Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 1 of 17

Exhibit A
 Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 2 of 17

TerriAnne Benedetto

From: TerriAnne Benedetto

Sent: Tuesday, April 18, 2017 4:21 PM
To: 'Scheff, Richard'; Breslauer, Peter; Herman, David F.
Cc: Chris Seeger; Buchanan, David (DBuchanan@seegerweiss.com);
'dburns@paulweiss.com'; 'lbayard@paulweiss.com'; 'sweiss@anapolweiss.com'; Chris
Van De Kieft; Dion Kekatos; George, Scott (sgeorge@seegerweiss.com)
Subject: NFL - NFL Case Consulting LLC and Jim McCabe Motion for Injunction
Attachments: Home Page - NFL CASE CONSULTING LLC.pdf; 2017-03-27 [7347-02.6] Ex F - Decl. of
CAS ISO Co-Lead Class Counsel's ....pdf; How We Help NFL CASE Consulting.pdf

Richard,

Infollowuptotodayscall,IwantedtosetforththeitemsdiscussedwhichwerenotaddressedinCoLeadClass
CounselsmotionforinjunctionfiledonMarch27.IhaveattachedforcomparisontheExhibitFthatwasattachedtoour
motion(yourclientshomepageatthetime)andthecurrenthomepageforNFLCaseConsulting.Theonlytabsonthe
homepageinExhibitFwereApplyNowandCallToday.Onthecurrenthomepage,thereareseveraltabsthathave
beenadded,namely,HowWeHelp,AbouttheNFLSettlement,andOurStory.Iwantedtonotethatwehadnt
raisedinthemotioncertainissuesdiscussedontodayscall(asreiteratedbelow),becauseyourclientswebsitedidnot
containthislanguagewhenthemotionwasfiled.

Onthecall,wediscussedcertainstatementsandmisrepresentationsonyourclientsHowWeHelppage,whichis
attached,asfollows:

1) UnderOver1BillionDollarsinClaimsRecoveredforClients,weseetwoproblems.
a. TheNFLConcussionSettlementAgreementwillbeadministeredfortheNFLandtheCourtbyclaims
consultants.First,itisbeingadministeredforthePartiesandtheCourt,thePartiesincludetheNFL
andtheClass.Asworded,theClassmemberswereleftoutoftheequation.Second,itisbeing
administeredbytheCourtappointedClaimsAdministrator,BrownGreer,notclaimsconsultants.(I
alsonotethatyourclientsbrochure(whichwasnotpreviouslyavailableonthewebsite)claimstheyour
clienthasexperiencedealingwiththecourtappointedadministratorsoftheNFL.BrownGreerisnot
theNFLsadministratoritistheSettlementsadministrator.)
b. Thereferencetoyourclienthavingspentthelast7yearsdealingwiththesameclaimsprocessand
adversariesonthelargestClassSettlementinUSHistory,theBPOilSpill.Drawingsomeparallel
betweentheadversariesinBPandthoseinthiscaseisconfusing.Theonlycommonthreadwouldbe
BrownGreerandtocouchtheClaimsAdministratorasanadversaryismisleading.
2) UnderTurnkeyClaimsAssistance,thethreatofdenialsifthereareclaimprocessdeficienciesmakestheclaims
administrationprocesssoundrigidandlikeagetitrightthefirsttimeoryoureouttypeofprocess.Thatis
definitelynotthecase.
3) UnderReferralstoQualifiedDoctorstoIndependentMedicalEvaluations,thereferenceinthetitletoan
independentmedicalevaluationimpliesthat(1)theQualifiedBAPProvidersandQualifiedMAFPhysiciansare
biasedand(2)aClassMember,atthisjuncture,inthepostEffectiveDatetimeperiod,couldgetaQualifying
DiagnosisoutsideoftheSettlementProgram.Bothoftheserepresentationsareinaccurate.Sayingthat[m]ost
physiciansare*NOT*qualifiedtotestordiagnoseundertheseguidelines;andphysiciansshouldbechosenwith
care.Choosingthewrongphysicianmaydelayorjeopardizealegitimateclaim.HelpmeFindaQualified
Doctor.againmisrepresentsthataQualifyingDiagnosiscouldbeobtainedoutsideoftheSettlementProgram
atthispoint.Itcannot.

1
 Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 3 of 17
4) UnderLetUsHandletheComplexReportingRequirements,thestatementthatthefailuretomeet
requirementsoftheclaimsadministratorswillleadtodenials,liketheTurnkeysection,impliesrigidityinthe
claimsprocessthatisnotpresent.
5) UnderLetUsDetermineanIndependentValuationforYourClaim,thestatement[i]fyouwereinamotor
vehicleaccident,andneededcompensation,wouldyouletthepersonwhoinjuredyoudeterminethevalueof
yourloss?Thus,youmaywanttoreconsiderlettingtheNFLConcussionSettlementAuthoritydeterminethe
valueofyourclaimwithoutindependentclaimsexpertsonYourside.impliesthattheNFLisdeterminingthe
amountsofmonetaryawards.Theyarenot.ItalsoagaincallsintoquestiontheintegrityoftheQualifiedBAP
ProvidersandQualifiedMAFPhysiciansandtheClaimsAdministrator,asdoesthestatementlaterinthatsection
encouragingClassMemberstoobtainminicognitivetesting:Withoutabenchmark,aclaimantwillhaveno
basisuponwhichtoassessifthediagnosisandvaluationbytheclaimsadministratorsiscorrect.

Totheextentthatyourclientcontinuestoaddtoitswebsitecontent,wemayhavefurthercommentsandobjections.

Additionally,asnotedonthecall,wenowknow,basedupondiscussionsinmypriorcallwithyou,thatyourclienthas
recordedalltelephonecallstoClassMembers.Wewanttoinsurethatnoneoftheabovestatements,northosewhich
werediscussedinourmotion,werecommunicatedtothose6ClassMembersregisteredbyyourclient(andpossibly
playedapartinthedecisiontoretainyourclient),andanyotherClassMemberswhomaysincehaveretainedyour
client.AnyDeclarationbyyourclientshouldincludetherepresentation,baseduponreviewofthoserecordings,that
thosestatementswerenotmadetoClassMemberswhoretainedyourclient.Pleasenotethatthisemailisnotintended
torepeattheissuesdiscussedinourmotion.Itisonlyintendedtoaddressthosepointsunknownandunknowableat
thetimeourmotionwasfiled.

IlookforwardtoourcallonThursday.Ihopethattheabovewillhelptostreamlinematters,sothatweareableto
succinctlypresentanyoutstandingissuestoJudgeBrodyinthesubmissiondueonFriday.

Thankyou,
Terri

TerriAnneBenedetto
SeegerWeissLLP
1515MarketStreet
Suite1380
Philadelphia,PA19102
(t)2155642300
(d)2155537981
(f)2158518029

2
4/18/2017 NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 4 of 17

HOW WE HELP ABOUT THE NFL SETTLEMENT OUR STORY APPLY NOW CALL TODAY

NEEDHELPGETTING
SETTLEMENTFROMTH
CALL NOW

ContactUsTodayforaFreeEvaluation
Wereyouinjuredwhile
Name*
playingintheNFL?
Phone*

CallourTeamofNFLSettlementExpertsTodayat8558513963
Email*

NoRisk.NoUpfrontFees.WecanhelpwithanyNFLSettlementinjurycase.Wehandle

allnoticesandclaimadministrationforyouoryourclients.

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/ 1/3
4/18/2017 NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 5 of 17
PleaseletusknowhowwecanhelpwithyourNFLInjury
claim

APPLY NOW

ThegameplaysonattheNFL.
Isitforyouoryourclients?
Ourteamofexpertshavesettledover2BillionDollarsinclaimsandcan

handleallofyourNFLSettlementclaimnoticesandgetyoupaid!

Whatourclientsare
sayingaboutNFL

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/ 2/3
4/18/2017 NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 6 of 17

CaseConsulting,
LLC:
Yourlevelofprofessionalismanddedicationtoservice
areunsurpassed.Iamconfidentrecommendingplayers
andfriendstoyou.

LoganPayne

RetiredNFLPlayer

ContactUsTodayforaFreeEvaluation

Name*
OurNFL
SettlementClaim
Phone*

Email*

PleaseletusknowhowwecanhelpwithyourNFLInjury
claim AssistanceExperts
arewaitingfor
yourcall
APPLY NOW

ASettlementofaclassactionlawsuitwasreachedwiththeNFLandNFL

PropertiesandretiredNFLplayers,theirrepresentativesandfamily

members.TheretiredNFLplayerssued,accusingtheNFLofnotwarning

playersandhidingthedamagesofbraininjury.

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/ 3/3
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 7 of 17

HOW WE HELP ABOUT THE NFL SETTLEMENT OUR STORY APPLY NOW

CALL TODAY

Ourteamisheretoensurethat
alleligibleplayersreceivefull
valuations

WhyHireNFLCaseConsultingasYourNFLConcussionClaim
Experts

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 1/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 8 of 17

Over1Billion
DollarsinClaims
Recoveredfor
Clients
ClaimantsshouldbeapprisedthattheNFLConcussionSettlementislargely

anadministrativeprocessnow.Thereare,ofcourse,legalrequirementsand

reasonsforrepresentationbyanattorney,suchassubmissionof

Registrationandtherealpossibilityofappealsinthefuture.Butlargely,the

entireprocess,subjecttocompliancewithrequirementsestablishedinthe

NFLConcussionSettlementAgreement,willbeadministeredfortheNFL

andCourtbyclaimsconsultants.Consequently,itisreasonablefor

claimantstoconsideremploymentofclaimsexpertsontheirbehalveswho

understandthisprocess.TheNFLconcussionclaimsexpertsatNFLCase

Consultinghavetheexpertise,basedonover75yearsofcollectiveclaims

experience,particularlyhavingspentthelast7yearsdealingwiththesame

claimsprocessandadversariesonthelargestClassSettlementinUShistory,

theBPOilSpill.FreeConsultationwiththeExperts

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 2/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 9 of 17

TurnkeyClaims
Assistance
Atfirstglance,retiredNFLplayerswhoareclaimantsmaybelievethe

NFLConcussionSettlementAgreementisrelativelysimpleand

thereforetheonlyrequirementsaresubmissionoftestingmedicalreports

andotherdocuments.Unfortunately,thatapproachmayhaveaNFLclaim

delayed,denied,ordrasticallyunderpaid.

Aclaimantshouldbearinmindthatfailureoftestingorthecorrect

diagnosismaynotonlyprecludetheirclaimbutmaycauseareduced

valuation.Andfailuretoproperlydocumenteligibleseasonsmayfurther

reducevaluations.Deficienciesinanydocumentationwillresultindenialif

deficienciesarenotrespondedtocorrectlyandtimely.MakeY ourClaim

ProcessTurnkey

Referralsto
QualifiedDoctors
forIndependent
MedicalEvaluations

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 3/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 10 of 17
OnlyaqualifiedspecialistmaymakeaQualifyingDiagnosisasoutlinedin

theNFLConcussionSettlementAgreement.Dependingonthedateofthe

diagnosis,amedicalprovidermustmeetcertainrequirementstobe

consideredaqualifiedspecialist.Mostphysiciansare*NOT*qualifiedtotest

ordiagnoseundertheseguidelinesandphysiciansshouldbechosenwith

care.Choosingthewrongphysicianmaydelayorjeopardizea

legitimateclaim.NFLCaseConsultingiscommittedtosimplifyingthe

entireclaimsprocess.HelpmeFindaQualifiedDoctor

ThingsMayGet
MuchMore
Complicated
QuicklyAppeals
andOtherUnknown
FactorsCouldAffect
YouIfNotHandled
Properly
Claimantsshouldanticipatethatthisagreement,likeallotherclass

settlements,willbechallengedbyinterpretations.TheBPSettlement

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 4/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 11 of 17
Agreementcomprised1,138pagesandhasnowbeensupplementedbyover

600policyinterpretationswithover8,000pagesofdefinitionsand

instructions,someofwhichareverydetrimentalandproblematicifnot

understoodandconsidered.Itisaveryimportantpartoftheclaimsprocess

thattheclaimantsclaimsprocessorsbefamiliarwithallpoliciesand

instructionsthatwillinevitablybeproducedintheNFLSettlement.Handle

theComplexitiesforMe

DoNotDisqualify
YourClaimwith
Improper
Documentation
ClaimantsshouldexpectnumerousinquiriesbyNFLConcussionSettlement

claimsadministratorsregardingdocumentationeventhoughtheclaimant

orattorneymayhavefelttheysubmitteddocumentstosatisfy

requirements.CorrectformmattersandtheNoticesthatwillbeissued

duringreviewswillrequireveryspecificresponses.LetUsHandleY our

Documentation

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 5/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 12 of 17

LetUsHandlethe
ComplexReporting
Requirements
Claimantsmustbemadeawarethatfailuretomeetrequirementsofthe

claimsadministratorswillleadtodenialsofclaimsforadministrative

reasonsthataredifficulttoovercome.ThisisaprocessthatNFLCase

ConsultingsNFLConcussionSettlementexpertsfullyunderstand.LetUs

HandleY ourComplexReportingRequirements

LetUsDeterminean
Independent
ValuationforYour
Claim
Ifyouwereinamotorvehicleaccident,andneededcompensation,would CallourTeamof
youletthepersonwhoinjuredyoudeterminethevalueofyourloss?Thus, NFLSettlement
youmaywanttoreconsiderlettingtheNFLConcussionSettlement
ExpertsTodayat
Authoritydeterminethevalueforyourclaimwithoutindependentclaims
8558513963
expertsonY ourside.LetUsDetermineanIndependentClaimValuefor
NoRisk.NoUpfrontFees.Wecan
Y ou
helpwithanyNFLSettlement
http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 6/7
4/18/2017 HowWeHelpNFLCASE
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1 Filed 05/12/17 Page 13 of 17
NFLCaseConsultinghastheNFLConcussionSettlementexpertiseand injurycase.Wehandleallnotices

processestoassistclaimantswiththeproperdocumentationandvaluation andclaimadministrationforyouor

oftheirclaims,includingadministeringminicognitivetestingtodetermine yourclients.

iftheclaimantshouldsubmittocompletetestingandvaluation.Withouta

benchmark,aclaimantwillhavenobasisuponwhichtoassessifthe

diagnosisandvaluationbytheclaimsadministratorsiscorrect.And,future

monitoringoftheclaimantforpossiblesubmissionanddocumentationof

supplementalclaims(developmentofamoreseriousdiagnosisandaward)

isavitalcomponentoftheserviceprovidedbyNFLCaseConsulting.

Itisoftendifficultforclaimantstofullyappreciatethevalueofservicesthat

arebeingofferedbyattorneysandclaimsprofessionals.Webelievethereis

asimpleaxiomthatshouldbeconsideredtheclaimantshouldengagethe

properexpertsforthetasktofullyprotecttheirinterests.

FreeConsultationwiththeExperts

AllRightsReserv edby NFLCASECONSULTING.com 2 01 7

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/howwehelp/ 7/7
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7625-1
7347-2 Filed 05/12/17
03/27/17 Page 14
21 of 17
26

Exhibit F
3/21/2017 NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7347-2 Filed 05/12/17
7625-1 03/27/17 Page 15
22 of 17
26

APPLY NOW CALL TODAY

NEEDHELPGETTING
SETTLEMENTFROMTH
V I E W M O R E C A L L N O W

Name*
W er eyo uinjur edw h ile
Phone*
pla yinginth eNFL?
Email*

PleaseletusknowhowwecanhelpwithyourNFLInjury Ca llou rTea m ofNFLS ettlem en tEx pertsToda ya t855-851-39 6 3

claim

NoRisk.NoUpfrontFees.WecanhelpwithanyNFLSettlementinjurycase.Wehandle

allnoticesandclaimadministrationforyouoryourclients.

APPLY NOW

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/ 1/3
3/21/2017 NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7347-2 Filed 05/12/17
7625-1 03/27/17 Page 16
23 of 17
26

Th egam eplaysonatth eNFL.

Isitfor you or you r clients?
Our team ofexper tshav esettledov er 2BillionDollar sinclaim sandcan

handleallofy our NFL S ettlem entclaim noticesandgety oupaid!

RECENT NFLCa seConsu lting ,LLCisa na w a r d w inning com p a ny

CASES w itha r ep u ta tionfor consistentinnova tiona tthehig hest

levelofcla im s.

Ou r NFLSettlem ent
http://nflcaseconsulting.com/
Claim Assistance 2/3
3/21/2017 Claim Assistance
NFLCASECONSULTINGLLC
Case 2:12-md-02323-AB Document 7347-2 Filed 05/12/17
7625-1 03/27/17 Page 17
24 of 17
26

Exper tsar ew aiting

for you r call
AS ettlem entofaclassactionlaw suitw asr eachedw iththeNFL andNFL P r oper tiesand

r etir edNFL play er s,their r epr esentativ esandfam ily m em b er s.T her etir edNFL

play er ssued,accusingtheNFL ofnotw ar ningplay er sandhidingthedam agesofb r ain

injur y .

AllRightsReserv edby NFLCASECONSULTING.com 2 01 7

http://nflcaseconsulting.com/ 3/3