Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Liberal thinkers have accepted common arrangement. Manners family income and
women supervise domestic expenditure. Indian concept of “Gruhalaxmi” what follows
from this is:
1) Wife should not go out to work because then she will not be able to do her domestic
duties properly.
2) Wife should contribute her labor and household his money or capital.
3) Both men and women are accepted as equal but both have different roles or duties to
perform.
4) Women should have civil right to vote, right to education etc.
5) Indian social reform of 19th century was influenced by this idea. Hence, they started
movements for abolition “Sali” practice, widow remarriage, women’s education etc. so
these women become better wife and mother.
6) According to these social reformer and liberal feminist the basic structure of the
society should be reformed and not restructured.
7) Accumulation of reforms will bring transformation.
8) It becomes imp political weapon.
Liberal feminism is widely diffused approach in contemporary women’s movements.
There are many issues taken up by women activists such as careers for women, equal
parenting, gender free education etc. One of the topics widely discussed is public and
private spheres of activities. Men are for public sphere there is money, power, status,
freedom, choice, opportunities to grow, self-worth and other rewards of social life.
Women are for private sphere which has no particular value. It has endless round of
demanding, mindless, unpaid and undervalued lasts associated with house work. Child
case and emotional practical serving to men. All this restrict women’s access to public
sphere, burden them with family responsibilities and isolate them into individual
household, so that they cannot come together and unite themselves. This distribution of
social rewards is unfair and unequal. The main reason for this is sexist attitude. This
consists partly of prejudices and discrimination practices against women and partly taken
for granted belief about the “natural” differences between women and men. These biases
are transmitted through family socialization and school educational system.
Liberal feminism dominated till 1960s. Yet did not provide any explanation or roots of
women but accepted the existing social order as valid. The advocated for improvement
of social customs, institution, laws, attitudes without altering social structure. The
strongly believed that progression reforms will lead to real and substantial equality for
women as individuals. Liberal feminists state that democracy and democratic structure
constitute essential condition for successful reform. Radical change could only diminish
the available freedom and justice for both men and women.
Radical feminism
Radical feminism is also known as revolutionary feminism. It is difficult to distinguish
between radical and socialist feminism. Many times radical feminist movement emerged
because radical of the bad experiences women had in the socialist movement. Liberal
feminist blame the system and/or socialization process. Socialist feminism but blames an
economic and cultural exploitation and capitalism, while radical feminism blame men and
patriarchy.
Both radical and socialist feminists have their roots in Marxist concepts at class-conflict
and exploitation. Engel in his book,‟‟ the origin at family, private property, and the
state” provide a starting point by explaining that women’s oppression originated in the
first division at labor between men and women a division that has been sharpened by
the women a division that has been sharpened by the advent at capitalism and the
biological family from this socialist feminist get their theoretical backing radicalists
develop revolutionary ideas.
Radical feminist’s main demand is destruction of patriarchy. There are three emotionally
charged beliefs stared by radicalists:-
1) Women are of absolute positive value as men this belief is asserted against what they
claim to be universal devaluation at women.
2) Women are everywhere violently oppressed by the system at patriarchy
3) Roots at women’s subordination are in the biological family, the hierarchical sexual
division at society & sex roles. Biological differences are linked with social distribution at
power, wealth and status.
According to radical feminists, patriarchy is an autonomous historical fast, preserved
through marriage and family. It is expressed in variety at ways in various institution,
however in all these institutions, power is always with men and every institution and in
society’s most basic structure some people dominated other e.g. caste class ethnicity
etc. In all these system of domination the most fundamental structure of oppression is
gender, the system of patriarchy starting from the patriarchy family system men learn to
dominate or to oppression.
According to radical feminists, patriarchy is the least noticed and yet the most significant
structure of inequality. Even men activities in socialist movement are not clear about
gender inequality.
Patriarchy exists in a near universal form because man can muster the most basic power
resource, physical force. Men create and maintain patriarchy because it is in their own
interest. Violence may be hidden in more complex practices of exploitation and control in
fashions, beauty contest, films and media. Men create and maintain patriarchy because
they have real interest in women and necessary for reproduction. For this men keep
women under control.
We conclude this discussion a radical feminism starting that they have done significant
cross-culture research to support their theory. They also have action plan to deal with
the issues. 46
Theoretically radical feminism combines both, Marxist and Psychoanalytical feminism
probing the reasons or causes of women’s subordination.
__________________
Socialist Feminism:
This is a very broad term and included different shades. It is a diverse cluster of
writings, referring to different cultural situations. All these types of socialist feminism
share theoretical background though three different ideologies viz. Marxian, radical and
phenomenological. Socialist feminism has its roots in Marxian thoughts and it is linked
with radical feminism. Like any other type of feminism, socialist feminism also stresses
women’s perspective. Hence, it is close to phenomenology stating women’s subjective
construction of social reality.
Socialist feminists set three main goals for themselves. These are:-
1) To achieve a combination of breadth and precision, so that all forms it oppression are
explored and that exploration is anchored in women’s experiences. Hence the stress is
on finding out different form of oppression of women; either within the family or
outsider. Then to develop a common agenda for women’s movements.
2) To develop explicit and adequate methods for social analysis by standing in an
expended nation of historical materialism. All types of socialist feminisms rely on
historical materialism. Throughout history material culture, systems of production are
owned by one class and used it as a weapon to exploit labor class. This labor also
includes labor class women. Hence, socialist feminists aim to find out different methods
to gain information and to use it.
3) To treat ideas as equal to material production in determing human affairs.
Socialist feminist stress two main area of work one is wage labor. Society is a root cause
of all economic exploitation and oppression. Given is socialist society women‟s
inequalities continued. Like other oppressed groups, women provide labor for low pay do
all routine, unpleasant domestic work and they are politically docile. Their work with in
the family and outside is seen as secondary. Therefore, they can be hired and fired
according to economic conditions of patriarch husband or employer. Women in an exploit
table section of society. Hence, the liberal feminist position is that women are
discriminated against because of flows in the system that should change. The socialist
feminist claim that women are exploited because of the system itself the capitalist
days gain from exploitation of working class and worked acting as ageist and exploiting
women in their families.
Socialist feminist argue family needs to be transformed. They have focused on
something ignored by earlier economist’s theorist. That is to say the family functions as
a private domain of work. House work is a form of labor which is unpaid and hence has
no status. This give rise to stereo type image of women is petty minded, jealous,
irrational, emotional.
Types of Socialist Feminism:
As stated before there are different types of socialist feminism. One such group focuses
of women’s operation and understands it by combing together knowledge of class and
gender oppression. Though this they try to map out commonalities and a variation is
women’s experiences of domination. The second group describes and explains, all forms
of social oppression using knowledge of class, and gender hierarchies as a base from
which to explore oppression in class, gender, race, ethnicity, religion etc. The word they
use is domination.
Women remain in the center in socialist feminism in two ways.
1) Oppression of women becomes primary topic of analysis. They describe various forms
of domination or oppression.
2) Women’s location and experience of world serve as an essential vintage point of
domination in all its forms. They also talk about women dominating other women e.g.
upper caste women dominating lower-caste or while women dominating black women.
According to socialist view, “women is inferior position is rooted private property and
class decided society family structure in such society maintains women’s inferior status
exploitation is a part of oppression. Yet oppression is a large complex process. Power is
divided in sex and class & this is manifested materially and ideologically in patriarchy
and class relation. The major task is to discover inter–dependence between patriarchy
and class structure. Socialist feminist believe the overthrowing of capitalist system by
itself will not transform patriarchal ideology. Hence, it is necessary to organize struggle
simultaneously against capitalism and patriarchy from private family life ho public social
life oppression of women take place.
According to socialist feminist, the powerlessness of women in society is rooted in four
basic structures production, Reproduction, sexuality and socialization of children. Family
and economy should not be looked upon as separate systems, but as vitally interacting
systems. Socialist feminists have raised debate over households worth women’s
oppression is based on unpaid work, child bearing child care house work are material
activities resulting in products. Such products have use value but not exchange value.
Criticisms of socialist feminist approach:
The important criticism of socialist feminism and indeed all varieties of feminism that
despite their emancipator claims they lend to be located in the assumption and
aspiration at urban middle class women. There is growing concern within feminist theory
over practical and theoretical problems passed by the exploitation of women of one
class, rare ethnic group and religious community by another group
To conclude this discussion on socialists feminism, we can say, this is most active group
amongst feminist. Using Marx and Engel‟s frame work they have observed & analyzed
women’s problems. Oppressed women’s involvement in the struggle is achieved by
socialist feminist.
CONCEPT OF VIOLENCE:
According to United Nations Declaration of Elimination of Violence against Women in the
book “Women in the Third World” (1998); Violence is defined as any act of gender based
violence that results in, or is likely to result in physical, sexual or psychological harm or
suffering to women, including threats of such acts, coercion or arbitrary deprivations of
liberty whether occurring in public or private life. It shall be understood to encompass
but not be limited to physical, sexual & psychological violence occurring in the family &
in the community including battering, sexual abuse of female children, dowry violence,
marital rape & other traditional practices harmful to woman.
VIOLENCE WITHIN HOME
It is one area in which very little amount of evidence is available. Girl child abuse within
the home takes place in various forms.
2) The various forms are sexual aggression, beatings and child labor.
3) All available studies on girl child abuse have shown that the abuse is of physical and
emotional nature.
4) The causes of the girl child abuse are the environment at home, social environment as
well as life situations. All these three factors are significant in nature.
5) One of the most common forms of girl child abuse at home is sexual molestation and
rape.
6) Families rarely talk about issues such as rape very openly. If a daughter has been
raped, there is a tendency to suppress the matter. If the rapist is a family member such
as father, brother or an uncle, the chances of reporting the rape case is almost nil.
7) In this situation, the child does not get the necessary support even from her mother.
The mother may try to suppress the event in order to protest her own family members.
8) However a few cases of molestation and rape of their girl child were reported my
mothers to the Crime against women cell in Delhi. This was a significant step taken by
the mothers. However, the mothers expected the police to merely give a warning to the
offending family member and not file any case against him.
9) Young girls became easy targets or victims of sexual violence. Out of the 10,000
reported cases in 1990, 2.5% of the victims were girls below the age of 16 and about
1/5th of the victims were below the age of 10 years. This clearly indicates the
seriousness of the problem of sexual violence against girl child.
10) One important aspect related to sexual violence of very young girls is that since the
victims are very young, they are not able to understand the meaning of this sexual
violence. It means they are not able to differentiate between beatings and sexual
violence. As a result, the girl child rape has to be understood from a different point of
view as compared to the rape of a girl of a higher age.
__________________
make a wish, take a chance, make a change