Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Steven Errede
LECTURE NOTES 8
A More Sophisticated Treatment of EM Wave Propagation in Conducting Media
In the previous P436 Lecture Notes 7, we discussed the propagation of EM waves in
conducting media (e.g. metals), taking into account Ohms Law J r , t C E r , t and the
continuity equation J r , t free r , t t in the conductor.
However, this treatment of conducting media neglected certain inertial effects associated
with the finite mass of free / conduction electrons in the metal conductor we need to consider
more carefully the actual motion of the free / conduction electrons in the conductor, and their
response e.g. to the application of a monochromatic plane EM wave of angular frequency .
Since the free / conduction electrons in a metal are not bound to individual atoms in a
conductor, there are no elastic restoring forces acting on the free / conduction electrons
{i.e. spring constant ke 0 }, as there was in the case of the polarization of bound atomic
electrons, e.g. in a dispersive, linear non-conducting medium. Thus, the differential equation
describing the motion of the free / conduction electrons in a metal is of the general form:
dv r , t
me me v r , t 0r t eE r , t Fe r , t
dt
where the driving force Fe r , t eE r , t = the charge of the electron e times the electric
field E r , t of the monochromatic plane EM wave propagating in the conducting metal.
Note also that me = mass of the free /conduction electron in the metal conductor which,
depending on the microscopic/quantum mechanical details of the conductor is {often} not equal
to the mass of a {truly free, isolated} electron me 9.11031kg , but {often} me ~ me .
The quantity me is known as the frictional / Joule dissipation constant, associated with
electron energy / momentum losses i.e. free /conduction electron scattering losses in the
conductor. The damping constant {n.b. units of angular frequency (radians/sec)} is associated
with dissipative/ energy loss mechanism(s) of the motion of free / conduction electrons in the
metal free / conduction electrons scattering off of each other, off of atoms, lattice vibrations,
crystal defects and impurities in real metals. Thus, we can also define a relaxation time constant
relax 1 associated with the free / conduction electrons present in the metal conductor.
The free current density in the metal conductor is J free r , t ne ev r , t {Amps/m2}, where:
nef free / conduction electron number density in the metal conductor {#/unit volume = #/m3}.
q e the electric charge of free / conduction electrons {Coulombs}.
v r , t vD = the drift velocity c of free / conduction electrons in metal at r , t {m/s}.
{e.g. vDCu ~ 80 m sec in copper.}
dv r , t
Thus: m
e me v r , t eE r , t multiply through by ne e :
dt
dv r , t
ne eme
f
nef eme v r , t nef e 2 E r , t
dt
dv r , t f
me nef e me ne ev r , t ne e E r , t
f 2
dt
d
me nef ev r , t me nef ev r , t nef e 2 E r , t
dt
dJ r , t dJ free r , t
n f e2
me J free r , t ne e E r , t or:
J free r , t e E r , t
free
me f 2
dt dt me
Using the continuity equation J free r , t free r , t t {expressing conservation of
free electric charge} in the above homogeneous equation, with E r , t 0 :
d n f e2
J free r , t J free r , t e E r , t
dt me
0
free r , t
2
free r , t
0
t 2 t
2 free r , t free r , t free r , t
thus: 0 free r , t 0
t 2
t t
free r , t o free r e t o free r e t relax .
But from P436 Lecture Notes 7, p. 1 we also obtained the relation free r , t o free r e C t .
Thus, comparing these two equations we see that: C 1 relax .
b.) For a static non-zero electric field E r Eo , then this static problem can have no explicit
time dependence, hence dJ free r , t dt 0 and thus the first-order linear, inhomogeneous
equation becomes:
n f e2 n f e2
Thus, we see here that: J free r e E r C E r i.e. the static conductivity C e
me me
1 m
or equivalently, the static resistivity: C fe 2 . {n.b. both purely real quantities}
C ne e
C m
The static / DC resistance e.g. of a long wire is thus: R fe 2 Ohms
A ne e A
{again, a purely real quantity}
c.) For a harmonically time-dependent {in general, complex} electric field (e.g. associated with a
monochromatic EM plane wave (or an AC current, using Ohms law), with angular frequency 2 f :
it dJ free r , t n f e 2
E r , t Eo r e and: J free r , t e E r , t
dt me
We assume that the {in general, complex} free current density solution to this linear
inhomogeneous first-order differential equation is of the general form: J free r , t J o free r e it .
Then the solution to this linear, inhomogeneous first-order differential equation is:
Thus, we see that the {complex} AC resistance (aka impedance, Z) e.g. of a long wire is:
C me
Z R AC C 1 i / f 2 1 i / n.b. complex quantity
A A ne e A
n.b. Can hear the effect of complex R AC in {audiophile-type} hi-fi stereo systems
by comparing good (thick) vs. bad (thin/cheap) L & R loudspeaker cables!
free r , t free r , t Gauss
The AC continuity equation is: J free r , t with: E r , t
t Law
C nef e 2 me
But: J free r , t C E r , t
E r , t E r,t
1 i /
1 i /
C nef e 2 me
Thus: J free r , t C E r , t E r , t E r , t
1 i / 1 i /
free r , t C free r , t free r , t C
or: free r , t
t 1 i / t 1 i /
The solution to the above differential equation for the free electric charge volume density is of
the form: free r , t o r e it provided that:
free r , t C free C
free r , t i n.b. implies free free {complex!}
t 1 i / 1 i /
1 C C nef e 2 1
i.e. that: free but: C
i 1 i / 1 i / me 1 i /
1 C
free o C o 1 C
o 1 1
free
i
i i
o
e
vacuum vacuum
o
vacuum
o
vacuum
metal
metal metal metal
because the vacuum pervades all space the conducting medium and the vacuum coexist in the
same region of space-time, invoking the superposition principle , the two electric permittivities
(n.b. both scalar quantities) are additive.
However, it can be seen that because the {DC} conductivity of metals is so high
{typically C ~ 107 Siemens/m }, that even for {angular} frequencies in the optical region
{ ~ 1016 radians/sec } the electric permittivity of free space, o is dwarfed by the second term,
i.e. o 8.85 1012 C i C i 1 i / Farads /m , so often the o term is
neglected/dropped in many textbooks... For technical correctness / completeness sake, we will
include it here. Thus, we see that even for metal conductors:
free 1 1 C 1 1 1 i /
1 C 1 1 C 1 efree
o i o i o 1 i / i o 1 / 2
1 C 1 C 1 1 1 i /
efree C
i o i o 1 i / i o 1 / 2
For pure copper metal at low frequencies, i.e. 0 , the static conductivity is CCu 6 107
Siemens/m; the number density of free electrons in pure copper metal is neCu 8.5 1028 /m3 and
using C nef e 2 me Cu neCu e 2 me CCu neCu e 2 me CCu 4 1013 sec 1 , which
corresponds to a relaxation time for free / conduction electrons in pure copper of
relax
Cu
1 Cu 2.5 1014 sec .
For Conducting Metals with Free Electrons: J free r , t C E r , t
Note that in the static limit ( 0):
E r , t Eo r e it Eo r static / constant J free C E
J free r , t J o free r e it J o free r static / constant J free free
t
free r , t o free
r eit o r
free
static / constant
C nef e 2
C C 1 static / constant C
1 i / C me
1
C C 1 i / C static / constant
C
C C C
free o o o singular !!!
i i 1 i / / i
In the previous P436 Lecture Notes 7.5 on dispersion in non-conducting, non-magnetic
linear / homogeneous / isotropic media, we showed / derived the complex electric permittivity
(due to bound atomic electrons) of the dielectric medium to be:
neb e2 n osc 12j 2 i j
bnd o 1
bnd
o 1 f j
o me j 1 2 2 2 2 2
e
1 j j
with: K ebnd bnd 1 ebnd and: n bnd o K ebnd 1 ebnd .
o
If only one / a single resonance exists, this relation reduces to:
neb e 2 1 i
2 2
neb e 2 kejb
1 o 1
with: 1 j 0 j 3 m and: 0 j m
2
o me 1
2 2
2 2 2
o e e
Comparing this expression to that for conducting media with free / conduction electrons:
C n f e2
free o with static conductivity: C e
/ i me
nef e 2 i
2
nef e 2 1 1 nef e 2 1
free o o 2 o 4
me / i me i me
2 2
nef e 2 0 i
2 2
Note that the sign in the above formula {relative to that for bound atomic electrons} arises because
of fact that free / conduction electrons in metal are not bound (i.e. phase shift of 180o @ f = 0 Hz).
Then for dispersive conducting media containing free electrons, Maxwells equations become:
C
1) D free E free 5) Ohms Law: J free C E
1 i
free
2) B 0 6) Continuity Equation: J free
t
B
3) E
t
Assume dispersive conducting
D E
4) B o J free o
t
o J free o free
t
medium is non-magnetic o
Again, we use the curl operator on equations 3) and 4) to obtain wave equation(s) for EM waves
propagating in a dispersive metal / conductor, e.g. for equation 3):
J free
2 E
E B o o free 2
t t t
E 2 E n2 1 here, for non-magnetic
E 2 E o C o free 2 and: 2 2 o free conductors o
t t c v
1 2 E E C E
sec 1 ps we obtain: E 2 2 o C o
12 2
Thus, for times t 10
v t t 1 i t
Using equation 4) above, an identical wave equation is obtained for the magnetic field B r , t :
1 2 B B C B
B 2 2 o C
2
o
v t t 1 i t
Solutions to above wave equation(s) for monochromatic EM plane waves propagating in the
z direction in a dispersive conducting media with free electrons will be of the form e.g.
i kz t k i kz t
E r , t Eo e and: B r , t k E r , t Bo e .
c
k n or: n k where the complex index of refraction:
c
c c
n n i thus: n e n k and: m n .
i kz t
Plugging in the expression E r , t Eo e for monochromatic plane EM waves propagating
in a dispersive, non-magnetic conducting medium into the above wave equation, we obtain the
so-called characteristic equation for this situation {Exercise - explicitly work this out yourselves!}:
2
io C 1 n f e2 n f e2
k 2 with: c 2 and: C e or: e
c 1 i o o me me C
1 i
2
c
Then: n 2 k 2 = (complex index of refraction)2 n 2 1 i C
o 1
2
nef e 2 C
Definition of low frequency: 1 where: and: .
me C o
2
io C io C keeping only
For 0 (but not 0 !): k 2 k 2 io C
c 1 i 1 terms linear in
1 i
Now note that: i 1 {Please work this out/derive this yourselves!}
2
o C
Thus for 0 i.e. 1 : k 2 io C k k i io C 1 i
2
From which we see immediately that for monochromatic plane EM waves propagating in a
o C
dispersive, non-magnetic conducting medium, that: k and thus here
2
{again} we see that the B -field lags the E -field by: k B E tan 1 tan 1 1 45o .
k 4
2
c
Similarly, for 0 i.e. 1 since: n k 2
2
2
c 2 c
2 1 i 1 i
Then:
n 2
k
i
o C i o C C . Using:
2
i
o o
o 2
i C C C
n n i 1 i which again implies that: n .
o 2 o 2 o
1 2 same as before,
Here again, we can define a low-frequency skin depth: sc
o C but with o
the characteristic distance that the E and B fields fall to 1 e e1 0.368 of their z = 0 values.
For pure copper metal, for which Cu 4.11013 sec 1 and CCu 6 107 Siemens /m and thus
CCu o 6.5 1018 / sec , then for low frequencies, e.g. f 2 1012 Hz we see that pure
copper metal is in the low-frequency regime for vacuum wavelengths of:
c 3 108 2 o 2 f CCu
o 3 104 m 300 m cf w/ Cu f 2 106 m 1 m
f 1012
k f 2
In pure copper metal, the skin depth sc associated with monochromatic EM waves of
frequency f ~ 1012 Hz = 1 THz = 106 MHz is:
2 2
sccu f 1 THz , o 300 m 6.5 108 m 65 nm
o C 4 10 2 10 6 10
7 12 7
10
sc
12
Hz 65 nm Cu 1012 Hz 1 m o 300 m
In pure copper metal, the skin depth sc associated with monochromatic EM waves of
frequency f ~ 1010 Hz = 10 GHz = 104 MHz (e.g. cell phones) {which corresponds to a vacuum
wavelength of o c f 3 108 1010 3 102 m 3 cm } is:
1 2 2
sccu 1010 Hz 6.5 107 m 650 nm
o C 4 10 2 10 6 10
7 10 7
The wavelength of EM waves with frequency f 1010 Hz propagating in the pure copper metal is:
2 o 2 f CCu
Cu f 2 105 m 10 m
k f 2
Thus at low frequencies, we {again} see that:
10
sc
10
Hz 650 nm Cu 1010 Hz 10 m o 3.0 cm
The High Frequency Behavior of a Dispersive, Non-Magnetic Conducting Medium:
n e2 C
Definition of high frequency: 1 where: e and: .
me C o
1 1 i
n 2 1 i C 1 i C
o 1 i o 1
2
At high frequencies, the free / conduction electrons in a metal will undergo a great many
oscillations before scattering i.e. the period of oscillations 1 f 2 is short compared
to the mean time between scatterings, essentially the relaxation time, relax 1 .
In the high-frequency regime, the volume charge density of free electrons and the lattice of
positive ions in metal together can be thought of as a plasma whose electron charge density
oscillates longitudinally { i.e. in the direction of propagation of the EM wave) at the {natural}
angular resonance frequency known as the plasma frequency, defined as:
nef e2
The plasma frequency in a metal/conductor: P (radians/sec) and: f P P Hz .
o me
2
PCu
For pure copper: PCu 1.644 1016 rad / sec f PCu 2.616 1015 Hz
2
c
The corresponding plasma wavelength in copper is: PCu Cu
1.147 107 m = 114.7 nm
f P
Operative in the optical UV portion of the EM spectrum typical for many metals !!!
We can rewrite the (complex index of refraction)2 in terms of the plasma frequency :
i C o n f e2 1 nef e 2 1 used:
n 2 1 1 i e 1
1 i o me 1 i o me i 1 i i 1
P2 i 1 i
Equating the real and imaginary portions of n 2 n 2 2 i 2n use the following trick:
2 i 2 i i 1 i 1 i
2 2 2
1 1
2 2 2 2 2
2 i 2 i 2 i 4 2 2 2 2
2
P2 P2 1 i P2 P
2
n 1 2
2
1 1 2 2
i 2 2
n 2 2 i 2n
i
2 2
n 2 2 2 n
P2 P2
n 2 2 1 and: 2 n 2 2
2
2
P2
Now define: x and: x .
2
2
Then: n 2 2 1 x and: 2n x x x
2
x x x2 x2
Thus: n 1 x n
2 2 2
1 x or: n 1 x n x x 0
4 2
2n 4n 2 2
2
Define: x n , then: x 1 x x x x 0 which is a quadratic equation of the form:
2 2
2
2
ax 2 bx c 0 with: a = 1, b = 1 x and c = x x .
2
must select +ve root on physical grounds!
b b 2 4ac 1 x 1 x x2 x2
2
1
2
x P2
n x
x
2
1 1 x
2
1 x
2
2
1 1
2
x
n
x
where: 1 x
2
1 x
x nef e 2 nef e 2 P2
and: x where: P and:
2n o me me C C o
Typical plasma frequencies for free electrons in metals are: P 1016 rad / sec .
Typical -factors for free electrons in metals are: 1 relax 1013 1014 rad / sec .
2
P2
Then: x P 1 and: x 1 at high frequencies.
2 2
2 2
P P
x x
2
P
And: 1
1x P
2
P
2
1 1
2 2
1
Then: n 1 x 1 P 1 P 1 {Using 1 1 12 for 1 }
2
2
P
x x
2
1
And: 1 at high frequencies.
2n 1 P 2 2
2 1
2
Some {alkali} metals are transparent / begin to be transparent in the UV region of the EM spectrum!
c 2 c nef e 2
Metal P P
f P P o me
7
3 Li 155.0 nm
23
11 Na 209.0 nm
39
19 K 287.0 nm
63
29 Cu 114.7 nm
85
Alkali Metals 37 Rb 322.0 nm UV
k B tan 1 0 for P
k
B is {nearly} in-phase with E for EM waves propagating in metals/conductors with frequency
well above the plasma frequency P .
Well above the plasma frequency, we also have , such that:
dv r , t
me me v r , t eE r , t me a r , t eE r , t Fe r , t
dt
i kz t
Because E r , t Eo e , and a r , t
r t 2 r t t 2 we see that for P that the
free electrons in a metal oscillate {nearly} in-phase with the driving E of the monochromatic EM
wave. Well above the plasma frequency P , a metals complex index of refraction is real (i.e.
absorption is small), the conductor becomes increasingly transparent as is increased beyond P .
Note also that n 1 for P {i.e. in the so-called anomalous dispersion region}!!!
2 2
n 1 P for ( P ) and: P for ( P )
Since n 2 free o 1 efree for non-magnetic conductors, free and efree are
{also} predominantly real at high frequencies ( ) , i.e. K free 1 for .
P free o e p
2
c 1
1 c
The skin depth for p is: sc
P
Below the plasma frequency P , the index of refraction is complex, i.e. is large and
therefore non-negligible; Metals are thus opaque for P .
k 4
The free / conduction electrons in a dispersive conductor also lag E -field by same phase lag.
For P , since the incident EM wave is not transmitted, much of the EM wave is reflected.
Metals have a high reflection coefficient R for P .
Then for situations with negligible damping, i.e. 0 , then n 2 n 2 and the above
relations simply somewhat:
free P
2
nef e 2
n
2
K e 1 e e n n 1
free free
2 2
with: P
o o me
The above relation holds {i.e. is valid} over a wide range of frequencies, including .
For situations with 0 , the imaginary part of complex n ,
2
m n P 0 because 0 .
2
In this regime, where 0 , the wavenumber k is: k 1 P
c
which is sometimes expressed as: 2 P2 ck 2 dispersion relation for k .
{n.b. In dispersive conducting media, where is not small, the above formulae apply only for P .}
2
Note that in a tenuous plasma with P : k 1 P is purely imaginary!!!
c
EM waves with P incident on such a plasma are reflected for P , because the EM
fields inside tenuous plasma are exponentially attenuated by the factor e kz .
It is precisely this fact that enables e.g. short-wave radio communication around the globe
the short-wave radio waves reflect off of the plasma in the earths ionosphere!
For tenuous electron plasmas in the laboratory:
ne e 2
ne 1018 1022 electrons/m3 P 6 1010 6 1012 radians/sec
o me
At = 0, the static attenuation constant is: m k P c at = 0.
Skin depth (at = 0):
1 c
sc 0 0.5 cm 5 103 cm for static (or low-frequency) EM fields
0 P
Expulsion of EM fields within a plasma is well-known phenomena, e.g. in controlled thermo-
nuclear processes, and can also be exploited e.g. in attempts at confinement of a hot plasma.
Some conducting metals, such as gold and copper, as well as various alloys e.g. bronze and
brass (zinc, tin and copper) do not have a silvery-gray appearance, but have a yellow / orange /
red tinge to them. This is because these metals preferentially absorb (i.e. transmit) in the
green-blue region and thus reflect more-so in the yellow / orange / red region of the visible light
spectrum, giving these metals their characteristic hues / colors.
Gold-metalized safety glasses with a very thin layer of gold deposited on them have
transmittance T(f) peaked ~ in the green portion of the visible spectrum. Goggles/safety glasses
coated with a thin gold layer are used by people who work around high-temperature furnaces.
Visible light from the furnace {peaked ~ in the green} is transmitted, but infrared light (i.e. heat)
is strongly reflected by gold!
Because free / conduction electrons in a metal have no resonances (except the one at = 0)
because there are no restoring forces acting on them. In such metals as gold and copper, bound
electrons e.g. in the so-called valence bands of the metal also play a non-negligible role e.g. in
the optical properties of the metal i.e. in the visible light portion of the EM spectrum!
Since (i.e. we assume) the response of the free electrons in the conduction band is separable /
independent of the response of the bound electrons in the valence band(s) to incident EM waves
(valid as long as the amplitudes of E / B are not too large). Thus we {again} use the principle of linear
superposition for the complex electric permittivity: tot o vac bnd efree
n.b. nbe = # density (= #/m3) of bound atomic electrons in the dispersive conducting medium
nef e 2 0 i 0 2 i 0
2 2
and: nef = # density (#/m3) of free conduction-band electrons in the dispersive conducting medium.
nef e 2
The plasma frequency of free electrons in the dispersive conducting medium is: P
o me
Then:
12j 2 i j
nb e 2 n bound 2 i 0
tot o 1 o 1 e f josc
tot 2
2 2
o me j 1
e P
0
2 2 2 2 2 4
1 j j
e e e P
0
2 4 2 2
m
o e j 1 2 2 2 2
1 j j
12j 2 i j
tot ne e n bound
b 2 2 i 0
e
2
n f j
2 tot
1 1
osc
2 2
o m
P
0
2 4
o e j 1
2 2 2 2
1 j j
n bound
nef e 2
with: f josc 1 , P and with: n 2 n i n i n 2 2 i 2n
j 1 o me
c c c
k n or: n k with: n k and:
c