Youth Parliament

-Voice of the Next Generation..

ek'kZy% ekuuh; lHkkx.k] ekuuh; lHkklnksa!

Speaker (Kanika Rana): Good morning! I welcome you all to this 48th Youth
Parliament session and hope that this session will be fruitful. We begin with
todays session with oath or affirmation of the newly elected members,
Secretary General please.
Secretary General (Rafia Mahir): Ms. Ishita Bhattacharjee who stands
elected from the Howrah Constituency of West Bengal will now take the oath
or affirmation.
Ms. Ishita please.
Ma'am, do you want to talk oath or affirmation?
Ishita Bhattacharjee: Oath please.
Secretary General: In which language would you like to take oath?
Ishita Bhattacharjee: In Bengali please.
Secretary General: Okay ma'am. Kindly proceed.
Ishita Bhattacharjee: , ,
, , , . ,
, ,
.
Secretary General: Ms. Anusha Nawaz who stands elected from the Ambala
Constituency of Haryana will now take the oath or affirmation.
Ms. Anusha Nawaz, please.
Ma'am, do you want to talk oath or affirmation?
Anusha Nawaz: Oath please.
Secretary General: In which language would you like to take the oath?
Anusha Nawaz: In Hindi please.
Secretary General: Okay ma'am. Proceed please.

eSa vuq"kk uokt+ tks ;qok laln dh lnL;k

Anusha Nawaz: :
fuokZfpr gqbZ gksa] bZ'oj dh 'kiFk ysrh gw lR;fu"Bk ls
izfrKk djrh gw eSa fof/ }kjk LFkkfir Hkkjr ds lafo/ku ds

1
izfr Jk j[kwaxh] ns'k dh izHkqlkk vkSj ,drk cuk;s
j[kwaxh rFkk ftl in eSa xzg.k djus okyh gwa] mlds
drZO;ksa dk JkiwoZd fuokZgu (ikyu) d:axhA
______________________________________________________________________________________

OBITUARY MAKING

Speaker : ekuuh; lnL;x.k] vkt ge rhu ekg ds i'pkr fey jgs

gSa] eq>s ;g dgrs gq, vR;Ur nq[k gks jgk gS fd Jh v#.k
usg: th vc gekjs chp ugha jgsA mudk nsgkUr 25
tqykbZ] 2013 dks xqM+xkao esa gqvkA os u dssoy ,d
lqizfl dk;ZdkkZ Fks] ijUrq ,d tkus&ekus lektlsoh Hkh
FksA

Mitali Manu (P.M.) - Madam, I would like to pay my tribute to Shri Arun
Nehru, whose death has been deeply mourned by all. He had been one of the
sharpest minds in Indian politics and during his parliamentary career he
actively participated in House proceedings and made valuable contributions
for the society. He was a warm person who had dream and determination to
get the nation to reach the heights of glory. He was an active social and
political leader. Therefore, the shock of his passing away is regretted. I would
like to pay my condolences to his family.

egksn;k] v#.k usg:

Leader of Opposition (Jessica Duggal): Speaker
th ds vdLekr~ fu/u ij ge 'kksd trkrs gSaA os ,d lqfoK
euq"; FksA os ,d 'kkld o lkalnh; [kkldkj FksA mUgksaus
viuk lkjk thou ns'k o vius yksxksa ds fy, lefiZr fd;kA
mudk fu/u gekjs ns'k ds fy, vkSj fo'ks"k :i ls mRrj izns'k
ds fy, viw.kZuh; {kfr gSA bl 'kksdxzLr ?kM+h esa ge
muds ifjokj ds lkFk gSa vkSj bZ'oj ls mudh vkRek dh
'kkafr ds izkFkZuk ds fy, 'kkfUr ds fy, izkFkZuk djrs
gSaA
Speaker: The House may now stand in silence for a while to express our deep
sorrow.

2
Secretary General may convey the message to the bereaved family.

INTRODUCTION OF NEW MEMBERS

Prime Minister to introduce the new members please.

Mitali Manu (P.M.) Madam, its my pleasure in introducing to you and
through you, to the House, my colleagues, the new ministers Ms. Aleena,
Minister of Rural Housing and Development and Ms. Deeksha, Minister of
Energy.

QUESTION HOUR
Speaker: Now the question hour starts, Question number 101:
Ms. Vani Gupta please.
Vani Gupta: Honble speaker madam,
Will the Minister of Commerce and Industry be pleased to state?
(a) Why does the Government want to bring in Foreign Direct Investment in
India?
(b) Brands like McDonalds and Starbucks harm the native business like
Haldirams and Bikanerwalas.

eSa] ekuuh; ea=kh th ls tkuus dh bPNqd gwa fd

Hkkjrh; dEifu;ksa dk Hkfo"; dSlk gS\ tc ge fons'kh
dEifu;ksa dks Hkkjr esa izxfr djus dh vktknh ns jgs
gSa\

Speaker: Honble Minister of Commerce and Industries please.

Honble Minister of Commerce and Industries: With The Permission Of
Honourable Speaker Madam, I would like to answer the questions raised by
The worthy member of the opposition party.
(a) The list of advantages of FDI goes on with better education, per capita
income, better products and services.

3
You should not only ponder over the profit making aspect but to others as well
i.e. better and much better lifestyles of people associated with the FDI.
The economy of India is tearing down the barrel and FDI can provide some
stability, and mind you madam, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has proved to
be resilient during financial crises. For instance, in the East Asian countries,
such investment was remarkably stable during the financial crises of 1997-98.

(b)usldSiQs ihus okyksa iwNksa eSMe th ls V~foVj dk

bLrseky D;ksa djrh gSa\ D;k og fons'kh ugha gS\ I
congratulate my friends from the opposition party that they took Haldirams
and Bikanerwala into consideration.

McDonalds came to India and started making aaloo tikki after all, Indians
would not let go off their palate.
But equally important is the fact that Haldirams now has 38 stores worldwide
including 3 in London. Bikanerwala is a 1000 crore company with 85 stores
across the world.
Speaker: Member to ask supplementary question please.
Vani Gupta: Maybe a college student aspiring for a part time job will benefit
from FDI. But what about the local kirana shop owner, the poor farmer, the
uneducated man in search of a job, who only finds jobs scant and scarce
dominated by those with education. What about them, madam?
If we must go down, we will go down fighting. But, we must go down fighting
for the poor not the rich, for the country not MNCs.

Speaker: Minister of Industries and Commerce please.

Minister of Industries and Commerce: FDI will not solve all the problems
but it gives an option. It will provide millions of jobs, so those who will lose
their jobs will get another as well and that too with better salaries.
And maam, dont underestimate the farmers of India, they are not fools, they
will sell to the person who gives them the best price.
With FDI, the farmer will get money straight and the middlemen will be done
away with.
FDI in retail will not hurt the local markets, we must weigh the pros and cons
of FDI as no one wants the farmers and local traders to be affected, but there
should be no fear mongering that money from abroad will colonise India like
the East India Company. Why do we doubt our capability? Why should we be
4
so scared of FDI? Who knows that one that one day even Indian retail giants
might expand to give the foreign trade a stiff competition.

bl fo"k; esa cl vc ;gh dguk pkgwaxh eksgrjek]

eqgCcrksa esa rqEgsa vkalw cgkus ugha vkrs]
eqgCcrksa esa rqEgsa vkalw cgkus ugha vkrs--- cukjl
vkdj] cukjl ds iku [kkus ugha vkrs---
!
Speaker: Question no 102. Mr.Sujeet Bhandari please.
Mr.Sujeet Bhandari: Will the Minister of Agriculture be pleased to state?
(a) The government intends to pass the food security bill, why doesn't it
strengthen schemes which already exist, like NREGA?
(b) How will the govt. mobilise resources?
Its all food for you, security for you and bill for us?

Speaker: Honourable Minister Of Agriculture Please.

Minister Of Agriculture: The answer for the aforementioned question-
(a) The Food Security Bill is not impractical...at all. The eastern state of
Chhattisgarh ruled by one of the main opposition party, has prepared its own
Food Security Act, and a recent survey by IIT Delhi confirms these food related
programs are quite effective. I hope this experience helps to dispel the notion
that Food Security Bill is impractical.
And I think money is no big a deal where upliftment of people is concern.
After all, we're using public money for the benefit of people.

(b) gekjh vkSj rqEgkjh ckr er NsfM+;s] viuh dqlhZ ds

fy, tT+ckr er NsfM+;sA NsfM+;s tax xjhch ds f[kykiQ]
fliQZ laln esa cSBdj jktuhfr er dhft,A

Our every move for the greater good cannot be criticised like this. We have to
mobilise the resources the resources, somehow.
Its not that we wont do it or we wont do it... We have to do it.

Speaker: Member to ask supplementary question please. Ms. Medha please.

5
Medha: Your party sings the glories of the mid-day meal, but what about the
children in Bihar who were fed with insecticides instead of nutritious food and
in regions like Chennai, Punjab, and Madhya Pradesh where the foul food was
served and claimed the lives of many children.
Speaker: Deputy Minister Of Agriculture please.
Deputy Minister Of Agriculture: Madam, Were shocked by the Bihar mid-
day meal tragedy the centre has for the first time come out with guidelines to
be followed by all schools within the country with special emphasis on hiring
qualified hands in the kitchen and strict monitoring, we will prescribed code
of hygiene and safe practices to be followed during procurement preparation
and securing of meals.
According to this, schools should have at least one full time in-charge certified in
food safety, I repeat, one full time in-charge certified in food safety education
training.
Speaker: Next question Ms. Jessica Duggal.
Jessica Duggal: Thank you maam!
Will the Minister of Defence be pleased to state?
(a) What steps has the government taken in regard to the REPETITIVE and
REPORTED incursions of our neighbouring country China on borders of
Laddakh?
(b) Kindly brief us with the actual conditions of the LINE OF ACTUAL
CONTROL.

Speaker: Honble Defence Minister please.

Minister Of Defence: Madam, Ms Jessica begs to call the attention but I
myself will draw your attention to the steps taken by the government on the
same. From time to time government takes up major decision along the line of
actual control with the Chinese side through established mechanism including
personnel border meetings. The two sides have worked hard to maintain
peace. Government keeps a watch on all the developments related to Indias
security and takes all necessary measures to safeguard it.
Member to ask supplementary question, Ms. Jessica Duggal Please.
Jessica Duggal: No agony, no pain shall make me cry,
Soldier was I born
Soldier shall I die.

6
With even the brigadier level talks failing and the Chinese continue their
reinforcement of the military camps they had set in the expanded 19 km
Indian territory and our DEAR government still looking for available options
and hoping for peaceful relations with China. It seems that our country is the
tolerant of all.
-
.
, |
I request the honble Minister to brief us with the actual conditions.
Speaker: Minister of Defence please.

Minister of Defence : egksn;k]

eSa Jherh tsfldk dks dguk
pkgwaxh fd phu tSls 'kfDr'kkyh o cy'kkyh ns'k ds lkFk
Hkkjr ds laca/ csgn laosnu'khy gSA blfy, Hkkjr dksbZ
Hkh ,slk dne u mBk;s] ftlls bu vUrjkZ"Vh; laca/ksa ij
dksbZ izHkko iM+sA vkt ds le; esa tgka #i;s dk Hkko
fujUrj fxjrk tk jgk gS] Hkkjr dks phu dh mlh izdkj t:jr
gS] ftl izdkj ljdkj dks foi{k dhA eSa foi{k dh lnL;k ls ,d
fo'ks"k ckr ij xkSj djus dks dgwaxh tks fd bl izdkj gS%
dqN ikus ds fy, dqN [kksuk iM+rk gS] ijUrq ;fn vki lc
dqN ysdj] dqN ugha nsuk pkgrh rks mlesa uk gh ge
dqN dj ldrs gSa] u gh phuA cl ;gh izkFkZuk djsaxs j?
kqifr jk?ko jktkjke] lcdks lUefr ns HkxokuA
Speaker: Member to ask supplementary questions Mr. R Sharma Please.
Mr.R.Sharma : I would like to ask the honourable minister of Defence that
what the government has done regarding the killing of soldiers on the Border by
Pakistan.

Minister Of Defence: Pakistans armys role in the attack could not be denied.
Every Indians heart burns with anger & fury & the blood boils. As a defence
minister I have to do something but as an Indian citizen it is my duty to do
something & I will do everything possible in this regard. Those in Pakistan
who are responsible for this tragedy & the brutal killing of the soldiers will not
go unpunished. The government calls for military to military mechanisms to
ensure that the situation does not escalate. India is all set to discuss steps with
Pakistan for further strengthening of the already existing mechanism both at
political & military levels. Proper compensation have been given to the
families of the soldiers. Well simply not act as mute spectators but will take

7
the case to the highest level possible. The solution lies in dialogue &
discussion and not in distributions.
I assure the house that our government will take necessary measures to
uphold the sanctity of the nation.

Speaker: No more supplementary Questions. Mr. Maham Khalid please.

Mr.Maham Khalid: Honourable speaker madam, I would like to ask the
honourable Minister of Women and Child Welfare:
(a) What steps has the government taken regarding the increasing rates of
female infanticides in India?
(b) How far have these steps been successful?

Speaker: Minister of Women and Child Development please.

Minister of Women and Child Development: Hon'ble Speaker ma'am,

I would like to enlighten the house with effective steps undertaken by the govt
to combat social evils and to bring a change in the attitudes of the people. The
schemes that have been selected for secondary review & some which have
been implemented as well are:

i)Dhanlakshmi schemes of government of India, Bihar.

ii) Kanyadan schemes of Madhya Pradesh.
The Cradle Baby Scheme was expected to provide one solution to widely
prevalent practices of female foeticide and female infanticide in these districts.
But luckily improving literacy rate of women up from 33.2% in 1987 to 69.9%
in 2000, which is more than the average. Which have proved to be more useful
in these practices?
The government has allocated 1.88 lacks per district for establishing a
reception centre. Amidst allegation of huge money transactions, involved in
the adopting of cradle babies from private voluntary organizations, the official
claims that the NGO centres are monitored after the babies are handed over to
them

eSa cl ;gh dguk pkgwxh gVk nks lc ck/k,a esjs iFk

dh] feVk nks lc vk'kadk,a esjs eu dh] tekus dh cnyus

8
dh 'kfDr dks le>ks dne ls dne feykdj pyus rks nks
eq>dksA

Speaker: Lets move on to our next question. Question 105 Ms. Libin Deena
Raju please.
Libin: Thank you, Speaker.

v;{k egksn;k] eSa vkidh vuqefr ls ;g iwNuk pkgwaxh

fd D;ksa ljdkj ;equk dks lkiQ djus dk ,d nh?kZdkfyd
mik; ugha <wa< jgh gS\

Speaker: Honble Minister of Forest and Environmentt please.

Minister of Forest and Environment: Madam, I heard the honourable
member of the opposition and I want to assure the house through you that the
government has taken this, issue seriously. The house discussed the entire
issue of the pollution of river Ganga and Yamuna last year and effort such as
Ganga action plan-I, II, Yamuna action plan I, II, III were taken up and it has
bore fruits to this extend that the water level would have been much worse if
those efforts were not taken up.

Speaker: No Supplementary question. We proceed. Question 106 Mr. A. K.

Shaju please.

Mr. AK Shaju: egaxkbZ dh vkink us dgj gS <k;k] egaxkbZ

dh vkink us dgj gS <k;k] dc mBsxk vke vkneh ds lj ls]
egaxkbZ dk lk;kA

Honourable Speaker madam, will the Minister of Finance be pleased to state:

(a) The reasons behind the freefall of the rupee.

(b) The measures undertaken by the government to hold the falling rupee in
its grip.

Speaker: Minister of Finance please.

Minister Of Finance: The prices are going high due to inflationary pressures
emerging in the world market. The supply of a product is limited to its
9
increased demand leading to price hike. Today onion costs Rs. 80 because
exporting of onion has stopped and prices are rising due to hoarding. And as
you stated dc mBsxk vke ds lj bl egaxkbZ dk lk;k] rks
eSa ;gh dguk pkgwaxh eksgrjek fd egaxkbZ [kkyh vke
vkneh ds fy, ugha] ge tSls yksxksa ds fy, Hkh gksrh gS
vkSj gj ckr ds ihNs dksbZ u dksbZ dkj.k gksrk gS] rks
d`i;k mu dkj.kksa dks tkus fcuk viuh ckrsa tkfgj u
djsaA
Speaker: Member to ask supplementary question please
Mr. P.Khemkha: Respected speaker madam,
I heard the rupee is falling, please tell me from where I can collect it?
Today the only way to save the Rupee is to have it tie a Rakhi to the Dollar and
to the Euro and say Protect Me! Save Me!
Money cant buy happiness especially if its Rupee and invested in Sensex.

vknj.kh; Lihdj egksn;k] pkfg, rks ;g Fkk fd fok ea=kh

th viuh rjiQ ls dqN iz;kl djrs] ftlls ns'k dk fo'okl c<+rk]
fuos'kdksa dk gkSalyk c<+rk vkSj #i;k pkgs nl&chl
iSls gh p<+rk vkSj vxj p<+rk ugha rks de ls de fxjus ls
#drk] ysfdu eSMe& gqvk blds fcYdqy foijhr] lsUlsDl ds
yq<+dus ds ckn] #i;s us bl rjg ls fxjus 'kq: fd;k] bl rjg
ls fiQlyus 'kq: fd;k fd 56 #i;s ls fxjrk&fxjrk 68-89 ij vkdj
[kM+k gks x;k gSA eSa ;g dguk pkgwxk fd #i;k
dsoy ,d uksV] ,d flDdk ;k fiQj dkxt dk VqdM+k ugha
gksrk] mlds lkFk iwjs ns'k dh izfr"Bk rFkk iwjs ns'k dk
lEeku tqM+k gksrk gS vkSj tc ;g #i;k uhps fxjrk gS rks
iwjs ns'k dk lEeku o izfr"Bk Hkh uhps fxjrh gSA

Dollar on escalator.. Rupee on ventilator... Nation in ICU... We are in coma...

government in sleeping room... Onion in showroom... God bless India.!

10
Honourable speaker madam, I would like to ask concerned minister what
plan of action will be initiated by the government to win back the trust of
domestic & foreign investors?

Speaker: Minister of Finance please.

Minister Of Finance: Honourable Speaker madam. Here are my answers:
It is very easy to claim and point out decisions, but criticising every move of
ours wont help the worthy opposition to gain confidence. Firstly, everyone is
well aware of the fact that no economy can be a growing economy always.
Boom and slump are part of an economy. They cannot be avoided but certainly
measures can be taken to reduce its affects. devaluation of rupee is visible to
all but what they fail to understand is the increasing height of volatile
uncertainties emerging in the world marketare beyond of the government of

India or of opposition. dSlh ;s gok pyh esjs 'kgj esa] dSlh ;s

gok pyh esjs 'kgj esa] dqN cUns cu x, [kqnk esjs 'kgj
esaA

The measures are likely to send the rupee in a permanent upward trajectory.
Therefore let us not make the people panic, let us see realistically and though
it is a matter of serious concern let us not consider a situation that Indian
economy is dead. Even today despite de acceleration of economic growth, after
china India has grown at a rate of 5 % during 2012-13.
______________________________________________________________________________________

BREACH OF PRIVILEGE

Speaker: Ms. Meghna Singh, do you wish to say anything?

Meghna Singh: Respected speaker madam,

I would like to bring to the notice of the house a serious instance of breach of
privilege. This happened with regard to an Urdu newspaper published and
circulated from Aligarh whose editor has cast our party members in bad light
going as far as using demeaning vocabulary for many. I think that the house
11
should take strict action and act in union with regard to upholding the dignity
and sanctity of our public positions.

Speaker: Honourable member, have you given a notice of it earlier? If not you
may & I shall consider it. You cannot play a spring of surprise on me like this.
Meghna: Yes, ma'am I have submitted the evidence of this at 8:00 am this
morning.
Speaker: It will be examined when it comes to me, I shall consider it and let you
know my decision. Now papers to be laid.
________________________________________________________________________________
PAPERS TO BE LAID
Speaker: Honble Minister of Human Resource and Development.
Minister of Human Resource and Development: Honble Speaker Madam, I beg
to lay on the table a copy of each following notifications. Under sub-section(G)
of section 17 of the Indian Companies Bill 2012:
i) The second amendment rule 2013 published in notification No. G.S.R. 92 in
the Gazette of India dated 7th April, 2013.
ii) S.O.115K published in Gazette of India dated 13 th August 2013.

MESSAGE FROM UPPER CHAMBER

Speaker: Secretary General to report message from the Upper Chamber of
the Youth Parliament.
Secretary General: Ma'am I have to report the following message received
from the Secretary of the upper chamber of Youth Parliament. I am directed to
enclose the copy of ' Indian Companies Bill 2012', which has been passed by
the Upper Chamber on its sitting held on the 8th of August 2013.
Speaker: Secretary General to lay on the table a copy of the bill passed by the
Upper Chamber.
Secretary General: Ma'am, I lay on the table of the House, the copy of 'Indian
Companies Bill' as passed by the Upper Chamber of the Youth Parliament.
__________________________________________________________________________________

WELCOME TO THE DELEGATION

Speaker: Hon. members I have to make an announcement.

12
I have great pleasure in extending our warm welcome to our delegates :
Mr. Thomas, Speaker and Ms. Martha, Deputy Speaker & Ms. Elizabeth,
Minister Of states.
They are now seated in the special box. We wish them a happy and fruitful
stay in our country. We also convey our warm greetings to the friendly people
of United Kingdom. I hope this visit helps in making stronger ties with India.
________________________________________________________________________________
CALLING ATTENTION MOTION

Speaker: Now let us take up the Calling Attention Motion.

Ms. Vandana Bhatia please call the attention of the concerned minister.

Vandana Bhatia: ekuuh; Lihdj egksn;k] eSa vkids }kjk

x`gea=kh dh psruk gky esa gqbZ mkjk[k.M ck<+
vkink ij vkdf"kZr djuk pkgrh gwA

egksn;k] tc mkjk[kaM esa ckny iQVus ls ekSr] [kkSiQ

o rckgh dk eatj lkeus ns[kus dks feyk] rks iwjs ns'k ds
jksaxVsa [kM+s gks x;s FksA igkM+ksa] taxyksa esa
yk'kksa dh <sj yx xbZ Fkh] ftudk vfUre laLdkj vkink ds
nks grs ckn Hkh u gks ldkA

ekuuh; Lihdj egksn;k] o ;wFk ikfyZ;kesaV ds lHkkx.k]

ckr njvly ;g gS fd yEcs le; ls mRrjk[k.M esa dbZ rjg dk
voS/ fuekZ.k tkjh FkkA lM+dsa pkSM+h djus ds uke ij
cM+s iSekus ij igkM+ dkVdj mldk eyok ufn;ksa esa
Mkyk tk jgk Fkk vkSj pkSdkus okyh ckr rks ;g gS lnL;x.k
fd ;g lc mRrjk[k.M ljdkj dh ukd ds uhps ugha] cfYd iwjh
lgefr ls gks jgk FkkA VwfjT+e o /eZ dh lud mkjk[k.M

13
ljdkj ij bruh lokj Fkh fd fcYdqy ufn;ksa ds
fdukjs&fdukjs] gksVyksa] jsLVksjsaV o fjtksVZ ds :i esa
dadjhV dh ?ksjkcanh dj nh xbZA

ufn;ksa us gesa thou fn;k gS] ij geus fodkl dh lud esa

mUgsa dwM+k o dpjk /ksus okyh okf'kax e'khu le>
fy;k gSA

ekuuh; Lihdj egksn;k] ge ,d iq[rk bUDok;jh dh ekax djrs

gSa fd vkf[kj D;ksa o fdl vk/kj ij bu gksVyksa]
jsLVksjsaV o fjtksVZ ds fuekZ.k ij gkeh Hkjh xbZ\
vkSj ;g tkurs gq, fd mkjk[k.M "High Risk Prone Zones" esa
ls ,d gSA vkirdkyhu esa vko';d gsyhiSM~l] ,vjfVIl vkfn
lk/uksa dk izcU/u mfpr le; ij D;ksa ugha fd;k x;k\

Speaker: ekuuh; x`gea=kh th

Debasmita Goswami: : ekuuh; v;{k egksn;k] mkjk[k.M jkT;
esa ?kfVr fgeky;u =kklnh ls ge Hkh mruk gh nq%[k o
'kksd eglwl dj jgsa gSa] ftruk ;gk mifLFkr ekuuh;
lHkkx.kA izfro"kZ djksM+ksa HkDrtu mkjk[k.M esa
pkj/ke ds n'kZu djus ds fy, vkrs gSaA ns'k&fons'k u
tkus fdrus izkUr ls HkDrtu ;gk i/kjrs gSaA muds jgus
dh O;oLFkk dgk dh tk,\ v vki gh crkb, egksn;k muds
jgus dh O;oLFkk D;k lM+dksa ij VsaV gkl yxkdj djsa\
ugha uk\ blh dkj.k gesa vf/d ls vf/d gksVyksa ,oa
/eZ'kkykvksa dk izca/ djuk iM+rk gSA egksn;k

14
mkjk[k.M ij ,d izkd`frd dgj vk iM+k Fkk] ,d izkd`frd
dgj ftlesa yk[kksa yksx vius izk.kksa ls gkFk /ks cSBs]
geus fiQj Hkh pkeksyh] mkjdk'kh] jkecM+k bR;kfn
LFkkuksa ij jkgr dk;Z ds fy, gsyhdkWIVj Hksts fks] vc
egksn;k ,sls ifjfLFkfr;ksa esa ;s iSlksa dk fglkc&fdrkc
j[kuk dkiQh gh dfBu gSA vc vki dgsaxs fd lk/qvksa us
djksM+ksa #i;ksa dk ?kksVkyk dj fn;k] vc D;k mldh
Hkh ftEesnkjh ljdkj mBk,xh egksn;k\ ugha egksn;k
ugha] ;g ugha gks ldrkA ;s ftrus egaxs diM+s vki igurh
gSa uk] mlesa ls d`i;k ,d VqdM+k viuk p'ek lki+Q djus
ds fy, j[k ysa] vkids dke esa vk,xkA vkSj gka egksn;k ;s
D;k 'koksa dh vafre laLdkjksa dh ckr djrh gSa\ 'koksa
ds vafre laLdkj rks rHkh gks x, Fks egksn;k] tc ;s vius ?
kj ij ,-lh- esa cSBdj ;g lksp jgh Fkha fd gesa lokyksa
ds ?ksjksa esa dSls dSn fd;k tk;s\ iz'kklu cpko dk;Z esa
yxs gq, Fks egksn;k vkSj mUgksaus ihfM+r yksxksa
dks lqjf{kr LFkkuksa ij igqapkus esa dksbZ dlj ugha
NksM+h vkSj ;g eSa iQ ds lkFk dg ldrh gwA

Speaker: Members to ask clarification question please.

Vandana Bhatia: vjs! eksgrjek] gekjh ljdkj rks vius p'esa

lkiQ dj ysxh] ysfdu vkidh ljdkj ds ?kksVkyksa ds nkxksa
dks vkf[+kj fdl fMVtZUV ls lkiQ fd;k tk;sxkA

15
vkSj gk] eksgrjek] gekjs diM+s rks egaxs gksaxs gh]
vf[+kj egaxkbZ vki gh dh ljdkj dk tks migkj gSA

ekuuh;] Lihdj egksn;k] National Disaster Management Authority

ges'kk #i;ksa ls yckyc jgh gS] 2010 ls 2015 ds vius
dk;Zdky esa ljdkj dh bl foHkkx esa djksM+ksa #i;s bl
ikVhZ ds fjVk;MZ viQljksa dh eksVh ru[okg esa yxs
Fks] rks vkink izcU/u [kkd djrs\--- iSlksa dh leL;k dHkh
u Fkh] 835 djksM+ #i;s ,u-Mh-,e-,- dks 2013 ls 2014
esa tkx#drk dk;ks ds fy, fn;s x;sA ge tkuuk pkgrs gSa
fd ,slh dkSu lh vkink esa bu #i;ksa dk bLrseky gqvk\---

vkSj gk] eksgrjek vc vkbZ ckr foi{k ds dke dh] crk

nwa vkidks] foi{k dk dke uk ?kj esa cSBdj vkidks ;gka
lokyksa ds ?ksjksa esa dSls dSn djsa\--- ds ckjs esa
lkspus dk ugha gS] cfYd foi{k dk dke rks vkidks ;gka
lPpkbZ ds dB?kjs esa ykus dk gS! vkSj ;fn vki lp lquus
dh fgEer j[krh gSa rks lqfu;s] lp ;g gS fd vkt ns'k dk gj
oks ukxfjd tks viuh iwjh fln~nr ls bUde] izkiVhZ] lsYl
vkfn VSDl Hkjrk gS] vius dks Bxk&lk eglwl djrk gSA

egksn;k] ge bl Hk;kud vkink ds vkus ds ckn ljdkj dh

ck<+ ihfM+rksa ds fy, iquokZl ,oa iqufuekZ.k tkuus ds
bPNqd gSaA---

Speaker: ekuuh; x`gea=kh th

16
Home Minister: mkjk[k.M ds iquokZl ,oa iqufuZek.k ds
iFk ij gekjs ljdkj ds egRoiw.kZ fu.kZ; dqN bl izdkj gSa
%

nSoh; vkink ls izHkkfor lHkh ifjokjksa dks fu%'kqYd

jk'ku ftlesa 15 fdyksxzke pkoy] vkVk bR;kfn fn;k
tk;sxkA

lHkh ifjokjksa ds fo|qr fcy 1 twu 2013 ls 31 ekpZ

2014 rd ekiQ jgsxhA

lHkh Hkouksa dk fuekZ.k fu;e ,oa fof/ vuqlkj fd;k

tk;sxkA

lHkh Ldwyksa ds Nk=kksa dks 500@&# izfr

Nk=k] ikWfyVsdfud vkfn dks 1000@& #i;s izfr Nk=k
fn;k tk;sxkA

lHkh vukFk gq, cPpksa ds ykyu&iks"k.k dh

ftEesnkjh ljdkj mBk;sxhA

bldh ,d dkWih ge ekuuh; egksn;k dks lkSai jgs gSa vkSj

bldh ,d dkiWh ge vkids ?kj dksfj;j djok nsaxsA tjk ;ku
ls i<+ yhft,xkA

Speaker: Mr. M.Gupta Please.

Mr. M.Gupta: Respected Speaker madam,

With rescue and relief operations on a full serving in rain ravished
Uttarakhand.

17
cs'kd bf.M;u vkehZ o usoh us bl vkink ds ladV ls
yksxksa dks cpk;k gS] ysfdu ,d dM+ok lp rks ;g gS
egksn;k dh lsukvksa ds tokuksa dh dqckZfu;ksa esa gh
,u-Mh-,e-,- dh iQkslsZt dh lcls cM+h o fuUnktud
ukdke;kch fNih gSA

Speaker: Ms. Joshita Juneja please.

Joshita Juneja: With thousands of people crying for their graves and many
more dead bodies are still unclaimed with resentment among saved people
and sorrow in atmosphere we pray that such incidents are never by the tears
of all sufferers in the History of India.
Speaker: Ms. Nivedita Pandit please.
Nivedita Pandit: Each & Every citizen stood united for this cause. So why cant
we also act with togetherness for the betterment of our country & people of
Uttarakhand.
______________________________________________________________________________________

BILL INTRODUCTION

Speaker: Now let us take up legislative business now. Honourable Minister of

Labour please.
Minister Of Labour: Maam, I beg for a leave to introduce the bill further
The Employment of Children (Amendment) Bill, 1985
Speaker: Now the question is:
That the bill should be passed
Those who are in favour will say Aye
Those who are against it will say no
I think the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
Leave is granted. Honble minister please
Minister of Labour: Maam, I introduce the bill
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Bill for consideration

18
Speaker: Now the House will take up consideration of the indecent and
surrogate advertising and re-mixing songs prohibition bill. Honble Minister of
Information and Broadcasting please.
Minister of Information and Broadcasting: Madam I lay on the table a copy
of the Indecent and Surrogate Advertising and Re-mixing Songs Prohibition
Bill to be taken into consideration.
Honourable speaker madam, I would like to introduce the bill which is in
regard to prohibit publication or telecast of indecent or surrogate
advertisements and remixing songs which contain vulgarity and nudity that
adversely affect the minds of children and the young generation. With the view
to protect the values and culture of the society and for the matter therewith or
incidental.
Under this act no person shall:
a) Publish or telecast or cause to be published or telecast or arrange to
part in the publication, telecast or exhibition.
b) Produce or cause to be produce, depict, circulate, distribute, broadcast
or telecast any indecent remixing song.
c) Any person who contravenes the provisions of sub section (1) shall be
guilty of an offence under this act.
d) Any person who contravenes the provisions of section 3 shall be punished
with an imprisonment of 5 years and may extend up to 10 years and with the
fine which shall not less than 3 lakh rupees which may extend up to 7 lakh
rupees.
e) Where an offence under this act has been committed by a company, firm, or
association of individuals every person who, at the time the offence was
committed, was in charge of and was responsible to the company, firm or
association for the conduct of such acts.
Speaker maam, I am confident that all honble members of this house
irrespective of the party affiliation will welcome the bill whole-heartedly and
help to put an end to the publication of vulgarity. With these words, I now
move the Indecent and Surrogate advertisement and re-mixing songs
prohibition bill to be taken into consideration.
Speaker: Motion moved. Ms. Kritika Taneja please.
Kritika Taneja: Hon'ble speaker madam, I assert my vehement opposition to
the consideration of such a bill. Madam, India is a democracy where freedom
of speech and expression is its USP. Most of the vulgar ads as termed by the
members of YP are of brands which manufacture products like inner wears,
vests, deo, body lotions, creams, soaps or shower gels. Madam, quite obviously
& evidently; the use of such products is done without clothes which mean to
19
promote these products, it is necessary to show the body parts concerned
which in no sense portrays vulgarity. If it was so, such ads won't have been
allowed to be telecast on national television. I may have no faith in this Govt.
but i have trust on this Ministry in these regards.
Speaker: Ms. Ishita Bhattacharjee please.
Ishita Bhattacharjee: Honourable speaker maam, even I as a responsible
Indian citizen & audience assert absolute faith in the passing of this bill.
Madam, in the name of freedom of speech and expression the ad-makers
have woefully gone beyond their limits. Today, the exposure of the society to
obscenity, nudity & vulgarity is crossing all levels of decency and damaging
our culture. Of late, the television channels show remixed songs where the
popular songs of the Hindi movies are played in the backdrop of vulgar scenes
or ads. Also As per the government policies, advertisements of liquor and
tobacco products are prohibited in print and e-media. But manufacturers
promote such products in surrogate ads.
Speaker: Ms Anya Korula please.
Anya Korula: Remix music is a freedom of expression.
Its lyrical content flow like a poetry and often tells us a story.
Advertisements are the source of mass media for earning its livelihood.
In my opinion these ads & remixes are not so bad. Instead of putting a ban on
it, we should change the mindsets of people.

Speaker: Honourable Home Minister please.

Home Minister: Madam, Most of these advertisements are for foreign
products. The display of indecently dressed women has nothing to do with the
product that has to be advertised. Instead it creates a sense of negativity in the
minds of the viewers and young minds.
Maam, all this hints that the makers of such advertisements are not so
interested in advertising the actual product but in promoting vulgarity.
Add makers of such products brim with messages aimed at tickling the
libidinous male instincts and portrayal of women as lustily hankering after
men under the influence of such deodorants, are heinous , vulgar suggestive
and appear in decent to all the masses.
Speaker: Mr. A. Titus please.
Mr. A. Titus: Madam the contaminating effects of such ads and songs is
evident through sky rocketing crime rates and cases of rape, eve teasing,

20
murder, etc. hence I conclude with the belief of banning such ads and songs
which is vested in the welfare of larger interest of the public..
Speaker: Ms. Marya please.
Marya: Honourable speaker maam. I am strongly in favour of this bill to be
passed, since advertisements that we see on our televisions, which obviously
are seen by people of every age including children & senior citizens. They are
made so indecent and controversial that it seems what they are advertising is
not the product but vulgarity and nudity. The modern advertising Era has
proved to be a bane to our society.

Speaker: Ms. Subhra Goswami Please.

Subhra Goswami : The songs which retain the essence of morals, decency &
melodies are now called Old-School.
Modernisation is one thing but spreading vulgarity under the banner of
modernisation is highly condemned.
Speaker: Ms. Sumbul please.
Sumbul: Honble Speaker madam, I present my dissent on the very idea of
proposal of this bill, madam through you I would like to address the respected
blue bloods of our incredible India by only saying: vxj ,sls fcy ikl gks
Hkh tk,axs rks cnyko dgka utj vk;saxsA cSu yxkus dk
eryc ;g rks ugha fd vka[kksa ij inZs iM+ tk,axsA ftUgsa
ilUn gS ;g lc] og FkksM+h u #d tk,axs] fcy ds ikl gksus
ls bUVjusV lk/u dgk feV tk,axsA mEehn gS fd blls vki
vo'; gh esjk rdZ le> ik;saxsA

Speaker: Ms. Nagma Narang please.

Nagma Narang: : eqqUuh cnuke gqbZ] 'khyk toku gqbZ]

ns'k dh e;kZnk Hkax ;wa gh ljsvke gqbZA

fVadw ft;k gS cs'kehZ fe;ka] ySyk us epkbZ gS xehZ

fe;ka

g yk yk dk cksyckyk] ns'k dh bTtr dks /ks MkykA

21
When we think of music videos, one visualises image of a woman who is
titillating, sensuous and whose sole purpose is to arouse men with the show of
half naked bodies. The music industry has begun a new onslaught on women's
dignity and right to privacy with the lyrics, scenes and dialogues touching
dangerously low levels of degradation and sexual abuse. Such music albums
that have become popular with the youth can encourage them to indulge into
casual sex and intimate relationships. We dont need more nudity and
profanity on television. I think the house would agree what we need is
stringent censorship of indecent and surrogate advertisements and remix
songs that adversely influence our impressionable generations. This isnt an
issue which should be taken lightly & requires immediate restriction,
censorship & control.
Speaker: Minister of Information and Broadcasting please.
Minister of Information and Broadcasting: Based on the wide ranging and
holistic discussion by the House, Speaker maam
I request the house to pass the bill.
Speaker: The question is:
That the bill indecent and surrogate advertisements and re mixing of songs
prohibition bill be taken into consideration
Those who are in favour will say Aye
Those who are against it will say No
I think the Ayes have it , the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
The motion is adopted.
Clause by clause consideration.
Speaker: Now the question is that clause 2-10 stands part of the bill.
There is an amendment in clause 5 by Ms. Kritika Taneja. Are you moving it?

Kritika Taneja: Respected speaker maam, in view of the reply given by the
minister I am not pressing my amendment any further.
Speaker: Now the question is that clause 2-10 stand part of the bill.
Those who are in favour may say Aye
Those who are against it may say No
I think the Ayes have it , the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it
The motion is adopted.
22
Clause 2-10 stand part of the bill.
Now the question is:
That clause I, the enacting formula and the title stand part of the bill.
Those who are in favour will say Aye
Those who are against it will please say No
I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
The motion is adopted.
-Minister of Information & Broadcasting Please.
Minster of Information and Broadcasting: Maam, I move the bill to be
passed.
Speaker: motion moved.
That the bill is passed
Those in favour may please say Aye
Those against it may please say No
I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
The motion is moved.
______________________________________________________________________________________

PRIVATE MEMBERS RESOLUTION

Speaker: Now the House will take up the private members resolution.
Ms. Vandana Bhatia to move the resolution:
Vandana Bhatia: Madam, I move the following resolution.
This house recommends that the government should:
1) Take stringent steps to effectively combat the increasing rape cases
against women in India.
2) Strict instructions to be given to the police services to improve their
investigational conduct with the victims and not in any case deter from
lodging the FIRs.
3) There should be capital punishment for rapes to set examples in the
Indian society and send strong message against this evil crime.

23
4) A facility of post-trauma therapy to help the victims retain their calm,
peace and confidence to relive with ease and bliss.
Also Maam, Theres an urgent need to re-examine the laws that govern the
juveniles of our country.
Honourable speaker madam,
The existence of women epitomizes love, struggle and dedication; they do not
deserve this dastardly behaviour in return. The Indian government ought to
break into this serious matter and tame this menace with efficiency.
Speaker: Ms. Niharika Gupta please.
Niharika Gupta: Thank you maam. Maam at the outset I thank ms Vandana
Bhatia for bringing into centre stage this very shocking story in to resolution. I
would like to make two suggestions. First, the government should empower
and establish the institutions and the NGOs to work in these regards and
impose stringent measures to effectively combat such awful activities.
Also maam the zealous journalist of the media would be an immense
breakthrough in nailing such criminals and campaigning against this social
evil.

esjs mn~xkj ,d NksVh lh dfork }kjk%

vka[k [kqyh vkt+kn Fkh eSa]
vkt+knh esa tathjs D;ksa\
esjs Hkh dqN lius Fks]
csnnhZ ls rksM+s D;ksa\---
vc pyuk gS eq>dks vkxs]
gj dne ij vM+pu D;ksa\---
<wa< jgh gwa [kqn dks eSa]
cUn rsjs njokts D;ksa\---
eu ds ?kwa?kV dks ysdj]
lksp ij inkZ Mkys D;ksa\---
eu Fkk lkFk pyw]
iwNwa eSa ihNs D;ksa\---
eu Fkk ftUnk jgus dk---
Mwcuk eq>dks vk;k D;ksa\---

24
 vjek tkxs iwNwa D;ksa\---
gj iy rsjk lk;k D;ksa\---
[kwc le> esa vk;k vc]
tax yM+uh gS eq>dks D;ksa\---
pyrh Fkh rsjs cy ls]
cy vius ls vki pywA

Speaker: Deputy Min. Of women & child development please.

Deputy Min. Of women & child development: Respected speaker ma'am, the
resolution that has been proposed is consisting of many loopholes. First of all :
if capital punishment had the power to rinse out our society of atrocious
crimes, it would have done that long ago, because the notion of capital
punishment is not new to our judicial and political system. The use of formal
execution extends to the beginning of recorded history. We have always had
capital punishment for murders, but have murders stopped?? And now you
think that capital punishment can end rapes in our society?? Secondly:
Numbers of rape cases that go unreported are far more than those which are
reported. And the reach of capital punishment is limited only to this tip of the
iceberg. Thus reforms in the society are the best solution. Just like girls are
groomed in certain ways, boys should also be taught not to cross certain limits
and learn to respect women. We cannot legislate good behaviour, as the saying
goes, we have to build it in the DNA fellow members of the Youth Parliament;
it is the people who need an amendment and not the laws.
Speaker: Ms Aditi Chaudhury please.
Aditi Chaudhury: Respected Speaker Maam, our party is not against the
reformative theory but the failure of the reformative theory is not a new
concept. It is reflected by the case of two criminals, Santosh and Molai of
Madhya Pradesh who were already serving life imprisonment and were
employed as domestic helpers by their assistant jailer who claimed he could
reform them. But the delinquent men raped the jailers minor daughter and
murdered her. Therefore, capital punishment would not only act as a weapon
but also as a shield for women until the men of our society change for the
better. We need it because we cant ignore the fact that a five-year old girl was
raped and battered, had a plastic bottle and candles shoved into her private
parts and was left to die until she was found 40 hours later lying in a pool of
her own blood. Do you think her offender deserves anything but death? I
request all of you, for a minute, try to put yourself into the victims shoes. God
forbid, if anyone amongst us has to suffer such fate, would we not demand
capital punishment for our assailant? Would we wish that the goon be
reformed, the society be restructured? Capital punishment serves such
25
perpetrators right. It doesnt seek revenge it seeks retribution. We need it
because the lost dignity and chastity of a woman can never be restored. end I
would also like to quote from the judgment of the honourable Supreme Court
of India while awarding punishment to rapists The ends of justice in such a
case cry for extreme penalty of death to both the accused and nothing short.
There will be not only injustice to the society but sentencing will lose its
relevance, if lesser penalty is given. unquote. I hope that the ruling party will
take into account the oppositions view and introduce capital punishment so
that the fear of law is embedded in the minds of all those who even think of
committing rape.
Minister Of Women & Child Development: Ma'am I agree with the
sentiments expressed by the opposition and the government will surely pay
heed to this matter. But we cannot ignore the pressures put on the
government by different associations, organizations, advocating human rights
and the rights of prisoners. Honble speaker maam since the CRIMINAL
AMENDMENT ACT 2013as already been implemented and judiciary has got
discretionary powers. To award capital punishment in the rarest of rare cases,
as we saw in DEC 16 2012 GANGRAPE.
In view of the efforts undertaken by the government to this problem.
Honble speaker maam through you I request the honourable member of the
house to withdraw the resolution.
Speaker: Ms. Vandana Bhatia please.
Vandana Bhatia: Maam I am grateful to the Honble members for lending
support to my resolution. In view of the assurance given by the Honble
Minister and since a law has already been enacted to deal with this menace I
hope that the government will take all stringent measures to eliminate this
problem.
Therefore I may be allowed to withdraw the resolution.
Speaker: Has the Honble member leave of the house to withdraw the
resolution.
Several speakers: YES YES!
Speaker: The resolution by the leave of the house is withdrawn.

Speaker:The House is adjourned for today. We will meet tomorrow at 11 am.

Thank you.

26