Professional Documents
Culture Documents
-----------------
Nature: Refers to the type of procedures, and the mix of those procedures, to address
the audit risk for each account-assertion. Procedures could be controls testing, data
analysis, substantive analytics, key item testing, representative sampling, inquiries,
representations, etc.
Timing: (This is where I want to differ from Meghana Sarma's answer) Relates to when
the work is performed. In a controls-driven entity with high governance, audit work can
be performed well in advance of year end date, with only update procedures for the
remaining period. On the other extreme of this paradigm, some entities may require
procedures only at or very close to year end.
Extent: Refers to how much work is done, based on materiality, expected errors, error
rate, etc. Again, depending on the comfort obtained from other procedures, tests of
details could be based on transactions with different value thresholds.
The nature, timing and extent of the procedures performed by the auditor to obtain an
understanding of the accounting and internal control systems will vary with, among
other things:
• The size and complexity of the entity and of its computer system.
• Materiality considerations.
The following are examples of ways in which planned audit procedures may be modified
to address assessed fraud risks:
Nature- First of all keep in mind that ‘nature’ is used for nature of an audit procedure,
it simply means the type of audit procedure you are performinh whether it is
inspection,observation,etc see the follwing extract(ICAI MODULE OF AUDITING) for
knowing the types of audit procedures
TIMING- Learn it from example ,as we know that inventory is valued at the year end
for finding out closing stock, now some intelligent auditor will say i want to apply
observation(nature of audit procedure) for inventory audit on say 30th of September -_-
because i have less work load than on 31st march ;here is where timing is important ,its
very important to know for the auditor the timing to apply an audit procedure which is
in above example clear is YEAR END ,ofcourse.
NOTE:MUTATIS MUTANDIS
EXTENT- The best and most simple example is of bank audit ,auditor may face
difficulty in determining the extent of INSPECTION(it is an audit procedure-it means to
examine books, documents,etc) as he cant go to every branch especially in rural area
branches, so here he would like to limit the extent of HIS audit procedure and may apply
alternative procedure of relying on SA600(USING THE WORK OF ANOTHER
AUDIT).Other explanation in the answers below/above also holds true as to SAMPLING
EXTENT.
.----------
1. Nature covers what audit procedures will be performed for the company.
2. Timing indicates when the audit procedures will be performed.
3. Extent is how the audit will be performed on a test basis of large or small
sample sizes to gather evidence.
So the “assertion level” is the level at which statements are presented as completely true. E.G.
Management tells the auditor the financial statements show a true valuation of inventory –
management are formally “asserting” this statement as being correct, so we call this at the
“assertion level”.
Definition. Audit Assertions are the implicit or explicit claims and representations made by the
management responsible for the preparation of financial statements regarding the
appropriateness of the various elements of financial statements and disclosures.
Substantive testing is an audit procedure that examines the financial statements and
supporting documentation to see if they contain errors. These tests are needed as evidence to
support the assertion that the financial records of an entity are complete, valid, and accurate.
Substantive procedures (or substantive tests) are those activities performed by the auditor to
detect material misstatement or fraud at the assertion level. The different assertions of balances
are: existence, rights and obligations, validity, and.
--
Assertions about classes of transactions and events and related disclosures for the period
under audit. (i) Occurrence – the transactions and events that have been recorded or
disclosed, have occurred, and such transactions and events pertain to the entity.
Analytical procedures are one of many financial audit processes which help an auditor
understand the client's business and changes in the business, and to identify potential risk
areas to plan other audit procedures. Analytical procedures include comparison of financial
information (data in financial statement) with.
So the “assertion level” is the level at which statements are presented as completely true.
E.G
Management tells the auditor the financial statements show a true valuation of inventory –
management are formally “asserting” this statement as being correct, so we call this at the “assertion
level”.
Just because management give a statement at the assertion level, doesn’t mean it is actually true –
but I didn’t need to tell you that!
The auditor actually does not “do these assertions”. These are the assertions management makes.
The auditor in planning the audit will assess the risk inherent in the assertions management makes,
by assessing what could go wrong with the control.
n a Layman’s language, whatever that has been stated in the Financial statements
(whether it may be sales, purchases, Expenses, Debtor balances, Creditor Balances,
Advances paid, Liabilities incurred, any disclosures made regarding Contingent
liabilities etc), Management is implicitly stating that such transactions have really
occured (Sales, Purchases, Additions to Assets etc), the account balances shown as such
are correct (eg: Debtor Balance is 10,000/-) and disclosures have been made based on
fair estimates. For most of the transactions embodied in FS, Management need not
agree explicitly with the auditor that these transactions are correct as per the view and
judgement of management.
So Assertions are nothing but facts stated by the members of management that form
part of Financial Statements, implicitly or otherwise. Every Journal entry recorded by
the management is a assertion. Financial Statements is a group of assertions made by
the management. Risks arising at this level (i.e, whether a transaction is not recorded in
full, not posted to appropriate head, not recorded in the relevant period, not classified
appropriately etc) are called Assertion Level Risks as they are directly related to
particular assertion concerned.
In contrast, Financial Statement Level risk do not relate to a particular assertion, but for
entire Financial Statements, affects the reliability and genuineness of many assertions
made by the management. Eg - Fraud by management may bring into question many
assertions made by management. Hence evaluation of integrity of management shall be
made.
Assertions - Representations by management, explicit or otherwise, that are embodied
in the financial statements, as used by the auditor to consider the different types of
potential misstatements that may occur.
They are -
1. Occurrence
2. Completeness
3. Accuracy
4. Cut off
5. Classifications
6. Existence
7. Rights and obligations
8. Valuation and allocation
The above assertions are used by the auditor to assess potential misstatements which
may be present in the financial statements. He assesses the risk of material
misstatement at the assertion level for ABCOTD level. (Account balances , class of
transaction and disclosures)
Example,
He assesses the risk that fixed assets though mentioned in the financial statements, may
not exist at all. (Existence )
He assesses the risk that some transactions of previous period have been recorded in the
current period. (cut off )
Meaning of assertion
Now in order to perform audit procedure like Vouch the Credit Sales Transaction, Sampling
& External Confirmations etc are audit technique. In short, Audit Procedure means “What
you have to do.” & Audit Technique means “How you will do it.” Following are the audit
techniques as per Chapter 5 of CA Final Study Material 1. Confirmations; 2. Enquiry; 3.
Observation; 4. Analytical review procedures.
Dividend is appropriation to profits and interest is charge to profit and loss account, if only
profit accrues to the entity dividend shall be paid . It cannot be paid out of capital.