Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
I Ps. lxix. Ps. xxiv.
3 For the text of the Ordo Qualiter see Albers Consuetudines Monasticae
i i i ; Hergott Vetus Disciplines Monastica, etc. This document dates
a t latest from the end of the eighth century ; unfortunately little is known
of it beyond the fact t h a t it was drawn up for the use of some Benedictine
monastery. It does not appear in either of the great collections of
Benedict of Aniane, the Concordia Regularum and the Codex Regularum.
* See my Note on Trina Oratio in the Downside Review, Jan. 1924,
p p . 67.
S Pss. vi, xxxi, xxxvii, 1, ci, exxix, cxlii.
The Downside Review
collect for the King, Queen and Benefactors, the last
two by one for the faithful departed.
Meanwhile the " pueri," oblates, as we should call
them to-day, were entering the church with their
master. As soon as all were there, the first signal for
Nocturns, which had been ringing continuously, ceased.
The " pueri " then proceeded to carry out their Trino
Oratio together while the monks entered the stalls and,
at the second signal for Nocturns, began the recitation
of the fifteen Gradual psalms1 in three groups of five
psalms with a genuflection after each group. This is
another practice of common observance that can be
traced to the reform of Benedict of Aniane, though at
Aniane in the ninth century, and almost everywhere
in the tenth, an additional fifteen psalms2 were said in
winter. When all these preliminaries were over the
third signal, consisting of those bells which had not yet
been rung, was given and Nocturns were begun. This
Office being celebrated according to the Rule of St
Benedict is not described in detail; in connection with
it, however, we may notice a custom mentioned by
the Concordia when dealing with the office of the Circa,3
a monk whose duty it was to enforce the discipline of
the monastery. This official went about the choir with
a lantern during the third lesson on ferial days4, or the
last lesson of each Nocturn on feast days, to see if the
brethren were attentive. If he found a monk sleeping,
he placed the lantern before him and retired to his stall.
Awakened by the light, the sleeper had first to make
1 Pss. cxix, . . . cxxxiii.
2 i.e., to the end of the Psalter.
3 Chap, vii
4 In winter o n l y ; in accordance with the Rule of St Benedict there
were no lessons on summer ferias. Thirty years or so after the Concordia
was written we find Aelfricin his Letter to the monks of Eynsham expressing
his pleasure t h a t a t Eynsham three lessons were being read on week-days
in summer and winter alike (Hants Record Society, 1892, p. 196.) The
point had been disputed since the days of Warnfrid : see his letter to
Charlemagne (Albers Cons. Monast. iii, pp. 52 f.)
l6
The Regularis Concordia 3
satisfaction on his knees and then to continue the round
of the choir, placing the lantern before any brother
found dozing, just as had been done to himself by the
Circa. And so, according to the length of the lesson,
the lantern was passed on from one inattentive brother
to another. Almost exactly the same custom is found
in the ancient fragment of monastic customs connected
with Verdun and in the Treves and Einsiedeln recensions
of the Consuetudines Germaniae, all of them representing
an observance more or less contemporary with that of
the Concordia.
Nocturns were followed by yet more devotions : the
psalms Domine ne in furore1 for the King and Exaudiat
te Deus* for the Queen and Benefactors, with a collect
for the King, one for the Queen and another for the
King, Queen and Benefactors. Next, after the short
interval till daybreak, prescribed by the Rule, came
Matins of the day (the modern Lauds), the psalms
Miserere, Beati quorum and Inclina Domine3 with collects
and versicles for the King, Queen and Benefactors,
anthems of Holy Cross, Our Lady, and of the Patron
Saint of the place. The brethren then went in pro-
cession to another chapel (porticus) singing on their
way an anthem in honour of the saint to whom it was
dedicated ; there they recited Matins of All Saints and
Matins of the Dead. If by that time the day had broken,
the office of Prime was said immediately, other-
wise there was an interval during which the monks
might exercise their private devotions until, at daybreak,
the signal was given and all assembled in choir for Prime.
This was followed by the psalms Domine ne in furore,
Miserere mei Deus* with versicles and collects against
fleshly temptation and for departed brethren, the psalm
Inclina Domine? the seven penitential psalms, a short
form of litany—said prostrate, the Lord's Prayer, the
psalm In te Domine speravi6, and, lastly, some unspecified
versicles and collects.
1 Ps. vi. 2 Ps. xix. 3 Pss. 1, xxxi, lxxxv.
* Pss. xxxvii, 1. 5 Ps, lxxxv. 6 Ps. lxx.
L
J
°4 The Downside Review
Here we may pause a moment to remark that the
extra offices and devotions of the Concordia were not
greater in amount than those found elsewhere at the
time, certain practices—that, for example, of adding to
the fifteen psalms said in summer immediately before
Nocturns another fifteen in winter—being discreetly
left alone by the English reformers. What is particu-
larly English is that so large a proportion of these
devotions was offered for the King—two psalms with
collects said after each portion of the Opus Dei, Prime
alone excepted, as well as after the conventual Mass—
sixteen psalms in all—not to mention the middle section
of the Trina Oratio before Nocturns as well as the
Matin Mass, when said for the King. The reference
earlier in the Concordia to " those prayers which, usu
patrum, we are accustomed to say for the King and
Benefactors " shows that the practice was no new one.
Their early morning devotions over, the brethren
occupied themselves " until the second hour "—roughly,
eight o'clock—in the reading prescribed by the Rule.
A bell was then rung and the monks went to the dor-
mitory to put on their day shoes, none but the
" ministers " of the Matin Mass being allowed to do
this before the signal was given—a curious piece of
discipline, found also in the earliest known Cluniac
Consuetudinaries. After this the boys with their masters
and the Abbot and, apart from them, the rest of the
brethren, washed their hands and faces, " sanctifying
their actions," says the Concordia in its usual elaborate
style, " with psalms and prayers." All being ready, the
monks went to the church for the second Trina Oratio
of the day.1 On the entry of the " pueri," the Aedituus,
or sacristan, gave the first signal for the office of Terce
upon which the boys too said the Trina Oratio. All
then went to their places in choir, the second bell was
l No details of this are given.
l6
The Regularis Concordia 5
rung and Terce, the Psalms Usquequo Domine and
Miserere met Domine, miserere mei,1 and the usual collects
for the King, Queen and Benefactors were sung. At
the Matin Mass which followed, the monks of the right
hand of the choir " made the offering " on Mondays,
those of the left hand side " offering " at the principal
Mass ; on Tuesdays the reverse was done, and so forth
to the end of the week. It is interesting to find the
same custom in the Consuetudines Germaniae. Inci-
dentally, the Matin Mass was said either for the King,
as had been stated, or for any pressing need.
We now come to a very important item in the daily
life of the monks, the Chapter consisting of readings
and prayers2 followed by the public confession and
correction of offences against monastic discipline. The
section is based on the description of chapter given
in the Ordo Qualiter.3 On the signal being given,
the monks went in procession to the Chapter House
(Capitulum) where, turning to the east, they bowed
to the Cross and to one another. When all were seated,
the Martyrology was read ; then, standing, the brethren
recited the prayers referred to above from the Pretiosa in
conspectu Domini down to the end of the collect Dirigere
et sanctificare, adding to this the versicle Deus in adiu-
torium meum intende. They then sat down again for
the reading of the Rule of St Benedict on ordinary
days, or, on festivals, of the Gospel of the day, on which
the abbot gave a short homily. What is now called
" Chapter of Faults " followed immediately ; any monk
who was conscious of having committed a breach of
discipline or who was accused of some misdeameanour
1 Pss. xii, lvi.
2 Merged later in the Office of Prime (Monastic Breviary.)
3 This explains inter alia, why the Abbot is here called " p r i o r , " a
title that appears in the Rule but which was by the end of the t e n t h
century applied to the "senior d e c a n u s " or, as we should say to-day, t h e
Claustral Prior.
*66 The Downside Review
by one of the officials of the monastery, asking pardon
on his knees. Examples of the kind of accusation made
are given in the seventh chapter of the Concordia.
There the Circa is instructed to point out at chapter
any monk observed by him to have been " accidiosus
aut alicui vanitati deditus "—negligent at the prayers
and offices or wasteful of his time ; there also he is
ordered to bring to the chapter any clothes or books
that had been left about, so that the responsible parties
might claim them and make satisfaction for their careless-
ness. On the abbot asking a monk the cause for which
he was on his knees, he was to answer Mea culpa even
if unjustly accused—any attempt at self-defence being
regarded as an offence against humility and as an admission
of guilt ; he might then admit or deny the charge
brought against him. Nothing is said of the punish-
ments inflicted, the Concordia being content to quote
the words of the Ordo Qualiter to the effect that " the
more humbly a monk admits his fault, the more leniently
is he to be dealt with by the abbot."
The Chapter, as carried out in monasteries of the
tenth and later centuries was unknown in St Benedict's
day ; nevertheless it appears in Warnefrid's Commentary
on the Rule, of the last quarter of the eighth century.
Its origin is probably to be found in St Benedict's own
prescription that one or more of the senior monks should
be deputed to watch over the externals of discipline and
to secure the punishment of offenders against it. 1 We
may note that the Concordia practice is the primitive
religious exercise of Warnefrid and the Ordo Qualiter—
quite a different thing from the harsh discipline of the
Chapter that found favour in some monasteries of a
later age.