You are on page 1of 16
rage 1 of 26) ‘D 2 geht ae BRIANE WATKINS: CIATES unty of Les s : ee epee | § 3 Suserer ar 90°49 eee | § SAN DIEGO, CALIFO! sn Gorn if Taemiowasie | AFRO fon 2 5 FACSIMILE: 619255 5369 & EmalLovatinsgbiamatersiewcon — AG] D5 elo 7 ° ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS, Comptasue a 7 2 8 STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 2 2 LOS ANGELES SUPERIOR COURT a 10 BC67 304 0 3 cre f t fee at tp|| | ESTATEOF CARMEL Muscrove; CASE NO}; __ = g year sree 1. WRONGFUL DEATH 3 gs 8 ow | 3 44 PLAINTIFFS, ~<| 3 Rey) E 15 5 MARTIN HERROLD; & 16)| | JOEL SILVER; 17|| | SILVER PICTURES; SILVER-KATZ HOLDINGS; 18}| | and Does 1-10, a DEFENDANTS. 20 a 22 2B Ee 4 § z 8 5 S 233 : agagffe jeeeees “* fe |g i Bl age ls & S@ 13 228 8 g co es & teng 3 = MOSGROVEY. SILVER cal ober a2 e ; covtantronwaoweruLpzert racer SEBB 8 Doct 2 Faged 4 ~ Boo 3D = 1707151908 - Doe typo = Ona rage 2 of 16) -ARTIES 1, Plaintiff Estate of Carmel Musgrove is the successor-in-interest to the interests of Carmel Musgrove individually, who died on August 19, 2015. She was a resident of Los Angeles County. 2% The Estate of Carmel Musgrove is represented by her successor-in-interest, Ronald Musgrove, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure, section 377.30, et seq. 3. The Estate of Carmel Musgrove is also represented by her successor-in- interest, Ann Musgrove, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure, section 377.30, et 8eq. 10 4, Ronald Musgrove is also a Plaintiff, bringing a claim for the loss, affection eceraweaene 11| | and other adverse consequences of Carmel’s death as to him. He resides in San Diego 12| | County. B 5. Ann Musgrove is also a Plaintiff, bringing a claim for the loss, affection and 14}] other adverse consequences of Carmel’s death as to her. She resides in San Diego County. 15 6. Defendant Martin Herold is an individual believed to reside in Los Angeles 16] | County, and is a resident thereof. 7 7. Defendant Joel Silver is an individual believed to be residing in Los Angeles 18] | County and is a resident of California. 19 8. Defendants Silver Pictures is an entity of unknown corporate form and is 20 | | believed to have its principal office and place of business located at 2434 Main St, Santa 21| | Monica, CA 90405. 9. Defendant Silver-Katz, Holdings is a Delaware Corporation formed on May 23 | |27, 2015 and is believed to have its principal office and place of business located at 2434 24| | Main St, Santa Monica, CA 90405. 5 10, Although Carmel’s death occurred in Bora Bora, given the overall resident \WATRINS LAW OFFICES 26 | | locations of the parties, an appropriate, reasonable and fair forum for this dispute is a <@1| | California state court, in particular, Los Angeles Superior Court. 8 = x COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH -PAGE2 ‘Dock 2 Pago 2 - Boa HD = 4707151008 ~ boo Type = OTR ago 3 of 26) 11. Unless otherwise specified by name, Joel Silver, Silver Pictures and Silver- Katz Holdings will be collectively referred to as the “Silver Defendants.” 12, The true names and capacities, whether individual, corporate, associate or otherwise, of defendants named as Does 1 through 10, inclusive, are unknown to plaintiff who therefore sues such defendants by fictitious names. Plaintiff will seek leave of this Court to ‘amend this Complaint with the true names and capacities ofthe Doe defendants when the true names and capacities become known to plaintiff. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and thereon allege, that each of the ficttiously-named defendants is responsible in some manner for wewrsHerune the claims, obligations, and damages sued upon herein, 10 ‘ATEMENT OF FACTS M1 13, On July 25, 2015, Defendant Silver Pictures charted a gulfstream private jet to 12| | fly his family and personal guests to Bora Bora, for $82,698.00 if paid by credit card in 13] | August, 2015. 14. On August 3, 2015, Martin Herold arrived in Bora Bora. ‘WATKINS LAW OFFICES 15 15. Herold is an employee of one of the Silver Defendants and works as the Silver 16| | family's personal chef. 7 16. According to Herold, he hed become close to Carmel in his four years of i 18} | working together with Carmel: close in his working énvironment, close as a friend, sometimes 19} | sexual relationship, and close as a drinking and party buddy. 20 1 ‘Carmel Musgrove was a 28-year-old woman, employed as a personal assistant 21| | and sometimes associate movie producer by one or more of the Silver Defendants, 22 18. ‘Her duties included handling the daily affairs and activities of Mr. Silver. 23 19. ‘On August 4, 2015, Carmel arrived in Bora Bora on work assignment and 24} | spent the following weeks attending working events and work functions. rt} 20. She, Herold, the Silver-related guests, along with a larger entourage of movie 26 | | stars and their family members, stayed at the Four Seasons Hotel by occupying over 40 2 bungalows as part of Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux’s honeymoon celebration. 8 = MUSGROVE v. SILVER, ef al 5 ‘COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH —PAGE i ‘Dood 4 Raged 3 ~ Deo ED = 1707151808 - Doo ype = OTIER erage 4 of 16) 21. Sometime between August 4, 2015 and her deat’a on August 19, 2015, Defendant Herold provided Carmel (and possibly others) with cocaine. 22. On August 6, 2015, Joe! Silver and his family entourage consisting of 12 persons arrived in Bora Bora. : 23. They were there for vacation purposes, as was their custom, however for the staff, including Carmel and Mr. Herold, it was an occupational duty ina different location. 24. On August 6, 2015, one of the Silver Defendants provided alcohol to Carmel by virtue of her purchase of it on her room tab, including 4 bottles of Chateau Laroque wine, Johnny Walker Black scotch and Jack Daniels whiskey. 10 25. On August 9, 2015, Carmel attended dinner with the Silver family. ut 26. On August 15, 2015, Carmel sent an email to what is believed the 12] | representative of her landlord expressing surprise that her rent check had not been received 13] | and committing to send a replacement check on August 17, 2015. 27. On August 18, 2015, Carmel participated in a fishing trip in conjunction with 15] | her duties as Silver's personal assistant, where she was furnished alcohol during the 16] | excursion, The trip lasted from approximately 9 am to 2 pm. eceyraunrene [WATIINS LAW OFFICES W 28. Carmel was seen by the participants on the trip, which included Joel Silver. 8 29. Around 2 pm, she was observed by Morosowski Igor, the Four Season’s hotel 19] | director. 20 30. Upon returning from the fishing trip, Carmel ate lunch with the Silver family, 21 | until about-4 pm, and on information and belied, the Silver Defendants furnished Carmel with 22| | additional alcohol. 2B 31. At around 8 pm, Carmel had dinner with the Silver family, and on information 24| | and belief, the Silver Defendants furnished Carmel with additional alcohol. 25 32, Carmel was planning to watch a movie with Silver’s children after dinner, but excused herself from the obligation by reporting that she felt physically uncomfortable and ‘was returning to her bungalow, possibly because of cramps from her menstrual cycle. MUSGROVE v. SILVER, eral, ‘COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH PAGE 4 ZTQZ/Q TRAN : ‘och 3 Pages @ ~ bos XD = 1707351806 ~ Doo Type = om Gage 3 of 16) 1 33. At approximately 9:15 pm, Martin Herold completed his duties for the Silver 2| | Defendants and returned to his bungalow. 3 34. At approximately 9:25 pm, Herold sent Carmel and email informing her that 4| | he was “drinking by myself” and thus implicitly inviting her to come over.” 5 35. Between 9:30 pm and 10:00 pm, Carmel and Herold exchanged messages of a 6 | | flirtatious nature discussing why they had not firmed up plans with each other during the 7) | evening. 8 36. At approximately 10:00 pm, they initially said good night to each other, but at 9| | 10:01 pm, Herold told Carmel that he didn’t want to go to bed. 10 37. At approximately 10:15 pm, Carmel asked Herold if he was still awake, he 11 | confirmed that he was, and she came over. , 2 38. At approximately 10:20 pm, Carmel visited Defendant Herold in his bungalow 2 13]| and forthe next hour or so, he fumished Carmel with additional alcohol, marijuana and 3 141) cocaine. 4 1s 39. Herold also ingested alcohol, marijuane and cocaine during this visit. 5 16 40. Carmel took a shower while at Herold’s bungalow, reflecting their familiarity 17] | and physical comfort with each other. 18 41. On 10:21 pm, Joel Silver's wife, Karyn, sent Carmel a message stating 19] | “howling wind.” 20 42. It appears that Carmel and Mr. Herold were in a sexual relationship but did 21 | | not have sexual intercourse on that particular evening, although they flirted and had physical contact, 43. Herold acknowledged that he purchased about a gram’s worth of cocaine while in Bora Bora (50 euros worth). 44, On information and belief, he bought more than a single gram if he was PBR providing some for Carmel to have in her bungalow as well as stare it with her when she came to visit him at his. sees RR "MUSGROVE v, SILVER, ea i COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH~ PAGE 5 | Lets Dock 1 Pages & - Boe HD = 7075108 - Goo Type = om (rage 6 of 16) 1 45. Atl. records of the hotel. 1 pm, Carmel retumed to her bungalow as reflected by the key swipe 46. At 12:00 am, the beginning of August 19, 2015, Carmel sent an email to Mr. ‘Herold stating “Xxx,” which could mean in more common parlance “xoxo” as a sort of parting romantic goodbye or it could have been‘an invitation for him to come over to her bungalow for a late night tryst. 47. Around 'the same time, Carmel contacted the hotel front desk and asked someone to bring her matches. caw aneen 48. Within a half hour, hotel representative delivered the matches and reported 10] | that she opened the door with her body behind it, just exposing her head and hand in order to 11] | receive the matches. 12 49. Carmel’s decision to hide behind the door suggests she was not fully clothed E 13] orshat she otherwise did not want staff to have a window tothe activity in her bungalow. 5 4 50. Either way, the delivery of the matches was the last time anyone reported i 15] | seeing Carmel alive, 6 51. At7:04 am, an email message was sent from Carmel’s phone, establishing that 17 | | she was stil alive as of that time assuming she was the one that sent it. 18 52. Onher front door, a do not disturb sign was later noticed. 9 53, Inher room, later inventoried by police, two wine glasses were found on the 20 | bungalow’s bar area. a 54, Inher room, later inventoried by police, a cannabis joint, paraphernalia for 22 | marijuana use and cocaine residue use were found. 3 55. Inher room, later inventoried by police, items reflecting management of her 24 | | menstrual eycle were found. 25 36. Inher room, later inventoried by police, a wet bathing suit was found on the 26] | floor. If that was utilized to take a “midnight swim” after the matches were delivered, then it 21 ||is not clear why she would have taken a second swim, naked, sometime after 7 am in the 48) | moming. > = MUSGROVEv. SILVER, a/al oy COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH -PAGE 6 ‘Dood 1 Fagen € ~ Doo TD = L7G7ASIEG0 ~ boo Fype = OTHER (rage 7 of 26) 57. There were no signs of forced entry into Carmel’s bungalow. 58. Inher room, later inventoried by police, the bed was made, This is odd. If she never slept init, then she was up all night with no indication or trail of any activity from 12:30 am, when she was last seen, through 7:04 am when she sent her last email communication, to some decision thereafter to venture outside in the early morning hours of August 19, 2015 into the lagoon where she presumptively drowned. 59, If she did sleep in it, then she woke up at 7:04 am to send an email and made her bed sometime thereafter, despite the fact that the remainder of the room was relatively disheveled. After making her bed, of all things, she then oddly went for an early morning. 10| | swim where she presumptively drowned. weeraurene 11 60. If her “Xxx” communication to Martin Herold was not the equivalent of a 12| | parting “xoxo” but an invitation for him to come over for sexual purposes, and her hiding 13 | | behind the door when staff brought her the matches at 12:30 am was to conceal Mr. Herold’s presence in her bungalow, then someone made the bed after probable sexual relations as 2 15 | | way of concealing the event; if so, Mr. Herold was far more involved in Carmel’s death than 16} | he disclosed to police when he reported his last observation of her to be around 11 pm the 17| | night before. 18 61. The next moming no one reported seeing Carmel, and more importantly, no WATKINS LAW OFFICES z 19| | one saw her take a swim after 7 am in the moming, when although the activity might have 20 | | been slow given the vacation atmosphere, it was not so early thet it should not have been 21 || noticed by atleast one person occupying the adjacent bungalows. 2 62, According to Michael Baden’s estimate of the time of her death based on 23| | subtracting his estimate of 12 hours in the water based on the bedy’s presentation from the 24 | | time she was found on August 20, 2015 at approximately 1 am, her time of death per his estimate was approximately 1 pm on August 19, 2015. 63. Yetno one saw Carmel at any time after 12:30 am on August 19, 2015, although according to Dr. Baden’s opinion, she was alive until approximately 1 pm on that same afternoon. MUSGROVE v. SILVER, efai COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH— PAGE 7 Taz72TRAN RR 1 Doct 4 Page? 7 ~ Boo XD = 2707363808 - Doo type = Omm (age a of 30) 1 64, On August 19, 2015, as the day wore on, and Cermel’s non-appearance 2] | increasingly observed, Silver and other coworkers began searching for Carmel. 3 65. Around 6:03 pm, Herold sent Carmel an email message asking her if she 4|| needed anything. 5 66. At or around 6:30 pm on August 19, 2015, Joel Silver knocked on her 6 || bungalow door and involved members of the hotel to enter the tnit and check on her welfare. 7|| There was no one inside. Mr. Silver later reported that the bay window wes wide open. 8 67. Hotel personnel began to search the facility. 9 68. Her body was found at 1 am the following morning, August 20, 2015, floating 10] | nude on one of the banks in a nearby lagoon, 400-500 yards from her bungalow. 1 69. Officials formally declared her death to be 1 am on August 20, 2015 because 12} | that is when her body was found; however, she clearly died sometime earlier than the time 13] | that she washed up on shore 400-500 yards from her bungalow and was later found, 70. An autopsy report was prepared by French officials including toxicology tests 15] | reporting positive results for alcohol, marijuana and cocaine. 16 71. Dr, Michael Baden was present for the autopsy. He estimated that the 17] | decedent was in the water approximately 12 hours. However, itis difficult to reconcile a 1 \WATIINS LAW OFFICES z 18| | pm time of death (on August 19, 2015) with a complete lack of witnesses to any activity on 19| | her part from 12:01 am onward that moming. Ey 72. A San Diego County autopsy report was later performed and they declared the 21] | time of death at 2.am, not 1 am, on August 20, 2015, again reflecting an assignment of the 22| | time of death as when her body was found rather than cateulating when she actually died, B 73. Iman interview later given to French police, Mr, Silver informed that he knew 24] | Carmel and Mr. Herold sometimes drank together but as regards to drug use, “Tnever saw 25| | anything.” In other words, one inference from Mr. Silver’s phraseology is that he knew 26 | Carmel and Herold did drugs together, but he did not personally witness these events. 74, Ata different point in the interview, Silver denied any knowledge of Carmel’s use of marijuana or cocaine. MUSGROVE v. SILVER, etal COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH PAGES ‘Doct 4 Pageb 8 - Doo aD = 470752808 - Doo Type = OMI (rage 9 of 16) 75. When the body was found, it did not have any signs of trauma on it indicating violent death, 76. According to Mr. Silver's statement to French police, he informed the ‘Musgrove family of Carmel’s death at 5:30 am on August 20, 2015 indicating to Ann ‘Musgrove that she accidentally drowned, 77, According to Ann Musgrove, Silver told her that he had seen Carmel jump into the ocean by herself around midnight the night before (the border of August 18 and August 19, 2015), however Mr. Silver told police thatthe last time he saw Carmel was at inner on August 18, 2015, which had concluded around 8 pm. 10 78. On August 21, 2015, police became concerned because Martin Herold left 11] | Bora Bora by paying cash for a flight out. Although he had given police a statement on cersawroene 12| | August 20, 2015, his prompt departure created some amount of suspicion, a i 13 79. On August 21, 2015 at approximately 1:52 pm, a day after she was found 3 14{| deceased, Carmel’s Instagram account password was changed by an unknown actor, bos 80. No activity was detected with Carmel’s key card from August 18, 2015 at s 16} | 11:11 pm through 7:11 pm on August 19, 2015, thus continuing the uncertainty of her 17] | movements and activities from 12:30 am to the time she died. 18 81. According to a perusal of her cellular phone, Carmel received a number of | 19] | emails on August 19, 2015 without responding. ; 20 82. According to the French investigation, Carmel drowned as a product of five 21 | | factors: s (@) overconsumption of alcohol; f (b) consumption of cocaine; : B (©) fatigue caused by overwork; | (d) heat stroke after the fishing trip on August 18, 2015; (e) a midnight swim during unfavorable weather conditions. i 25 83. Four of these reasons (a-d) are traceable to conduct involving Defendants. : ‘MUSGROVE v. SILVER, eral. COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH~PAGE 9 Dock 1 Faged 9 ~ Hoa ab = 1707151808 ~ bo typo = ommn (age 10 ot 36) [WATKINS LAW OFFICES 2s RRR veervausaen 21nz/g L CAUSE OF ACTION FOR WRONGFUL DEATH 84, Plaintiffs incorporate the allegations of paragraphs 1-83. 85, Defendant Herold committed a wrongful act by furnishing Carmel with cocaine, which contributed to her death. 86. The Silver Defendants, themselves or through their agents, committed wrongful acts by fumishing Carmel with excessive amounts of alcohol, furnishing her with cocaine, creating excessive fatigue by requiring her performance of work functions during the Silver's family vacation in Bora Bora from August 4, 2015 to August 18, 2015, which included her suffering a heat stroke as a result of a work function on August 18, 2015 during a fishing trip. 87. These acts caused, or contributed to the cause, of Carmel’s death. 88, Plaintiff Estate of Carmel Musgrove was damaged by virtue of the loss of ‘earnings during her lifetime and the loss of the remainder of her life itself 89, Plaintiff Ann Musgrove suffered damages by the loss of her daughter and its many and varied logistic, economié, personal and emotional consequences for Ann's life. 90, Plaintiff Ron Musgrove suffered damages by the loss of her daughter and its ‘many and varied logistic, economic, personal and emotional consequences for Ron's life. Wherefore, Plaintiffs seek the following relief: @ —_ past and future compensatory damages according to proof; i) interest according to proof; Gi) attomey’s fees and costs as allowable by law; Gv) such other relief as the Court deems just and proper. Date: August 18, 2017 BRIAN E. WATKINS & ASSOCIATES ei eeete Brian E. Watkins, Esq, Attomey for Plaintifis ~~~" MUSGROVE v. SILVER, af al ‘COMPLAINT FOR WRONGFUL DEATH PAGE 10 Dock 1 Paget 10 - Doo 1D = 17071536 ~ pee type = OER Wage 12 of 16) e “ euas IL = a ER Sebsmesesg Fi Se tneianos 619 235 5930 619 255 5369 sate tena ‘aan a naa _mtomsronemar Estate of Carmel Musgrove, ea ny of os Angates [SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, CouNTYOF Los Angeles ‘swecroomess: 111 North Hil Street AUG 18 2017 errasoar cove: Los Angeles, CA 90012 Bx eure Centrale Gora —— Paty cree Musgrove v. Silver, et al. CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Gompiex Case Designation. biesaer=se2 Clues — | Cy couner Cloner | —BC673010 | demanded is Filed with first appearance by defendant | ™°* ecru 25000) S25awarewn| ""(Cartuesctooat mesa | cere Tem 4 Bly ba Saad (ne ava CHT Thee oe bx bla reat pea bos cesaioes tis css autoe Prerenty Gomae ha itgaton ine FT vroceteauachoranyion (ak hecho noes se tient RlearOctetre 2) =] mana mater CimerevpoMD PerentivuyProneny — ] Orerconsesy 1 commen ae ancawrongt Set Tor tercmescomaec) —— ] vaeion ey Teoma 1 crerenvexsn cute pte 2) Pretty) Iatpeney Encomerttetot esa main Fy ern anamene iqumescowage canst tune | OI cas eons Ssoeteemety Ssenspemecapeetay tn Nom PuPDA (Other Tort, rent even (3) test) < Busasionenir tests pace or) C) Ofer 26) Eeceman ot udgmant i Gannees Ute CO ence then z Fy stat FEy"Cmneros fee aacenae & fae 1 reweenrcy Ci ncoan TS] heres cpery Downes TH cece trate bor 2) {} Protessionat nogigence (25) _pudlelal Review: Miscellaneous Civil Petition Cher onPIPDRD ot 39 set) TT prmetipeascapete goomnca 2 Empoynen Fel: atten a1) ty 7 Fy Trotemnaton 5) i Witerent omer et rrtade [ chereneymen 9 [1 onertaserede am 2 Thiscase L_Tis [Tis not complex undor nile 2400 of re Calforia Rules of Cour ifthe case & complex, mark tho factors requing exceptional judeal management 2.) Large number of separately represented parties d. [—] Large number of wineseos Extensive motion practice raising dificult er novel, [_] Coordination with related actions pending in ene or more courts: ‘issues that willbe time cansuming to resolve in other counts ststes or counbies, orn a federal court ¢. [) Substantial amount of documentary evidence +. 2) suectanta postudgment judicial supervision ‘3. Remedies sought (check ail hat apply): a.Z1] monetary ».[—] nonmonetary, declaratory or injunctive relief & [—]punitive 4. Number of causes of acon (speci 1 8. Thiscase Cis [2 Visnot actass actionsuit, 6. tore are any known related cases, fle and serve a noice of related case (You may use frm C¥-O76) Date: August 18, 2017 a Brian E, Watkins, Esq. >» a= A Ta SETS TET OA AREY NOTICE «+ Plainsif must fie this cover sheet wit te frst pape fled in he action or proceeding (except small claims cases or cases fled Lurder the Probate Cade, Family Code, or Welfare and Insttudons Code). (Cal. Rules of Court, rue 3.220.) Faure to fle may resut ‘sanctions, He this Coversheet in action to any cover sheet required by local cour rl. ‘flhthis case is complex uncer re 3.400 et sea. of fhe Calforia Rules of Cour, you must serve a copy ofthis caver sheet on all ‘cother pares tothe action or procasdlng. ‘Unless tis ea calectons cate under rule 3.740 ora complex case, this cover sheet wil be Usod for statistical purposes ony, CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Sey ea a (age 12 of 16) : 010 INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO COMPLETE THE COVER SHEET fe ‘To Plsinttts and Others Filing First Papers, Ifyou are fing a fst paper (or example, a compain) ina cv! case, you must complete and fe, along with your fst paper tie Chl Casa Cover Sheet cortanad on page 1; Ts nfomaton wil be used & come Stasis about ta pes and ruber of eases fed. You must complete tome 9 vaugh& onthe sheet. Init 1, you must check ane box or the case foo tat bet descibes the casa. ith cases baba geneal and a more speciype of ese lated fern shock he more spect one, I the case hes mule causes of actan, check the box tal best ndeates ths par ease of aton ‘To assist youn completing iho shee. examples ofthe cases tat belong under each case ype In em 1 ar provided below. A cover test must be fled ariy with yur fal paper. Far fo fa cover snsat wth to st popr fed n'a Cal ane may abject «pany {is counselor both to sanclone under rules 2.30 and 9.220 ofthe Calfomia Rules of Cour To Pares In Rule 2.740 Collections Casas. A “colectons case" under ro 3.749 is defined ss an acton fo ecovery of money ied na sum sated to bo carta tats ole thon #26000, exe of teeat end alloy’ feos. ang hom a tonsacion whith propary, services, or mancy was acauved on ere A calectons cose doesnot Incude an acon Seeking we falewan (ft | damages, 2) puniive damages, (2) eoavery of real propery, (8) recovery of personal propery. or (8) @ pehudgmant wt of 1 attachment” The leticaonof@ case asa le 3740 coectens ane on ts fom means bet il be exert fon te gerral {imeorsanicarequrements and caso menagement rls, uross a deferdent Res a response pleating. Alo 9740 clacton, ‘ase ibe subject he requrement for service and cbarng ajodgmentin ue 3.740. To Parties In Complex Cases, In complex cases ony, paras must algo Use the Ciel Case Cover Sheet to designate whoter the cave i comalex. Ia pani believes te case is complex unde ula 3.400 ote Calfonia Rules ef Gout, tis mt be lndated by Cergletng the anprorao boxes in tems {and 21a lanl esinates a cave as complox the cover sheet must be sered wih Be Cerrplanton al pares tothe actor. A dolendant may le and sere no ler than te tine of fe st appearance a bind’ In he | Bll destin, 2 couner-destnatin hale cases rel care, oy, he plant has mace ne dostnaton a doegnaton at the cass cemriex CASE TYPES AND EXAMPLES ‘ato To : cont a Peat amps cu xanton i ‘io (@2-Peronl iu Propeny hot Cantata fuer o'Sola Ree actos ‘Oarapefongtl Dean ‘nach atteran ace ‘nabs elie) unncostecatacaa “Snap wt etaier Corccton Seto i i ‘rare et Gham uegatese fot 0 | contacthy Soccer Secs tigen i ar pa fot erresowre) Extenmeneb cet ny i nega aca imursnss overage Cae, | Wang (arising from provisionally complex ! corer Seth ot costacrtsranty Sceigotteoaron Os { CollecSons (e.9., money owed, open Enforcement of Judgment ! %3 Troyer ferent 2 : niet datpren Oot ea confers fagent on- mex eos cae Si oso ‘erate gency hart ye Peloton of oy ot cians & Surgeons vt lab tet rca ea coe Sone nas ‘Malpractice Other Contract Dispute ‘Othe Enforcement of Judgement ‘Othe: PUPDAWD (23) Reel Property Civil Complaint Press Ushi oa, sp ning Dome " | seta ge soln aes i ete teeta (ogy ene varia ‘a al repay (eg at We) me tment ncn | Sint ot Porerdon si Sel Prope Peclarlny Reet ony 1 clonal Gates MengieePocceroe rae i seal ieleae ce acta en abcess et Ret rey rt eninent 7 ‘ober PueOIMD chin nator ‘Omar Commercial Compa on#upoMD (ote) Tor ieeccesae) onete(enieate usnes Tenurar Bess Unie Baten wc Conga Fracion Soumeca cates Cn Peden con ge. center, foneertal se ee, te esc Sa fcr nota et occ essen Suse sr, Poon cto ead, ed stp Connors ecartey aan 03) uaa er BaF Fea 80) Set Fora (=) eg iezecunt Prepeny 19 Pelion en ann (1) wees Boer gsc an ‘et enc), a tocar i ae antars away Be Peles apace Witter nie Sat Seaeracneascites "Ccneteas ah ‘case taner Paige net Conte ier Nea PONS Ton) vic Shanes Cou Case ‘ae : Ender aun on Reve Cer it Petn sin rast ow ‘Gin emgoymera (2) Ome ew can Ser rer : : Nolet ppes-ianr 7 consti oral ae : Bape aT CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ‘Dect 1 Pages 22 ~ pec 10 = 1707151808 ~ boo Type = OTHER : i | age 13 of 16) s FERTITE ccrove v. Siver came BCCT SULT ct CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ADDENDUM AND ‘STATEMENT OF LOCATION (CERTIFICATE OF GROUNDS FOR ASSIGNMENT TO COURTHOUSE LOCATION) ‘This form is required pursuantto Local Rule 2.3 in all now civil case filings inthe Los Angeles Superior Court, Step 1: After completing the Civil Case Cover Sheet (Judicial Council form CM-010), find the exact case type in Step Column A that corresponds to the case type indicated in the Civil ase Cover Sheet. In Column 8, check the box forthe type of action that best describes the nature of the case. ‘Step 3: In Colum; circle the number which explains the reason forthe cour fling location you have chosen. Applicable Reasons for Choosing Court Filing Location (Column C) 4.Cias econs must be fed in he Staney Mosk Courthouse, Cena ise, 7, Location where petoner eis. 2 Permissve ing canal kc. Location wteren ceentanespondenttunetion why, 3. Locaten where cause of ation arse, 8 Locaon where one or mare ofthe panies resid, 4. wansmery personaly ing n Noth Dit, 4. Locaton where perfomance requted or éetendotresees, 6 Location of property er permanently garaged venice 10. Locaon of Labor Commsloner Oe, ‘Mandatory ng cation Hub Cses— aul deter tinted = ror-coteeton nied eallecton, or perona ny) zy B T (Cl Cate Cove Sheet typo Acton : Calegary No. (checeony on ‘ ‘to (22) A100 Mater Vehicle Personal inry/Propety DamaneNrengh Death 8 23 | veresnauonc) [0 A710 Peon hyPeptyDanepsterts est akoand ona ee | 1 AGC Asbestos Proper Damage 4a = aes A721 Asbestos - Personal Injay/Wrongful Death wt CF eee cee gs 1 ATE Hodes! brace. Pyscas & Sugeans want EB | MMOD Luo onerrctesenlnetn car Maratea nant é ie SE repay a =F TiuyPropery | OL AT290 Ierona Body unPrpery DamagerNvonah Death 69. oe 28 atte wrooete ‘essaullverdalsm, ele) 4, Dane) {A727 Inara tcen of nao tess e 1. 720 One Perna yPropetyDamogetrengltesth URGiv 105 Rev 276) CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ADDENDUM ‘Local Rule 2.3 ASE Approved 09-04 AND STATEMENT OF LOCATION Page 1 of 4 ‘book i Faget 43 - Doo 1 = 3707151008 - oo Type = On rage 14 of 36) PSTTTTE susgrove v. Silver |eeeee A [ . B Cepia Chit Case Cove eet Typeet cton Reasons Se2 Stop Galery. (Cheek anyone) ‘above “| GushessTotan [0 A6Qe® One Conmeresteuiess Tort pt Heureachof cata 1.23 f 5 ‘ies 05) [ABODE Cu igaRDEcmaton 12.3) € i e: Detmneency | AB0:0 Detamatn endeman 123 i 5 1 i Fraud (16) (1 A6013 Frau (no contact) 42.9 i 2 8 (© AGor7 Lege Natracice 4.28 BB | rrotessiontnesigence Bp [tr ee eee ret = é ther 25) 1. AG02s OtherNon PerscnaliiyPropry Damage lat 123 | WenataTeminaion 98) [2 AB097 Worst Temiaton 123 & 8 1D Aotes Otter Employment Compl Case 123 3 opment EB | OM ERPMENOD La 509 Later comminsiner Apes ‘0 1 A804 Genet Reswe Cored Gautotlanaherarmerets Tag ‘ain s Seamer mare | eacs Content Seach Sete Pure rotasnenienn [8 (rotinurncs) ——/ ry AGoY8 Nepigent Breach of Conractvaranly (ro av) 128 1 Aet2e Other Gresch of Conracvarany (ot aut or eaigence) fae coteaemon [0 M002 Cotetons cre sete ante 5.6.11 0 Aeot2 Ober Pronissoy NeteCetectns Case an 6 1 Abtos Gotectns Case Purchased Deb (Charged ONCensumer Debt | 5.6.11 Purchased on orate Januar 12013) Inswance Coverage (1) [1 AGOIS insurance Coverage (not cmpiex) 1.2.5.8 1 AG609 Contractual Freud 4.2.3.5 her Contact (g7) ASO Terlaus nteterence 1.2.38 148027 Cer Contac Deptt reachirsuranceotnetgence) 123,88 Empey Donamiva®® Yel A7g00 ErinentOomahiCondemmalon — Nunberofpacds___—«|.2.6 F [ womttevcten cay | aera wnght tact cne ae é 5 1 AGOY8 HoganeForecosure 26 3 | onwrainerayen [5 sam ontrie ae e080 Ofer Real Prope (at eminent domain, anlordtenanerecesure) | 2.6 ¢ [ieeitoaaner Somme cay owt Diner Conners a ug ornate aa y z . 3 | UntawlOetanerResidentat | asa20 Unlantl DelinerResHientel not drugs or wronshevicton) an 2 aavtubeaies, | asazorUnantiDebsner Pest Foreesure 26.11 S| Urtantut Detainee Onige (#8) | 2 A6022 Unlawful DetainerOnuge 2.611 r_—_—e_e———ee—ese ens Device pevane CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ADDENDUM Tose! Rule23 ARG Averoves 3.04 AND STATEMENT OF LOCATION Page 2 of Doo 1 Paget 24 = Dee XD = 1707254808 - Doc Type = OER (rage 15 of 36) TOT oro w Sher wane : 7 7 — ‘micas Cover Sheet Type ctclon Heston ne seheckonyom). fy ‘AseetFeetuze0s) | EL ASIO8 Asset Fee Cae 238 4g |_Pettonreauatency | AGtt6 PethentaConperContnntvacate tation 28 = i é 1 ABISH Wit Admire Mandamus 28 : 3 | winermarcton |x nets wit tarcamson tinted Cau Cove tee 2 i 3 {ASI Wt LintedCort se Ravew 2 i Otter Judicial Review (39) | C1 “6150 Other Writ Musicial Review 28 ! asnvisiadeRegusion (03) [AGUS havin Reguaton 128 & [Teeesennere [oso ences re | Semretmsaraneetot |e azo cantante Tet 128 z 8 | seaamesungaton aay [2 Ao0ns Seeutes igaten cate 128 2 5 Envcments@q) | A8036 Tow Towendonmenat 1.2.38 E | umescrmaee Gee [nore sees CneopeSarguon tonnes oh nase Hl SS in See i a 1 as%60 Ansvacttsugeent 28 | z Enfoceament 1D ASIG7 Confession of Sedgment (non-domeste relations) 29 1 B | tsueamentany | apteo AcrinstraneAgnoy Ava (et urpaitares) 28 : | #2 ASI Pettentertente fr Ey of sudan on Unpaid Tex 20 : 1 AGI12 Other Enforcement of Judgment Case 289 ICO @) 1 AGOSS Racetaning RO) Cove 128 gt a3 1D AG090 Declaratory Rell Oniy 28 as Other Comptains 1 6040 Iyuncive Rei Oty (nt domesticmarass ment) a8 BE | iotSrecocabove 2) |. pears oterCemmerisl Complaint Case (non totnon-complen) 428 I ms 0000 Other Cin Cola (nerernon-compln) 128 : i Parzen Conoaten 1c) ao113 Pornanipsnd Gepore Govnnce Care 28 1 Aet2t Chi Hererement 238 8 0129 Woiglice Harassment : 209 ze 7 7 Be | nervetemge | A812 ElerDependenadut tse Case 239 3 s ‘Spectied Above) (43) (2 A6190 Election Contest 2 26 © A6%10 Pettanto Change otNanetChange of Gender ae i ©. A6170 Pettentor Rebelo ale Cain Lew a : g ©. A6300 Oner ci Pton 20 a ‘acne evans CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ADDENDUM Local Rue 23 e208 AND STATEMENT OF LOCATION Pogeof4 ‘Dood i Faged 45 ~ Doo 29 = 1707151008 ~ boo Type = OTHER rage 26 of 36) SOTTO om Sher Ose MER ‘Step 4: statement of Reason and Address: Check the appropriate boxes for the numbers shown under Column C for the type of action that you have selected. Enter the address which is the basis for the filing location, including zip code. {Wo address required for class action cases). |470 Layton Way 01,02.03.04,.05.06.07. 08.0 9.010.014, |tosAngeles, CA 80049 REASON: ore ware] arcoot: Los Angeles ca} e0049 ‘Step 5: Certification of Assignment: I certty that this cases properly filed in the Contral District of the Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles [Code Civ. Proc., 8392 et seq., and Local Rule 2.3(a)(1)E)). wee ree August 18, 2017 [SoweTUREO= ATORRUNGPART PLEASE HAVE THE FOLLOWING ITEMS COMPLETED AND READY TO BE FILEDIN ORDER TO PROPERLY ‘COMIMENCE YOUR NEW COURT CASE: 4. Original Complaint or 2, Iffling a Complaint, a completed Summons form for issuance by the Clerk. 3, ClvilCase Cover Sheet, Judicial Council form CN-Ot0. 4 Gy ese Cover Sheet Addendum and Statement of Location form, LACIV 108, LASC Approved 03-04 (Rev. 5. Payment in fu of the fling fee, unless there is cau crder fr waiver, paral or scheduled payments ‘6. Asigned order appointing the Guardian ad titer, Judicial Council form ClV-010, ithe plain or pettioneris a ‘minor under 18 years of age will be required by Courtin order to issue a summons. 7. Additional copies of documents to be conformed by the Clerk. Copies ofthe cover sheet and this addendum ‘must be served along with the summons and complaint, or other initiating pleading in the case. tion. : & = LAB 09 evar) CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET ADDENDUM Tocal Rule 23 LaSG Approved a3.0¢ AND STATEMENT OF LOCATION Page 4 of 4 oot £ Paget 16 ~ Doo XD = 17073541008 - Doc Type = OnIER

You might also like