Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This report presents the result of a fractal analysis of human for many decades. Researchers have introduced different terms
sagittal sutures using documented dry skull specimens. In 1999 to describe this growth. For example, Enlow (1975) used the
a theoretical model of cranial growth and adaptation was pro- phrase architectonic equilibrium, and Hanken and Hall (1993)
posed by Yu et al. This crude but effective model explained called it the epigenetic cascade. At the heart of this cranial
how growth of different parts of the cranium can be synchro- growth model is the repeated iteration function, also known as
nized solely by the expansion of the brain. Such coordinated, the recursive function, a special form of mathematical opera-
synchronized growth of the cranial bones has been recognized tions in which a rule or set of rules (iterators) are repeatedly
applied such that each output becomes the input for the next
iteration (Yu et al., 2001b). When a system with many inter-
Dr. Yu is the Director of the Craniofacial Center at the Medical College of acting elements undergoes repeated iterations of a set of rules,
Georgia, Augusta, Georgia. Mr. Wright is currently a graduate student in the the results are optimization of some parameters pertaining to
Department of Anthropology at the University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida. these elements as defined by the rules. Very often there is
Dr. Williamson is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Health and Ki-
nesiology, Mr. Braselton is an Assistant Professor of Mathematics, and Dr.
generation of fractals, an example of such being the branching
Abell is a Professor of Mathematics at Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, morphogenesis of the tracheal-bronchial tree (Bassingthwaite
Georgia. et al., 1994). The products of these recursive functions can
This work was presented at the 58th Annual Meeting of the American Cleft manifest as either temporal or spatial fractal patterns.
Palate–Craniofacial Association; Minneapolis, Minnesota; April 23 to 28, 2001. The word fractal, first coined by Benoit Mandelbrot in the
Submitted March 2002; Accepted August 2002.
Address correspondence to: Dr. Jack Yu, Section of Plastic Surgery, De-
1970s and referred to by Kauffman (1993), means break or
partment of Surgery, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta, Georgia 30912- fragment. Fractal objects have self-similar features, that is, re-
4080. E-mail jyu@mail.mcg.edu. peating details emerge as the scales change, with parts resem-
409
410 Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, July 2003, Vol. 40 No. 4
1424 WH M 51 1.34442
Specimen Race* Sex* Age D
1481 WH M 54 1.36254
139R WH F 56 1.27293 1506 BL M 26 1.33822
335 WH M 18 1.43658 1507 BL F 23 1.35089
525 WH M 49 1.34646 1539 BL M 23 1.12404
529 BL F 37 1.32783 1544 BL F 23 1.28476
540 BL M 40 1.29605 1553 BL F 30 1.18061
541 BL F 28 1.27675 1563 WH F 29 1.20896
561 BL F 22 1.12936 1571 WH F 55 1.36239
562 BL F 17 1.37122 1572 WH F 45 1.27570
563 WH M 41 1.26303 1591 WH M 19 1.34547
565 BL M 32 1.22827 1594 WH F 40 1.24335
566 WH M 40 1.35203 1599 WH F 41 1.40929
568 BL F 27 1.06788 1600 BL F 26 1.17175
570 BL M 37 1.09270 1602 WH M 20 1.34160
574 BL M 35 1.38477 1607 WH M 32 1.21847
591 WH M 28 1.39704 1611 WH F 59 1.40362
592 BL M 25 1.22745 1617 WH F 35 1.14515
595 BL M 25 1.33257 1624 WH F 58 1.13098
614 WH M 50 1.29552 11R BL F 24 1.27427
676 BL M 46 1.27243 1289R BL F 28 1.38720
680 WH F 30 1.27634 1270R WH F 59 1.39326
719 BL M 25 1.25880 13R BL M 28 1.27155
760 BL M 19 1.25929 1482R WH F 35 1.40103
782 BL M 30 1.31759 161R WH F 50 1.38599
815 BL F 32 1.24656 187R WH M 29 1.47408
824 BL F 30 1.24445 225R WH F 55 1.21038
830 BL M 28 1.25485 256R WH F 50 1.38132
847 WH F 39 1.38411 311R WH M 27 1.20616
850 BL M 23 1.23709 351R WH F 30 1.42672
868 WH M 60 1.48340 405R WH F 34 1.25911
876 BL M 22 1.36455 41R WH F 41 1.34123
886 BL F 23 1.25261 612R WH F 60 1.38485
897 WH M 43 1.27859 64R WH F 57 1.26114
898 BL M 22 1.29651 69R WH F 52 1.21121
905 BL M 31 1.20557
* WH 5 white, BL 5 black, F 5 female; M 5 male.
915 BL M 27 1.19882
920 BL F 36 1.35970
926 BL F 23 1.29395
929 BL F 20 1.26876 xy-plane (two-dimensions) by graphing each the x and y co-
932 BL M 27 1.29185 ordinates of each datum point with Mathematica (Wolfram Re-
937 BL M 50 1.33633
949 BL F 24 1.40396 search). Each two-dimensional graphic was inverted (black to
970 BL M 21 1.22427 white, white to black) and saved as a bitmap file for analysis
983 WH F 30 1.28463 using a commercially available software program called Benoit
994 BL F 30 1.23571
1006 BL F 27 1.39021 (Trusoft, Inc., Tampa, FL). Benoit processed the inverted two-
1010 BL F 25 1.20597 dimensional bitmap files to compute the box-counting dimen-
1020 BL M 24 1.24048 sion, Db, also known more simply as the box dimension. This
1023 WH M 20 1.37788
1076 BL F 26 1.44519 was done by using progressively reduced sizes of the boxes in
1105 BL F 22 1.27625 a non-rotating square grid and counting the minimum number
1148 BL M 23 1.21682 of boxes containing part of the suture.
1165 BL M 26 1.30703
1186 WH F 44 1.28528 A nonrotating grid format was selected because of the an-
1187 BL M 21 1.21231 isotropic nature of the sutural pattern. The process is similar
1195 BL M 29 1.44737 to the hand calculations, except Benoit can generate approxi-
1225 WH M 59 1.23618
1232 WH M 57 1.32707 mately 10 times as many refinements (at least 50 data points)
1239R WH F 52 1.22564 per suture than the five refinements in hand calculations and
1271 WH M 58 1.03750 in a much shorter time. The slope of the graph plotting the
1274 WH M 56 1.23058
1286 WH M 50 1.33708 logarithm of the number of boxes needed to contain a given
1287 BL F 24 1.33757 suture pattern against the logarithm of the side length of the
1300 BL M 28 1.32507 boxes is referred to as the box-counting dimension, Db. These
1351 BL F 24 1.24387
1354 BL F 25 1.37791 box-counting dimensions were then statistically processed us-
1363 BL F 14 1.19994 ing Mathematica (Wolfram Research). Benoit (Trusoft) also
1383 WH M 55 1.29370 permitted the determination of Hurst exponents, H, which is
1413 BL F 27 1.37349
an indicator of autocorrelation of the data set being analyzed.
412 Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal, July 2003, Vol. 40 No. 4
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
eled and experimentally verified. Several antagonistic cou- of 0.078457. The 95% confidence interval was 1.27634 to
plings within the sutures have recently been confirmed: Twist 1.30944. Thus, with a high degree of confidence, it appears
and fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 (Johnson et al., 2000), that human sagittal sutures are fractal and can be described in
Tbx2, and connexin 43 (Chen et al., 2001), noggin and bone terms of repeated iteration functions. The underlying mecha-
morphogenic proteins (Warren et al., 2002). These signaling nism that produced these oscillations is not random. Because
peptides provide the means for a closed-loop control system the Hurst exponent is greater than 0.5, sagittal suture patterns
at the transcriptional level, which has the mature patent suture have long-range correlation: the systems demonstrate memory.
as an end product. More importantly, this type of analysis allows for the quanti-
By critically examining the characteristic of the sutures, im- tative characterization of sutural morphology and permits the
portant information can be extracted. One such parameter is testing of future hypotheses. One such hypothesis is that clo-
how serrated the suture is, quantitatively measured by Db. Fig- sure of the coronal suture increases tensile strain across the
ure 2 plots all 103 Db measured against the ages of the skulls. sagittal suture. This can be tested by comparing the sagittal
The lack of correlation between the ages of the skulls and their suture fractal dimension between normal specimens and those
sagittal suture fractal dimensions is graphically depicted. It is showing coronal craniosynostosis (if the local-regional bio-
conceivable that in some special conditions, such as hydro- mechanical strain data can be correlated with the fractal di-
cephalus, the fractal dimension will increase as time progresses mension of the suture). Efforts are under way to confirm or
because of the persistent high local strain. Such studies are refute this conjecture of strain-induced Db alteration as well as
currently being designed and conducted. In this study of the the potential mechanisms to increase the information dimen-
human sagittal sutures, the anterior-posterior axis (from breg- sion, such as oscillation of intracellular calcium ion concen-
ma to lambda) is assigned the x-axis, and the medial-lateral tration, that is necessary during the mechanotransduction pro-
variations are expressed in the corresponding y-axis (Fig. 3). cess (Yu et al., 2001a).
Variations in the sagittal plane (i.e., the z-axis data) were not Sutures are records of dynamic interactions of past events.
included to simplify the calculations. For all tracings generated Detailed fractal analysis permits the numerical characterization
by truly stochastic processes, the fractal dimension would be of the end product of this complex and robustly adaptive sys-
1.5 with their Hurst exponents equal to 0.5, indicating the lack tem. The next task is to determine how such macroscopic frac-
of both persistence and antipersistence within the data set. If, tal curves are generated from the coordinated antagonistic in-
on the other hand, the data points are not independent, the teractions between osteoblastic and osteoclastic mechanisms
deviation from H 5 0.5 tells whether a more positive y value based on the genetic and environmental inputs.
at x 5 a is more likely to have a more negative y value (an-
tipersistence) or a more positive y value (persistence) at x 5 Acknowledgments. This study was supported, in part, by a grant from the
a 1 1. This type of analysis is known as autocorrelation. Based American Society of Maxillofacial Surgeons and the Ronald E. McNair Foun-
dation. The authors also wish to thank the Smithsonian Institution for the use
on the 103 skulls studied, the human sagittal sutures demon-
of the Terry Collection.
strated definite antipersistence with H 5 0.70711. In other
words, sagittal suture morphology demonstrated memory. It is REFERENCES
entirely possible that not only does H differ between different
sutures but also within each individual suture. In the case of Bassingthwaite JB, Leibovitch LS, West BJ. The surprising statistical properties
sagittal sutures, the more anterior portion (closer to bregma) of fractals. In: Bassingthwaite JB, Leibovitch LS, West BJ, eds. Fractal
indeed appears to have less medial/lateral variation amplitude. Physiology. London: Oxford University Press; 1994:33–44.
Chen J, Zhong Q, Wang J, Cameron RS, Borke JL, Isales CM, Bollag RJ.
Future studies will have to address this quantitatively. Microarray analysis of Tbx2-directed gene expression: a possible role in
Whatever the mechanisms that produced these sagittal su- osteogenesis. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 2001;177:43–54.
ture patterns, each one being unique, the end output must obey Enlow DH. Introductory concepts of the growth process. In: DH Enlow, ed.
a simple rule. This simple rule is that log Nr 5 1.29 log 1/r, Handbook of Facial Growth. Philadelphia: Saunders Co.; 1975:18–47.
Glenny RW, Robertson HT, Yamashiro S, Bassingthwaighte JB. Application of
where Nr is the number of square boxes with sides of length
fractal analysis to physiology. J Appl Physiol. 1991;70:2351–2367.
r, which are needed to contain the sutural pattern and r equals Hanken J, Hall BK. Mechanisms of skull diversity and evolution. In: J Hanken,
to the length of the sides of the square boxes. An understand- BK Hall, ed. The Skull. Vol. 3: Functional and Evolutionary Mechanisms.
ing of this is the focus of our current investigative effort. Even Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1993:1–26.
though this study failed to show sexual dimorphism, others Johnson D, Iseki S, Wilkie AOM, Morris-Kay GM. Expression patterns of
Twist and Fgfr1, -2 and -3 in the developing mouse coronal suture suggest
have reported, at least in some human craniofacial sutures, the
a key role for Twist in suture initiation and biogenesis. Mech Dev. 2000;91:
fractal dimension can be used for reliable morphognostic sex 341–345.
determination (Schiwy-Bochat, 2001). Kauffman SA. Self-organization and adaptation in complex systems. In: SA
Kauffman, ed. The Origins of Order. New York: Oxford University Press;
CONCLUSION 1993:175–181.
Long CA. Intricate sutures as fractal curves. J Morphol. 1985;185:285–295.
Long CA, Long JE. Fractal dimension of cranial sutures and waveforms. Acta
One hundred three documented dry human skull specimens Anat. 1992;145:201–206.
were analyzed for fractal dimension calculations by the box- Mandelbrot BB. The Fractal Geometry of Nature. New York: WH Freeman
counting method. The Db was 1.29289 for the group with SD and Co.; 1983.
Yu et al., FRACTAL ANALYSIS OF HUMAN CRANIAL SUTURES 415
Monteiro LR, Lessa LG. Comparative analysis of cranial suture complexity in Warren SM, Brunet LJ, Economides AN, Harland RM, Fong KD, Longaker
the genus Caiman (Crododylia alligatoridae). Rev Bras Biol. 2000;60:689– MT. Apert and Crouzon fibroblast growth factor receptor gain-of-function
694. mutations suppress noggin: a mechanism for FGF-mediated cranial suture
Pashley DH, Borke JL, Yu JC. Biomechanics and craniofacial morphogenesis. fusion. In: Proceedings of the 47th Plastic Surgery Research Council. Han-
In: Lin K, Ogle RC, Jane JA, eds. Craniofacial Surgery: Science and Sur- over, NH: Plastic Surgery Research Council; 2002:93.
gical Technique. Philadelphia: Saunders Co.; 2002:84–100. Yu JC, Lucas JH, Borke JL. Tension-induced FGF-2 release in neonatal rat
Potter EL, Craig JM. Rate of antenatal growth. In: Potter EL, Craig JM, eds. coronal sutures: a self-organizing mechanism in cranial development. J
Pathology of the Fetus and the Infant. 3rd ed. Chicago: Year Book Medical Craniofac Surg. 1999;8:29–32.
Publishers, Inc.; 1975:15–24. Yu JC, Braselton JP, Abell ML, Borke JL. The identification of calcium oscil-
Russell AP, Thomason JJ. Mechanical analysis of the mammalian head skeleton. lators in immature rat cranial sutures. In: Lauritzen CGK, ed. Craniofacial
In: Hanken J, Hall BK, eds. The Skull: Vol. 3: Functional and Evolutionary Surgery. Bologna: Monduzzi Editore, 2001a;9:139–141.
Mechanisms. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1993:345–383. Yu JC, Lucas JH, Fryberg K, Borke JL. Extrinsic tension results in FGF-2
Schiwy-Bochat KH. The roughness of the supranasal region—a morphological release, membrane permeability change, and intracellular Ca11 increase in
sex trait. For Sci Int. 2001;117:7–13. immature cranial sutures. J Craniofac Surg. 2001b;12:391–398.