Part 1 Timothy A. Smith, CPD When pressure in the municipal wa- specify and convey to an installer for water demand for different types of ter supply is not sufficient to satisfy assembly and construction. When de- building occupancies varies greatly. building requirements and water de- signing multiple-pump systems with For instance, 10 water closet flush mands, there are three accepted meth- controls to monitor water pressures, valves in an office building require a ods to boost the pressure to an accept- electrical currents, suction pressures, lower maximum flow rate than, say, able level. A hydro-pneumatic tank, a discharge pressures, motor, 10 water closet flush gravity tank, or a water-pressure boost- and speeds, you will find valves in a public school. er pump can be used. This installment the system can become Determination of Current sizing technolo- focuses on the sizing and application of very complex from a con- the probable flow gy utilizes a sliding-scale pressure-booster pumps and systems. trol standpoint. It is recom- rate is the most graph, commonly referred Smaller applications may only need mended that you seek the to as Hunters curve. This difficult and a single pump, possibly with a small advice of a booster-system graph applies more diver- hydro-pneumatic bladder tank to manufacturer when its controversial part sity to water flow as the avoid a need for continuous pump time to write specifications of sizing a water- quantity of fixture units in- operation. Larger applications may re- for the control-circuit tech- pressure booster creases. The theory is that quire multiple pumps, but hydro- nology utilized for pres- as the quantity of fixtures pneumatic tanks may not be required, sure-booster systems. It is pump or system. increases, the likelihood because a larger building often has a also recommended that of simultaneous use de- continuous demand that justifies con- you have an electrical en- creases. The ASPE Research tinuous pump operation. gineer review all control-wiring dia- Foundation is working on a program A single-pump application can be grams and control-panel product data to to study water demand to develop controlled by a combination starter be submitted with the pressure-booster queuing factors based on building disconnect with pressure switch. A system shop drawings. type and occupancies. The intention multiple-pump system requires control Sizing of the Research Foundations work is from an engineered and factory-wired Two things need to be determined to take the water demand curve, panel with intelligent and sequencing when sizing a pressure-booster sys- which was originally intended to be control circuitry. In commonly used tem: system water demand and sys- applied to every building, and modify terminology, pressure-booster pump tem pressure demand. Calculating wa- it to more closely model a buildings refers to a single-pump combination, ter and pressure demand is not diffi- water demand based on different while a pressure booster system is a cult, but it does require a set of build- building types and occupancies. factory assembled, multiple-pump ing plans or a site inspection. A site The judgment and experience of the combination. The word system refers inspection allows you to count the designer plays an important part, be- to multiple components (e.g., pumps, various types of plumbing fixtures uti- cause there can be a wide difference control panels, pipe, valves) pre-engi- lized in the building, but you may in water demand between building neered in a factory-fabricated and test- need a very long tape measure to de- types. The designer needs to quantify ed assembly. The assembly is custom termine the required static height. Us- all of the various plumbing fixtures in fabricated to the exact specifications ing building plans works best, espe- a building in terms of fixture-unit val- set forth by the designer. cially if the building in question ues to determine the fixture-units total. For a larger system, specification of has yet to be built. Figure 1 is an example of demand a factory-fabricated, packaged system weight of fixtures in fixture units. Al- System Water Demand is the preferred method. Building and ways check your local codes, because Water demand or flow rate is the wiring a system in place from scratch fixture-unit values are not the same in volume of waterin gallonsthat can easily result in confusion, improp- the different codes. needs to be delivered to any part of er installation, and necessary addition- Another controversy in establishing the building each minute of the day. al costs. flow rates is the best way to determine Flow rate is a very dynamic condition, A packaged system also has the ad- the value to apply to fixtures that are and determination of the probable vantage of a single responsibility source. not normally used. For example, a flow rate is the most difficult and con- A pressure-booster pump with simple service sink in an office building is troversial part of sizing a water-pres- pressure-switch controls is easy to normally used by the janitors only at sure booster pump or system. The
44 Plumbing Systems & Design Nov/Dec 2003
DESIGNERS NOTEBOOK Figure 1. Demand Weight of Fixtures night; therefore, the service sink should not be counted as a fixture in the total demand. Hose bibbs should not be counted at 100% of their num- ber. In a large building, many hose bibbs may be installed, but few are operated at the same time. After the designer has determined which fixtures to include in the water- demand calculation, the maximum or peak-flow rate can be determined. The total fixture-unit value is obtained by adding all water-using fixtures that have normal domestic diversity. The fixture units can be converted into a gallons-per-minute (gpm) flow rate by using the conversion charts illustrated in Figure 2. The flow demand of all continuous-use fixtures is then added to the flow rate established from the conversion charts. A continuous-use fixture or piece of equipment does not have normal diversity; water- cooled equipment, air-conditioning cooling towers, lawn sprinklers, and industrial processes are some continu- ous-use fixtures or equipment. Any such fixtures or equipment should be calculated independently. The com- bined total figure represents the flow rate for the building. A designer with extensive project experience may apply additional diver- sity factors to the conversion graphs in Figure 2 to adjust for different building types and occupancies. Some pres- sure-booster system manufacturers have taken Hunters curve and com- bined it with their project experience to develop modified curves for specific building types and applications. Expe- rience dictates that the manufacturers data is more useful than the single Hunters curve that is supposed to apply to all building types. System Pressure Demand Pressure demand or residual pres- sure is the pressure of the water, in pounds per square inch (psi), that must be supplied to the fixture or de- vice while flowing the required water demand. Many fixtures or devices require minimum inlet pressures to Reprinted from ASPE Data Book Vol. 2 (2001), p. 123 continued on page 46
Nov/Dec 2003 Plumbing Systems & Design 45
DESIGNERS NOTEBOOK Figure 2. Conversion of Fixture Units to Gallons per Minute (Liters per Second) Fixture demand pressures need close evaluation against the static lift re- quirements of the system. The conversion formula of 1 psi = 2.31 ft of static is used to determine the pressure boost required from a pump. Calculate the difference in verti- cal height between the discharge out- let or pressure-sustaining valve of the booster pump and the highest served plumbing fixture or device. This num- ber represents the height or vertical lift factor in the system-pressure demand determination. Then you can divide the static lift required by 2.31 to obtain the pressure in psi. Please note that static pressure and residual pressure are different (static is without water flow, and residual is with water flow). Booster pumps and systems are de- signed to have water flow. Design considerations for residual pressures are calculated with the next factor.
Delivery of 3040 psi at the
most remote fixture is a good rule of thumb for most applications.
The friction-loss factor of the calcu-
lation includes not only piping losses but also losses from valves, fittings, sensing wells, devices, and bushings. Reprinted from ASPE Data Book Vol. 2 (2001), p. 120 Bushings are a significant source of friction loss in domestic plumbing sys- operate and function to the engi- You should consider three main fac- tems. Often, bushings are substituted neered specifications. For instance, a tors when calculating the water-pres- for tapered fittings, although the fric- diaphragm-type flush valve needs ap- sure demand for a booster pump or tion loss through a bushing can be proximately 30 psi to operate properly, system: 510 times higher than through a fit- delivering the required volume of wa- static height or vertical elevation of ting, depending on size and flow. To ter in a short enough time to develop the highest fixture from the booster achieve the designed friction loss, it is velocity sufficient to clean the bowl. friction losses through the piping important to qualify piping details and Conversely, an open faucet tap can system at the most remote location specifications as to the types of fittings operate with minimal pressurebe- the minimum required residual allowed. low 10 psi. Inlet pressures are most pressure at the highest and most re- The friction loss graph in Figure 3 critical to plumbing fixtures with me- mote location. illustrates the relation among flow, chanical mechanisms or pressure-ad- The most remote fixture may not al- friction loss, and velocity through justing components (e.g., thermostatic ways be the fixture that dictates the smooth copper water pipe. It is rec- or pressure-balanced shower valves, minimum required system pressure. It ommended that velocities be kept flush valves, pressure-sustaining is common to have the most demand- low, because they are correlated with valves). ing fixture at a lower elevationin higher friction losses and more rapid closer proximity to the booster system.
46 Plumbing Systems & Design Nov/Dec 2003
DESIGNERS NOTEBOOK Figure 3. Pipe Sizing Data (Smooth Pipe) schedule may be needed if conserva- tive velocities are utilized in the pipe sizing at the onset. The minimum required residual pressure at a fixture is the last factor of the equation. Delivery of 3040 psi at the most remote fixture is a good rule of thumb for most applications. In most buildings, the diaphragm flush valve is the most demanding fix- ture. It requires a minimum of 30 psi. Pressure-balanced shower valves or mixing valves require 20 psi mini- mum. In any case, this designer would not design a system that could not maintain a minimum of 20 psi residual system pressure. Buildings more than 8 stories in height require multiple pressure zones, because there are also maximum allowable in- let pressures for fixtures and devices. Most of the model codes recognize 80 psi as a maximum system pressure. Future articles will discuss multiple pressure zones, pressure-reducing sta- tions, and recirculation issues associat- ed with high-rise building design. Simply add the three factorsstatic lift, friction/pressure losses, and mini- mum required residual pressureand you have the required delivery pres- sure of the booster pump or system. Combine this with the water demand calculation and you can select a pump or system. In Part 2, pressure-booster pump system types, various pump Reprinted from ASPE Data Book Vol. 2 (2001), p. 139 types, the use of hydrostatic accumu- lator tanks, the application of multiple pump systems, and system controls deterioration of the piping system. To sionless number, it is used to deter- will be discussed. arrive at an approximate booster size, mine friction losses through various you should apply the design criteria valve types and sizes based upon the for establishing system water demand, flow rate. You should refer to the estimate approximate pipe sizes for valve manufacturers product data for the supply mains, and use Figure 3 to its liquid flow graphs and correspon- Tim Smith is vice presi- dent, partner, and found- establish the respective friction/pres- ding Cv factors when you calculate ing member of Metro De- sure loss. Additional losses through friction losses and pressure drops sign Associates, Inc., in valves, fittings, and devices will have through the systems valves. You can Schaumburg, IL. He has to be calculated in the final sizing, but calculate the exact friction/pressure more than 23 years expe- this approach will help you approxi- loss when the design is 100% com- rience covering all aspects of consulting en- mate the size, configuration, pump plete and you are able to quantify gineering, specializing in plumbing, fire type, and horsepower required. The pipe sizes, pipe lengths, valve sizes protection, and civil engineering. His e- mail address is tsmith@metrodgn.com. Cv method of valve sizing reduces all and types, fittings, and devices. Only variables to a common denominator slight adjustments to the booster pump called the flow coefficient. A dimen- or systems specified performance