Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LITERATURE SURVEY
Due to these key properties, metallic materials are the widely used
biomaterials for replacing the structural parts of the human body. Some of
dental implants, artificial heart valves, bone plates and screws, artificial
joints, intramedullary nails, spinal fixations and spacers, pace maker cases,
external fixtators, wires and stents. Many metallic biomaterials have been
pure titanium, and titanium alloys (Sumita et al., 2004; Patel & Gohil,
2012).
2.1. STAINLESS STEELS:
Implants were initially produced from pure metals. Pure metal implants
corrosion problems. W.H. Hatfield used 18/8 stainless steel that showed
failures, and sensitivity problems were considerably lowered with the use
Stainless steel of 316 and 316L grades are commonly used for biomedical
low carbon content. The lower carbon content reduces the formation of
alloying elements. Conventional stainless steels are suitable for high load
not contain any Nickel content, which may result in increased corrosion
because of its nonmagnetic nature. Despite the fact that stainless steel is
stainless steels more suitable and more affordable material for stents
(Ducheyne & Kohn, 1998; Navarro et al., 2008; Disegi & Eschbach, 2000;
the material of choice for screws, nails, and fracture plates that provide
stainless steel which is higher than that of titanium, stainless steels are
strength, high elastic modulus, high abrasion resistance and high corrosion
which can cause adverse effects. Co-Cr-Mo alloy is used for femoral head
of joint prostheses along with polyethylene cup (UHMWPE) due to its high
wear resistance and corrosion resistance. However, metal ions released over
many years may lead to toxic issues. Co-29Cr-6Mo-1Ni alloy is one of the
the Nickel and Cobalt ions are responsible for inducing allergic reactions.
Hence, Co-Cr-Mo alloy may be prepared without Nickel, which may solve
the toxicity problem in cobalt nickel based systems (Dong et al., 2003;
Sargeant & Goswami, 2006; Sachiko et al., 2005; Prasad et al., 2017; Stohs
& Bagchi, 1995; Basketter et al., 1993; Uggowitzer et al, 1996; Chiba et
al., 2005).
direct contact is required with the bone. Yet, Cobalt-Chromium alloys can
give rise to metal corrosion and shredding (Li et al., 2014; Nayak et al.,
cancerous tumors. Even though the number of tumors is lower near the
implant site, the released ions could exist at other parts of the human body
pure titanium and titanium alloys were used for biomedical applications.
titanium. Ti6AL4V alloy is one of the popular titanium alloys used for
(Blackwood, 2003).
Since the time the bone plates and screws were introduced in 1965, pure
titanium and titanium alloys have been the attractive metallic materials
used for biomedical applications. Ti–6Al–4V alloy has been used for
Ti–5Al–2.5Fe have also been recently developed due to the toxic effects of
vanadium in the Ti–6Al–4V alloy (Frosch & Stürmer, 2006; Wang, 1996;
Niinomi, 1998; Elias et al., 2008; Milošev, 2010; Niinomi et al., 2005).
2008)
Pure Titanium does not become hard for load-bearing applications.
They have poor shear strength, leading the metal unsuitable for implant
rubbing against the natural bone or another implant surface. Due to high
materials. However, they are not bioactive. Hence, titanium alloys are
Temporary implants are kept for a shorter period. Once the fractured bone
tissue grows, they are usually removed. When the orthopaedic joints, such
as spinal, shoulder, hip, knee, and ankle affected by arthritis or parts
place of the entire joint after a arthroplasty surgery. Magnesium has been
the fourth most abundant element present in the human body, and the
release of metal does not affect the human metabolism. It is a a cofactor for
many enzymes and is considered to stabilise the DNA and RNA structures.
Magnesium has low density and Young's modulus close to natural bone and
from cleft palate, and to rectify the deformities of long bones, to overcome
the limb length problems (Manivasagam & Suwas, 2014; Agarwal et al.,
2016).
Magnesium shows high specific strength, low elastic modulus (41 GPa)
and low density (1.74 g/cm3), whose properties are closer to those of
natural bone. Due to the closer values, the risk of stress shielding is very
degradation provides the space for the growing tissues. As the material
degrades, the implants will fully be degraded and removed from the body.
Zn and Zn-based alloys have also been used in biomedical use. Daily
2015)
Nickel-titanium alloy, also called Nitinol, is a smart biomaterial with shape
is close to natural bone, but is different from other metal and alloys. Nitinol
is used in orthodontics, bone fractures, bone suture anchors, and stents etc.
titanium oxide surface and are used. and Nitinol is highly stable in the body
2018).
one may have to look into. The magnetic susceptibility of living tissues is
9x10-6 cm3/g, where as Ti has 3.2x10-6 cm3/g and Zr has 1.3x10-6 cm3/g.
alloys, Zr-3Nb, Zr-6Nb, and Zr-9Nb, Zr-Mo alloys and Zr-3Mo (Minnath,
2018; Nomura et al., 2009; Kondo et al., 2011; Suyalatu et al., 2011).
Figure: 2.3 : Historical development of metal based amorphous alloys or
Bulk Metallic Glass (BMG) first introduced in 1950’s by rapid cooling rate
(104-107 °C/s) from vapour phase of a metal or liquid phase. They possess
properties, Fe, Ti, Zr based BMGs have the potential for replacing stainless
steel, Ti, and Zr alloys (Ibrahim et al., 2017; Yi et al., 2017; Espallargas et
al, 2013; Li et al., 2016; Liu et al., 2013; Wang et al., 2008; Hench, 2016).
BIOMATERIAL
Metallic materials have been often used for biomedical use due to their
are the first choice for orthopedic implants, bone fixators, external fixators,
artificial joints, etc., because they are strong enough in the growth of the
hard tissues in orthopedics. Similarly, in the case of stents and stent grafts,
they are kept at stenotic blood vessels to dilatation, where elasticity and
fretting due to corrosion fatigue and poor adhesion with body cells and
materials (Sumita et al., 2004; Niinomi et al., 2005; Pound, 2004; Hench,
2002).
Biomaterials are majorly used in places where the materials make contact
material surfaces and human tissues must be clearly understood before use.
follows.
Corrosion is the loss of metallic ions which is released from metal implants'
corrosion. Crevice corrosion occurs when metallic ions dissolve and create
positively charged localized regions like screw implant and bone interface.
Pitting corrosion occurs when metallic ions dissolve and combine with
cloride ions to form pits on the surface of the implants. Galvanic corrosion
metal deterioration due to electron transfer (Saini, 2015; Lemons & Lucas,
Biomaterials, implanted within the human body, make contact with the
extracellular body fluids (blood, interstitial fluid etc.), which may corrode
these biomaterials. The pH values within the body changes due to the
presence of body fluids. The pH of blood and interstitial fluid vary usually
about 5.2 in the hard tissues, and it takes about 2 weeks to recover the pH
values to about 7.4. Therefore, abrupt decrease in the pH value may have
only little effect on corrosion. However, one has to worry about the the
toxicity and allergy of the implanted biomaterials. If the metallic ions are
released by the biomaterials into the body fluid, and combine with other
However, due to low cost of metal, 316L stainless steel is largely used for
2.6.2. Nontoxicity:
cytotoxicity data are shown in the figure, in which the relative growth rate
Since the orthopaedic implants may release metal into body fluids, such as
serum, urine, etc., the toxic effects of metal release is an important subject
used Cobalt based alloys were reported to release elevated amount of Co,
Cr and Ni metal release into in body fluids. The use of Ti–6Al–4V alloy for
implants releases vanadium that has toxic effects (Okazaki & Gotoh, 2005).
affects the human skin (for example, dermatitis); Cobalt can produce
Anemia B inhibiting iron from being absorbed into the blood stream;
Chromium can cause ulcers and disturbances in the central nervous system;
Vanadium can produce toxic effects in the elementary state (Aksakal et al.,
2004).
allergy in Europe. It was found that Nickel allergy affected about 20% of
from a pure metal or its alloy causes metal allergy. In dentistry, the most
common materials that caused metal allergy wer Cobalt, Chromium, and
applications (Niinomi et al., 2002). Some of metals and the metal allergy
Figure: 2.6: Nickel metal allergy reported in the Europe (Niinomi et al.,
2002)
Figure: 2.7: Percentage of metal allergy caused by the metallic elements
Release of nickel ions can cause allergy and cancer. The International
Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) says that nickel compounds are
generally carcinogenic, and therefore pure nickel and nickel alloys are also
such implants is not assured. There is no clear report supporting the lower
nickel content to be not toxic to the human body. The European Parliament
alloys, although they are currently approved for surgical use (Sumita et al.,
2004).
The human body contains the metallic elements, such as, iron, manganese,
are essential for normal biological functions of the body. However, the
the body. Hence, the released metal ions from the metallic implants may
lead to local inflammation, mutation (mutagenesis), or even cancer
2.6.5. Reliability:
using the implants with more reliability in long run. Figure shows the
steel, cobalt based alloys and titanium based alloys, and natural bone. To be
the order given by: Cobalt based alloy > Ti based alloys > 316L stainless
steel. From the values of fatigue strength, it can be seen that the fatigue
the fatigue limits of all metallic biomaterials shown are very much higher
Nickel, Chromium, and Cobalt present in both stainless steel and Cobalt-
dermatitis and the metal ions released into human body create allergic
solubilised ions. These nanoparticles can produce mechanical wear and the
Biomedical metals having some degree of toxicity can affect the body and
can accumulate with other parts of the body. Molebadynm and Neobium
implants containing Ag, Cr, Fe, Mo, Ni and Ta exhibit metallic debris in
human body tissues. Co, Cr, Sb and Sc also can accumulate in other human
organs, such as heart, kidney, liver and spleen. A 100 times increase of
elements. Higher levels of Ni, Ti, and V also have failed the total joint
that it is absorped by the human body. Co, Cr, and Mo were also absorped
by the human body and transported to other parts. These metal ions were
detected in hair strands and urine of patients that can generate abundant
to the human body. The release of these metals can rarely causes Tumour
metals with human body could create metal sensitivities, or allergies. These
Stainless steels, Cobalt alloys and titanium alloys are used for permanent
implants and they should be removed once the healing is done. The
titanium implants have high elastic modulus which is different from its
to implant loosening, bone resorption and even implant failures (Xin et al.,
implants highly affect the local defense system and can cause the surgical
Mg-based alloys, Fe-based alloys, and Zn-based alloys are some of the
times lower than that of magnesium); and it is 8-11 mg/day for zinc (30-40
of these metals may cause the adverse effects in human body. The elastic
modulus of natural bone is about 3-20 GPa, while it is about 43 GPa for
Magnesium, 211.4 GPa for iron and 90 GPa for zinc, respectively. The
mismatch of elastic modulus in iron and zinc may cause stress shielding.
Both pure iron and pure magnesium are good candidates in terms of
implants were proven to stimulate the new bone formation from the time
they are implanted (Chen et al., 2014; Zheng et al., 2014; Li et al., 2014).
material (Brar et al., 2009; Kirkland et al., 2012; Atrens et al., 2011;
which can bring biofunctionality of the surface and bulk properties of the
such as, elastic modulus, ultimate tensile stress, etc. provide sufficient
support for the applied mechanical loads. The biological response, on the
the metallic biomaterials (Agarwal, & García, 2019; Anderson et al., 2008).
Roach et al., 2007; Chu, 2002; Chu, 2013; Bagno & Di Bello, 2004)
and crystal structure of HA is very close to the apatite formed in the human
such as fish bones, seashells, eggshells, bovine bones and shrimp shells
mechanical strength and promote bacterial growth which in turn may be the
reasons for implant rejections. Addition of elements, having antibacterial
properties, such as silver (Ag), zinc (Zn), copper (Cu), cerium (Ce),
implants. Similar work was done by Herrera et al. (2015) and concluded
that the HA coated implants showed high survival rates compared to other
implants.
HA coatings were evaluated on various substrates by research community.
conditions.
delay the corrosion rate of magnesium alloys (10 times slower than the
In the work of Shi et al. (2011), the composite coating of Ca-P was carried
found that the process did not change the properties of HA coatings as