Professional Documents
Culture Documents
16
Towards a Critical Regionalism 19
because its initial utopian promise has been overrun by the internal out new kinds of programs_. .. Despite these limitations critical regionalism is
rationality of instrumental reason. Thi s "closure" was perhaps best a bridge over which any humanist ic architecture ofthe future must pass-'l
formulated by Herbert Marcuse when he wrote:
The fundamental strategy of Critical Regionalism is to mediate the impact of
The technological apriori is a political apriori inasmuch as the transformation universal civilization with elements derived indirectly from the peculiarities
of nature involves that of man, and inasmuch as the ~ ma n -made creat ions H
dominalion . But we have 10 admit lhal this encounter has nOI yetluen place al
the level of an authentic dialogue. That is why we are in a kind of lull or
interre,"um in which we can no longer practice the dogmatism of a si ngle
truth and in which we arc nee yet capable of conquering !he skepticism into
which we have Sleppcd.u
A parallel and complementary sent iment was expressed by the Dutch
architect Aldo Y.l.n Eyck who, quite coincidentally, wrote at the same time:
.. Western civilization habitually identifies itself with civilization as such on
the pontificial ass umption that what is not like it is a deviation, less
advanced . primitive, or. at best, exotically interesting at a safe distance ." 14
That Critical Regionalism cannot be simply based on the autochthonous
forms of a specific region alone was well put by the Californian architect
Hamilton Harwell Harris when he wrote, now nearly thirty years ago:
Opposed to the Regionalism of Rest riction is anDlher type of regionalism, the
Regionalism of Liberation. This is the manifestation of a region that is
especially in tune with the emerging thoughl of the time. We call such a
l rm
manifestation ~region al " only because it has not yet emerged elsewhere .. .. J0rn Utzon. BagswJ(!rd Church. 1973·76.
~ re~ion may develop ideas. A region may accept ideas . Imagination lind North elevation and section.
tntelllgence are necessary for both. In California in the late Twenties and
Thirties modern European ideas meta still.developing regional ism. In New
England . on the other hand . European Modernism met a rigid and restrictive mulliplecross·cultural references. Whi le the reinforced concrete shell vault
regionalism that at fi rst rt"sisted 100 then surrendered. New England accepted has long since held an established place withi n the received tectonic canon of
European Modernism whole because its own regionalism had been reduced 10 Western modern architecture , the highly configurated section adopted in
a collection of res;trictions'"
this instance is hardly familiar. and the only precedent for such a form . in a
The scope for achieving a self-conscious synthesis between univenal sacred context. is Eastern rather than Western - namely, the C hinese
civilization and world culture may be specifical ly illustrated by Jf!lrn Utzon's pagoda roof, cited by Utzon in his seminal essay of 1963, MPJatforms and
Bags~aerd Churc~, built near Copenhagen in 1976, a work whose complex Plateaus."" Although the main Bagsvaerd vault sponlaneously signi fies
meanmg siems dltectly from a revealed conj unction between. on the o ne its religious nature , it does so in such a way as to preclude an exclusively
hand. the rationalilY of normative technique and . on the other, the Occidental or O riental reading o f the code by which the public and sacred
ararioflll/iry of idiosyncratic form. Inasmuch as this building is organized space is constituted . The intent o f this expression is, of course, to secularize
around a regular grid and is comprised of repetitive. in-fill modules - the sacred form by precluding the usual set of semantic religious references
concrete blocks in the fint instance and precast concrete wall units in the and thereby the corresponding range of automatic responses that usually
second-wt; may justly regard it as the outcome of univenal civi lization. accompany them . This is arguably a more appropriate way of rendering a
Such a building system , comprising an in situ concrete frame with church in a highly secular age, where any symbol ic allusion to the
p'refabricated concrete in-fill elements, has indeed been applied countiess ecclesiastic usually degenerates immedialely into the vagaries of kitsch.
times a.1l over the developed world . However, the univenal ity of this And yet paradoxical ly. this desacralization at Bagsvaerd subtly reeonstitutes
productive method-which includes, in this instance, patent glazing on the a renewed basis for the spiritual. one founded , I would argue, in a regional
roof-is abruptly mediated when one passes from the optimal modular skin reaffirmation-grounds . at least . for some form of collective spi rituality.
of the exterior to the far less optimal reinforced concrete shell vault spanning
the nave . Thi s last is o bviou sly a re lativel y uneconomic mode of
construction , selected and manipu lated first for its direct associative
capacity - that is to say, the vault signifies sacred space-and second for its
Towards a Critical Regionalism 25
4. The Resislance of the Pl ace-Form bounded domain in order to create an architecture of resistance. Only such a
defi ned boundary will permit the built form to stand against- and hence
literally to withstand in an institutional sense- the end less processal flu x of
The Megalopolis recognized as such in 1961 by the geographer Jean
the MegakJpolis.
Gottman" continues to proliferate throughout the developed world to such 'The bounded place-form. in it.s public mode, is also essential to what
an extent that, with theexuption of cities which were laid in place befort the Hannah Arendt has termed .. the space of human appearance," sioce the
tum of the century. we are no Jonger able to maintain defined urban forms . eYOlution of legitimate power bas always been predicated upon the existence
1be last quarter of a century has seen the so-called field of urban design of the "polisw and upon companble unit.s of institutional and physical form .
degenerate into a theoretical subject whose. discourK bears liule relation to While the political life of the Greek polis did not stem directly from the
the processal realities of modern development. Today even the super- physical presence and representation of th.e city-state, it disp~ayed in
managerial disci pl ineof urban planning has entered into a state of crisis. The contrast to the MegaJopolis the cantonal attrIbutes of urban densIty. Thus
ult imate fate of the plan which was official ly promulgated for the rebui lding Arendt writes in The Human Condition:
of Rotterdam after World w.u- U is symptomatic in this regard . si nce it
testifies. in terms of its own recently changed status, to the current tendency The only indispensable material factor in the gencrttion of povr-er is the Jiving
to reduce all planning to little more than the allocation of land use and the together of people. Only where men Jive so close together that the
logistics of distribution . Until relatively recently, the Rotterdam master plan potentialities for action are always present will power remain wit? the~ and
the foundation of Cilies, which as city stales have remai ned paradIgmatIc for
was revised and upgraded every decade in the light of buildings which had
all Western political organization, is therefore the most important maleri!)1
been realized in the interi m. In 1975, however. this progressive urban
prerequisite for power.lf
cultural procedure was unexpectedly abandoned in fa vor of publishing a
nonphysical, infrastructure plan conceived at a regional scale . Such a plan Nothing could be more re moved fro m the political essence of the citt
concerns itself almost exclusively with the logistical projection of changes state than the rationalizations of positivistic urban planners such as Melv\fi
in land use and with the augmentation of existi ng distribution systems. Webber. whose ideological concepts of community without propinquity and
In his essay of 19S4. "Buildi ng. O....-elling, Thinking," Martin Heidegger the non-place urban realm are nothing if not slogans devised to rationalize
tO
provides us with a critical vantage point from which to behold this phenom- the absence of any true public realm in the modern motopia . The
enon of universal placelessness . Against the Latin or, rather, the antique manipulative bias of such ideologies has never bun more openly expressed
abstroct concept of space as a more or less end less continuum of evenly than in Roben Venturi 's Complexity and Cotllradic';on in Archi.ecture
subdivided spatial component.s or integers~hat he terms spotium and (1966) wherei n the author asserts that Americans do not need piauas. since
uunsio-Heidegger opposes the German word for space (or, rather. they should be at home walchi ng television .1I Such reaclionary auinKles
place). which is the term Raum . Heidegger argues that lite phenomenologi- emphasize the impotence of an urbanized populace which hu paradoxically
cal essenceofsuch aspacelplace depends upon tbc concme. clearly defined kKt the object of it.s urbanil.ltton.
nature of it.s boundary, for. as he puts it , " A boundary is not that at which Whi le the strategy of Critical Regionalism as outlined above a~5
somethi ng stops . bUI. as the Greeks recognized. the boundary is that froro itself mainly to the maintenance of an e.rpressive densi,y and nsonance In
I'
which something begins its presenting." Apart from confi rming that an architecture of resistance (a cultural density which under today's condi·
Western abstract reason has its origins in the antique cu lture of the tions could be said (0 be potentially liberative in and of itself since it opens
Mediterranean . Heidegger shows that etymologically the German gerund the user to manifold u~rjenus). the provision of a place· form is equally
building is closely linked with the archaic forms of being, cul,ivating and essential to critical practice, inasmuch as a resistant architecture. in an
dwelling. and goes on to state that the condition of ~dwell ing" and hence institutional sense. is necessarily dependent on a clearly defined domain.
ultimately of "being" can only take place in a domain that is clearly Perhaps the most generic example of such an urban form is the perimeter
bou nded . block. although other re lated. introspective types may be evoked, such as
While we may well remain skeptical as to the merit of grounding critical the galleria, the atrium , the forecourt and the labyri nth . And wh.ile these
practice in a concept so hermetically metaphysical as Being, we are, when types have in many inslances today si mpl y become the vehtcles for
confronted with the ubiquitous p.laceiessness of our modern e nvironment. accommodating psuedo-public realms (one thinks of recent megastructures
nonetheless brought to posit . after Heidcgger, the absolule precondition of a in housing. hotels, shopping centers. etc .), one cannot even in these
26 The Ant i-Aesthetic Towards a CriticaJ Regionalism 27
instances entirely discount the latent pol it ical and resistant potential of the Unt il recently. the received precepts of modern c uralOrial practice
place-form . favored the exclusive use of arlificia ll ight in all art galleries . It has perhaps
been insufficiently recognized how this encapsulation tends to reduce the
artwork to a commodity, since such an environment must conspire to render
the work placeless. This is because the local light spectrum is never
5. Culture Versus Nature: Topography, Contex t, permitted to pl ay across its surface: here. then. we see how the loss of aura.
attributed by Walter Benjamin to the processes of mechanical reprod uction.
Climate, Li ght and Tectonic Form also arises fro m a relatively stat ic application of universal technology. The
converse of this "placeless" practice would be to provide that art galleries
Critical Regionalism necessari ly involves a more directly dialecticaJ relation be top- lit through carefully contrived monitors so that. while the injurious
with nature than the more abstract, formal traditions of modem avant-garde effects of direct sunlight are avoided . the ambient light of the exhibition
architecture allow. It is sel f-evident thaI the tabula rasa tendency of volume changes under the impact of ti me, season, humidity, etc. Such
modernizat ion favors the optimum use of earth-moving equipment inas- conditions guarantee the appearance of a place·conscious poetic-a fo rm of
much as a total ly fl at datum is regarded as the most economic matrix upon filtration compounded out of an interaction between culture and nature.
which to predicate the rationalization of construction. Here agai n, one between art and light. Clearly this principle applies to all fe nestrat io n.
touches in concrete terms this fundamental opposition between universal irrespective of size and location. A constant "' regional in fl ec ti on~ of the
civilization and autochthonous culture . The bulldozing of an irregular form arises directly fro m the fac t that in certain climates the glazed aperture
topography into a fl at site is clearly a technocratic gesture which aspires to a is ad vanced . while in others it is recessed behind the masonry facade (or,
condition of absolute placeJessness, whereas the terraci ng of the same site to ailernati vely, shielded by adjustable sun breakers) .
receive the stepped form of a buildi ng is an engagement in the act of The way in which such openings provide for appropriate ventilation also
"cultivating" the sile. constitutes an unsentimental element refl ecti ng the nature of local culture.
Clearly such a mode of beholding and acting brings one close once again Here, clearly, the main antagonist of rooted culture is the ubiquitous air-
to Heidegger's etymology; at the same time. it evokes the method alluded to conditioner, applied in all times and in al l places, irrespective of the locaJ
by the Swiss architect Mario Bona as " building the site." It is possible to cl imat ic conditions which have a capacity to express the specific place and
argue that in thi s last instance the specific culture of the region-that is to the seasonal variations of its cl imate. Wherever they occur. the fixed
say, its history in both a geological and agricultural sense-becomes window and the remote-controlled air-conditioning system are mutually
inscribed into the form and realization of the work. This inscription . which indicative of domination by universal technique.
arises out of "i n-Iaying" the building into the site. has many levels of Despite the critical importance of topography and light , the primary
signi fica nce. for it has a capaCity to embody, in built fo rm, the prehistory of principle of architectural autonomy resides in the tectonic rather than the
the place. its archeologicaJ past and its subsequent cult ivation and trans- scenographic: that is to say. this autonomy is embodied in the revealed
formation across time. Through this layering into the site the idiosyncrasies ligaments of the construction and in the way in which the syntactical form of
of place fi nd their expression without falling inlo sentimentality. the structure explicitly resists the action of gravity. It is obvious that this
What is evident in the case of topography applies to a similar degree in the discourse of the load borne (the beam) and the load-bearing (the column)
case of an existing urban fabric, and the same can be claimed for the cannot be brought into being where the structure is masked or otherwise
contingencies of cl imate and the temporally inflected qualities of local light. concealed . On the other hand. the tectonic is not to be confused with the
Once again. the sensitive modulation and incorporatio n of such factors must purely technical . for it is more than the simple revelation of stereotomy or
almost by definition be fundamenta lly opposed to the optimum use of the expression of skeletaJ framework . Its essence was firs t defined by the
universal technique. This is perhaps most clear in the case of light and German aesthetician Karl Bou icher in his book Die Tektonik der Helfenen
climate control. The generic window is obviously the most delicate poi m at (1852): and it was perhaps best summarized by the architectural historian
which these two natural forces impinge upon the outer membrane of the Stanford Anderson when he wrote:
building, fenestratio n having an innate capacity to inscribe architecture with
Ihe character of a region and hence to express the place in which the work "T('klonik" referred not jusllo the ac tivilY of making the materiall)' requisite
is situated . conSlruction . .. but rather 10 Ihe activit)' Ihal raises this construction 10 an arl
28 The Anti-Aesthetic Towards a Critical Regionalism 29
The tactile resilience of the place-form and the capacity of the body to read
the environment in terms other than those of sight alone suggest a potential
strategy for resisting the domination of universal technology. It is
symptomatic of the priority given to sight that we find it necessary toremind
ourselves that the tactile is an important dimension in the perception of built
form . One has in mind a whole range of complementary sensory perceptions
which are registered by the labile body: the intensity of light , darkness, heat
and cold; the feeling of humidity; the aroma of material; the almost palpable
presence of masonry as the body senses its own confinement; the momentum
of an induced gait and the relative inertia of the body as it traverses the floor;
the echoing resonance of our own footfall . Luchino Visconti was well aware Alvar Aaito, SiiYTUltsalo Town Hall. 1952.
of these factors when making the film The Damned, for he insisted that the
main set of the Altona mansion should be paved in real wooden parquet. It
was his belief that without a solid floor underfoot the actors would be In this way, Critical Regionalism seeks to complement our normative
incapable of assuming appropriate and convincing postures. visual experience by readdressing the tactile range of human perceptions. In
A similar tactile sensitivity is evident in the finishing of the public so doing, it endeavors to balance the priority accorded to the image and to
circulation in Alvar Aalto's Saynatsalo Town Hall of 1952. The main route counter the Western tendency to interpret the environment in exclusively
leading to the second· floor council chamber is ult imately orchestrated in perspectival terms. According to its etymology, perspective means rational-
terms which are as much tactile as they are visual. Not only is the principal ized sight or clear seeing , and as such it presupposes a conscious suppression
access stair lined in raked brickwork, but the treads and risers are also of the senses of smell , hearing and taste, and a consequent distancing from a
finished in brick. The kinetic impetus of the body in climbing the stair is thus more direct experience of the environment. This self-imposed limitation
checked by the friction of the steps, which are "read" soon after in .contrast relates to that which Heidegger has called a " loss of nearness." In
to the timber fl oor of the council chamber itselr. This chamber asserts its attempting to counter this loss, the tactile opposes itself to the scenographic
honorific status through sound, smell and texture, not to mention the spri ngy and the drawing of veil s over the surface of reality. Its capacity to arouse the
deflection of the floor underfoot (and a noticeable tendency to lose one's impulse 10 touch returns the architect to the poetics of construction and to the
balance on its polished surface). From this example it is clear that the erection of works in which the tectonic value of each component depends
liberat ive importance of the tactile resides in the fact that it can only be upon the density of its objecthood. The tactile and the tectonic jointly have
decoded in terms of experience itself: it cannot be reduced to mere the capacity to transcend the mere appearance of the technical in much the
information, to representation or to the simple evocation of a simulacrum same way as the place-form has the potential to withstand the relentless
substituting for absent presences. ' onslaught of global modernization.
30 The Anti-Aesthetic
References
I. Paul Ricoeur. - Uni versal Civilization and Nat iona l Cu ltures" (1961). Hi$tOTY and Truth.
trans . C llas. A. Kelbley (Evanston: Northwestern University Press . 196.'5). pp. 276-7.
2. Tllat these are but two sides of tile same coin lias perllaps been most dramatically
demonstrated in tile Portland City Annex compl~ ted in Portland, Oregon in 1982 to Ille
desi8ns of Michael Grav~s. Th~ constructional fabric of Illis bu ild ing bears no relation
whatsoever to the "repres~nt.ative" sc~nogra plly tllal is applied to the building botll inside
and out.
3. Ricoeur. p. 277.
4. Fernand Braudel informs us tllalthc term -culture- hardly ~xisted befor~ the beginning of
the 19th centu ry wilen . as far as Anglo-Saxon lett~rs are concerned, it already find s itse lf
opposed 10 -ci viliUl ion" in Ille writings of Samuel Taylor Coleridge~above all. in
Coleridge's On the Constitution ofChurch and State of 1830. The noun -c i v ili za tion~ has
a somewhat longer lIistory, first appeari ng in 1766, althougll its verb and participle forms
date 10 the 16th and 17111 centuri~s . TII~ use Illat Ricoeur makes of the opposition between
these two terms relates 10 the work of 2OtIl·century German tllink~rs and writers such as
Osvald Spengler. Ferdinand Tonnies, Alfred Weber and Thomas Man n .
.'5. Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (Chicago: Univer~ity of Chicago Pr~", 1958),
p. 154.
6. Clement Gree nberg, - Avant·Gard~ and Ki tscll,- in Gillo Dorfl es , ed., Kitsch (New
York: Universe Books, 1969), p. 126.
7. Greenberg. - Moderni st Painting: in Gregory Hattcock. ed .. The ~w Art (New York:
Dutton, 1966), pp. 101-2.
8. See Charl~s l encks . The Language of Post-Modern Architecture (New York: Riuoli .
1977) .
9. And reas Huy"ens, - The Search for Tradition: Avant-Garde and Postmodernism in the
1970$," New German Critique . 22 (Winler 198 1). p. 34.
10. l erry Mander. Four Arguments for the Elimina/ion of Ttltvi,;on (New York: Mor row
Quill. 1978) , p. 134.
I I. Herbert Marcuse . Ont-Dimtnsional Man (Boston: Beacon Press. 1964). p. 156.
12 . Alex Tzonis and Liliane I..efaivre, "T he G r id and the Pathway. An Introduction to tile
Work of Dimitris and Susana Antonakakis : Arrhittctuft in Greece, 15 (Athens: 19111) ,
p. 1711 .
13. Ricocur, p. 283.
14. Aldo Van Eyc k. Forum (Amsterdam: 1962).
15. Hamilton Harwe ll Harris, "Liberative and RestriCTive Regionalism." Address given 10 the
Northwest Cllapter of the AlA in Eugene. Oregon in 1954.
16. J~n Utzon. -Platforms and Plateaus; Ideas of a Danish Architect," Zodiac, JO (Milan:
&li zioni Commun ila. 1963), pp. 112-14.
17. Jean Gotlmann , Mega/opolis (Cambridge: MIT Pre". 1961).
18. Martin Heidegger, "Bu ilding. Dwelling. Thinking: in PotITy. l..lInguage, Thought (New
York: Harper Coloplion. 1971). p. 154. Th is essay lirst appe ared in German in 1954.
19. Arendt, p. 201.
20. Mel vin Webber, Exp/orations in Urban Structure ( Phi lade lphia: Un iversity of Pennsyl·
va nia Pre ss. 1964) .
21. Robert VenTuri. Complnity and COn/roOk/ion in Architecture (New York: Museum of
Modern Art, 1966). p. 133.
22. Stanford Anderson, -Modern Architecture and Industry: Peler Behrens , the AEG. and
Indu stria l Design." OpP<)si(ion$ 2 1 (Su mmer 1980) . p. 83 .