Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Problem:
The problem is that fake news may actually pass off as true and correct.
This, in turn, affects people’s perception or opinion on others and harm
people’s reputation. Worse, fake news creates confusion about what is true and
adversely affects citizens’ decision-making on important issues (who to vote for
in an election or which side to take on public matters). Even the most
educated among us may be duped into believing fake news.
Fake news or false information has polarized an already divided nation
like ours, and the sad part is that this problem has a normative effect. People
may choose what “truths” to believe in, which may be shared and accepted by
the majority of the population. Fake news sways public opinion and adversely
affects a country’s ability to govern itself. It puts to great risk the proper
workings of a democratic nation like the Philippines.
RELEVANT LAWS: Please research on these. Read them and please include any other
possible arguments for BOTH SIDES.
1. Article 154 (Unlawful Use of Means of Publication and Unlawful Utterances) of
RPC in relation to R.A. 10951, Section 18 (for penalty)
2. Article 353 to 356 (Libel) of RPC
3. Senate Bill 1680 by Sen. Grace Poe
4. Senate Bill 1492 by Sen. Villanueva
TAKE NOTE:
Practicability means always comparing the affirmative and negative side: _____A_____
is better than ______B______ because ___________________________.
The arguments and research should answer the problem proposed by the necessity
speaker.
Look for statistics regarding the spread of fake news (if there is any)
Look for relevant jurisprudence regarding fake news
o Quote the discussion on the advantages and disadvantages of fake news
o Quote the ruling and the rationale for the ruling wherein a false news
was actually penalized
See Senate hearings on fake news: https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=WKS1VfIpbN4&list=PLxIGRNqt1BBizjopZxjeJReVU9UR3HcwW&index=3
AFFIRMATIVE
We will point out that it is better and practicable to impose penalties on fake news
than not to penalize it at all.