Professional Documents
Culture Documents
School district superintendents make the list. So do principals. But surprises on the local government top-earners list in the capital region came from police officers,
firefighters, a borough manager and an athletic director. The first-ever snapshot of earnings paid out by 75 local government agencies in the Harrisburg area — county
governments, townships, boroughs, cities and school districts — shows 139 officials can tout membership in the coveted $100,000 Club.
Sixty-six others earning between $95,000 and $100,000 were close to knocking on that clubhouse door. The data compiled by The Patriot-News through Right-to-Know
requests is from the end of 2009. Many of the people on the list have since left their jobs.
But this survey shows the payroll for the 17 school districts, four county governments and 53 townships, boroughs or cities included in the survey totaled just over $755
million for nearly 23,000 full- and part-time employees.
Former Harrisburg School District Superintendent Gerald Kohn topped the list of salaries at $235,431. Following him was his former deputy superintendent Julie Botel,
who made $204,790. They were the only ones to top the $200,000 mark.
A few, including former Harrisburg fire chiefs Donald Konkle and Daniel Soulier, made the list only because their earnings included the leave pay-outs they received when
retiring that year, which they had accrued over decades of service.
Other city firefighters topped the $100,000 threshold because of overtime they incurred, some of which was associated with their service as part of the Pennsylvania Urban
Search and Rescue Task Force 1. Harrisburg city spokesman Robert Philbin said no city employee in 2009 or even today earns a six-figure salary.
Whatever the reason that landed people on this $100,000 list, taxpayers foot the bill, and many of them earn less.
The state’s median household income for 2009 was $49,501, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. The newspaper’s local government salary survey showed 6,388
employees, or 28 percent of those who worked for county and local government and school districts that year earned more than that median income. The bulk of the local
government salaries fell between the $30,000 and $50,000 range.
A recent study of local and state government pay in Pennsylvania noted the highest of the top earners in the public sector in Pennsylvania don’t come close to highly paid
executives in the private sector, according to a recent study by the Economic Policy Institute in Washington, D.C. and labor-friendly Keystone Research Center in
Harrisburg.
For example, Kohn’s $235,431 salary in 2009 pales in comparison to the 2010 salaries of East Pennsboro Twp.-based Rite Aid Corp.’s chairwoman Mary Sammons, who
made $3.2 million, and The Hershey Co.’s former CEO David West, who made $10.5 million, according to AFL-CIO’s corporate watch website.
“The much lower pay at the top end of the public sector is why people never say: ‘I’m leaving the private sector to go make more money,’” said Stephen Herzenberg,
Keystone Research Center’s executive director.
While private sector pay may be higher, the public sector’s non-wage benefits tend to be more generous, according to the study’s author Jeffrey Keefe. But when the cost of
benefits and wages are combined, Keefe, an associate professor of labor and employment at Rutgers University, found the public sector’s total compensation to be on par
with that of the private sector.
139 central Pennsylvania officials tout membership in the $100k club
By JAN MURPHY, The Patriot-News, Harrisburg, PA
Published: Sunday, October 09, 2011, 12:00 AM
http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/10/139_central_pennsylvania_offic.html
2 / 14
But Matthew Brouillette, president of the conservative-leaning Commonwealth Foundation in Harrisburg, argues it’s hard to determine whether government employees are
overpaid or underpaid compared to their private sector peers because the basis for determining pay levels differs. “In the private sector, supply and demand as well as
performance and results determine the value of labor, or what someone should be compensated. This is not the case in the government sector,” where seniority and in the
case of educators, degrees earned generally determine pay levels, he said.
Moreover, he said those non-wage benefits, including lower employee contributions to health care and better pension plans, that attract people to local and state government
jobs are becoming unaffordable for taxpayers.
“Taxpayers are struggling to afford those costs now, and that is even with pushing the burden out onto future generations through the financial manipulations of politicians
at both the state and local levels,” Brouillette said. Compared to the local government salaries to those paid by state government, it’s pretty clear working for the
commonwealth gives employees a better shot at a bigger salary.
A Pittsburgh Tribune-Review’s state government salary survey from May found nearly 3,600 of 108,117 state workers making $5,000 or more per year earned $100,000 or
more. That compares to 139 out of 18,432 workers in the region’s local government arena earning $5,000 or more.
Even when looking at average salaries, state government employees earned more. According to the governor’s workforce statistics, state government employee salaries
averaged $47,821 in 2008-09, and $49,082 in 2009-10, while in the region’s local governments, the average employee salary was $46,541.
The local salaries included in the survey did not include county and district judges’ salaries since they are paid by the state.
At the bottom of the salary chart is Dauphin County’s Reed Twp. roadmaster Steven Allen, who earned $0 in 2009. Allen, whose hourly wage that year was $11, said the
township job is a part-time gig for him and it only earns him a paycheck when the township needs his services. That year, he said apparently no stop signs got plowed over
that needed replaced .
On the other end of the municipal payroll, the newspaper’s analysis shows six in 10 individuals earning $100,000 or more worked for school districts. Along with
superintendents, the six-figure earners include assistant superintendents, business managers, principals and other administrative staffers. The average pay in 2009 of the 16
superintendents included in the survey topped $142,500, which was higher than the state’s $125,087 average superintendent’s salary for that year, according to the
Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators.
But that organization’s executive director Jim Buckheit pointed out Pennsylvania’s average superintendent’s salary lags behind the national average of $155,631 for 2008-
09. A study done by his organization also found that Pennsylvania superintendents are generally responsible for larger budgets and more employees and students than their
counterparts in other states.
“So if you use those as benchmarks of responsibility and span of control, they get paid less but they are responsible for more than what superintendents around the country
are,” Buckheit said.
Dragging down the state’s average superintendent’s pay are the large number of small and rural school districts that pay their top executive in the $80,000 to $100,000
range, he said.
139 central Pennsylvania officials tout membership in the $100k club
By JAN MURPHY, The Patriot-News, Harrisburg, PA
Published: Sunday, October 09, 2011, 12:00 AM
http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/10/139_central_pennsylvania_offic.html
3 / 14
Superintendents in the Harrisburg area tend to fare better than those elsewhere in the state because the midstate districts they serve tend to be larger than those in rural areas
of the state, he said. But there are exceptions such as Camp Hill School District, where former Superintendent Connie Kindler’s salary was right up there with her collegues
in the region.
“That community does express a very strong interest in maintaining very high quality schools,” Buckheit said.
Finding superintendents among the local government’s highest earners came as no surprise to Herzenberg. He attributed that to the fact that teachers and administrators tend
to be more educated than other local government workers.
But he also pointed out the Economic Policy Institute study also found that despite their higher level of education, teachers and other public sector workers earn less than
private sector workers with college degrees.
So despite critics who complain about big taxpayer-funded salaries being paid by government, Herzenberg concludes the newspaper’s survey found what the institute’s
study found: “working for government is not a way to get rich.”
Staff writer Diana Fishlock and former staff writer Lara Brenckle contributed to this report.
Related Links:
Browse the database of central Pennsylvania's $100k Club:
http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/10/central_pennsylvania_100k_club.html
COMMENTS: