Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I-2015
Abstract-This paper explores the power grid discussed. Section IV discusses the test systems under
segmentation concept for power system stability study in this research. Section V compares and analyzes
improvement in detail. First, the firewall property of the simulation results. Section VI contains the
grid segmentation is investigated for a two area conclusion.
network. Then two HVDC technologies, LCC and
VSC, are compared for the same network. A two area II. LITERATURE REVIEW
VSC-AC segmented network is then compared with
two area VSC segmented network. Suitable The advantages and disadvantages of HVDC
segmentation topology and suitable number of VSC system have been discussed in [i]. HVDC system has
segmented areas are then investigated. Simulation found many applications, like power transmission over
results show that grid segmentation offers network a long distance, power transmission through cables,
stability during fault conditions and VSC is the most offshore transmission, power transmission to urban
suitable choice for segmentation over LCC. Results areas and grid segmentation, since its evolution in the
further show that having large number of DC late 1950s [i-iii].
segmented areas and using the radial segmentation The main components of HVDC system have been
topology improves the stability of the overall system. discussed in detail in [iii-iv]. Convertor is an integral
All the simulations were carried out in PSSE software component of HVDC system. There are three convertor
provided by SIEMENS. technologies available namely line commutated
current source (LCC), capacitor commutated
Keywords- HVDC System, Grid Segmentation, convertors (CCC) and voltage source convertors
Stability, Voltage Source Convertors, Line (VSC).
Commutated Convertors. Grid segmentation is one of the modern
applications of HVDC technology in which a huge
I. INTRODUCTION power grid is divided into smaller segments which are
then connected to each other through HVDC links. The
In the earlier days, DC (direct current) systems concept of grid segmentation was introduced by
were used for electrical power generation, transmission authors in [v-viii]. Increased reliability of renewable
and distribution. Due to low voltage levels and high sources integration [ix], efficient congestion
losses associated with DC systems in the past, the management [ix], improvement in power system
electrical power generating sources had to be located stability, power transfer capability and reduction of
very close to the electrical loads. With the invention of cascading outages and blackouts are the proposed
AC system, particularly the transformer, the problems advantages of grid segmentation [vi -xi].
of high transmission line losses and location of The authors concluded that VSC-HVDC
generating stations were solved. The development of technology gave better transient stability results than
power electronics and semi conductor devices LCC-HVDC technology and HVAC after studying a
resulted in significant improvement in the system two-area hybrid HVDC-HVAC system. A three phase
for transmitting DC power at high voltage levels. short circuit fault was applied and bus voltage, bus
This system is called high voltage direct current angle, generator speed and rotor angle were analyzed
(HVDC) system. [xii]. Two-area power network containing VSC-HVDC
This paper is structured as follows. In section II, links gave better results, with respect to system
merits and demerits of HVDC system, its latest stability, than that containing pure AC links.
applications and research work carried out in power Generation loss and tripping of transmission lines were
grid segmentation is discussed. In section III core the disturbances applied [xiii]. A two area network
HVDC technologies and power system stability is containing VSC-HVDC links in parallel with AC links
39
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
is shown to be more stable than that containing only the provide reactive power compensation automatically
AC links [xiv]. and improve voltage stability by providing
The research work presented in this paper is commutation voltage.
divided into four cases. In the first case, a comparison
between LCC, VSC and AC segmentation schemes is C. VSC-HVDC technology
made for a two area network. This network is not a VSC stands for voltage source convertors. This
hybrid HVDC-HVAC network as in [xii]. Second case technology is also known as HVDC LIGHT or HVDC
investigates whether it is better to segment a power grid PLUS. In this technology, self commutated IGBTs are
by VSC links only or segment it by VSC links in used for switching purpose. Reactive power is not
parallel with an AC link. The third case involves the consumed by VSC-HVDC convertors. They improve
study of the effect of increasing the number of HVDC- voltage regulation of AC system and can be used as a
segmented areas on the stability of the overall system. source of balanced three phase voltage. There is no
The fourth case involves study of three possible commutation problem in this technology. The authors
connection topologies of grid segmentation using VSC in [iii-iv] have done detailed comparison of LCC and
links. LCC and VSC links refer to HVDC transmission VSC convertors.
lines based on LCC and VSC convertor technologies
respectively. All the simulations were carried out in 3.2 Power system stability
PSSE software provided by SIEMENS. Stability of a power system is divided into three
categories; Rotor angle, Voltage and frequency
III. CORE HVDC TECHNOLOGIES AND stability. Rotor angle stability gives idea about
POWER SYSTEM STABILITY synchronism of synchronous machines after a
disturbance in the power system. A power system is
3.1 Core HVDC technologies voltage and frequency stable if all of its buses maintain
The different HVDC technologies present are: the steady state voltage and frequency respectively after
a) LCC / CSC (Classical) HVDC a disturbance [xv]. In this paper the first two categories
b) CCC-HVDC of stability are considered while speed of the generator
c) VSC-HVDC/ HVDC PLUS/ HVDC LIGHT is considered to study the frequency stability. The rotor
angle studied in this paper is relative to the swing bus.
A. LCC- HVDC technology
LCC stands for line commutated current source IV. SYSTEM UNDER STUDY
convertor. This technology is also called CSC or
classical HVDC. In this technology, thyristors are used Three cases are studied in this paper. In all of the
for switching purpose. The switching circuit consists of cases, all of the generators, along with their exciters and
three phase full wave bridge. A strong synchronous turbine governors, use built-in models of the software.
voltage source is required for commutation [ii].
Case 1
B. CCC- HVDC technology In this case the system shown in Fig. 1 is used as a
CCC stands for capacitor commutated convertors. test case provided by NTDC (National Transmission
In this technology, series capacitors are connected and Dispatch Company) limited Pakistan. It is a two-
between valves (built up with thyristor modules area four machine network. Bus 12 and 25 are the swing
connected in series) and convertor transformers. They buses. Three scenarios are studied; Scenario A: Area 1
Fig. 1. Two-area four machine network under study for case 1 and case 2
40
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
Case 2
In this case the system that is studied is shown in
Fig.1. Three scenarios are studied; Scenario D: In this
scenario, only an AC link is present between bus 11 and
20 (AC segmentation). Scenario E: VSC link is
connected in parallel with an AC link between bus 11
and 20 (VSC-AC segmentation). Scenario F: Only VSC
link is connected between bus 11 and 20 (VSC
segmentation). (2b)
Case 3
In this case of the research three scenarios are
studied for a four area system each containing a
generator , load , three buses and three transmission
lines; Scenario G: The system under study is as shown
in Fig. 2a. It's a two area VSC-segmented network i.e.
area 1 and 2 are separated by a VSC link. Scenario H: In
this case there are two VSC links between areas 1, 2 and
3 as shown in fig. 2b. It's a three area VSC-segmented
network. Scenario I: In this case there are three VSC
links between areas 1, 2, 3 and 4 as shown in fig. 2c. It's
a four area VSC-segmented network. Bus 1, 4, 7 and 10
are the swing buses.
(2c)
Case 4
In this case of research, four types of connection
topologies of a four area network are studied; Type 1:
All the areas are interconnected to each other by AC
links as shown in fig. 3a. Type 2: All the areas are
connected in a ring as shown in fig. 3b. Type 3: All the
areas are interconnected by VSC links as shown in
Fig. 3c. Type 4: All the areas are radially connected as
shown in Fig. 3d. Bus 1, 4, 7 and 10 are the swing buses.
(2a)
41
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
(3d)
Fig. 3. Four area network under study for case 4. (a)
(3a) Type 1: AC interconnection (b) Type 2: Ring topology
(c) Type 3: VSC interconnection (d) Type 4: Radial
topology
42
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
700
Rotor Angle (DEGREES) 600 1.1
1
500
(4a)
(4d)
50
0.02
40 0.018
0.015
0.013
30
0.01
0.008
20 0.005
0.002
10 0
-0.003
-0.005
0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
(4b)
80
70
60
(4e)
50
Fig. 4. Plots of different parameters of generator
Reactive Power (pu)
0 600
Rotor angle (Degrees)
-10 500
-20 400
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Time (seconds)
300
(4c) 200
100
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
(5a)
43
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
4,000 700
Rotor Angle (Degrees) 3,500 600
28 Case 2
27
The disturbance applied is 3 phase bus fault at
bus 1. Duration of fault is 0.18sec. Simulation results
26
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 are shown in Fig. 7a-7e. Each plot represents different
Time (seconds) parameters of bus 20 generator. In each plot the red,
Green and yellow curves represent scenarios D, E and F
respectively.
350
(5c)
300
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
450
400 250
350
Rotor Angle (Degrees)
200
300
150
250
200 100
150
50
100
50 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
0 Time (seconds)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
(7a)
(5d)
44
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
55 0.01
0.008
50
ACTIVE POWER (pu)
35 -0.003
30
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
(7e)
1.05
A three phase bus fault is applied at bus 10 for 0.18
1 sec. Simulation results are shown in Fig. 8-11. In
Fig. 8-11 the red, green, yellow and blue curves
0.95
represent parameters of generator at bus 10, 7, 4 and 1
0.9 respectively.
700
0.85
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
600
0.8
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 500
Time (seconds)
400
300
200
100
(7d) 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds)
(8a)
45
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
800
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
well like generator active power (Fig. 10a-10c) and
700
speed deviation (Fig.11a-11c) as well. Hence it is
600
concluded that having large number of DC segmented
500 areas improves overall system stability.
400
300
1
200
100 .75
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0.5
Time (seconds)
.25
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds)
(8b)
700
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
600
500
(9a)
400
300
200
1
100
0 .75
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds)
0.5
.25
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
(8c) Time (seconds)
46
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
25 0.015
15 0.007
0.005
10
0.002
0
5
-0.003
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds) Time (seconds)
(10a) (11a)
25
0.015
0.01
15 0.007
0.005
10
0.002
5 0
-0.003
0
-0.005
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (seconds)
(10b)
(11b)
25
0.013
SPEED DEVIATION (pu)
20 0.01
Active Power (pu)
0.007
15
0.005
10 0.002
0
5
-0.003
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 5
Time (seconds) Time (seconds)
(10c) (11c)
Fig. 10 Active Power plots for different scenarios of Fig. 11. Generator Speed deviation plots for different
case 3 (a) Scenario G: two area VSC-segmented scenarios of case 3 (a) Scenario G: two area VSC-
network (b) Scenario H: three area VSC-segmented segmented network (b) Scenario H: three area VSC-
network (c) Scenario I: four area VSC-segmented segmented network (c) Scenario I: four area VSC-
network segmented network
47
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
1,000
Case 4
800 0
700
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
-250
600 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds)
500
400
300
200
100
(12d)
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 Fig. 12. Rotor angle plots for different connection
Time (seconds)
types (a) Type 1: AC interconnection (b) Type 2: Ring
topology (c) Type 3: VSC interconnection (d) Type 4:
Radial topology
600
500
is negligible while area 2 (green curve) and 4 (blue
400
curve) experience change. Fig. 12c represents rotor
300
angle for connection type 3 and shows that all the areas
200 experience rotor angle change but less than the one they
100 experienced in type 1 connection.
0 Fig. 12d represents rotor angle for connection type
-100 4 and shows that area 3 and 4 under goes negligible
-200 rotor angle change.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Time (seconds) Area 4 is affected in type 2 connection because it is
directly attached to the area, where fault occurred,
through VSC link while in type 4 connection it is
indirectly attached to fault area 1 and hence remained
unaffected. Similarly all the areas in type 3 connection
is affected because of their direct connection with the
(12b) fault area 1 through VSC links.
This research shows that type 4 connection (radial)
1,250
is the best as more number of areas is stable. Further,
areas farther away from fault area are more stable. Also
ROTOR ANGLE (DEGREES)
1,000
this type of connection uses minimum number of VSC
750
links as compared to type 3 and type 4 connection and
500 hence reduction in the overall system cost.
250
VI. CONCLUSIONS
0
-250
In this paper, the concept of grid segmentation was
0 5 10 15 20
Time (seconds)
25 30 35 thoroughly explored in four cases. Case 1 concludes
that HVDC segmentation acts as a firewall by
minimizing the propagation of disturbance to healthy
areas of the power network. In this case it is also
concluded that Voltage source convertor (VSC)
technology, when used alone, is better than the line
(12c) commutated convertor (LCC) technology for grid
48
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 20 No. I-2015
49