You are on page 1of 14

Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1.

110-122

IMPEDIMENTS TO THE UTILIZATION OF E-LEARNING


OPPORTUNITIES IN PRIMARY SCHOOLS IN NSUKKA
EDUCATION ZONE

Ugwu, G.C. and Aleke, D.I.


Department of Educational Foundations,
University of Nigeria, Nsukka.

Abstract
The study investigated the impediments to the utilization of e-learning
opportunities in primary schools in Nsukka Local Education Authority of Enugu
State. The Study is a survey and four research questions guided the study.
Two hundred and forty (240) primary school teachers, randomly drawn using
simple random sampling technique formed the sample of the study. A 47-item
structured questionnaire titled Impediment to the Utilization of E-learning
Questionnaire (IUEQ) was used to elicit information. The study discovered
that, among others, lack of trained e-learning teachers and e-learning
infrastructures impede the utilization of e-learning in primary schools. Based
on the findings, some recommendations were made.

Introduction to describe gaps between the rich


Information communication and the poor in the effective access
technology (ICT) that has been and use of ICT (Wagner, 2002). All
developed these days is responsible these create competition in every
for globalization in which aspect of human life and the
information is shared. In the era of competition is perceived as the main
globalization, what happens in one characteristic of globalization. The
country will have impact, positive proper way to win the competition in
and/or negative on other countries. the era of globalization is by
People from different parts of the increasing the quality of the people
globe, to some degree, share with through well-programmed human
one another various information, resource development.
knowledge, science and technology. Education is believed to be
To some other degree, however this one of the important endeavours for
will create what is called Digital improving the quality of human
Divide. Digital Divide is a term used resources for it provides the
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

potential human resources with the system. Hence, its aims, among other
competitive competencies that things, is, to inculcate permanent
comprise knowledge, skills, and literacy and numeracy, and ability to
attitudes needed for winning the communicate effectively, lay a sound
competition as well as for national basic for scientific and reflective
development. thinking, develop in the child the
Nigeria, like many other ability to adapt to the childs
countries around the world, has over changing environment, give the child
the years sought to improve its opportunities for developing
education system by introducing manipulative skills that will enable
reforms and making plans based on the child function effectively in the
the education needs of the country, society within the limits of the childs
hence the development of Universal capacity and provide the child with
Basic Education (UBE). The broad basic tools for further educational
aim is to give a solid foundation for advancement. In pursuance of these
life-long learning through the goals, one of the curriculum for
inculcation of appropriate learning- primary education is Computer
to-learn, self awareness, citizenship Education. Computer Education can
and life skills (FGN2003). With this be define as the knowledge and
focus, it can be concluded that ability to use computers and related
beyond increasing access to technology efficiently, with a range
education, ensuring quality is a key of skills covering levels from
goal of basic education in Nigeria. elements any use of programming
This is in support of the Dakar and advanced problem solving. It
Framework for Action (2000) in also ensures that the people will
Education for All (EFA) that quality is know how to use and programme
at the heart of education - a computers, develop software
fundamental determinant of packages, understand the structure
enrolment, retention and and operation of computers and
achievement. their history, and to appreciate the
The primary education economic, social and psychological
segment, according to the National impact of the computer. The policy
Policy on Education (2004), is the stresses that the teaching of this
education given in institutions for subject shall be by practical,
children aged 6 to 11 plus. Since the exploratory and experimental
rest of the education system is built methods.
upon it, the primary level is the key From the foregoing, it can be
to the success or failure of the whole seen that computer education is an
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

important aspect of the Universal ways of acquiring knowledge


Basic Education (UBE) programme. through the internet or through the
This is in the spirit of making the offline CD-ROM. The online involves
countrys educational goals relevant the use of internet
to the needs of the society in explorer/Navigator. It may be in
consonance with the realities of the form of Audio, Visual, and or
environmental and the modern Audio/Visual. The applications and
world. There is an urgent need, process of e-learning include
therefore, to integrate e-learning computer-based learning, web-based
into primary education in Nigeria in learning, virtual classroom and digital
recognition of its prominent role in collaboration where content is
advancing knowledge and skills delivered via the internet,
necessary for effective functioning in intranet/extranet, audio and or video
the modern world. The need for the tapes, satellite TV and CD-ROM
changes in the learning process (Islam 1997).
paved way for e-learning use in the The importance of e-learning
teaching and learning processes to the world of teaching and learning
where students are expected to play cannot be overemphasized. As
more active roles than before (Alabi Onuigbo and Onuigbo (2006:71) Put
2004). it. the world is moving through
E-learning according to Sale the information superhighway with a
(2002), is the use of electronic network of computers that enable
technology to deliver education and one to obtain relevant information
training applications, monitor for specific purposes. With e-
learners performance and report learning, teachers and students alike
learners progress. Hedge and have access to unprecedented
Hayward (2004), defined it as an amount of quality and authentic
innovative approach for delivery information in all areas of study.
electronically mediated, well- The urge to embark on e-
designed, learner centered and learning is still a dream to some
interactive learning environments to educational institution, because their
anyone, anyplace, anytime by ICT infrastructures are very weak.
utilizing the internet and digital The rapid expansions of ICTs in
technologies in line with Nigeria offer an opportunity to
instructional design principles. It is all consider its use in the promotion of
about learning with the use of primary education. It offers students
computer. In this age, learning with considerable benefits including
the use of computer is simply online increased access to learning
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

opportunities, convenience of time, access to the technology itself by


and place, making available a greater students, the cost of a personal
variety of learning resources, computer (PC) and laptop,
improved opportunities for technophobia, internet connectivity,
individualized learning and software and license cost,
emergence of more powerful maintenance and technical support,
cognitive tools (Khan, 2006, Pierre, and electricity. Nwankpa (2004) in
1998). It is seen as a key tool in his study on impediments to the
acquiring, processing and growth of Information Communication
disseminating knowledge (Adeodoyin, Technologies in least developed
Akinnuwesi and Adeogoke 2008). It countries of which Nigeria is one
offers increasing possibilities for listed some of the impediments as ICT
codification of knowledge about education/limited human capital,
teaching activities through being (teachers) poor ICT infrastructure, weak
able to deliver learning cognitive policy/regulatory framework. Awolola
activities anywhere, and anytime and Tejumola (2008) in their study
(Larsen and Vincent Lancrin 2005). on enhancing quality teaching and
At this juncture, it can be seen that learning through the effective use of
e-learning, with ICT facilities is a very Information Technology listed two
useful tool in equipping the teachers basic barriers as teachers not being
with desirable techniques for computer literate and non-
effective teaching. They constitute availability of computers in school.
such a variety to the resources and On his part, Gyang (2008) in
styles in the handling of instruction his study on Information and
that learning actually becomes fun Communication Technology (ICT)
and the learner excited. When the Education Section Reform in Nigeria
learner is interested, he is motivated outlined the non-availability of
to learn. hardware facilities, lack of funds, lack
In spite of all these benefits of skilled staff and cultural/societal
of e-learning, a lot of factors may attitudes as impediments. While
impede its utilization at the primary agreeing with Gyang on lack of
level of education. Ajadi, Salawu and funds, Obanya, (2002) states that in
Adeoye (2008) in their study on the the United States while a personal
relevance of e-learning in the computer may cost less than a
position of distance education in month wages, an average Nigerian
Nigeria outline poor ICT worker may require more than six
infrastructure and other socio- months income to buy one. In their
economic reasons like inequality of study on blind spots in pre-primary
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

education in the South Eastern 1. What are the available e-


States, Offorma, Ibiam, Uzoeegwu learning tools in teaching
and Igbokwe (2008) noted that while and learning in primary
other instructional materials were schools?
available to some extent in the pre- 2. To what extent are e-
primary centers, ICT materials were learning tools utilized for
largely lacking. While these teaching and learning in
impediments are observed at other primary schools?
levels, one is not sure whether, such 3. To what extent are the
is obtainable in primary school and teachers prepared in the
that is what this study seeks to find use of e-learning tools?
out. 4. What are the barriers to
In spite of all the above, e-learning integration in
computer literacy is a major learning the teaching-learning
skill required in the present process?
information age because it is only a
computer literate person that can Method
adapt and make effective use of the The study employed the survey
vast electronic information available design. Four research questions were
in the world (Nwankpa, 2004). used for the study. The population
Therefore, in line with the ICT policy consists of all the primary school
in primary schools in Nigeria, there is teachers in Nsukka Local
need to start e-learning at the Government Education Authority. A
primary school level of education. sample of two hundred and forty
This is because although the respondents was used for the study
traditional methods of teaching and using the Simple random sampling
learning have been used for teaching technique by balloting was used to
and learning over years, their select the sample. The instrument
impacts on educational processes used was a 47 items structured
have not been felt like the e- questionnaire titled Impediments to
learning. the Utilization of E-learning
The thrust of this study Questionnaire (IUEQ). The
therefore is to find out the instrument was face validated by
impediments to the utilization of e- experts in Childhood Education and
learning opportunities in primary Educational Technology.
schools. For research question one,
The following research percentage was used to analyze the
questions guided the study. availability and non- availability of e-
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

learning tools. The cut off point for Strongly Disagreed weighted 4, 3, 2,
acceptance is 50%. A four-point 1 was used. The items were divided
modified Likert type scale of Great into 4 sections in line with the
Extent (GE), Moderate Extent (ME), research questions. Mean and
Little Extent (LE) Very little Extent standard deviation were used to
(VLE) weighted 4, 3, 2, 1 respectively analyze data for research questions
was used for research questions 2-4. Mean responses above 2.5 were
two(2) and three(3). And for accepted while those below 2.5 were
research question four (4), Agreed, rejected.
Strongly Agreed, Disagreed and

Result
Table I
Percentage on the availability of e-learning tools in primary schools.
S/N ITEMS AVAILABILITY % UNAVAILABILITY %
1 Storage facilities (floppy 22.7 77.3
diskettes, CD-ROM, Flash
Disc etc)
2 Digital cameras 2.4 97.6
3 Computers 36.4 63.6
4 Televisions 57.2 42.8
5 Scanners 3.6 96.4
6 Photocopies 27.3 72.7
7 Projectors 3.8 96.2
8 Power point software 3.1 96.9
9 Graphic software 3.2 96.8
10 Video cassette and tapes 60.2 39.8
11 CD writers 2.8 97.2
12 Radio 71.3 28.7
Result from Table I Shows that e-learning items number 4, 10 and 12 are the
available e-learning tools in primary schools in Nsukka Local Education
authority. The other items are not readily available
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

Table II
Mean rating on the extent of utilization of e-learning tools in primary schools.
S/N ITEMS N X SD DECISSION
13 Storage facilities (floppy diskettes, 240 1.7 1.43 Rejected
CD-ROM, Flash Disc etc)
14 Digital cameras 240 1.6 1.47 Rejected
15 Computers 240 2.1 1.35 Rejected
16 Televisions 240 2.7 1.03 Accepted
17 Scanners 240 1.9 1.39 Rejected
18 Photocopies 240 2.0 1.37 Rejected
19 Projectors 240 1.8 1.41 Rejected
20 Power point soft 240 1.8 1.41 Rejected
21 Graphic software 240 1.9 1.39 Rejected
22 Video cassette and tapes 240 2.5 1.08 Accepted
23 CD writers 240 1.6 1.47 Rejected
24 Radio 240 2.8 1.01 Accepted
Result from Table II Shows that e-learning tools are not yet readily utilized in
primary schools. Of all the items, items 16, 22 and 24 were accepted implying
that only televisions, video cassettes and radios are the facilities that are
being utilized in some primary schools to a little extent. All the other facilities
are not utilized.

Table III
Mean rating on the extent of preparedness of teachers in the use of e-
learning tools.
S/N ITEMS N X SD DECISION
25 I use e-learning tools in the 240 1.6 1.47 Rejected
classroom actively.
26 I have attended a computer 240 2.2 1.34 Rejected
literacy course.
27 I have skills in Microsoft word 240 1.8 1.41 Rejected
application.
28 I do not consider e-learning 240 2.0 1.37 Rejected
necessary for teaching and
learning.
29 I am not interested in acquiring 240 2.6 1.03 Accepted
e-learning
30 I prefer the traditional method 240 3.0 0.93 Accepted
of teaching, and learning.
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

31 E-learning is very confusing and 240 3.2 0.78 Accepted


is difficult to learn the skills.
32 I use e-learning tools only for 240 1.6 1.47 Rejected
personal purposes.
33 I feel inadequate in using e- 240 1.9 1.35 Rejected
learning.
34 I depend on other teachers to 240 2.8 0.30 Accepted
assist me with their e-learning
skills.
35 I encourage my pupils to use e- 240 2.2 1.34 Rejected
learning tools.
36 I make efforts to up grade my 240 2.2 1.33 Rejected
computer skills.

Table III Indicates that items 29, 30, mean responses below 2.5. The
31, 34 were accepted because they result indicates that the teachers
had mean responses of above 2.5 have neither been using e-learning,
while items 25, 26, 27, 28, 32, 33, 35, to teach nor have much knowledge
36 were rejected because they had of ICT usage

Table IV
Mean rating on the barriers to e-learning integration in teaching-learning
process.
S/N ITEMS N X SD DECISION
37 Lack of skilled teachers 240 3.6 0.69 Accepted
38 Lack of time on the part of the 240 1.6 1.47 Rejected
teachers to engage in training in
the use of e-learning tools.
39 Lack of instructional time to 240 2.8 0.61 Accepted
effectively use e-learning tools
within a forty-minute lesson
usually allocated for basic
schools.
40 Limited e-learning infrastructures. 240 3.6 0.69 Accepted
41 Poor internet connectivity. 240 3.2 0.78 Accepted
42 Lack of funds. 240 3.3 0.77 Accepted
43 Lack of information on existing 240 1.8 1.41 Rejected
software.
Ugwu, G.C. Review of Education Institute of Education Journal, University of Nigeria Nsukka. Vol. 23. No.1. 110-122

44 Lack of technical support 240 3.2 0.78 Accepted


45 Resistance to change 240 3.8 0.65 Accepted
46 Poor power supply 240 3.6 0.69 Accepted
47 Government inability to enforce 240 3.2 0.78 Accepted
policy implementation

Results on table IV answered resource development in terms of


questions on the barriers to e- skilled teachers to use ICT in teaching
learning integration in the teaching- and learning processes, as well as ICT
learning process. Out of the eleven infrastructure. The result is also in
(11) items, 9 were accepted because agreement with the findings of
they had mean responses above 2.5 Offorma, Eze and Egbe (2008) that
while two (2) items, items number what is lacking in schools to a large
38 and 43 were rejected because extent are ICT materials.
they had mean responses below 2.5. The results on research
question two, shows that e-learning
Discussion tools are not readily utilized in
The results of research primary schools. This is because
question one, shows that in spite of teachers are not well equipped to
the governments visions and teach using ICT. Because of the
policies for the use and integration nature of exposure of ICT, most
of e-learning in schools, ICT teachers operate even below the
infrastructures are lacking. Only emerging level. This is in agreement
television, video cassettes and radio with Adeosun and Maduekwe
are the tools available. Others are (2008), that Nigerian teachers
unavailable in primary schools used possess lower level skills in the use of
for the study. The tools have to be ICT.
on ground for any meaningful use of From research question
them to take place. This negates the three, result shows that most of the
provision in the National Policy on teachers lack the requisite skills for
Education (FRN, 2004) that using e-learning in primary school
government shall provide basic education. This is an alarming
infrastructure and training for the development since the teacher is the
realization of the ICT goal at the pivot of all educational activities in
primary school level. It supports the classroom. Without these
Oyenike (2010) that two very necessary ICT skills, he cannot
important features of integration of impact knowledge to the pupils since
e-learning are lacking-human one cannot give what one does not
Saba, T.M, Maaji, S.A. & Tsado, J. 124

have. This is in line with the views of support, and most importantly poor
Cajkler (1993) and Higham and power supply, a problem that is
Mararo (1993) that computer peculiar to Nigeria (Olakulehin,
literacy is essential for ICT use 2007). The study supports Ololube
especially in education. They also (2006) who also attributed these
note that all teachers and trainees barriers to economic disadvantages
should have opportunity to and government policies. Also, basic
experience ICT skills as a normal and infrastructure in school-buildings,
inescapable part of their training. It furniture, books, libraries,
is unfortunate that the teachers laboratories and adequate classroom
could not demonstrate evidence of are still big challenges which may
affective acquisition and use of ICT make blending education and
even at the basic skill level, hence technology especially of lower levels
they cannot fully utilize technology in a farce.
their classrooms, and the traditional
chalk and talk approach still Recommendation
dominates the school pedagogy. The following recommendations
The results on research were made which if implemented
question four shows that a chief will go a long way in integrating e-
barrier to e-learning integration in learning into the teaching learning
schools is the lack of skilled teachers. process in primary schools.
However, the teacher identified Government should provide
barriers have been supported by a training for teacher on how
number of studies, (Aduwa-Ogiegba to integrate e-learning into
and Iyamu 2005, Okafor and Edet the teaching learning process.
2008, and Salawu 2008). These Government should positively
include limited ICT infrastructures, demonstrate more serious
poor internet connectivity, attitude to the use of e-
inadequate learning resources learning in schools with the
(educational tools, course curriculum provision of facilities, but
etc) attitudes of teacher-trainees and more importantly, training of
teacher trainers which indicate a teachers.
gross lack in independent learning There is need for government
skills and reluctance to take to create an enabling
responsibility for their own learning, environment for teacher
software license and highly education programmes to
prohibitive costs associated with, strive toward producing
lack of maintenance and technical highly qualified ICT literate
125 Saba, T.M, Maaji, S.A. & Tsado, J.

teachers and teacher increasingly rely on various forms of


educators that would assist in electronic delivery and
making the integration and communication inside a market place
usage of e-learning in schools that requires education to be
a success. flexible. E-learning is now widely
For sustainable integration of used in most of the developed
e-learning in education countries to promote education and
funding and other life-long learning in effective ways. In
infrastructural issues should Nigeria, the recent developments
also be addressed by the and awareness of the Government
government. There is also the on ICT have opened an opportunity
need to develop a specific to adopt e-learning to educate most
policy for ICT in education- a of its uneducated or less, educated
national policy for ICT in people. Considering the recent
education will help to locate expansion of ICTs in the country,
Nigeria in the emerging Government should introduce e-
global knowledge based learning in primary schools so as to
economy, coupled with prepare children to fit into the global
strategic investment in village confidently.
education to enable greater
productivity in the workforce References
and thus increased national Adedoyin, A., Akinuwesi B. &
competitiveness. Adegoke, M. (2008). A
In harmonizing the efforts in Framework of Information and
the education sector with the Communication Technology (ICT)
national effort, the Ministry Policy for education in Nigeria. In
of Education should have a J.B. Babalola, L. Popoola, A.
standard policy for Onuka, A. Oni, W. Olatokun, & R.
stakeholders to have inputs Agbonlahor (Eds.), Revitalization
to the process of defining a of African Higher Education (pp.
common vision for the 305-317). Ibadan; Herpnet.
systematic integration of e-
learning in the education Adeosun, A.O and Maduekwe A.N.
system. (2008). Academic motivation
and e-learning in teacher
Conclusion education: an ESL contextual
The survival of the educational analysis. Proceedings of the 10th
system in the 21st century will Annual Conference on WWW
Saba, T.M, Maaji, S.A. & Tsado, J. 126

Applications, Cape Town, South Cajkler, W. (1993). The official


Africa. Retrieved on March 10th perspective- modern languages
2011 from and IT in the 1990s. In J. Higham
http://active.cput.ac.za/ZAW3/ & E. Macaro (Eds). Information
Public/index.asp?pageid = 638 Technology and initial teacher
education: the modern language
Aduwa-Ogiegbam, S.E. and Iyamu, perspective. (pp.5-35). York:
E.O.S.(2005). Using Information University of York.
and Communication Technology
in Secondary Schools in Nigeria: Federal Republic of Nigeria (2004)
problems and prospects. National Policy on Education (4 th
Educational Technology and ed). Lagos- NERDC.
Society 8(1), 104-112.
Federal Government of Nigeria
Ajadi, T.O., Salawu, I.O. & Adeoye, F. (2003): Universal Basic Education
(2008). E-learning and Distance Act. Lagos: NERDC.
Education in Nigeria. The Turkish
Online Journal of Educational Gyang, C.J. (2008). Information and
Technology- TOJET. Retrieved on Communication Technology (ICT)
March 10th , 2011 from Education Sector Reform in
http://www.tojet.net/articles/74 Nigeria, in Nigerian Journal of
7.pdf. Sociology of Education (NJSE)
16/11(3).
Alabi, A. (2004). Evolving Role of ICT
in Teaching, Research and Hedge, N. and Hayward, L. (2004)
Publishing. Nigerian Tribune, Redefining Roles. University e-
friday, 30 April, 30-31. learning contributing to life-long
learning in a networked world. E-
Awolola, S.A. & Tejumola, F.O. learning 1:128-145.
(2008). Enhacing Quality http://www.nationmaster.
Teaching and Learning through com/country/ni/internet.
the effective use of Information
Technology (IT). A Paper Islam, M.T. (1997). Educational
st
presented at the 21 Annual Technology for 21 st century.
Conference of Curriculum Observer magazine, Dhaka, May
Organization of Nigeria (CON) 9, 1997, pp. 3-4.
held at NERDC, sheda, Abuja.
127 Saba, T.M, Maaji, S.A. & Tsado, J.

Khan, A. (1996). Utilization of Centers. A paper presented at


communication technologies for the 13th Biennial Conference of
distance education, in K, Murali World Council for Curriculum and
Manohar (ed) distance education Instruction (WCCI)Held at
theory and practice. Media and Antalya, Turkey.
communication technology,
Hyderabad. Open learning Offorma. G.C, Eze K. O. & Egbe, C.I.
society. Prof. G. Ram Reddy (2008). Extent of implementation
memorial endowment of computer education in
committee, and India distance primary schools within south-
education association. east geopolitical zone. A paper
presented at the 21st Annual
Larsen, K. and Vincent-Lancrin, S. conference of the curriculum
(2005). The impact of ICT On organisation of Nigeria (CON).
tertiary education; advances and Held at Nigerian Educational
promises, presented at Research and Development
OECD/NSF/U. Michigan Council, Sheda, Abuja.
Conference Retrieved April 18th
2011 from http://www. Onuigbo, S.M. & Onuigbo, L.N.
advancingknowledge.com/drafts (2006). Teaching students with
/Larsen. Speech and language disorder:
The computer assisted strategy.
Nwankpa, N.N.. (2004). Impediments International Journal of Arts and
to the growth of Information Technology Education. 5(1), 61-
Communication Technologies in 81.
Least Developed Countries. LDCS.
An unpublished Ph.D Thesis in Oyenike, A. (2010). Quality basic
the Department of Mass Education Development in
Communication University of Nigeria: Imperative for use of ICT.
Nigeria, Nsukka. CICE Hiroshima University,
Journal of International
Obanya, P. (2002). Revitalizing Cooperation in Education, Vol.
Education in Africa string - 13(2), pp. 193-211.
Horden publisher (Nigeria).
Wagner, D.A. (2002). ICT and the
Offorma, G.C., Ibiam, J.U, Uzoegwu, Poor: problems and possibilities.
P.N. & Igbokwe, U. (2008). Blind Imfundo/ DFID Workshop.
Spots in Pre-primary Education London.
128

You might also like