Voip Pal Ex Parte Communication To Lead PTAB Judge

Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF Document 35 Filed 12/18/17 Page 1 of 40
1 ALVERSON, TAYLOR,
MORTENSEN & SANDERS
2 KURT R. BONDS, ESQ.
3 Nevada Bar No. 6228
ADAM R. KNECHT, ESQ.
4 Nevada Bar No. 13166
6605 Grand Montecito Pkwy, Ste 200
5 Las Vegas, NV 89149
6 (702) 384-7000
efile@alversontaylor.com
7 Attorneys for Plaintiff
Voip-Pal.com, Inc.
8
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
9
10 DISTRICT OF NEVADA
ALVERSON, TAYLOR, MORTENSEN & SANDERS
11 * * *
12
VOIP-PAL.COM, INC., a Nevada corporation, CASE NO.: 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF
6605 GRAND MONTECITO PKWY, STE 200
13
Plaintiff,
LAS VEGAS, NEVADA 89149
14 DECLARATION OF ADAM R.
v. KNECHT, ESQ. REGARDING
(702) 384-7000
LAWYERS
15 NOTICE OF VARIOUS LETTERS

16 APPLE, INC., a California corporation, FROM DR. THOMAS SAWYER TO
THE HONORABLE JUDGE
17 Defendants. RICHARD F. BOULWARE II (ECF
NOS. 28 AND 32)
18
19
I, Adam R. Knecht, Esq., declare that:
20
1. I am an attorney with the law firm of Alverson, Taylor, Mortensen & Sanders, counsel
21
of record for Plaintiff Voip-Pal.com, Inc. (“Plaintiff” or “Voip-Pal”) in the above-captioned matter.
22
I am licensed to practice law before all courts of the State of Nevada, including the United States
23
District Court, District of Nevada. I am permitted to practice before this Court with respect to this
24
matter. I submit this declaration based on personal knowledge, and if called upon as a witness, I
25
could competently testify to the truth of each statement herein.
26
2. On February 9, 2016, Voip-Pal filed this action against Defendant Apple, Inc.
27
(“Apple”) alleging infringement of U.S. Patent Nos. 8,542,815 (the “‘815 patent”) and 9,179,005
28
1 23443
1
(the “‘005 patent”). (ECF No. 1).
2
3. Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of the Civil Docket for the instant case that was
3
printed on December 18, 2017 (https://ecf.nvd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/DktRpt.pl?632863606486333-
4
L_1_0-1).
5
1. Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of a letter from Dr. Thomas E. Sawyer addressed
6
to the Honorable David P. Ruschke, Chief Judge, Patent Trial and Appeal Board (“PTAB”), dated
7
May 1, 2017. Several parties appear to be copied regarding the letter, including the Honorable
8
Richard F. Boulware II in the instant action. On May 8, 2017, the letter was filed and electronically
9
served upon all parties to this action as ECF No. 28. See also Exhibit A.
10
2. Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of a letter from Dr. Thomas E. Sawyer addressed
ALVERSON, TAYLOR, MORTENSEN & SANDERS
11
to the Honorable David P. Ruschke, Chief Judge, Patent Trial and Appeal Board (“PTAB”), dated
12
October 23, 2017. Several parties appear to be copied regarding the letter, including the Honorable
6605 GRAND MONTECITO PKWY, STE 200
13
Richard F. Boulware II in the instant action. On November 1, 2017, the letter was filed and
LAS VEGAS, NEVADA 89149
14
electronically served upon all parties to this action as ECF No. 32. See also Exhibit A.
(702) 384-7000
LAWYERS
15
3. Because this Court filed the May 1, 2017 letter (ECF No. 28) and the October 23,
16
2017 letter (ECF No. 28) through the Case Management/Electronic Case Files (“CM/ECF”) system,
17
our firm, as counsel of record for Voip-Palm, received and was electronically served notice of the
18
two letters through the CM/ECF system on May 8, 2017 and November 1, 2017, respectively. See
19
also Exhibit A.
20
Executed on December 18, 2017, in Las Vegas, Nevada.
21
22 /s/ Adam R. Knecht .

23 ADAM R. KNECHT, ESQ.
24
25
26
27
28
2 23443
Exhibit A
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 4 of 40
)*+,-./+012345232
6789:;<=9>9:?<@8?9A8B9<CDEA9<
@8?9A8B9<DF<G:H>;><IJ>?<K:L>?M<
CNKNJ<@OCPQR<SOT<CU=Q<VW<XWYZ[BH[\\XZ\[TS][KCS
^_à1bcdef_g/hijfehkeh+aadl/hijfeh .cplhwd̀loqh43545342h
+mmǹjlohp_qhrsonlhtf̀ucvohwehx_sdycvl/hiih rsvh.lgcjoqhx_puh
tlzlvvlohp_qh{cnm̀pvcplhrsonlh|cghwlvlj}cfuh cpsvlh_zh)sp̀qh4bcpljph
.lgcjoqh~/444h rsvm̀of̀p̀_jqhwlolvcdhslmp̀_j
|csmlqh2q223hbcpljphijzvj̀nlgljp
>8798FF
KD8[>BD<N7B vlavlmljploh}U;><T<P7:B9<
+dklvm_jh*cd_vh{_vpljmljhh)cjolvh
4hvcjoh{_jplfp̀_hbcvych
)sp̀lh344h
cmh^lncm/h^h2h
4311444h
wcqh4311444h
-gcd̀qhlzd̀lcdklvm_jpcd_vef_ghh
hh
¡¢h
PEA9<T<]D7;?<
+dklvm_jh*cd_vh{_vpljmlj/hlphcdh
4hvcjoh{_jplfp̀_hbcvych
)sp̀lh344h
cmh^lncm/h^h2h
4311444h
wcqh4311444h
-gcd̀qhlzd̀lcdklvm_jpcd_vef_ghh
hh
¡¢
êh
@:F:7;>79
U:<N7B vlavlmljploh}U::9<U<£D;8<
.lmgcvcm̀hbh
34hbcvh+klhwdh3h
lyh,_v/h,h242h
32312144h
-gcd̀qhcg_oòlmgcvcm̀ddaef_ghh
hh
¤¥¢¦¡¢hh
¡¢h
§D7<£<@:?>A>8?<
.lmgcvcm̀hbh
34hbcvh+kljsl/h3puhwd__vh
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 02
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 5 of 40
)*+,-./01,)-,23245,
67278,9:2;9<33,
=>?@A?BBCDE>F,,
GDCAH?IAJKI>,,
?BBCDE>FABCAL>AECBKI>@,
MNOOPQRSSTUPVWNNXT
Y*Z[\/\]Z,^^_,
793,_\/0,̀a*bc*1,74de,fg../,
)*+,-./01,)-,23245,
67278,9:2;9<33,
=>?@A?BBCDE>F,,
GDCAH?IAJKI>,,
hPijkNlTmnThiopNT
^*+]Z,q.r\,q.des*/t*/,ue/]Zd]*,^^_,
9559,v.+\/w,vcse*Z,_0+xy,
zc]d*,433,
^\Z,{*s\Z1,){,|5245;,
6}378,5<5;|733,
f\~,6}378,5<5;|949,
[\]g,[[rrc*g//ryr.[,,
=>?@A?BBCDE>F,,
hPijkNlTnTkSPiXT
Y*Z[\/\]Z,^^_,
793,_\/0,̀a*,
fg../,74,
)*+,-./01,)-,23245,
727;9:2;9<33,
f\~,727;9:2;9<32,
[\]g,[Zd\wb]r0w*Z[\/\]Zggyr.[,,
=>?@A?BBCDE>F,,
GDCAH?IAJKI>,,
mSkjkSTTpSkPST
v.+\/w,,v.+\/w,̀dd./b*xZ,_^û,
9|33,v.+\/w,vcse*Z,_0+xy,
zc]d*,2333,
^\Z,{*s\Z1,){,|5245,
6}378,44};<|79,
f\~,6}378,:4};2:4|,
[\]g,+e7g\+yr.[,,
B>DKE?B>@A
SNONNTkO
OnTjVkTnTkNO
kNTPlN iXNTN
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 12
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 6 of 40
)*+),+*)-. -/012345678/9:9;<=>/?@;AB39CDE@FG/6<ED/HI;C;<:/JKK/LM))/NKEK;A>/<OFPKN/),QRBS,,M).QTG
J;CKU/PV/?@;AB39CDE@FG/6<EDD/0KN>;J;E9>K/@J/6<>KNK=>KU/39N>;K=/UOK/PV/*+-,+*)-.D/3N@@J/@J
=KNW;EK/UOK/PV/.+R+*)-.D/H5>>9EXFK<>=Y/Z/-/6<UK[G/Z/*/\[X;P;>/5G/Z/S/\[X;P;>/]G/Z/M/\[X;P;>
0G/Z/^/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/./\[X;P;>/_BH0X9N>/-TG/Z/Q/\[X;P;>/_BH0X9N>/*TG/Z/R/\[X;P;>/_BH0X9N>/STG
Z/,/\[X;P;>/_BH0X9N>/MTG/Z/-)/\[X;P;>/\G/Z/--/\[X;P;>/IG/Z/-*/\[X;P;>/IB5UUK<UOF/-G/Z/-S
0;W;C/0@WKN/̀XKK>G/Z/-M/̀OFF@<=T/H]@<U=G/aON>T/H\<>KNKUY/)*+),+*)-.T
)*+),+*)-. /09=K/9==;:<KU/>@/bOU:K/c;EX9NU/ID/]@OCd9NKG/66/9<U/29:;=>N9>K/bOU:K/09F/IKNK<P9EXD//
efghijklmknhogpkqrsktfgjugkvfwj/H8cT/H\<>KNKUY/)*+-)+*)-.T
)*+-)+*)-. */71860\/3xc`x578/81/41054/cx4\/6]/*B*Y/6</9EE@NU9<EK/d;>X/*R/x`0/y/.S.HET
9<U/Ic03/QSG/>XK/A9N>;K=/;</>X;=/9E>;@</9NK/AN@W;UKU/d;>X/9/C;<z/>@/>XK/{51/R^/7@>;EK/@J
5W9;C9P;C;>VG/0@<=K<>G/9<U/1NUKN/@J/cKJKNK<EK/B/\[KNE;=K/@J/bON;=U;E>;@</PV/9/xD̀D
29:;=>N9>K/bOU:K{/J@NF/@</>XK/0@ON>|=/dKP=;>K/B/dddD<WUDO=E@ON>=D:@WD/}~kqkvluwjug
mliwkwlhke~kjkjjgiluofkmoj/xA@</E@<=K<>/@J/9CC/A9N>;K=G/E@O<=KC/9NK
9UW;=KU/>@/F9<O9CCV/J;CK/>XK/J@NF/d;>X/>XK/0CKNz|=/1JJ;EKD/H5/E@AV/@J/J@NF/51/R^/X9=/PKK<
F9;CKU/>@/A9N>;K=/<@>/NKEK;W;<:/KCKE>N@<;E/=KNW;EKDT
71860\/1I/\7\c54/1c_\c/*)-SB-/57_/1331c8x768/I1c/\3\_68\_
8c654/̀\8867Y/8XK/A9N>;K=/;</>X;=/9E>;@</9NK/AN@W;UKU/d;>X/9/C;<z/>@/K<KN9C/1NUKN
*)-SB-/9<U/>XK/x`_0/̀X@N>/8N;9C/cOCK=/@</>XK/0@ON>|=/dKP=;>K/B/dddD<WUDO=E@ON>=D:@WD/6J
>XK/A9N>;K=/9:NKK/>X9>/>X;=/9E>;@</E9</PK/NK9UV/J@N/>N;9C/d;>X;</-R)/U9V=/9<U/>X9>/9/>N;9C/@J
>X;=/F9>>KN/d@OCU/>9zK/>XNKK/HST/U9V=/@N/CK==G/>XK/A9N>;K=/=X@OCU/E@<=;UKN/A9N>;E;A9>;@</;</>XK
x`_0/̀X@N>/8N;9C/3N@:N9FD/6J/>XK/A9N>;K=/d;=X/>@/PK/E@<=;UKNKU/J@N/K<>NV/;<>@/>XK/0@ON>|=
`X@N>/8N;9C/3N@:N9FG/>XKV/=X@OCU/K[KEO>K/9<U/KCKE>N@<;E9CCV/J;CK/d;>X/x`_0/̀X@N>/8N;9C
I@NF/MH9TH-T/@N/I@NF/MH9TH*TD
ulkofjkfggfj/H8cT/H\<>KNKUY/)*+-)+*)-.T
)*+-)+*)-. S/51/-*)/B/c\31c8/@</>XK/J;C;<:/@N/UK>KNF;<9>;@</@J/9</9E>;@</NK:9NU;<:/9/A9>K<>/@N
>N9UKF9NzD/\BF9;CKU/>@/>XK/x`/39>K<>/9<U/8N9UKF9Nz/1JJ;EKD/H5>>9EXFK<>=Y/Z/-/E@FAC9;<>T
H8cT/H\<>KNKUY/)*+-)+*)-.T
)*+-)+*)-. M/ÒFF@<=/6==OKU/9=/>@/5AACKG/6<ED/NK/-/0@FAC9;<>D/H8cT/H\<>KNKUY/)*+-)+*)-.T
)*+*S+*)-. ^/0\c86I6058\/@J/6<>KNK=>KU/39N>;K=/J;CKU/PV/?@;AB39CDE@FG/6<EDD/8XKNK/9NK/<@/z<@d<
;<>KNK=>KU/A9N>;K=/@>XKN/>X9</>X@=K/A9N>;E;A9>;<:/;</>XK/E9=K/D/H]@<U=G/aON>T/H\<>KNKUY
)*+*S+*)-.T
)M+).+*)-. ./52\7_\_/012345678/d;>X/bONV/_KF9<U/9:9;<=>/5AACKG/6<EDG/J;CKU/PV/?@;AB39CDE@FG
6<EDD/7@/EX9<:K=/>@/A9N>;K=D/3N@@J/@J/=KNW;EK/UOK/PV/Q+^+*)-.D/H5>>9EXFK<>=Y/Z/-/\[X;P;>
89PCK/@J/\[X;P;>=G/Z/*/\[X;P;>/5G/Z/S/\[X;P;>/]G/Z/M/\[X;P;>/0G/Z/^/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/./6<UK[
0X9N>/>@/-/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/Q/6<UK[/0X9N>/>@/*/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/R/6<UK[/0X9N>/>@/S/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/,
6<UK[/0X9N>/>@/M/\[X;P;>/_G/Z/-)/\[X;P;>/\G/Z/--/\[X;P;>/IG/Z/-*/̀OAACKFK<>/5UUK<UOF/-
>@/\[X;P;>/IT/H]@<U=G/aON>T/H\<>KNKUY/)M+).+*)-.T
)M+*Q+*)-. Q/3c131`\_/̀x2217`/>@/PK/;==OKU/G/J;CKU/PV/3C9;<>;JJ/?@;AB39CDE@FG/6<EDD
H]@<U=G/aON>T/H\<>KNKUY/)M+*Q+*)-.T
)M+*Q+*)-. R/~/6<E@NNKE>/U@EOFK<>/9>>9EXKUD/_@EOFK<>/U@K=/<@>/AKN>9;</>@/>X;=/E9=KD
v~v~ep/5>>@N<KV/aON>/]@<U=/9UW;=KU/>@/NKJ;CK/9<U/9>>9EX/E@NNKE>/U@EOFK<>D
0\c86I6058\/@J/6<>KNK=>KU/39N>;K=/J;CKU/PV/?@;AB39CDE@FG/6<EDD/8XKNK/9NK/<@/z<@d<
;<>KNK=>KU/A9N>;K=/@>XKN/>X9</>X@=K/A9N>;E;A9>;<:/;</>XK/E9=KD/H]@<U=G/aON>T/H\<>KNKUY
)M+*Q+*)-.T
)M+*Q+*)-. ,/71860\Y/5>>@N<KV/5E>;@</cKO;NKU/>@/R/0KN>;J;E9>K/@J/6<>KNK=>KU/39N>;K=D/~
6<E@NNKE>/U@EOFK<>/9>>9EXKUD/_@EOFK<>/U@K=/<@>/AKN>9;</>@/>X;=/E9=KD/v~v~ep
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 %2
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 7 of 40
)**+,-./012,*03+-45064785.40*+0,.98:.0;.,*898<6*.0+90=-*.,.5*.40>6,*8.50*?6*0@.,*68-50*+0*?85
<65.ABCDEFGHIJEHKKHLMJNOPQ1RS0PT-*.,.4U0VWXYZXYV[\S
VWXYZXYV[\ [V0]2^^+-50=552.40650*+0)@@:._0=-<A0PàS0PT-*.,.4U0VWXYZXYV[\S
VbXVbXYV[\ [[0)cTdQTQ0;ec>f)=d`0g8*?0R2,/0Q.^6-406h68-5*0)@@:._0=-<A_098:.40i/0j+8@k>6:A<+^_
=-<AA0d+0<?6-h.50*+0@6,*8.5A0>,++90+905.,78<.042.0i/0lXmXYV[\A0P)**6<?^.-*5U0n0[0=-4.o
`6i:.0+90To?8i8*5_0n0Y0To?8i8*0)_0n0m0To?8i8*03_0n0W0To?8i8*0;_0n0b0To?8i8*0Q_0n0\0=-4.o
;?6,*0[0*+0To?8i8*0Q_0n0Z0=-4.o0;?6,*0Y0*+0To?8i8*0Q_0n0l0=-4.o0;?6,*0m0*+0To?8i8*0Q_0n0p
=-4.o0;?6,*0W0*+0To?8i8*0Q_0n0[V0To?8i8*0T_0n0[[0To?8i8*0q_0n0[Y0)@@.-48o0)44.-42^0[0*+
To?8i8*0qS0P3+-45_012,*S0PT-*.,.4U0VbXVbXYV[\S
VbX[lXYV[\ [Y0]`=>rf)`=ed0qea0Ts`Td]=ed0eq0̀=cT0Pq8,5*0a.t2.5*S0,.0[[0)^.-4.40;+^@:68-*_
u0i/0Q.9.-46-*0)@@:._0=-<AA0Pq+2-*68-_0R+-6*?6-S0PT-*.,.4U0VbX[lXYV[\S
VbXYVXYV[\ [m0eaQTa0v,6-*8-h0[Y0]*8@2:6*8+-0,.0[0;+^@:68-*A0)@@:._0=-<A06-5g.,042.0ZXYpXYV[\A
]8h-.40i/0c6h85*,6*.0R24h.0;6^0q.,.-i6<?0+-0bXYVX[\A0P;+@8.50?67.0i..-0485*,8i2*.4
@2,526-*0*+0*?.0dTq0k0)QaS0PT-*.,.4U0VbXYVXYV[\S
VbXY\XYV[\ [W0jTa=q=TQ0>T`=`=ed09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.0i/0)^..*0)A0c+4806-4
QT]=vd)`=ed0+90f+<6:0;+2-5.:0R+-6*?6-0xA0q+2-*68-0Pq8:8-h09..0y0YbV0,.<.8@*0-2î.,
VpZlkW[mblbmS098:.40i/0Q.9.-46-*0)@@:._0=-<A0A0Pq+2-*68-_0R+-6*?6-S0PT-*.,.4U
VbXY\XYV[\S
VbXY\XYV[\ [b0jTa=q=TQ0>T`=`=ed09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.0i/0c8<?6.:0>.*.,0]*64-8<z
6-40QT]=vd)`=ed0+90f+<6:0;+2-5.:0R+-6*?6-0xA0q+2-*68-0Pq8:8-h09..0y0YbV0,.<.8@*
-2î.,0VpZlkW[mbl\[S098:.40i/0Q.9.-46-*0)@@:._0=-<A0A0Pq+2-*68-_0R+-6*?6-S0PT-*.,.4U
VbXY\XYV[\S
VbXY\XYV[\ [\0jTa=q=TQ0>T`=`=ed09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.0i/0R+?-0c8<?6.:
Q.5^6,68506-40QT]=vd)`=ed0+90f+<6:0;+2-5.:0R+-6*?6-0xA0q+2-*68-0Pq8:8-h09..0y0YbV
,.<.8@*0-2î.,0VpZlkW[mblZVS098:.40i/0Q.9.-46-*0)@@:._0=-<A0A0Pq+2-*68-_0R+-6*?6-S
PT-*.,.4U0VbXY\XYV[\S
VbXY\XYV[\ [Z0jTa=q=TQ0>T`=`=ed09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.0i/01.,,8k)--0f8î..z
6-40QT]=vd)`=ed0+90f+<6:0;+2-5.:0R+-6*?6-0xA0q+2-*68-0Pq8:8-h09..0y0YbV0,.<.8@*
-2î.,0VpZlkW[mblZWS098:.40i/0Q.9.-46-*0)@@:._0=-<A0A0Pq+2-*68-_0R+-6*?6-S0PT-*.,.4U
VbXY\XYV[\S
VbXYpXYV[\ [l0eaQTa0v,6-*8-h0[W0j.,898.40>.*8*8+-09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.09+,
)**+,-./0)^..*0)A0c+4809+,0)@@:._0=-<A06-406@@,+78-h0Q.58h-6*8+-0+90f+<6:0;+2-5.:
R+-6*?6-0xA0q+2-*68-A0]8h-.40i/0R24h.0a8<?6,40qA03+2:g6,._0==0+-0bXYpX[\A00
)-/0)**+,-./0-+*0/.*0,.h85*.,.40g8*?0*?.0;+2,*{50;cXT;q0]/5*.^05?6::052i^8*06
a.h85*,6*8+-0q+,^0+-0*?.0;+2,*{50g.i58*.0gggA-74A25<+2,*5Ah+7
P;+@8.50?67.0i..-0485*,8i2*.40@2,526-*0*+0*?.0dTq0k0̀aS0PT-*.,.40U0V\XV[XYV[\S
VbXm[XYV[\ [p0eaQTa0H||}D~FCI0T;q0d+A0[b0j.,898.40>.*8*8+-09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.
9+,0)**+,-./0c8<?6.:0>.*.,0]*64-8<z09+,0)@@:._0=-<A06-406@@,+78-h0Q.58h-6*8+-0+90f+<6:
;+2-5.:A0]8h-.40i/0R24h.0a8<?6,40qA03+2:g6,._0==0+-0bXm[X[\A00
)-/0)**+,-./0-+*0/.*0,.h85*.,.40g8*?0*?.0;+2,*{50;cXT;q0]/5*.^05?6::052i^8*06
a.h85*,6*8+-0q+,^0+-0*?.0;+2,*{50g.i58*.0gggA-74A25<+2,*5Ah+70
P;+@8.50?67.0i..-0485*,8i2*.40@2,526-*0*+0*?.0dTq0k0R;S0PT-*.,.4U0V\XV[XYV[\S
VbXm[XYV[\ YV0eaQTa0H||}D~FCI0T;q0d+A0[\0j.,898.40>.*8*8+-09+,0>.,^8558+-0*+0>,6<*8<.0>,+0w6<0j8<.
9+,0)**+,-./0R+?-0c8<?6.:0Q.5^6,68509+,0)@@:._0=-<A06-406@@,+78-h0Q.58h-6*8+-0+90f+<6:
;+2-5.:A0]8h-.40i/0R24h.0a8<?6,40qA03+2:g6,._0==0+-0bXm[X[\A00
)-/0)**+,-./0-+*0/.*0,.h85*.,.40g8*?0*?.0;+2,*{50;cXT;q0]/5*.^05?6::052i^8*06
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 &2
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 8 of 40
*+,-./01/-23452064234/7+48290/:.4;+<.-/+4;;;=3>?=9.@290/.=,2>4
A82B-+.471>+4<++34?-./0-<9/+?4B90.913/4/24/7+4CD54E4F8G4AD3/+0+?H4IJKILKMILJG
INKOLKMILJ ML4P*QD*4RSSTUVWXY4D854C2=4LZ4[+0-\-+?4]+/-/-234\204]+06-..-234/24]01@/-@+4]024^1@4[-@+
\204_//203+`4a+00-E_334b-6<++c4\204_BBd+e4f3@=413?41BB02>-3,4Q+.-,31/-2342\4b2@1d
8293.+d=4g-,3+?4<`4F9?,+4*-@710?45=4h29d;10+e4ff4234NKOLKLJ=44
_3`4_//203+`432/4̀+/40+,-./+0+?4;-/74/7+48290/:.48iKD854g`./+64.71dd4.9<6-/41
*+,-./01/-23452064234/7+48290/:.4;+<.-/+4;;;=3>?=9.@290/.=,2>4
A82B-+.471>+4<++34?-./0-<9/+?4B90.913/4/24/7+4CD54E4F8G4AD3/+0+?H4IJKILKMILJG
IJKIMKMILJ MM4gjiiPCg4*+/903+?4Dk+@9/+?4<`4[2-BE]1d=@26e4f3@=40+4LL4_6+3?+?4826Bd1-3/e=4_BBd+e
f3@=4.+0>+?4234NKlKMILJe413.;+04?9+4ZKMlKMILJ=4Ah23?.e4a90/G4AD3/+0+?H4IJKIMKMILJG
IZKImKMILJ MO4iPnfPC4/24g/1`4opqrsqtuvpwxyz{sxqux|u}q{p~uo~{pwuvpspuu{puo{pq{u~syuqr
pyux~r4<`4Q+\+3?13/4_BBd+e4f3@==4A_//1@76+3/.H44L4Q+@d101/-2342\4a+00-E_33
b-6<++ce44M4f3?+k42\4Dk7-<-/.e44O4Dk7-<-/4L4E4_BBd+:.4]+/-/-234\204f]*42\4/7+4meNMemLN
]1/+3/e444Dk7-<-/4M4E4_BBd+:.4]+/-/-234\204f]*42\4/7+4leLZleIIN4]1/+3/e44N4Dk7-<-/4O4E
j3-\-+?:.4]+/-/-234\204f]*42\4/7+4meNMemLN4]1/+3/e44J4Dk7-<-/44E4C2/-@+42\45-d-3,4Q1/+4\20
_BBd+:.4f]*42\4/7+4meNMemLN4]1/+3/e44Z4Dk7-<-/4N4E4C2/-@+42\45-d-3,4Q1/+4\204_BBd+:.4f]*
2\4/7+4leLZleIIN4]1/+3/e44m4Dk7-<-/4J4E4C2/-@+42\45-d-3,4Q1/+4\204j3-\-+?:.4f]*42\4/7+
meNMemLN4]1/+3/e44l4Dk7-<-/4Z4E4]n_h4g/1/-./-@.4Ai1`4OLe4MILJGe44LI4Dk7-<-/4m4E4[2f]E
]1d4826B13`4P>+0>-+;e44LL4Dk7-<-/4l4E4[2f]E]1d4h210?42\4Q-0+@/20.4i1`4MNe4MILJ
823\+0+3@+481dd4n013.@0-B/4A+k@+0B/GGA5293/1-3e4F231/713G4AD3/+0+?H4IZKImKMILJG
IZKLlKMILJ M4gnf]jb_nfPC4qruo~xxwpru~rp~u{xu{uopqrsqtuupswsxquu{puo{pq{u~syuqr
pyux~ruvpt~rsqtu}qw{s{z{sxqux|u}q{p~uo~{pwuvpsp4<`4Q+\+3?13/4_BBd+e4f3@==
A5293/1-3e4F231/713G4AD3/+0+?H4IZKLlKMILJG
IZKLlKMILJ MN4P*QD*40+4M4g/-B9d1/-23=4fn4fg4^D*Dh4P*QD*DQ4/71/4MO4i2/-234/24g/1`4-.4QDCfDQ
1.4iPPn=4g-,3+?4<`4i1,-./01/+4F9?,+481645+0+3<1@74234ZKLlKLJ=4A82B-+.471>+4<++3
?-./0-<9/+?4B90.913/4/24/7+4CD54E4n*G4AD3/+0+?H4IZKMIKMILJG
LMKMIKMILJ MJ4gnf]jb_nfPC40+4MN4P0?+04234i2/-234/24g/1è4P0?+04234g/-B9d1/-23e44}o}u
}u4<`4Q+\+3?13/4_BBd+e4f3@==4A5293/1-3e4F231/713G4AD3/+0+?H4LMKMIKMILJG
LMKMIKMILJ MZ4P*QD*4013/-3,4MJ4gnf]jb_nfPC4nP48PCnfCjD4gn_4]+3?-3,40-//+34Q+@-.-23.
<`4/7+4]1/+3/4n0-1d413?4_BB+1d4h210?=4F2-3/4g/1/9.4*+B20/4?9+4<`4LMKLMKMILZ=4g-,3+?4<`
i1,-./01/+4F9?,+481645+0+3<1@74234LMKMIKLJ=4A82B-+.471>+4<++34?-./0-<9/+?4B90.913/4/2
/7+4CD54E4iiiG4AD3/+0+?H4LMKMLKMILJG
INKImKMILZ Mm482B`42\4bDnnD*4/24^23201<d+4Q1>-?4]=4*9.@7c+4?1/+?4NKLKLZ4\-d+?4<`4f3/+0+./+?4]10/̀e
Q0=4n7261.4D=4g1;`+0=4A_Q*G4AD3/+0+?H4INKLIKMILZG
ImKMNKMILZ Ml4iPnfPC4/24-/7?01;41.4_//203+`4<`4F231/7134=45293/1-34<`4Q+\+3?13/4_BBd+e4f3@==
A5293/1-3e4F231/713G4AD3/+0+?H4ImKMNKMILZG
ImKMNKMILZ OI4CPnf8D42\4_BB+1013@+4<`41//203+`4i-@71+d4F=4i@89+4234<+71d\42\4Q+\+3?13/4_BBd+e
f3@==4Ai@89+e4i-@71+dG4AD3/+0+?H4ImKMNKMILZG
IlKLLKMILZ OL4P*QD*4013/-3,4Ml4i2/-234/24-/7?01;41.4_//203+`=4g-,3+?4<`4i1,-./01/+4F9?,+4816
5+0+3<1@74234lKLLKLZ=4A82B-+.471>+4<++34?-./0-<9/+?4B90.913/4/24/7+4CD54E4i*G4AD3/+0+?H
IlKLLKMILZG
LLKILKMILZ OM482B`42\4bDnnD*4/24/7+4^23201<d+4Q1>-?4]=4*9.@7c+413?4F2.+B74i1/1d4?1/+?4LIKMOKMILZ
\0264Q0=4n7261.4D=4g1;`+0=4Ai*G4AD3/+0+?H4LLKIMKMILZG
LMKLMKMILZ OO45-0./4gnf]jb_nfPC45P*4DnDCgfPC4P54nfiD4A5-0./4*+9+./G4u}u}
uvov4<`4]d1-3/-\\4[2-BE]1d=@26e4f3@==4Aa3+@7/e4_?16G4AD3/+0+?H4LMKLMKMILZG
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 )2
0120321405 Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF 672
869

35
Document
Filed

12/18/17
0 Page 9 of 40
)*+),+*-). ,/012342056789:8;0,,0<9:=>?79:@80A@604B9C8D:@80@A0E:FC09@0G:?C0H@:890<979>D02C=@690IG:6D9
2CJ>CD9KL0H@:890<979>D02C=@690M>C0NO0)+*P+*-)QL0<:;8CM0NO0R7;:D9679C0H>M;C0S7F
GC6C8N7TU0@80)*+),+*-).L0IS@=:CD0U7VC0NCC80M:D96:N>9CM0=>6D>78909@09UC0W4G0X0R2K
I489C6CMY0)*+),+*-).K
Z[\]^_àbcdea_\afgab
hbifjiegdkf_âeadlg
)*+)Q+*-).0)-Y)/Y,.
Z[\]^ pN@8MD.--- \qdafg_\krao
mkndfo
sajebdlgdkfo 3@TpC9 àibet
2C=@69 \bdgabdio vSG
*Y)PXTVX--*P-X2GuX
wdqqixqa y \kjgo -Ly-
Zinajo
22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 2

Exhibit B
Case
Case2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF
2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF Document
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page11
1 of
of18
40
2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page12
2 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page13
3 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page14
4 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page15
5 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page16
6 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page17
7 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page18
8 of
of18
40
Case
Document35
28 Filed
Filed12/18/17
05/08/17 Page
Page19
9 of
of18
40
Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF Document 35
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 20
10 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 21
11 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 22
12 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 23
13 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 24
14 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 25
15 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 26
16 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 27
17 of 40
18
28 Filed 12/18/17
05/08/17 Page 28
18 of 40
18
Exhibit C
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page30
1 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page31
2 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page32
3 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page33
4 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page34
5 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page35
6 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page36
7 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page37
8 of
of11
40
Case
Document35
32 Filed
Filed12/18/17
11/01/17 Page
Page38
9 of
of11
40
32 Filed 12/18/17
11/01/17 Page 39
10 of 40
11
32 Filed 12/18/17
11/01/17 Page 40
11 of 40
11

Voip Pal Ex Parte Communication To Lead PTAB Judge

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Voip Pal Ex Parte Communication To Lead PTAB Judge

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF Document 35 Filed 12/18/17 Page 1 of 40

15 NOTICE OF VARIOUS LETTERS

22 /s/ Adam R. Knecht .

22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 2

You might also like

Voip Pal Ex Parte Communication To Lead PTAB Judge

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Voip Pal Ex Parte Communication To Lead PTAB Judge

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case 2:16-cv-00260-RFB-VCF Document 35 Filed 12/18/17 Page 1 of 40

15 NOTICE OF VARIOUS LETTERS

22 /s/ Adam R. Knecht .

22  2  2!"#$%13%4&3%%% '(0(4 0 2

You might also like

22 22!"#$%13%4&3%%%'(0(40 2