Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Optics Communications
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/optcom
art ic l e i nf o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Next-generation access networks require provision of wireless services and high data rate to meet the
Received 4 December 2014 huge demands for mobility and multiple services. Moreover, reusing the currently deployed optical
Received in revised form distribution networks (ODNs) is highly benecial and cost effective for providing the new high data rate
29 December 2014
wireless demands. In this paper, bidirectional radio over ber passive optical network (RoF-PON) capable
Accepted 13 January 2015
Available online 14 January 2015
of handling multiple-inputmultiple-output (MIMO) streams at low cost, high spectral efciency and
backward compatibility with currently deployed PON, is proposed. To the best of our knowledge, all the
Keywords: existing RoF MIMO solutions have not considered compatibility with currently deployed ODNs. Eight
Stacked TDM-PON laser diodes (LDs) at the central ofce (CO) are enough for the whole system, instead of having LD or
Next generation PON
optical transmitter at each remote antenna unit (RAU), which makes a colorless and cost-effective RAU.
Polarization multiplexing
Twenty four wavelengths are generated using optical comb technique. Each two 16-QAM MIMO signals
Radio over ber
Multiple-input multiple-output that have the same carrier frequency in the downstream (DS) transmission are optically combined using
polarization-division-multiplexing (PDM), where each two upstream (US) MIMO signals are time divi-
sion multiplexed. The PDM conguration doubles spectral efciency with a power penalty of only 1.5 dB.
The proposed architecture is a bidirectional asymmetric RoF-PON with total 40/10 Gb/s for DS/US
transmission. Even after transmission over 20 km SMF and splitting ratio of 32, acceptable transmission
performance and widely separated constellation diagrams for the 16-QAM signals are achieved, with bit
error rate (BER) of 10 6 for DS signals and 10 3 for the US signals which can be reduced down to 10 6 by
using forward error correction (FEC).
& 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.optcom.2015.01.040
0030-4018/& 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
56 M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564
Fig. 1. (a) Hybrid TDM/WDM-PON architecture and (b) stacked TDM-PON architecture.
group of optical network units (ONUs) selects its wavelength by a demonstrated. The drawback of this method is dedicating a wa-
tunable optical lter (TOF) by following the optical line terminal velength for each MIMO stream. In [14] polarization-division-
(OLT) commands in the central ofce (CO) [8]. TWDM-PON, also multipexing (PDM) is used to carry each MIMO stream at different
called broadcast-and-select WDM-PON, stacked TDM-PON or polarization of the same wavelength taking an advantage of the
multi-wavelength TDM-PON is one of the most promising candi- wavelength two polarizations.
date architectures for NG-PON due to its compatibility with the The solutions so far offered by researchers elsewhere have not
existing PON and WDM operation capability. considered compatibility with currently deployed ODNs. They are
For wireless broadband transmission, multiple-inputmultiple- proposed for typical WDM-PON or point to point communication.
output (MIMO) is an indispensable technique for all the new Moreover, since most of the currently deployed PON are based on
wireless standards and systems that require high data rate. MIMO TDM-PON ODN and considering that FSAN has selected TWDM-
system is designed to improve transmission range/reliability and PON as solution for NG-PON, it is more attractive and cost effective
deliver higher data transmission rates than the single-input single- to deploy RoF-PON that supports MIMO technique and WDM op-
output (SISO) system [9]. Therefore, to build any RoF-PON system eration with compatibility with currently deployed ODN as shown
for NG-PON, MIMO technique has to be considered. In spite of the in Fig. 2.
importance of MIMO technique, most of the proposed RoF-PONs In this paper, RoF-PON capable of handling MIMO streams at
are considering SISO signal instead of MIMO. The problem of low cost and high spectral efciency, is proposed. Moreover, to the
sending MIMO signals that have the same carrier frequency over a best of our knowledge, this is the rst work that demonstrates
single optical wavelength directly is that they overlap in the fre- bidirectional MIMO RoF wireless trafc in PON compatible with
quency domain. The solution for this problem was proposed using currently deployed ODNs.
WDM and subcarrier multiplexing (SCM) techniques [10,11]. These The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 elabo-
techniques are not cost-effective, since multiple optical sources rates the principles of the proposed method. The MIMO RoF-PON
and photodetectors are required. Transmission of three wireless system design and simulation considerations are covered in Sec-
MIMO signals over an optical ber is proposed and demonstrated tion 3. Section 4 demonstrates results and analysis. Finally, Section
using an electrical single sideband frequency-translation (ESSB-FT) 5 concludes the paper and suggests future work.
technique [12]. The main disadvantage using this approach is the
need to use local oscillators at the transmitting and receiving
sides, moreover, it has a relatively low data rate. In [13], trans- 2. Principle of the proposed MIMO RoF-PON technique
mission of two wireless MIMO signals with the same carrier fre-
quency over ber in RoF system using an optical single sideband A novel method that solves the challenge of transmitting MIMO
frequency-translation (OSSB-FT) technique has been proposed and RF signals with the same frequency over one SMF in a typical
M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564 57
TDM-PON ODN is proposed. This method uses optical multi- continuous-wave (CW) laser. A simple optical double sideband
wavelength frequency generation technique to generate three with carrier (ODSB C) technique is used to generate three wa-
wavelengths for each laser diode (LD), and then using PDM for velengths for each LD by using dual drive MachZehnder mod-
transmitting MIMO RF signals with the same frequency. ulator (DD-MZM). Then, the three wavelengths (optical carrier
Taking advantage from the optical frequency comb techniques (OC), upper optical sideband (UOSB) and lower optical sideband
and high bandwidth optical modulators (up to 100 GHz) [15], (LOSB)) are used independently to modulate MIMO signals.
multiple widely separated wavelengths can be generated from one The lightwave from the LD can be expressed as Ein(t) = Eceict .
58 M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564
The DD-MZM is driven by RF sinusoidal clock signals Eq. (1) it is clear that the power difference between the optical
V1(t) = V2(t) = VRF cos mt applied to the two arms with the fre- carrier and the two sidebands depends on the difference between
quency at fm = m/2 . The optical eld of the output signal Eout (t) J0 (mh) and J1 (mh) Bessel functions. In the simulation design, the
from the DD-MZM can be mathematically expressed as [9,16] values of VRF and V are set to 1 and 4, respectively. This makes the
optical carrier power to be higher than the two sidebands by 4 dB,
1
Eout (t) = Ec the other higher order sidebands are ignored due to the small
2 optical powers. Moreover, these higher order sidebands are sup-
{ J1(mh)ei( +
c m)t + J0 (mh)eic t + J1 (mh)ei(c m)t }} (1) pressed by the WDM lters which passes only the required wa-
velengths. Unlike the other methods that try to maintain atness
Here the modulation index is dened as mh = VRF /V , V is the between the new generated wavelengths or attenuating the op-
necessary driving voltage for achieving a phase shift of (half- tical carrier to be equal to the other generated wavelengths [9] or
wave voltage) and is the insertion loss of the modulator. The suppress the optical carrier [16], in this work the high power op-
three components obtained from Eq. (1) represents the optical tical carrier (compared to the newly generated wavelengths) is
carrier and the two sidebands. The channel spacing of the gener- used to carry the upstream (US) trafc. This means that the OC will
ated wavelengths is determined by the frequency of the sinusoidal arrive at the RAU without any data and is used there to carry the
clock ( fo ) that is applied to the DD-MZM. In this work the sinu- US trafc. The two sidebands wavelengths, LOSB and UOSB are
soidal clock frequency is set at 50 GHz, which makes the optical used to modulate four MIMO signals separately by using PDM as
carrier spacing from each of the sidebands as 50 GHz (0.4 nm) and shown in Fig. 3. The third wavelength which is the optical carrier
the spacing between the two sidebands as 100 GHz (0.8 nm). frequency (OC) is used to carry two time multiplexed MIMO sig-
WDM DeMux is used to separate the generated wavelengths. From nals (US) from the RAU.
M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564 59
Fig. 5. Optical power spectra of the allocated channels at the OLT. (a) Before the comb. (b) After the comb.
The newly generated wavelengths LOSB and UOSB are sepa- the two MIMO signals are polarization de-multiplexed at a po-
rated using WDM DeMux, and each one is equally divided into two larization beam splitter (PBS), as shown in Fig. 4. For the US an-
portions using power splitter (PS). Each portion is sent to a DD- other TOF is used to select the US wavelength and then the two US
MZM through a polarization controller (PC). The two PCs set the MIMO signals are time division multiplexed and modulated also
wavelength to polarization x (Pol-x) and polarization y (Pol-y). The using OSSB C modulation technique. The approach of time divi-
upper portion (Pol-x) is intensity modulated using DD-MZM by a sion multiplexing (TDM) is used in the US MIMO signals com-
16-QAM MIMO1 signal, while the lower portion (Pol-y) is modu- bining, to reduce the power, area and cost of multiple antenna
lated by 16-QAM MIMO2 also using DD-MZM. Also note that the receivers [18]. Moreover, one DD-MZM will be required at each
two MIMO signals are modulated using optical single sideband RAU, since power, space and cost are a scarce resource at base
with carrier (OSSB C) modulation technique and have an optical station.
spectra as shown again in Fig. 3. The OSSB C modulation method
enhances optical spectral efciency and overcomes the ber
chromatic dispersion problem [17]. The two MIMO signals are then 3. Design of the proposed MIMO RoF-PON system
polarization multiplexed using a polarization beam combiner
(PBC). The multiplexed optical signals are then transmitted to the Fig. 4 depicts the design of the proposed RoF-PON system based
RAU through a length of single mode ber (SMF) and PS/C at the on MIMO transmission. The OLT contains LDs array that has eight
RN as shown Fig. 4. Once the DS wavelength is selected using TOF, LDs. Using the technique explained in Section 2, twenty four
60 M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564
Table 1 Table 2
The allocated optical wavelengths at OLT. The general specications of the proposed MIMO RoF-PON.
Table 3
Specications of MIMO signals.
Parameter Value
Fig. 11. Constellation diagrams of one of the DS wavelengths for: (a) transmitted signal, (b) MIMO1 BtB, (c) MIMO1 20 km, (d) MIMO2 BtB, and (e) MIMO2 20 km.
Fig. 12. Constellation diagrams of one of the US wavelengths for (a) transmitted signal, (b) BtB, and (c) 20 km.
DS transmission a BER of 10 6 can be obtained without using FEC. with the kth symbol, Srx, k is the received symbol associated with
The EVMs are calculated considering the following equation Stx, k , and M is the number of the symbols for the inphase-quad-
[9]: rature constellation.
The BER is calculated according to [20]
M 2
Stx, k Srx, k
EVM(dB) = 10log10 k = 1 ,
M
K = 1 Stx, k
2
(2) BER
(1 Q1) ,
log2Q
where EVM is the value of the difference between a collection of
received symbols and transmitted or ideal symbols, Stx, k is the
corresponding transmitted symbol of the constellation associated
M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564 63
two MIMO signals carried in Pol-x and Pol-y. This is due to the
EDFA polarization dependent gain and polarization mode
dispersion.
Fig. 10 shows the received power for one of the US wave-
lengths, when the BER is 10 3 (FEC limit), the measured received
power is 28.5 dBm for BtB transmission. After a transmission of
20 km the power penalty is 1.5 dB at 10 3 BER.
Figs. 11 and 12 shows the constellation diagrams for one of the
DS and US wavelengths, respectively, in the case of transmitted
and received signals. For the received signal, BtB and 20 km SMF
transmission cases are considered. For BtB case, clear scatter-plots
are achieved for DS an US transmission, although each constella-
tion point appears to have some expansion due to the noise of the
LD, the PD and power loss and noise introduced by the passive
optical components. After a transmission over 20 km SMF, it can
be seen that the clusters in the constellations are still clearly se-
parated for DS transmission. In the case of 20 km US transmission
(Fig. 12(c)), the received signal is also maintaining clear scatter-
Fig. 13. The DS performance with and without PDM. plots, even though the distance between the constellation points
are becoming shorter owing to the noise and ber dispersion, plus
the aforementioned reasons that worsen the US transmission.
1 3 log2Q 2 Using the proposed technique by sending the US wavelengths
= erfc ,
2 (Q2 1) (k EVMrms )2 log2M from OLT is feasible and has an advantage of easily tunable wa-
velength-control at OLT which creates colorless RAU although it is
exposed by Rayleigh backscattering and round trip loss.
Stx, max
k= , The comparison between PDM and single polarization is shown
M
i = 1 ( Stx, i /M) (3) in Fig. 13. It can be observed that the power penalty induced due to
the use of PDM at 10 6 BER is only 1.5 dB. Polarization tracking at
where Q is the number of signal levels within each branch of the the customer premises is required for on-the-eld deployment
constellation diagram, log2 M is the amount of bits encoded into [22].
one QAM symbol, and K is a modulation format-dependent factor Also note that there are two main reasons behind these big
giving the relationship between maximum eld magnitude and uctuations in the BER curves. Firstly, when optical power greater
average overall M eld magnitudes dened by the constellation
than 7.9 dBm is launched onto bere with carrier frequency 5 GHz,
diagram for the chosen modulation format. This factor is calcu-
this results in nonlinearity effects on the system performance [9].
lated according to (3) to be 6/( 5 + 2) for 16-QAM. The Stx, i is the
Secondly, using high gain EDFA results also in nonlinearity effects
ideal transmitted eld vector, and Stx, max is the eld vector of the
such as spectral-hole-burning and Er-ion concentration quenching
outermost constellation point.
[23].
To evaluate the performance of the proposed system,
Figs. 7 and 8 show the BER performance versus the received op-
tical power at the receiver for the DS and the US transmission,
5. Conclusions
respectively.
The power sensitivity differences of the receivers for all the 16
Bidirectional MIMO wireless RoF-PON compatible with cur-
DS wavelengths are small, and the two MIMO streams within each
rently deployed ODN is proposed to satisfy the requirements of
wavelength have almost the same performance. The maximum
NG-PON. The proposed architecture is a bidirectional asymmetric
power penalty of 1 dB is recorded at BER of 10 6 between the DS
RoF-PON with total 40/10 Gb/s DS/US transmission for 32 RAUs at
wavelengths. For US transmission (Fig. 8), the maximum power
a distance of 20 km. Eight LDs at the OLT are enough for the whole
penalty of 1.5 dB is recorded at BER of 10 3 (FEC limit) between system, which makes colorless RAUs. From the eight LDs twenty
the US wavelengths. The difference margins are due to the pro- four wavelengths are generated using ODSB C comb technique.
pagation characteristics of the different wavelengths along the The physical layer performance has been reported in terms of the
optical ber and the slightly difference of power loss in the used BER and receiver sensitivity. In addition, the constellation dia-
passive optical components in the design. Also note that, the DS grams are analyzed in this study. The DS MIMO signals with the
wavelengths performance is much better than the US wavelengths same radio frequency are polarization division multiplexed and
and a BER of 10 6 can be obtained without FEC. That is due to the the US MIMO signals are time division multiplexed. The PDM
round trip loss which is faced by US wavelengths. Moreover, conguration doubles spectral efciency with a power penalty of
Rayleigh backscattered signal transmitted from the OLT during only 1.5 dB. The simulation results show that the 16-QAM MIMO
propagation in ber is detected simultaneously at the receiver in signals carried by the allocated optical DS and US wavelengths
OLT with the US data signal from RAU, and then it may cause keep acceptable transmission performance even after transmission
degradation of system performance as a Rayleigh backscattering over 20 km SMF and splitting ratio of 32. The DS performance is
induced intensity noise, since the same wavelength is transmitted better than the US and that is due to Rayleigh backscattering and
in both direction [21]. round trip loss that faced by the US wavelengths.
Fig. 9 shows the received power for one of the DS wavelengths, Our future research on the MIMO RoF-PON would be steered in
when the BER is 10 6, the measured received power is about enhancing the US performance and make the proposed system
26 dBm for back-to-back (BtB) transmission. After a transmis- symmetric PON (40 Gb/s for US and DS). Also, the network layer
sion of 20 km, the power plenty is 2 dB at 10 6 BER. Also note that aspects of the RoF-PON based on transmission of wireless MIMO
in the 20 km case there is a power plenty of 0.4 dB between the signals over typical TDM-PON ODN will be studied in the future.
64 M.A. Elmagzoub et al. / Optics Communications 344 (2015) 5564