Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An MD Simulation Approach
R. Komanduri (11, N. Chandrasekaran, L. M. Raffl
School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering and 'Chemistry Department,
Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, USA
Received on December 10, 1998
Abstract
Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of nanometric cutting on single crystal aluminum were conducted to
investigate the nature of the chip formation process with crystal orientation. Extensive dislocation
generation ahead of the tool in the workmaterial was found principally along, normal to, along and normal to,
-
or at - 45 deg. or 60 deg. to the cutting direction depending on the specific orientation and direction of
cutting. These differences in the dislocation motion observed here for the first time lead to significant
variations in the nature of plastic deformation ahead of the tool and consequent variation in the magnitude of
the forces, force ratio, specific energy, and subsurface deformation.
1 INTRODUCTION
Studies on the machining of metals and their alloys are
generally conducted on polycrystalline materials as most
engineering materials are polycrystalline in nature. They
represent, by and large, the average behavior of the
material. Macroscopic analysis, such as continuum
mechanics approach taken to describe the process
represents the process reasonably well. Thus, the
simplest but most comprehensive 2-D orthogonal cutting
model developed by Merchant on the mechanics of chip
formation is still extensively used to describe the
machining process [l]. While the material ahead of the
tool is considered to deform plastically in a narrow plane,
termed as the shear plane [Figure 1 (a)] in that model
(which is valid for some materials and cutting conditions),
the deformation may occur more in a zone [Figure 1 (b)]
with certain other materials and cutting conditions.
From a fundamental point of view, it is of interest to
investigate the response of single crystal materials in
different crystallographic orientations and directions of
cutting. In addition, the rapidly advancing field of Figure 1 (b) SEM micrograph of a chip root showing
ultraprecision machining, namely, finishing of optical plastic deformation occurring in a shear zone
mirrors (visible, U.V., as well as infrared) for laser
applications, aluminum disks for hard disks in the
computer industry, and a myriad of other applications 2 MACHINING OF S I N G L E CRYSTAL
involve machining of single crystal metals totally or MATERIALS
multitude of crystals (polycrystalline material) where each One of the pioneering studies on the micromachining of
crystal is oriented in a slightly different crystallographic single crystal Cu and Al was made by von Turkovich and
direction than the next. Black [2] who used ultramicrotome to study the chip
formation process at a cutting speed of 1 mmlsec using a
glass knife of 75 deg. included angle, a rake angle of 13-
14 deg, and a clearance angle of 2-3 deg. The cutting
directions investigated in Cu and Al single crystals were:
<loo> parallel to the (100) plane, <110> parallel to the
(110)plane, <112> parallel to the (1 11) plane, and <1 lo>
parallel to the (1 12) plane (see Figure 2 for details). They
reported for the first time that shear ahead of the tool
occurs in a shear front whose thickness is of the order of
a few tens or hundreds of atomic spacing implying strain
rates much larger than lo4 sec-' even at very low speed
of cutting (-1 mm/sec). This was followed by the work of
Black (31 who observed the discontinuous nature of the
machining process on a microscale leading to the
systematic formation of shear lamella separated by shear
fronts in the chip. He reported large variations in the chip
thickness ratio (ratio of chip thickness to the uncut chip
Figure 1 (a) SEM micrograph of a chip root showing thickness) with variation in the crystal orientation.
plastic deformationoccurring on a shear plane Ramalingam and Hazra [4] conducted cutting
68
memory requirements significantly. Komanduri el a1 [Sl] convenience, an infinitely hard (tungsten) tool was used
reported MD simulation studies on machining with large in these simulations as tool wear is hardly a problem when
negative rake angle tools to simulate grinding and machining pure aluminum. The potential used for the
compared them with the experimental results. Komanduri simulation was a pairwise sum of Morse potential. Table 1
et a1 [32] also investigated the effect of tool geometry gives the computational parameters, details of the
with tools of different edge radii relative to depth of cut in workmaterial and tool dimensions, depth of cut, width of
nanometric cutting. Overall, while a sound foundation has cut, and tool geometry used in the simulations.
been laid for the MD simulation of nanometric cutting,
many of the challenging machining problems are yet to be
investigated. Table 1: Computational parameters used in MD
simulation of nanometric cutting of aluminum
single crystal
69
(b) (111)[?11]
(e) ( ~ ~ i ) [ i i o ]
Figures 4 MD simulation of nanometric cutting for different orientations ((11l ) , (1lo), and (001)) and
(a) - (f) cutting directions < [ i l O ] , [Tll], and [I OO]>, in specific combinations
70
Figures 5 (a) - (c) show schematically three modes of The differences in the dislocation motion lead to
plastic deformation in the shear zone in nanometric variations in the nature of plastic deformation and
cutting. Figure 5 (a) shows the case of the chip formation consequently the forces, specific energy, force ratio, and
process in which the shear plane orientation is similar to subsurface deformation. Such variations in the mode of
the one commonly experienced in conventional machining deformation could not be detected earlier as most of the
of polycrystalline materials at conventional depths of cut. machining tests were conducted on polycrystalline
In the case of (001)orientation and [loo]direction of aluminum. Even though some researchers reported shear
cutting [Figure 4 (f)], the chip formation process and the angle > 45 deg., no explanation was offered for this
shear angle orientation were found to be very similar to unusual behavior of single crystal materials [lo, 141.This
the conventional shear ahead of the tool material as is because of the difficulty in observing continuously the
shown in Figure 5 (a). Thus, it is recommended that this cutting process by other experimental techniques while
combination be used for simulating machining if only one animation of the MD simulation of nanometric cutting
orientation has to be selected. However, in certain other permits such unusual observations.
combinations of crystal Orientation and cutting direction, The cutting forces were found to vary with the orientation
the shear angles were found to be much higher than 45 of the crystal and the direction of cutting. Minimum
deg. For example, in the case of (1 10) orientation and cutting forces were generated when machining in the
[OOl]direction [Figure 4 (d)], the dislocations were found [TlO]directions on the (1 11) or (110) orientations. This is
to generate at right angle to the direction of cutting, i. e., followed by cutting in the (001)direction on the [loo]
material is deformed perpendicular to the cutting orientation. The cutting force was maximum when
direction. Consequently, the shear angle is greater than machining in the [OOl]direction on the (1 10)orientation.
60 deg. This mode of dislocation generation and plastic
deformation in the shear zone is shown schematically in
Figure 5 (b). In cgntrast, when machining in the (001) 5 CONCLUSIONS
orientation and [110] direction [Figure 4 (e)], the 1 . When an aluminum crystal was oriented in the ( 1 1 1 )
dislocations were found to be generated parallel to the plane and cut in the [TlO] direction, the chip formation
cutting direction. Consequently, the material is deformed appears to be' predominantly due to shear and
parallel to the cutting direction and the shear angle is compression ahead of the tool along the cutting direction.
much below 45 deg. This mode of dislocation generation Consequently, there was very little subsurface
and plastic deformation in the shear zone is shown deformation as atoms tend to reorganize to their original
schematically in Figure 5 (c). positions due to elastic recovery subsequent to cutting.
In contrast, when the crystal was oriented in the (110)
plane but cut in the [OOl]direction, the dislocations were
generated normal to the cutting direction. Consequently,
the deformation ahead of the tool was found to be more of
a compression than shear. There was also a considerable
amount of side flow due to this squeezing effect. This
mode of deformation in the shear zone seems to be
id
-1- - - -- - - - - - -
- - -- -
specific to the single crystal material of this orientation as
no such effect was observed in conventional machining
of polycrystalline materials.
(a) Dislocations generated at an angle to the 2. In the case of MD simulation of nanometric cutting in
cutting direction e.g. (001) orientation and the( 110) plane and [ i l O ] cutting direction, dislocations
[loo] cutting direction were found to be generated and propagated both along
and perpendicular to the cutting direction.
3. Shear angles much higher than 45 deg. were observed
when machining in specific planes and directions of
cutting in the machining of single crystal aluminum similar
to that reported in the literature [10,14]. For example in
the (110)orientation and [OOl]direction, the dislocations
are at right angle to the direction of cutting. In the case of
.-J-- ----___________ (001) orientation and [loo] cutting direction, extensive
(b) Dislocations generated perpendicular to the -
dislocations motion at 45 deg. to the cutting direqion
cutting direction e.g. (110) orientation and are observed. In the case of (11 1 ) orientation and [211]
[OOl]cutting direction cutting direction, the dislocation motion was observed to
h /\ -
be at 60 deg. to the cutting direction. Thus it is possible
to obtain shear angles> 45 deg. depending on the crystal
orientation and direction of cutting.
4. Based on the MD simulation of nanometric cutting in
different crystallographic planes and directions of
cutting, three modes of deformation was observed in the
,'-
- i- - d- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ - - - - - - - /
direction shear zone. In the first case, namely, [(OOl)orientation
and [loo]direction], the chip formation process and the
shear plane orientation was similar to the one commonly
(c) Dislocations generated parallel to the cutting experienced in conventional machining of polycrystalline
direction e.g. (001)orientation and [-1101 materials at conventional depths of cut. In the second
cutting direction case, namely, [(l 10)orientation and [OOl]direction], the
Figures 5 Schematic showing three modes of plastic dislocations are generated at right angle to the direction
of cutting, i. e., material is deformed perpendicular to the
(a) to (c) deformation in the shear zone in nanometric
cutting of a single crystal in different crystal cutting direction.-In the third case, namely, [(OOl)
orientations and directions of cutting orientation and [110] direction], the dislocations are
generated parallel to the cutting direction. Consequently,
the material is deformed parallel to the cutting direction
71
and the shear angle is much below 45 deg. Such Microcutting of Aluminum Single Crystal," JSME, 34
variations in the mode of deformation were not reported Ill, 531.
earlier as most of the machining tests were conducted on [17] To, S., Lee, W. B., and Chan, C. Y., 1997,
polycrystalline aluminum. In addition, it is not possible to 'Ultraprecision Diamond Turning of Aluminum Single
observe continuously by other experimental techniques Crystals," J. of Mat. Proc. Tech., 63, 157.
while animation of the MD simulation of nanometric cutting
provides such an unique opportunity. [ t 8 ] Belak, J., and I. Stoawers,l990, "A Molecular
Dynamics Model of the Orthogonal Cutting
Process,' Proc ASPE Annual Conf., Rochester, NY,
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 76
This project is sponsored by two grants (DMl-9523551 (191 Belak, J., Lucca, D. A., Komanduri, R., Rhorer, R.
and CMS 9414610) from the National Science Foundation. L., Moriwaki, T.,Okuda, K., Ikawa, Shimada, S.,
The authors thank Drs. Ming Leu, Delcie Durham, and 8. Tanaka, H., Dow., T. A., Drescher, J. D., and I. F.
M. Kramer of DMll and Dr. J. Larsen Basse of the Stowers. 1991, "Molecular Dynamics Simulation of
Tribology and Surface Engineering Program for their the Chip Forming Process in Single Crystal Copper
interest in and support of this work. and Comparison with Experimental Data,' Proc. of
the ASPE Annual Conference, 100.
REFERENCES [20] Belak, J., 1994, "Nanotribology: Modelling Atoms
When Surfaces Collide," Energy & Technology
Merchant, M. E, 1944,"Basic Mechanics of Metal Review , Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, 13.
Cutting," Trans ASME, 66, A65-A71
[21] Ikawa, N., Shimada, S., Tanaka, H., and Ohmori, G.,
von Turkovich, B. F., and J. T. Black, 1970, 1991, "An Atomistic Analysis of Nanometric Chip
"Micromachining of Copper and Aluminum Crystals," Removal as Affected by Tool-Work Interaction in
Trans ASME, J. of Eng. for Industry, 92, 130. Diamond Turning," Annals of the CIRP, @/l, 551.
Black, J. T., 1971, "On the Fundamental Mechanism (221 Shimada. S., Ikawa, N.,Ohmori, G., and Tanaka, H.,
of Large Strain Plastic Deformation," Trans. ASME, 1992, "Molecular Dynamics Analysis as Compared
J. of Eng. for Industry, 93, 507. with Experimental Results of Micromachining,"
Ramalingam, S., and Hazra, J., 1973, "Dynamic Annals of the CIRP, U/1,117.
Shear Stress-Analysis of Single Crystal Machining
[23] Shimada. S . , Ikawa. N., Tanaka, H., Ohmori, G.,
Studies,' Trans. ASME, J. of Eng. for Industry, 95B.
Uchikoshi, J., and Yoshinaga, H., 1993, 'Feasibility
939.
Study on Ultimate Accuracy in Microcutting Using
Chao, B. T., Trigger, K. J., and Zylstra, L. Molecular Dynamics Simulation," Annals of the
B.,"Thermophysical Aspects of Metal Cutting," CIRP, &/1, 91.
1952, Trans. ASME, 74, 1039.
[24] Shimada, S.. Ikawa, N., Tanaka, H.,and Uchikoshi,
Chao, B. T., Trigger, K. J., 1959,"Controlled Contact J., 1994, "Structure of Micromachined Surface
Cutting Tools," Trans ASME, 81, 139. Simulated by Molecular Dynamics Analysis," Annals
Kobayashi, S.,and Thomson, E. G., 1959, "Some of the CIRP, 4311, 51.
Observatons on the Shearing Process in Metal
[25] Shimada, S., 1995, "Molecular Dynamics Analysis of
Cuttingm,'"Trans. ASME, 81, 251.
Nanometric Cutting Process,' Int. J of Japan SOC.
Williams, J. A.. and Gane, N., 1977, "Some Prec. Eng., 29, No.4. 283.
Observations On the Flow Stress of Metals During
(261 Inamura, T., Suzuki, H., and Takezawa, N., 1991,
Metal Cutting," Wear, 42, 341.
"Cutting Experiments in a Computer Using Atomic
Williams, J. A., 1993, "Small Scale Effects in Metal Models of Copper Crystal and a Diamond Tool," Int.
Cutting," Thin Films in Tribology, 289. J. Japan SOC.Prec. Eng., a,No. 4, 259.
Ueda, K., and Iwata, K., 1980, "Chip Formation [27] Inamura, T., Takezawa, N., and Taniguchi, N., 1992,
Mechanism in Single Crystal Cutting of beta-brass," "Atomic-Scale Cutting in a Computer Using Crystal
Annals of CIRP, 41(1), 65. Models of Copper and Diamond," Annals of the
Lee, W. B., 1990, "Prediction of Micromachining CIRP, 4J1, 121.
Force Variation in Ultraprecision Machining," [28] Inamura, T., Takezawa, N., and Kumaki, Y., 1993,
Precision Eng., 12(1), 25.
"Mechanics and Energy Dissipation in Nanoscale
Lee, W. B., and Zhou, M., 1993, "A Theoretical Cutting," Annals of the CIRP, 42/1, 79.
Analysis of the Effect of Crystallographic
Orientation On Chip Formation in Micromachining," [29] Inamura, T., Takezawa, N., Kumaki, Y., and Sata.
Int. J. of Mach. Tool and Manuf., 33, 439.
T., 1994, "On a Possible Mechanism of Shear
Deformation in Nanoscale Cutting," Annals of the
Konig, W. B., and Senrath, N., 1991, "The Influence CIRP, @ / l , 47.
of the Crystallographic Structure of the Substrate
Material on Surface Quality and Cutting Forces in [30] Chandrasekaran, N., Noori-Khajavi, A., Raff, L. M.,
Micromachining," Progress in Precision Engineering, and Komanduri, R., 1998, "A New Method for
Springer-Verlag, Braunschweig, Germany, 141. Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Nanometric
Cutting," Philo. Mag. 5,77(1). 7.
[14] Moriwaki, T., Sugimura, N., Manabe, K., and Iwata,
K., 1991, "A Study on Orthdgonal Micromachining of (311 Komanduri, R., Chandrasekaran, N., and Raff, L. M.,
Single Crystal Copper," Trans of NAMRV SME, 9, 1999, "Some Aspects of Machining with Negative
177. Rake Tools Simulating Grinding: An MD Simulation
Approach." accepted for publication in Phil. Mag.
(151 Moriwaki, T., Okuda, K., 1989, 'Machinability of
Copper in Ultraprecision Micro-diamond Cutting,' [32] Komanduri, R., Chandrasekaran, N., and Raff, L. M.,
Annals of CIRP, Vol. 3811, 115. 1998,"Effect of Tool Geometry in Nanometric
Cutting: An MD Simulation Approach", Wear, 219,
[16] Sato, M., Yamazaki, T., Shimizu, Y., Nakagawa, T.,
and Takabayashi, T., 1991, 'A Study on the 84.
72