only business association whose focus is on the City of Jackson alone, and not the metro area. Ben has been the most effective CEO, DIP has had over these twenty-five years. Right now | can look out of my office window and see construction underway on the revamping of Capitol Street. Ben found the money for this project. Ben called the meeting in DJP's office where Jackson and Mississipp\'s first charter school was born, The list goes on. We need Ben on the job working for our city, Our city Is hurting and It needs his leadership in getting things dore, Ben is a person who naturally brings people together. You may recall that Ben, a white Republican, was elected president of the Jackson City Council, Over the last twenty years, I can say, no one in Jackson, in my opinion, has done more for our city, Ben Allen is genulnely a good man. Sincerely, wef R (jy Loland R speed Sie Chairman Emeritus afd Directdr EastGroup Properties LRS/Ib SUITE 09 « JHCRSON, MS SI2I52 ‘semcentgropinet {POST OME BOX 2728 + JACKSON, MS 39225.2728» 190 EAST CAPITOL SH TEL Got 354-3555 © PAX GO 352-1141» INTERNE ADDIE67. KANE DITTO State Street Group Jackson, MississippiSN StateStreetGroup February 24, 2017 Honorable Winston L. Kidd 407 Fast Pascayeula Street Jackson, MS 39205, Dear Judge Kidd have known Ben Allen for about twenty years. I have worked with him when he was a member of the Jackson City Couneil, and [have worked closely with him in his capacity as President of Downtown Jackson Partners. We worked together on improvements and programs to enhance the downtown area. We also worked on legislation to benefit the downtown area and the entre city. Ben has always been very collegial in his approach to city development, He worked closely with groups trying to set up an organization similar to DIP on Highwvay 80 and County Line Road. always found Ben to be a very hard worker and a very capable advocate for downtown Jackson ‘and the entire city. 1 also found him to be honest and forthright in his dealings with me and other members of the Jackson community. Nothing was more important to Ben than making Jackson a better place to live for all of its citizens. hope that you consider favorably Ben’s request to be placed on probation pending the appeal of the verdict in his case. T believe his unselfish dedication to our city qualifies him for leniency while he tries to get on with his life. With best wishes, Iam Very truly yours, IKD/da so2uerens Fak Ove Sule A Rds Msp 9987 “P.O ox 1505, uchson Mati 229801 Se 44S TEL 6011S Fae eases com68. ALAN LANGE JACKSON, MISSISSIPPIAlan Lange 222 Ridge Drive Jackson, MS 39216 February 24, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Gircult Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Judge Kidd: I've had the pleasure of knowing Ben Allen for the last twenty years both personally and professionally, and | am writing this letter to urge you to provide a sentence that does not involve jail time for Mr. Allen while his conviction is on appeal. I've watched Ben both up close and from a distance provide leadership to the entire City of Jackson through his distinguished service record as a City Councilman as well as his involvement in various business and civic organizations. Ben is one of the few people | can name that lends his time and talent to almost any cause that he assesses is in the best interest of the community. He has a demonstrable track record as a bridge builder in the City of Jackson and has always sought to make substantial inroads at being a connective point between different parts of our community. His success in the business world followed by his record of accomplishment with DUP speaks volumes as to his honesty and character. The volume of similar letters you aro getting along with mine probably speaks to those points even more pointedly. | don't think I've ever heard of a case an embezzlement case was prosecuted In spite of the fact that the alleged victim (in this case DJP) disputed the matter and actually vigorously testified on behalf of the defendant. It would be an unspeakable travesty to render a sentence involving jail time only to have a subsequent court reverse or remand the verdict. | urge your consideration of a moderate sentencing approach in this matter. ‘Thank you for your time and consideration. Sigely, lan Lan69. STEVEN G. ROGERS JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI FOUNDER, ROGERS AND ASSOCIATES, LLCFebruary 24, 2017 ‘The Honorable Winston L. Kidd Hinds County Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Judge Kidd, Lam writing to you as a long time Jacksonian and former CEO of Parkway Properties to ask you to respectfully consider leniency regarding the matters of Ben Allen's recent trial, Ben has done so much for our community. His selfless service to all of our citizens while serving on the Jackson City Council is evidence of this commitment, He was elected president of the Council and presided over many important changes that helped our city grow and prosper. After serving our ‘was appointed as the leader for the Jackson's downtown development authority where he has served faithfully and effectively for many years. Ben is widely respected for his efforts to help bring back business and commerce to our capitol city and act a great ambassador for all things Jackson, he Tunderstand that he may have made mistakes....we all do. Tonly ask you to consider his total life of contribution rather than a small sampling of it when you ‘make your judgment regarding his sentencing and consider leniency in this matter. My heart is hurting for Ben and his family.... trust you to make the best determination of the outcome Sincerely, Steven G. Rogers Founder Rogers and Associates, LLC70. RICK CALHOON 217 West Capitol Street, Suite 201 Jackson, MS 39201 Pruet Oil Company, LLC Jackson, MSPRUET OIL COMPANY LLC 217 Weer Carirol SrRcer/SUITE 201 * JACKSON, Mississire! 39201 February 27, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Cireuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Re: Ben Allen Dear Sir: This letter is to offer support and testament for Mr. Ben Allen as relates to his sentencing hearing in your court. have personally known Mr, Allen for approximately 35 years as well as his wonderful family, 1 have always known Ben to be an honorable man with the highest of character traits. He is an affable person with many friends from all walks of life. I not only know him personally, but professionally, as a long term property owner in downtown Jackson, Our property is a building next to the old King Edward Hotel (Hilton). We renovated our building in 1980 and have officed here during good and bad times and have committed to seeing downtown revitalized. ‘We have always been a dues paying member to Downtown Jackson Partners and have supported them in other ways. Our reason for supporting them is because we believe in Mr. Allen’s energy, abilities, and his sincere desite to see us rebuild Downtown Jackson. We credit him with making downtown revitalization a reality, with more projects on the way. I see buildings being renovated ‘out of my window across the street as I write, Mr. Allen and his family have endured much pain and embarrassment as a result of his trial, Fortunately, the outeome was positive except for one issue, which P’m told was resolved long. before charges were filed. Therefore, I respectfully request that your Honorable Court please dismiss this charge, and put this behind us for the benefit of the Aliens and for the betterment of Downtown Jackson,‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd February 27, 2017 Page Two Should you need to verify my thoughts, please feel free to contact me at 601-946-7800. We know you are faced with tough decisions on a daily basis, and we respect you and appreciate ‘what you do for our legal system, Thank you for listening, Very truly yours, PRUET OIL COMPANY LLC Rick Calhoon RIC/bb71. FRANKIE BOX Post Office Box 232 Madison, MS 39130 A Friend of Ben Allen’s Since 1968ele _ bok vA 7 ZGE Pddeion=, tein (Ne FALSE steele72. SUNNY DESAIMarch 1, 2017 Honorable Winston L. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Dear Honorable Winston L. Kidd, First off, thenk you for your time and attention to this letter, I wanted to write you in order describe to ‘you the Benjamin Allen that I have the pleasure of knowing. Throughout the past few years of knowing Ben, he has stood out to me in more ways than one, His generosity and involvement in the community are a great Influence to those around him, Ben is involved in the Boy Scouts, many boards and commissions and city ‘council 3 terms. He also invests a great deal of his time in coaching youth sports along with volunteering at his church home. For the past three years I have known Ben to be an honest and trustworthy man who cares greatly about his community and his family. Sincerely, ‘Sunny Desal73. NIC LOTT Jackson, Mississippi‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kidd Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 ‘To the Honorable Judge Kidd: Please accept this letter of support for my friend Len Allen, Pye known Ben and his family since I moved to Jackson in 2003. Over those years, I've watched him work hard to better the lives of those around him. ‘Whether it was working on projects for the people he represented as a Counsilman or finding a way to assist individuals in need, he has been a tireless force working for the betterment of others, He is a man of integrity, eompassion and devotion to being a servant in the community, His efforts have contributed to positive growth and economie gain for our capital city. In my interactions with and observations of Ben, his character has been revealed most through his love for and commitment to his family, his friends, and the eitizens of Jackson, Ben has always extended a friendly smile and a helping hhand when those around him needed him most. He’s a good! man, a good public servant, and a good friend. It is my hope you will take to heart my comments when making a decision regarding his future, “Thank you. Sincerely, Nic Lott74, CYNTHIA BUCHANAN P. O. Box 22548 201 South President Street Jackson, MS 39225-2548 Vice President of the Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership in Jackson, MS. * Greater Jackson Chamber PARTNERSHIP MISSISSIPPI March 1, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge L. Winston Kidd Ciccult judge District 3 407 Bast Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205, Dear Judge Kidd: ‘My name ig Cynthia Buchanan, Vice President of the Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership in Jackson, MS. lam writing on behalf of Ben Allen whom I've known and worked with for the past 8 years, Ben is a selfless, extraordinary leader ofthis community whose passion for Jackson is only outdone by his devotion to his family. Ben has served on the Jackson Chamber Board since 2008, So I've worked with him on numerous projects and have seen first- hand his countless contributions to this community. Ben's goals in life are to make Jackson a world-class city and to give young people a platform to be heard and included. Ben creates a welcoming cliniate for entrepreneurs who want to invest In Jackson. [can recall the time when Craig Noone aspired to open a restaurant in Jackson. The first person he talked to was Ben Allen. Ben encouraged him, walked him through the process, and helped alleviate any barriers. Today Parlor Market is one of the top restaurants in Jackson: ‘This is just one of many occasions I personally know of in which Ben has encouraged and assisted businesses. | also remember a time when a downtown business was financially dramed and met with numerous individuals seeking a loan, When others sald no, Ben didn't, Although he Inew it would be tough, he found a way to get assistance for this business. Ben always seems to find a way to help people and businesses in Jackson get to "yes." Ben also has a heart for young people. In most meetings, you will hear him say that his, mission is to set the foundation and then hand it off to young people, Ben is constantly seeking ways to get young people engaged in this community and develop them as leaders. He's always thinking of others and is inclusive of all people. Thave witnessed many of Ben's acts of kindness over the past years. He has always been personally supportive of me, especially when I and others were new to the Chamber, His encouragement and support helped us to succeed, Also, Ihave served on Downtown Jackson Partners Advisory Board and am aware of the events that have taken place, I plead with you to show mercy for Ben Allen. He is a leader 720, Box 22548, 201 South Pesident See, Jackson, Missi 9225 2548 (601) 940-7676, FAX (ot) 352-8500 \wreatjacksonpeteship.comwho works hard for this community and inspires us all to keep fighting for Jackson. This. commiinity needs him, His passion for this city is contagious and it catches on to people ‘who surround him. One lit candle can light many candles, and that is what Ben does. His energy radiates this entire community, We need that candle to continue burning in our community. ‘Thank you for your consideration, Sincerely, Cynthia Ho us Vice President Greater Jackson Chamber Partnership75. FOSTER KENNEDY Jackson, MississippiMarch 1, 2017 ‘The Honorable Judge Winston Kid Circuit Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, MS 39205 Judge Kidd, am writing this letter in xegards to Bon Allen's recent trial and upcoming sentencing, As a 38 year old native Jacksonian, I have known Mr, Allen the majority of my life. T grew up as best firicnds with his youngest son Clayton. We lived around the comer from each other from the time we were born until approximately 18 years of ago. ‘To say I spent a lot of days and nights at the Allen household is an understatement, On a personal level, onc of the greatest experience and achievements of my life is participating in Boy Scouts of America and obtaining the rank of Eagle Scout, I can honestly say if it was not for the guidance of Mr, Allen as Scout Master (Troop 8 First ‘Baptist Church of Jackson), this accomplishment would not have been achieved. Mr. Allen committed countless hours of his ‘own personal time over 5 years serving and impacting the lives of 11-18 year old boys and guiding thom to become men who would serve as leaders in thelr communities and country, Boy Scouts of America has its own code of conduct as is defined through the Scout Oath and Scout Law. The Scout Oath and Scout Law read as follows: ‘Scout Oath On my honor I will do my best fo do my duty to God and my country and to obey the Scout Law; to help other people at all times; to keep myself physically strong, mentally awake, and morally straight,‘Scout Law A Scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean, and reverent, Treforonce the Scout Oath and Scout Law for one reason, ‘The values desoribed in the Scout Oath and Scout Law are values that define Ben Allen and they are values he instilled in hundreds of young men through his countless number of hours serving as Scout Master for ‘Troop 8, In my opinion, the evidence of an individual's character is often reflected in their children, Mr. Allen has raised two of the most outstanding children, Clayton and Matt, Both Clayton and Matt srew up as leaders among their peers. They were diligent students, active in the community, extremely hard workers, and have impeccable eharaoter, They have both gone on to be led in them at an early age by their father and are a true reflection of the person Ben Allen is, Ben Allen is one of the finest individuals I have ever known, His charaoter is impeccable, He has served this community tirelessly and unselfishly, He has impacted hundreds of young men who have also gone on fo serve this community and our country. It is my hope you will take the true character of Ben Allen into consideration as you discern Mr. Allen’s future as it relates to this matter, Sincerely, Foster Kenned76. STEVE DAVIS 308 East Pearl Street, Suite 101 Electric 308 Building Jackson, MS 39201 Chairman — Downtown Jackson PartnersMarch 1, 2017 Honorable Winston L. Kidd Circuit Court Judge District 3 407 East Pascagoula Street Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Dear Honorable Winston L. Kidd: The Board Members of Downtown Jackson Partners, Inc. promote the economic and social health of the City of Jackson. As active businessman and women in the Jackson Community, we take our role on the DJP Board of Directors seriously. The DIP Board is comprised of diverse members interested in the economic growth of Jackson. Mr. Ben Allen has been serving as President of DJP since 2007. Under Mr. Allen’s 'eadership, DIP has become more involved than ever before in the economic growth of Jackson, There has been a renewed interest in Jackson. Ben is one of Jackson’s greatest supporters. He has worked to develop support for projects which enhance Jackson, such as the repaving of Capitol Street and the construction of the Jackson Art Lofts. He was instrumental in founding Team Jackson, a group committed to the growth and success of all of Jackson. ‘As members of the Jackson business community, we ask that you grant unto Mr. Allen a sentence of probation. This will allow Mr. Allen to continue to serve Downtown Jackson Partners and the city of Jackson. We understand Mr. Allen will seek through his attorneys to appeal the decision of the jury, and we obviously support that decision. Nevertheless, Mr. Allen has been a long-time resident of Jackson. He has been active in his church, kid’s sports, Boy Scouts, and numerous other community projects and events. He is a good, decent person. He has never been convicted of any crime and we believe he will continue to serve his community well. Thank you for your time and attention, C Steve Davis, Chairman Downtown Jackson Partners In, Bec 308 Bung {0 est Pe Suet ‘Sue 101, Jaca, Mssigp 38001 601-353.9800 Iy's pownrown 6013533169 ‘domtounjetsoncon