Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Civic Institutions.
A study of public libraries.
1.1 Introduction 2
Aims and objectives 4
Scope and limitations 5
Methodology 6
1.2 Libraries through history 7
1.3 History of libraries in India 17
3.1 Introduction 44
3.2 National Library, Kolkata 47
3.3 David Sassoon Library and Reading Room, Mumbai 54
3.4 M.J. Library, Ahmedabad 63
3.5 Inferences 76
4.1 Introduction 78
4.2 Waterford City Library, Ireland 79
4.3 Palo Verde Library and Community Center, Phoenix, USA 90
4.4 Seattle Central Library, USA 99
4.5 Inferences 114
Bibliography 120
Interviews/E-mail correspondences 122
Illustration Credits 123
Drawing Credits 124
Acknowledgements 125
“The Library will endure: illuminated, soli-
tary, infinite, perfectly motionless, equipped
with precious volumes, useless, incorruptible,
secret.”
1.1 Introduction
1. Asiatic Society Library, Mumbai, India. The role of the library as merely a civic monument,
or as a public repository for books is fast fading. In
its place, it is developing a new mutating role as an
urban hangout, meeting place and as an arbiter of
information. The evolution of the new age library
has less to do with the digital evolution of informa-
tion than with the age-old need for human contact.
The reshaping of information brought about due
to the internet has even led the prognosticators to
speculate about the ultimate demise of the library
as a physical institution. But rather than declining,
the urban public library is surfacing as a complex
civic and social institution.
3
Introduction and History
4
Introduction and History
5
Introduction and History
Methodology
6
Introduction and History
7
Introduction and History
8
Introduction and History
9
Introduction and History
11
Introduction and History
15
Introduction and History
16
Introduction and History
Ancient India
Pre-Independence Libraries
17
Introduction and History
18
Introduction and History
20
Introduction and History
21
Introduction and History
22
Chapter 2.0
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public
Library
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
25
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
26
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
A. Urban Parameters
B. Library Parameters
Urban Parameters
2. Urban presence:
• Landmark/icon/ institutional importance
3. Style:
• Architectural language of the building.
Library Parameters
1. Spatial layout
• Allocation of areas
a) Stacking
b) Reading/ Reader Service
c) Staff and support areas
d) Services (toilets, staircases, elevators)
2. Light
• Natural light
g) Windows
h) Skylights
i) Light wells
j) Skin of the building
• Artificial light
4. Ancillary spaces
• Location of ancillary spaces
• Amalgamation/division from library
activities
5. Noise control
• Internal noise
• External noise
6. Climate control
• Temperature and humidity control
• Protection from dust
• Ventilation
8. Expansion/Flexibility
28
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
A. Urban Parameters
3. Style
29
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
i. open access
ii. Carrels
60. Reading alcoves arranged on the periphery and stacking in Individual study rooms are required where serious
the center of the Manchester Public Library.
researchers need to be undisturbed. These rooms are
30
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
vi. Catalouges
63. Catalouge sizes and arrangement diagram The staff areas need to be designed keeping in mind
the following necessities.
i. Arrival and dispatch of materials
ii. Accessioning
iii. Cataloguing and classifying
iv. Office areas
v. Processing
vi. Bindery
vii. Printing department
viii. Staff training section
ix. Committee rooms
x. Staff entrances
64. Staff pantry and meeting area in the DOK Library xi. Staff rest areas
2. Lighting.
33
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
3. Circulation
34
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
4. Ancillary areas
6. Climate control
36
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
8. Expansion/Flexibility
37
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
Spatial Implications
39
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
Experimental Concepts
40
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
entrance
41
Planning & Design Aspects of a Public Library
79. Reading section of the library with the glazed roof. 83. X-boxes and Playstations provided for kids and adults
80. Reading tables arranged between enclosing book stacks 84. Media collection -“Discotake”, with CD’s and DVD’s for
and provided with computer terminals for search or surfing. films and music.
81. Children’s reading area with a rug and pillows for relax- 85. Multimedia chairs designed for listening and download-
ation and no chairs or tables. ing music and videos.
82. Romance section interiors done in red. 86. Swiveling chairs designed with computer terminals pro-
vided for browsing or surfing the net.
42
Chapter 3.0
Study of Selected Public Libraries
in India
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
3.1 Introduction
45
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
46
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
Introduction
47
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
The Extensions
48
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
93. Reading Room of the National Library at Belvedere, which was formerly a Ball Room, with the
long central table, the reading alcoves on the sides and the individual carrels in the balcony above.
94. A wooden bench designed for seating in the 97. Reading tables fitted with local light fixtures
Reading Room. with indirect light for comfortable reading.
95. Carrels arranged in the balcony above the 98. Individual carrels fitted with light sources for
Reading Room against a series of windows. reading.
96. Entrance to the Children’s Library at the 99. The Children’s Library reading area.
ground floor level of Belvedere.
49
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
100. View of the north side entrance and facade Belvedere which was closed when 103. The grounds on the north side.
the National Library was shifted there.
101. View of the south side facade and the main entrance of National Library, Bel- 104. View of the north grounds from the ter-
vedere. race of Belvedere.
N.T.S.
107. Site plan of the National Library from 1987 when the initial proposal was given for a
phase II extension building (Bhasha Bhavan) for the Library.
50
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
51
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
52
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
Bhasha
Bhavan 118. The Bhasha Bhavan as seen from the ter-
race of the Belvedere.
Belvedere
119. Sattelite image of the National Library site indicating the Belvedere and the
Bhasha Bhavan in red.
53
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
Introduction
54
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
A. Urban Parameters
2. Urban Presence
55
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
3. Style of Architecture
transept
The style of the library is Revivalist Venetian Gothic.
Like the other Heritage structures in the row the li-
nave brary is made of yellow Malad stone. The columns are
of black (Deccan) trap and the dressing is in random
rubble masonry. The ground floor facade has pointed
arches decorated in white and black stripes protecting
126. Plan of the library forms a Gothic cross. the arcade. The Venetian Gothic style is noted in its
heavy, strong construction with thick walls, the style
of its openings with pointed arches, the turrets that
flank its façade and the clock tower.
56
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
Stack areas
57
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
2. Light
Natural Light
134. Entry from the staff office to The entrance passage and foyer remain dark recessed
the garden.
spaces which get little light from the door opening
into the garden as the main entrance is shaded by a
covered arcade and a portico from the M.G. Road
side. The first floor reading hall gets light from two
tall glazed wooden windows placed symmetrically on
the east and west walls and from the doors opening
towards the verandah on the south. The verandah on
the south shades the reading room from direct glare
and heat. The windows are double shuttered with
glass and wood shutter on the outer side and wooden
louvered shutters on the inner side. This allows the
windows to be completely opened for direct light or
partially opened for indirect and diffused light.
135. Office area for the assistant
librarians on the ground level.
Artificial Light
137. Chandelier above the foyer area. 141. Truss supporting the wooden roof from which the
chandelier is suspended.
142. The reading hall and the door opening to the ve-
randah on the south side.
140. Chandelier in the entrance passage. 143. Light fixtures in the ceiling of the reading hall.
59
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
3. Circulation/Accessibility
4. Ancillary Spaces
61
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
7. Expansion/Flexibility
8. Technology
62
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
Introduction
63
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
A. Urban Parameters
2. Urban Presence
3. Style of Architecture
154. The library in 1945 with the front garden.
The building was designed by Claude Batley of Greg-
son Batley and King, an Anglo-Indian firm based in
Mumbai and executed by his assistant Mr. Sharma
(Desai). The library was built when there was a strong
attempt to emphasize and define the Indian identity;
at a time when the struggle for independence was at
its peak. Claude Batley believed in using elements
of past architecture of India along with elements of
western architecture to evolve the definition of mod-
ern Indian architecture. Unlike the Town Hall (1940)
155. Corner of the library compound wall which
has a bust of Balvantrai Thakore.
built by Claude Batley which has a distinct Art Deco
64
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
159. Portico at the entrance to the reading hall. Elevation of the portico at the entrance of the reading hall
0.75 2.25 5.25 m
65
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
66
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
Stack areas
Staff area
67
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
173. Circulating Library collection on the first floor. 177. Card catalouge shelves.
2. Light 179. Cabins for the librarians and the committe room
on the ground floor, north wing of the library.
Natural Light
The new building has three floors and thus blocks the
entry of light into the old building from the western
side. Entry of light from the central court is minimal
due to the small and insufficient openings most of 181. Windows in the reading hall, east wing
which are usually kept closed. The facades in the new
building have a series of continuous windows but the
light quality is reduced due to the wire mesh which is
used to seal up most of the windows. Most windows
in the new parts of the library have a fixed double
layer of metal grill and wire mesh which reduces the
amount of light considerably and prevents the win-
dows from being completely opened up for light
and ventilation. But the windows in the old part are
double shuttered with glazed shutter on the outer side
and wire meshed shutter on the inner. This allows the
windows to be partially or completely open and helps
to control the amount of light required.
182. Windows in the english stack section
on the first floor.
69
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
Artificial Light
4. Ancillary Spaces
70
emergency exit
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
7. Expansion/Flexibility
73
Study of Selected Public Libraries in India
8. Technology
75
3.5 Inferences
76
Chapter 4.0
Study of Selected Contemporary
Public Libraries
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
4.1 Introduction
78
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Introduction
A. Urban Parameters
2. Urban Presence
3. Style of Architecture
80
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Plan of Waterford showing the location of the library in the zone of archaeological potential
81
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
197. Street view of the library along the Lady Lane The extension of the library was carried out for the
side.
purpose of accommodating a new range of digital
technology and facilities for the community of read-
ers. This consisted of a special area provided for in-
ternet facility, an audio library and facility for readers
with impaired vision to be able to read on enlarged
screens.
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
Stack areas
Reading area
Staff areas
2. Light
Natural Light
84
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
3. Circulation/Accessibility
200. View of the new block and the main entrance of the The central hall which was originally the main reading
library.
hall of the library is now also used for general reading
purposes with movement through the different sec-
tions placed around it. The separate staff floor ensures
that the staff movement is restricted to one level ex-
cept for the information/control areas. Another entry
from the Bakehouse Lane into the adult section at the
ground level is kept closed.
86
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
7. Expansion/Flexibility
8. Technology
88
originally a caretaker’s
house
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Introduction
A. Urban Parameters
90
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
2. Urban Presence
3. Style of Architecture
The new building design has an innovative modern 210. Metal box of the library and the masonry administration
block connected with the in-between breezeway.
approach. The buildings have been kept in line with
the street but to avoid making a wall in between the
park on the west and the street on the east, the two
91
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
213. Street facing metal volumes resting on continuous The building design manifests what the architect Wen-
bands of glass. dell Burnette calls the ‘mind/body’ duality, with the
library for intellectual contemplation and a sports hall
for physical recreation (Slessor 51). The complex pro-
vides both facilities to its community members in an
enclosed, temperature controlled structure. The func-
tions are organized in a user-friendly and functional
means which is easily accessible even for people with
physical disabilities. The most contributing factor is
the proximity of the buildings and the visual connec-
tion as well as the common circulation between the
two. The idea is to remove the confinement of the
library as a secluded, isolated space and to locate it
such that it creates a sociable sense of awareness of
the other surrounding activities and a sense of being
connected to them. The complex contributes to the
general urban wellbeing of the community by stimu-
214. Sports hall in the community center which is visually
lating both the mind and the body and providing an
connected to the library collections opposite via the glazed attractive ambience for the users.
bands.
92
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
Staff areas
2. Light
Natural Light
93
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Artificial Light
3. Circulation/Accessibility
219. Breezeway continuing the main axis for circulation The user and staff accessibility is split with a separate
within the library.
staff access into the southwestern masonry block. The
vehicular access for the book drop and book shipping/
receiving are also provided in a separate entry into the
staff block. The breezeway entering the library acts
as a multi purpose area by functioning as the main
movement spine and also holding the main informa-
tion desk along with other reference tables provided
for browsing.
4. Ancillary Spaces
220. Vehicular entry from the private access drive for the 5. Noise and Climate Control
library parking and the book drop
96
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
7. Expansion/Flexibility
8. Technology
98
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Introduction
99
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
A. Urban Parameters
2. Urban Presence
100
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
3. Style of Architecture
B. Library Parameters
1. Spatial Layout
Stack areas
103
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Reading Areas
237. Diagonally arranged stacks in the fiction section on The other reading area is on level 3 in the ‘Living
level 3. Room’ which is an informal space on the southern
side from the entrance at the 5th Avenue. This is more
of a browsing area for the fiction stacks, periodicals
and has provision for accessing personal laptops.
Seattle’s Living Room is not about research, or any
explicit library-related task but it’s about pleasure ori-
ented activities with its coffee area, gift shop, fiction
stacks, teen center and its unrestrained use of space
for meeting friends, browsing or just relaxing. It be-
comes a close parallel to a public space and a center
238. Reading galleries on level 10 in the ‘Betty Jane Narver for the community within the city.
Reading Room’.
The reference section on level 5 has computers dedi-
cated to the catalog and subscription databases, a gen
104
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Staff Areas
The main staff levels are on level 2 and level 11 and 239. Staff Headquarter’s platform on level 11 seen above
from the reading room on level 10.
both these levels are restricted only to the staff. Level
2 has shipping, receiving, book sorting and technical
and collection services. It also has the loading dock,
the book conveyor and space for storing book carts.
This level deals with the general receiving, sorting and
re-shelving of the checked in books. It also deals with
the arrival, dispatch and distribution of new books.
Level 11, which is the topmost level of the library, is
the main administrative platform and is known as the
headquarters. It has all the administrative offices, the
head librarian’s office, the board room, staff lounge
and meeting and conference rooms. 240. Meeting room platform on level 4 seen from level 3
‘Living Room’.
The other staff areas are on level 4 with conference
and meeting rooms along with two Boeing Technolo-
gy Training Center labs used for public and staff com-
puter instruction. On level 5 the ‘Mixing Chamber’
has a large interdisciplinary area where the librarians
work and interact with the users by providing neces-
sary help and information. Every level has its own
administrative office space along with service and in-
formation desks in each section.
2. Light
241. Bookshelf lighting in the fiction stacks.
Natural Light
105
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
Artificial Light
3. Circulation/Accessibility
106
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
For easy navigation all the vertical circulation servic- 248. Staircase leading from level 4 meeting rooms to level
es have been painted neon- chartreuse except for the 5 ‘Mixing Chamber’.
4. Ancillary Spaces
7. Expansion/Flexibility
110
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
drastic change and the other group has all the func-
tions which might need to be modified or spatially
altered over a period of time. The parking, staff level,
meeting rooms, book-spiral and the administrative
headquarters are all placed in 5 platforms as fixed,
permanent functions. The in-between functions are
the ones which require flexibility and change over a
period of time. These spaces are mostly public areas
with distinctive service and sections and will most
likely change with the growing number of readers and
the changing technology. This division encourages
change by redefining use and forming new programs
in certain sections but not at the cost of encroachment
on other fixed sections.
The main concern was for the growing number of 254. Platforms with fixed functions and in-between flexible
areas for future changes and expansion.
non-fiction stacks which formed 75% of the collec-
tion of the library. This problem was solved by the
design of a book-spiral which is a 4-storey continuous
ramp with enough room to double the current hold-
ings of around 750,000 books to about 1.4 million.
This means that the continuing collections grow with-
in the fixed platform of the book-spiral without being
shifted or divided into other areas. Compact shelving
has been provided along with the stacks for accommo-
dating the growing collections. The aluminum floor-
ing in the technological sections has interchangeable
square units, and is screwed on to raised plenums to
accommodate inevitable changes in the technological
need (Lamprecht 56). 255. Search and technical section in the book spiral.
8. Technology
111
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
112
Study of Selected Contemporary Public Libraries
113
4.5 Inferences
114
Chapter 5.0
Conclusion
Conclusion
Conclusion
116
Conclusion
117
Conclusion
118
Chapter 6.0
Appendices
Bibliography
Books
Borges, Jorge Luis. “The Library of Babel.” Labyrinths. Ed. James E. Irby. Argentina: Editorial Sur, 1962.
Caldenby, Claes and Hultin, Olof. Asplund. New York: Rizzoli International Publications, 1986
Fletcher, Banister. A History of Architecture. 19th edition. Ed. John Musgrove. London: The Butterworth Group, 1987.
Fleming, John, Honour, Hugh and Pevsner, Nikolaus. The Penguin Dictionary of Architecture and Landscape Architec-
ture. Fifth edition. Great Britain and USA: Penguin Group: 1999.
Gutheim, Frederick. Alvar Aalto. George Braziller, Inc. New York, 1960
Hughes, J. Quentin and Lynton, Norbert. Renaissance Architecture. London: Longman, 1964
Jones, Peter Blundell. Modern Architecture Through Case Studies. Oxford: Architectural Press, 2002
Kesavan, B.S. India’s National Library. Kolkata: The National Library of India, 1961
Konya, Allan. Libraries: A Briefing and Design Guide. London: The Architectural Press, 1986
Majumder, Uma. India’s National Library: Systematization and Modernization. The National Library of India, 1987
Mehrotra, Rahul and Savant, Sandhya. The Fort Precinct in Bombay: A Proposal for Area Conservation Volume II. Mum-
bai: Urban Design Research Institute, 1994.
Nair, P. Thankappan. Echoes From Belvedere: Home of National Library, Kolkata. Kolkata: Associated Book Agency,
2006
Nair, P. Thankappan. Origin of The National Library of India. Kolkata: Associated Book Agency, 2006
Norberg-Schulz, Christian. Meaning in Western Architecture. New York: Rizzoli International, 1981
Pevsner, Nikolaus. A History of Building Types. London: Thames & Hudson, 1976
Thompson, Godfrey. Plannin and Design of Library Buildings, Third edition. London: Butterworth Architecture, 1989.
Journals/Articles
Boddy, Trevor. “Civic Locus: From Galleries to Libraries.” The Architectural Review: The Library and The City. Vol.
CCXIX no. 1312, June 2006.
C.S. “Layers of Meaning.” The Architectural Review: Mass. Vol. CCXV no. 1283, Jan. 2004.
Davey, Peter. “Book Cases.” The Architectural Review: Libraries. Vol. CCIII no. 1216, June 1998.
120
Graham, Clare. “Libraries in History.” The Architectural Review: Libraries. Vol. CCIII no. 1216, June 1998.
Graham, Barbara. “Integrating New Technology: Research Libraries Enter The Future.” INSPEL 30. Paper delivered at the
Open Session of the section Social Science Libraries at the 62nd IFLA General Conference. Beijing, 27 August 1996: 316-
323.
Lamprecht, Barbara. “The Nice and The Good.” The Architectural Review: Material Benefits. Vol. CCXX no. 1314, Aug.
2006.
Menon, A.G. Krishna. “Landmark Library.” Frontline. Vol. 19, issue 11, May 25-June 07, 2002.
Nair, R. Raman. “National Library of India: A Historical Perspective.” International Library Movement. Vol. 9, no. 1. India,
1987: 8-21
Nair, R. Raman. “Public Library System in Ancient South India.” ILA Bulletin. Vol. XXVII, no.2, July-Sept 1991.
Slessor, Catherine. “Suburban Oasis.” The Architectural Review: Hot Issues. Vol. CCXX no. 1314, Aug. 2006.
Internet Articles/Websites
Becker, Lynn. “Sleekness in Seattle.” 2006. Repeat: An archive of writing on architecture in Chicago and the world. 13 May
2008. http://lynnbecker.com/repeat/seattle/seattlepl.htm.
Boekesteijn, Erik. “Discover Innovations at DOK, Holland’s Library Concept Center.” Mar/Apr 2008, Marketing Library
Services. Vol. 22 No. 2. http://www.infotoday.com/MLS/mar08/Boekesteijn.shtml.
Brown-Syed, Christopher. “All Roads Lead to Rome.” 16 Sept. 2003. Ancient and Medieval Libraries. 27 March 2008 http://
www.ithaca.edu/history/journal/papers/sp02ancientlibraries.html
DelFraino, Steve. “Seattle Public Library - Detailing the Skin.” Architecture Week. 3 October 2007. Artifice, Inc. 10 May
2008. http://www.architectureweek.com/2007/1003/building_1-2.html.
Draft Development Plan. “Schedule 1”. December 2006, Planning & Development Act, 2000. 13 Aug. 2008.
http://www.waterfordcity.ie/documents/developmentplan/Schedule1-RPS.pdf.
Draft Development Plan. “Schedule 2”. December 2006, Planning & Development Act, 2000. 13 Aug. 2008.
http://www.waterfordcity.ie/documents/developmentplan/Schedule2-%20ACAs.pdf.
Krasner-Khait, Barbara. “Survivor: The History of the Library.” History Magazine. October/November 2001. 24 March 2008
http://www.history-magazine.com/libraries.html.
Levine, Jenny. “Visiting the Most Modern Library in the World.” 19 March 2008. The Shifted Librarian, TSL Archives. 12
May 2008 http://www.theshiftedlibrarian.com/archives/2008/03/19/visiting-the-most-modern-library-in-the-world.html.
Rawlinson, Linnie. “Seattle Central Library: Creating the perfect public space.” 2 August 2007. Cable News Network. 13
May 2008. http://edition.cnn.com/TECH.
Spoon, Jacalyn.C. “Ancient Libraries of Greece and Rome: A Summary of Research Findings”, 1999. http://www.ithaca.
edu/history/journal/papers/sp02ancientlibraries.html.
121
Stockholm Library, Great Buildings Online. 2008, Artifice, Inc. 10 May 2008. http://www.GreatBuildings.com/build-
ings/Stockholm_Library.html.
Such, Robert. “Seattle Public Library.” Architecture Week. 20 April 2005. Artifice, Inc. 24 March 2008. http://www.
architectureweek.com/2005/0420.html.
Waterford City Development Plan. 21 Jan. 2002. Waterford City Council. 13 Aug. 2008. http://www.waterfordcity.
ie/documents/developmentplan/CityDevelopmentPlan.pdf.
“Welcome to the Library of King Ashurbanipal Web Page.” 27 March 2008 http://web.utk.edu/~giles.
“History of David Sassoon Library.” David Sassoon Library and Reading Room Archive.
English Pamphlet. “Sheth Maneklal Jethabhai Pustakalay (M.J. Library).” Ahmedabad: M.J. Library, March 24, 2006.
The Sassoon Mechanics’ Institute. “Library and Reading Room.”. Bombay: September 1930. David Sassoon Library
and Reading Room Archive.
Students Work
Patel, Sameer. Critical Look into Revivalist Trend in Architecture with Reference to Ahmedabad. Ahmedabad: CEPT
Univ. School of Architecture, 2003 (TH-0826)
Vohra, Nasir Ahmed M. Study of Design Norms for Libraries of Educational Institutes. Ahmedabad: CEPT Univ.
School of Architecture, 1989 (TH-0384)
Interviews
Mr. David Cartoz Architect from Bombay Collaborative, the firm in charge of restoring the
David Sassoon Library
Prof. R.J. Vasavada Initial architect for the proposal to renovate M.J. Library by the AMC
Prof. Miki Desai Research on the architectural style and elements of M.J. Library
Mr. Vivekanand R. Ajgaonkar President Emeritus, David Sassoon Library & Reading Room
Mr. Shantibhai B. Patel Principal Librarian at M.J. Library
Mr. Ashim Mukherjee Library information officer, at the National Library of India
Mr. P. Thankappan Nair Historian and author on Kolkata and the National Library
E-mail correspondences
122
Illustration Credits
All the illustrations, photographs and drawings included in this document are unless specifically credited as
otherwise, the work of the author.
2, 30 http://www.greatbuildings.com/buildings/Stockholm_Library.html
3 The Architectural Review, June 2006, pg. 59
4 The Architectural Review, June 2006, pg. 6
5 AEQUO architects, lecture by Aat Vos at the NBD reunion.
6, 70, 74, 78-79 ‘The Shifted Librarian’ photoset, http://flickr.com
83, 84
7 http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/arcnat/lascaux.html
8 http://www.history-magazine.com/libraries.html
9a http://ecai.org/iraq/siteplan.asp?siteid=14
9b, 10 http://archaeotype.dalton.org/library/oldsite/seventh.html
11 http://www.british museum.org
12 Library of Alexandria - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
13, 14 Roman Architecture, J.B.W. Perkins
15 A History of Architecture, Sir Banister Fletcher, pg. 260
16, 19, 20, 21, 26 The Architectural Review, June 1998, pg. 72-74
17 Meaning in Western Architecture, Christian Norberg-Schulz, pg.138
18, 22 Renaissance Architecture, J.Q. Hughes and L. Norbert, pg. 115, 372
23 British Museum Reading Room - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
24 Bibliotheque Nationale, http://www.greatbuildings.com
25, 26 Bibliotheque Ste. Genevieve, http://www.essential-architecture.com
27 Public Libraries Act, http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk
28 Survivor: The History of the Library, http://www.history-magazine.com
29 Modern Architecture through Case Studies, Peter B. Jones, pg. 125
30 http://www.earchitect.co.uk
31 http://modblog.tate.org.uk
32, 33, 34 Alvar Aalto, Frederick Gutheim, images 9-11, 16
35, 36 Vistara - The Architecture of India, pg. 40-41
37 Asiatic Society of Bombay - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
38-45, 47, 88, 108 Origin of India’s National Library, P.T. Nair, plates 1, 5, 6, 7, 10, 15
46, 89, 90, 91 India’s National Library, B.S. Kesavan
49, 50 Delhi Public Library website, http://www.dpl.gov.in
51 Frontline, May 25 - June 07, 2002, http://www.hinduonnet.com
52, 53 The Architectural Review, June 2006, pg. 81-82
54, 55, 56 Libraries: A Briefing and Design Guide, Allan Konya
57 The Architectural Review, April 2005, pg. 63
58, 59, 63 Libraries: A Briefing and Design Guide, Allan Konya
60, 65, 68, 69 Planning and design of library buildings, Godfrey Thompson, pg. 43, 79, 89
61 The Architectural Review, June 1998, pg. 70
62, 64, 70, 81, AEQUO Architects, http://www.aequo.nl
82, 85, 86
66 http://www.flickr.com
67 Bibliotheque Ste. Genevieve, http://www.greatbuildings.com
72, 73 The Architectural Review, April 2005, pg. 63
76, 77 Dok Architecten, http://www.dok-architecten.nl
93-95, 97, 98 Archives of the National Library
107 India’s National Library, Uma Majumder, plate 4
119, 206 Google satellite image
120 David Sassoon - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
122, 123 The Fort Precinct in Bombay, Volume 2, Rahul Mehrotra.
150, 154 Archive of M.J. Library
152 http://www.gujaratestate.com/ahmedabadmap.php
191, 205 Google Maps
123
192, 194 City Development Plan, http://www.waterfordcity.ie
193 Draft Development Plan 2008-2014, http://www.waterfordcity.ie
196, 200, 201 Waterford City Library, http://www.archrecord.construction.com
197, 199, 202-204 The Architectural Review, Jan. 2004, pg. 42-47
207-210, 213-218, e-mailed by Gould Evans, Palo_Verde_-_Maryvale.pdf
220-222
223, 227, 231 Seattle Central Library - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
226, 225, 232, 233, REX – Architecture, http://www.rex-ny.com/work/seattle-library/
236, 249, 250, 260
224, 228, 230, 234, Seattle Public Library website http://www.spl.org
235, 237, 238-242,
248, 252-259
229, 244, 245 Seattle Public Library, http://www.greatbuildings.com
243, 246 Seattle Public Library, http://www.arcspace.com
251 Seattle Public Library, http://news-world-architects.com
Drawing Credits
Architectural drawings provided by Mr. David Cartoz, architect, Bombay Collaborative, Mumbai for the res-
toration of the library building. The drawings have been re-drawn and additional information concerning the
interior spatial layout and use of space has been added by the author.
Measure drawings prepared by Mr. Bakul Jani under the guidance of Prof. R.J. Vasavada for his project for
A.M.C. Ahmedabad. The additional information concerning the interior spatial layout and use of space has
been added by the author.
Library drawings acquired from The Architectural Review, Jan 2006, Vol. CCXV no. 1283. Waterford City
Development plans obtained from - http://www.waterfordcity.ie/documents/developmentplan/DraftDevelop-
mentPlan2008-2014Map-CityCentreOnly.pdf
Drawings e-mailed by Josh Bentley, Gould Evans as Palo_Verde_-_Maryvale.pdf for 2007 Institute Honor
Awards for Architecture. The drawings have been re-drawn and additional information concerning the use of
space has been added by the author. Section AA on plate 9 is from The Architectural Review, April 2005, Vol.
CCXVII no. 1298 and is re-drawn by the author.
Architectural drawings e-mailed by Jodee Fenton, Seattle Public Library as Central Plans Part 1.pdf, Central
Plans Part 2.pdf. Additional information concerning the use of space has been added by the author. Satellite
Images on page 101 are from google. Site elevation and sketches on pg. 101 and plate 10 are from The Seattle
Public Library OMA’s Concept Book, http://www.spl.org and http://www.arcspace.com
Site plan and all level plans from Architecture in the Netherlands Yearbook 2007-08, “DOK Architecten/AE-
QUO Architects Mediatheek/Multimedia Center”, NAI Publishers, Jan. 2008.
124
Acknowledgements
To Professor Qamar Shaikh for his clear guidance in understanding and structuring this thesis. His faith in
the topic, encouragement in times of confusion and emphasis on self-discovery and learning has been an
important motivation for this exploratory study.
To Professor Ismet Khambatta for her initial guidance and discussions in arriving at the research topic. Spe-
cial thanks to her for pushing me to explore and understand more.
Thanks to Professor R.J. Vasavada for his crucial insights and for lending drawings and information on M.J.
Library from his personal collection. I also wish to thank him for his insightful discussions on the topic.
Thanks to Professor Prabhakar Bhagwat for his interest, enthusiasm and discussions on libraries. His enthusi-
asm and faith have been inspiring.
Thanks to Professor Aniket Bhagwat for his encouragement and assurance in me.
Thanks to Professor Miki Desai and Madhavi Desai for their impromptu discussion and insight on M.J.
Library.
Thanks to Mr. David Cartoz for his help and information on David Sassoon Library and thanks to Mr. Ashim
Mukherjee for all his help and guidance on The National Library.
I wish to thank all the librarians and architects who have helped and provided valuable information via
discussions and e-mail correspondences. Special thanks to both Aat Vos, AEQUO for his liberal sharing of
information on his own lectures and designs and staff of the Seattle Public Library for their speedy help in
seeking information.
Thanks to all my amazing friends who have supported, helped and pushed me to finish my work.
Thanks to my mother and all my family for their patient support and in making me realize that my time is
valuable and so should not be wasted.
Above all, very special thanks to my elder brother for his long lasting patience, indulgence, care and his
timely impatience. He has opened this wonderful world of architecture to me and from his collection I’ve
been sneaking out books since I was ten.
125