Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A.P.A.C. Ltd.
Archaeological Perspectives Analysis Consultancy
REPORT
WB/MON/15
Prepared for:
MR A Nichols & Mrs Alex Watkins
By: Dr N. Phillips.
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Summary
MCC imposed the advised condition and this report is the result of the watching
brief, undertaken to satisfy it.
The work did not impact upon any significant archaeological resources.
Given the proximity of the Clawdd du ditch the findings support the opinion that
the immediate area has been subject to extensive redevelopment.
Copyright Notice:
A.P.A.C. Ltd. retains copyright of this report under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988.
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577) to reproduce map information; Copyright remains
otherwise with the Ordnance Survey.
1
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Contents
Summary ......................................................................................................................................... 1
Contents........................................................................................................................................... 2
Figures: ............................................................................................................................................ 2
Plates: .............................................................................................................................................. 3
Appendices ...................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 4
Site Location and Description ......................................................................................................... 4
Brief archaeological and historical background .............................................................................. 5
Aims and Objectives ....................................................................................................................... 6
Watching Brief ................................................................................................................................ 6
Watching Brief Results ................................................................................................................... 7
Interpretation ................................................................................................................................... 8
Staff ................................................................................................................................................. 9
Archive: ........................................................................................................................................... 9
Acknowledgements: ........................................................................................................................ 9
Bibliography and References: ....................................................................................................... 10
Figures:
2
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Plates:
Appendices
3
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Introduction
This Watching Brief Report has been prepared by Dr Neil Phillips, A.P.A.C. Ltd, in order to satisfy a condition
placed on a planning proposal to build a single story extension on a pre-existing house, 34, Clawdd Ddu.
DC/2015/00183.
Glamorgan Gwent Archaeological Trust; (GGAT), advisors to the planning department, were notified of the
proposed development by Monmouthshire County Council (MCC).
GGAT advised planning that the work posed a potential for disturbance of archaeological remains; inferred from
evidence of Roman, medieval and post medieval resources, unearthed in the close vicinity.
The developer shall ensure that a suitably qualified archaeologist is present during the
undertaking of any ground disturbing works in the development area, so that an
archaeological watching brief can be conducted. The archaeological watching brief shall
be undertaken to the standards of the Institute for Archaeologists. The local planning
authority shall be informed, in writing, at least two weeks prior to the commencement of the
development of the name of the said archaeologist and no work shall begin until the local
planning authority has confirmed, in writing that the proposed archaeologist is suitable. A
copy of the watching brief report shall be submitted to the local planning authority within
two months of the fieldwork being completed by the archaeologist.
The property is situated at NGR: 350418 212208, on the outer edge of the town of Monmouth.
The location of the site can be gained from the A40, Abergavenny – Monmouth Rd, fig 01.
When travelling north on the A40, turn immediately left after going through the road tunnels; pass the garage and at
the roundabout take the second turn towards the town centre.
At the traffic lights, turn left onto Goldwire Lane and second left onto “Clawdd Ddu”,
The site is one of a terrace of modern houses which back onto a grassed recreation area, bounded by the “Clawdd
Ddu” ditch.
The “Clawdd Ddu” ditch, which is some 12m south east of the site, is a Scheduled Ancient Monument (Cadw ref
MM036), a defensive ditch built in medieval age to protect the suburb of Overmonnow.
The geology at the site consists of superficial Alluvium deposits: normally soft to firm consolidated, compressible
clay, but can contain layers of silt, sand, peat and basal gravel above a solid geology of St Maughan’s sandstone.
(BGS 2014)
The area of the site is within the natural flood plain of the nearby rivers Wye and Monnow; responsible for the
superficial deposits most of which, in the area of the site, have been largely disturbed by building development.
4
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
The archaeological record for the Monmouth area is well represented from prehistory to present; indeed, a 5km
diameter search centred on the town would yield archaeological resources from the Bronze Age, Iron Age, Roman,
Early Medieval, Medieval, Norman, Post medieval and even Modern WWII.
The first documented record of Monmouth comes in the British section of the Itinerarium Provinciarum Antonini
Augusti, (RIVIT, 57. 1970).
On a Roman road between ISCA SILVRVM (Caerleon) and CALLEVA AREBATVM (Silchester);
mid way at 11 miles between BVRRIVM (Usk) and ARICONIVM (Weston Under Penyard is
Monmouth.
The Antonine Itinerary has BLESTIO equidistant between BVRRIVM and ARICONIVM.
Accepting the interpretation for Roman BLESTIO (Blestium) as Monmouth, the location would have been for a site
of Roman interest on a boundary between the Iron Age tribes of the Silures and the Dobunni.
Primarily a military site, it is likely that later development in the 2nd to 4th centuries changed Blestio into a civilian
settlement, (Marvell 2001); a civilian site undertaking a great deal of Iron working, (Newman, 394. 2000) &
(Clarke, 99. 2008).
Little is known of the period between the departure of the Romans and the coming of the Normans but it is
inconceivable that such an important site, with defences, infrastructure and possibly industry would have ceased to
exist.
Certainly, the church of St Cadoc’s existed before the Normans because it is listed in the foundation charter of
Monmouth Priory, (Soulsby 181. 1983).
Norman presence in Monmouth was established when William Fitz Osbern built a motte at Monmouth dated pre
AD 1071, for that is when he died.
The position of such a defence would be typical of the sites selected by Fitz Osbern as he strengthened a border
along the Wye, (Phillips, p74 2006).
Further Norman control of Monmouth led to other building projects such as a Benedictine Priory and St Mary’s
Church, 1101-2, or clearance for the market place and a grid pattern of streets, synonymous of burghal development,
(Shoesmith, 2. 1973).
AD. 1297-1320 saw the construction of defences with the erection of town walls with fortified gates and gated
bridges encircling the town.
A later visitor, John Leland, c 1538, described Monmouth as ‘enclosed by a wall on that part which is not defended
by rivers…through age, the wall is broken and much of the defence is down… nevertheless extensive ruins remain
along with a deep ditch.’ (in) (Clarke, 69. 2008).
It is the existence of part of those defences; ‘Clawdd du’ (HER 5134. SAM MM036) and its proximity to the site,
approximately 12m, that prompted GGAT to recommend the condition of a watching brief, (MON2158/JB).
A date for the digging of the ‘Clawdd du’ ditch is not known but it has been proposed that it is a later addition to the
main defences; taking the form of an extra, floodable defence in times of need.
Unfortunately, extensive development in the area and unmonitored clearing of the ditch in the 1950s is thought to
have had a detrimental impact on any potential remains, (HER 5134, E004653).
To assess the potential of archaeological resources, a 500m diameter search centred on the proposed site; HER 5134,
was commissioned from the Historic Environment Record (HER) held by GGAT; appendices I-III.
5
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
The search map, fig 02, shows the concentration of both Core (b) and Event (a) records around the site as provided
by HER 5134.
The search produced 32 archaeological events and a core list of 40 archaeological resources which included:
2 x Grade I structures
31 x Grade II structures
4 x Grade II* structures
2 x SAM (Scheduled Ancient Monuments)
2 x Grade II Parks & Gardens
Of the Event records, Fig 2a, record an evaluation E003734 (1992); which closest to the site, listed residual Roman
and Medieval ceramics and the possible rampart profile of the Clawdd du ditch.
In contrast, subsequent evaluations that impacted on the ditch E002492 (1999) and E004653 (2002) produced no
finds or features and suggested that its current profile was likely to be that of the 1950s cleaning operation.
In summary therefore the HER record would suggest the potential for archaeological resources ranging from Iron
Age to Medieval although these are likely to have been mostly destroyed or redistributed by 20th century
development.
To complete the brief archaeological background for the site, a map progression was undertaken in order to assess
changes and indicators of previous land use, fig03.
The first map consulted was that of the 1831, First Series Ordnance Survey Sheet 43, fig 03a, which shows the area
now occupied by 34 Clawd du as an enclosed field abutting the Clawd du ditch.
The later 1881 Ordnance Survey map, Monmouthshire XIV, fig 03b, gives a clearer depiction of the area revealing
that the present site corresponds to the edge of a cultivated field and an orchard which abutted the Clawd du ditch.
With the exception of a well being added to the adjacent northern field, there was little change recorded by 1900
Ordnance Survey map, Monmouthshire XIV, fig 03c, nor indeed before the later 1943 edition.
The situation did change in the 1950s, with housing development as noted above, the results of which are shown in
the last map dated 2015. fig 03d.
The aim of the watching brief was to preserve by record, within the resources available, any archaeological deposits
uncovered during groundwork.
The watching brief also ensured that: in the event of archaeological resources of significance, being discovered and
requiring treatment beyond the remit of the watching brief, that steps would be implemented to ensure that their
treatment would be undertaken within the standards recommended by the CIFA.
Watching Brief
The watching brief was undertaken over 3 days: 14th 15th September 2015 and the 19th November 2015.
6
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
The site was cleared of obstructions on the first day with fencing removed for access and patio slabs and wall
revetments to the steps removed in the area of the proposed ground work, PL01.
Initial recording
A record of the features and stratigraphy exposed during excavation was kept including written notes and
photographs.
Measurements were taken regularly using Leica Disto 510, laser measurement device.
A limited number of finds were recovered for post excavation processing and disposed of at the clients request.
Post Ex
Following the watching brief, the field notes and photographs were digitised to produce the context record of the
stratigraphy; Appendix IV, and an annotated list of the photographs, Appendix V.
The finds which were washed by hand, dried, identified, photographed and packed in sealed and ladled bags, were
recorded in Appendix VI.
The three appendices; IV Context and V Photographs VI finds were cross referenced ready for inclusion in the
report.
Presentation Notes:
All contexts are denoted [#] in the text, listed in Appendix V, cross referenced in Appendix VI, to the plates section.
Photographs used in the text are listed Pl # and a complete list of photographs can be found in appendix VI with
contact sheets.
Finds are listed {#}.
Work began on site with the removal of the flagstones, [100], PL01, to reveal various deposits of bedding [101],
[106], [107] & [109], relating to the structures of the patio [100], & path [108].
The excavation was bounded to the north west by the house wall [104] and to the south east by the revetment wall
[102].
The first trench TR1, PL02, was excavated to an initial depth of 1.3m exposing the general sequence shown in
PL03:
Within the general sequence were two localised events; both c200mm diameter bitumen pipes [115] & [117].
The lower pipe [117] was in a tapered fill [111], which had been cut, [118] into [112], whereas [115] was in another
fill event [110], which had been cut [116] into [111].
The sequence revealed that the house [104] had been set on a concrete foundation which had been cut into [113] at a
depth of around 1 metre; the contexts: [101], [107], [109], [110], [111], [112] having been deposited after.
A finds assemblage {1} of 18th to 20th century ceramics, was collected from fill event [111].
7
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
The stratigraphic sequence was similar to that of TR1 but lacked the bitumen pipe [115] as the upper pipe serviced
the rain gutter to the west of the property, PL05.
The buildings inspector visited the site at this point and requested a test pit to be excavated as the ground exposed at
that depth was deemed unsuitable for the building to progress.
The required test pit was dug at the western end of Trench 1, PL06 and increased the overall depth to 1.8m.
The underlying stratigraphic sequence changed to a red sandy silt [114] overlaying a dark brown sandy clay (natural
alluvial deposit) which extended beyond the depth of the test pit.
The inspector considered [119] to be a suitable surface for building purposes and both trenches were extended to
1.8m. PL07.
The final foundation trench, TR3, joined the two eastern ends of trenches 1 and 2 exposing a stratigraphy not
disturbed by the drainage sequences associated with pipes [115] and [117], found closer to the house.
There was however the addition of the patio revetment wall [102] which had been cut into [112] and underlay the
lawn [103].
Trench 3 did provide two sherds of 18th/19th century ceramics {2} and one small sherd of Medieval ceramic {3}
which was noticed by the contractor as it fell off the excavator bucket.
The remaining service trenches and soakaway where excavated on the 19/11/2015; the soakaway position can be
seen in Plate 08 as can the waterlogged ground condition.
Two shallow service trenches c 400mm in depth, were cut from trench 3, PL09, and joined to continue to the
soakaway, PL10.
The service trenches, for the majority of their run, impacted upon contexts [102] and [112] but the deeper soakaway
cut into [113], [114] & [119].
A partial horse skeleton burial [121] was cut [122], into [113] and [114] at the north east corner of the soakaway; a
context that had already revealed 18th/19th century finds assemblage {2}.
Two teeth from the skeleton were collected and left with the client for safe keeping the rest was left in situ.
At this point excavation ceased and work to fill the drainage system as quickly as possible, due to the heavy rain
began.
The adverse effect of the rain can be seen in PL11 which shows the service trench flooding with a flow of mud.
Finds
The site provided a small amount finds, all except one, modern domestic ceramic wares, {1} & {2}.
Find {3} a thumbnail sized sherd of applied, Bristol Radcliff, came from an uncertain context and is therefore of
only circumstantial value.
The partial horse skeleton appeared to be in a good state of preservation and its cut [122] indicated a fairly modern
deposition and as such it was not excavated.
The finds were not retained beyond post ex processing and disposed of by permission of the client.
Interpretation
The entire excavation was confined to a depth wherein no archaeological resources were disturbed.
The extent of deposit that was excavated would appear to be of recent redistributed land fill/levelling.
8
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Staff
Archive:
The original archive for this project will remain with APAC Ltd and a copy deposited with Gwent Archive
Copies of the report will be deposited with the client, GGAT HER & MCC Planning.
Acknowledgements:
Thanks to Mr Nichols & Ms Watkins for allowing access to his site, and their groundwork’s contractors for their
assistance and efficient handling of the excavations.
9
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
Clarke, S., 2008. Down the Dig Monmouth an Adventure in Archaeology. Monmouth
Archaeological Society.
Code of Conduct and the Code of Approved Practice for the regulation of
Contractual Arrangements in Field Archaeology. 2008.
GGAT. 2014. MON2158/JB. Re: Proposed single story rear extension 34 Clawdd Du, Monmouth,
Pl.App.Nos.: 2015/00183
GGAT HER 5134 HER 500m search centred at 350418 212208: 34 Clawdd Du, Monmouth
Marvell, A. G. (ed.), 2001, BAR British Series 320: Investigations along Monnow Street, Monmouth, Oxford
Monmouthshire County
Council Approval of Planning Permission. DC/2015/00183.
Newman, J., 2000. The Building of Wales Gwent and Monmouthshire. Penguin Books. University of
Wales Press.
Phillips , N., 2006. Earthwork Castles of Gwent & Ergyng AD 1050 – 1250. BAR Series 420.
RIVIT, A.L.F., 1970. The British Section of the Antonine Itinerary (in) Britannia. I. 34-82.
Shoesmith, R., 1973. Excavations in Monmouth. The Monmouthshire Antiquary, 10-15, VI. 1990.
10
A.P.A.C. 34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth WB/MON/15
11
34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
Glyn Smith RIBA.Architect
“Ty-Lllawen”
Pen-yr-ale Lane Llangynidr
Powys. NP8 1NE
a Event
b Core
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/MON/15
Fig 02: HER search area 5134
The ordnance survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
34 Clawdd du, Monmouth
a Ordnance survey first series, sheet 43 1:63360 b 1880 - 1881, published 1886 Monmouthshire XIV
c 1900. published 1902 Monmouthshire XIV NE d 2015 Magic map A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/MON/15
The ordnance survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth
Living
room
[104]
Patio Bo
[100] und
ary
]
02
ll [1
TR
1
wa
[117]
TR
2
2
[115] Lawn
TR
[103]
ry
TR4 TR
6
da
un
Bo
Bo TR
und 5
ary
[122]
0 10m
Contractors:
FA Foundations Archaeology
GGAT Glamorgan Gwent Archaeological Trust
MA Monmouth Archaeology
BaRAS Bristol and Regions Archaeological Services
DAT Dyfed Archaeological Trusts
A.P.A.C. Ltd. Appendix II WB/MON/15
DSC08772
DSC08779
Plate 01: Raised patio area to be excavated. [100], [102], [103], [104]
DSC08777
Plate 01: TR1. Initial excavation SW edge. Footings of no:34. [104], Plate 03: TR1. Initial excavation SW edge.
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/MON/15
106], [107], [108], [109], [110], [111], [112], [115], [117]. Detail Footings of no:34. [104], [106], [107], [108], [109],
[110], [111], [112], [113], [115], [117].
34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth
DSC08783
DSC08780
Plate 04: TR1 & TR2 positions Plate 05: TR2. [100], [110], [111], [112], [113], [114], [119].
DSC08784
DSC08781
Plate 06: TR1. Initial excavation SW edge. Footings of no:34. Plate 07: TR2. [100], [104], [110], [111],
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/MON/15
[104], [106], [105], [107], [108], [109], [110], [111], [112], [113], [112], [113], [114], [119].
[114], [119], [115], [117].
34 Clawdd Ddu, Monmouth
DSC09096
DSC09093
Plate 08: Lawn before excavation [103]. Plate 09: Excavation of soak away. [103], [113], [114].
DSC09099
DSC09098
Plate 10: Excavation of soak away. [103], [113], [114]. Detail Plate 11: Excavation of soak away.
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/MON/15
[103], [113], [114]. Detail with three
drain runs
A.P.A.C. Ltd Appendix VI WB/MON/15
Finds Index
DSCO8806
1
DSCO8807
2
DSCO8808
3