Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: This paper gives an overview of methods used in the The magnitude of the voltage sag is mainly determined by
mitigation of voltage sags. Different solutions for improving the the impedance between the faulted bus and the load and by
performance of the power system, as well as the immunity of the the method of connection of the transformer windings [1].
equipment, are described. Finally, mitigation devices to be installed The voltage sag lasts until the fault is cleared by a protective
at the system-load interface for power quality enhancement are
device, therefore the duration of the sag is determined by the
presented.
Keywords: voltage sags, power quality, electromagnetic fault-clearing time of the protection system adopted.
compatibility (EMC), distribution system design, power electronics Moreover, if automatic reclosure is used by the utility, the
voltage sag condition can occur repeatedly in the case of a
I. INTRODUCTION permanent fault. Finally, depending on its magnitude and
duration, the sag can cause an equipment trip, thus becoming
Power quality and reliability are essential for proper a power quality problem.
operation of industrial processes which involve critical and Based on the mechanism leading to a voltage sag (from
sensitive loads. Short-duration power disturbances, such as short-circuit fault to equipment trip, Fig. 2) three different
voltage sags, swells and short interruptions, are major locations, for the mitigation of voltage sags can be
concerns for industrial customers. Due to the wide usage of distinguished [2]: on the power system side or upstream of
sensitive electronic equipment in process automation, even the meter, on the equipment, downstream of the meter, or,
voltage sags which last for only few tenths of a second may finally, at the system-equipment interface, at the meter.
cause production stops with considerable associated costs;
these costs include production losses, equipment restarting,
damaged or lower-quality product and reduced customer Reduction of number and
SHORT-CIRCUIT FAULT
satisfaction [1]. duration of faults
The high costs associated with these disturbances explain
the increasing interest towards voltage sag mitigation
techniques. The cost of the mitigation intervention has to be
compared with the loss of revenue and takes into account all PROPAGATION THROUGH Changes in the structure
the economic factors involved. THE POWER SYSTEM of the power system
To understand the different ways of mitigating voltage
sags, various factors contributing to the problem have to be
understood. The cause of most voltage sags is a short-circuit
fault occurring either within the industrial facility under SYSTEM-EQUIPMENT Installation of
INTERFACE mitigation devices
consideration or on the utility system. The starting of large
motors also results in voltage sags, but these are not usually
very severe. The short-circuit fault causes the voltage to drop
to almost zero at the fault position. This zero voltage turns
Improvement of
then into an event of a certain magnitude and duration at the EQUIPMENT TRIP
equipment immunity
interface between the power system and the equipment. A
typical voltage sag waveform is shown in Fig. 1. Fig. 2. Establishment of the voltage quality problem
V [V ] and various ways of mitigation
8000
6000
This paper gives a comprehensive overview of various
mitigation methods. It is organised in the following way: in
4000
Section II the mitigation through intervention on the power
2000 system is treated, considering both changes in the electrical
components of the system and in its structure. In Section III
0
0,00 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,10 0,12 0,14 0,16 0,18 0,20 0,22 0,24 0,26
t [s] the effect of voltage sags on the performance of the
-2000 equipment is described, together with possible actions to be
-4000
taken on loads in order to improve their immunity. Low-
power electronics (computers, process-control equipment), as
-6000
well as higher-power electronics (ac and dc drives) are
-8000
considered. Section IV is dedicated to mitigation devices to
be installed at the interface between the system and the
Fig. 1. Typical waveform of a voltage sag caused by remote fault-clearing
equipment. Finally, conclusions are drawn in Section V.
II. CHANGES IN THE POWER SYSTEM than a static circuit breaker) is very suitable in this case, since
no re-closure is necessary: with a single load, the fault is
A. Reducing the number of faults likely to be permanent and repair is needed before power
restoring.
Limiting the number of faults is an effective way to
reduce not only the number of voltage sags, but also the
frequencies of short and long interruptions.
Fault prevention actions may include the institution of tree
trimming policies, the addition of lightning arresters,
insulator washing and the addition of animal guards [3].
Insulation on transmission systems cannot withstand the most
severe lightning strokes, but lines which are often subject to
lightning-induced faults should be carefully investigated for
improvement of the insulation level. Faults due to lightning time-graded overcurrent protection
can be reduced by lowering the ground resistance at the foot
Fig. 3. Radial distribution system with cascaded substation
of the tower for overhead static wires. Other measures
include the use of recently introduced special wires, which An ideal application of a static breaker, even in already
are covered by a thin layer of insulation material [4], or the existing distribution systems, is at the tie-line location shown
installation of additional shielding wires, placed in such a in Fig. 4 [8]. In the event of a fault on a feeder downstream, it
way that they are more likely to be hit by a lightning stroke provides fast bus-splitting after which the fault is cleared by a
than the phase conductors. downstream protective device, thus reducing the total fault
A considerable reduction in the number of faults per year current and the duration of the sag as seen by the loads
can otherwise be achieved by replacing overhead lines by supplied by the adjacent feeder.
underground cables, which are less affected by adverse
weather. The fault rate of an overhead line is much higher
than that of an underground cable [5], but in case of a fault 66 kV substation
the repair time of the latter is longer.
66 kV substation I 66 kV substation II
LOAD
66/11 kV
Fig. 7. Static Transfer Switch
11 kV bus
A. Computers and process-control equipment The ac drive is normally set to trip either upon an
undervoltage on the dc bus or in the event of an overcurrent
The power supply of computers and other low-power through the diodes or on the ac side. Sometimes line-side
devices normally consists of a single-phase diode rectifier fuses blow because of the high current on voltage recovery.
followed by a dc-dc voltage regulator. The latter transforms Assuming, however, that no protections trip the drive during
the non-regulated dc voltage at a few hundreds volts into a the sag, the process may not be able to tolerate the drop in
regulated dc voltage. A capacitor is connected to the non- speed or the torque variations due to the sag.
regulated dc bus in order to reduce the voltage ripple at the Improvements in drive performance can be obtained by
input of the voltage regulator. adding a series reactor to limit the post-sag inrush and by
If the RMS value of the ac voltage drops suddenly, the reducing the setting of the dc bus undervoltage protection
capacitor discharges not only for half a cycle, as in normal [12]. Note that the latter needs to be co-ordinated with the
operation, but for a longer period, until its voltage drops protection and tolerance of the rectifier and the inverter.
below the ac value of voltage again, and a new equilibrium is However, it is generally accepted that the current design of
reached. The duration of the discharge of the capacitor is adjustable-speed drives does not leave much room for
directly dependent on the magnitude of the voltage sag. The improvement of the tolerance against balanced sags.
voltage regulator is normally able to maintain the output During unbalanced sags, the behaviour depends to a large
voltage constant over a certain range of variation of the input extent on the size of the dc bus capacitance. For a moderate
voltage. But if the voltage on the non-regulated side becomes capacitor size, the dc bus voltage will not drop very much
too low, the protection will trip the device to protect the during one half-cycle [2]. The result is that the minimum dc
digital electronic components on the other side of the bus voltage during the event is determined by the highest of
regulator. the three phase-to-phase supply voltages. It can be shown that
This can be a limiting factor in applying electronic the highest phase voltage is rarely below 80% of nominal
equipment for the automation of production lines: the voltage during an unbalanced sag. The dc bus voltage will
operation of a 120 V ac PLC I/O unit, for instance, has been therefore rarely drop below 80%. [2].
reported to be disrupted by a sag of less than 86 % magnitude
and more than 16 ms duration [11]. C. DC Drives
C. Inverter-based solutions
POWER SENSITIVE
SYSTEM LOAD A UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) consists of a diode
rectifier followed by an inverter (Fig. 13). The energy storage
Fig. 10. Motor-generator set is usually a battery block connected to the dc link. During
normal operation, power coming from the ac supply is
B. Transformer-based solutions rectified and then inverted. The batteries remain in standby
mode and only serve to keep the dc bus voltage constant.
A Constant Voltage, or ferro-resonant, Transformer (CVT) During a voltage sag or an interruption, the energy released
works in a similar manner to a transformer with a 1:1 turns by the battery block maintains the voltage at the dc bus.
ratio which is excited at a high point on its saturation curve, Depending on the storage capacity of the battery block, it can
thus providing an output voltage which is not affected by supply the load for minutes or even hours.
lagging voltage in quadrature with the load current [17]. The
POWER SENSITIVE inverter is usually based on IGBTs characterised by high
SYSTEM ~ LOAD switching frequencies: therefore, with proper control, it is
~ possible to perform perfect voltage compensation in less than
half a cycle.
POWER SENSITIVE
ENERGY
SYSTEM LOAD
STORAGE
DEVICE
Fig. 13. Uninterruptible power supply
Low cost, simple operation and control have made the UPS
Voltage Source
the standard solution for low-power equipment like Inverter
computers. For higher-power loads the costs associated with
losses due to the two additional conversions and the
maintenance of the batteries become too high and this
solution no longer appears to be economically feasible. Energy Storage
Device