You are on page 1of 53

----------------------- Page 1-----------------------

Addis Ababa University

Higher Diploma Program

HDP PORTFOLIO OF EVIDENCE

th
Round/Phase: 6

Muaz Bedru Hussen

School of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering


Addis Ababa Institute of Technology-Addis Ababa University

Higher Diploma Leader: Firdissa Jebessa (PhD)


Higher Diploma Tutor: Hailu Gutema (PhD)

Submitted to: Teaching and Learning Support Office, AAU

July, 2017

----------------------- Page 2-----------------------

Table of Contents
1.
Introduction ......................................................................
................................................................... 4

2. Reflective activities (at least the best 2 from each


module) ............................................................. 4

2.1 Module
One ...............................................................................
........................................................ 4

Reflective activity
1 .................................................................................
............................................ 4

Reflective activity
17 ................................................................................
........................................... 5

End of Module One - Self


Assessments .......................................................................
...................... 6

2.2 Module 2 - Modularization and modular


curriculum ................................................................... 7

Reflective Activity
11 ................................................................................
.......................................... 7

Reflective Activity
32 ................................................................................
.......................................... 7

End of Module Two - Self


Assessments .......................................................................
...................... 7

2.3 Module Three - Managing learning and


assessment ..................................................................... 8

Reflective Activity
16 ................................................................................
.......................................... 8

Reflective Activity
21 ................................................................................
.......................................... 8

End of Module Three - Self


Assessments .......................................................................
................... 9

2.4 Module Four - Teaching Subject Area


Module ............................................................................
10

1. Reflective Activity
1 .................................................................................
..................................... 10

2. Reflective Activity
26 ................................................................................
.................................... 11

End of Module Four - Self


Assessments .......................................................................
................... 11

2.5 Module Five - Action Research and Field-Based


Learning ........................................................ 12

1. Reflective Activity
2 .................................................................................
..................................... 12

2. Reflective Activity
3 .................................................................................
..................................... 13

End of Module Five - Self


Assessments .......................................................................
.................... 14

3. Lesson
plan ..............................................................................
.............................................................. 15

4. Assignments
set ...............................................................................
...................................................... 17

----------------------- Page 3-----------------------

5. Continuous Professional Development (CPD)


Plans ......................................................................... 22

6. Action
Research .........................................................................
........................................................... 24

7. HDLs end module


assessment.........................................................................
.................................... 42

8. Higher Diploma Leaders Final


Assessment .......................................................................
............... 43
3

----------------------- Page 4-----------------------

1. Introduction

This Portfolio consists of selected reflective activities from each module,


assignments given

at different times, action research and other related materials developed


throughout attending

the HDP program. These were produced during the 6th round HDP Program
convened from

Late 2016 to January2017.

2. Reflective activities (at least the best 2 from each module)

2.1 Module One

Reflective activity 1

What are modern day challenges of higher education? Particularly focus on the case
of Ethiopian

higher education.

Quality education provision

Resource limitation

Lack of motivated teachers

Students attitude and poor academic background


Poor time management to start class

Infrastructure

Policy

1. Discuss the specific nature of higher education compared to other educational


sectors

Higher education is a decision making center

Higher education are more problem solving sectors focusing on research and
community

service

Higher education are centers where independent problem soling skills are
improved

2. Higher education

Focus on local capacity development of professionals for industry demand

Form task force responsible for identification of real world problems

----------------------- Page 5-----------------------

Strengthen industry university linkage unit in terms of provision


of seed money for

researchers engaged in industrial problem solving projects

Reflective activity 17

1. Discuss the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities ratified


by Ethiopia?

What are the key aspects of conventions?

The UN conventions on the Rights of persons with Disabilities


(CRPD) is the first

international legally binding human rights treaty targeted at protecting


the human rights

of people with disabilities. Key aspects of this convention are:

o The right to be protected from abuse, violence, and torture.

o The right to have access to education, transportation and


other public services
o The right to access information and communication including
via sign language

or Braille.

o The right to employment and decent standard of living

o The right to access social justice

2. To what extent do you think the AAU community wants to facilitate


the education of

students with disabilities

AAU basically provides disability specific provision for most categories


of disabilities.

The AAU communities have good experience of facilitating the


education of disabled

students.

3. What are the actions taken by the university to include students


with disabilities in the

system?

The university designed curriculum suitable for most of disability


types, which is

students have opportunity to join AAU. In addition to this, disability


specific provisions

are relatively good at AAU. The resource provision for hearing


and visual impairment

and the university needs to improve this issue.

----------------------- Page 6-----------------------

End of Module One - Self Assessments

HDP CANDIDATE'S SELF-ASSESSMENT MODULE ONE

What have you found most useful in this Module?

Reflective teaching part in this module is most useful part in my view. In this
module I have
acquired knowledge and basic understandings on the following points

a. Deep tacit knowledge(our own knowledge)Process of


transformation(research

thinking)Explicit knowing (our action in the world)

b. Learning domains :

Cognitive domain : objectives skills that make


up understanding and

concept formation

Affective domains : objectives that deal with


interactions and attitudes,

appreciation values and emotional sets or basis

Psychomotor domain

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this


Module.

I attended all the classes, participated in group discussion and performed all the
activities
required in this module

How would you evaluate your overall performance in this Module ? Please circle what
you should

receive

PASS or REFERRED

Answer: PASS

----------------------- Page 7-----------------------

2.2 Module 2 - Modularization and modular curriculum

Reflective Activity 11

1. Discuss the practice

In interactive study, the instructor meet students to introduce overall


things, but in
independent learning, students perform most activities independently. In
collaborative
learning, instructor meets students in small group

2. What are the challenges in determining the delivery of the modular


curriculum?

Deciding the type of learning style would be a challenge in determining


the delivery of
modular curriculum because different discipline have different nature.

3. The delivery of a modular curriculum could be either in block teaching or


in non-block

teaching. Discuss your experience in connection with these modes of


delivery.

Most of the courses in my field are designed for non-block teaching mode
because of the
nature of courses and program duration.

Reflective Activity 32

1. Discuss the importance of planning in your teaching?

Plans provide and maintain a sense of direction and instructor


confidence in teaching.
It helps to accomplish an activity on time.

2. What do you think are the factors that affect planning in AAU?

Inconsistent academic calendar

Dalliance on class start

Frequent black outs in electricity that affects lecture activity

End of Module Two - Self Assessments

What have you found most useful in this Module?

- The concept of Modularization and Modular Curriculum

----------------------- Page 8-----------------------

- Credit System considering student work load

- Lesson planning

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this


Module

I have attended the class discussion and got a thorough understanding of


the module. I have
exercised all the reflective activities and homework, assignments given by HDL

How would you evaluate your overall performance in this Module? Please
circle what you

should receive:

PASS or REFER

Answer: PASS

2.3 Module Three - Managing learning and assessment

Reflective Activity 16

1. Have you used these methods to asses the contribution of individual group
members? If

yes, which method(s)? Please state your experience and present to the HDP
team.

Yes I have used. I use oral tests in a form of group work presentation and
asking
questions for each member of group from the document they produced.

2. Do you think that is practical/feasible to use these methods in


most Addis Ababa

University classrooms?

Yes, because it helps to evaluate the students based on the report as well
as their response
to questions asked.

Reflective Activity 21

1. When should feedback given to students? Why?

Feedback should be given as soon as possible because it will help students


realize where
they have done well and indicate what they should improve on.

----------------------- Page 9-----------------------

2. What is the difference between immediate and delayed feedback?

Immediate feedback helps students to improve their performance before


final assessment
is over where as delayed feedback will not give time for
students to improve their
deficiency ahead of final assessment.

3. How detailed does feedback have to be?


Feedback should clarify the students work, it should value what is done,
and it should
include the concern and finally suggest future efforts needed.

4. Should it be oral or written? Which of these is more effective?

Feedback should be both oral and written but written feedback would be
more effective
because students will be able to revise it while trying to improve their
work.

5. What is the feedback policy/guideline of Addis Ababa University?

The AAU Senate Legislation obliges the instructor to give feedback on


students work as
soon as possible (within one week of exam administration).

6. What is your experience of providing feedback? Do you think you have


benefited from

this practice?

I provide timely feedback to students according to the university


guideline and it helped
me assist students to improve their weakness and justify my assessment
procedure.

End of Module Three - Self Assessments

What have you found most useful in this Module?

All contents covered in this module are equally important but I found learning
assessment and

grading to be most useful part

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this


Module.

I thoroughly understood learning principle, active learning methods, learning


assessment and

grading, consideration during student advisement and support.

Would you say that for your overall performance in this Module you should receive a

----------------------- Page 10-----------------------

PASS or REFER?

Answer: PASS

2.4 Module Four - Teaching Subject Area Module


1. Reflective Activity 1

Teachers' belief about the subject matter knowledge (SMK)

1. First, indicate your belief as a teacher by putting a tick mark in the table
below. Then, sit in

a group of three and discuss your individual reactions with that of others in
the group.

No Opinions Agree
Disagree Not decided

1 We cannot teach what we do not know ourselves.

2 If we know it, we can teach it.

3 Pedagogues Folly, insufficient knowledge of

subject matter
4 If we say the subject matter, we have taught it.

5 If they hear the subject matter, they have learned it.

6 Teachers must have solid foundation in the subject

matters they plan to teach.


7 Teachers should continue to learn subject matter

throughout their careers.


8 For a teacher, both knowledge of subject matter

and knowledge of teaching the subject matter


(pedagogical knowledge) are essential.
9 Pedagogical knowledge is more important than the

subject matter knowledge for teaching purposes.


10 Anyone who aspires to become a teacher must be

trained with teaching methods such as that of Post


Graduate Diploma in Teaching Program( PGDT)
in Ethiopian after completing his/her training in
subject matter or disciplinary area
11 Good teachers are born; they do not need any

training in teaching methods.

2. Write brief answers to the following questions.

1. Can you give the best definition of the subject you teach? Please
try.

10
----------------------- Page 11-----------------------

Heat transfer is a branch of physical science that deals with transfer


of energy due to
temperature difference by different mechanisms.
2. Have differences been observed across time among definition of your
subject matter,

for example in the past and at present?

Yes, because the subject by itself is dynamic in nature so that


different innovations in
the field enrich its definition.
3. If there can be changes in the definitions of the subject matter you
teach, how would

you explain those changes?

These changes are due to new concepts and advancement on mechanisms as


well as
emerging application areas.

2. Reflective Activity 26

Now take a course from your area and write down three learning outcomes:

My subject area or course title: Refrigeration and Air Conditioning

1. Learning outcome one (knowledge area):

Students will be able to define cooling load

Students will be able to explain the need for ventilation

2. Learning outcome two (skills area):

Students will be able to calculate different heat loads

Students will have a capacity to conduct experiment on cooling


and heating

process

3. Learning outcome three (attitude area):

Students will be able to justify the need for air conditioning


of a given space

Students will have a capacity to verify that experimental result


is valid

End of Module Four - Self Assessments

What have you found most useful in this Module?

- I found active learning instructional strategies in subject matter teaching


as most useful part

in this module.

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this


Module?

11

----------------------- Page 12-----------------------

- I improved my knowledge of subject area teaching through class discussion and


independent

study

How would you evaluate your overall performance in this Module?

- My overall performance in this module is very good.

Please circle on what you should receive: PASS or REFER

Answer: PASS

2.5 Module Five - Action Research and Field-Based Learning

1. Reflective Activity 2

1. What makes action research different from conventional academic research?

Action research is best defined on page 6 of Module 5, of course there are many
definitions but

in my opinion I prefer the one by (Reason and Bradbury, 2001); Action


research is a

participatory, democratic process concerned with developing practical knowing in


the pursuit of

worthwhile human purposes, grounded in a participatory worldview, which we


believe, is

emerging at this historical moment. It seeks to bring together action and


reflection, theory and

practice, in participation with others, in the pursuit of practical solutions to


issues of pressing

concern to people, and more generally the flourishing of individual


persons and their

communities.

Also, Action research is a strategy educators can use to study educational issues,
implement change

and develop professional competency while field-based learning allows to practice


teaching- learning

in real world contexts rather than only in classrooms from textbooks, which
convectional research

mainly is focused with. Conventional research is limited to literature


reviews, theoretical

disunions, conclusions from the theoretical results. The action and self-reflection
part is omitted

as a custom especially in our country. Hence, Action research is an eye opening


practice that we

should practice.

2. Look at the expression below and identify the characterizing features of action
research.

12

----------------------- Page 13-----------------------

Action research is research into practice, by practitioners, for practitioners.


In action research,

all actors involved in the research process are equal participants, and must be
involved in every

stage of the research. The kind of involvement required is collaborative


involvement. It requires

a special kind of communication, which has been described


as symmetrical

communication which allows all participants to be partners of communication on


equal terms.

Collaborative participation in theoretical, practical and political discourse is


thus a hallmark of

action research and the action researcher (Grundy and Kemmis,1988).

Characterizing features from the above statements made by (Grundy and Kemmis,
1988).

Action research is research into practice, by practitioners, for


practitioners

All actors are equal participants at each stage of the research

Collaborative involvement is highly required

Symmetrical communication which allows all participants


to be partners of
communication on equal terms is necessary in action research

3. Who do you think should conduct action research? Why?

Conducting action research is important because it seeks to bring together action


and reflection,

theory and practice, in participation with others, in the pursuit of practical


solutions to issues of

pressing concern to people, and more generally the flourishing of individual


persons and their

communities.

2. Reflective Activity 3

Which of these types of action research do you think would be more useful
particularly to your

area? How?

Practical type of action research is particularly important for my area which is


engineering, this

improves practitioners understanding and transformation of their


consciousness also Socratic

role enables the facilitator in encouraging participation and self-reflection of


his/her own method

of delivery or even in further enhancement of the subject matter.

13

----------------------- Page 14-----------------------

End of Module Five - Self Assessments

General Observations;

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this


Module

In this module I have learnt the following very important lessons that I must
follow in future

Recognize that teaching-learning needs to be task-oriented and


innovative;

Design a course delivery that integrates Action Research and Field-based


Learning;

Contribute to the improvement of current educational practices through


Action Research
and Field-based Learning activities;

Recognize that it is possible to achieve


partnership, relevance, flexibility, and

accreditation in higher education provided Action Research and Field-


based Learning are

integrated.

Would you say that for your overall performance in the HDP you should
receive a PASS or

REFER/

Answer: PASS

14

----------------------- Page 15-----------------------

3. Lesson plan

Date 21-01-2017 Level


B.S Degree Program

Learning Area Heat Transfer Topic:


Introduction to Modes of Heat Transfer

Strand Heat Transfer

Learning Students will be equipped with the basic principles


required for understanding conduction,
Outcomes radiation and convection heat transfer.

Lesson By the end of this lesson, students should be able to:


Objectives
Describe what heat transfer is and what the three basic
forms of heat transfer are

Describe heat versus temperature

Timing Learning & teaching strategies Key teaching


points Equipment/resources

10 minutes Lecture Introduction:


Text Books, power points
Definition of heat
and videos.
transfer and
Temperature
gradient,

30 minutes The instructor gives lecture, Conduction:


Occurs Same as above
guides and moderates the due to
thermal
students. gradient
across
stationary
medium
The instructor will help the
(solid or
fluid)
students to clearly visualize

Representative
problems and show methods Example
to tackle them.

Students are expected to


participate actively in the

class during group


discussion and by asking
and solving problems.
30 minutes Same as above Convection:
Occurs Same as above
due to temperature

difference between
a
surface and a
moving
fluid

Representative
Example:

15

----------------------- Page 16-----------------------


30 minutes Same as above
Radiation(thermal): Same as above
Net heat
transfer due to
emissions
between
surfaces

Representative
Example:

15 minutes Same as above Relevance


of heat Same as above
transfer

5 minutes Lecture Conclusion:

Summarizing
main
points

Assessment of Briefly describe heat Self-


evaluation:
learning and transfer What went
well? Why?
teaching: What are the three modes of What didnt
go as well?
heat transfer? Why? What
will I do
What three things do you next time?

think heat depends on?


How do you think heat and
temperature are related?
Notes for next Conduction rate equation:

lesson Fourier law

16

----------------------- Page 17-----------------------

4. Assignments set
Four assignments were considered for evaluation by HDP leader regardless
of different home

works given during training. All assignment were submitted in class and
returned to me after

correction

Assignment one on HDP Training

Questions:

Which areas (skills, knowledge, and personal qualities) do you want to improve and
why?

Outline how you plan to do this and when

I understand that skills, knowledge and personal qualities are very important
things that a good

teacher needs to have. I believe that I have sufficient background on most of


skill, knowledge

and personal quality contents mentioned in question number 1. However I need to


improve my

career on some of the skill areas like pedagogical skill and reflective skills plus
knowledge of

pedagogy and knowledge of pupils under knowledge improvement part.

The reason why I need to improve these areas is because I believe that I need to
fill the gap I

have at this on areas I mentioned above. For instance pedagogical skill provides a
teacher with

means of combining instructional techniques with subject matter. Skill like


creation and selection

of teaching methods, presentation skills and use of technologies, learning


activities, student

groupings classroom management, evaluation and instruction materials are among


pedagogical

skills that I expect improvement from my side and that is why I identified those
things as areas of

interest for improvement. Skills and practices for systematic, purposeful


inquiry and critical

reflection to analyze my ways of teaching about learning to teach are also among
reflective skills

that I need improvement.

Knowledge of pedagogy is also part of area I mentioned to be improved to connect


students and

subject matter in meaningful ways. I need to develop a pedagogical


bearing in knowledge of

adolescent development and learning. Knowledge of pupils that I mentioned


to be improved

from my side deals with understanding the linkages between developments,


knowledge and

learning to support all aspects of a students learning and development.

17

----------------------- Page 18-----------------------

I planned to improve those mentioned skills and knowledge areas through successful
completion

of this higher diploma program training. In addition I will


improve these things by

implementation in my classroom. Most importantly, I plan to update myself


continuously on

pedagogical knowledge and skill areas to become successful teacher.

HDP Training Assignment Two

Question:

Consider a module that you are teaching currently, or imagine one that
you will teach in the

future. Allot ECTS considering student workload, the learning outcomes and
competencies to be

achieved at the end. Then list all student activities that will add up
as the student workload.

Again allot hours to each student activity and justify it with reason. Write your
own assessment

of the time allotted. Then request other participants to assess your time
allotment.

Solution:

The module I considered is a Heat Transfer, a module for the course I am teaching
at school of

Mechanical & industrial engineering this time. This module has 5 ECTS credits which
requires

5x27=135 hours of study. The activities and hours allotted are shown in table
below.

No. Item (Major Activities) Hours Required


%

1 For attending lectures 30


22.2

2 For Design Project work 20


14.8

3 For Laboratory work 15


11.1

4 For Tutorial and problem 30


22.2
solving sessions

5 For continuous and final 5


3.7
assessment

6 For Group Assignments 15


11.1

7 For Independent study 20


14.8

Total 135
100

18

----------------------- Page 19-----------------------

The hour allotted for each activity is based on the contact hour requirement for
each activity (i.e.

lecture, Lab, Tutorial) per week and project work, assignment, and
independent study are

decided based on sample proportion on HDP manual.

Assignment 3 Lesson Plan Preparations

HDP Training Assignment Three

Lesson Plan

Date 21-01-2017 Level


B.S Degree Program

Learning Area Heat Transfer Topic:


Introduction to Modes of Heat Transfer

Strand Heat Transfer

Learning Students will be equipped with the basic principles


required for understanding conduction,
Outcomes radiation and convection heat transfer.

Lesson By the end of this lesson, students should be able to:


Objectives
Describe what heat transfer is and what the three basic
forms of heat transfer are

Describe heat versus temperature

Timing Learning & teaching strategies Key teaching


points Equipment/resources

10 minutes Lecture Introduction:


Text Books, power points
Definition of heat
and videos.
transfer and
Temperature
gradient,

30 minutes The instructor gives lecture, Conduction:


Occurs Same as above
guides and moderates the due to
thermal
students. gradient
across
stationary
medium
The instructor will help the
(solid or
fluid)
students to clearly visualize

Representative
problems and show methods Example
to tackle them.

Students are expected to


participate actively in the

class during group

19

----------------------- Page 20-----------------------

discussion and by asking


and solving problems.
30 minutes Same as above Convection:
Occurs Same as above
due to
temperature
difference
between a
surface and a
moving
fluid

Representative

Example:

30 minutes Same as above


Radiation(thermal): Same as above
Net heat
transfer due to
emissions
between
surfaces

Representative

Example:

15 minutes Same as above Relevance of


heat Same as above
transfer

5 minutes Lecture Conclusion:

Summarizing
main
points

Assessment of Briefly describe heat Self-


evaluation:
learning and transfer What went
well? Why?
teaching: What are the three modes of What didnt go
as well?
heat transfer? Why? What will
I do
What three things do you next time?
think heat depends on?
How do you think heat and
temperature are related?
Notes for next Conduction rate equation:

lesson Fourier law


20

----------------------- Page 21-----------------------

Assignment 4 Module 4 page 55

Reflective activity 32:

This activity was performed in class room discussion in group and the compiled
response of our
group is taken as final answer.

Please find detailed descriptions of the following active learning strategies? Show
how you apply
them in your classroom?

Concept tests

This part of active learning strategy is telling the hypothesis and fundamental
thought of the
content to be thought. Using cognitive theory at this part is advisable in my
opinion.

Purposive questions

Raise questions to students about the content aiming enhanced step by step
learning. Students
will be pipelined to the core content of the subject through designed questions.

Classroom demonstrations

Specific to engineering disciple classroom demonstration is rarely performed as the

demonstration scale is usually impossible at class room levels and separate


demonstration rooms,
laboratories and workshops are available. However after the classroom discussion,
students will
be taken to those laboratory or practical demonstration rooms. The teacher will
clearly show the
procedures, guidelines prior to leaving it for students demonstration.

Short in-class writings

Usually the short in class writings are for social science and medical schools
students as far as I
understand, in engineering classes analytical problem tutorial classes are common
and the results
of analytical problems will be interpreted physically. The implication of the
result from the
practical aspect will be viewed and discussions on whether the solution can
actually be
implemented or not will be evaluated.
Subject matter warm ups/ ice-breakers

Subject related previous experiences either on sites or in classes could be used as


an ice breaker

Humor/joke of the day

21

----------------------- Page 22-----------------------

Subject related funny jokes that has been done on field works, common funny
mistakes in classes
or fields that students usually face or any could be used in class. Jokes may not
be limited to
subject matter however. In my opinion any funny joke that will not affect the moral
of the
students or learning in general can be used in classes when necessary.

Relating the topic to current events

Subject matter current status especially with the growth of technological


innovations will better
impress students and increase their motivation to know about the content more. Some

technologies are old but the basic science impact on the recent advancement could
be highlighted
to the students as a chronological technological history aspects.

Compare and contrast traditional lectures with

The active learning strategy is more effective and makes students closer
to their teacher.
Learning will be much more enhanced and change of attitude will be observed.

In the traditional lectures usually the teacher talks and the students listen
without any significant
activity. This will make the students to be expectants from the teacher alone
rather than digging
by themselves. Independent learning strategy will not be achieved in this regard.

5. Continuous Professional Development (CPD) Plans

In the areas of Science and Engineering we have been taught in Module


IV about specific
pedagogies across disciplines, hence for engineering students or Instructors as a
general principle
for their continuous professional development the following requirements are
necessary

Laboratory/practical classes and workshops play a major role in


the education of
experimental scientists. In this environment students learn to be
scientists or engineers and
develop professional skills and attitudes. Sciences are applied subj ects and
academics see this
practical experience as vital and nonnegotiable. Such
learning experiences are very
expensive in terms of staff time, support staff, consumable materials and
equipment. They
are vital for the development of practical and, discipline specific
skills. They are also
important in providing rich opportunities for the development of intellectual
and transferrable
skills. Although students are carrying out an investigation or
producing a design, the
learning objectives for practical sessions are usually much broader and
might include the
following.
Gain practical skills;
Gain experience of particular techniques or pieces of equipment;
Produce a design;
Plan an experiment;

22

----------------------- Page 23-----------------------

Make links between theory and practice;


Gather, manipulate and interpret data;
Make observations;
Form and test hypotheses;
Use judgment;
Develop problem solving skills;
Communicate data and concepts;
Develop personal skills;
Develop ICT skills;
Develop safe working practices;
Motivate and enthuse students;
Simulate professional practice

6. Report on field based learning or Reflective Activity 19 in Module 5.

This assignment is replaced with Assignment 4 Module 4 page 55, Reflective activity
32
23

----------------------- Page 24-----------------------

6. Action Research

Pedagogical Knowledge of Engineering Professionals in Ethiopian Higher

Education Technology Institutions:

Case study: Addis Ababa University-Addis Ababa Institute of Technology

Higher Diploma Program

By: Yilma Tadesse, (PhD)

Muaz Bediru, (MSc)

Araya Abera, (MSc)


24

----------------------- Page 25-----------------------

Chapter - 1

Background and Introduction

1. Background

Engineering education is the most challenging task that


engineering educators face.

Understanding and comprehending the concept of the subject for the


learners and ineffective

methodologies or ways of addressing the subject by the educators are the


two most common

challenges that engineering educators face unlike non engineering educators


and learners. In

addition to the above mentioned challenges, the time required to


comprehend one issue of

engineering concept and its application in an integrated system makes it more


complicated. Also

in a defined curriculum systems where Ethiopian education system adopted from


foreign which

is designed with full teaching facilities, ours with less education facility
systems will be more

challenging. One of the reasons that Ethiopian engineers are less productive
towards following

an up-to-date technological system and innovation is its poor education towards


addressing the
core concepts to the learners. Yet, individual efforts by the learners are still
making changes in

some aspects. However, nationwide impact by the majority of engineering


graduates is not

observed until now, change is necessary and engineering students should be more
benefited from

the education system or method.

Several other countries such as India and China have addressed this
issue to improve their

engineering education system, which will be addressed in the coming literature


review session.

The main objective of this action research is to look for ways of improvement of
the existing

teaching methodology with respect to pedagogical enhancement. Although


there are several

factors that affect the engineering education system such as equipment and lab
facilities, yet with

the existing available resource it is possible to enhance the educators


pedagogical skill.

1.1 Statement of the Problem

It is already well known that pedagogical knowledge has a paramount


importance to deliver

knowledge of any science and to communicate students in the class room


properly. However

25

----------------------- Page 26-----------------------

studies show that knowledge of pedagogy among teachers of higher education in


Ethiopia found

very poor especially among teachers of physical and hard sciences.

As a result, in addition to other factors, quality of education in Ethiopia


deteriorating from time
to time because of lack of pedagogical knowledge among teachers to
deliver their academic

knowledge to their students.

Therefore, examining pedagogical knowledge of engineering professionals may help to


identify

their states and to provide policy related recommendation to the university


management.

1.3 Objective

1. To assess awareness and views of engineering professionals on


the importance of

pedagogical science

2. To examine pedagogical knowledge of Teachers in the Addis Ababa


Institute of

Technology

1.4 Research Question

1 What is the awareness level and views of engineering professionals on the


importance of

pedagogical science?

2. What is the pedagogical knowledge of Teachers in the Institute of


Technology?
26

----------------------- Page 27-----------------------

Chapter -2

Literature review

Several articles have been written regarding engineering education improvement


strategies from

different perspectives, Tharwat M, et al, have studied Pedagogical Innovations and


Engineering

Students Perceptions of the Relevance of an English for Engineering Course, [1]


and they have

found that cross-sectional study of junior, senior and graduate engineering


students assesses their

perceptions of an English for engineering course, focusing mainly on communication


skills, that

they have successfully completed. A survey comprising multiple choice


questions and open-

ended questions shows significantly positive attitudes towards the course


contents. This study

also identified differences in students perceptions of the English for engineering


course by year

of study and gender. The perceptions of graduate students are more positive than
those indicated

by junior and senior students. Female respondents show a higher mean


than males regarding

overall course contents relevance. While cohort effects may be present, it seems
that perceptions

are highly positive, becoming more so when students find themselves in a situation
where they

have to use the skills learned from the course.

On another parameter which is Information technology (IT) usage for


engineering educators

Elisabeth Saalman at Chalmers University of Technology has studied


Engineering education
teachers pedagogical use of digital media shown in projects carried out in a
Higher education

course: Learning in Digital Media,[2]. This paper tells about experiences


and conclusions of

giving a higher education course Learning in Digital Media to


teachers at Chalmers

University of technology. Though it is at Chalmers since the nature of the course


is similar we at

Addis Ababa University would be benefited from such scripts as such, the
main question of

interest in Elisabeth study is how engineering education teachers choose


to use IT with

pedagogical aims to support teaching and student learning. The learning objectives
in the course

Learning in digital media is to give opportunity to the participating


teachers to develop their

courses and create stimulating learning environments in order to support


their teaching and

student learning. In the course the teachers work with individual


projects using digital media

27

----------------------- Page 28-----------------------

with pedagogical purpose to support student learning. In this research which is at


Chalmers the

following important discussions have been observed:

It seems clear from experiences giving the higher education course learning in
digital media for

several years that motivation is necessary to get high quality in teachers


projects and learning.

The importance of attitudes, personal goals, engagement and willingness to


participate in a

learning community is crucial. The emotions are important and it is a good idea to
put effort in

order to create an open, positive, trusty, creative atmosphere among the teachers.
Key concepts

are collegiality and transparency in getting a mutual learning environment with


ongoing dialogue
and feedback to each other. Learning and knowledge-building takes place
when you reflect

together with colleagues and uses the knowledge to solve real, authentic problems.

However it is not simple and obvious to all of teachers to start to use IT in


teaching and learning.

To many teachers it is a rather huge threshold to overcome to start


using e-learning/blended

learning. Everyone do not have a high level of knowledge concerning the


use of educational

technique, regarding IT and digital media in teaching and learning. Teachers


sometimes report

about their insecurity and hesitation to start to use IT and digital


media. They also tell about

technical problems and administrative problems using digital media.


Negative comments

concerning new technique often is about bad user interface and non-intuitive
interaction design.

In addition teachers may feel insecurity, hesitation, obstacles to start to use IT


in teaching and

learning and may have negative attitudes towards using IT. It might be a good idea
to engage

students as co-workers in planning for using IT since students often have a very
natural attitude

and are familiar with the technique and virtual communication compared to many of
the today

teachers. IT in teaching and learning is today a natural part of the


overall pedagogy used in

university courses/education but the use varies a lot.

It seems natural to take advantage of the impact of scholarship of teaching on the


educational

development at universities also concerning learning technology, blended


learning and online

pedagogy. Scholarship of teaching and learning is important in order to


reflect and share

experiences among colleagues in higher education and to take


advantage of academic

pedagogical dialogue. Startup of, and establishment of, collegial pedagogical


discussions that are

28

----------------------- Page 29-----------------------

regarded as tempting and developing could help meeting tomorrows needs


and demands on

teaching and learning. The aim is to create an ongoing, valuable dialogue among
academic staff

in order to support organizational development, both individual and


collective competence

development. There is a great need for documentation and evaluation of


web based course

curriculum [3]. There is more research needed addressing pedagogical design [4].
More research

effort is needed concerning parameters influencing student learning


in virtual learning

environments. The students need to be asked about their expectations on


online courses, how

they learn, how they experience using IT and digital media, how they
experience virtual

communication, teamwork and online assessment. What meaningful interactivity there


actually is

for the students and how to bring about good virtual communication. One
possibility, suitable to

teachers, is to use the action research approach to study what happens with respect
to classroom

situation and learning while using digital media and blended learning. It is
important to view also

the administrative aspects of learning technology from a pedagogical point


of view [5]. The

administration have importance for what role you get in for example a learning
platform and thus

for what you can do in the platform and how you behave. This influences the
interactivity, how

you work together with other participants, how people collaborate and
communicate. A huge
task, in this very rapidly changing digital era, will also be the test
and evaluation of new

technology in order to find good user-friendly technique and to find good


pedagogical use of the

technique.

Another study by Manoj J.D. et al, [6] which is on Extreme Pedagogy:


An Agile Teaching-

Learning Methodology for Engineering Education stated that Traditional


instructor-centered,

lecture-based teaching methods in engineering education have been


criticized for being too

linear, dogmatic, systematic and constraining. And the study proposes


Extreme Pedagogy, a

student-centered teaching-learning conceptual framework to improve quality


of engineering

education which is built on four core values: students and teachers and
their interactions,

working knowledge, collaboration with students and responding to change. Extreme


Pedagogy

derives its philosophy from Extreme Programming, an agile software


methodology. Extreme

Pedagogy aims at continuous improvement of student learning, keeping


students needs and

satisfaction as its focus. In its conclusion the study summarizes much


of the teaching in

29

----------------------- Page 30-----------------------

engineering colleges is lecture based and teacher-centered. Faculty members are


over concerned

with completing the pre-designed syllabus, without giving sufficient attention to


students needs,

learning styles, learning pace, learning outcomes etc.

Students turn out to be passive listeners, memorize the subject content to get good
grades in the

exams without actually developing skills needed. Extreme pedagogy shifts focus from
teacher-

centered instruction to student-centered instruction, from teaching to


learning. As a learner-

centered pedagogy, its focus is on the students, student learning,


student satisfaction, student

motivation. Unlike traditional pedagogies, which are rigid and inflexible, extreme
pedagogy is

flexible and adaptable to cater to students needs always. Extreme


pedagogy is a novel

framework for teaching and learning in engineering education. Its concepts and
practices can be

easily implemented in classroom teaching in engineering colleges. Its core


practices are drawn

from XP, [7] (Extreme Programming (XP) which is one of the most
popular agile software

development methodologies has become very successful in the software


industry developing

high quality software in response to the changing requirements of the customer.)


and mapped to

the best practices in existing teaching learning methodologies in education.


Extreme pedagogy

framework intends to bring about innovation in the classroom teaching. Its main
purpose is to

improve the quality of learning in engineering education and address many of the
limitations of

the traditional teaching-learning methods.

Atasi Mohanty, et.al, in their study for India professional engineering


educators preparation

scenario,[8] have also highlighted the need for technical faculty to


learn the innovative

approaches to teaching and learning, which in turn will require


effective professional

development for both new and experienced instructors alike. In 21st


century, engineering

education requires meeting the demands of technical profession and


emerging job market.
Researchers have found some universally preferred, yet challenging skills for
global workforce,

e.g., science, technology, engineering and math (STEM), statistics and data
analysis skills, are of

the topmost priority. Ethiopian engineering professionals and engineering


students need to

upgrade themselves for this world work force competition besides filling
the gap in class

teaching and learning with improved pedagogical aspects. From the


current government

30

----------------------- Page 31-----------------------

strategies which is 70-30 policy, most graduates are engineers whom besides
satisfying the need

for local work force, Ethiopian engineers could learn a lesson from
countries such as India,

China and Nigeria for a possible export of engineering educators to neighboring


countries and

elsewhere in the world. It is customary that Ethiopians have high


reputation in academics in

several higher Intuitions of the West, most of them are renowned


professors and technical

personnels. Hence, it is time that we need to upgrade our engineering


education system with

better pedagogical skills. Coming to this action research, questionaries


are prepared for both

learners and educators setting some key parameters that would improve the
pedagogical skills of

the educators.
31

----------------------- Page 32-----------------------

Chapter -3

Research Methodology

3.1 Research Design and Methodology

The very focus of this study was assessment of teacher awareness and views about
issues related

to pedagogical knowledge. This study used both quantitative and


qualitative approaches. The

design applied for this mixed approach study was cross-sectional since
the study relies on

existing variations and data collection was at one point in time.


3.1.1 Source and nature of the data

In this study, primary and secondary methods of data gathering were made
to address the

formulated objectives so far. The secondary information was collected from library
books and on

line searches about issues related pedagogical science. The primary data
were collected from

institute of technology at Addis Ababa University.

3.1.2 Sampling Techniques and sampling population

The selection of sampling techniques for the study was based on the
representative-ness and

resourceful-ness of the sample. Therefore, in order to collect a wide


range of and in depth

information for the study from selected lecturers, the researcher


used stratified random

techniques. Therefore, the researcher collected data from 60 randomly


selected teachers of

school of mechanical & Industrial engineering.

3.1.3 Data collection instrument and its Preparation

This study employed both qualitative and quantitative research approach in


order to touch

important aspects of the situation. Therefore, it used multiple data


collection tools such as

questioner, interview and observation which serve as a data collection instrument.


The researcher

believes that this approach helps to substantiate or support the information


collected using one

instrument by another. To gather a data one instrument were developed to


assess teachers

awareness of and views about issues related to pedagogical science:


attitude scale. The

32
----------------------- Page 33-----------------------

instrument was constructed on the bases of extensive review of literature,


referring text books

and related studies that were made so fare.

3.1.4 Attitude scale

The attitude scale had two parts, the cover page that contained the first part
requested personal

information of teachers like sex, academic rank, and year of experience, e.t.c.,
and second part

contain 12 moderate statements and agreement for all statement means the
participant have a

positive attitude towards pedagogical education and HDP training.

3.1.5 Administration of instruments

The questioner was circulated in a separate offices and data was


gathered from each office

together with interview session.

3.1.6 Methods of Data Analysis.

Data were computed and analyzed using a number of techniques. Percentage


was used to

summaries results. And basically data was analyzed using qualitative method called
description.
33

----------------------- Page 34-----------------------

Chapter 4

Data presentation and Discussion

4.1 Pedagogical Science as a Breakthrough to Improve Educational Quality

Lecturers who participate in this study showed a very strong attitude


towards, up-to-date

knowledge its access and public policy related to pedagogical science to improve
the scientific

communication of teachers with their students. On the other hand teachers


demonstrated

apparently strong attitude towards HDP to improve their teaching skill and
ultimately to improve

educational quality in their respective schools.

About three forth of teachers agreed that The teaching profession in this country
need to have

up-to-date knowledge for teaching 21st century skills (W1). About 8 % of


teachers however do

not associate problem of educational quality with pedagogical science knowledge


deficit

code Statement

W1 The teaching profession in this country need to have up-to-


date knowledge for

teaching 21st century skills

W2 Technology institute teachers need to have access to new


knowledge from the
Science of Learning about how students learn

W3 Attending HDP class is very helpful for professional career of the


teachers

W4 Our country need to have public policies that can be


developed to facilitate the

teaching profession in keeping its pedagogical knowledge current and


up-to-date

The very surprising result that has been identified in this study was, technology
institute teachers

believe that, pedagogical science has a vital importance for


their professional carrier

development. Here 64 percent of participants of this pity research


responded that, Attending

HDP class is very helpful for professional career of the teachers. This shows
whenever there is a

proper and continuous in-job professional capacity building programs,


university te chnology

institute teachers have a positive attitude towards getting and participating on


those programs.

34

----------------------- Page 35-----------------------

Table 4.1:- Lectures view about importance of


general pedagogical science for

improvement of educational quality (figures are in percent)

No Items Scale

I II III IV
V I+II VI+V
1 W1 60 24 8 4
4 84 8

2 W2 64 18 4 8
6 82 14

3 W3 32 32 16 12
8 64 20
4 W4 32 36 12 6
14 68 20
Source: Compiled from own survey, 2017

About two third of the participants strongly agree or agree for policy
formulation to develop

scientific knowledge of university lectures in order to have educational quality


in this county.

With this regard 68 percent of the participants said Our country needs to have
public policies

that can be developed to facilitate the teaching profession in keeping its


pedagogical knowledge

current and up-to-date. Actually on this regard, every stakeholder needs


to work to create

awareness creation on the issue. Because even on this study about 30 percent of the
participants

are neutral or dont agree with the issue of policy formulation and
continuous professional

development teachers.

4.2 Pedagogical Tools to Disseminate Knowledge in the Class Room

In the ongoing quest to improve the quality of student learning and academic
teaching, change

and innovation in higher education continue to proliferate and are now


commonplace in

pedagogical rhetoric (Findlow 2008). What is uncommon, and much more difficult to
achieve, is

sustained improvement and systemic change across program, department and


institutional

boundaries. The necessity to successfully translate and reproduce improvements in


learning and

teaching into new contexts, beyond the local site of origin, relies
strongly on effective use of

pedagogical tools to dissemination knowledge (Coburn 2003; McKenzie et al. 2005;


Southwell

et al. 2005).

35
----------------------- Page 36-----------------------

In this regard assessing pedagogical tools of lecturers to disseminate


knowledge in the class

room has a paramount importance.

code Statement

W5 Using familiar examples to explain concepts related to the subject


matter is helpful
for students

W6 I use multimedia or technology (e.g. PowerPoint) to express the


concept of subject.

W7 I Cleary explain the objective of the course and the chapter in the
class room

W8 I consider classroom context appropriately.

Statement (W5) that says Using familiar examples to explain concepts


related to the subject

matter is helpful for students got the support of about 56 percent of the
participants. Actually it

is very amazing to find even 4 percent of teacher who oppose providing different
examples and

option to clarify concepts in the classroom.

This view was reinforced by their response to I use multimedia or technology (e.g.
PowerPoint)

to express the concept of subject got the agreement of nearly 80 percent of the
total participants.

Here teachers strongly do have positive views towards clarity of explaining


objective of a lesson

before starting the class on one hand and considering classroom context on the
other.

Table 4.2:- Tools used by teachers to disseminate knowledge in the class room

No Items Scale

I II III
IV V I+II VI+V
1 W5 66 30 4
0 0 96 0
2 W6 46 32 8
8 6 78 14
3 W7 68 24 8
0 0 92 0

4 W8 30 38 14
10 8 68 18
Source: Compiled from own survey, 2017

36

----------------------- Page 37-----------------------

4.3 Importance of Creating Active Class Room for Educational Quality

"Active learning" means students engage with the material, participate in


the class, and

collaborate with each other. Don't expect your students simply to listen
and memorize;

instead, have them help demonstrate a process, analyze an argument, or apply a


concept to a

real-world situation (Andrew, Tolson, and D. Ferguson, 2008).

Whether youre facing a lecture hall filled with 300 students or a seminar table
with 15 students,

one of your primary goals for the class should be to actively engage students with
the material.

Students learn more when they participate in the process of learning,


whether its through

discussion, practice, review, or application (Grunert, 1997). This is in stark


contrast to traditional

styles of teaching, where students are expected to sit for hours,


listening and, theoretically,

absorbing information presented by the instructor.

code Statement

W9 I prefer active way of teaching and provide assessment continuously

W10 I realize students prior knowledge before the class.


W11 I provide tests and quiz to help students to realize the learning
situation.

W12 I prepare myself and knows the whole structure and direction
of the subject that I
teach

All four statements related to importance of active learning responded positively


by participant

teachers. Preference of active learning W9, considering prior knowledge


W10, Continuous

assessment W11 and pre-preparation of teacher before class room W12 responded
positively y

all participants of the study.

Table 4.3:- Views about importance creating active learning

No Items Scale

I II III IV
V I+II VI+V
1 W9 24 10 10 4
2 34 6
2 W10 16 22 8 3
1 38 4
3 W11 19 17 6 3
5 36 8
4 W12 28 14 4 4
0 42 4
Source: Compiled from own survey, 2017

37

----------------------- Page 38-----------------------

5. References

[1] Tharwat M. EL-Sakran, Mujo Mesanovic, Pedagogical Innovations and


Engineering

Students Perceptions of the Relevance of an English for Engineering Course ,


International

Journal of Pedagogical Innovations , No. 1, 15-24 (2013)

[2] Elisabeth Saalman, Engineering education teachers pedagogical use of


digital media

shown in projects carried out in a Higher education course: Learning in


Digital Media,

st
Chalmers University of Technology, 1 World Engineering Education Flash Week,
(WEE2011)

Lisbon, Portugal, 2011.

[3] Mikropoulos, T. A. & Natsis, A. Educational environments: A ten-year


review of

empirical research Computers & Education 56(3), 769-780, (2011).

[4] Dalgarno, Barney & Lee, Mark J. W. What are the learning
affordances of 3-D virtual

environments? British journal of educational technology 41, 1 (2010), 10-32.

[5] Collis, B., Moonen, J. Flexible learning in a digital world: experiences and
expectations

Kogan Page. London, 2001

[6] Manoj Joseph D'Souza and Paul Rodrigues, Extreme Pedagogy: An Agile
Teaching-

Learning Methodology for Engineering Education , Indian Journal of Science and


Technology,

Vol 8(9), 828833, May 2015

[7] Brown S, Knight P. Assessing learners in higher education New York, NY:
Psychology

Press; 1994.

[8] Atasi Mohanty, Deepshikha Dash, Engineering Education in India:


Preparation of

Professional Engineering Educators , Journal of Human Resource and Sustainability


Studies,

4, 92-101, 2016.

[9] Andrew, N., D. Tolson, and D. Ferguson. Building on Wenger: Communities of


practice in

nursing. Nurse Education Today 28, no. 2: 246-52. 2008

[10] Findlow, S. Accountability and innovation in higher education: A


disabling tension
Higher Education 33, no. 3: 313-29, 2008.

[11] Coburn, C.E. 2003. Rethinking scale: Moving beyond numbers to deep
and lasting
change. Educational Researcher 32, no. 6: 3-12.

[12] McKenzie, J., S. Alexander, C. Harper, and S. Anderson.


Dissemination, adoption &
adaptation of project innovations in higher education A report for the
Carrick Institute for
Learning and Teaching in Higher Education, 2005.
38

----------------------- Page 39-----------------------

[13] Southwell, D., D. Gannaway, J. Orrell, D. Chalmers, and C. Abraham.


Strategies for
effective dissemination of project outcomes Brisbane & Adelaide: University of
Queensland &
Flinders University, 2005.
39

----------------------- Page 40-----------------------

I. ANNEX

Questioner

A questioner to be completed by lecturers of AAiT at AAU

Dear Colleagues

This questioner is meant to gather information for a study on an aspect of


pedagogical science.

We hope that the research outcomes contribute to the betterment of teaching


learning process of

the Institute. Please note that the response you give will not have any negative
impact on you as

a lecturer. Furthermore, you do not need to write your name on the


questionnaire. What is

needed is the response you give to the issues raised. Jest feel free and write only
what you think

is correct!!

Yours Faithfully,

HDP Student

Part one: please give the required information through putting an (X) mark on the
appropriate

space.

Note:

All issues in the questioner (including those addressed in the


masculine terms) apply

equally to male and female students.


You may raise your hands up and ask for classification

There is no time limit.

Name of the school__________________________

Department _________________________

Your age___________________________________

Your sex: male _______ Female__________

Years of Experience: 1- 3 _______ 4 - 6 ______ 7 - 9 _____ 10 and > _____

Part Two

Please read each of the following statements very carefully and decide
whether you 'Strongly

agree' 'agree but not very much', 'disagree but not very much' or 'strongly
disagree'. If you cant

agree or disagree, mark 'Undecided'.

40

----------------------- Page 41-----------------------

Put an (x) mark in the appropriate box to indicate your opinion.

Note

One statement can have an (x) mark only once.

No 1tems
Scale
Strongly Agree
Undecided Disagree Strongly
Agree
disagree
1 The teaching profession in this country

need to have up-to-date knowledge for


teaching 21st century skills
2 Technology institute teachers need to

have access to new knowledge from the


Science of Learning about how students
learn
3 Attending HDP class is very helpful for

professional career of the teachers


4 Our country need to have public policies
that can be developed to facilitate the
teaching profession in keeping its
pedagogical knowledge current and up-
to-date
5 Using familiar examples to explain

concepts related to the subject matter is


helpful for students
6 I use multimedia or technology (e.g.

PowerPoint) to express the concept of


subject.
7 I Cleary explain the objective of the

course and the chapter in the class room


8 I consider classroom context

appropriately.
9 I prefer active way of teaching and

provide assessment continuously


10 I realize students prior knowledge before

the class.
11 I provide tests and quiz to help students

to realize the learning situation.


12 I prepare myself and knows the whole

structure and direction of the subject that


I teach

41

----------------------- Page 42-----------------------

7. HDLs end module assessment

Name of the HDP Candidate: Muaz Bedru Hussen

Candidates Final Self-Assessment

What have you found most useful in the program?

I found this program most interesting and useful that enhances my professional
carrier on

teaching at higher education institutions. I thoroughly understood the contents


covered in this

HDP program such as Understanding Higher Education, Modularization and Modular


Curriculum,
Managing Learning and Assessment, Subject Area Teaching and Action Research and
Field-based

Learning

I have also conducted Action research on pedagogical knowledge of


engineering professionals

and found interesting result.

Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in the


program

I have gained hands on knowledge of pedagogy from this program so that my


feature teaching

strategy will be definitely improved. I have exercised all the reflective


activities and homework,

assignments given by HDL during the program hence accomplished the program
successfully as

required.

42

----------------------- Page 43-----------------------

8. Higher Diploma Leaders Final Assessment

General comments on Candidates contribution to and achievement on the HDP


The overall performance of the candidate in the HDP based on the requirements on
pages 12-13 of

the Handbook:

PASS or REFER (Please circle your choice)

In the case of REFER, kindly state the reason(s) - inadequate


attendance, sections that the

candidate missed, etc

Name of HDL __________________________________

Signature of HDL: _______________________________ Date:_____________________

43

You might also like