Professional Documents
Culture Documents
174]
Original Article
348 2016 Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Tuesday, October 10, 2017, IP: 157.50.12.174]
health problem, many believe that it is caused by practices by dentists is reportedly prevalent.[10]
others.[5] Surveys of antibiotics prescribing among general
dental practitioners in the UK,[11,12] Australia,[13]
Factors contributing to the antibiotic resistance and Belgium,[14] among others, have concluded that
phenomenon have been reported to include the therapeutic prescribing of antibiotics varied widely
routine use of antibiotics in agriculture resulting and was suboptimal. Overprescribing[15] and low
in potential direct infection with resistant bacteria adherence to professional guidelines[16] in antibiotics
from an animal source[6] and overconsumption of prescribing for dental infections in children have also
antibiotics in healthcare settings.[3] It is generally been reported.
acknowledged that the dentists have a role in helping
to reduce antimicrobial resistance development by Recent research has focused on preparing health
prescribing the correct drug, at the standard dosage professions students for appropriate antibiotic
and appropriate regimen when necessary,[7,8] and prescribing.[1720] A survey of 37 medical schools in
evidencebased guidance on sensible protocols for 13 European countries has reported wide variations
antimicrobials prescribing has been set out.[9] in exposure of students to important principles of
prudent antibiotic use among countries and within
Systemic antibiotics are not routinely used in the same country.[21] Among dental vocational
dentistry as most dental and periodontal diseases practitioners in the UK, wide variations in the
are best managed by surgical interventions and therapeutic antibiotic regimens used have been
oral hygiene measures, but overprescribing reported, with most not conforming to the guidelines
Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Oct-Dec 2016 | Vol 34 | Issue 4 | 349
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Tuesday, October 10, 2017, IP: 157.50.12.174]
available.[22] Some researchers have suggested that it is Table2: Distribution of subjects by sex, dental
crucial to develop appropriate curricula for teaching school, training in antibiotic prescribing, and
healthcare (pharmacy, dentistry, nursing, veterinary number of child patients treated(n=108)
medicine, and midwifery) undergraduate students
n(%)
about judicious antibiotic prescribing.[23,24] Little is
Sex
known about antibiotic prescribing among dental
Male 40(37.0)
students. This paper aims to report on antibiotic
prescribing training received by dental students, Female 68(63.0)
clinical experience in treating child patients, awareness School nationality
of antibiotic prescribing guidelines, preparedness in Malaysian 74(68.5)
antibiotic prescribing, and compliance with antibiotic NonMalaysian 34(31.5)
prescribing guidelines for the management of dental Training in antibiotic prescribing in the last 12
infections in children. months?
Yes 75(69.4)
No 33(30.6)
Methods Average number of child patients treated per week
Fewer than 1 41(38.0)
A crosssectional survey was conducted on final
1 or more 67(62.0)
year dental students using a selfadministered
questionnaire. Opportunistic sampling was carried out
to recruit students from a sample Malaysian and Asian Table3: Awareness of antibiotic prescribing
dental schools, selected through personal contacts. guidelines and association with sex, school
The survey was approved by the Institutional Review nationality, training in antibiotic prescribing and
Board. average number of child patients treated per week
Awareness of antibiotic prescribing
The survey instrument consisted of four main parts guidelines for treating dental
which included sample characteristics, clinical case infections in children
scenarios involving antibiotic prescribing decisions,[16] Yes n(%) No n(%) P value
perceptions on antibiotic resistance,[25] and confidence Sex
in prescribing antibiotics for dental infections.[26] Table1 Male 16(40.0) 24(60.0) 0.625
presents the five clinical cases on antibiotic prescribing Female 24(35.3) 44(64.7)
for dental infections in children. Four scenarios are School nationality
offered for case 14, and three for case 5. Students were
Malaysian 35(47.3) 39(52.7) 0.001
asked to indicate for each scenario whether they would
NonMalaysian 5(14.7) 29(85.3)
prescribe antibiotics or not. Students were deemed
Training in antibiotic
compliant with the guidelines if they answered all prescribing in the last 12
scenarios correctly in each case. They were considered months?
noncompliant if they answered wrongly in any one Yes 29(38.7) 46(61.3) 0.597
scenario. The proportion of participants who complied No 11(33.3) 22(66.7)
with the guidelines in each scenario was calculated. Average number of
child patients treated
Students were also asked for the number of child per week
patients they treated in a week, whether they had Fewer than 1 9(22.0) 32(78.0) 0.011
antibiotic training in the past 12 months, their 1 or more 31(46.3) 36(53.7)
awareness of any antibiotic prescribing guidelines and Total 40(37.0) 68(63.0)
how well prepared they felt in antibiotic prescribing
for children.
prescribing guidelines in each case were calculated.
An email was sent to selected dental schools in Compliance in each scenario was tested for association
Malaysia, Hong Kong, and Taiwan, seeking for approval with their preparedness in antibiotic prescribing,
to conduct the survey on their students. Following this, previous training on antibiotic prescribing, and
an email containing a link to the online questionnaire awareness of antibiotic prescribing guidelines using
was sent to the deans and student representatives of the Chisquare test.
the dental schools for them to cascade down to their
final year students from September to December 2014. Results
One further email was sent 1 month later to remind
those who had not responded. A total of 108 complete questionnaires were received
from final year dental students. Table 2 shows the
The data collected were analyzed using SPSS statistics distribution of students by sex, nationality of dental
version20 (IBM, Armonk, New York). The proportions school, training in antibiotic prescribing, and number
of participants who complied with antibiotic of child patients treated. Most were female(63.0%) and
350 Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Oct-Dec 2016 | Vol 34 | Issue 4 |
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Tuesday, October 10, 2017, IP: 157.50.12.174]
from Malaysian dental schools(68.5%). Most reported Table4: Preparedness in antibiotic prescribing
having had training in antibiotic prescribing in the last for children and association with sex, school
12months(69.4%) and treated at least one child patient nationality, training in antibiotic prescribing and
per week(62.0%). average number of child patients treated per week
Do you think you have been
Only 37.0% students reported the awareness of prepared well in antibiotic
antibiotic prescribing guidelines for dental infections prescribing for children?
in children[Table3]. Those attending Malaysian dental Yes n(%) No n(%) P value
schools(47.3%) were more likely to report awareness
compared to those attending nonMalaysian dental Sex
schools(14.7%). Students who treated on average one Male 7(17.5) 33(82.5) 0.859
child patient or more per week(46.3%) were statistically Female 11(16.2) 57(83.8)
significantly more likely to be aware of antibiotic School nationality
prescribing guidelines compared to those who
treated fewer than one child patient per week(22.0%). Malaysian 15(20.3) 59(79.7) 0.138
Awareness of antibiotic guidelines was not associated NonMalaysian 3(8.8) 31(91.2)
with sex or antibiotic prescribing training. Training in antibiotic
prescribing in the last 12
months?
Only 16.7% of students thought that they were well
Yes 16(21.3) 59(78.7) 0.050
prepared for antibiotic prescribing for children
No 2(6.1) 31(93.9)
[Table 4]. Students who had received antibiotic
Average number of child
prescribing training (21.3%) were statistically patients treated per week
significantly more likely to think they were well Fewer than 1 3(7.3) 38(92.7) 0.041
prepared in antibiotic prescribing compared to those 1 or more 15(22.4) 52(77.6)
who had not received training (6.1%). Those who
Total 18(16.7) 90(83.3)
treated on average one child patient or more per
week (22.4%) were statistically significantly more
likely to be aware of antibiotic prescribing guidelines
compared to those who treated fewer than one child Table5: Compliance rates to antibiotic guidelines
patient per week (7.3%). Preparedness in antibiotic for each of the clinical cases
prescribing for children was not associated with sex or Noncompliance with Compliance with
school nationality. clinical guidelines clinical guidelines
n(%) n(%)
The compliance rate with prescribing guidelines in Case 1 61(56.5) 47(43.5)
each of the clinical case ranged from 15.7% to 43.5% Case 2 91(84.3) 17(15.7)
[Table5]. For case 1, 43.5% would prescribe antibiotics Case 3 71(65.7) 37(34.3)
only for pain and facial swelling with radiographic Case 4 77(71.3) 31(28.7)
evidence of pathology, which is consistent with the Case 5 80(74.1) 28(25.9)
AAPD guidelines. For case 2, when fever was added to
the scenario, the compliance rate was 15.7%. For case 3,
when fever was absent, but draining fistula was added Discussion
to the signs and symptoms, the compliance was 34.3%.
For cases 4 and 5, which were nonworking day cases, the This study investigated the prevalence dental students
compliance rates were 28.7% and 25.9%, respectively. training in antibiotic prescribing, clinical experience
in treating child patients, awareness of antibiotic
For most of the cases, compliance with antibiotic prescribing guidelines for dental infections in children,
guidelines did not appear to be associated with school and preparedness in antibiotic prescribing, and their
nationality, training in antibiotic prescribing in the last association with compliance with existing guidelines.
12months, child patients treated per week, awareness The key findings were that most students had received
of antibiotic prescribing guidelines, or preparedness training on antibiotic prescribing and had treated
in antibiotic prescribing. The exceptions were for one or more child patients per week, but most were
case 2, in which students who had received antibiotic not aware of any guidelines on antibiotic prescribing
prescribing training (21.3%) were more likely to be or felt well prepared in antibiotic prescribing.
compliant when compared to students who had Compliance with guidelines was generally low and
not(3.0%). For nonworking day case 5, students who was not associated with training, clinical experience,
treated one or more child patient per week (52.2%) awareness, or preparedness.
were more likely to be compliant when compared to
students who treated fewer than one child patient per Only a third of participants in the present study
week(31.7%). reported the awareness of any antibiotic prescribing
Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Oct-Dec 2016 | Vol 34 | Issue 4 | 351
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Tuesday, October 10, 2017, IP: 157.50.12.174]
352 Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Oct-Dec 2016 | Vol 34 | Issue 4 |
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Tuesday, October 10, 2017, IP: 157.50.12.174]
14. MainjotA, DHooreW, VanheusdenA, Van NieuwenhuysenJP. effectiveness, target, and content for prudent antibiotic use.
Antibiotic prescribing in dental practice in Belgium. Int Endod Biomed Res Int 2015;2015:214021.
J 2009;42:11127. 24. OhlCA, LutherVP. Health care provider education as a tool
15. SivaramanSS, HassanM, PearsonJM. Anational survey of to enhance antibiotic stewardship practices. Infect Dis Clin
pediatric dentists on antibiotic use in children. Pediatr Dent North Am 2014;28:17793.
2013;35:5469. 25. Garca C, LlamoccaLP, Garca K, Jimnez A, SamalvidesF,
16. CherryWR, LeeJY, ShugarsDA, White RP Jr., GotuzzoE, etal. Knowledge, attitudes and practice survey
Vann WF Jr. Antibiotic use for treating dental infections in about antimicrobial resistance and prescribing among
children: A survey of dentists prescribing practices. JAm physicians in a hospital setting in Lima, Peru. BMC Clin
Dent Assoc 2012;143:318. Pharmacol 2011;11:18.
17. HuangY, GuJ, ZhangM, RenZ, YangW, ChenY, 26. PulciniC, WilliamsF, MolinariN, DaveyP, NathwaniD.
etal. Knowledge, attitude and practice of antibiotics: A Junior doctors knowledge and perceptions of antibiotic
questionnaire study among 2500 Chinese students. BMC Med resistance and prescribing: A survey in France and Scotland.
Educ 2013;13:163. Clin Microbiol Infect 2011;17:807.
18. ScaioliG, GualanoMR, GiliR, MasucciS, BertF, 27. AbboLM, CosgroveSE, PottingerPS, PereyraM,
SiliquiniR. Antibiotic use: A crosssectional survey SinkowitzCochranR, SrinivasanA, etal. Medical students
assessing the knowledge, attitudes and practices amongst perceptions and knowledge about antimicrobial stewardship:
students of a school of medicine in Italy. PLoS One How are we educating our future prescribers? Clin Infect Dis
2015;10:E0122476. 2013;57:6318.
19. HarakehS, AlmatrafiM, UngapenH, HammadR, OlayanF, 28. DyarOJ, PulciniC, HowardP, Nathwani D; ESGAP(ESCMID
HakimR, etal. Perceptions of medical students towards Study Group for Antibiotic Policies). European medical
antibiotic prescribing for upper respiratory tract infections in students: A first multicentre study of knowledge, attitudes and
Saudi Arabia. BMJ Open Respir Res 2015;2:E000078. perceptions of antibiotic prescribing and antibiotic resistance.
20. MinenMT, DuquaineD, MarxMA, WeissD. Asurvey JAntimicrob Chemother 2014;69:8426.
of knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs of medical students 29. DallasA, van DrielM, van de MortelT, MaginP. Antibiotic
concerning antimicrobial use and resistance. Microb Drug prescribing for the future: Exploring the attitudes of trainees in
Resist 2010;16:2859. general practice. Br J Gen Pract 2014;64:E5617.
21. PulciniC, WenckerF, FrimodtMller N, KernWV, 30. ArnoldSR, StrausSE. Interventions to improve antibiotic
NathwaniD, RodrguezBao J, etal. European survey prescribing practices in ambulatory care. Cochrane Database
on principles of prudent antibiotic prescribing teaching in Syst Rev 2005;19:CD003539.
undergraduate students. Clin Microbiol Infect 2015;21:35461. 31. BekkersMJ, SimpsonSA, DunstanF, HoodK, HareM,
22. PalmerNO, BatchelorPA. An audit of antibiotic prescribing by EvansJ, etal. Enhancing the quality of antibiotic prescribing
vocational dental practitioners. Prim Dent Care 2004;11:7780. in primary care: Qualitative evaluation of a blended learning
23. LeeCR, LeeJH, KangLW, JeongBC, LeeSH. Educational intervention. BMC Fam Pract 2010;11:34.
Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry | Oct-Dec 2016 | Vol 34 | Issue 4 | 353