Professional Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Mesostructure and contact interface properties are important for material design and performance
Received 15 May 2013 assessment of asphalt mixtures, which is sensitive to the crack. Conventional asphalt mixture design
Received in revised form 26 November 2013 method always ignores the fact that mesostructure and interface signicantly inuence the performance
Accepted 28 November 2013
of pavement. To evaluate these factors, rstly the properties of contacting interface between asphalt and
Available online 14 January 2014
aggregate were achieved through uniaxial tension test. Then numerical cohesive zone model (CZM) was
utilized to estimate the crack resistance of the interface based on laboratory damage parameters. Finally,
Keywords:
mesostructural damage simulation of asphalt mortar was conducted to unfold the entire cracking distri-
Interface
Damage
bution, which included the contact interface properties. The results show that mesostructural parameters
Uniaxial tension and interface properties have an important impact on damage characteristics. However, these factors are
Digital image processing not comprehensively understood in current hot mixture asphalt design method.
Finite element method 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0950-0618/$ - see front matter 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2013.11.109
666 Z. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 53 (2014) 665673
Fig. 1. Different scales in multi-scale for asphalt material and pavement structure.
All above studies show that asphalt mixture is dened as a kind mortar), which is given onto the top surface of a cylinder specimen
(h100 mm 100 mm) at 20 C, material test equipment records deformation
of composites, which exhibits different outputs undergoing exter-
and loading curves. After the remove of instant elastic strain according to straight
nal or internal stimulation in various scales. However, most of the line of loaddisplacement curve, the creep curve can be obtained. In this part,
specications and pavement construction guides have focused on observation and analysis are conducted based on experimental results of asphalt
macroscopic circumstance without considerations about other mortar specimens, shown in Figs. 3 and 4.
smaller scales. There is a big challenge to totally contain micro- The asphalt mortar of Mix B shows a strongest compressive strength, followed
by Mix A and Mix C. Although in the value distribution of creep curves, asphalt mor-
scopic and mesoscopic characteristics for current asphalt mixture
tar of Mix B is larger than Mix A, and it is obvious that the changing rate of Mix B
design method, and macroscopic indexes are difcult to evaluate presents a stablest variation, which positively affect the long-term deformation
material feature in other tinier scales. The methodologies of this resistance. A conclusion about a strongest asphalt mortar of Mix B is easily con-
paper took digital image processing technique, nite element anal- cluded based on these macroscopic experiments. However, it would be several dif-
ferent results existing in mesostructural parameters, which could be discussed in
ysis, and uniaxial tension of a single particle into consideration.
next part.
Firstly, the numerical models of three kinds of similar asphalt mix-
tures in macro composition were implemented, then aggregate
shape indexes were obtain from blackwhite images of asphalt 3. Methodologies
mixes section. Then, accounting for an accurate measurement of
contacting interface with aggregate shapes inuence, uniaxial ten- 3.1. Digital image processing technique
sion equipment was developed to achieve some damage parame-
ters for numerical models. Finally, computational simulations 3.1.1. Brief introduction
were conducted to nd different mechanical responses between Based on computational algorithms, digital image processing
diverse asphalt mix models. The main objective of this study was techniques are used to perform image processing on digital images,
to prove that macroscopic asphalt mixture design method could which are developed in the 1960s [24]. This technique has many
be fail to distinguish the mesostructural differences, especially in advantages in dealing with two-dimensional even multidimen-
damage simulation utilizing macro indexes. The second objective sional systems, such as the compatibility with wider range of algo-
was to compare the diversities to do precise assessment for meso- rithms and avoiding issues about noise and signal distortion during
structural parameters and microscopic indexes in damage situa- processing. In particular, digital image processing method is a use-
tion, and this paper was preliminary to summary the inuence of ful and necessary tool to resolve many cutting-edge problems in
mesoscopic characteristics on asphalt mixture damage. terms of classication, feature extraction, multi-scale medium
analysis.
2. Materials
3.1.2. Mesostructural parameters illustration
2.1. Material elastic parameters
In asphalt mixtures, macroscopic information is convenient to
Three kinds of asphalt mixes are named as Mix A, Mix B and Mix C (gradation be obtained through experiments and theories, but asphalt mixes
curves shown in Fig. 2). According to the multi-scale classication (shown in are typical isotropic and inhomogeneous. Consequently, illustra-
Fig. 1), in meso-scale asphalt mixture is divided into two main components (aggre- tion of mesostructural parameters is an important part in this pa-
gates are bigger than 2.36 mm and asphalt mortar consists of asphalt binder and
per. Several colorful section pictures of asphalt mixtures are
other smaller aggregates). NMAS (Nominal Maximum Aggregate Size), OAC (Opti-
mal Asphalt Content), types of asphalt mixtures are determined by Marshall Design processed based on digital image processing method. Firstly, col-
Method. Material parameters in elastic realm of two main components are impor- orful pictures are converted into 8 bit gray-scale images, and then
tant for numerical simulation. The material properties of coarse aggregate are histogram equalization is utilized to balance the distribution of
adopted through rock experiments. Elastic parameters of asphalt mortar are ob-
gray level. Thirdly, background and impulsive noises are de-
tained by the static resilient modulus experiment. It keeps the same ller-bitumen
ratio with macroscopic asphalt mixtures. In the specication of Application Hand-
creased or eliminated via median ltering instead of mean lter-
book of Standard Test Methods of Bitumen and Bituminous Mixture, static resilient ing. Finally, gray-scale images are converted into blackwhite
modulus experiment [22] is applied to calculate the resilient modulus which is images after mathematical morphology process which could
equivalent to the elastic modulus of asphalt mixture. The resilient displacement make aggregate a single one out from the attached pairs. Black
of cylinder specimens is measured from material test equipment (MTS-810) with
white images of coarse aggregates and asphalt mortar are shown
seven-level stress load, and static resilient modulus can be achieved through data
process. The value of Poissons ratio [23] of asphalt mixture and mortar is referred in Fig. 5.
based on one related study. Experimental results are shown in Table 1. Coarse aggregates mesostructural parameters present a crucial
impact on asphalt mixture performance, such as shape and angu-
2.2. Static creep test larity provide interlocking strength, texture can inuence inter-
face bonding capacity, which is presented in Fig. 6. Digital
Known as the viscoelastic compounds, asphalt mixture is sensitive to the load-
ing rate and temperature. Static creep test is treated as a key tool in asphalt mixture
image processing software can measure and determine the mes-
design, it is used to assess and predict long-time performance of deformation resis- oscopic parameters based on these blackwhite images. In this
tance. A static pressure is equal to 0.2P (P means compressive strength of asphalt part, ratio of the minor axis length to the majors (using AR
Z. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 53 (2014) 665673 667
Fig. 2. Gradation curves with Taylor coordinate (x axis is equal to the power of 0.45 for the size).
Table 1
Material parameters of asphalt mixtures (20 C).
Fig. 9. Bilinear separate law and energy determination from traction. Fig. 11. Loaddisplacement curves of wet and dry surface contacts.
Z Z dmax release rate at the crack tip are mainly considerate. The main prin-
/ rdd f ddd 2 ciple of VCCT is about a fracture mechanics method, and it works
0 based on the assumption that when the crack comes out the re-
leased strain energy is the same with the energy required to close
3.2.2. Extended FEM with virtual crack closure technique the crack by the same amount.
As damage keeps growing, crack will occur and propagation
into asphalt mortar. In the realm of nonlinear nite element meth-
3.2.3. Uniaxial tension experiment for initial crack energy
od, by enriching the solution space for solutions to differential
Damage energy release rate is a key parameter for the imple-
equations with discontinuous functions, extended nite element
mentation of CZM and XFEM cooperated with VCCT, the uniaxial
method (XFEM) is developed in 1999 by Belytschko et al. [28].
tension experiment equipment was developed to account for the
Mesh free methods while alleviating their negative sides are main
impact of mesostructural aggregate (shape, angularity and texture)
advantage and development compared with FEM. A key advantage
[29], it is shown in Fig. 10. Traction fracture of adhesive interface
of XFEM is that in such problems the nite element mesh does not
and cohesive asphalt mortar is a common kind of distress type,
need to be updated to track the crack path, discontinuous basis
all numerical criteria is on the basis of traction mode. In this exper-
functions are added to standardize polynomial basis functions for
iment, some precondition should be provided to guarantee the pre-
nodes. These nodes are belonged to elements which are intersected
cision. Firstly, single size coarse aggregates (19 mm) chosen from
by a crack to provide a basis that included crack opening displace-
the same crushed aggregate plant should have similar mesostruc-
ments. Eq. (3) describes the main theory of XFEM and it is reason-
tural parameters. Secondly, a controlled line is used to make con-
able to estimate displacement of crack surface, where l(x) is
tact depth the same for each aggregate. These preparations are
approximate displacement interpolation functions, N is nodes col-
for the sake of a control of inuence factors.
lection of all regular elements, Ndisc is nodes collection of all com-
Microscopic interface is an adhesive contact and asphalt mortar
pletely cracking elements, Nasy is the nodes collection of all
bond is a cohesive type. Based on consideration of two contacts,
cracking tip elements, li means nodes of regular elements, aj
the employment of wet and dry surface is an approach to evaluate
means node of completely cracking elements and b is displacement
mechanical responses for adhesive and cohesive contacts (shown
of cracking lip elements.
in Fig. 11). After approximation and lter process of loaddisplace-
X X X a
lx Ni li Nj Hxaj Nk /a xbk 3 ment data through eight parallel tests, parameters of numerical
i2N j2N disc k2N asy models are calculated, GI in Table 2 means traction fracture energy
release rate.
Not only XFEM is conducted to simulate crack behavior of asphalt
mortar, but also virtual crack closure technique (VCCT) is imple-
mented into the crack propagation of bonding interface. VCCT is a 4. Discussion and analysis
well-known public domain post processing and remeshing tech-
nique that provides progressive crack growth between contacting All models about cohesive and XFEM with VCCT are shown in
surfaces. The fracture toughness of the bond and the strain energy Fig. 12, models bear 1 mm shear displacement load on the
Fig. 13. Mesostructural damage model calibration including DIC for IDT test.
Z. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 53 (2014) 665673 671
5. Conclusion
[10] Barksdale R, Itani S. Inuence of aggregate shape on base behavior. Trans Res [20] Cho DW, Kim K, Lee MJ. Chemical model to explain asphalt binder and
Rec 1994;1227:17182. asphaltaggregate interface behaviors. Can J Civil Eng 2010;37(1):4553.
[11] Rao C, Tutumluer E, Kim I. Quantication of coarse aggregate angularity based [21] Alvarez AE, Ovalles E, Caro S. Assessment of the effect of mineral ller on
on image analysis. Trans Res Rec 2002;1787:11724. asphaltaggregate interfaces based on thermodynamic properties. Constr
[12] Rezaei A, Masad E, Chowdhury A. Development of a model for asphalt Build Mater 2012;28(1):599606.
pavement skid resistance based on aggregate characteristics and gradation. J [22] Ministry of transport of the Peoples Republic of China. Application handbook
Trans Eng ASCE 2011;137(12):86373. of standard test methods of bitumen and bituminous mixture (JTG E202011).
[13] Gruber I, Zinovik I, Holzer L, Flisch A, et al. A computational study of the effect Beijing: China Communications Press; 2011, p. 2405.
of structural anisotropy of porous asphalt on hydraulic conductivity. Constr [23] Shao X, Shao M, Bi Y, Sun L. Testing method of asphalt mixture poisson ratio. J
Build Mater 2012;36:6677. Tongji Univ. 2006;34(11):14704.
[14] Masad E, Saadeh S, Al-Rousan T, Garboczi E, et al. Computations of particle [24] Azriel R. Picture processing by computer. New York: Academic Press; 1969. p.
surface characteristics using optical and X-ray CT images. Comput Mater Sci 150.
2005;34(4):40624. [25] Ying H. Study and application of digital image processing technique on asphalt
[15] Masad E, Muhunthan B, Shashidhar N, Harman T. Internal structure concrete. Ph.D dissertation, Chongqing Jiaotong University; 2008, p. 3940.
characterization of asphalt concrete using image analysis. J Comput Civil Eng [26] Dugdale DS. Yielding of steel sheets containing slits. J Mech Phys Solids
1999;13(2):8895. 1960;8(2):1004.
[16] Ng K, Dai Q. Investigation of fracture behavior of heterogeneous infrastructure [27] Barenblatt GI. The mathematical theory of equilibrium cracks in brittle
materials with extended-nite-element method and image analysis. J Mater fracture. Adv Appl Mech 1962;7(1):55129.
Civil Eng 2011;23(12):166271. [28] Dolbow J, Belytschko T, Belytschko Ted. A nite element method for crack
[17] Liu Y, You Z. Discrete-element modeling: impacts of aggregate sphericity, growth without remeshing. Int J Num Meth Eng 1999;46(1):13150.
orientation, and angularity on creep stiffness of idealized asphalt mixtures. J [29] Zhao L. Inuence factors and meso mechanism of asphalt pavement damages
Eng Mech ASCE 2010;137(4):294303. caused by condensate ice. Ph.D dissertation, Harbin Institute of Technology;
[18] Caro S, Masad E, Bhasin A, Little D. Micromechanical modeling of the inuence 2012, p. 8993.
of material properties on moisture-induced damage in asphalt mixtures.
Constr Build Mater 2010;24(7):118492.
[19] Fini E, Al-Qadi I. Development of a pressurized blister test for interface
characterization of aggregate highly polymerized bituminous materials. J
Mater Civil Eng 2011;23(5):65663.