Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sign In/Register
NEWS FULL COMMENT SPORTS CULTURE LIFE MORE DRIVING CLASSIFIEDS JOBS SUBSCRIBE FINANCIAL POST
Comment
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 1/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
Facebook objectively innocent, benign, cute and even touching and it was
N EW S VI D EO S
absolutely well-intended. But Ive spent so much time in Stupid
Twitter
Twitter-Land that I expected the parents to stand up and start booing
and hissing and calling for the studio owners head.
Email
Niki Ashton Follow Bodies found in Swiss glacier may unlock 75-
@nikiashton year-old mystery
TY @BLM_Van We removed it.Not our intention to
appropriate.We're committed to a platform of racial justice+would
Nefarious, stupid, or he just doesn't care:
appreciate ur feedback.
Three theories about why Trump met
9:43 AM - 14 Mar 2017
secretly with Putin
7 14
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 2/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
But without intending to, Twitters culture warriors also have created
what might be described as a sort of crowdsourced ideological
autocracy. And paradoxically, the public figures who are most
consistently victimized by it are creatures of the left, such as Niki
Ashton since these are the same figures whose legitimacy as
politicians, activists and writers depends on the moral judgments of
Stupid Twitter-Lands most ruthless enforcers.
Understanding how all this came to pass means looking past the
dynamics of the online world for the pathologies that have taken
root on Twitter are rooted in changes in the increasingly
impoverished bricks-and-mortar world of workaday publishing and
academia. In the good old days when a young columnist, copy editor
or adjunct professor could aspire to a job with a pension, and a
middle-class life on a leafy street, it made sense to avoid fights and
play nice with your peers. But in a world where starving artists go
online every day with that lean and hungry look, being right or
seen as right often is the only thing that matters.
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 3/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 4/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
cycling may play out through several iterations before the force of
the attack is spent.)
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 5/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
the fear and malaise that now grips much of the Canadian
R ELAT ED community of arts and letters more generally: There is not one star
ST O RI ES in its entire firmament whose professional status cannot be
threatened by small, ad hoc coalitions of intellectuals and artists
whose names are entirely unknown to ordinary Canadians. Indeed,
this is the reason why the debates over issues such as cultural
appropriation are so one-sided: It may take a day or two for Twitters
Jonathan Kay: Why I quit tastemakers to crowdsource a moral judgment. But once they do,
The Walrus for an
there is little room for dissent. And then everyone from the
exciting new future of
reckless commentary at wealthy men and women who run the champagne speaking salons,
Taco Barn
down to the humblest activist with an egg avatar is expected to
fall into line.
John Robson: While
you're all freaked about
One of the most unsettling experiences I had at my magazine took
appropriation, I'll just
read some Shakespeare place following the 2016 dismissal of University of British Columbia
creative writing chair Steven Galloway, after he was accused of
Rex Murphy: First the sexual assault by one of his students. None of the accusations
trigger-warning brigade against Galloway have been proven in court, and so I navely
came for my yoga mat.
Will my Milton and Yeats imagined that it would be uncontroversial to publish an article by
be next? memoirist Carmen Aguirre that stood in support of the principle of
due process and innocent-until-proven-guilty especially given that
Aguirre herself is a woman of colour who knows the horror of sexual
assault first hand, having been raped at gunpoint as a young
teenager. Yet by the time her article appeared, the fix was in: Stupid
Twitter-Land had decided that any defence of Galloway effectively
was tantamount to misogynistic hate speech. Aguirre was tarred as
a rape apologist. Several colleagues warned me that publishing it
would compromise our reputation with literary A-listers.
The author, to her great credit, persevered anyway, and included this
extraordinary salvo against her critics. The left is in shambles in
North America. And the Galloway controversy reveals why, Aguirre
wrote. It has become the new puritanical church, shaming, bullying,
condemning, and expelling anyone in its ranks who is seen as taking
a misstep. It has become victim to its own victim stance, choosing to
see oppressors and enemies within its own membership.
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 6/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
recoiled in horror lest the Posts right-leaning ideological taint rub off
on him like some kind of dermatological pathogen.
Its also the case that the world of arts and letters now looks a lot like
Uber or eBay an increasingly physically disconnected world that
is woven together by email and social media. Many writers and
editors never see one another in person, with each toiling in their
respective basements or nearby coffee shops. The normal, everyday
water-cooler social lubricants that help encourage everyone to give
each other the benefit of the doubt are absent. And so innocent or
satirical comments are seized on as evidence of ignorance or
malice.
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 7/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
known than they are now. There was no Twitter back then. So if your
name didnt appear on the masthead, and you didnt write books or
columns, it was likely that no one in the general public knew your
name. Some of this countrys greatest editors passed through their
entire careers in almost complete anonymity.
At the same time, wages within the journalism industry flat-lined, and
job security eroded. So there was less motivation to toe your bosss
line, and more motivation to go rogue and focus on your own digital
brand. Your boss could take away your paycheque. But she could
never take away your followers.
When they watch their likes and retweets and such, they are like
investors of old watching a stock ticker. To lose status on social
media is, for this cohort, a form of bankruptcy. Thats why they run
scared from controversial opinions, pressure colleagues within their
organization to respect the Twitter-enforced party line, and join the
pack against excommunicated heretics. In this environment, each of
them secretly knows that they could be next.
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 8/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9b 9/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9 10/11
7/19/2017 Jonathan Kay on the tyranny of Twitter: How mob censure is changing the intellectual landscape | National Post
the solution requires collective action that cuts against the self-
interest of the dogmatists who now dominate Twitter, there is no
obvious path to a systematic solution. Nor does such a campaign
have any obvious leader. (Since the very fact of this essays
existence will make me a popular target among trolls, even my
friends would agree that I am uniquely unqualified for the role.)
So all I can ask is that people reading this give a thought to how their
use of social media is shaping the broader intellectual landscape in
this country and that other writers consider lending their voices to
the effort. Civility and empathy are qualities Im trying to channel
when I send a tweet these days. On my best days, I even manage to
pretend that the people behind those Twitter accounts are real, live
human beings.
191 Comments
Share your thoughts
W O RLD
Governor General breaks royal protocol by touching Queen Elizabeth II
French woman captured in Iraq with four children faces prosecution for collaborating with ISIL
Behind this photo, a Crown princes plot to usurp the presumptive king of Saudi Arabia
Nefarious, stupid, or he just doesn't care: Three theories about why Trump met secretly with Putin
http://nationalpost.com/g00/news/world/jonathan-kay-on-the-tyranny-of-twitter-how-mob-censure-is-changing-the-intellectual-landscape/wcm/c94cb9 11/11