You are on page 1of 20

Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.

com

Otherpower.com

Dan Bartmann and Dan Fink


Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Wind is the most difficult energy resource to harvest


Solar, hydro, and fossil
fuel sources give smooth
and steady energy, so
efficient generators for
them are easy to design.

The wind varies wildly
and unpredictably, with
an exponential power
curve.

Power available in the
wind (in watts) =
½ x air density x swept
area x wind speed³
(kg/m³, m², m/s)
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

The objective: Slow down the wind, and transfer


this energy into a spinning shaft


Wind quantity and quality are
both important

Most winds come to us at low
speeds

Tall towers are essential—you
wouldn't mount a solar panel
in the shade!

Turbulence is also a problem
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

HAWT vs. VAWT


1kw HAWT 
½ of a VAWTs rotor is moving in
the wrong direction

VAWT blades are also ½ as
efficient as HAWTs

Therefore VAWTs must be 4 times
as large as HAWTs to make the
same energy

VAWTs experience severe cyclical
stresses every rotation

1kw VAWT

VAWTs cannot be yawed out of the
wind to control them

VAWTs are not more quiet than
HAWTs, nor are they safer for birds

VAWTs do NOT perform better near
the ground, on turbulent sites, or in
low winds, than HAWTs—despite
the advertising hype
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Comparison of wind turbine rotor design


efficiency and Tip Speed Ratios
Graph source: NREL

No wind turbine power
coefficient (cP) can exceed
the Betz Limit of 59.26%

Drag-based turbines are
very inefficient, suitable
only for grinding grain or
pumping water

High-solidity rotors have a
very high drag component,
and are also not suitable for
producing electricity
Before you try to think 
3-blade, low drag, lift-based
“outside the box,” find out turbines operating at TSRs
what's IN the box and why.
of 5-7 are the most
efficient, and are easiest
and cheapest to build.
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Objective: produce electricity


POOR POOR

The lower the shaft RPM, the
heavier and more expensive the
alternator must be

Gearing to increase RPM is
undesirable due to friction,
which hurts low wind
performance
Waterpumper: 
Using electromagnets to
Savonious: Mostly Lift-based but produce magnetic flux hurts low-
drag based VAWT high solidity wind performance
with very low RPM and high drag
give low RPM 
Ferrous coil cores increase
FANTASY magnetic flux, but hurt low-wind
performance by cogging
There are many 
In winds of 7-28 mph that we
reasons this is a
graphic and not an want to capture, turbine RPM of
actual photo! 80-500 is ideal for TSR=5-7 and
therefore maximum cP
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Wind turbine alternators



No effective commercial or surplus
products exist:
NO

Vehicle alternators need 1000 RPM plus;
too fast

Servo motors are wired wrong: very
inefficient, with high possibility of burnout
NO

Induction motors and surplus gasoline
generators need constant RPM

The only effective solution:


Build your own low-RPM
alternator.

Just like what all legitimate wind


turbine companies do!
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Axial flux air gap alternator



Low RPM, specifically designed for
individual system voltage

Permanent magnets eliminate
parasitic losses from
electromagnets

Large mass of very powerful
magnetic material makes up for
large air gap and no ferrous coil
cores

Start-up cogging losses are
eliminated

Easy to build using standard
vehicle parts and/or flat steel
sheets, even in remote areas

Common in commercial wind
turbine designs
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Furling Systems

Wind turbines must cope
with an exponential
increase in power from the
wind to survive

Alternators react to power
input on a mostly linear
curve

Matching the turbine rotor
to the alternator is critical

Reducing the swept area is
the best way to regulate
small wind turbine output

The most reliable, elegant,
easy to fabricate, and
effective solution is the
furling tail
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Renewable energy systems



Hybrid solar/wind systems
produce the most energy, in kwh
per month, at most locations

Rated output is overrated

You cannot compare solar and
wind systems by “rated output”

Solar PV rated output assumes
full sun, fairly common

Wind rated output assumes 28
mph wind speeds, very rare

The critical figure is ENERGY
production in watt-hours, not
instantaneous POWER output in
watts. Instantaneous power
output does not matter much—
what matters is for how long you
gained or used it.
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Local Manufacture and Training



Local manufacture is possible,
these photos from Bluefields,
Nicaragua, Blue Energy Group NGO

Skills and equipment needed
include welding, metalworking,
electrical wiring, resin casting,
wood carving
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Frame Fabrication

Flat steel parts can be cut
with torch or hacksaw

Strong welding is
absolutely essential

Standard trailer bearings
are available worldwide
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Stator Fabrication

The stator
must be a
solid resin
casting
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Magnet Rotor Fabrication


Again, a
strong
casting is
needed
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Blade Carving

Wood--the original
carbon-graphite
composite!

The main
advantage of
fiberglass is in
mass production
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Towers

Towers must be both
tall and sturdy

Turbines must fly 30
feet above anything
within 300 feet in any
direction

Tower cost and time
to build it is at least
equal to that of the
turbine itself

Climb or tilt up—
depends on your skill
set and training
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Regular Maintenance

A regular, yearly maintenance schedule
is essential with ALL wind turbines, not
just homebrew ones.

Maintenance training is critical with
inexperienced turbine owners

Climate affects the maintenance
schedule of turbines and towers
tremendously

Attention to detail is critical!

The “EVENT CASCADE” is the start of


almost all wind turbine failures.

For example, a $5 rectifier fails from a heat sink


that's too small. The turbine runs single phase,
and the stator overheats. The stator melts and
swells, causing magnets to rub it. Friction heating
brings the magnets past their Curie temperature.
The magnets no longer adhere to the rotors, and
fly out, hitting the blades. You are left with a pile
of junk!
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Homebrew wind turbine books


Windpower Workshop
by Hugh Piggott

Axial Flux Wind
Turbine Plans by
Hugh Piggott

Homebrew Wind
Power by us
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Wind turbine seminars



Hands-on experience for
educators is essential

Develop your own curriculum
to suit the ultimate location,
no matter how remote

Custom tailor the curriculum
to the skill level of your
students
Copyright 2008 by Otherpower.com

Wind energy should be:

- Cost effective
- Reliable
- Silent
- Easy to live with
- Fun!

You might also like