Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Objective: To determine whether Reiki, a process of transmission of healing energy, can significantly re-
duce microvascular leakage caused by exposure to excessive noise using an animal model.
Rationale: Reiki is beginning to be used in hospitals to accelerate recovery. Despite many anecdotes de-
scribing Reiki’s success, few scientific studies are reported and none of those use animals. Animal models have
the advantage over human subjects in that they provide well-controlled, easily interpretable experiments. The
use of noise is relevant to hospital patients because of the excessive ambient noise in hospitals in the United
Kingdom and United States. Loud noise can lead to several nonauditory disorders in humans and animals that
impair recovery. In the rat, stress from noise damages the mesenteric microvasculature, leading to leakage of
plasma into the surrounding tissue.
Design: One group of four rats simultaneously received daily noise and Reiki, while two other groups re-
ceived “sham” Reiki or noise alone. A fourth group did not receive noise or additional treatment. The experi-
ment was performed three times to test for reproducibility.
Outcome Measures: Average number and area of microvascular leaks to fluorescent albumin per unit length
of venule.
Results: In all three experiments, Reiki significantly reduced the outcome measures compared to the other
noise groups (sham Reiki and noise alone) (p 0.01).
Conclusions: Application of Reiki significantly reduces noise-induced microvascular leakage in an animal
model. Whether or not these effects are caused by Reiki itself, or the relaxing effect of the Reiki practitioner,
this procedure could be useful for minimizing effects of environmental stress on research animals and hospital
patients.
INTRODUCTION need for research to understand if, how, and why they work,
and to evaluate their effectiveness.2 A survey conducted at
Boston’s Beth Israel Hospital3 found that one in every three
R eiki is a fast growing complementary and alternative
medicine (CAM) technique used by approximately one
million practitioners worldwide, and in at least one hundred
Americans has used CAM care, spending over 14 billion
dollars (not covered by insurance) in 1990 alone. However,
hospitals in the United States.1 A thorough review of the despite the hundreds of accounts describing Reiki, there are
Reiki programs in several hospitals can be found at: only a handful of publications in peer-reviewed journals;
www.reiki.org/reikinews/reiki_in_hospitals.html One rea- therefore, there is little quantitative science to support the
son for the rapid growth of Reiki lies in its simplicity and use of Reiki in hospitals and elsewhere. The few published
ease of application. During the last decade or so, there has scientific studies of Reiki relevant to the present experiment
been a surge in the use of CAM treatments, emphasizing the are summarized as follows. Olson and Hanson4 explored the
15
16 BALDWIN AND SCHWARTZ
FIG. 2. Panels (A) and (B) show light micrographs of rat mesen-
teric venules that were perfused in situ with fluorescently labeled
albumin. The image shown in panel (A) is from an animal that was
subjected to noise but also received Reiki, whereas the image in
panel (B) is from an animal that received noise alone. Note the
focal regions of leakage of fluorescent albumin (arrow). Scale bar:
25 m. Panel (C) shows a confocal image of a mesenteric venule
from an animal treated with noise alone. This mesenteric network
was perfused with fluorescent albumin and later fixed and stained
with rhodamine phalloidin to demonstrate endothelial actin (block
arrow) around the periphery of each endothelial cell. Note that
FIG. 1. Diagram depicting the surgical preparation of the mesen- the albumin leaks occur at the cell junctions (arrow). Scale bar:
teric microcirculation. 10 m.
18 BALDWIN AND SCHWARTZ
RESULTS A
were compared with sham Reiki controls, and second be- and after measures, there were significant reductions in anx-
cause an animal model was used, thus removing problems iety and systolic blood pressure and a significant increase
with variations in diet and lifestyle, and the complications in salivary immunoglobulin A (IgA). Fifteen subjects showed
with attitude that are encountered when using human sub- decreased plasma cortisol concentrations after treatment. In
jects. One possible weakness is that only two Reiki practi- contrast, during periods of stress, salivary IgA is reduced23
tioners were used. However, this is a “proof of concept” and plasma cortisol increased.24 Therefore, these results in-
study; therefore, it would not have been expedient to recruit dicate that the stress response was decreased in most cases
more practitioners, especially if the result had been nega- after Reiki. However, this study did not demonstrate that it
tive. was Reiki that reduced the stress response because no sham
Reiki control subjects were included. Thus the results may
Strengths and weaknesses in relation to other studies. have been produced by an effect of being in a quiet room
There are very few published scientific studies of Reiki that with a caring person rather than by Reiki per se.
are relevant to the present experiment because this is such The present study is a more rigorous test of Reiki than
a new and controversial area. One study, currently being those reported in the literature, first because it is the only
performed at Portsmouth Regional Hospital (Portsmouth, one that involves animals (and thus eliminates variations
NH) is showing that Reiki helps patients reduce their stress in diet and lifestyle that are present in human studies),
levels preoperatively and induces a calming effect that as- and second because it demonstrates repeatability under
sists in decreasing the amount of pain medication required the same conditions. In addition, every outcome parame-
postoperatively.21 These results support the idea of re- ter was quantifiable; thus, the measures did not rely on
searching into the potential benefits of Reiki for use in a the subjective assessments of pain relief or general state
hospital setting. Another study22 indicates that Reiki can re- of health that are common in the other studies. Finally,
duce emotional stress in people. Healthy individuals were the inclusion of a sham Reiki group provided an excellent
given a 30-minute Reiki treatment, and comparing before control.
FIG. 5. Reiki versus sham: pre- versus post-treatments and individual ratings. Graphs show pre (solid lines) and post (dashed lines)
ratings in Reiki practitioner (left panel) and Sham control (right panel), averaged more than 21 sessions. Not only are the overall rat-
ings higher in the Reiki practitioner, but the increase post- versus pre-treatment is greater in Reiki compared to sham, F(1,74) 14.82,
p 0.001.
REIKI, NOISE, AND MICROVASCULAR DAMAGE 21
Meaning of the study Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Its con-
tents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not
One question that this research raises is, “How did the
necessarily represent the official views of the NCCAM or NIH.
Reiki reduce the noise-induced microvascular leakage?”
The animal experiments were conducted under the guide-
There is evidence that exposure to excessive noise stimu-
lines, and with the approval of, the Institutional Animal Care
lates peripheral nerves in the intestine to release neuro-
and Use Committee of the University of Arizona.
transmitters that may damage microvessels directly as well
as promoting mast cell degranulation and subsequent release
of inflammatory mediators that cause further damage.25 Pre-
liminary studies26 indicate that Reiki has some effect on the
autonomic nervous system. Thus, perhaps Reiki reduces the REFERENCES
stimulation of peripheral nerves in the intestine and mesen-
1. Lubeck W, Petter FA, Rand WL, Grim CM. The Spirit of
tery and hence decreases the release of neurotransmitters.
Reiki. Twin Lakes, WI: Lotus Press, 2001.
Although it may be difficult to believe that energy healing
2. Miles P. Reiki. Review of a biofield therapy. History, theory,
can actually impinge on physiologic systems, such as nerves practice and research. Alt Ther Health Med 2003;9:62–72.
and cells, one other study has shown that bioenergy, a gen- 3. Eisenberg D. Unconventional medicine in the United States.
eral term that encompasses Reiki, can directly affect the con- N Engl J Med 1993;328(4):246–252.
centration of intracellular free calcium.27 4. Olson K, Hanson J. Using Reiki to manage pain: A prelimi-
On the other hand, it is possible that the rats may have nary report. J Pain Symp Manage 2003;26:990–997.
been reacting to physiologic and/or psychologic changes that 5. Motz J. Hands of Life. New York: Bantam Books, 1998.
occurred in the Reiki practitioners, rather than to the Reiki 6. Brewitt B, Vittetoe T, Hartwell B. The efficiency of Reiki
itself. This idea is supported by daily evaluations of the over- hands-on healing: Improvements in spleen and nervous sys-
all state of Reiki and sham Reiki practitioners pre- and post- tem function as quantified by electrodermal screening [abstr].
Alt Ther 1997;3(4):89.
administering treatments throughout Experiment 3. During
7. Wilson LM, Baldwin AL. Effects of environmental stress on
Experiment 3, the Reiki practitioner and the “sham” student
the architecture and permeability of the rat mesenteric mi-
completed a questionnaire rating their mental, emotional, crovasculature. Microcirculation 1998;5(4):299–308.
and spiritual states, before and after performing each treat- 8. Baldwin AL, Wilson LM. Effects of noise on mesenteric per-
ment. The results (Fig. 5) show that the ratings increased meability in the rat [abstr]. FASEB J 1999;13:A1,1.3.
much more post-treatment versus pretreatment for Reiki 9. Barrett A, Stockham MA. The effect of housing conditions
than for sham Reiki. Therefore, further experiments are re- and simple experimental procedures upon the corticosterone
quired, using the same animal model in which Reiki is given level in the plasma of rats. J Endocrinol 1963;26:97–105.
remotely, so that the practitioner does not have to enter the 10. Kahn DM, Cook TE, Carlisle CC, et al. Identification and mod-
room. If similar results were obtained in such a study, they ification of environmental noise in an ICU setting. Chest 1998;
could not be explained by the animals merely responding to 114(2):535–540.
11. Christensen M. Noise levels in a general surgical ward: A de-
changes in the Reiki practitioner.
scriptive study. J Clin Nurs 2004;14:156–164.
12. Falk SA, Woods N. Hospital noise: Levels and potential health
hazards. N Engl J Med 1973;289:774–781.
CONCLUSIONS 13. Jonsson A, Hansson L. Prolonged exposure to a stressful stim-
ulus (noise) as a cause of raised blood pressure in man. Lancet
Whether or not the effects of Reiki result from a putative 1977;309:86–87.
bioenergy or the relaxing effect of the Reiki practitioner, 14. Long JG, Lucey JF, Phillips AGS. Noise and hypoxemia in
this procedure could still be useful for minimizing the ef- the intensive care nursery. Paediatrics 1980;65:143–145.
15. Tomei F, Papaleo B, Baccolo TP, et al. Noise and gastric se-
fects of environmental stress on research animals28 and per-
cretion. Am J Indust Med 1994;26:367–372.
haps on humans. Further rigorous, placebo-controlled ex-
16. Ginsberg MI, Baldwin AL. Disodium chromoglycate stabilizes
periments are needed to determine the effectiveness of Reiki mast cell degranulation while reducing the number of hemo-
for reducing the deleterious physiological consequences of globin-induced microcvascular leaks in rat mesentery. Am J
excessive noise throughout the body. Physiol 2003;286:H1750–H1756.
17. Baldwin AL. Modified hemoglobins produce venular interen-
dothelial gaps and albumin leakage in rat mesentery. Am J
Physiol 1999;277:H650–H659.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 18. Thurston G, Baldwin AL, Wilson LM. Changes in endothelial
actin cytoskeleton at leakage sites in the rat mesenteric mi-
The authors thank Katherine Spetner for designing and per- crovasculature. Am J Physiol 1995;266:H316–H329.
forming the artwork for Figure 4. This research was supported 19. Valeski JE, Baldwin AL. Why do some venules leak and not
in part by National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants R21 AT others? Microcirculation 7th World Congress, Sydney, Aus-
1124 (ALB) and P20 AT00774 (GES) the National Center for tralia, August, 2001.
22 BALDWIN AND SCHWARTZ
20. Haraldsson B, Sörensson J. Why do we not all have protein- 27. Kiang JG, Ives JA, Jonas WB. External bioenergy-induced in-
uria? An update of our current understanding of the glomeru- creases in intracellular free calcium concentrations are medi-
lar barrier. News Physiol Sci 2004;19(1):7–10. ated by Na/Ca2 exchanger and L-type calcium channel. Mol
21. Alandyly P, Alandyly K. Using Reiki to support surgical pa- Cell Biochem 2005;271:51–59.
tients. J Nurs Care Qual 1999;13:89–91. 28. Clough G. Environmental effects on animals used in biomed-
22. Wardell D, Engebretson J. Biological correlates of Reiki ical research. Biol Rev 1982;57(3):487–523.
touch-healing. J Adv Nursing 2001;33(4):439–445.
23. Jemmott JB, Borysenko JZ, Borysenko M, et al. Academic stress,
power motivation and decrease in secretion rate of salivary se-
cretory immunoglobulin A. Lancet 1983;1:14900–14902. Address reprint requests to:
24. Benjamins C, Asscheman H, Schuurs AH. Increased salivary
Ann L. Baldwin, Ph.D.
cortisol in severe dental anxiety. Psychophysiology 1992;
29(3):302–305.
Department of Physiology
25. Soderholm JD, Perdue MH. Stress and intestinal barrier func- College of Medicine
tion. Am J Physiol 2001;280:G7–G13. University of Arizona
26. Mackay N, Hansen S, McFarlane O. Autonomic nervous sys- Tucson, AZ 85724-5051
tem changes during Reiki treatment: A preliminary study. J
Alt Comp Med 2004;10(6):1077–1081. E-mail: abaldwin@u.arizona.edu