You are on page 1of 120

WCDMA Ra dio

Fre que ncy Optimiza tion

www.huawei.com

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved.


Fore word
 RF (Radio Frequency) optimization is the most important
step to ensure the quality of the network.
 RF optimization will solve network problems related to
neighbor cell list, coverage and interference.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page2
Obje ctive s
 Upon completion of this course, you will be able to:

Know the steps of RF optimization

Know how to solve the RF problems caused by neighbor cell
list, poor coverage and interference

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page3
Conte nts
 RF Optimization Workflow
 Typical Problems Analysis in RF optimization

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page4
RF Optimiza tion Workflow
Start

Preparation:
 Set the optimization target
 Divide the optimization cluster
 Draw out the test route line
 Prepare the DT tools

Data Collection:
 DT test Adjustment:
 Indoor DT test  Engineering parameters adjust
 RNC configuration data  Neighbor cell list adjust

The DT result is satisfied N


Problem Analysis
with optimization target?  neighbor cell list
 poor coverage
Y  pilot pollution
 handover
RF optimization  interference
finished

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page5
RF Optimiza tion Workflow
 Set RF optimization target, for example:
Reference
Target Item Remark
Value
CPICH Ec/Io ≥ -12dB & RSCP ≥
Coverage Probability ≥95%
-95dBm
CPICH Ec/Io ≥ -12dB ≥95% Scanner result
CPICH RSCP ≥
≥95% Scanner result
-95dBm

SHO Percentage 30%-40%

Pilot pollution
≤5%
Percentage

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page6
RF Optimiza tion Workflow
 RF optimization clusters division

Cluster is the area for one time drive test

One cluster should contains 15 to 25 sites

Cluster division should consider the following factor, such
as:
 Ter
rain
 Tr
aff
ic
 Rout
eline

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page7
RF Optimiza tion Workflow
 Preparation for DT (drive test)

Hardware
 Tes
tphone

S
canner
 GPS

Software
 Dr
ivet
ests
oft
war
e, f
orex
ampl
e, GENEXPr
obe
 Dr
ivetes
tpos
tpr
oces
ssof
twar
e, f
orex
ampl
e, GENEX
As
sis
tant

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page8
Conte nts
 Preparation of RF Optimization

 Typical Problems Analysis in RF optimization

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page9
Conte nts
 Typical Problems Analysis in RF optimization

RF case related to neighbor cell list

RF case related to bad coverage
 RF case related to interference

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page10
Ca s e 1
 Description

In DT, call drop happened

Check the signaling trace at UE side

Call Drop
After call drop, begin
to read
system information

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page11
Ca s e 1
 Data analysis
 Check cell information from UE active set and cell information
from scanner at call drop points.
From UE From Scanner

No SC
170 cell!!
Why?

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page12
Ca s e 1
 Data analysis
 Checking monitor set
Check monitor set for
the scramble measured
by scanner

SC 170 is not in monitor set


Missing neighbor cell
 Delayed handover

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page13
Ca s e 1
 Data analysis

Check the latest measurement control

Search for the latest intra-


frequency measurement control

Call drop
point

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page14
Ca s e 1

Measurement ID is 1. It is Intra-
frequency measurement control

The primary scramble


of the cell is 6

Check the list of intra-frequency


neighbor cell in measurement
control and no SC 170

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page15
Ca s e 1

 Solution

Add neighbor cells in neighbor cell list
 Summary
 In the beginning stage of network, it is very common that
missing neighbor cell cased cause call drop.

Analysis with signaling procedure is the common way to find
and solve the problem

Some problems can be avoided if the Combined Neighbor Cell
Algorithm is switched on.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page16
Ca s e 2

 Phenomenon description
 In DT, call drop

happened at cell A

Cell B (PSC277)

Cell A
(PSC58)

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page17
Ca s e 2

 Phenomenon description

In Cell A, UE keeps reporting PSC 277 1A event.

RNC received this event and send Active Set Update to UE
according to the signaling trace record
 UE send Active Set Update complete to RNC

Then, RNC send Active Set Update to delete PSC 277 from
active set

Finally call drop happened due to RL failure

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page18
Ca s e 2
 Problem Analysis

From the signaling trace of DT, it looks like the handover is
complete successfully.

But, according to the signaling trace from CDT, the handover
failed actually.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page19
Ca s e 2
 Problem Analysis

Signaling trace from CDT shows:
UE NodeB RNC

Measurement control (1A Event for PSC 227)

Radio Link Setup

Radio Link Setup Response

Active set update

Active set update complete

Radio Link Failure

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page20
Ca s e 2
 Problem Analysis
Cell C (PSC277)

After checking the
neighbor cell list, the
following problem is
found
Cell B (PSC277)

Cell C has the same
PSC as Cell B

Cell A (PSC58)

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page21
Ca s e 2
 Problem Analysis

The neighbor cell list shows
Cell ID PSC Cell ID NCell ID
A 58 A C
B 277 C A
C 277

Missing Cell A
configuring Mistake for
(PSC58)
NCell configuring
NCell

Cell B Cell C
(PSC277) (PSC277)

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page22
Ca s e 2
 Problem Analysis

Based on the analysis above, the new NodeB is not the one of
cell B, but the one of cell C

Even the cell C prepared resource for UE according to the RNC
command of “Radio Link Setup”, it can not find the UE uplink
signal.
 That does why the “Radio Link Failure” is sent by NodeB

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page23
Ca s e 2
 Solution

Change the wrong neighbor cell list

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page24
Ca s e 2
 Summary
 Phenomenon for wrong neighbor cell list
 Fr
omDT, r
adiol
inkbr
anc
hisaddedint
oac
tives
et, t
hen
del
etedf
romac
tives
etr
epeat
edl
y.
 S
HO s
ucc
essr
ateisl
ow
 Radiol
inkf
ail
ureisl
owint
hewr
ongneighborc
ell
,for
ex
ampl
e, c
ellCinc
ase2
 Cal
ldr
opishighint
hec
ellwit
hwr
ongneighborc
ell
,for
ex
ampl
e, c
ellAinc
ase2

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page25
Ca s e 2
 Summary

About SHO event, UE will only report PSC to RNC in
Measurement Report

RNC will find the right cell according to the neighbor cell list
between cell ID and PSC

This problem is mainly happened in dense urban when is PSC
is reused a lot

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page26
Ca s e 3
 Description

14605 (Frequency C)
Call drop rate high
14603 (Frequency A)

14602 (Frequency B) 14031 (Frequency B)

Inter-frequency handover based on capacity

Inter-RAT handover based on coverage

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page27
Ca s e 3
 Description

UE is in Cell 14602 with frequency B

When 14602 is in high load level, UE will be handed over to
14603 with another frequency A

When 14603 is in high load level, UE will be handed over to
14605 with frequency C

Because frequency A and C are not used continuously at this
area, UE has to be handed over to Cell 14031 with frequency
B

14603 and 14605 can share the load level, but the call drop
rate in 14603 is very high.
Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page28
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

Because it’s difficult to do drive test for collecting signaling
trace, the IOS (Information of Subscriber) trace is used.

Based on the analysis for the call dropped UE, there is one
thing is common:
 Bef
orec
alldr
opin24603, al
lUEsinit
iat
edc
ompr
essmode,
ands
endMeas
urementRepor
ttoRNCper
iodic
all
y, but
handoverisnott
rigger
ed.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page29
Ca s e 3
 Analysis
2D Event

Compress
mode
Inter-frequency
measurement
control

Inter-frequency
Measurement
report

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page30
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

Open “Inter-frequency Measurement Control”, the Cell 14605
with frequency C is put in the first place

And in the following measurement report, UE only report Cell
14605
 But the cell 14605 cell signal level is lower than -90dBm, which
can not trigger handover, till call drop.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page31
Ca s e 3
 Analysis Cell 14605 with
Frequency C

Measurement Control

Cell 14031 with


Frequency B

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page32
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

Measurement Report
Cell 14605 with
Frequency C

Cell 14605 CPICH


& Ec/Io

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page33
Ca s e 3
 Question

Why the handover can not be triggered?

Since the network give UE the information of cell 14605 and
cell 14031, Why UE only report cell 14605?

Did UE measure cell 14301, just not report it?
 Or, UE never measure cell 14301, just 14605?

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page34
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

UE report cell 14605 CPICH RSCP is 19, which is -96dBm.

After checking the RNC configuration file, this CPICH RSCP
level can not trigger inter-frequency handover

Actually, because cell 14605 and 14603 are in one sector, their
signal level should be same.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page35
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

If UE can report cell 14031, the handover may be triggered

After analyze the compress mode principle, it is found that UE
can only monitor 1 WCDMA frequency in the gap of compress
mode.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page36
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

Because UE can not measure cell 14301 with frequency B,
only monitor cell 14605 with frequency C, and meanwhile cell
14605 and 14603 signal level are same, the call dropped due
to the poor signal of 14605 and 14603

How to make UE monitor cell 14301 with frequency B instead
of 14605 with frequency C?

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page37
Ca s e 3
 Solution

Delete the neighbor relation from 14603 with frequency A to
14605 with frequency C

Add the neighbor relation from 14602 with frequency B to
14605 with frequency C

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page38
Ca s e 3
 Solution

14605 (Frequency C)

14603 (Frequency A)

14602 (Frequency B) 14031 (Frequency B)

Inter-frequency handover based on capacity

Inter-RAT handover based on coverage

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page39
Ca s e 3
 Summary

Do not configure two different frequency neighbor cells in
WCDMA system

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page40
Conte nts
 Typical Problems Analysis in RF optimization

RF case related to neighbor cell list


RF case related to bad coverage
 RF case related to interference

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page41
Ca s e 1
 Description

In drive test for RF optimization, call drop happened in the
circle area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page42
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

After analyze the signal level of this area, the call drop is
caused by discontinuous coverage of the cell with PSC 442

Problem Zone

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page43
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

After checking the RF
transmission Antenna

environment, the signal


is blocked by the glass
Call drop
wall

The Wall

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page44
Ca s e 1
 Solution

Solution 1: Decrease the downtilt to increase the signal level
 Maybet
hepr
obl
emar
eawil
lbec
omebet
ter
, butduet
othe
wal
l,t
hispr
obl
emmays
til
lex
istnear
by.

Solution 2:Increase the antenna height
 Af
terc
hec
kingt
heins
tal
lat
ionc
ondit
ion, it
’sver
yhar
dto
inc
reas
etheheight
 Eveninc
reas
edt
heheight
,thepr
obl
emmays
til
lex
istduet
o
t
hewal
l.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page45
Ca s e 1
 Solution

Solution 3:
 Movet
heant
ennapos
itionifpos
sibl
e, andt
hemain

Movet dir
ec
heant t
ionant
ennaposennaispar
itiont
or all
elwit
hthes
ideoft
ightabout15met
ers hewal
l
c
ons
ider
ingt
heins
tal
lat
ionc
ondit
ion
Wall

New
Original Position
Position

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page46
Ca s e 1
 Solution

Solution 3:
 Aboutt
heant
ennadownt
il
t,t
wos
trat
egiesar
edes
igned.
 Fir
st, 10degr
ees
10 Degree

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page47
Ca s e 1
 Solution

Solution 3:
 S
econd, 5degr
ees

5 Degree

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page48
Ca s e 1
 Summary

Before RF adjustment, site survey should be done.

Find the problem and the reason, design several strategies for
the adjustment

One time adjustment, and check the performance at the same
time. Adjustment and performance checking should be done at
the same to improve the work efficiency.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page49
Ca s e 2
 Description

In drive test for RF optimization, the area Ec/Io is bad

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page50
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Checking the cell distribution at this area

PSC186 PSC184

PSC185

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page51
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

One site with 3 cells, PSC184, 185 and 186 cover this area

Two cells, PSC 184 and 185, are separated to two sectors to
cover different direction

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page52
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

The area is covered by different cell – PSC 184 and 185

No dominant cell – PSC 184 and 185 is the best cell crossly in
this area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page53
Ca s e 2
 Solution

Change the sector PSC, or combine some sector

Previously, 3 cells
 PS
C184: s
ect
or1&s
ect
or3
 PS
C185: s
ect
or2&s
ect
or4
 PS
C186: s
ect
or5

After adjustment, 2 cells:
 PS
C184: s
ect
or1&s
ect
or3
 PS
C185: s
ect
or4&s
ect
or5
 Del
etes
ect
or2
Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page54
Ca s e 2
 After adjustment, the drive test for PSC 184 and 185

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page55
Ca s e 2
 The comparison result for scanner Ec/Io

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page56
Ca s e 2
 The comparison result for UE Ec/Io

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page57
Ca s e 2
 Summary

In order to get better coverage performance at the place with
complicated transmission environment, splitter is used to
separate one cell into different sectors to cover different area.

In this case, the sector should be designed reasonably to
control the interference

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page58
Ca s e 3
 Description

In drive test for RF optimization, bad Ec/Io is found on the
bridge

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page59
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

Check the RSCP value of scanner, the result shows the RSCP
value is good.

Based on this, pilot pollution need be considered in this area.

Check the top N pilot RSCP and Ec/Io in scanner result

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page60
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

From the DT result, it shows the RSCP value is strong, but the
Ec/Io is bad.

And the signal level of different cell are very similar.

Find the cells which cover this area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page61
Ca s e 3
 Analysis Site 2 Cell C Site 3 Cell C

Site 1 Cell A

Site 4 Cell C

Site 5 Cell C

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page62
Ca s e 3
 Analysis

On the bridge, the signal from different cell can cover this area
due to reflection of the river and no building.

From DT, following cell cover this area:
 S
ite1c
ellA
 S
ite2c
ellC
 S
ite3c
ellC
 S
ite4c
ellC
 S
ite5c
ellC

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page63
Ca s e 3
 Analysis Site 2 Cell C Site 3 Cell C


Need to find the
best cell
Site 1 Cell A

Check the map, Site 6
the site 6 is very
near to the
bridge.

Site 4 Cell C

Site 5 Cell C

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page64
Ca s e 3
 Analysis
The residence buildings

After checking site 6 RF are much higher than
antenna, which block
environment, it is difficult to the signal of site 6

increase the antenna height or


move site 6 position to avoid
the blocking caused by the
building

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page65
Ca s e 3
 Analysis Site 2 Cell C Site 3 Cell C


Then, site 1 cell
A can be the
best cell to Site 1 Cell A

cover this area

Site 4 Cell C

Site 5 Cell C

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page66
Ca s e 3
 Analysis Site 2 Cell C Site 3 Cell C


Then, try to
increase the
signal of site 1 Site 1 Cell A

cell A, and
decrease other
cells
 To confirm this, Site 4 Cell C
DT for site 1 cell Site 5 Cell C

A needs to be
done
Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page67
Ca s e 3
 Solution

Increase the signal of site 1 cell A
 Changet
heant
ennadownt
il
tfr
om10t
o7
 I
ncr
eas
eCPI
CH Txpower1.5dBhigher

Decrease other cell signal – change the antenna downtilt
 Fr
om7t
o10f
ors
ite2c
ellC
 Fr
om5t
o8f
orS
ite3c
ellC
 Fr
om9t
o11f
ors
ite4c
ellC
 Fr
om9t
o11f
ors
ite5c
ellC

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page68
Ca s e 3
 Confirmation

After the modification, the DT shows the pilot pollution area
as below

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page69
Ca s e 3
 Confirmation

The Ec/Io comparison

After

Before

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page70
Ca s e 3
 Summary

To solve the pilot pollution, the following issues has be
considered
 Findt
her
eas
onc
aus
edpil
otpol
lut
ion
– Due to no s trong s igna l
– Due to too much s trong s igna l

 Af
tert
headj
ust
ment
,theDThast
obedoneatt
hisc
lus
ter
t
oconf
ir
mthatnonewpr
obl
emappear
ed

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page71
Ca s e 4
 Description
 In DT, video call quality is decreased at the problem
area. Also, the PS call drop happened several times

Problem Area

3G Antenna

2G Antenna

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page72
Ca s e 4
 Analysis
 RSCP distribution in DT

Problem
area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page73
Ca s e 4
 Analysis

Ec/Io distribution in DT

Problem
Problem
area
area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page74
Ca s e 4
 Analysis

Checking the RF environment, the antenna is installed on 10-
meter platform

2G and 3G antenna are installed at one platform, but 3G
antenna is a little bit inner than 2G antenna.
 After finishing DT in 2G, signal level is very stable

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page75
Ca s e 4
 Analysis

If 3G and 2G antenna are installed at the same place, the
problem may be solved.

The short wall of this platform may block the signal of 3G

Since 2G antenna is near to the border, the wall influence 2G little

Problem Area

3G Antenna Wall

2G Antenna

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page76
Ca s e 4
 Solution

Solution 1
 I
ncr
eas
etheant
ennaheightc
ans
olvet
hispr
obl
em

Solution 2
 Movet
heins
tal
lat
ionpl
aceneart
othebor
der

Solution 3
 3Gand2Gus
ethes
amepl
ace

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page77
Ca s e 4
 Solution
 Solution 3 is adopted

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page78
Ca s e 4
 Question

Do you have other methods?

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page79
Ca s e 4
 Summary

Sharing the same installation place for 3G and 2G is
very common, and several strategies can solve the
problem

In this situation, 3G and 2G can share the feeder
system, or can only share the installation platform.

Considering the factors of the installation and related
resource, a easiest and simplest method should be
adopted

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page80
Ca s e 5
 Description

In DT, call drop happened a lot in the area

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page81
Ca s e 5
 Description

Check the DT information, SC304 is in active set with
the signal level – RSCP -76dBm and Ec/Io -18

 Analysis
 Consider the pilot pollution
 Butonl
y1c
ellinac
tives
etand1Cel
linmonit
or
s
et

 Consider the missing neighbor cell



Butt
hec
ellinmonit
ors
ethasver
ygoodqual
it
y–
RS
CP-65dBmandEc
/Io-6
Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page82
Ca s e 5
 Analysis

Check the signaling trace at UE side
Before call drop, UE
sends measurement
report to RNC with 1A
event for cell 298

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page83
Ca s e 5
 Analysis

Check the signaling trace at RNC side

RNC sent Active Set Update to


UE, but no response. Then, RNC
send release RRC connection –
Call Drop

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page84
Ca s e 5
 Analysis

Based on the DT and signaling trace, this call drop
can be take as handover failure
 For example

cel l 56 vs cel l 041

- 10
EcNo

cel l 56
- 20 cel l 041

- 30
t i me

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page85
Ca s e 5
 Analysis

Around the corner, the original cell 304 signal level
drop very quickly because of the building
shadowing, and the neighbor cell 298 increase
very quickly.

After UE sent measurement report to RNC, cell
304 has become very bad when RNC sent active
set update.

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page86
Ca s e 5
 Adjustment

Since cell 298 has better coverage at this area,
handover can happen earlier

Decrease the coverage performance at this area
– Increase the downtilt from 5 to 9

– Adjust the direction from 0 to 310

 Increase the coverage performance at this area


– Decrease the downtilt from 5 to 4

– Adjust the direction from 300 to 270

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page87
Ca s e 5
 Adjustment

Result after adjustment

Handover
area

Handover
Before area After

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page88
Ca s e 5
 Adjustment

Comparison of Ec/Io of UE

Before After

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page89
Ca s e 5
 Summary

Confirm the corner effect by analyzing signaling
trace at UE and RNC
 About corner effect, Taking the method make the
handover happen earlier, such as RF optimization
 Other method can also adopted

Modify 1A event

Modify CIO (Cell Individual Offset)

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page90
Conte nts
 Typical Problems Analysis in RF optimization

RF case related to neighbor cell list
 RF case related to bad coverage

 RF case related to interference

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page91
Ca s e 1
 Description
 From traffic statistic, the following RTWP problem is found
RNCI VS.MaxRTW VS.MeanRTW
CellId CellName Time(As hour) VS.MinRTWP
d P P
6250 2005-5-16
1 KwongYu1 -74.5 -102.34 -105.3
1 17:00
6250 2006-5-16
1 KwongYu2 -74.3 -94.89 -105.5
2 17:00
6250 2006-5-16
1 KwongYu3 -82 -101.6 -105.4
3 17:00

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page92
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Connect to the problem NodeB, and monitor the RTWP
 Cell 62501 RTWP

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page93
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Cell 62502 RTWP

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page94
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Cell 62503 RTWP

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page95
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

The main diversity antenna is interfered seriously
 Can not find any relation between interference and time,
and the interference appears randomly

Check the neighbor site, no interference
 Deduction
 Inter-modulation cause the interference, could be
 I
nter
-modul
ationc
aus
edbybadc
onnec
tor
s
 I
nter
-modul
ationbyGS
M

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page96
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Check the RF environment

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page97
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Check the RF environment
 No blocking or any reflection due to the glass wall
 The site RF condition is very good

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page98
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

2G and 3G share the feeder system

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page99
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Check 2G frequency planning
 Sector 1 – 544 with hopping frequency 821
– 544 – 1811.6MHz & 821 – 1867MHz
 Sector 2 – 538 with hopping frequency 821
– 538 – 1808.6MHz & 821 – 1867MHz
 Sector 3 – 858 with hopping frequency 821
– 858 – 1874.4MHz & 821 – 1867MHz

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page100
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Calculate the third order intermodulation
 Cell 1 – 1922.4MHz
 Cell 2 – 1925.4MHz
 Cell 3 – 1859.6MHz


Check cell 2 uplink interference
 The interval of 2 interference is

821-544

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page101
Ca s e 1
 Analysis

Conclusion
 The third intermodulation of cell 1 and cell 2 is just in WCDMA
uplink band

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page102
Ca s e 1
 Solution

Change the hopping frequency of DSC

 Confirmation
 Check the RTWP again, the values are normal

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page103
Ca s e 1
 Summary

Characteristics of inner system interference
 The RTWP result are not same at the main and diversity antenna
 The amplitude of interference is big, and the difference is more than 10
dB
 High RTWP will appear in a duration, and will not change so frequently
 High RTWP will not show in a certain time each day, but randomly

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page104
Ca s e 2
 Description

In a commercial network of country U, the following RTWP
problem is found from traffic statistic
RNCI RTWP_MEA RTWP_MA RTWP_MI
CellId CellName Time(As hour)
d N X N

201 11912 Aguada_C 2005-11-15 4:00 -93.94 -88.65 -105.66

201 11942 Centenario_C 2005-11-15 4:00 -95.86 -87.65 -105.66

2005-11-15
201 11932 Centro_C -96.62 -93.65 -97.65
17:00

201 11623 Ciudad Vieja_C 2005-11-15 0:00 -96.74 -91 -105.65

2005-11-15
201 11461 Palacio_C -97.1 -96 -104.65
20:00

201 11643 Pocitos_C 2005-11-15 2:00 -97.72 -92.65 -105.65

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page105
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Connect to the problem NodeB, and monitor the RTWP
 Take one site as example

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page106
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

The main and diversity antenna have the same
interference trend

The different between main and diversity is less than
10dB

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page107
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Check the location of the sites with high RTWP

High

Medium

Low

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page108
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

All the problem cells are in the third sector of the
NodeB, and the direction is to the northwest

Many cells at this area show high interference, and the
cells with low RTWP are at low place

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page109
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Analyze the RTWP in the nearly one month, the
interference shows randomly, but if appears, usually one
whole day, or several days

The interference shows with high traffic, and also with
low traffic. No evidence shows it is related to the traffic

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page110
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Maybe the interference comes from outside and the
northwest direction

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page111
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Use YBT250 to do the interference checking

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page112
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

All the test results show the interference comes from the
same direction – to the country A

But the distance to country A from the test place is
around 50Km to 200Km

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page113
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Frequency analysis
 UCount
ryUMTSf
requenc
y
– 1900MHz
 Ac
ount
ryGS
Mfr
equenc
y
– 1900MHz

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page114
Ca s e 2
 Analysis

Maybe the interference comes from A country, but looks
like impossible because the distance (50 to 200Km) is
beyond the transmission

To confirm this problem, use A country cell phone at the
area with high RTWP

The result shows the phone does receive the A country
DSC

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page115
Ca s e 2
 Conclusion

The interference comes from A country GSM
 Even the distance is very far, the area between the
border is covered by a large water area

Due to reflection the water, the signal can be transmitted
far away

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page116
Ca s e 2
 Conclusion

After known the reason, the following character of this
kind of interference is found
 Rel
atedt
otheweat
her
– Ra in da y, no inte rfe re nce
– Cloudy da y, le s s inte rfe re nce
– S unny da y, high inte rfe re nce
 Rel
atedt
othes
eas
onsal
so
– P roble ms s how a t S umme r more tha n Winte r

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page117
Ca s e 2
 Summary

Characteristics of external interference
 The RTWP result are same at the main and diversity antenna
 The amplitude of interference is small, and the difference is less than 10
dB
 The interference exists at large area, not just one cell, also including
neighbor cells
 The direction of external interference is obvious
 The cell with high antenna is easier to be interferenced

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page118
S umma ry
 RF optimization

Neighbor cell list optimization

Coverage performance optimization
 Interference optimization

Copyright © 2007 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Page119
Thank you
www.huawei.com