Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2014
SJP0010.1177/1403494814562598Gender inequality and women’s healthF. Eek and A. Axmon
Original Article
1Department of Health Sciences, Lund University, Lund, Sweden, and 2Division of Occupational and Environmental
Medicine, Lund University, Lund, Sweden
Abstract
Background: As more women have joined the work force, the difference in employment rate between men and women has
decreased, in Sweden as well as many other countries. Despite this, traditional gender patterns regarding, for example,
responsibility for household duties still remain. Women are on sick leave more often than men, and previous studies have
indicated that an unequal split of household responsibilities and perceived gender inequality could be associated with negative
health outcomes. Aims: The aim of the present study was to explore whether an unequal distribution of responsibilities in
the home was related to various health related outcomes among women. Methods: A sample consisting of 837 women living
in a relationship, and working at least 50% of full time, responded to a questionnaire including information about division
of responsibilities at home as well as various psychological and physiological health related outcomes. Results: The results
showed that women living in relationships with perceived more unequal distribution of responsibility for house hold duties
showed significantly higher levels of perceived stress, fatigue, physical/psychosomatic symptoms, and work family conflict
compared with women living in more equal relationships. They also had significantly increased odds for insufficient time for
various forms of recovery, which may further contribute to an increased risk of poor health. Conclusions: Although an
increasing employment rate among women is valuable for both society and individuals, it is important to work
towards greater gender equality at home to maintain this development without it having a negative effect on
women’s health and well-being.
Introduction
Over the last decades, an increasing number of Women are on sick leave more often than men [4].
women, in many parts of the world, have joined the Higher sick leave among women is not only found in
work force. Today, the majority of Swedish parents, Sweden, but also in many other European countries
mothers and fathers, are working. The employment [5]. In Sweden, among employees in the private
rate among Swedish women (16–64 years) has sector, psychological/psychiatric diagnoses are the
increased from 68% in 1976 to 72% in 2004. The most common reason for a long (<15 days) sick leave
difference in employment rate between men and [4]. Psychiatric diagnoses are also the most common
women has, during the same period, decreased from reason for longer sick leave among women in general,
a 20% to 3% lower employment rate among women both 1–2 years before, and up to 7 years after the
[1]. In 2010, Sweden was one of the countries in EU birth of a child [6].
with the highest employment rate among women During the 1980s and 1990s, the gap in sick leave
aged 20–64 years [2]. Swedish parents were employed between men and women increased [5]. One possible
to an even higher extent; in 2008, 83% of all children explanation for this increase in difference is that
aged 0–17 years had an employed mother and 93% women work more today than they did 30 years ago.
had an employed father [3]. Since the turn of the millennium, the gap has
Correspondence: Frida Eek, Department of Health Sciences, Lund University, PO Box 157, SE-22100 Sweden. E-mail: frida.eek@med.lu.se
*Unequal’ means women taking much more responsibility for household duties than their partner. ‘Equal’ means women taking a little
more, equally much (or less) responsibility as their partner.
*p-Value from ANOVA, adjusted for work time, age of youngest child and educational level.
Score ranges: PSS 0–4, SHC 0–5, SRH 1–7, SOFI 0–6, Satisfaction 1–7, QPS 1–5, UWES 0–6, Work family interference 1–5.
Table III. OR (95% CI) for experience of insufficient time for power and impact among men and women, in society
different recovery- and leisure activities among women with per- as well as at home.
ceived unequal compared to more equal distribution of house hold
duties. However, it appears that the development towards
gender equality at home has not completely followed
Insufficient time for OR 95% CI development in the labour market. More women than
Sleep 1.39 0.91–2.13 men still take the largest responsibility for household
Relaxation 1.99 1.45–2.72 work and child care, despite also taking equal part in
Exercise 1.50 1.10–2.04 the labour market. This persistent unequal role divi-
Hobbies 1.67 1.23–2.27 sion seems to have consequences in terms of impact
Friends 1.55 1.07–2.24
on women’s health and well-being. Women are more
Relatives 2.02 1.26–3.26
Partner 1.55 1.08–2.21 often on sick leave than men, a gender inequality
Children 1.24 0.78–1.97 which increases after the birth of a child [4–6], a time
period when also traditional gender roles are known
Adjusted for work time, age of youngest child and educational to be strengthened with increased inequality in the
level.
division of household responsibilities as a conse-
quence. It is worth noting that sick leave among par-
Discussion ents, mothers and fathers, only relates to their own
Even though there are many structures on the labour sickness. When the child is sick, Swedish parents have
market where gender inequality is still evident, the what is called ‘leave for temporary care of a child’,
equality in terms of employment rate and participa- which is not registered as sick leave for the parent.
tion in the labour market has increased markedly Our results showed that women who take the larg-
during the last decades in Sweden and in many other est responsibility for household work also report
countries. This increasing gender equality in terms of more stress, lower subjective well-being, and more
increasingly equal employment rate among men and fatigue and subjective health complaints. They also
women is generally considered positive. That women report lower satisfaction with their general life situa-
become more active on the labour market has many tion than women in more equal relationships.
positive effects in society as well as for the women’s One potential link in this association may be that
individual situation and possibilities. The health women in perceived unequal relationships also report
effects associated with active employment are well less time for relaxation and also leisure activities such
known [27], and more women in the labour market as exercise, hobbies and social intercourse with
increases the possibility of a more equal share of friends. These activities may serve as important
Gender inequality and women’s health 181
sources of recovery, which is an important clue in the woman takes much larger responsibility at home
prevention of poor health effects as a result of the does not necessarily mean that she would label
stress experienced. These women also report higher her relationship as ‘unequal’. It is possible that the
levels of both general- and work-related stress. overall division of responsibility in the family is more
Regarding work-related stress, the stress experienced equal. Nevertheless, a role division where the woman
seems to stem from higher demands placed on these takes much more responsibility for household duties
women than women living in more equal relation- reflects a traditional or conservative pattern of gender
ships. The experience of work-related control did not roles, regardless of whether the couple are content
differ. Even though the QPS measures work-related with the division of responsibility or not. Our study
stress, this experience is not sharply marked off from would show the actual effect of or association between
private life. The women in perceived unequal actual unequal division of responsibilities, rather
relationships also report higher levels of family to than the perception of ‘unequal relationship’, even if
work spill-over, which may add to the burden of those states probably often coincide. Only women
work-related demands experienced. are included in the present study, hence the men’s
Apart from the higher experience of work-related opinion or situation is not taken into consideration
stress, more particularly work-related demands, here. Both men and women were included in the
work-related factors do not seem to differ between original sample [19]. However, almost no men
women with more or less equal relationships. Their reported that they took much more responsibility for
satisfaction with work does not differ significantly, household duties. Actually, a previous report showed
and there is no significant difference in work engage- that the men agreed on the division of responsibility;
ment, either regarding vitality, engagement or the number of men who stated that their partner
absorption. A lower interest or engagement in their took much more responsibility for the household
job could perhaps have been an indication that the work was almost equal to the number of women who
unequal division of house hold works and responsi- stated that they took much more responsibility [28].
bility reflects a volunteer and possibly desired The women were also generally less satisfied with the
role division, with a volunteer down grading of the division of responsibility than the men were. A separate
woman’s work engagement and an upgrading of the question asked about the responsibility for daily child
home responsibility. Though, this seemed not to care. The pattern here was similar: the women took
be the explanation since the women in unequal rela- greater responsibility. However, the question used in
tionships showed no less work engagement than the present analyses concerns household duties only.
women in more equal relationships. Even though Still, the study has a heteronormative perspective and
part of the increased responsibility among women focuses on women only, which may be considered a
could be explained by more women working part limitation. At the same time, the aim of the study was
time, especially when children are young, that is not to explore potential effects of traditional gender roles
the complete explanation since the unequal share of and unequal share of household duties between men
household duties is present also in couples where and women. Since it is almost exclusively the woman
both work full time [28]. In the present study, we did who takes the largest responsibility in couples where
not find any interaction effects between perceived the division is not equal [28–30], the focus naturally
inequality and work time with respect to health out- falls on the effect on women’s health and well-being,
comes. This indicates that the effect of unequal role which justifies the narrow perspective.
division persists regardless of work time. The finding The choice of household duty responsibility only,
that the women in perceived unequal relationships and not responsibility for child care, means a poten-
experience similar work engagement, and are equally tial dilution of true associations since there may be
satisfied with their work situation, also contributes couples that share household duties more equally but
to the explanation that the difference in health, well- where the woman still takes much more responsibility
being and time for recovery should depend on a for daily child care, and hence the total general house-
general level of negative affectivity in this group. hold/child responsibility is unequal towards a more
Also, these women do not report insufficient time traditional gender pattern even though household
for sleep or intercourse with children. The latter duties are more equally divided.
may be explained by the fact that these women as a The cross-sectional nature of the study does not
consequence of having a larger responsibility for allow for inference regarding direction of causality
household duties and less time for leisure activities between examined variables. However, there are no
spend more time at home, where the children are. reasons to believe that women who are more stressed
A limitation of the study is the rough measure of and in poorer health should start to take much more
‘equality’, based on one single question regarding responsibility at home, especially while maintaining
division of responsibility for household duties. That a occupational activity and engagement. The reverse
182 F. Eek and A. Axmon
causality seems more plausible, even though of [11] Hanson LL, Leineweber C, Chungkham HS, et al. Work-
home interference and its prospective relation to major
course a bidirectional relationship is possible.
depression and treatment with antidepressants. Scand J Work
Environ Health 2014;40:66–73.
[12] Leineweber C, Baltzer M, Magnusson Hanson LL, et al.
Conclusion Work-family conflict and health in Swedish working women
and men: A 2-year prospective analysis (the SLOSH study).
Previous studies have shown a persistent unequal Eur J Public Health 2013;23:710–6.
gender role division, also in couples where both the [13] Berntsson L, Lundberg U and Krantz G. Gender differ-
man and the woman are occupationally active. The ences in work-home interplay and symptom perception
present study indicates that such an unequal division among Swedish white-collar employees. J Epidemiol Com-
munity Health 2006;60:1070–6.
of responsibility for household duties may lead to [14] Lundberg U, Mardberg B and Frankenhaeuser M. The total
increased stress and impaired health and well-being workload of male and female white collar workers as related
among women. A high share of responsibility for to age, occupational level, and number of children. Scand J
household duties was also related to insufficient Psychol 1994;35:315–27.
[15] Hammarstrom A and Phillips SP. Gender inequity needs to
time for leisure activities and relaxation, which may be regarded as a social determinant of depressive symptoms:
contribute to an increased risk of poor health. Hence, Results from the Northern Swedish cohort. Scand J Public
although an increasing employment rate among Health 2012;40:746–52.
women is valuable for both society and individuals, [16] Harryson L, Novo M and Hammarstr A. Is gender
inequality in the domestic sphere associated with psycho-
it is important to work towards a greater gender logical distress among women and men? Results from the
equality at home, to maintain this development Northern Swedish Cohort. J Epidemiol Commun Health
without having negative effects on women’s health 2012;66:271.
and well-being. [17] Harryson L, Strandh M and Hammarstrom A. Domestic
work and psychological distress—what is the importance of
relative socioeconomic position and gender inequality in the
Conflicts of interest couple relationship? PLoS One 2012;7:e38484.
[18] Bohlin A, Ahlgren C, Hammarstrom A, et al. Perceived gen-
None declared. der inequality in the couple relationship and musculoskel-
etal pain in middle-aged women and men. Scand J Public
Funding Health 2013;41:825–31.
[19] Eek F and Axmon A. Attitude and flexibility are the most
This work was supported by the Swedish Council important work place factors for working parents’ men-
for Working Life and Social Research (FAS no. tal wellbeing, stress, and work engagement. Scand J Public
2007:0083). Health 2013;41:692–705.
[20] Cohen S, Kamarck T and Mermelstein R. A global measure
of perceived stress. J Health Soc Behav 1983;24:385–96.
References [21] Bjorner JB, Kristensen TS, Orth-Gomér K, et al. Self-rated
[1] Sysselsättning och arbetslöshet 1976–2004. Statistiska cen- health. A useful concept in research, prevention and clinical
tralbyrån, 2005. medicine. Stockholm: Forskningsrådsnämnden 1996;96:9.
[2] Eurostat. http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/tgm/refreshTable- [22] Ahsberg E. Dimensions of fatigue in different working pop-
Action.do?tab=table&plugin=1&pcode=t2020_10&languag ulations. Scand J Psychol 2000;41:231–41.
e=en. [cited 2011]. [23] Ahsberg E, Gamberale F and Gustafsson K. Perceived
[3] SCB. http://www.scb.se/Pages/TableAndChart____255880. fatigue after mental work: An experimental evaluation of a
aspx. [updated 2009-11-23 cited 2011]. fatigue inventory. Ergonomics 2000;43:252–68.
[4] Sjukskrivningsmönster hos kvinnor och män. Stockholm: [24] Dallner M, Lindström K, Elo A-L, et al. Användarmanual
AFA Försäkring, 2014. för QPSNordic. Frågeformulär om psykologiska och sociala
[5] Angelov N, Johansson P and Lindahl E. Gender differences faktorer i arbetslivet utprovat i Danmark, Finland, Norge och
in sickness absence and the gender division of family respon- Sverige. Solna: Arbetslivsinstitutet, 2000 2000:19.
sibilities (Working paper). Stockholm: Institutet för arbets- [25] Schaufeli WB, Bakker AB and Salanova M. The Measure-
marknadspolitisk utvärdering (IFAU), 2013 Contract No.: 9. ment of work engagement with a short questionnaire. Educ
[6] Kvinnors sjukfrånvaro. Redovisning av regeringsuppdrag Psychol Measure 2006;66:701–16.
2013. Försäkringskassan, 2013. [26] Chandola T, Martikainen P, Bartley M, et al. Does conflict
[7] Molarius A, Granstrom F, Linden-Bostrom M, et al. between home and work explain the effect of multiple roles
Domestic work and self-rated health among women and on mental health? A comparative study of Finland, Japan,
men aged 25–64 years: Results from a population-based and the UK. Int J Epidemiol 2004;33:884–93.
survey in Sweden. Scand J Public Health 2014;42:52–9. [27] Waddell B and Burton KA. Is Work Good for Your Health and
[8] Staland-Nyman C, Alexanderson K and Hensing G. Asso- Well-being? London: TCO; 2006.
ciations between strain in domestic work and self-rated [28] Eek F and Axmon A. Yrkesarbetande småbarnsföräldrar –
health: A study of employed women in Sweden. Scand J arbetsförhållanden, arbetsplatsklimat och ansvarsfördelning
Public Health 2008;36:21–7. i hemmet. [Working parents -work place conditions, work
[9] Strandh M and Nordenmark M. The interference of paid place climate and responsibilities at home]. 2011 13.
work with household demands in different social policy [29] Jolly S, Griffith KA, DeCastro R, et al. Gender differences
contexts: Perceived work-household conflict in Sweden, the in time spent on parenting and domestic responsibilities by
UK, the Netherlands, Hungary, and the Czech Republic. Br high-achieving young physician-researchers. Ann Intern Med
J Sociol 2006;57:597–617. 2014;160:344–53.
[10] Blom V, Sverke M, Bodin L, et al. Work-home interference [30] Nu för tiden: En undersökning om svenska folkets tidsan-
and burnout: A study based on Swedish twins. J Occup Envi- vändning år 2010/11 (Swedish Time Use Survey 2010/11).
ron Med 2014;56:361–6. SCB (Statistics Sweden), 2010.
Copyright of Scandinavian Journal of Public Health is the property of Sage Publications, Ltd.
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without
the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.