Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Background: Experiencing the death of an infant in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) affects both families and staff,
creating challenges and opportunities for best practices.
Purpose: This practice-based article describes a comprehensive approach to delivering bereavement services to NICU
families, as well as education and support to NICU staff.
Methods: Bereaved NICU parent and staff survey feedback, including quotes describing individual experiences and sug-
gestions for improved service delivery.
Results: Bereaved NICU families and caregivers find meaning and purpose in the act of creating keepsake memories at
the time of the infant’s death. Mutual healing takes place with subsequent, individualized follow-up contacts by staff
familiar to the bereaved parents over the course of a year.
Implications for Practice: Those staff involved in the care of a NICU infant and family, during and after the infant’s death,
attest to the value in providing tangible keepsakes as well as continuing their relationship with the bereaved parents. An
effective administrative infrastructure is key to efficient program operations and follow-through.
Implications for Research: Studying different methods of in-hospital and follow-up emotional support for NICU bereaved
families. Identifying strategies for staff support during and after NICU infant loss, and the impact a formal program may
have on staff satisfaction and retention.
Key Words: bereavement, bereavement support, neonatal intensive care unit (NICU), perinatal bereavement, staff sup-
port, staff–family relationships
ne year later a mother states: “I really appre- the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) experience a
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
www.advancesinneonatalcare.org
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
is the defining goal of this program—helping them “It’s all we have” (to remember our baby), and
say goodbye before they barely had the chance to say another said, “Everything means something.”
hello to their newborn. They are encouraged to Children deserve special attention when their
bring siblings and invite loved ones to the NICU infant sibling dies. The NICU experience in itself can
bedside. Grandparents, other extended family, close be traumatic, but the unique loss of one’s sibling can
friends, and clergy are welcome to participate, add additional stress, confusion, and anxiety.
depending on the parents’ wishes. Depending on their age, developmental stage, and
Offering parents the opportunity to hold and bathe level of involvement, siblings’ grief responses need to
their infant can be very meaningful and a way for be monitored and honored.33,34 An 8-year-old
them to nurture their infant as they say goodbye. In bereaved sibling shared in a letter, “I remember
addition, preserving the infant’s bedside environment when my brother was born … I held him … I remem-
until the parents are ready to remove items is very ber getting stones at the grave … I remember his hair
important to ensure they have closure. The parents was curly.” Moreover, having preestablished con-
may choose (or ask staff) to remove photographs, tacts with siblings during the hospitalization helps to
milestone signs, and other tangible memories at their facilitate the work the BCT provides at the time of
infant’s bedside. It is important to remember that this death. At HDVCH NICU, siblings are welcome in
hospital space will become embedded in their minds the NICU at any time; we offer sibling support pro-
forever as their infant’s first (and only) “nursery,” and grams,33-35 and the child life specialists host a weekly
not to rush the process of saying goodbye. “Super Sibs” pizza party with age-appropriate activ-
Keepsakes, offered with written parental permis- ities. If the children have been involved in NICU sib-
sion, enable families to remember the short time ling activities and regularly scheduled time with
with their precious child.3-5,24 When parents are their sibling in the NICU, they are already immersed
uncertain about the potential value of keepsakes, the in the NICU milieu and reasonably comfortable
following talking points are used by staff to help with its surroundings and staff. The interdisciplinary
illustrate these benefits: “We have learned from teams—nurses, child life specialists, social work-
other families that this can be helpful to their grief ers—often have made a connection with the sibling,
over time” and “I can make the keepsakes today and so that when death occurs, they are in a prime posi-
hold onto them, in case you change your mind.” In tion to attend to the unique emotional needs of each
fact, one family requested their infant’s keepsakes sibling during the death/bereavement events.
2 years later. The bereavement/keepsake checklist
(Box 1) provides an organized, helpful list of PARENT AND FAMILY FOLLOW-UP CARE
bereavement support reminders for staff, along with
a list of keepsakes to prepare for the bereaved NICU At the time of the infant’s death, parents are informed
family members. This checklist was developed for that a staff member will be reaching out to them in
the staff by the BCT to have a clear plan to follow the days ahead, unless they state a preference to not
during this highly charged emotional time. receive this contact. A sympathy card is initiated by
It is important to offer parents the opportunity to one of the BCT nurse leaders, signed by staff across
help with the ink footprints, foam, and/or alginate the NICU interdisciplinary team, and sent to the
plaster impressions, which requires one person to bereaved family within 2 weeks after their infant’s
hold the infant while a second person gently guides death. Comforting words with personal, individual-
the infant’s body into the foam or alginate. Every ized messages and memories specific to their infant
parent is different in their desire to help, and most are written on each card, such as the following: “I
help in some capacity (e.g., actually creating the am heartbroken for your loss. Getting a smile or
keepsakes), holding their infant while the staff does babbling out of her made my day” and “I enjoyed
impressions. If not, parents are asked whether they working on reaching for her toys.”
want to be present while impressions are made. A The neonatologist who was most involved in the
distinctive aspect of our program is the offer of par- infant’s care attempts a call to the parents 2 to
ent and/or sibling hand impressions to be displayed 3 weeks after the infant’s death, offering a family
with the infant’s, as well as face profile impressions conference and answering medical questions the
of the infant, all of which bring the parents and fam- family might have. Autopsy results are also shared
ily members comfort, as another memory of their when requested. One parent shared on her survey
infant (Figures 1-4). It is important to mention that that she appreciated the neonatologist’s 2 attempts
when the face profile impressions were first intro- to call, finding the voicemail messages comforting—
duced, the staff’s reaction was guarded, wondering even though she did not feel a need to talk with him.
whether this would be uncomfortable for the par- The ongoing telephone follow-up by the intention-
ents. Over time, staff has learned from parents who ally designated staff member begins after 3 weeks, a
have shared their overwhelming interest in creating time frame that was suggested by former bereaved
this additional keepsake item. As one parent stated, parents in our NICU, affording time beyond the
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
funeral and after the neonatologist’s call. In most months, unless a family has specifically requested to
situations, the infant’s designated primary care nurse, not receive further contact. The amount and fre-
and/or another nurse who was intimately involved in quency of contacts are determined by individual fam-
the care, makes the calls. This individualized approach ily needs. Information and guidelines for the follow-
is intentional, as it provides emotional support, edu- up provider are shared in Box 2. In addition, the
cation, and as-needed referrals for each bereaved neonatologist sends a card 11 months after their loss,
family with the nurse(s) who personally provided pri- in anticipation of the 1-year anniversary date.
mary care and/or bereavement care in the NICU. The administrative infrastructure to support the
Cards are sent and calls attempted for at least 12 program is organized as follows. First one of the
www.advancesinneonatalcare.org
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
FIGURE 1 FIGURE 2
Foam impressions - parent, sibling and infant hands. Foam impressions - parent hand and infant feet.
BCT nurse leaders records information onto a contacts and cards, and informs the BCT leader if
spreadsheet that includes the infant’s date of birth, unable to fulfill the 12-month commitment, at
date of death, parents’ address and phone number, which time the BCT leader assesses the family’s
dates for sympathy cards, keepsakes, and the tim- ongoing needs and finds an appropriate substitute.
ing of the follow-up parent survey about the pro- The neonatologists’ administrative assistant
gram. The name of follow-up support staff respon- reminds the neonatologist to call the parents 2 to 3
sible for the follow-up and reminders of the time weeks after their infant’s death, and sends the
frames to complete are also included. The follow- 11-month card personally signed by one or more
up support staff is responsible for continuing neonatologists.
FIGURE 3
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
www.advancesinneonatalcare.org
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
From June 2011 through December 2016, 178 passed.” When contacted for clarification, this par-
surveys were mailed representing all NICU deaths in ent stated that she was not prepared for what she
that period, unless parents had specified they desired would see in the photographs. This feedback served
no further contact. One survey was sent to a family as a good reminder for staff to describe all keepsakes
who had experienced the deaths of multiple infants in detail before the family receives them—before
in the same period (e.g., twins). Thirty-six surveys they leave the hospital and/or before mailing them.
were returned for a 20% response rate. One of the most profound surveys was returned
Parents responded to questions about their expe- blank, with a sticky note attached stating, “I am
rience at the time of their infant’s death in the NICU, sorry I cannot help you with this survey. I would
with 34 of 36 indicating they felt they were treated want to give you accurate information, but the day
with understanding, care, and compassion. Two sur- our baby died seems like a blur.” This was a power-
veys were left blank. Open-ended questions regard- ful message that this parent was not able to process
ing what was “most helpful” and “least helpful” her feelings in the midst of her grief—and beyond—
were unanimously positive (27 “most helpful” whereas the other surveys revealed vivid memories
responses, 2 “least helpful” responses, and 7 blank). of every detail.
A sampling of parent feedback is shown in Table 1, In response to follow-up supportive care ques-
informing staff that their interventions were mostly tions, parents were also asked whether the ongoing
effective. Interestingly, 31 of 36 parents signed the cards and contacts they received for the first 12
“optional signature” line, showing they prefer to be months after their infant’s death were helpful.
identified by name. Twenty-seven of 36 parents answered “yes” to the
There were 2 “least helpful” responses, the first of question regarding cards received, 0 answered “no”,
which was in regard to the absence of laundry ser- and 9 left this question blank. When asked “How do
vices for parents in the NICU when they preferred to you feel about the amount of contact you had with
stay at the bedside with their dying infant rather the person who called you?,” 4 parents checked
than leaving the hospital to attend to their laundry “not enough,” 24 “just the right amount,” 1 “too
needs. Fortunately, they also stated that a staff mem- much,” and 7 left it blank. There were several unso-
ber recognized the need and washed their dirty laun- licited parent responses to these questions, which are
dry for them. The second “least helpful” response illustrated in Table 1. In addition, 19 of 36 parents
was as follows: “The photos after our son had (50%) personally named 1 or more staff member
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
www.advancesinneonatalcare.org
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
infant’s death event to bereaved parents may account an online, confidential survey via the hospital por-
for the high satisfaction rate. This individualized tal, to achieve higher response rates.
matching approach to follow-up bereavement care is Our informal, 1-item staff survey specifically
supported by the fact that more than 50% of the asked them to describe their “sense of meaning” in
parents who completed the survey specifically (and providing this service to families, which is an
nonsolicited) named their follow-up staff member important consideration when developing support
on the written survey. services for staff who can experience distress when
The low response rate (20%) for our parent sur- faced with end-of-life NICU events.26,40 At HDVCH,
vey is consistent with others who have reported confidential employee assistance program counsel-
similar rates for surveys conducted with bereaved ing and hospital-run debriefing services41 are avail-
parents.38,39 As one of our respondents so mov- able. To recognize and reinforce the value of the
ingly reported, some bereaved parents simply can- staff person’s skilled, caring practice with bereaved
not emotionally bring themselves to complete a families, the BCT leaders give small gestures of
survey. Despite the potential for this limitation, gratitude, such as an individualized appreciation
obtaining feedback from parents (and developing card signed by one’s peers and a nurturing gift of
better ways to increase response rates) is essential homemade soap. The HDVCH NICU bereavement
to program evaluation and quality improvement. team is also exploring ways to formalize one-to-one
Parent feedback underscores the need for parents staff peer mentoring, and several staff members
to hear from NICU staff and acknowledge the have expressed interest in becoming involved in
family’s profound loss in the days, weeks, and this new, formal initiative. The collective prelimi-
months after their infant’s death, suggesting nary feedback we sought from our NICU staff war-
encouragement to continue practices that help rants further empirical study. Still, the respondents’
bereaved parents navigate their grief journey.5,11,24 comments (primarily from nurses) illuminated the
The BCT has discussed modifications in our sur- intensity of this unique, supportive relationship
vey procedure, such as sending an e-mail survey between parents and staff during and after a NICU
with a link (when an e-mail address is available) or infant’s death.
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
www.advancesinneonatalcare.org
Copyright © 2017 National Association of Neonatal Nurses. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.