Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tank Cleaning
Automation
Author:
Christine Pagcatipunan
Spraying Systems Co., USA
Overview
Automating the cleaning of tanks, totes, vats, vessels Understanding the Available Options
or any other type of container offers many benefits. Spray technology fundamentals and effect on cleaning
Typically, the top reason to automate is to improve efficiency:
cleaning thoroughness. However, the reduction of
maintenance time/production downtime is also a Flow design
compelling and motivating factor. Other common Flow rate
reasons include improving worker safety, reducing
consumption of expensive cleaning chemicals/solvents
Spray pattern
and lowering wastewater disposal costs. Spray coverage
Proper selection of a tank cleaning solution requires
Shadowing
collaboration between process plant personnel and the Spray distance
tank wash equipment manufacturer. Cleaning objectives Spray impact
are specific to a manufacturing process and should
be established by plant personnel. A variety of options Cycle time
is available tank wash nozzles for clean-in-place
(CIP), motorized tank washers, automatic retractable Understanding Possible Solutions
motorized tank washers and turnkey systems offering Clean-in-place (CIP) nozzles/systems
complete automation and it is essential to consider
your short- and long-term needs to ensure you make the
CIP or portable motorized tank washers
right buying decision. The discussion within addresses Retractable motorized tank washers
the following: Lances and strainers
Automated tank cleaning systems
Cleaning Criteria
What is the residue to be cleaned? Final Product Selection
What cleaning is required to remove the residue? Identifying the option that best meets
cleaning objectives
What is the temperature of the cleaning liquid?
Determining materials of construction
What is the reason for cleaning?
Installation considerations: CIP, portable,
What level of cleaning is required? physical layout
What flow design is used? Monitoring and validation requirements
What are the dimensions of the tank?
Are there obstructions within the tank?
How many tanks need to be cleaned?
How often do they need to be cleaned?
What is the size of the porthole and where is it
located?
What equipment is available?
Introduction
Process improvement and cost reduction are key The first step in setting objectives requires
motivators for any plant. As a result, automated tank evaluation of the product residue. A product
cleaning is increasing in popularity. A change in tank residue is defined as any material left behind
cleaning methods can result in dramatic increases which should be washed away before another
in production uptime, a reduction in the amount of batch of product arrives.
labor required for cleaning and cost savings on water,
cleaning chemicals, energy and wastewater disposal. Forms of Residue
There are other benefits as well improved worker
safety and elimination of the need for Vessel Entry Residue that does not stick to the surface and can
Permits required by OSHA. be cleaned easily.
Nearly all totes, tanks, vessels and vats contain product Residue that does not wash away quickly but can
residue that must be removed between batches or at be dissolved by the cleaning liquid.
routine intervals in continuous operations. Historically,
Residue that does not dissolve in the cleaning
two methods have been used for tank cleaning:
liquid but requires spray impact to break it up and
wash it away.
The Manual Method. A worker physically cleans
a tank and may need to actually enter the tank
to do so. This raises safety concerns about tank The second step is to identify a cleaning liquid
entry/exit and exposure to toxic fumes from that will react with the product residue to wash
cleaning agents. The Manual Method often it away or dissolve it. Once youve identified the
results in inconsistent cleaning and the use cleaning liquid, consider its temperature and
of more cleaning chemicals and water than material compatibility. This will be important
necessary. when selecting the tank wash nozzles/system for
your application.
The Fill and Drain Method. Tanks are usually
hosed down and then filled with hot water or a The third step is to determine what level of
mix of water and cleaning/sanitizing agents. The cleaning is required:
tank may be drained and rinsed several times
before use. This method is time-consuming and Cleaning Levels
utilizes significant amounts of water, cleaning
chemicals and energy. It also can keep a tank out Removes the majority of product
Rinsing
of production for several hours. residue with water.
Loosens and removes product residue
Cleaning
Many plants find they can save tens of thousands of with water and a cleaning agent.
dollars annually by automating their tank cleaning Includes the application of sanitizing
process. Facilities with several tanks have reported agents to all surfaces (per chemical
savings of more than $100,000 per year. Determining if Sanitizing
supplier instructions). Micro-organisms
you could benefit similarly through automation begins are killed to an acceptable level.
with a close look at your cleaning objectives.
Kills 100% of most bacteria, not
Disinfecting
spores.
Sterilizing Destroys or eliminates all forms of life.
Establishing Cleaning
Objectives Once youve established your cleaning objectives it
is time to focus on tank washing technology so you
The primary objective of tank cleaning is to clean, understand how to evaluate your options.
maintain and sanitize equipment at appropriate levels
to prevent malfunctions or contamination that would
alter the safety, identity, strength, quality or purity of
the finished product. Each tank cleaning application is
unique and finding the best automated solution requires
collaboration between plant personnel and the tank
wash equipment manufacturer.
A Guide to Tank Cleaning Automation
Automated Tank Washing: general, under equal operating conditions, solid stream
sprays provide the greatest impact, followed by flat fan
Spray Technology and full cone sprays.
Spray Coverage
Spray Pattern
Typical coverages include 180 up, 180 down, 270 up,
Most spray balls and tank wash nozzles generate a 270 down and 360. Use the least amount of coverage
solid stream, flat fan or full cone spray. Your cleaning required to achieve your cleaning objectives and
requirements will determine the pattern you need. In minimize water usage and wastewater disposal.
Spray Coverage
180 up 180 down 270 up 270 down 360
Shadowing For any given nozzle, this is the total impact, neglecting
When a spray cannot directly reach part of the all losses that an equivalent solid stream nozzle would
vessel because of an internal obstruction, it is called have when operating at the same pressure and with the
shadowing. Common obstructions include mixers, same flow as the given nozzle.
agitators or filling tubes. The challenge is to clean both
Effects of flow rate on impact: Using the equation
the shadowed area and the obstruction itself. Multiple
below, it is evident that increasing flow rate is more
nozzles may be needed to cover the entire internal
effective than increasing pressure to increase impact.
surface.
The table below shows that doubling the flow rate
increases impact as much as 100%, while doubling
pressure provides only 40% more impact.
Effects of spray distance on impact: The actual impact Cleaning Cycle Time
of a solid stream nozzle is close to theoretical when There are four common cleaning stages. In many cases,
12 (30 cm) away from the nozzle. The further the spray if cleaning effectiveness falls short, more thorough
is from the nozzle, the impact efficiency lessens. Below cleaning can be achieved by extending the time of one
is an example of the impact values taken at various or more stages.
distances for a solid stream nozzle.
of the residue.
Lviv>i>}i
This stage involves the application
of the chemical. Using cleaning
detergents will chemically remove
contamination or surface film,
working with the soil over a period
of time. Consult your chemical
&T supplier to determine the optimal
Cleaning residence time for your process.
-ETERS
With water-based chemicals,
,>`>>Vi increasing temperature will also
improve cleaning action. However,
Data showing the decrease in impact as distance is
increased from the nozzles orifice should be available heating the cleaning liquid can be
from the manufacturer. expensive. Clean vessels at room
temperature if possible.
Effects of pressure on impact: Operate at the
lowest possible pressure for your specific cleaning During this stage, suspended
requirements. If more impact is required, consider residue and cleaning agents
increasing flow rate instead of pressure to get twice Post-Rinse are removed. Rinse time will be
the impact. Increasing pressure may actually decrease determined by the absence of
impact as the spray will start to atomize into smaller residue.
droplets and lose its cleaning effectiveness.
If required, the chemical
Effects of rotational speed on impact: When increasing
Sanitizing manufacturer will provide
pressure to achieve faster cleaning cycle times, be
instructions for cycle time.
aware that faster rotational speed can compromise
cleaning impact and efficiency. The spray rotates so
fast that energy dissipates as the spray is no longer a Depending on the application, cleaning can be done in as
controlled pattern when it hits the tank surface. The little as a minute or take up to 45 minutes or more.
spray needs solid contact with the tank surface with Most cleaning cycles fall within the 10 to 30 minute range.
enough time to clean the residue.
Automated Tank Wash
Product Options
Clean-In-Place (CIP) Nozzles/Systems
ClP systems usually consist of spray balls or spray
nozzles permanently mounted on pipes over a tank.
These nozzles typically operate at low pressures
and offer economical and reliable performance. It is
important to understand the various operating methods
and performance of nozzles commonly used in CIP
applications in order to make the best selection. The Fixed spray balls provide low-pressure washing and
chart that follows compares the options. rinsing of tanks.
Nozzles are free Rinsing and Higher impact, good overall cover-
Fluid-Driven Reactionary spinning, increas- cleaning of tanks age, reduced fluid requirements.
Force ing rotational 3 to 25 (0.9 m
velocity as pres- to 7.6 m) with a Material options include TEFLON,
sure to the nozzle choice of solid stainless steel and Kynar.
increases. stream or flat fan Sanitary 3A connections. Some
spray patterns. are self-draining; some are avail-
able without O-rings for sanitary
applications.
As speed increases, the spray
decreases in focus.
Clogging could prevent rotation
especially if water supply isnt
clean.
Fluid-Driven Constant Nozzles use the Cleaning and The slow rotational speed
Speed momentum of sanitizing of improves impact and throw
the liquid flow to tanks 12 to 20 compared to reactionary force
drive the nozzles (3.7 m to 6 m). nozzles.
spray head while
constant rotat- Good filtration is needed to keep
ing speed is contaminating particles away from
maintained. Fluid the gears so that rotation wont be
pressure can be blocked.
adjusted indepen- Low liquid consumption.
dently providing
adjustments in
impact force.
A Guide to Tank Cleaning Automation
CIP or Portable Motorized Tank Washers Provide The units can be taken from tank to tank or permanently
High-Impact Cleaning installed. The distance between tanks, cleaning cycle
frequency, the number of tanks, the flow system design
Another option is high-pressure motor-driven tank
and labor availability are key considerations when
washers. These units are typically used to clean tanks
choosing between portability and permanency.
ranging in size from 8 to 80 (2.4 to 24.4 m) in diameter
that require more thorough cleaning.
Disadvantages
As with any mechanical device, some
maintenance is required.
Priced higher than fixed spray nozzles or fluid-
driven reactionary force and constant speed
nozzles. Performance, long service life and
minimal maintenance time/costs may offset the
higher cost. Motorized tank washer Motorized tank washer
with electric motor. with air motor.
Retractable Motorized Tank Washers Provide a Ensure Efficient Fluid Delivery to Nozzles with
Higher Level of Automation Lances and Strainers
Some motorized tank washers offer a higher level of
To ensure optimal performance, tank cleaning nozzles
automation if the units can be permanently installed in
need consistent and efficient delivery of the cleaning fluid.
the tank. Designed for use with tanks up to 40 (12 m)
The devices that feed the nozzles are called tank wash
in diameter, these units include a pneumatic retraction
lances and they can have a significant impact on overall
mechanism that lowers and raises the tank washer from performance.
the tank. Manual lifting of the unit is eliminated as is
clogging resulting from the nozzles being left in the tank Lances are available in different lengths for optimal
when not in use. positioning of the nozzles within the tank to provide overall
coverage or address heavily soiled areas or skim lines.
Easy-to-use control options are available that allow
multiple stopping points between full insertion and full
retraction to position the nozzles where more impact is
required or to clean around obstructions. The control
panel is often located away from the tank for safety or
convenience.
Retractable tank washers can operate at pressures
up to 4000 psi (275 bar) to ensure removal of even the Tank wash lance
Tank wash lance
with threadless
most difficult residues. The units can be equipped nozzle for use
with dual nozzle
with either a two- or four-nozzle hub and a manual or assembly for
in sanitary
programmable control panel. Optional features include rinsing deep tanks.
applications.
explosion-proof designs, isolation valves to ensure liquid
cannot escape from the tank when the tank washer is
retracted and liquid valves and liquid pressure switches Additional lance considerations include flange type, pipe
to control water flow and monitor water pressure. fitting/connector, pipe/tube size and material.
A Guide to Tank Cleaning Automation
10
Other validation techniques include taking cultures proof environments are all options to consider. Some
with swabs to verify the desired level of disinfection tank wash nozzles are ATEX certified which fulfill
has been achieved. Also, measuring the conductivity the European EC-Directive 94/9/EC Equipment and
or resistivity of the water or the cleaning agent will Protective Systems for Use in Potentially Explosive
determine if contamination is present. Atmospheres.
11
A Guide to Tank Cleaning Automation
Selecting the Right Tank A broad product line, a proven track record and
references are essential. Ask about access to
Cleaning Products application specialists to ensure problem solving
assistance will be available if needed. It is also a
If you believe you can benefit from automated tank good idea to request maintenance recommendations
cleaning, the next step is to identify the exact products early in the process, so you know how much time to
required. The checklist below may prove helpful. allocate and what type of future financial investments
In choosing an automated tank wash solution, be sure to may be required.
select a company that is willing to work with you.
Existing flow design and equipment. Lances for fluid delivery to the nozzles.
Ask your colleagues about their tank Talk to your nozzle supplier or identify
cleaning applications. companies that sell automated tank
cleaning equipment.
Identify two to three suppliers of tank cleaning equipment and request a no-obligation
on-site evaluation.