Professional Documents
Culture Documents
G.R. No. 190432 The Court believes that it need not delve into
April 25, 2017 the issue of whether the instruments have been
delivered, because it is a matter of defense that
FACTS: would have to be proven during trial on the
merits.
Within the period of September 1996 to July
1998, 10 checks and 16 demand drafts In Aquino v. Quiazon, we held that if the
(collectively, “instruments”) were issued in the allegations in a complaint furnish sufficient
name of Charlie Go. The instruments, with a basis on which the suit may be maintained, the
total value of P3,785,257.38, bore the complaint should not be dismissed regardless
annotation “endorsed by PCI Bank, Ayala of the defenses that may be raised by the
Branch, All Prior Endorsement And/Or Lack of defendants.
Endorsement Guaranteed.” All the demand
In other words, "[a]n affirmative defense,
drafts, except those issued by the Lucena City
raising the ground that there is no cause of
and Ozamis branches of Allied Bank, were
action as against the defendants poses a
crossed.
question of fact that should be resolved after
In their Complaint, petitioners narrate: the conduct of the trial on the merits.”
ISSUE:
HELD: