5E Dungeons & Dragons Magic Item Crafting Rules

Introduction
The following is a set of optional rules for creating magic items in a Dungeons & Dragons 5E campaign. When compared
to the optional rules in the DMG, this ruleset makes lower rarity items slightly more expensive, higher rarity items
slightly less expensive, and all items will creatable in a reasonable amount of time. A balance of difficulty yet
reasonableness is the goal.

Creating Magic Items

In order to create magic items, you must have the following, in various amounts or degrees as determined by the items
rarity, theme and DM discretion:

1. A formula
2. Creation time and minimum caster level
3. Location
4. Expense
5. Material Components

In addition, you must be an arcane or divine spell caster.

Magical Formula
All magical items have a magical formula that tells the crafter how to create them. For some, it will be the item itself, for
others, the formula explains what is required to add a property to a magical item - for example, flaming.

Example:

Mazen the wizard has a formula that tells him how to craft a +1 magical weapon. It has its own requirements for time,
materials, location and expense. Mazen also has a formula that tells him how to add the Flaming property to a magical
weapon. That formula has its own set of requirements for time, materials, location and expense. Mazen can create a +1
Flaming weapon by combining the two formulas together.

Magical formula can be acquired in the following ways:

1. Purchased at a price set by the DM (item rarity can act as a guide), assuming the character can find someone
who has it.
2. Found through adventuring, for example in the treasure hoard of a dragon or the research books of a mad
wizard.
3. Discovered by studying magical items.

Studying Magical Items

To discover the formula by studying a magical item, roll % dice. If the % rolled is equal or less than a set DC, the formula
is discovered. The set DC represents the % chance that the formula can be discovered. At the DMs discretion Artifacts
and Intelligent magical items cannot be studied or created.

Items can only be studied once a day and require 8 hours of uninterrupted time. Only one item can be studied per day.

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

1
To set the DC for the formula and therefore the % chance of learning it, do the following:

1. If it is the first day attempting to study the item, the base DC is 0. Each subsequent day attempting to learn the
formula adds 5 to the DC.
2. The DC can be increased through positive influences to the study process, such as using a lab.
3. The DC can be reduced through negative influences on the study process, such as studying in the wilderness
while adventuring.
4. The character studying the item makes an Intelligence (Arcana) roll and adds the result to the DC.

After successfully discovering the formula for an item, roll a second % dice. If the result is 10 or lower, the item is
destroyed in the process of discovering the formula.

Influences on Studying Magical Items

Influences on studying, whether positive or negative, are fully at the discretion of the DM. Listed below are some
examples of positive and negative influences.

Note: It is very possible, and highly likely, that the base DC of learning some magical items formula will be negative until
a sufficient amount of time has been spent studying it.

Example Positive Influences on Studying:

Influence Effect
Using an arcane lab or holy site +5 to base DC
Having an arcane apprentice or holy acolyte +2 to base DC
Using specialized or thematically appropriate books +2 to base DC
Thematically appropriate weather +2 to base DC
Studying the item in its location of creation +5 to base DC
Other possibilities at DMs discretion DM Discretion

Example Negative Influences on Studying:

Influence Effect
Studying in the wilderness -5 to base DC
Currently under the effects of a disease or poison -5 to base DC
Thematically inappropriate weather -2 to base DC
Uncommon magic item -5 to base DC
Rare magic item -10 to base DC
Very rare magic item -25 to base DC
Legendary magic item -100 to base DC
Other possibilities at DMs discretion DM Discretion

Examples:

Mazen the wizard is attempting to study a +1 Longsword to learn how to create a +1 weapon. He has not studied this
item before so his base DC = 0. He is studying in a lab, so his base DC increases by 5 to a total of 5. Since this is an
uncommon magic item, his base DC decreases by 5 back to 0. He makes an Intelligence (Arcana) check and gets a 12. He

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

2
adds that number to his base DC of 0 to get a total of 12. This final DC of 12 represents that Mazen has a 12% chance of
discovering the formula during this day’s study attempt. Mazen then rolls % dice and gets 63. Because he did not get
equal or lower than 12, he did not discover the items formula.

After 8 attempts of trying to learn the item, Mazen tries again. This is his ninth attempt. Because it his ninth attempt his
base DC = 0 + (8×5) = 40 (this represents an increase of 5 for each day after the first attempt, or n-1 × 5 where n = total
number of attempts). Since Mazen is studying in the wilderness, his base DC decreases by 5 to 35. Since it is an
uncommon magic item, the DC is lowered again by 5 to 30. Mazen then makes an Intelligence (Arcana) roll and gets a
21. The final DC for discovering the item formula is now 30 + 21 = 51. This final DC of 51 represents that Mazen has a
51% chance of discovering the items formula on this study attempt. Mazen then rolls % dice and gets a 34. Because he
rolled lower than 51, Mazen discovers the formula!

Because Mazen was successful at discovering the formula for the magic item, he then rolls a second % dice. Mazen gets
a 7. Mazen’s experiments and fiddling with the item to learn its properties has destroyed the item! Good thing he at
least knows how to make another one…

Creation Time and Minimum Caster Level

The base item rarity table gives the creation time for each items rarity. This is the amount of days of uninterrupted work
that are required in order to create the item. In addition, a character must have total class levels in an arcane or divine
spellcasting class equal to the Minimum Caster Level required. Whether the caster must be arcane or divine is up to DM
discretion.

Item Creation Time and Caster Level by Rarity

Rarity Minimum Caster Level Creation Time

Common 3 3 days
Uncommon 5 7 days
Rare 7 14 days
Very Rare 11 1 month
Legendary 15 1 year

Location
Magic items require specific locations in order to create them. In most cases, this will be an arcane lab, a forge, or a
temple or cathedral. In some special cases, the formula may require something more exotic, such as the top of a high
mountain, the fiery heart of an active volcano or even the Throne of Thunder on the Primal plane of Air. The location
required for a magic items creation is entirely up to the DM.

Expense
Creating magic items is not a cheap endeavor. The cost required to create magic items is an abstract representation of
the many costs required to prepare and forge items of great magical power. This cost is in addition to the cost of any
specified materials that the items formula requires.

Item Cost by Rarity

Rarity Creation Cost

Common 100 gp

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

3
 Uncommon 1,000 gp
Rare 5,000 gp
Very Rare 10,000 gp
Legendary 100,000 gp

Examples:

Mazen the wizard has the formula required to create a +1 longsword. Through adventuring, he has gathered rare Elvish
Mithril that he will use to create the sword, thus saving himself the extra cost and time required to find a trader that will
sell him the metal. Because a +1 longsword is an uncommon item, Mazen must pay 1,000 gp and spend 7 days to craft
the item.

Lira the cleric has the formula to create a Decanter of Endless Water. She, however, does not have the materials
required to create the item. Fortunately, through a network of traders, she has secured the required materials for a cost
of 500 gp. Because the Decanter is an uncommon magic item, she must also spend an additional 1,000 gp for a total
cost of 1,500 gp. She then spends the required 7 days to create the item.

Material Components
The material components required to create magical items is left in the hands of the DM. DMs should use the following
guidelines when setting appropriate materials for a magical formula.

All magical items require material components to create. These material components may include zero to many of each
of the following items.

1. A spell
2. A material of appropriate rarity for the magical item
3. A monster trophy thematically appropriate to the magical item
4. A magical focus thematically appropriate to the magical item

Spells as Components

When building the components required to create a magical item (and thus be a part of its formula), consider requiring
the use of a thematically appropriate spell. The spell can be cast from the magic item creator directly, read from a scroll
at the time of magical creation, or cast by someone the creator has negotiated with to help him or her with the creation
of the item. The selection of a spell requirement for a magic item formula is an art – not science. Do what feels right for
spell power level and thematic spell elements for the item.

Examples:

A Decanter of Endless Water requires the casting of the spell Create Water.

A +1 enhancement to armor requires the casting of the spell Mage Armor, Shield or both.

The sword Frost Brand requires the casting of the spell Cone of Cold.

Materials of Appropriate Rarity

Magical items are not created out of common materials. The process of infusing magical energies into items requires

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

4
materials strong enough to absorb the energy and thus function as a magical item. Each magical item formula should
require one or more material component of rarity equal to or greater than the rarity of the magical item. The table
below shows some examples of materials and their appropriate rarity. In addition, monsters can be harvested for
materials of appropriate rarity based on their CR.

Example Materials by Rarity

Common Uncommon Rare Very Rare Legendary

Plain Wood Darkwood Dwarven Mithril Elven Leafweave Hellfire Shadowsteel
Stone Marble Elvish Mithril Shadow Touched Holy-Touched
Stone Angelic Brightsteel
Iron Dwarven Steel Adamantine Star Ruby Astral Diamond
Steel Common Mithril Cold Iron Moon Iron
Copper Silver Deep Crystal Truesteel
Bronze Elvish Steel Elven Darkleaf
Cow Leather Blended Quartz Blue Ice
Beaver Fur Obsidian Iron Oak

Materials do not have special properties themselves, they simply represent the uncommon - legendary materials
required to create items imbued with magical powers. Of course, everything is at the DMs discretion and if the DM says
Moon Iron gives a glow, so be it. Thematically, the material used to create a magic item is directly related to how an
item looks and feels – its personality. A sword crafted from Obsidian is can be described as black with a glass finish,
where a sword crafted from Darkwood is earth toned and may have a handle wrapped with vines and leaves. This part
of creating magic items is in the minds of the players and their DM. The tables above are only a small example of
materials that could be used.

Most materials can be found while adventuring. If not, and the PCs are looking to purchase materials, prices of the
listed materials are up to the DMs discretion. In addition to paying for the material, it may be difficult if not impossible
for PCs to find a trader or dealer that even has access to some of these materials. The rarity of the material can be used
as a guide to set prices as listed below.

Material Cost Based on Rarity

Rarity Cost
Common 50 gp
Uncommon 500 gp
Rare 2,500 gp
Very Rare 5,000 gp
Legendary 50,000 gp

Material Rarity by Monster CR

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

5
 Rarity Monster CR
Common 0-2
Uncommon 3-7
Rare 8 - 13
Very Rare 14 - 20
Legendary DM Discretion

Monsters have many pieces and parts that can be harvested for materials of various rarities. Using the table listed
above, the DM can allow harvesting of monster parts for materials. It is up to the DMs discretion on whether a creature
can be harvested for materials, whether certain parts of that creature can be harvested, what skill and DC is required to
do so and whether a certain part can be used in a formula or not. Dragon Scales, for example, would make great armor
but may not work for creating a Wand of Magic Missiles.

Examples:

Drozan the Barbarian has just slain a bulette. He uses his skills to harvest the bulette’s blood and bones. Since the
bulette is a CR 5 monster, it falls in the realm of uncommon materials. The bulette’s bones or wood soaked in the blood
of the bulette count as an uncommon crafting material.

Tila the Rogue and her party have just slain an adult red dragon. She makes a skill check and harvests some of the
dragon’s scales to be used later. Since an adult red dragon is CR 17, it counts as a very rare crafting material.

Monster Trophies

Monster trophies are specific pieces or parts of monsters that could be required to create a magic item. When
determining what monster trophy or trophies are required for a given formula, use theme to guide the selection. In
addition, the monster CR can be used to help guide the selection. DMs can choose to allow PCs to purchase monster
trophies from dealers and traders at the same general prices as materials based on rarity. DMs may also not allow the
purchasing of monster trophies and instead, PCs will be required to find the appropriate monster and slay it during
adventuring.

PCs should not be allowed to simply chop up every piece of every monster they find. As always DM discretion is at play,
but in general a PC must know what specific part of the monster is required for a trophy when gathering it and
potentially make some sort of skill or attribute check to get it, otherwise items act as crafting materials of various rarities
as mentioned above.

Monster Trophy Cost Based on Rarity

Rarity Cost Monster CR

Common 50 gp 0-2
Uncommon 500 gp 3-7
Rare 2,500 gp 8 - 13
Very Rare 5,000 gp 14 - 20
Legendary 50,000 gp DM Discretion

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

6
Examples:

The eyes from a basilisk, the feather of a phoenix, the scales of a red dragon, the fangs of a vampire lord, the pelt of a
dire wolf, the eye from a beholder eyestalk, the tears of a pixie, the last dying breath of a fire giant.

Magical Focus

In the case of some magical items, a monster trophy may not be an appropriate material required to create that item. A
magical focus can be used in addition to or in place of a monster trophy. Magical foci are typically items such as
gemstones of a certain gp value, valuable ores or rock such as raw mithril or meteorite, and items from nature such as
the drops of a pure spring at midnight during a full moon. In the Dungeon Master’s Guide on page 134 there is a table
listing of gemstones and their values.

Typically the formula will require these foci to be ground into powder or in some other way destroyed as part of creating
the magic item.

Gemstones Costs when used as Magical Foci

Rarity Cost
Common 50 gp
Uncommon 500 gp
Rare 2,500 gp
Very Rare 5,000 gp
Legendary 50,000 gp

Examples:

Mazen the wizard is creating a +1 longsword. Part of the formula requires an uncommon gemstone to be crushed and
dusted onto the weapon. Mazen happens to have a Topaz (DMG p134) worth 500 gp that he found while adventuring.
He crushes his Topaz and douses the longsword in its dust as part of creating the item.

Putting It All Together

Using the guidelines discussed above, here are some example formulas for magic item creation. Every group and every
campaign is different. One DMs formula for a +1 magic item may not look like another’s – that’s ok! Use the rules as a
guideline and put together clever, thematically appropriate formulas for your magic items however you see fit.

Remember, the DM always has the last word when it comes to creating magic items.

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

7
Example Magic Item Formulas

FORMULA: +1 Weapon
Item and Formula Rarity Uncommon
Creation Time and Caster Lvl 7 days, Arcane Caster Lvl 5
Location Arcane Lab or Forge
Expense 1,000 gp
Crafting Materials
Spell Magic Weapon
Material Uncommon crafting material
Monster Trophy None
Arcane Focus 500 gp gemstone, ground into powder

FORMULA: Ioun Stone - Agility

Item and Formula Rarity Very Rare
Creation Time and Caster Lvl 1 Month, Arcane Caster lvl 11
Location Arcane Lab
Expense 10,000 gp
Crafting Materials
Spell Enhance Ability – Cats Grace
Material Very Rare crafting material worked into a geometrical shape no larger
than 3 cm diameter
Monster Trophy The tears of a pixie or the spark of a wil-o-the-wisp
Arcane Focus None

medzz16@gmail.com, @edz16 on Twitter

8