Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kyle Humphreys
5/7/2018
Mass Media
It was a late night at The Silent Barn, a DIY venue in Brooklyn, November 2017. My friends and
I were surrounded and separated by sweaty strangers, jumping and pushing each other around to the
acoustics and vocals of AJJ’s Sean Bonnette (guitar) and Ben Gallaty (upright bass). A taller white guy
whipped his dreads into my mouth as he was moshing to the chorus of “Bad Bad Things”, two
complete strangers helped me up and asked if I was okay when I fell down, and I never thought I would
feel so unified in a room of strangers. These people surely lead different lives, but we all still seem to
We can’t be all too different having shared this experience, this feeling. One could not possibly feel less
alone physically or emotionally as you shouted along that night. And that’s the beauty and power of
today’s punk music; it unifies people, be it as a whole or against the enemy. It’s this power that has
brought ideas of shared experience, humanism, and caring to turntables and speakers of today’s youth,
oppositional to the media’s idea that punk is apathetic and violent. Of course, these misconceptions
have to come from somewhere; punk as a culture was and is not always a bunch of people jumping
around at a show to shed the stress of the daily grind through their sweat and/or blood. Those that deny
punk’s potential to harbor chaotic moments and people fail to understand that nothing is black or white.
Humphreys 2
Yet punk culture has changed and evolved with its musical and written mediums to spread powerful
moral and political messages meant to mobilize and inspire the new generation of punk.
Nobody really knows where the word “punk” first came from, but Mark Blake, writer for MOJO
Magazine says he first came across the word in 1971 in a US rock magazine called Creem. Dave
Marsh, writer for Creem, claims he coined the term “punk rock” in a review he wrote for the magazine
in late 1971. Yet it was supposedly Lester Bangs, another writer for Creem who really took the word
and kick-started the scene (MOJO 14). The more prominent areas of the scenes existed in California-
Hollywood and San Francisco (Doe 99). The sound also made its way to New York City (MOJO 8) and
the neighborhoods known for their counterculture streaks in Washington D.C (Andersen, Jenkins 3).
The print method of spreading this form of counterculture was born through the zine, short for fanzine.
These contained a mess of pictures, band interviews, comics, prose, and reviews. A popular one worth
noting is Cometbus, started in 1981 by Aaron Cometbus. Aaron Cometbus was an active member of the
punk scene, playing in numerous punk bands such as Pinhead Gunpowder, Thorns of Life, and
Cleveland Bound Death Sentence. Cometbus currently has 58 issues and can be purchased
commercially through Microcosm Publishing (Microcosm Publishing). Smaller zines have still had
their reach as well, such as King Maxwell’s “punk rock political art zine,” Snotrag. In volume two,
issue one of Snotrag, Maxwell prefaces his segments on segments on oppression, the exploitative
nature of capitalism, animal rights, and resistance, with his experiences with punk. There was also
PUNK mag, a zine esque magazine that began publication in 1975, about a year after punk became a
shapeless face. PUNK is largely responsible for really putting punk on the map and making it seem like
punk was going somewhere despite how new it still was (Holstrom 1, 7). PUNK contained interviews
with bands, reviews, and comics, all laced with a MAD-esque humor (14). Just as influential was the
DIY style zine Sniffin’ Glue by Mark Perry. Perry, says it was through his love for music that he found
punk (Robb 62). Armed with a typewriter, Perry put out issues of the “seminal punk fanzine” for about
Humphreys 3
a year before he stopped. He was inspired after a clerk at a record store suggested he make his own
zine, seeing as the store didn’t have any on The Ramones or punk. He brought his first 50 copies to the
record store, which sold within a week. Shortly after its distribution, copycat versions cropped up and
the spread of punk continued. At its peak, Perry sold about 20,000 copies through any record store
selling punk records, even overseas (203-206). For a scene so new, 20,000 isn’t so bad.
Though PUNK takes a more playful approach to punk attitudes, bands of the time were hard
wired to be provocative. An often overlooked hardcore punk band, Aus-Rotten, formed later in the
punk scene, 1991. Their name is German and translates essentially to mass extinction of people (“AUS
ROTTEN INTERVIEW). Two of their more prolific songs are “The Second Rape” and “The System
Works For Them.” “The System Works For Them” sounds how you think it would lyrically, shouting
about how you can boycott the companies that drag people beneath them, but if you give into
consumerist culture they still win. “The Second Rape” is extremely in your face, starting out with a
statistic for rape. The lyrics point out that rape isn’t just a crime, it’s a cultural issue:
It’s this in-your-face provocative nature that defines punk. Songs can be progressive and not be punk.
Some punk musicians however are provocateurs in less desirable ways. Famous, or otherwise infamous
UK band The Sex Pistols, were a brief but sensational group, causing as much chaos as you can fit into
Humphreys 4
their lifespan, which was just 1975-1978. The Sex Pistols had created a reputation for themselves, so
much to the point that two of their band members did not immediately receive visas for their 1978 US
tour (Mark). Earlier on in their career, they also made a foul mouthed television appearance in 1976
when punk was still a huge buzzword, getting into somewhat of a verbal skirmish with host Bill
Grundy. It was this incident that kick started their stardom (Robb 259). In 1976 they tried to tour the
UK, yet their reputation as punks caused all but four of their shows to be canceled (264). John Lydon of
The Sex Pistols believes any band that came after theirs were a bunch of “copycat wankers” (97).
Given the aggressive and anarchistic nature of punk, it was inevitable that ideas like fascism and
homophobia would permeate the culture. Anarchist punks were anti-authority and utilized radical
tactics that survive through today’s Black Bloc, anarchists who wear all black and take social and
institutional issues into their own hands with direct action perceived as violence and vandalism. Their
targets are often police and those who seek to benefit from laws and actions that harm the common man
(St. John). But being that their enemy was authority, this shifts them more left politically given that
their ideas are not conservative in nature (Ward 161). Skinheads were not rare sights at punk shows,
getting into fights with other audience goers and acting violently towards artists and musicians (Robb
430-431). Television show New Wave Theatre (1979-1983) attempted to “lessen confusion” and “bring
humankind closer,” but their host Peter Ivers often heightened feelings of conflict and homophobia
(Stiffler 44). Early punk also had aesthetic traces of Nazism, with some artists donning the symbols and
writing with blatant references to Nazism, such as The Sex Pistols’ “Belsen Was a Gas” (Ward 160).
However loud the minority, the majority was ready to fight back. A great example of ways punk culture
fought back would be the Dead Kennedys’ rapid paced hardcore song, “Nazi Punks Fuck Off”, a direct
Nazi punks
Nazi punks
Nazi punks
In the UK, an anti-racist music rally took place on April 30th, 1978, called Rock Against Racism.
Among other punk bands, David Bowie made an appearance in Victoria Park that day. This was largely
in response to the right wing party, The National Front, rising in popularity and worming its way into
Punk always seems to have resonated with younger generations. This isn’t to say punk music has
older fans (my uncle will profess his admiration to this day for The Ramones & Me First and the
Gimmie Gimmies), but punk’s appeal has always been that it is counterculture. Whatever is mainstream
at any given time, punk culture is not that. Punk from the beginning was always structured to be
provocative, the aesthetics just as important as the lyrics and sound. To some, it’s patches on denim
vests that were once jackets. To some, it’s head to toe leather and spikes and zippers. But at the core of
punk has always been a disdain for oppressors. Today’s punk has more of an emphasis on humanity and
making the world a better place to spite oppressive forces. It’s small, but such efforts can make a world
of difference if you do it right. Jeff Rosenstock is a fantastic example of modern punk’s gentler .nature.
A song writer for the late punk band Bomb The Music Industry (Tumblr), Rosenstock recently released
a solo album titled -POST, his self-described “emotionally hazy” attempt at coping with the new reality
of the Trump Administration and helping others to do the same (Downing). Ian Cohen from recognized
and renowned music review hub Pitchfork considers Jeff “...one of the most important figures in
modern punk...” and claims -POST is his magnum opus (Cohen). While this may be subjective, there is
Humphreys 6
no doubt Jeff is spreading some emotionally charged messages. In the second track, “USA”, Jeff sings
This verse followed by lyrics in which he describes how it feels like things no longer matter, and how
people are tired of the cries for change to the point they repress those voices. “TV Stars” takes a more
direct dig at Trump and his supporters, the lyric “TV Stars don’t care about who you are” emphasizing
Trump’s lack of care for the common man. The closing song, “Let Them Win”, is paced in a manner
that suggests exhaustion, but the lyrics and affect suggest Rosenstock is not ready to let the forces of
the administration and conservative agenda win over him and the people he cares about. Rosenstock
refuses to be all talk and no action however- 10% of proceeds from this release have gone to a charity
that aims to benefit Puerto Rico (Bandcamp). To people more right from center, they may feel he is
overreacting to the presidency. But Rosenstock is a being with a lot of empathy for those who suffer; in
an interview with Noisey’s Dan Ozzi, Jeff says, “I think I just try to be truthful about how I feel. I’m a
person who would like to see a lot of changes...” (Ozzi). Rosenstock also sings of greater human griefs
that don’t get addressed often enough. A particularly moving track, “...While You’re Alive”, from his
album WORRY. talks about his desire and passion to tell people in his life that he loves them now
And his pain is all too real for so many; in 2016, the CDC found suicide as the second leading cause of
death among people ages 10 to 34 in the United States, only beaten out by fatal accidents (NIMH). It’s
not easy to measure the impact of his message in “...While You’re Alive”, but I can personally attest to
it inspiring me to tell people in my life that I love them very much. I feel we tend to not get “meta”
with our interpersonal relationships by discussing the dimensions or feelings attached, and it can make
such a difference if you do. Another album, We Cool? hosts a song, “Nausea” about the anxieties of
growing older, and how it’s exhausting to feel you need to prove your usefulness as a productive
member of society to those around you. It’s the relatability of his lyrics that has given him such a strong
young audience.
In his aforementioned interview with Noisey, Jeff credits other bands signed to SideOneDummy,
a popular punk record label, that he has toured with and shared success with. One of those bands was
AJJ (Ozzi). AJJ, formerly known as Andrew Jackson Jihad, is a punk band from Arizona with heavy
folk influences, making for a very unique sound. The name change was announced on Facebook, citing
them not being of Muslim faith and not liking president Andrew Jackson as their reasoning (Anthony).
AJJ has been well known for their blunt attitudes, harboring a vendetta against Maricopa county’s Joe
Arpaio strong enough that they wrote a whole song about him, boldly titled “Joe Arpaio is a Punk.”
Bolder so is the line in which Sean calls Arpaio a “racist fuck,” and states that he wishes Arpaio were
dead. Joe Arpaio is so infamous that a group of advocates bought the domain www.arpaio.com solely to
broadcast his horrible deeds (Arpaio.com). He is well known for his cruel treatment of inmates at the
Maricopa County jail, forcing them to wear striped uniforms, along with pink socks and underwear.
Before he left his position, his mission was to stop illegal immigrants, and he targeted them
specifically. He also established “Tent City”, a series of tents on concrete fenced in, housing 1,700
inmates at its peak. On warmer days in Tent City, it could reach 130 degrees Fahrenheit (Fernández). In
Humphreys 8
another song, “This Is Not a War”, Sean Bonnette sings in solidarity with protesters during Occupy
Fear is a poison
It breeds violence
He makes a metaphor comparing the movement to an immune system, and big business to a disease.
He compares the ways we have tried to deal with this disease to phony home cures like vitamins and
Echinacea (AJJ). And as I mentioned earlier, their stage presence and demeanor make for amazing
shows. Sarah Tanori talks about her experience at an AJJ show in 2015 and offers a needed perspective
The performance wasn't about some pretentious band of musicians who think they're sad yet cool
and want the world to know. It was about a band of musicians who live and breathe the feelings
that they write about. It was refreshing to watch a band not trying to give off some try-hard vibe
(Tandori).
But AJJ doesn’t just play music for what they believe in, AJJ tries to get their listeners involved. In
February of this year, AJJ worked with the Democratic Socialists of America to get people at their
show in Miami to register to vote. A table was set up, and numerous people at the show that night
registered to vote (@AJJtheBand). Sean also sells stickers on his Etsy page of Donald Trump with
snakes coming out of his eyes, and at one point had an original piece of Calvin peeing into Trump’s
Humphreys 9
mouth as he pleasured himself. All proceeds for the art went to the buyer’s choice of Planned
Nobody may hate Trump more than Green Day, however. Well known for their politically
powered album, American Idiot (MOJO 264), Green Day put out a music video for their new album
Revolution Radio in 2017. The visuals for “Troubled Times” have a DIY flair, showing photo clippings
of racially segregated spaces, people voting and protesting as the band members play on a violently
rocking scale. Trump is depicted with wild hair and sharp teeth in the shape of KKK hoods, waving his
arms wildly as a barbed wire fence is erected. A hand sends images representative of social progress
over the years (voting rights for women & people of color, job equality) into a trash can, and at the end
of the music video sets off a nuclear explosion. To Green Day, a Trump Presidency spells disaster for
everyone, and they aren’t afraid to be vocal about it (Green Day). Their singer, Billie Joe Armstrong
This is not about who’s conservative and who’s liberal, or what race you are. This is not about
what religion you are, or if you’re an atheist. This is about being together, everybody, here,
tonight. We’re going to leave all this shit behind us. We’re going to rub up against each other.
We’re going to look each other in the eyes. We’re going to sing together. We’re going to dance
together. We’re going to fucking cry together. Goddamnit, this is an experience — and it’s all
One of the more prolific individuals of today’s punk however is Laura Jane Grace. Laura Jane
Grace is the openly transgender singer and songwriter of Against Me!, a punk band she formed in
Gainesville, Florida in 1997. Fans decried her and her bandmates as sellouts when they switched labels,
but she still maintains a strong following, especially following the Rolling Stones feature in which she
came out (Snapes). From the beginning, many of her songs were laced with lyrics alluding to her
struggles with her gender identity, but it wasn’t until she released Transgender Dysphoria Blues that
Humphreys 10
she made her feelings and experiences more blatant. The first song in the album talks about her
They'll hold their breath not to catch the sick (Against Me!).
“Paralytic States” is a song about how she would stay in hotel rooms to live her life as a woman, which
is made clear in her interview with MTV. The lyrics tell of a distressed trans woman in a hotel who sees
the reflection of her mother’s son, and in her interview, Grace says, “I couldn't exist as a woman in
hotel rooms by myself and then come home and pretend to be someone else, I'd end up killing myself"
(Montgomery). The album is heavily laden with her struggles, and for many other trans youth out there
her visibility and openness about her identity can make all the difference. To see that trans people can
be successful and visible in a time of trans violence gives trans youth hope. In 2017, 28 known
transgender individuals were murdered, and at the time of writing this paper, 8 known transgender
individuals have been murdered, and they are all trans women (HRC). In a survey conducted by
GLSEN of 150,000 transgender students in primary school, 75% of those surveyed felt unsafe at school
because of their gender expression. 70% of those surveyed also avoided using the bathrooms due to
Humphreys 11
feeling unsafe or uncomfortable (GLSEN). Being transgender, punk music has always been a refuge for
Grace. In an NPR Interview, she shares what drew her to punk music and culture:
...one of the very appealing things to me about the punk rock world when I was, like, 15, 16,
especially stumbling onto, like, anarchist punk rock and activist punk rock. And, you know, a
scene that was really strongly feminist and anti-racist and anti-homophobia, anti-transphobia, all
about body liberation, all about, like, you know, just being yourself (Gross).
She was faced with a challenge in May of 2016 when she was playing a show in North Carolina,
shortly after the announcing of the bathroom bill, HB2. She said, “Fighting that ignorance is why I put
myself out there the way I do – and that was the point of still doing the show.” It was also at this show
she lit her birth certificate on fire before the audience (Singal).
Punk culture would not have been able to spread without the use of music and written media. To
...music and art represent the real avenues of change. I think that most people grow and learn new
things by having come in contact with interesting people and with art. Music is a uniquely
Love it or hate it, punk will not be going anywhere anytime soon. It may not have the same kind of
impact or influence that corporate deals with politicians possess, but punk music lets people know they
aren’t alone in this; nobody is alone in their desire for change or feelings of distress in the face of
human error or simply being. Music has always been a way of spreading messages and sharing
emotions, and punk music tries to utilize it in the best way possible. And thanks to technology like the
internet, punk can now reach a wider audience and evolve even more.
Humphreys 12
Works Cited
Against Me!. Lyrics for “Transgender Dysphoria Blues.” Genius, 2014, genius.com/Against-me-
transgender-dysphoria-blues-lyrics.
rape-lyrics.
Andersen, Mark, and Jenkins, Mark. Dance of Days: Two Decades of Punk in the Nation’s
Anthony, David. “Sean Bonnette on switching from Andrew Jackson Jihad to AJJ.” AV Music, 8
2018.
Cohen, Ian. “Jeff Rosenstock: WORRY. Album Review.” Pitchfork, 23 Nov. 2016, pitchfork.com/
reviews/albums/22622-worry/.
Dead Kennedys. Lyrics for “Nazi Punks Fuck Off.” Genius, 1981, genius.com/Dead-kennedys-
nazi-punks-fuck-off-lyrics.
Doe, John. Under the Big Black Sun: A Personal History of L.A. Punk. Boston, Da Capo Press,
2016.
Humphreys 13
Fernández, Valeria. “Arizona’s ‘concentration camp’: why was Tent City kept open for 24 years?”
“Green Day – Troubled Times (Official Lyric Video).” YouTube, Uploaded by Green Day, 16 Jan
2017.
Gross, Terry. "For Trans Rocker Laura Jane Grace, Punk Was A Form Of Armor." Fresh Air, 4
Holstrom, John and Hurd, Bridget. The Best of Punk Magazine. New York, HarperCollins
Publishers, 2012.
Hughes, Hilary. “When Punk Rock Is More Patriotic Than The President.” MTV, 21 Mar. 2017,
www.mtv.com/news/2995387/green-day-against-me-concert-review/
Jeff Rosenstock. Lyrics for “...While You’re Alive.” Genius, 2016, genius.com/Jeff-rosenstock-
while-youre-alive-lyrics.
Jenkins, Mark. "Book World: Life as a Sex Pistol: Criminally raucous riffs." Washington Post, 2
Maxwell, King. Snotrag. Vol. Two Num. One. Pittsburgh, King Maxwell’s Snotrag.
Montgomery, James. “Laura Jane Grace: A Life Unburdened.” MTV, 18 June 2012,
www.mtv.com/news/1687702/laura-jane-grace-tom-gabel-against-me-interview/.
Humphreys 14
Ozzi, Dan. “A Chat With Jeff Rosenstock, the Music Industry’s Favorite Music Industry
music-industrys-favorite-music-industry-outsider.
“Separation and Stigma: Transgender Youth & School Facilities.” GLSEN, 2017, www.glsen.org/
Sheriff Joe Arpaio Maricopa County must go!. 2009, www.arpaio.com/index.php. Accessed 4
May 2018.
Singal, Jesse. "Against Me!'s Transgender Front Woman Laura Jane Grace on Why She Wanted to
link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A509060786/ITOF?u=nysl_ca_csr&sid=ITOF&xid=88ac8432. Accessed
4 May 2018.
Snapes, Laura. "Laura Jane Grace on being transgender in the age of Trump: 'Panic isn't the
answer'; As she publishes an intimate new memoir, the Against Me! founder shares her thoughts on the
presidential election, parenting and the healing power of punk." Guardian [London, England], 3 Dec.
Stiffler, Brad. "Punk Subculture and the Queer Critique of Community on 1980S Cable TV: The
Case of New Wave Theatre." Television & New Media, vol. 19, no. 1, Jan. 2018, pp. 42-58.
EBSCOhost, doi:10.1177/1527476416687040.
St. John, Paige. “Inside the black bloc militant protest movement as it rises up against Trump.”
story.html.
Humphreys 15
Tandori, Sarah. "Indie band hits home with lyrics." UWIRE Text, 16 Apr. 2015, p. 1. General
OneFile, link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A409860089/ITOF?u=nysl_ca_csr&sid=ITOF&xid=69d3121c.
“Violence Against the Transgender Community in 2018.” Human Rights Campaign, 2018,
Ward, J. J. (1996). "This is germany! It’s 1933!" Appropriations and Constructions of "Facism" in
New York Punk/Hardcore in the 1980s. Journal of Popular Culture, 30(3), 155-184. Retrieved from
https://ezproxy.strose.edu/login?url=https://search.proquest.com/docview/195362253?accountid=14120
@AJJtheBand. “Thanks for signing up voters!” Twitter, 21 Feb. 2018, 8:45 p.m.,
twitter.com/AJJtheBand/status/966534284667445248
rotten.html