Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I
magine a place where the term ‘million- Above Frosty morning: imagine also that these excavations were fiercely
aire archaeologist’ would not sound looking south on the N9/ regulated to control their quality. This sounds like
N10 motorway project
photo: Headland Archaeology (Ireland) Ltd
ridiculous, and where young archae- an archaeo-utopia: but for a short time it existed.
at Russellstown, County
ology students could look forward to Carlow. This was Ireland’s Celtic Tiger archaeology.
excellent career prospects with salaries Current Archaeology last published a special
equivalent to any other profession. issue on Irish archaeology in September 1970 (CA
Imagine hundreds of excavations up and down 22). The sites reported on then by Andrew Selkirk
the country crying out for help, willing to pay (Knowth, Newgrange, Navan Fort and Ballyglass)
handsomely, even for inexperienced diggers; remained state-of-the-art for the following 30
700
600
500
400
years. The eminent archaeologists interviewed
in that issue, and the sites which they excavated, 300
eventually came to dominate Irish archaeology.
Now, the sheer scale of work undertaken during
graph: National Roads Authority
200
the boom has challenged the accepted wisdom of
many key site types and periods. 100
During the Celtic Tiger prosperity, the world
became aware of the contentious Irish sites that 0
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
made international headlines (see box feature on
Rumsfeldian archaeology
The majority of archaeologists in both Britain
and Ireland are employed to work on develop-
ment-led (commercial) projects. Embedding
archaeology in the planning process has been
called ‘Rumsfeldian Archaeology’, because it is
best explained by a somewhat mystifying speech
given by the former US Secretary of State for
Defence, Donald Rumsfeld:
As we know,
There are known knowns.
There are things we know we know.
We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say
We know there are some things
We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns,
The ones we don’t know
We don’t know.
12 February 2002,
Department of Defence news briefing
Nowhere were these tactics more apparent than during the preferred route was selected from a number of different options, all of
excavations on the M3 as it passed through the Tara-Skryne valley in which attempted to steer clear of known archaeological sites.
Co. Meath. The Hill of Tara is a complex of earthworks dating from the Nevertheless, in such a rich archaeological landscape it was inevitable
Neolithic to the early Medieval period, and according to tradition was that entirely new sites would be unearthed, and when a highly significant
the seat of the High King of Ireland. The distance between the new Iron Age enclosure was discovered at Lismullin, the excavation rekindled
motorway and the exact site of the hill is 2.2 km (1.37 miles), and the debate in the media on the proposed route. The site was seized upon by
pressure groups opposed to development, and the motorway
was widely reported as being built through ‘the hill of Tara.’ The
perception at home and abroad was that Ireland was riding
roughshod over its past, blatantly bulldozing one of its most iconic
monuments. Public opinion was polarised, and commercial field
archaeologists, engaged by the NRA, were caught in the crossfire.
The fiercest critics of Celtic Tiger archaeology object on
principle. Condemning the ‘development at all costs’ agenda, the
Nobel Laureate Seamus Heaney criticised modern day Ireland’s
pursuit of the secular above the sacred. In an interview with
the BBC in March 2008, he said, ‘If ever there was a place that
deserved to be preserved in the name of the dead generations
from pre-historic times up to historic times up to completely
PHOTO: Michael Fox/Knowth.com
more about modern Ireland’s concerns in the present than it does about
preserving the past. Irrespective of the clear protocols for the conduct of
excavations on road schemes, headlines typically depict the impact of
development as a simple choice between preservation and destruction,
rather than a negotiated process of impact assessment and consultation.
further READING